Melodeon.net Forums
Discussions => General Discussion => Topic started by: Andy Simpson on May 21, 2008, 07:37:51 PM
-
I'll shortly be selling one of my guitars and the proceeds will be sufficient to propel me into the dreamed-of world of Castagnari ownership. The problem is tha unless I want a Lilly, (sounds a bit too concertina-ish), a Tommy, (a bit strident and rather small and fiddly), or a Mory, (sounds magnificent but a bit more than I need), it's unlikely that I'll find one in a shop I can try out so if I want to join the Costalotti Club I'm going to have to order one. I'm aware of how such things can turn out because I'd never played a Lowden guitar I didn't like until I custom ordered one two years ago and after 8 months it finally arrived with poor fretwork, several cosmetic blemishes and a most uncomfortable neck, I wouldn't have bought it if I'd tried it in a shop but I was stuck with it.
I have heard of people ordering direct from Castagnari and I assume that it's the same situation as with other small instrument makers, such as the aforementioned Lowden Guitars, that do accept orders from the public but don't go out of their way to let people know that they do but I just have to ask if anyone knows if that's still the case?. If so, has anyone had any relatively recent experience, (what are they like to deal with, etc), and is there any advantage to going direct instead of through a shop?.
-
Hi, I ordered a Castagnari DinnII through a dealer in late March. I have contacted Castagnari directly via email to follow up on the details. Although they answer back, I'm not real sure we are communicating well.
They give me a lead time of two to three months ARO. Since the dealer speaks their lingo, I'm hoping all goes well and I get the instrument and tuning I requested.
Good Luck
Don
-
I believe that Castagnari will still accept orders from individuals - why don't you ask them? Be warned though they are not particularly quick at answering emails. What they won't do is send them to a UK address because they have made sole importer agreements with UK dealers, so you would have to include a trip to Italy to collect.
I do urge you to try as many example as you can before you buy, you will have a wait of several months anyway for a special order. I've heard many cases of people (myself included) who have ordered a box sight unseen, and been disappointed when it arrives. This does noy just apply to castagnari. Individual examples of the same model do vary in sound and playability, so make every effort to try before you buy.
-
I visited the Castagnari workshop about two and a half years ago. Got a cheap flight, hired a car and four nights in a hotel. Okay the euro was a lot weaker then but it was a very reasonable short break holiday. Castagnari were quite happy for me to play boxes and seemed more than willing to sell a box to me there and then. As I wasn't in the market for a new box at the time I can't recall what sort of prices they were asking.
I'd certainly say that if you can stretch to a short break there, go for it. There's other makers you can vist too and I'm sure they'd be willing to let you try boxes and buy (might struggle to buy a DG off the shelf though).
Although I've successfully bought two melodeons, sight unseen from Italy (Giustozzi) that was out of necessity and wouldn't normally buy without trying first.
Edited to add: Surprisingly, I was only able to find one shop in Castelfidardo that sold melodeons and they were bottom end organettos rather than good quality two rows.
-
I have owned 6 Castagnaris
Bought form dealers, Euro dealers, private parties and direct
Disappointed twice
I have owned 2 Lilly's , Melodeon, Tommy and Mory and a Hascy
Lillys are all but unplayable due to the tight button spacing but I like them
The Melodeons other than the odd air button placement are outstanding
I got burned on a Mory by a German dealer cost me a lot of time money and aggravation to get it right.. then offed it in disgust
The Tommy is the only acoordeon I ever owned I could run out of air.. I know lots of folks who own and love them, I thik they are wimpy and the latest ones arenl;t near the quality of 10 years ago
The best of the bunch and I stupidly sold mine the Hascy... this is an adult sized pro box with no unneceesary bits...simply outstanding... like a BMW bike or a Chrysler slant six or Levis ( before they cheapened them) or Irish made Clarks shoes just right
Best way to buy is from a dealer who has one in stock if you must buy new
I would look for one that is 2000 or older
Or order direct from castagnari and expect to have it fiddled once you get it
Thought for the day
Know thy dealer
-
Following on from the previous post re car reference I would add that when I first sat down in the shop (hobgoblin) and tried out what is , and has been for the last year my Mory I likend it to a Rolls ,solid, smooth and unbeliveably responsive.The chap in the shop said that they supply them dry tuned and after playing it for a year to see , am now without it for a couple of weeks while its away getting moistened. Still only a week to go , and believe you me going back to my dino as lovely as it is (very punchy ) I am more than ever made aware of what it is that makes the Mory for me anyway the most sublime of playing experiences.
Andy
-
Thanks for the responses so far.
It looks like ordering direct is out of the question If I'd have to go to Italy to collect it.
I recently played a Sander, a model I previously wouldn't have considered, but I loved the sound and the size and weight were just right but it wasn't for sale. I have played both a Lilly, which I found too fiddly to handle and rather shrill for my taste, and a Tommy which sounded better but still didn't quite do it for me and was also a bit too small. I am considering the Hascy on the basis that it seems to be a fancier Sander with better, (or at least more expensive), reeds but I have no experience of one and since I was pleased with the sound and feel of the one I played and like the case design more I think I'm most likely to go for a Sander. I can't recall seeing a new Sander anywhere, there's currently a used one listed at Hobgoblin in Wadebridge, which is too far for me, and I really want a bass end stop, which no off-the-peg Castagnari has as far as I know.
I know it's a bit of a gamble but the chances of finding a Sander with a bass end stop for sale that I could try, new or used, or even a standard Sander or Hascy are rather slim and I've tried examples of the Castagnari models that can be found in shops and I definitely don't want a Lilly or a Tommy and a Mory is more than I need right now and would be a bit of a stretch financially. I wouldn't expect any instrument to be in peak playing condition from new, the guitar I'm selling was £2400 and needed attention, and then there's also the need to play it in so I know what to expect from a brand new instrument and I'm also used to waiting a long time, (and being disappointed at the end of it).
Ok, next question...is there a UK Castagnari dealer anyone would recommend?.
-
Ok, next question...is there a UK Castagnari dealer anyone would recommend?.
Just in case Rees is too modest Wesson Accordions (http://www.melodeons.com/) is good. But I note the site is down thanks to Orange - http://forum.melodeon.net/index.php?topic=541.0
-
(snip) I am considering the Hascy on the basis that it seems to be a fancier Sander with better, (or at least more expensive), reeds but I have no experience of one and since I was pleased with the sound and feel of the one I played and like the case design more I think I'm most likely to go for a Sander. (sniip)
__. I'd urge you to do everything that you can to find a Hascy to try. Not only is the treble side like a much-improved-quality Sander, but the bass sound is fantastic. I bought one in early '92 (D/G with one stop on the treble, in cherry) from Mallinson's (as was) in the original shop (forget the town, near 'uhduhsfield'). I didn't know enough then to have wanted one with the bass stop and I've since realized that one would be very valuable (although I long ago solved that problem by refusing to play minor key stuff) so if you can get a stop on the bass, it would be good. Latest price quoted in the US is about $300 extra so I'm guessing you're looking more at about 150 UKPounds for the option.
__. My Hascy was a true find. It was an "in stock" item; Mallinson played one at the time and was "pushing" them as an alternative to the Tommy. He said (and I've since come to agree) that the extra reed in the bass of the Hascy plus the resonant size of the bass side gives the Hascy a better bass sound. On the other hand, it's like a breezeblock to haul around on a Morris Day of Dance compared to a Tommy. I went in the shop to look for a Baffetti or Pokerwork but when I tried the Hascy, it was all over. I hadn't planned to pay up to Castignari prices but many's the day since then I've been happy that I went ahead and made the plunge.
__. My Hascy has been hauled around and played hard. It's never been really wet but it's sure not had an easy life. I just had Nils Nielsen do a "total tune" and he said that it was in good shape for 15 years of hard playing. Does the Sander have a stop for the octave in the treble? (It wasn't available when I was looking but that was years ago.) Also, I think the case of the instrument is a little more solid on the Hascy. And I'll *always* pay more for top quality reeds.
__. I can't imagine being without my Hascy. If I consider that it's been with me for 15 years and I hope to keep it many more, I'm glad that I made the trip to Cleckeetin (there it is, sometimes the battered, over-beered brain cell still hold hands). The effort was a small investment in many years of satisfaction with the instrument. I strongly advise you to try to find a place with at least a couple (or a couple of places with at least one) so you can try them. The time and expense of a little travel will pay itself back in satisfaction for years.
BH, North Carolina USA
-
Ok, next question...is there a UK Castagnari dealer anyone would recommend?.
Just in case Rees is too modest Wesson Accordions (http://www.melodeons.com/) is good. But I note the site is down thanks to Orange - http://forum.melodeon.net/index.php?topic=541.0
While Rees Wesson's website is down - a quick search of the phone book (http://bt.com/) reveals an R Wesson in Welshpool. It may be him, so may be worth a call.
-
Rees's website is now up and running again.
http://www.melodeons.com/
I can personally vouch for Rees - I have known him for many years and have bought several melodeons from him. He is a fine musician as well as being a Castagnari dealer, so he knows his stuff and is well-respected in the UK melodeon community. He always does his utmost to help.
(And no - he has not paid me to say this!)
-
While Rees Wesson's website is down - a quick search of the phone book (http://bt.com/) reveals an R Wesson in Welshpool. It may be him, so may be worth a call.
That's the chap!
-
Rees's website is now up and running again.
http://www.melodeons.com/
Oh! no it isn't, well not for me anyway
-
No reason not to order directly if you have "faith"
As to needing a bass stop... I will assume to take out the thirds
I would rethink that
Find a Hascy then tape over the thirds cheap and easy
Try Len Killick in Germany... see what he has at Akkordeon Service
another vote of confidence for Rees
The Sander is an ok unit... I quite like the sound of the lesser quality reeds.. they are robust boxes
-
Find a Hascy then tape over the thirds cheap and easy
Another vote for just taping out the thirds. I have a Salterelle le'Elfique with a stop which I never use as I always have the thirds out and have taped them off in my Tommy. So mostly a waste of time in my view.
-
I'll consider taping off the thirds if the surcharge for a stop is outrageous but I'd rather have the option of both to hand rather than one or the other.
Wow Bruce, suddenly Wadebridge doesn't seem like such a long way. :o
To the best of my knowledge, the more expensive Castagnaris no longer use proper hand-made reeds and instead have hand-made type ones so the difference in reed quality wouldn't be so much as it was in 1992. I previously wouldn't have seriously considered a Castagnari that didn't have hand-made reeds but I actually prefered the sound of the recent Sander I played with dural reeds to the Lilly and Tommy with hand-made reeds, although it must be said that it was played in and the other two were brand new and the Mory definitely sounded better, although not by the huge margin I would have assumed. I can't be sure if the one I played was a particularly good one or an average one but I think I'm likely to go for a Sander, although I wouldn't rule out a Hascy and I haven't made my mind up for sure yet.
Rees seems to be the obvious choice anyway, I'll call or email him next week to see how much the various options would cost and what kind of lead times there are at the moment.
Thanks again for everyone's input.
-
Rees seems to be the obvious choice anyway, I'll call or email him next week to see how much the various options would cost and what kind of lead times there are at the moment.
Thanks again for everyone's input.
I'm told by "people who know" that "hand made" or "tipa a mano" reeds hold a tune longer and are more resistant to breaking over time than "machine" reeds and there's an important long-term value to them. But if you prefer some particular reeds after a good trial, then those are the ones that you should go for. But get good guidance from Rees -- I'm just another melodeon player who really doesn't know much.
And don't be too concerned about distances to try a melodeon. I was actually working in Solihull at the time so the trek wasn't as extravagant as it might seem.
Best wishes on your project! BH NC USA
-
I'm not sure that hand made reeds last longer
I have Hohners form the 50's that have original reeds in well played instruments
My experience with true "hand made" is that they speak more quickly and modulate more easily
If you have played Saltarelles no doubt you have played dural ior lesser quality reeds
and the latest ones come with Cagnoni low middle grade
The Castagnaris I have played with the medium quality reeds, which include the low end flat keybaord ,Ciaci ? .. I liked it better than the Illary with tipo a mano
I often think it comes down to the care in tuning
And as I have said prior... boxes are kits... buy the one that rings your bell then go and have it fiddled.
I think a stop in the bass is around $300 US
-
Hi folks, here I am at last. I've been away at Chippenham festival and elsewhere, drinking good ale and squeezing my organ - oo er, missus.
Thank you all for your votes of confidence (especially Steve, cheque in the post, mate ;D).
Let's deal with the reeds first. I've been working with Castagnari since 1984 and they have never used hand-made reeds. These reeds are quite rare and are only used in top flight piano accordions costing several million pounds. ;) The myths attached to pre-1992 reeds or whatever are just that - myths. The current TAM reeds are as good as they've ever been. VA and Cagnoni operate from large, modern factories with state of the art machinery while Claudio Binci works in an old cowshed in his back garden. All are dedicated to producing a first class product.
There are two main types of reeds used these days. Tipo a Mano (TAM), literally hand-made type. These are made by Voci Armoniche (VA) formerly Antonelli/Salpa and are used by Castagnari. Binci Professional are also TAM as are the Cagnoni top grade reeds. TAM reeds are also used in Louisiana made Cajun accordions.
Export or Super Durall reeds are also made by all of the above and are used in most of the other Italian boxes including Saltarelle, Gabbanelli and the Castagnari Studio, Nik and Sander.
They all sound different, not only in the reeds themselves but also which melodeon they are fitted to.
I use TAM reeds when building my one-row, four-stops but my main D/G box is a 20 year old Sander with Export reeds (never broken a reed).
Next topic: Castagnari lead time. Scotch mist is the only way to describe it. After all this time it doesn't bother me any more but it drives my customers mad. I can usually guarantee delivery within 12 months but certain models can take longer. I've just waited 2 years for a Benny. I never have many in stock because most of the instruments are pre-ordered. (Pssst! - just checked out the competition at Chippenham and neither of them have much Castagnari stock either, so we're all in the same gondola).
I do have both Hascy and Sander (with TAM reeds) on order so either of those may be reserved without any obligation to buy. If you wish to reserve either or both, I operate a first come, first served list so that if the first on the list doesn't go for it then it is offered to the next on the list. My aim is to match the melodeon to the player. I don't have to do the hard sell as Castagnari melodeons sell themselves.
Either of the above can be fitted with a stop to remove the thirds at £150. (300 dollars).
I'm also expecting a couple of Trillys which have seven treble couplers and four bass couplers giving you all the options.
Please don't ask when I expect them to be delivered - it's Scotch mist.
I always give a full guarantee on all new Castagnaris. I also check them over in my workshop when they arrive just to sort out any minor tuning discrepancies or other faults that may have occurred in transit. I have no objection to anyone going direct to Castagnari for their instruments but they would then lose the obvious advantage of a dedicated UK service point.
Good to see that Orange have finally sorted out the server problem and my website is back on-line at www.melodeons.com . (Have you got it yet, Lester?). Apologies for any inconvenience.
-
Castagnari LILLY. D/G with hand-made reeds.
Castagnari TOMMY. D/G with hand-made reeds.
Both quotes from Rees' s web site.
-
Absolutely mate. That's what they quote in the Castagnari catalogue and every other maker who uses them will call them hand-made.
My point is that it's the current name for TAM reeds.
Gottit?
-
Castagnari LILLY. D/G with hand-made reeds.
Castagnari TOMMY. D/G with hand-made reeds.
Both quotes from Rees' s web site.
Lets see you talk your way out of that young man!!
You might start by explaining that there is no longer any such a thing as a "hand made" reed and that all the references are just to the amount of hand finishing.
If the hair splitting season is open, even Binci "Professional" (apart from using better reed steel) are only claimed to be assembled and finished by hand.
All their reeds are on dural frames so I cannot understand why some folks equate dural with machine made?
In my estimation you cannot place too much credence on how reeds are described . You can find some machine ground with profiling as good as a typical TAM and others that are all flats and steps.
Going downmarket, I am equally baffled by the people who generalise about "good old Hohner H type" reeds, probably not realising that there were for or five different style of manufacture, all stamped "H".
Personally I would never spend good money on a "Costalotti" with fancy reeds in the hope of sounding better, I will stick to blaming the box - it cannot be me!
Regards, Bruce
-
It is indeed a can of worms.
As I said before there are basically two types of reed used in melodeon manufacture.
TAM reeds (usually known as hand-made) and Export which the Italians often call Super Durall.
The obvious way to visually differentiate is as follows:
The TAM reeds will have five flats on the rivet head where it has been riveted by hand with a hammer.
Export reeds are machine riveted and have a round rivet head.
There are other differences such as the way the steel tongue is cut from the plate, but I won't bother to explain here as I have some paint that I need to watch drying.
Most of the reed manufacturers offer around seven different grades of reed, some Export and some TAM. Then there's your brass reed plates and Cairdin claim to have a "special" reed as does Charlie Watkins with his "Super M" and you're absolutely right about Hohner reeds. I recently tried to tune a set of H reeds that appeared to be made from porridge, other H reeds are to die for. Modern T reeds also seem to vary in quality from batch to batch. Anyone know if Hohner reeds are still made in Germany or has reed production also moved to China?
So what should we call these TAM reeds as used by Castagnari et al? It needs to be adopted by all the UK dealers, eBayers, etc. to avoid this confusion that has existed for some time. Jon Loomes from The Music Room is here on melodeon.net
Hi Jon, what thinkest thou?
Anyone from Hobgoblin like to jump in?
-
Charlie Watkins told me Binci made his "Super M"s!
-
The plot thickens....................
-
Thank you very much Rees, most informative. Expect an email soon.
I'm finding this current discussion about reed types fascinating, there's a great deal of misinformation, half-truths and common or garden nonsense talked about all instruments and discussions like this are a great help in getting to the bottom of things.
Thanks again to everyone for your input.
-
I think we should just play the box and judge it on how it responds and how it sounds!
-
I think we should just play the box and judge it on how it responds and how it sounds!
I agree absolutely! - some expensive boxes can be disapointing and some relatively inexpensive ones can siute an individuals requirements better. I have twice over the years sold expensive posh boxes replacing them with cheaper ones that sound & feel much better to me ( but probably not to many others) choosing a box is very much a personal thing - sod the theory - if it feels and sounds good to you then it must by definition be good good!
george
-
I think we should just play the box and judge it on how it responds and how it sounds!
I agree absolutely! - some expensive boxes can be disapointing and some relatively inexpensive ones can siute an individuals requirements better. I have twice over the years sold expensive posh boxes replacing them with cheaper ones that sound & feel much better to me ( but probably not to many others) choosing a box is very much a personal thing - sod the theory - if it feels and sounds good to you then it must by definition be good good!
george
I've been away too (sword spec in York.) I have to agree with George on this one...
-
So what are Castagnari like with special orders? Say, hypothetically, if somebody wanted the treble end of a Handry, with MMM reeds tuned B, C and, what the hell, C#, with the bass end of a Magica K3. Presumably such a concoction would cost as much as a moderate-sized house, but would it be likely to arrive within the average life-expectancy? Just checking in case I ever win the lottery. Without having entered.
-
So what are Castagnari like with special orders?
__. My only experience has been with my Benny (about '97). I went to my dealer and asked "can I order a Benny with low notes on the treble and a stop for the 3rd on the bass?" He FAXed them and they said yes. So, we put in my order with a chart for the low notes and the order for the 3rd stop. The completion date was quoted 5-6 months - it arrived in 10 with accidentals. "Oh, send it back and we'll put it into the production process; but everyone knows that you can't get a bass stop on a Benny". It was time for a good "WTF" -- I just kept it like it was.
-
The completion date was quoted 5-6 months - it arrived in 10 with accidentals. "Oh, send it back and we'll put it into the production process
Any decent dealer would have offered to put the low notes in for you. Bass stop would be a different matter.
The time factor and lack of attention to specifics of the note layout matches my experience of a Mory ordered in 2000.
-
Mannie alerted me to this thread. I wanted to take Rees up on the idea of getting some agreement on how to describe the reed type. After hearing of this discussion and a recent customer comment - one of you here maybe? I just recently decided to standardise on the Italian terms super durall and tipo a mano. I've deleted all the references I could find to handmade reeds in Hobgoblin literature.
We have always used the term handmade reeds to describe the tipo a mano, and factory reeds for the others because it is the common parlance and understood by most players. I know it is not entirely accurate, so as there seems to be more awareness in the days of the internet, we have decided to make it more specific.
As for what makes a difference, I have some experience. When we started making the Gremlin Saxon concertinas in the early 80s we tested nearly all the currently available Italian reads, Cagnoni and Antonelli seemed best, and Antonelli's tipo a mano made a big difference compared to their machine reeds. We settled on them and when we re-started production in the last few years with the Sherwood concertinas, we continued with the new Siva production of the old antonellis. these are just as good or better than the old ones.
I believe reeds age and sound different after a lot of playing. The actual steel and its content and hardness makes a significant diffence too.
I agree with those who rate the Hascy, I have a Casta.. a sort of special model they made for me similar to a Hascy and it is a great box and exactly the right size for a melodeon in my opinion.
Finally I quizzed Hohner about their reed production today to try to get to the bottom of it. The answer was indirect because they didn't make it clear whether they were talking about reeds or blocks - but perhaps clear enough. Everything is done in China with the same machines, methods, materials and quality control as they previously had in Germany. They said the wood of the blocks has changed because they can no longer get the original stuff for enviromental reasons. they also pointed out that reeds age and conceded that the different woods do make a difference. They were a bit defensive and obviously irritated by some of the criticism. Len Killick told me he went to Trossingen and there were definitely no reeds being made. But I have been told by others that the harmonicas are still made there?
I also know that the Czech reeds are used in Italy and by Harmona, and that Italians have links to factories in Ukraine, N Korea and other strange places as well as China. It is not as simple as it looks.
We are currently assessing melodeon samples from China that have Italian reeds in Italin frames. Most of the Chinese factories use either German frames, tongues or German machines. I have found it pretty difficult to get all the info I want even though we talk to all the makers. The most important thing is the quality control, you can make a good reed or a bad one out of the same stuff.
-
Nice one Pete. Thanks for all that info.
(naming no names but it ends with an i :D) - I had heard that some so called Italian reeds were actually Czech made.
I think this only applies to Super Durall and not TAM.
I agree that the Hascy is the best of all the Castagnaris. I think it was the first one I ever saw/heard.
Casta is a wee cracker too. Shame they stopped making it. I've just received a new Benny today with a special note layout and everything is in the right place and it's in tune. This is normal and what I have come to expect. OK, they do drop some big howlers but they are still the best. No contest.
I also vote for "tipo a mano" and "super durall" and do hereby solemnly swear to update my website.......... whenever.
Will you phone John Turner or shall I? ;)
-
http://www.flickr.com/photos/78769625@N00/2253870197/sizes/l/
Links to a photo of a few of my reeds described on the invoice as Duralluminium Hand Type. They seem to have the hand hammered reeds as described by Rees. They offer, but I declined, hand made reeds at more of a premium so Giustozzi at least offer three qualities of reeds.
-
Some fine photos there Dazbo, thanks
Tom
-
I ordered my Castagnari direct from them (Castagnari) last year and it took about 5 months for it to arrive. It was a Kriss III with extra stop on bass to remove thirds and Joe Burke bass Layout. What i did find is that they only reply to your e-mails on a Thursday oddly enough so if you asked them something simple on a Friday like " Is my accordion ready yet?" it was the following Thursday before they replied "No". Also they did tell me that they wouldn't deliver and that i had to pick up from Ancona Italy myself. This wasn't economical for me as i'm self employed and a trip midweek (Shut weekends) to Italy would have cost me loss of earnings too. So i haggled with them for a bit and they agreed to post via TNT for 95€. After a few more weeks had passed they e-mailed me and told me my accordion was ready for PICK UP!! this resulted in me then ringing Castagnari office and trying to explain to a women who couldn't speak English very well that they are supposed to be sending the accordion by shipment. To cut a long story short they sent it in the end and i was very happy with the product. So what i'm trying to say is if you're happy to buy direct off them you have to keep bugging them with e-mails and even phone calls but in hindsight i should have used a U.K dealer as i wouldn't have been pulling my hair out as much.
Any way this Rees chap seems to know his tongues and reeds from his bellows and valves so go with him for peace of mind. Oh here's pictures of my Kriss III:
http://www.flickr.com/photos/14636356@N08/ (http://www.flickr.com/photos/14636356@N08/)