Have you ever enlarged the holes and bushed the holes with felt? It seems like a nice upgrade.I'm about to do that on a Hohner Erica. Lester has kindly supplied me with replacement nails for the rod pivots (which I need to dismantle to get access to the button holes), and I have bought some proper concertina bushing felt from David Leese in North Wales which I hope will be just the job. Will report back as and when I progress with the work.
I'm about to do that on a Hohner Erica. Lester has kindly supplied me with replacement nails for the rod pivots (which I need to dismantle to get access to the button holes), and I have bought some proper concertina bushing felt from David Leese in North Wales which I hope will be just the job. Will report back as and when I progress with
Here are my photos of the instrument before repairs.
http://picasaweb.google.com/TeleMorris/PresswoodPokerwork?authkey=Gv1sRgCLuXpqru26SMfg#
I would recommend disconnecting the springs before either unscrewing or replacing the mechanism as they place a lot of strain on the very small brass screws until the mechanism is screwed down with all the screws. |
Right-oh. It may take me a while to get going with it though, at this time of year.
I'm about to do that on a Hohner Erica. Lester has kindly supplied me with replacement nails for the rod pivots (which I need to dismantle to get access to the button holes), and I have bought some proper concertina bushing felt from David Leese in North Wales which I hope will be just the job. Will report back as and when I progress with
Photos please as it is on my list for my super-Erica I'm building.
Right-oh. It may take me a while to get going with it though, at this time of year.
Well, I'm far from expert on this, but I've done a half dozen or so (with much help from others here) and actually happened to take a few photos along the way. So, on the chance that they may be of help to anyone here, I've posted them at Picasa, along with some explanatory notes.
You can find them here: http://picasaweb.google.com/robtgf/HohnerPokerwork?feat=directlink (http://picasaweb.google.com/robtgf/HohnerPokerwork?feat=directlink)
Bob
Well, I'm far from expert on this, but I've done a half dozen or so (with much help from others here) and actually happened to take a few photos along the way. So, on the chance that they may be of help to anyone here, I've posted them at Picasa, along with some explanatory notes.Nice work. I need to re-visit the bass on my Pokerwork.
You can find them here: http://picasaweb.google.com/robtgf/HohnerPokerwork?feat=directlink (http://picasaweb.google.com/robtgf/HohnerPokerwork?feat=directlink)
Bob
Lester, would you mind explaining "Super Erica", please? I'm really curious now.
Well, I'm far from expert on this, but I've done a half dozen or so (with much help from others here) and actually happened to take a few photos along the way. So, on the chance that they may be of help to anyone here, I've posted them at Picasa, along with some explanatory notes.
You can find them here: http://picasaweb.google.com/robtgf/HohnerPokerwork?feat=directlink (http://picasaweb.google.com/robtgf/HohnerPokerwork?feat=directlink)
Bob
Well, I'm far from expert on this, but I've done a half dozen or so (with much help from others here) and actually happened to take a few photos along the way. So, on the chance that they may be of help to anyone here, I've posted them at Picasa, along with some explanatory notes.That's really nice work. What a great sequence of photos.
You can find them here: http://picasaweb.google.com/robtgf/HohnerPokerwork?feat=directlink (http://picasaweb.google.com/robtgf/HohnerPokerwork?feat=directlink)
Bob
snip
Interested by the ultrasonic cleaner. Is this one that uses water as a solvent? Does it work well?
The cheap ones really aren't worth it, you need one of the proper industrial ones that start at a couple of hundred quid.
I bought a £40 one, (when it was on sale for £25), and I've tried different cleaning solutions and none of them really shift stubborn rust, wax or glue. They make it a lot easier to remove but they don't get very good results, even cleaning for ages and ages in pretty strong solvents. Boiling in plain water is more effective and cheaper. In both cases I applied camelia oil to the reed tongues and no problems with rusting so far.
I tried boiling some reeds that I thought were beyond redemption in pickling vinegar and after only a few minutes nearly all the rust was gone....along with the blue oxide layer on the base and undersides of the tongues.... ::)
I tried boiling some reeds that I thought were beyond redemption in pickling vinegar and after only a few minutes nearly all the rust was gone....along with the blue oxide layer on the base and undersides of the tongues.... ::)
having seen a post from Theo in the archives warning against that.
I don't like the idea of using solvents to clean wax off reeds or blocks.Is that because it opens them up to corrosion, or a different reason? Interesting because there was a mention somewhere of using an ultrasonic bath which might have a similar effect.
Third photo? - I can only see two... ???
I get a squeek, groan, high pitched overtone, flapping warble, but not a note, though I do hear air passing through the reed plate.
Assuming that it is a German M. Grimm valve, the beige part should be appr. 1/3 shorter in order to allow the white part to open satisfactorily. It looks wider than necessary, indicating again that it was probably meant to cover a larger reed. It's perfectly alright to adjust the length of plastic valves (within reason) as long as one remembers to cut the covering parts correspondingly. By not doing so, sound quality can suffer significantly.
These are usually symptoms of the reed tongue either being obstructed by a bit of airborne debris (sometimes too small to see with the naked eye) or the reed tongue coming into contact with the side of the vent. The latter can be a result of the reed tongue being off centre, damage to the edge of the vent leaving a projecting burr, or occasionally the reed having the beginnings of a crack causing it to bend slightly sideways.
@telemorris: If these valves are the smallest in the set, and if they really are Grimm valves (but then, where else should they come from?) they have definitely been shortened after they left the factory.
I would only have used the two right hand side size valves on the treble end, the others are to big. I would also have trimmed he overlapping bit (technical term) to be the same proportion as it was on the uncut valve - hopefully you understand that, if not I will try again ;D
I would only have used the two right hand side size valves on the treble end, the others are to big. I would also have trimmed he overlapping bit (technical term) to be the same proportion as it was on the uncut valve - hopefully you understand that, if not I will try again ;D
Thanks Lester. Yes, your comments/instructions make sense. I could pull off the valves I've put on so far and match the valve length to the chamber length. Are you thinking I should not have used the large white leather valve then? I'll need to count the valve blanks I have and make sure I'll have enough valves in the correct sizes to do 84 reeds. I know there are a couple of extras for each size.
For the last reeds on the block that require valves I'd go for a valve without cover.
To what length should the valves be positioned/cut? Just overlapping the cut-out, or rather more?
Yes, that's quite alright. I did that myself once, when I had run out of #13F.
I'd be interested in knowing whether your reeds with more suitable valves now behave as they should when being pre-tuned.
Hmm, that doesn't sound pleasant. I have a horrible feeling that the papers as well as the tape on my Imperial need replacing, which would increase the work significantly and your experience meets up to my expectations :P
I dare say that Theo, Rees, and the others who are professionals, with all their years of experience, still find themselves with repair tasks that have not come up before