Melodeon.net Forums
Discussions => Instrument Design, Construction and Repair => Topic started by: blafleur on December 12, 2010, 01:08:46 AM
-
Been doing a lot of research on reeds and just heard of the A Mano Bombatte's, but not a lot of info on them. Anyone who's used them notice a tonal difference between them and A mano's? Response is reported to be much better. What company('s) make them?
I'm building myself a one row and may consider these.
Thanks,
Bryan
-
I haven't heard anything about them. Dancemaster has been selling them for a year or so. You might contact them.
-
I intend to AJ. I believe he has Voci Armoniche's. Very little about these on the web.
-
He was going to put them on the Hohner you see in my Profile pic, I went for Binci TaM instead due to price difference.
-
Some info concerning A Mano Bombate and the even more exclusive A Mano Tirate in an other thread: "What makes heavy etc." in Instrument Makes & Models
-
Yep, Diatonix, that was the thread that started me on my quest. I can't find any other info on the tirates, and very little on the bombattes. There was a thread or two on the Reyes forum also.
Santa Clause will be getting an odd request this year.
-
Information on a lot of accordion related production is pretty scant.
The reed makers have a large and very reliable market right on their doorstep so they don't really need to take the time and effort to chase orders from the relatively small one outside Castelfidardo. They also have no real rivals elsewhere in the world so they know people who want high quality accordion reeds are going to have to come to them.
I suspect the only way to really get any kind of in-depth information is to go to Castelfidardo, make appointments with them and talk face to face...ideally with a huge wad of Euros...
Andy Simpson, currently taking Italian lessons....
-
[...] go to Castelfidardo, make appointments with them [...]
I'm not sure that "appointments" translates into the local language...
-
Which makes it harder still... ;D
I certainly get the impression that they don't need to do the hard sell in Castelfidardo so business is very much on their terms and the onus seems to be on the buyer to make it worth their while.
Even if I'm totally wrong, it's certainly different from the way things are done in the anglophone world...
-
My hope is to find a middle man to get some from, and I'd like to start with one set in mine to see what they sound like before I do too much investing. Even if the response is better than Binci A Mano's, I'm still very curious as to the tone and actual sound. Pretty intriguing.
-
You are right, Andy, when it comes to chromatic reeds. But when talking about first class diatonic reeds the situation is very different. Few Italian makers put them into their diatonic instruments. Even Castagnari uses TAM with only very few exceptions. Top diatonic reed makers such as Binci and his few competitors depend largely on the foreign market.
-
Hmm, that's interesting, it makes sense when I think about it.
Wherever their products are going, none of them seem to have to try too hard to attract business or have much need to advertise their wares and the customer has to do a bit of digging to find out what they need.
-
You are right, Andy, when it comes to chromatic reeds. But when talking about first class diatonic reeds the situation is very different. Few Italian makers put them into their diatonic instruments. Even Castagnari uses TAM with only very few exceptions. Top diatonic reed makers such as Binci and his few competitors depend largely on the foreign market.
And Binci, while offering several options, is basically making reeds that would be called TAM (or perhaps a mano?) by Voci Armoniche, right?
My impression is that the reeds typically used in high-end diatonics, i.e. Bincis and Antonelli/Salpa TAMs, are a compromise between loudness and responsiveness, and that they reflect the desires and needs of many diatonic players. The more extreme a mano options like bombate etc might sacrifice the higher end of the volume range to an extent that most diatonic players would not desire. Is this correct? One can tweak a bit more responsiveness, at the price of a bit of volume, by ordering longer-scale reeds from Binci or VA, without going all the way to a mano or even bombate.
-
A very important difference between TAM and AM consists of the fact that the raw material (steel) is fundamentally different. TAM reeds are punched out from steel plates (often already pre-tuned befor being cut), whereas AM reeds are made from long thin, already slightly bent strips of (usually Swedish) band steel. Its width corresponds to that of the reed foot, which as a consequence shows bluish edges on the sides. Usually the reeds are made as "Siamese" twins, sharing a long common foot which subsequently is cut in the middle (this is done by hand, small imperfections being another way of distinguishing AM from TAM). For many years, Binci has only had the latter type in his repertoire, so his reeds may justly be called AM (a mano).
I have recently become familiar with even more sophisticated reeds (bombate and tirate) from another excellent Castelfidardan reed maker. I don't have the necessary equipment to measure "loudness", "responsiveness" or "richness" nor do I want it. All good A mano reeds should be responsive, but my and many of my customers' impression is that by "upgrading" (I don't really like that term, given the fact that Bincis' standard type of AM reeds are, inspite of casual issues, nothing but wonderful) you get an even richer sound, with all the effortless power associated with AM.
-
Diatonix, what is the difference between Bombatte and Tirade?
-
I cannot tell you much more than what I posted in my answer to Melodeon in the already mentioned thread ("what makes heavy etc.), reply #34. Basically, bombate ("rounded") reeds are supposed to offer optimal aerodynamic conditions. Tirate ("stretched") reeds are said to have optimized the inherent sound producing potential of the steel by grinding/filing it (and thus influencing its elasticity/stiffness) in a certain manner. An interesting conclusion which just crossed my mind is that theoretically it should make sense to make combined tirate/bombate reeds. Hmm, that's something I must ask my reed maker. On the other hand, let's not exaggerate...
-
Since I haven't played a box with AM reeds I'm wondering is the response of these new reed types really any different than the TaM Binci's. I would assume that the more voices you have in a box there is an incremental need for reed performance. That said is there really that much performance difference between Binci TaM and AM and these Tirate Bombate reeds. Enough to make a significant difference in performance and dynamics? My understanding is that the average boxplayer would be hard put to discern the difference between the TaM reeds and the AM reeds. What does that say about Tirate and Bombate?
-
My understanding is that the average boxplayer would be hard put to discern the difference between the TaM reeds and the AM reeds.
I'm not sure that is true. Most Cajun box players readily distinguish Bincis from Salpas, and the Salpas that were typically supplied for Cajun boxes were TAM, whereas according to the info above, Binci prof are basically AM.
-
@A.J.: Both types have been around for many years. It's more like that until not so long ago it was widely considered an absolute waste to put them into the simple, supposed to be cheap diatonic instruments.
-
All the old Paolo Sopranis that I have seen were never fitted with TAM or AM reeds at the factory.
-
All the old Paolo Sopranis that I have seen were never fitted with TAM or AM reeds at the factory.
Agreed, I've had 12 paolo sopranis over the last years, and all have had "regular" no-fuss reeds. There were some difference, though. One thing is the scale length:
The 1920's reeds were a little thin, short scale, and had very very long scale deep bass reeds. Great sound and response, and they have a very fine range of harmonics throughout the range. Not as loud as later reeds, though.
The 1930's reeds were quite similar, though the bass reeds were down to a more modern lenth. Sounded alright, but I find they don't have the same ringing tone as the 20's, and not the power of the 40's...
The 40's brough the real deal. Still just basic factory-made reeds, but if played a lot over the years, they have an very open, ringing sound. My favorite kind of reeds were put in some Paolo Sopranis made by Busilacchio in this decade - no matter what kind of box Ive heard them in, they sounded incredible. Much more open than the reeds in the Pancotti-made dark grey paolo sopranis.
The early 50's reeds are just all round fab. With just a little regular playing, they will keep that special open tone; clear enough to ring, but not enough harmonics to get too bright. Not as powerful as modern Binci reeds, but to me, they just sound "right".
The 60's are a little too late for my taste, but I've had a paolo from this era as well. Very nice reeds, but I did not play this box enough to get much of an opinion on the reeds.
As for binci reeds - I recently tried different reeds on comparable boxes (Paolos from the early-mid 50's, same size and all MMM) - one with Binci TAM, one had Binci AM-professional, one had original Paolo reeds, and one had Cagnoni TAM reeds. All reeds were played regularly to get them 'played in'. I preferred the sound of the old paolo reeds, the binci AM were lovely, though a bit of a 'hard' tone, but Ive kept the binci TAM for best tone/volume/harmonics ratio.
__________
NOTE: The above is based on reeds that have played a lot (been played 'in'), and only excamples where I've tried the same reeds in different kind of boxes, to keep focus on the reeds - not the boxes.
-
Wow, thanks Lars! That is real information.
-
I have this vision of Italian reedmakers winking at each other over how much extra people are willing to pay for a few hammer blows on the rivet and some bluing. ;)
-
Wow, thanks Lars! That is real information.
Lars, thanks from me also. Over the years I did a lot of careful switching experiments of that sort with reeds in concertinas, and the results are very interesting. I haven't yet done much of that with accordions, but it will be great to keep in mind your results for comparison. With concertinas I found that the most desirable qualities in reeds also varied with the skill level and playing style of the player!
PG
-
Lars, thanks from me also. Over the years I did a lot of careful switching experiments of that sort with reeds in concertinas, and the results are very interesting. I haven't yet done much of that with accordions, but it will be great to keep in mind your results for comparison. With concertinas I found that the most desirable qualities in reeds also varied with the skill level and playing style of the player!
Just keep in mind that I like my accordions tuned to around the -15, 0, +15 cents, or wetter. It does make a difference. I tried having the 20's reeds tuned very dry (5 cents), and they sounded very squeaky. At 10 cents, they opened up quite a bit, both in a paolo and in a hohner. Personally, I think old reeds always sounds a little better with a solid tremolo, whereas new reeds will have good quialities at both dry and wet settings.
Concertinas, yes. Never got around to fix up my old Lachenal, but the brass reeds sure sound swell!
-
I have this vision of Italian reedmakers winking at each other over how much extra people are willing to pay for a few hammer blows on the rivet and some bluing. ;)
Yeah, it's like the "hand hammered" cymbals, I can imagine a guy holding the cymbal in his hands while moving it under the hydraulic hammer...
-
I have this vision of Italian reedmakers winking at each other over how much extra people are willing to pay for a few hammer blows on the rivet and some bluing. ;)
That got a chuckle. I think the power of the mind can come into play in this. If someone thinks they have better reeds, then they hear better reeds. Might be the case for me, but I won't be happy till I hear a set.
-
Just think about the meaning of the expression tipo a mano and what it could actually mean... Besides, with the technology we have today, robot-made reeds are probably made with a lot more precision than anyone could do by hand!
-
Ciccarelli Bombate reeds on brass plates ordered through Dancemaster. I think this is the feeling I remember as a kid right before Christmas. Can't wait to hear 'em.
What a knowledgeable and friendly guy Michael at Dancemaster is.
-
Yep he has worked on 4-5 boxes for me and he has always been very helpful. There are some detractors of his work but I'm not one of them. He does like to talk though!
-
He does like to talk though!
Ha ha, he does, and it works out great because what he says is worth listening to and I love to listen to someone who knows his stuff and is so willing to share it.
-
Ciccarelli Bombate reeds on brass plates ordered through Dancemaster. I think this is the feeling I remember as a kid right before Christmas. Can't wait to hear 'em.
What a knowledgeable and friendly guy Michael at Dancemaster is.
Fantastic, looking forward to hear the results (:) I have an optimistic hope that a course on vibration next term coupled with my doubtless disastrous attempts at tuning will mean that I will understand reeds. I have a feeling that reed acoustics is post-doc stuff though...
-
From what I know, most Busilacchios were exportet to the Australian market - you'll see a lot of them down there - in G/C or C/C#.
A friend of mine just got a Busilacchio-made Paolo (red 3v.), and it sounds very very close to a grey box. It's branded Paolo Soprani, but is clearly made by Busilacchio, and even has many features in common with the early grey boxes of the early 40's.
I've seen a few Busilacchios, some in better condition than others. They sound just as good as red paolos I think, but since they've all been 2 voice models, it's hard to say if they have the same sound as the 3 voice paolos - you get the feeling that some of the sound is there, but the 3 voice musette just kicks in some extra force.
I know there's a few 3 voice Busilacchios out there - I'd love to have one, but they seem very rare compared to the 2 voice models.
-
I'm building myself a one row and may consider these.
Thanks,
Bryan
Hi Bryan
I am in the process of building a one row as well and would like to talk.
I will pm you .
thanks
Michael