Melodeon.net Forums
Discussions => Instrument Makes and Models => Topic started by: Keithypete. on December 07, 2010, 01:52:03 PM
-
http://cgi.ebay.co.uk/ws/eBayISAPI.dll?ViewItem&item=200532238587&ssPageName=STRK:MEWAX:IT#ht_500wt_922 (http://cgi.ebay.co.uk/ws/eBayISAPI.dll?ViewItem&item=200532238587&ssPageName=STRK:MEWAX:IT#ht_500wt_922)
I understand these are Chinese copies of Cairdin instruments. Has anyone had a go on one, or know anything about them - first-hand? How do they compare to the Chinese Pokerwork? Do they have any potential whatsoever in terms of tuning or diy mods? The far-eastern bellows never seem to get mentioned in great detail - any good?
-
Only for upside down players of Irish music!
-
Remember the old saying: You get what you pay for!
-
Remember the old saying: You get what you pay for!
OK - that is so but has anyone here tried one and could they answer the questions in the OP?
-
I think that some of these chinese boxes are fairly good for beginners, particularly if they have been fettled with by a technician. My understanding is that many makers in china are improving quality as their industry evolves. That said I think many beginners would be discouraged by the lack of playability.
-
Only available in D/G yet Stephanelli do a very similar looking box in B/C - and charge £150 on top. I wonder if they come from the same place. There are probably lots of factories doing much the same thing over there. One of them must get it right eventually. I suppose.
-
There seem to be only 2 or 3 factories in China doing all those models with fake Italian-sounding names. We recognize the bellows, buttons, metal corners, etc.
Same with other instruments, like wind and brass, fake Italian-sounding names, low prices, not so good quality...
-
There seem to be only 2 or 3 factories in China doing all those models with fake Italian-sounding names. We recognize the bellows, buttons, metal corners, etc.
Same with other instruments, like wind and brass, fake Italian-sounding names, low prices, not so good quality...
Fair comment.
-
Not so much a copy - I reckon they must have seen a picture of a CairdÃn box, and just cobbled together something that looks externally similar. Inside, it's going to be the same guts and blocks you'd get in their Erica lookalikes... Besides, CairdÃns are solid wood. The wood finish on the Chinese box looks like some kind of shiny plasticy kitchen veneer... over goodness knows what base materiel...
I always remember the story of some poor bloke trying to sand smooth/re-finish a Chinese guitar - and discovered it was veneered... when he saw an orange box brand stamp appearing through the thinned veneer... ooops! ;D
Ed J
-
Could one of these boxes be a source for a fancy wood-ended box? Anything would be better than the garish original. Then replace the bellows. And finally the reeds!
Nigel
-
Just looking at the reedblocks of one of those will convince you of the "quality" of the instument.
In the few chinese boxes I have opened I have seen reedblocks made of really cheap softwood, that seemed carved with a pocket knife! The surfaces are not flat, there are splinters everywhere around the holes and openings, glue everywhere, dodgy wax jobs around really cheap reeds that need lots of air to play...
Some sources say that when you buy one of those for $300 the seller makes about $200 profit! Gives you an idea of the "quality" you are getting...
-
Could one of these boxes be a source for a fancy wood-ended box? Anything would be better than the garish original. Then replace the bellows. And finally the reeds!
Nigel
You could perhaps get one of these and also get an original Cairdin. Then swap the wooden ends to improve the Chinese box. Next week you could swap the bellows, then the reeds etc, until you have swapped all the parts. Then you would indeed have a quality box made from the Chinese original.
-
without trying this box it is impossi;ble to comment on its qualityy/playability or whatever. However if the seller can sell it for £169 new (anad a 3 voice 96 bass (looks like same factory as scarlatti) for £300) and if it is only comparable to the crappy scarlatti sold for around £300 by major sellers it could indicate an element of profiteering in certain quarters.
As one of the critics of chinese boxes i would emphasise that much of my criticism relates to the crappyness to price ratio which coupoled to the instant depreciation makes them a bad buy. However if something that is playable in the sense of getting somebody started & providing a sort of 'first year' box £169 seems ok as it would probably bring 50 quid in part ex against something better and wouldn't be too much of a loss if the owner desided not to persue the instrument.
another way to look at chinese boxes is to only buy them secondhand at which point the price can maake sense. I have a BC scarlatti nero as new which I bought for £100 (new around £360) At £100 it is quite a nice box, at £360 I would not recommend it to anybody!
george
-
Agree with George. I've played a few chinese boxes around and have never been at all impressed. By contrast, my Weltmeister, which I got second hand for £30 is not a good box at all, it's poorly designed and doesn't sound amazing. However, it feels nice to play and feels a lot more solid and instrument-like than most of the current haul of ultra-cheap boxes from China.
-
The Chinese bellows are on a par with the HARMONA bellows which an American self styled "accordion engineer" said are "in many ways better than Italian bellows"... his words... but he could/would never explain that absurd statement.. Neither are on par or close to Italian bellows
Thin materials all around, sloppy workmanship.
Chinese accordions are typically brought in at around 16% of the eventual suggested retail price.
This covers the ones they throw in the trash, ones that are parts donors, some held back for "warranty" exchange ( ggod luck)
wholesaling to e bay hustlers and retail sales.
One day the CHinese boxes may be a good deal.. but for now.. too many fingers in the pie and the components come from too many different sources and the supply line is obscure at best... quality is still not on par with anything made in Europe..
I see NO value in Chinese boxes... even hotrodded with Italian reeds , action worked on etc...
Pay more, get more
-
Not so much a copy - I reckon they must have seen a picture of a CairdÃn box, and just cobbled together something that looks externally similar. Inside, it's going to be the same guts and blocks you'd get in their Erica lookalikes... Besides, CairdÃns are solid wood. The wood finish on the Chinese box looks like some kind of shiny plasticy kitchen veneer... over goodness knows what base materiel...
I recall that Cairdin tried to have some cheaper boxes made in China years ago. This was back in the early days of Cairdin. It follows that their "designs" are floating around in Chinese accordion factories.
-
I played one of these Chinese "Cairdin" boxes and was under the impression they were rip-offs.
I did not know they were sanctioned by Cairdin themselves.
I wonder how many of these were made and have since been passed off as the real deal.
-
I don't really understand how a "crappy" box can miraculously improve when sold cheaper (discount/second hand). If it's a pain at £360 it won't give you much pleasure at £100 (or for free) either.
-
No evidence that its a Cairdin sanctioned chinese copy. Plenty of unscrupulous makers in China willing to copy the looks of a popular accordion. I doubt that Cairdin would want their boxes contaminated by the association. I do believe though that the time is coming that some of these chinese boxes might be good buys.
-
No evidence that its a Cairdin sanctioned chinese copy. Plenty of unscrupulous makers in China willing to copy the looks of a popular accordion. I doubt that Cairdin would want their boxes contaminated by the association. I do believe though that the time is coming that some of these chinese boxes might be good buys.
I agree, and for a long time I've thought this could be true. But one thing must change before that is possible: by and large the Chinese manufacturing firms do not seem care about Western consumers' idea of quality control when it comes to musical instruments -- they care first and foremost for meeting production goals and making money. Just like Soviet-style command economics, their managers are concerned primarily with meeting the goal and being rewarded for it.*
It seems like it's up to Western importers or dealers to perform the inspections, tunings, etc that insure a quality product is coming from Eastern factories. It's a fact of life now with so much coming from China -- same for baby formula, guitars, accordions, toys, tools, you name it.
*There are some notable exceptions to this rule, but it largely holds true.
-
Too bad the Japanese haven't gotten involved in accordion making. They have a pretty good record when it comes to quality!
-
Too bad the Japanese haven't gotten involved in accordion making. They have a pretty good record when it comes to quality!
Always thought about that! When you see what happened with the guitar making back in the 70's, I wonder what a japanese melodeon would be like. We would have "lawsuit" melodeon models, better than the originals...
-
Too bad the Japanese haven't gotten involved in accordion making. They have a pretty good record when it comes to quality!
Always thought about that! When you see what happened with the guitar making back in the 70's, I wonder what a japanese melodeon would be like. We would have "lawsuit" melodeon models, better than the originals...
Like the Gibson Les Paul copy that Hohner was sued for. Or the Fender Jazz Bass copy that Hohner was sued for. Or the Fended Telecaster copy that Hohner was sued for. Nice guitars, all. ;D
The concept of Total Quality Management originated in Japan and has been applied to business and public administration models around the world.
-
Too bad the Japanese haven't gotten involved in accordion making. They have a pretty good record when it comes to quality!
Always thought about that! When you see what happened with the guitar making back in the 70's, I wonder what a japanese melodeon would be like. We would have "lawsuit" melodeon models, better than the originals...
Like the Gibson Les Paul copy that Hohner was sued for. Or the Fender Jazz Bass copy that Hohner was sued for. Or the Fended Telecaster copy that Hohner was sued for. Nice guitars, all. ;D
The concept of Total Quality Management originated in Japan and has been applied to business and public administration models around the world.
Are Fender and Gibson finally taking a leaf out of Rickenbacker's book?
-
I keep hoping that one day I will see Tombo try their hand at melodeon or concertina.
-
Tombo would be my choice.. they make very fine harmonicas... too bad only the "Lee OSKARS" are available in the US
The self proclaimed American "accordion engineer" has said he is attempting to collaborate with a Japanese fabricator to
make "action" parts for melodeons. It would be a shame if these were attached to his Chinese imports with "better than Italian" Harmona bellows.
I own an Epiphone Elitist Byrdland archtop jazz guitar made in the Japanese TERADA shop. The Terada folks make the high end Gretsch guitars including the White Falcons and Setter Hot Rod models. The quality far exceeds USA made products from its parent firm, Gibson
I suspect there are companies in Japan that could make a very fine melodeon. Perhaps it has not penetrated their culture, as has the guitar and mandolin. Some of the finest guitars and mandolins are made in Japan and have been since the 60's... and not
"law suit models" but their own. Examples would be OCHAI ( SP) and SUMI mandolins, Kohno and Yamaha ( high end ) guitars
-
We could have a Toyota melodeon that never stops playing once started...
-
Look at what happened when the Japanese decided to get involved in motorcycle manufacture. I doubt the Italian accordion industry would suffer the same fate as the British motorcycle industry did. Look at where we are now compared to the days of the 750 sohc Honda, or the K 1 - which could run on unleaded right from its introduction. Where will accordion development go if they get the bit between their teeth? Incidentally the Japanese have the same word for copy and for learn!
-
We could have a Toyota melodeon that never stops playing once started...
Might upset some Morris Musicians if it did 300 tunes to the pint !
>:E :|glug >:E
-
The concept of Total Quality Management originated in Japan and has been applied to business and public administration models around the world.
The foundations of Japanese quality were laid, post WW2, by an American, Dr. W. Edwards Deming. See http://www.lii.net/deming.html (http://www.lii.net/deming.html)
-
We could have a Toyota melodeon that never stops playing once started...
The melodeon in front is a Toyota.......
Or maybe they'd do a Prius hybrid model?
(Me, I drive a Mitsubishi pickup............ (:))
Graham
-
The concept of Total Quality Management originated in Japan and has been applied to business and public administration models around the world.
The foundations of Japanese quality were laid, post WW2, by an American, Dr. W. Edwards Deming. See http://www.lii.net/deming.html (http://www.lii.net/deming.html)
That's right, and the Japanese took to it very well, expanding upon Deming's ideas.
http://www.bpir.com/total-quality-management-history-of-tqm-and-business-excellence-bpir.com.html
-
The concept of Total Quality Management originated in Japan and has been applied to business and public administration models around the world.
The foundations of Japanese quality were laid, post WW2, by an American, Dr. W. Edwards Deming. See http://www.lii.net/deming.html (http://www.lii.net/deming.html)
That's right, and the Japanese took to it very well, expanding upon Deming's ideas.
http://www.bpir.com/total-quality-management-history-of-tqm-and-business-excellence-bpir.com.html
A very interesting reference, thanks. In another life, >15 years ago, I would devour such stuff avidly. Now I'm content with occasional lay overviews.
-
Within the toy industry (my field), production figures are high enough so that the big players (Walmart, Melissa& Doug, Tobar etc) have their own quality control people on the ground in China or even own their factories (M&D). This ensures that quality products come out that conform to spec and safety regs. The FOB trade is different, you rely on samples from the trade fairs etc to do your purchasing but you have no control as the product is not released until payment is made.
The melodeon trade is in this latter categary as the numbers are still small. For some other instruments UK companies have set up relationships with Chinese manufacturers and the quality is improving dramatically. Across the board I don't think this has yet happened in our field and I'm not sure the volumnes are going to be there to make it cost effective.
I would be interested to know just how much work, for example, The Music Room are having to do on each Sandpiper.
Steve
-
Within the toy industry (my field), production figures are high enough so that the big players (Walmart, Melissa& Doug, Tobar etc) have their own quality control people on the ground in China or even own their factories (M&D). This ensures that quality products come out that conform to spec and safety regs. The FOB trade is different, you rely on samples from the trade fairs etc to do your purchasing but you have no control as the product is not released until payment is made.
The melodeon trade is in this latter categary as the numbers are still small. For some other instruments UK companies have set up relationships with Chinese manufacturers and the quality is improving dramatically. Across the board I don't think this has yet happened in our field and I'm not sure the volumnes are going to be there to make it cost effective.
I would be interested to know just how much work, for example, The Music Room are having to do on each Sandpiper.
Steve
That's what I was crying for when I received my Panther (tuned by a deaf man?) earlier this year: someone in the US to perform a basic inspection upon the instrument's arrival from the factory. Large guitar companies do this routinely, performing QC on both sides of the Pacific. I'd like to see it more with accordions from China!
-
Why not just recognize the value (the Panther is a great value, pretty solid construction and components) and build in another $150 to have it tuned and set up proper?
IF you buy on ebay or the discount houses, you get that great initial price. Take it.
But then, if you want tune and playability, you have to pay more.
It has been said on this forum, over and over, and over, you get what you pay for.
-
Why not just recognize the value (the Panther is a great value, pretty solid construction and components) and build in another $150 to have it tuned and set up proper?
IF you buy on ebay or the discount houses, you get that great initial price. Take it.
But then, if you want tune and playability, you have to pay more.
It has been said on this forum, over and over, and over, you get what you pay for.
Normally, and especially with used goods, I wholeheartedly agree. But when I buy a new instrument from a company that specializes in new musical instruments, I expect to receive a working product in exchange for my payment. I paid the average price (not a discount), for a new, working accordion. What I received was a new, out of tune, non-functioning or semi-functioning accordion that required additional work in order to be fully functional.
So I didn't get what I paid for.
If an extra $150 must be added to insure this does not happen, then it should be done before any funds are exchanged. I'll pay the extra bit, but not after I purchase the accordion as a new item only to discover that I must run it around on top of two jobs, four classes, and the rest of my life. If I figured in the time it would have taken me to see the matter through to having a fully functioning instrument, then the cost would be more like $350 on top of what I'd already laid out. That's twice the price. And that's monkey business. I could have bought 7 out-of-tune vintage Hohners for that much dough 8)
-
What I received was a new, out of tune, non-functioning or semi-functioning accordion that required additional work in order to be fully functional.
If it was non-functioning, then it sounds like it was outside of spec, and you should have returned it for repair or replacement. Either the retailer or Hohner needs to make it right. It's a different question if it simply isn't to your liking, but if it doesn't function as a musical instrument, the rectification should be covered by the warranty. Did you contact Hohner or the retailer to solve the issues?
I think the Panther is a good value for a beginner.
-
George's crappyness to price ratio (C/P=V) has always been one of my "go to" metrics.
Such that when V=1, all things are equal. No basis to complain.
Anytime, when V is less than 1, be happy. ;D
When V is less than .75, you have a very nice deal. ;D ;D
When V is more than 1.05 , cie la vie. ???
When V is more than 1.10 start getting cranky, consider complaining :(
When V is more than 1.2 you have a bad deal, needs resolution. >:(
Whenever V exceeds 1.25, well >:E
-
What I received was a new, out of tune, non-functioning or semi-functioning accordion that required additional work in order to be fully functional.
If it was non-functioning, then it sounds like it was outside of spec, and you should have returned it for repair or replacement. Either the retailer or Hohner needs to make it right. It's a different question if it simply isn't to your liking, but if it doesn't function as a musical instrument, the rectification should be covered by the warranty. Did you contact Hohner or the retailer to solve the issues?
I think the Panther is a good value for a beginner.
That's exactly what I did - returned it at the retailer's expense. The kid on the phone with customer service said, "sorry, we don't retune accordions. You'd have to buy another one!" And it is certainly could be a good value for a beginner, provided the thing is in tune and works correctly. It played much better than the other Chinese three row boxes that cost about the same, and the casework seemed indestructible.
George's crappyness to price ratio (C/P=V) has always been one of my "go to" metrics.
Such that when V=1, all things are equal. No basis to complain.
Anytime, when V is less than 1, be happy. Grin
When V is less than .75, you have a very nice deal. Grin Grin
When V is more than 1.05 , cie la vie. Huh?
When V is more than 1.10 start getting cranky, consider complaining Sad
When V is more than 1.2 you have a bad deal, needs resolution. Angry
Whenever V exceeds 1.25, well Evil
lol... my method is to hand the accordion to someone who has never played the box. In this case, she said "what the hell is wrong with this thing?" followed by "don't play that note any more, it's making me feel sick!"
-
Quote from Melodeon:
"Tombo would be my choice.. they make very fine harmonicas... too bad only the "Lee OSKARS" are available in the US . . .
. . . I suspect there are companies in Japan that could make a very fine melodeon. Perhaps it has not penetrated their culture, as has the guitar and mandolin. Some of the finest guitars and mandolins are made in Japan and have been since the 60's... and not
"law suit models" but their own. Examples would be OCHAI ( SP) and SUMI mandolins, Kohno and Yamaha ( high end ) guitars."
In regard to Japanese made melodeons, there was a Tombo melodeon on eBay about six months ago. It looked to be from the 20s and of the usual type that was made in the thousands in Germany back then.
I agree with Jeff (Melodeon) about the quality of Tombo harmonicas and also would like to see their other products in the US.
-
I see that the box that sparked off this discussion has now dropped to £149.95 (+£15 carriage)
For Pete's sake someone just buy one and put us all out of our misery!
I would, but have just blown my savings on a Sandpiper from TMR - if that is Chinese construction then long live Chinese constructors! The Sandpiper is a gobsmackingly beautiful looking and sounding box with a finish, playability and sound quality that says £2,000 rather than the £700 I paid!
-
There are quality instruments coming out of some Chinese factories, but not the mass-produced "melodeon-shaped" objects sold for a few hundred pounds/dollars/euros.
Reputed manufacturers that use quality parts and materials, and perform proper quality control can indeed have instruments made in China or anywhere else, that offer the quality you would expect.
-
would the Sandpiper technically be considered a Chinese melodeon? or are they put together in the UK?
-
Reeds--where does one go to be suitably dazzled?
-
Well that would be only at Jim Laab Music near Oshkosh Wisconsin, USA -
http://www.jimlaabsmusic.com/
Excalibur North American Guadalajara
Also on ebay:
http://cgi.ebay.com/Excalibur-North-American-Guadalajara-4-Color-Choices-/300493748661?pt=LH_DefaultDomain_0&hash=item45f6d2b9b5
Like I always say, "STABILITY: Perfect straight upper and lower butt assemblies are essential to proper installation of the bellows."
-
Next I need to get a bass boost switch.
-
Well that would be only at Jim Laab Music near Oshkosh Wisconsin, USA -
http://www.jimlaabsmusic.com/
The "European" model looks suspiciously like the one marketed under the Guidi name (though that has a bit of inlay), and obviously modelled very closely on the Serenellini 213k; I think I'd probably fork out the extra for the Serenellini, myself......
-
Well that would be only at Jim Laab Music near Oshkosh Wisconsin, USA -
http://www.jimlaabsmusic.com/
The "European" model looks suspiciously like the one marketed under the Guidi name (though that has a bit of inlay), and obviously modelled very closely on the Serenellini 213k; I think I'd probably fork out the extra for the Serenellini, myself......
They do look very similar.
-
"Expert Castelfidardo workmanship" That would be true if Castelfidardo were in Shanghai!
-
"Expert Castelfidardo workmanship" That would be true if Castelfidardo were in Shanghai!
... or there is a guy named 'Castelfidardo' in the Chinese factory...
-
Well that would be only at Jim Laab Music near Oshkosh Wisconsin, USA -
http://www.jimlaabsmusic.com/
Excalibur North American Guadalajara
Also on ebay:
http://cgi.ebay.com/Excalibur-North-American-Guadalajara-4-Color-Choices-/300493748661?pt=LH_DefaultDomain_0&hash=item45f6d2b9b5
Like I always say, "STABILITY: Perfect straight upper and lower butt assemblies are essential to proper installation of the bellows."
Thank you for that, I've never laughed so hard at an eBay listing before. :D
I'm so envious of all those Excalibur owners with their 16 sphere bellows...
-
You get same laugh on Ebay in Bagpipe section it states Makers is called Blackwood of Africa, I wrote and told them it should be bagpipes are made of African Blackwood, no company called Blackwood, and as usual they continued and ignored me.they cant understand African Blackwood doesnt grow in Pakistan or India, Black wood has nothing to do with colour,often wonder where ebay workers are educated.
-
I see that the box that sparked off this discussion has now dropped to £149.95 (+£15 carriage)
For Pete's sake someone just buy one and put us all out of our misery!
I have actually seen a couple of these boxes. The first was in the London branch of Hobgoblin, the second at The Music Room. I do not know if the one in Hobgoblin was typical, but even as a beginner, I was not impressed. None of the reeds on the higher half of both treble rows would sound in either direction, and the box was quickly put back on the shelf. That was maybe six months ago and I would not be surprised if it were still there now.
-
Someone has bought one from the eBay listing. Almost certainly nobody here. I wonder how they're getting on. I wonder what the returns policy is? Perhaps I'll get one and send it back if its a 'pup'.
-
The instrument in the original ad looks identical to the first melodeon I bought, second-hand, off of e-bay. It was badged "Scarlatti" and had been bought originally from Hobgoblin music. It had a number faults:
- it was not well tuned
- several of the low reeds on the treble side made a nasty vibrating noise when played, almost like an overtone to the note
- some notes played quieter than others
- there was some air-leakage.
On the plus side, the mechanics were very good - the action was considerably better than on the Chinese pokerwork I eventually replaced it with, the exterior fit and finish was good, and the left-hand strap was adjustable (my pokerwork's isn't). Also there were no thirds in the bass, which I quite liked. If I had been a competent fixer-up of melodeons, I suspect I could have made something rather nice out of it. I sold it on ebay, in the end -I got about £150 for it, which I think is probably fair.
I am however still fairly new to melodeons, so my comments are by no means those of an expert.