Melodeon.net Forums
Discussions => Teaching and Learning => Topic started by: Ellie on May 22, 2008, 09:27:50 PM
-
Possibly a slightly random question, but now having a bit more time on my hands to devote to playing, I was going through and figuring out (alright, writing down!) which notes can be played cross both rows (on a D/G), and noticed that the same notes sounds ever-so-slightly different when played on the push versus the pull. Is this normal? I've also noticed that my playing is generally slightly stronger (and louder) on the pull - which is actually quite nice to give a bit of instinctive variety through a tune :) Just wondering whether that's just me really!
Is it worth practising to try and get the same 'strength' of note on both push and pull?
-
I was going through and figuring out (alright, writing down!) which notes can be played cross both rows (on a D/G), and noticed that the same notes sounds ever-so-slightly different when played on the push versus the pull. Is this normal?
The difference may be that the reeds are tuned slightly differently giving a slightly different feel to the notes. Or it may be the air flow takes more of the sound into the bellows so you hear more of the note affected by the internal bellows space - Theo?
I've also noticed that my playing is generally slightly stronger (and louder) on the pull - which is actually quite nice to give a bit of instinctive variety through a tune :) Just wondering whether that's just me really!
Is it worth practising to try and get the same 'strength' of note on both push and pull?
I'm surprised you're louder on the pull, I would have thought most people would be stronger on the push. To me it sounds like you're using your strength to the limit - a common problem with beginners, especially on cheaper boxes. Learn to play quietly, and you should find balancing the volume between push and pull on the bellows comes easlily and naturally; then use the bellows to give dynamics to the music (louder, quieter etc).
-
I was going through and figuring out (alright, writing down!) which notes can be played cross both rows (on a D/G), and noticed that the same notes sounds ever-so-slightly different when played on the push versus the pull. Is this normal?
The difference may be that the reeds are tuned slightly differently giving a slightly different feel to the notes. Or it may be the air flow takes more of the sound into the bellows so you hear more of the note affected by the internal bellows space - Theo?
I notice this quite often on many different boxes, and it remains despite my best efforts to get the tuning exactly the same on both example of the same note. In contrast when I've worked on piano accordions its relatively simple to get the notes sounding with no discernible difference on push and pull. I can only conclude that the slight differences in timbre are something to do with the reeds being on different reedblocks.
I've also noticed that my playing is generally slightly stronger (and louder) on the pull - which is actually quite nice to give a bit of instinctive variety through a tune :) Just wondering whether that's just me really!
Is it worth practising to try and get the same 'strength' of note on both push and pull?
I'm surprised you're louder on the pull, I would have thought most people would be stronger on the push. To me it sounds like you're using your strength to the limit - a common problem with beginners, especially on cheaper boxes. Learn to play quietly, and you should find balancing the volume between push and pull on the bellows comes easlily and naturally; then use the bellows to give dynamics to the music (louder, quieter etc).
I'm with Ellie on this one. Max volume for me on the pull too.
-
I can only conclude that the slight differences in timbre are something to do with the reeds being on different reedblocks.
Isn't the timbre different between the rows on virtually all boxes, and isn't this a question of how far the pallets open? On a conventional setup, the levers on the outer row of buttons are much longer and lift the pallets farther off the soundboard. The pallets operated by the inner row of buttons stay closer to the soundboard, giving a more muted, flutey kind of sound. That's been my experience and that's the explanation I've had.
I've been told the "reverse lever" mechanism used on some boxes, notably Paolo Sopranis, is designed to offset this by getting the inner row of pallets to open more and thus even out the timbre between the rows.
This type of mechanism is also used on my Serenellini 273 (http://www.rogermillington.com/steam/233_treble.jpg)
-
Thanks guys - that's good to know :)
Dazbo - interestingly enough, I have been following various people's advice to play quietly - it's quite rare that I play at full volume (it's living in a terrace!). I think perhaps having the weight of the bass end of the box adds a little 'oomph' to the pull. Good to know I'm not alone ;D
-
Thanks guys - that's good to know :)
Dazbo - interestingly enough, I have been following various people's advice to play quietly - it's quite rare that I play at full volume (it's living in a terrace!). I think perhaps having the weight of the bass end of the box adds a little 'oomph' to the pull. Good to know I'm not alone ;D
the weight of the bass end is likely to have more effect if you are playing with the bellows well out but less effect if you keep them 'tight' This is because with extended bellows it is necessary to use the arm elbow & shoulder muscles to do the push/pulling whereas when playing 'tight' (the bellows not you!) a lot of the work can be done with the wrist giving finer control.
george
-
maybe similar to difference when you blow and suck on a mouthorgan. You get a 'wilder' sound on the suck as when playing Cajun in G on a C box or blues in E on an A harp. Or in A on a D/G box as in High Reel or Athol Highlanders
Mike
-
Yes, but everything in life is a compromise, though. The slight differences in timbre that the player picks up probably won't be heard by others. The real plus side of cross rowing is the ability to play the best bass line against the melody. Recognising this, pretty much from the outset, eliminates the unmusical sawing heard from many tyros at sessions or even playing for Morris - we've all heard it, hold the G bass throughout and play single row style in G. It sounds CR*P !! I admit to a tendency to be uninventive and simply play the three chord trick, but without cross row playing, that can be reduced to a discordant two chord trick (very much like when I play the four stop).
-
...... hold the G bass throughout and play single row style in G. It sounds CR*P !! ...
Hmmmm....
There might well be a lot of one-row players who would disagree with you here.
e.g. John K, Katie Howson, the Ghost of Oscar Woods, possibly?
.
.
.
Yes - I play a two-row melodeon and I do like to try get the 'correct chords' (whatever that might mean)' to go with the melody, by cross-rowing (or not) as required.
However, I also play one-row four-stop melodeons where you have no choice about the chords, so sometimes they are 'wrong' according to the the 3-chord trick. I don't care. In this context they are not 'wrong' at all, in my opinion. They add to the rhythmic, almost percussive, drive to the music.
-
...... hold the G bass throughout and play single row style in G. It sounds CR*P !! ...
Wrong!!!! - it sounds fantastic.
Listen to the Veteran CD "Pigeon on the Gate - the essence of English melodeon playing as it was and should be.
OK, I'm not averse to a bit of nifty bass work around all 8 or 12 buttons especially on the Continental tunes and Tony Hall is something else, but give me Percy Brown's staccato style any day. He often dabbed out a rhythm on just one chord button with no bass note.
On a one-row in D, for instance, if the tune in the right hand moves through a G chord, just pull that left hand A chord harder. There lies the soul and character of the one-row melodeon. I should know, Oscars Woods ghost lives in my attic.
-
[ There lies the soul and character of the one-row melodeon. I should know, Oscars Woods ghost lives in my attic.
So that's where he went, the tart...leaving me only an out of tune G 1 row... :)
Baz
-
Oh come on guys! I said holding the bass buttons and sawing back and forth!
On a four-stop, that also sound cr*p (mostly). Like you say, a staccato rythmic dab is sometimes all that's on offer and suits well, though. Yes, even Donkey Riding has a few of those!
Rob.
-
Oh come on guys! I said holding the bass buttons and sawing back and forth!
On a four-stop, that also sound cr*p (mostly). Like you say, a staccato rythmic dab is sometimes all that's on offer and suits well, though. Yes, even Donkey Riding has a few of those!
Rob.
The simplest way of tackling the problem is to always play staccato (touching the bass buttons as if red hot) exept on purpose.
Learning to play lightly & rhythmically on the bass requires developing good manual dexterity & is also tied up with good bellows control. Playing long notes, chords or whatever is relatively easy & should be done (on purpose) only where you feel that it really enhances a tune.
george