Melodeon.net Forums
Discussions => Instrument Makes and Models => Topic started by: Fungusface on December 16, 2010, 05:50:16 PM
-
Did you know this ,that certain melodeons wont sell in Ireland if not grey or black and the latter being easiest to sell, I was in conversation with an Irish melodeon player, and he told me that there is only two melodeon bands in his area that wont play accordions if box isnt a certain colour, red accordions are hard to sell he said and grey is hard also but black accordions he cant get enough, thats amazing and yet Hohner insists on producing mainly red there seems more of them than blacks wonder why.same with the Paolo Soprani the only grey they prefer is the illusive grey,he said,I would have thought anyone would have done as long as genuine and old,
what do you think, does colour make a difference to you.?
-
I do not care for Hohner's red celluloid except,
the early garnet/burgundy red and the new Xtreme red
I prefer black or natural wood.
-
That makes as much sense as skinheads only wearing Ben Sherman shirts (which had nothing special going for them). I like boxes that are distinctive, if possible. It would sure save some time after a morris beer break when the band are trying to devide which Pokerwork is whose!
My usual box is Paduk, but I was very taken with the burr walnut Sara Rees has for sale. Has everyone seen the pale blue Pokerwork picie? I'd love to have a truly tatty box that needs a refinish - how about a tie-dyed effect?
Rob.
-
I'm not sure it's true either. A red Paolo is a red Paolo and still is pretty desirable. He may be speaking about Hohners since they don't make Black boxes anymore. I don't know too many Irish players who would turn up there noses at a nice 1950's red 3 voice. For myself if a box sounds good and is playable I don't care if it's bright pink....
-
Ooh, a bright pink one. Well ive had 2 blond boxes, but don't mind colour as long as its classy.
-
I'm with you LDT! :||: ;D (Mind, I do have a shocking pink electric fiddle! :|bl)
Chris B.
-
That makes as much sense as skinheads only wearing Ben Sherman shirts (which had nothing special going for them). I like boxes that are distinctive, if possible. It would sure save some time after a morris beer break when the band are trying to devide which Pokerwork is whose!
My usual box is Paduk, but I was very taken with the burr walnut Sara Rees has for sale. Has everyone seen the pale blue Pokerwork picie? I'd love to have a truly tatty box that needs a refinish - how about a tie-dyed effect?
Rob.
That would be good for Gogs ;D
-
then there was the purple peril ;)
-
Who else has seen the boxes from Ebay seller Bad613 -- the old German boxes in wild colors. Some say Hohner on them but many have funny brands painted across the front like Kalliope and probably come from Klingenthal factories, or maybe the Koch plant. The celluloid is often in bright pink, green, blue, gold, purple, orange, honey, and other multicolored finishes.
I like the idea of fun colors for a change, but then I'm the guy who wants to build an accordion out of flamed purpleheart. (:)
I saw an advertisement somewhere for a Castagnari in natural cherry finish, and the seller was calling it "traditional wood finish" -- what's traditional about that? Natural wood grain finishes seem pretty new on accordions.
Why did Hohner stop making a deep royal blue Erica. I saw one once on Ebay, not cheap, either, so people are willing to pay more.
I like Hohner's standby reds, blacks and whites these days but I'd rather have, and maybe even pay a little more for British racing green, royal blue, navy, "crackle" black, stormy grey...
-
The thing is, are you buying a musical instrument or a piece of furniture? I've seen some truly awful-looking Italian "stage" accordions from the first half of the 20th century that sounded absolutely wonderful. I've no idea what they're like to play as I don't play PA. Personally I'd rather have a weird-looking box that sounds and plays like a dream than a cabinet-maker's exhibition piece that's a musical dog. Of course, in an ideal world you'd be able to get the exact combination of sound, playability & appearance that suits you........
Graham
-
I'm with you LDT! :||: ;D (Mind, I do have a shocking pink electric fiddle! :|bl)
Chris B.
Cool. Pink is the 'in' colour this season in fashion.
-
Cool. Pink is the 'in' colour this season in fashion.
Should be a good year for the Bunnies from Hull Hell.
One of our musicians plays a yellow Oakwood - which is very loud indeed, probably nothing to do with the colour though. :||:
-
I don't really care much what colour box I play, but please don't make me play one of these in public:
-
Cool. Pink is the 'in' colour this season in fashion.
Should be a good year for the Bunnies from Hull Hell.
One of our musicians plays a yellow Oakwood - which is very loud indeed, probably nothing to do with the colour though. :||:
That wouldn't be Jim, would it?
-
Just having the mental image of my one row in pink with black edging. Chanel stylee.
Classy.....
-
Colour isn't too much of a problem, I prefer wooden, but plain, unadorned celluloid is fine. As soon as you have more than one colour or have any rhinestones whatsoever then I'm out :P
-
Noodle - that would indeed be Jim. Et who Brutee?
The thing with bling is that you can end up all show and no go. Looking good isn't everything if you can't play.
-
I just can't do red. The bellows on my pressed wood are close but I prefer to think of them as Autumnal :Ph
Whatever floats your boat !
-
Noodle - that would indeed be Jim. Et who Brutee?
Thought so. I've only ever seen one yellow/greeny melodeon and that belongs to him.
I'm part of the Bunnies btw. :D
In danger of derailing the thread, I suppose I am fairly picky about colour. I'm not keen on the bare wood boxs people appear to like. I also don't like the pokerwork pattern, and I'm not sure cream is such a great look for any melodeon or accordion. You can't go wrong with black though, and I still await a glimpse of a florescent yellow colour scheme
-
Which part of Bunnies are you sir/madam? Introduce yourself!
:M
-
As mentioned in a thread elsewhere in the forum,I'm about to embark on building myself a melodeon (or two - or three...) and I have a reasonable supply of exotic hardwoods for the casework. I also have a very large amount of well-seasoned lime, which is light in weight, works beautifully and is fairly strong & stable, but has absolutely no figure or character at all (hence its position as a timber of choice for fine detailed carving). Now it occurs to me that a melodeon built from lime would be the perfect blank canvas to experiment with outré finishes......pink, metallic lacquer, animal fur prints, mirror tiles..................
-
Well just to prove that neither good taste nor color matter to me I just purchased this beauty!
http://cgi.ebay.com/ws/eBayISAPI.dll?ViewItem&rt=nc&nma=true&item=160517517021&si=W6qUOoY2OuxRBJm%252FxWbIUzkacIY%253D&viewitem=&sspagename=STRK%3AMEWAX%3AIT
Why? I just thought it was very unique. Kind of art psychedelic meets Paolo Soprani. Closest thing to hot pink I could find!
-
Actually I think that Pancotti's rather splendid.............