Melodeon.net Forums

Discussions => General Discussion => Topic started by: Andrew Culwell on December 14, 2010, 01:33:29 AM

Title: 4 stop Irish single row eBay purchase?
Post by: Andrew Culwell on December 14, 2010, 01:33:29 AM
Sounds interesting but no...I got overly exuberant in bidding for a 4 stop Irish single row but nothing green!
Title: 4 stop Irish single row eBay purchase?
Post by: Christopher K. on December 14, 2010, 01:47:51 AM
I think I know both those boxes...

Green one, but the buttons aren't black, I think it was available along with a small burgundy/red one of different make, from member g.mu6. It didn't sell the first time and is still available. Might not be the same box.
http://cgi.ebay.com/Small-old-button-accordion-/130463028423

And the expensive one-row A.J. - did you win it? I was trying to figure out the reason it got so high, other than the provenance.
http://cgi.ebay.com/ws/eBayISAPI.dll?ViewItem&item=180597014202

 :||: :||: :||:
Title: 4 stop Irish single row eBay purchase?
Post by: Andrew Culwell on December 14, 2010, 02:25:08 AM
Yes that's the one, I immediately experienced buyers remorse.  The provenance was the most exciting thing to me as I really am into the history of that era and particularly Irish American music hall culture, the clincher was the shape it's in.  Of course I don't even play the one row that well.  It really is just a piece of history that appealed to me.  It was way overpriced, but I have never seen one like it, I'm sure Paul Groff can weigh in and enlighten me as to how rare it is.  Of course who knows what I will do with it, I might even trade it down the line for something that I will play more.  

That's the reason I'm selling my black Double Ray.  I just can't justify that kind of price tag without offsetting it.  I guess you could just call it an early Christmas gift.
Title: 4 stop Irish single row eBay purchase?
Post by: Andrew Culwell on December 14, 2010, 02:03:03 PM
Actually I think it's more along the lines of a Globe Melodeon.  Which a number of folks in this parrish own and consider to be of some value, that said it could be what you say.   The value is really in the markings and the provenance. Including the original box marked as O'byrne Dewitt.  Some may scoff at this, but the idea wasn't to buy it just to play it but for it's uniqueness and it's history.  That said it may turn out to be a foolish purchase.  I knew that before I hit the enter button.   I believe thought that it's a Globe Melodeon, very similar to my other Globe.  On the face of it the price is exhorbitant, but I'm pleased with what I see so far. "One mans trash is another mans treasure"
Title: 4 stop Irish single row eBay purchase?
Post by: pgroff on December 14, 2010, 02:34:37 PM
Drew (A. J.),

If you are referring to this one, mentioned by cpsmart above:

"... the expensive one-row A.J. - did you win it? I was trying to figure out the reason it got so high, other than the provenance.
http://cgi.ebay.com/ws/eBayISAPI.dll?ViewItem&item=180597014202"

Yes, these O'Byrne DeWitt labeled Dienst Internationals are similar in quality and construction to the Meisel- imported Globes.  I have at least one similar OBD International 1-row 4-stop that was reportedly bought by the father of one of my pals at the new OBD shop around 1925. That one is in G, MMHH, but obviously D would have been common. Great accordions of their type, and your new one is really in spectacular condition. Don't break those bellows clasps -- I'd take them off, replace with metal ones you can fabricate or leather ones, and save the originals aside.  Also, don't retune it right away -- gently clean, releather, and re-wax the reeds (which is a pain due to the glued-down blocks) and note down the original pitch and the (probably) beautiful original unequal temperament.  Yes, C# and F# will be flat!  Is G also tuned flat on this? And what about B, E, and A?

Take lots of pics including the writing on the accordion and the box (before that crumbles) and send them to Steve Chambers!

You paid a lot but no more than a new Weltmeister melodeon and it is amazing to find one like yours in such condition.

PG
Title: 4 stop Irish single row eBay purchase?
Post by: Graham Spencer on December 14, 2010, 03:04:38 PM
On the face of it the price is exhorbitant, but I'm pleased with what I see so far. "One mans trash is another mans treasure"

Absolutely - I couldn't agree more. What matters is that you're happy with it, and I really hope it does turn out that Theo and I are wrong! I'll be interested to see what history you eventually dig up.

Graham
Title: 4 stop Irish single row eBay purchase?
Post by: Andrew Culwell on December 14, 2010, 05:54:40 PM
Oops this is like two threads in one!  Confusing to say the least.  So Paul, I will do as you say.  I'm very interested to see what this box looks and sounds like.  the bellows I'm told are air tight and in fantastic shape.  I'm sure the valves and reeds need some attention but I'm anxious to have the box back to it's original tuning and fettle.  Since I am in no way equipped or versed enough in restoration I don't know who to go to for this job.  Paul if you know of anyone that is capable and willing then let me know.  I'm planning to keep it all original although if the reeds are screwed in I'm more than likely going to go with Waxed in for practicality.  What is your take on this? 
Title: 4 stop Irish single row eBay purchase?
Post by: pgroff on December 14, 2010, 06:03:34 PM
Hi Drew,

Why not post some pics when it arrives?

Hey, does everyone agree it might make sense to ask a moderator to split this thread and/or for Drew to start another one for his O'Byrne DeWitt International?  BTW later this month I may be able to photo mine as well.

PG
Title: Re: 4 stop Irish single row eBay purchase?
Post by: Theo on December 14, 2010, 06:41:22 PM
Topics split.

 It would be really really helpful if everyone posting could start a new thread when there you want to say something about a different subject.

 If anyone thinks their own contribution is in the wrong place please PM me.
Title: Re: 4 stop Irish single row eBay purchase?
Post by: Andrew Culwell on December 17, 2010, 03:53:57 PM
Well the Box arrived.  I had emailed the gentleman who sold it immediately after the sale to instruct him how to pack it and send it.  He packed it incorrectly.  He left the Accordion in the original box unpadded and packed the original box in another box that was packed well.  The accordion rattled around in the interior box and came to me in pieces internally, guts obliterated.  The Accordion externally is beautiful the reeds were rattling loose and the internal mechanism was broken.  I'm distraught because I don't even know how to put it back together.  Here is the box directly after I unpacked it.
Title: Re: 4 stop Irish single row eBay purchase?
Post by: Theo on December 17, 2010, 04:03:20 PM
I don't think its too serious Drew.  The reeds would have to come out anyway for new valves and wax.  The reed blocks will need to be carefully glued back together, but the wood parts seem to have survived more or less intact.
Title: Re: 4 stop Irish single row eBay purchase?
Post by: Lester on December 17, 2010, 04:07:51 PM
I would be really surprised if the damage shown was as a result of it being transported badly. The reeds coming off I could understand but the reed plate damage and the cracks in the sound board I would imagine were there before it was packed.

But like Theo said it looks like it could be fixed with some TLC.
Title: Re: 4 stop Irish single row eBay purchase?
Post by: Andrew Culwell on December 17, 2010, 04:09:51 PM
Agreed, however prior to the sale I asked the seller if there was anything rattling around in the box and he replied in the negative.  Oh well Caveat Emptor!
Title: Re: 4 stop Irish single row eBay purchase?
Post by: Owen Woods on December 17, 2010, 04:20:48 PM
The soundboard looks like the only thing that could be a problem :-\ It would have needed restoring anyway, which would require all the reeds to be removed as Theo says. The reedblocks look like they'd glue well.

The crack in the soundboard wasn't there in the listing, so I think that you should be able to claim some money back off the chap. If that needs replacing then it could change the character of the box. Best send it to a sympathetic repairer!
Title: Re: 4 stop Irish single row eBay purchase?
Post by: Andrew Culwell on December 17, 2010, 04:25:47 PM
You are correct that the crack wasn't there.  Simply packing the box correctly would have solved this issue.  Now to find a sympathetic repairer!
Title: Re: 4 stop Irish single row eBay purchase?
Post by: Owen Woods on December 17, 2010, 05:16:58 PM
Was it insured? I would definitely try to get some money back. Sorry that it hasn't worked out well :(
Title: Re: 4 stop Irish single row eBay purchase?
Post by: Andrew Culwell on December 17, 2010, 05:24:50 PM
It was insured, not sure how much though. Have to investigate my options. 
Title: Re: 4 stop Irish single row eBay purchase?
Post by: Theo on December 17, 2010, 05:47:21 PM
You are correct that the crack wasn't there.  Simply packing the box correctly would have solved this issue.  Now to find a sympathetic repairer!

Are you sure?  The description mentions "There is a seam on the wooden face that is opened a 1/16 " under the 6th pad from the left"  which you can just about see because it goes through the R of Steel Reeds above the 6th pallet
Title: Re: 4 stop Irish single row eBay purchase?
Post by: Quebecois on December 17, 2010, 05:53:44 PM
Agreed, however prior to the sale I asked the seller if there was anything rattling around in the box and he replied in the negative. 
The description states: "Everything moves freely"  :o
Title: Re: 4 stop Irish single row eBay purchase?
Post by: an bosca ceoil on December 17, 2010, 05:54:05 PM
The soundboard looks like the only thing that could be a problem :-\ It would have needed restoring anyway, which would require all the reeds to be removed as Theo says. The reedblocks look like they'd glue well.

The crack in the soundboard wasn't there in the listing, so I think that you should be able to claim some money back off the chap. If that needs replacing then it could change the character of the box. Best send it to a sympathetic repairer!

According to the listing " a seam in the wooden face had opened up 1/16" behind pallet 6 " - so it was mentioned.
Title: Re: 4 stop Irish single row eBay purchase?
Post by: Andrew Culwell on December 17, 2010, 05:55:38 PM
Ah well...then nothing to do but move forward with restoration.  It is over 75 years old after all!
Title: Re: 4 stop Irish single row eBay purchase?
Post by: an bosca ceoil on December 17, 2010, 06:16:50 PM
Look on the positive side, at least the vendors poor packaging has saved you the problem of getting the blocks unglued (:)
Title: Re: 4 stop Irish single row eBay purchase?
Post by: Andrew Culwell on December 17, 2010, 06:21:23 PM
That's a glass half full!  What worries me is that the glue holding the thing together might be crystallized and so dried out that the whole box needs a re-glue.  It really is a pretty box.  I just think it deserves to be restored and played for that historical sound!
Title: Re: 4 stop Irish single row eBay purchase?
Post by: Owen Woods on December 18, 2010, 01:43:26 AM
According to the listing " a seam in the wooden face had opened up 1/16" behind pallet 6 " - so it was mentioned.

Are you sure?  The description mentions "There is a seam on the wooden face that is opened a 1/16 " under the 6th pad from the left"  which you can just about see because it goes through the R of Steel Reeds above the 6th pallet

Haha, this is what comes of not reading the description :P Apologies, yes, it was mentioned. It does seem to have opened up though, whether this is because of dodgy packaging or not I don't know. Would it be difficult to fix Theo?
Title: Re: 4 stop Irish single row eBay purchase?
Post by: Theo on December 18, 2010, 09:28:05 AM
Always tricky to fix what appears to be  shrinkage crack in a thin panel of solid timber.   If this was furniture the panel would not be fixed with glue thus allowing movement to continue as a result of seasonal changes in humidity.  Clearly that would lead to an instrument that is not airtight.  Replace the panel with ply?  Very unsatisfactory on an otherwise original piece.   One approach worth considering would be to fill the crack, and apply a veneer over the entire inside surface, with the grain running at right angles.  In order to get the lettering looking right the frame should be removed , and the crack closed up,  when the panel could perhaps be fixed with a flexible glue??? Its certainly not as simple as it looks. You could just fill the crack and hope for the best.   :o
Title: Re: 4 stop Irish single row eBay purchase?
Post by: Mike Averill on December 18, 2010, 03:41:40 PM
seal the cracked piece in a plastic bag with some fresh orange peel. Leave for a week or two.

I've used this technique with cracked woodwind instrument joints with sucess - Im sure it will work with other instrements as long as they are wooden.
Title: Re: 4 stop Irish single row eBay purchase?
Post by: oggiesnr on December 18, 2010, 06:43:28 PM
On a guitar or similar, the approach would probably be to clean the crack up and chamfer it and insert a wedge shaped fillet which is then sanded flush.  Then refinish as required.

Steve
Title: Re: 4 stop Irish single row eBay purchase?
Post by: Theo on December 18, 2010, 08:01:19 PM
Yes that would be the simplest.  Downside would be that the lettering would end up disrupted.
Title: Re: 4 stop Irish single row eBay purchase?
Post by: RGF on December 18, 2010, 11:06:45 PM
Sounds like a dreadful lot of work, but........could one add material at the ends of the panel rather than at the break?

Rather than trying to fill the gap, could the panel be removed from the frame and the two pieces edge-glued back together, thus maintaing the lettering? (Or at least rendering it restorable by a paintings conservator or someone with similar skills.) Then, if needed, perhaps a tiny filler strip could be edge-glued at one or both ends to restore the length. With luck, those might disappear into the frame rabbet, or -- if not -- at least it might be preferable to paint at the ends of the panel, rather than across the lettering.

Just bouncing ideas. Hope I've worded it in an understandable way!

Bob
Bob
Title: Re: 4 stop Irish single row eBay purchase?
Post by: Andrew Culwell on December 18, 2010, 11:34:08 PM
I've been consulting with some experts via email, some members of this forum about this box.  One thought is that the reason the melodeon never got played was that the box was damaged early on.  His theory being that the box was probably dropped soon after purchase or before purchase resulting in  the damage seen and either a return to the retailer or simply placed in a closet and left there to moulder.

  I've also considered just taking the best parts of the OBDW box and combining it with my Globe that is in similar condition but the bellows and keyboard on the OBDW are in fine condition.  I know makes for a very expensive bellows replacement.  But the alternative seems to be two classic old Melodeons both in need of a lot of work.  Why not cut my losses and combine the best of both?  Short of finding someone else to buy the OBDW I don't think I'm going to regain my initial investment. 
Title: Re: 4 stop Irish single row eBay purchase?
Post by: pgroff on December 19, 2010, 12:18:29 AM
Hey Drew,

My speculation was actually that this accordion developed a serious shrinkage crack in the soundboard early on, that made it not play properly and probably loosened the reedblocks (possibly before it was ever sold) .... not from being dropped, but from dry conditions. Maybe because the piece of wood used for that plate was unstable or too green, or maybe the accordion was left too near a stove or in direct sun in a shop window....  The method of construction of these Internationals does demand a lot from a piece of wood, and although I have seen a good few without cracks, many did crack.  Just like the tops of guitars. The one you just purchased most likely cracked before it could be purchased, or soon after, and I think that is why it was put away for 85 years unplayed.

Over the years I have seen a lot of "near mint, never played" instruments of many kinds, and they can have a lot of great information in them since they are so original -- but sometimes as likely in this case there may be a good reason they weren't played.  Some of the best old instruments are the really worn ones, that may have been chosen by serious players as the best sounding or best playing instruments when new, and that were played hard for decades or more!

PG

Title: Re: 4 stop Irish single row eBay purchase?
Post by: Andrew Culwell on December 19, 2010, 12:53:45 AM
Paul thanks for clarifying.  I see your point about the near mint condition and it's relationship to early damage.  I've been looking at my photo's of the GLobe and OBDW and the more I think about it the more I think my options are limited by lack of know how and the amount of work involved in the OBDW restore.  I Could take the guts out of the Globe but then the Sound Board Crack is still an issue.  That Globe is solid w/ the exception of patina and bellows it's soundboard, reed blocks are in superb condition. My choice is to keep the OBDW together for it's historical value and allow it to languish on the shelf, trade it or sell it (at a loss) or use the combined parts to make one heck of a nice playable semi-historical Melodeon.  At this point I see no reason in taking a total loss on the box.  As I said in my email to you I'm leaning more towards attaching the best parts of both boxes together to make one very nice box.  I feel crummy though about taking apart that OBDW box.  But it's a crime that it should sit on a shelf as a curiosity and decoration.
Title: Re: 4 stop Irish single row eBay purchase?
Post by: pgroff on December 19, 2010, 01:36:29 AM
Hi Drew,

I agree with Theo and others that the O'Byrne DeWitt International should be very repairable.  It's just a tricky job that will need some thought and skill. 

PG
Title: Re: 4 stop Irish single row eBay purchase?
Post by: RGF on December 19, 2010, 03:38:56 AM
Drew,

Having read the thread thus far, I would suggest that maybe you not rush into anything too immediately. Put it someplace safe (in a good climate), enjoy the holidays, and just move away for a bit. Give it some extended consideration before doing anything at all. Things will not get any worse in the interim....give yourself some space, and then come back to it.

Bob
Title: Re: 4 stop Irish single row eBay purchase?
Post by: Andrew Culwell on December 19, 2010, 04:09:55 AM
Good advice Bob.  Having spent far too much on the box already and having some other costly projects in the offing the box will sit on my shelf for the next 6 months anyway. You know how it is when something is exciting and new!  I won't be taking any hasty action.  Just throwing ideas out there.  It looks awful good on the shelf anyway!
Title: Re: 4 stop Irish single row eBay purchase?
Post by: Andy in Vermont on December 19, 2010, 06:40:54 AM
    Just throwing ideas out there.

Any chance of just returning it for a refund?  I mean, it certainly wasn't delivered in the condition indicated in the auction.  Did you use a credit card? Sometimes credit cards offer to remedy the situation.  The box, as delivered, was not playable as a musical instrument, and a "decoration box" surely should not cost that much!
Title: Re: 4 stop Irish single row eBay purchase?
Post by: blafleur on December 19, 2010, 03:29:00 PM
Pretty box.  If it were mine I'd try to make it playable, too good a shape otherwise not to.  I agree with Theo's suggestion to lay a veneer backing in the inside of the faceplate.  First I'd close the 2 gaps, and I'd use thin aircraft plywood.  Keep in mind that if you do that, the slides will need to be reset for the thicker faceplate.  The problem I'd be worried about in just fixing the cracks is that if those developed, after you fixed them and starting playing it, it's very likely others would develop in other spots.  In furniture making it's rarely advisable to glue plywood to solid wood, but in this case with such a thin and small piece, I wouldn't anticipate it being a problem, but that's just an opinion.

Also looks like it needs a new backing plate (that the reed blocks are attached to), it's missing some pieces between the standup blocks.  Maybe that one could be repaired, but not sure without seeing it up close.

Hows the base side look?
Title: Re: 4 stop Irish single row eBay purchase?
Post by: Andrew Culwell on December 20, 2010, 02:14:17 AM
The Bass side reeds are intact and the growl box seems to be in pretty good condition.  I took this picture before I left for home in California it simply shows the shape of the bass side.  Interior seems to be intact exterior is as you see.
SimplePortal 2.3.5 © 2008-2012, SimplePortal