Melodeon.net Forums

Discussions => Teaching and Learning => Topic started by: docEdock on December 16, 2010, 09:17:24 PM

Title: Pignol and Milleret Learners, Hello?
Post by: docEdock on December 16, 2010, 09:17:24 PM
I'm discovering that learning French traditional accordion here in Atlanta Georgia is a lonely sport. Finding local TexMex or Cajun players might not be too hard but I listened to grivemusicienne and was lost. Now I'm working through Pignol and Milleret's Diatonic Accordion Technique, Volume 1 and have made it to page 20.  So, here's the question: is anyone else on a similar journey? I'd be delighted to hear about it.

I've been inspired by ladydetemps' shameless promotion page and the helpful response and advice this forum has offered. I'm envisioning a virtual support group for Pignol and Milleret learners.  Perhaps we could post versions of the Pignol and Milleret tunes on youtube and give assurance that it's just a matter of time (and a lifetime of  practice, not to mention talent) before we too sound like M. Brotto. 
Title: Re: Pignol and Milleret Learners, Hello?
Post by: michik on December 16, 2010, 10:38:50 PM
I'm also learning french stuff, but I have a teacher.  (:)
In parallel I'm using the Yann Dour's tutor book, but I'm thinking of
getting the Pignol & Milleret book too.
Title: Re: Pignol and Milleret Learners, Hello?
Post by: Chris Ryall on December 17, 2010, 08:10:11 AM
I love these two Norbert and Stéph to bits - but would council that they are not considered "French Traditional Accordion" within metropolitan France. Both grew up deeply rooted in traditional music and dance  but their instincts are towards jazz. To express that starting from a danceable trad basis has been the challenge. (Stéph in particular doesn't think most 'jazz standards' are particularly good tunes)!  Loads of searchable stuff on youtube to hear what I mean.

By the time you get to book three  - they'll also be taking liberties with the rhythms - although nearly everything they've done remains danceable.  It's all very sound stuff, but intentionally goes beyond the folk idiom.  There are other (many) French players who do it very trad (though not too many in the Grenoble scene).
Title: Re: Pignol and Milleret Learners, Hello?
Post by: docEdock on December 17, 2010, 11:20:36 AM
Chris,
Thanks for that insight about French Traditional. Just to clarify in my mind, was your reference, "I love these two to bits" referring to Pignol and Millerete or Brotto and grievemusicienne?

I think I'll adopt Michik's terminology, "french stuff" which does a better job of covering my interest, or even expand it to "continental stuff", since I'm appreciating Carles Belda and others on http://www.lamaredelsous.com (http://www.lamaredelsous.com). I've been thinking of Carles Belda's style as traditional Catalan but perhaps it is also a modern interpretation of traditional.

I like your confidence in "By the time you get to book three . . .". From my perspective of learning the first tune in book 1, that looks like a long and steep climb. I assume you've been up that path and would recommend it?

Michik,
I haven't found a detailed description of Yann Dour's book or a glimpse of it's table of contents. What learning approach does it use?

I would say that the learning approach in the Pignol & Milleret books is that of using 8 or 10 discrete exercises to build skills, followed by a tune that incorporates the new skills. The recorded examples cover every exercise and present the tunes in slow and faster versions (book 1 and book 3 audio is downloadable and book 2 includes 2 CD's). So far -- well in the first 20 pages at least -- I think the progression is well paced and logical, though my fingers might have other opinions.

I envy your having a teacher. I assume you've found a local resource and are doing on-site lessons. I'm mulling over whether to enroll in Accademia del Mantice so as to have a virtual tutor.
Title: Re: Pignol and Milleret Learners, Hello?
Post by: Larry on December 17, 2010, 01:22:56 PM
Hello Altanta,
I was from Des Moines till 15 years. With that as ground work french
(grenoble style) was my faté. :)  the Pignol/Milleret books will make
all players better players. Good choice. I started my first two years
with Pennec and Ronan Robert books. The Robert book being just
fabulous. It, like the mustradem series is a fine companion.
You will be proud of your skills if you stay with those books. AND
very possible without a teacher you can prove yourself a good player.
I highly recommend the Mustradem series!!
Title: Re: Pignol and Milleret Learners, Hello?
Post by: docEdock on December 17, 2010, 08:25:42 PM
Larry,

You may find this a stunning question, but Des Moines as in Iowa? I know I'm missing something here and am clueless, clueless, clueless.
Title: Re: Pignol and Milleret Learners, Hello?
Post by: Nick Hudis on December 17, 2010, 09:38:33 PM
I've been using the Pignol and Milleret books as a revision rather than learning from scratch. I'm most of the way through Book 2. I think they are excellent books and beat most tutors because the tunes are such high quality.

I'd echo what Chris Ryall says.  This is a modern and quite idiosyncratic approach to the accordion with strong jazz influences.  That suits me very well, but traditional it is not.
Title: Re: Pignol and Milleret Learners, Hello?
Post by: docEdock on December 17, 2010, 10:10:21 PM
Which tutorial books would fit into the French Traditional category?
Title: Re: Pignol and Milleret Learners, Hello?
Post by: waltzman on December 18, 2010, 12:16:10 AM
I've worked on exercises and tunes in all three books and I would argue that the first two volumes are straight forward skill building for playing the diatonic accordion in any style.  The emphasis I would say is on traditional french dance music.  There is a section on the rhythm structure and recommended tempos for 19 different dances.  There are multiple examples of traditional tunes in the repertoire section.  While the musicians themselves may play mostly  nontraditional stuff, I would not characterize their method books as jazz oriented.  The third volume does introduce blues scales and compound chords.
Title: Re: Pignol and Milleret Learners, Hello?
Post by: Andy in Vermont on December 18, 2010, 02:23:49 PM
Which tutorial books would fit into the French Traditional category?

Well, first of all, while what Chris said above is true, the vol. 1 M/P book is still traditional -- it's not really until vol 2 and especially 3 that you move beyond techniques that are typical in the tradition(s).

I wanted to add that if you are interested in leaning more toward the traditional playing techniques (and tunes), one path for you -- since you are so far away from a "live" player from whom to learn -- would be to acquire some good recordings of trad players without the bells and whistles.  What I mean is that you could seek out some solo recordings without jazzed-up arrangements.  Yann Dour's book (with recording) of Breton tunes is a good place to start.  Fredric Paris is another good one -- even his originals seem to be "new tunes played in the old way," albeit to a level of technical proficiency that probably exceeds the typical player, say, 75 years ago.  Remember that everyone's notion of "traditional" is different -- it can be a very relative concept and tends to cause a lot of disagreement among players.

Generally, remember that you can simply learn "by ear," and using software to slow down a recording, while a "technological" solution, probably comes closest to the experience of learning by ear from a master player who is willing to play a tune slowly for you, over and over.  I used to think that this was a real compromise until I saw some film footage of Philippe Bruneau, whose adherence to tradition would not be questioned by anyone, doing basically the same thing with a variable speed tape player!  I think that you will find that learning by ear, you will assimilate the tune better and once you've learned it, you won't have to worry about throwing away the crutch (that is sheet music/tabs).  That said, tabs are still very helpful for understanding the relation of bellows direction choice with chords once you get into cross-rowing.
-Andy
Title: Re: Pignol and Milleret Learners, Hello?
Post by: docEdock on December 19, 2010, 10:26:19 AM
I fear that I laid a false scent by slinging around the term: French Traditional without understanding the nuance. Y'all have been very kind in educating me rather than sneering at a newbie -- I'm thinking of other forums in which I would have emerged scalded like a lobster and none the wiser.

I want to learn to play in the style of these YouTube posters: diatonik46, grivemusicienne, pierrOtdiat. I can just imagine the groans, since for all I know their only commonality is listing France as the country in a YouTube profile and playing diatonic.

Given the distant shores of Atlanta, is Pignol and Milleret volume 1-2 a reasonable way to proceed, along with YouTube and various recordings as has been suggested? Or are other tutorials better suited to where I want to go? Here I'm asking for an evaluation of both the musical style and learning approach, since if either is off target I'll wander off my path. For example, might Yann Dour's three volume series be a better starting place? Or would it be a good supplement to Pignol and Milleret?
Title: Re: Pignol and Milleret Learners, Hello?
Post by: Larry on December 19, 2010, 11:00:06 AM
Hello, buy all of these listed.
alain pennec
ronan robert
dominique gravouille
yann dour
trad magazine (volume 4 répertoire de bal breton
pignol and milleret series.
 You will be happy and that isn't much to invest in teaching yourself.
Good luck in Atlana. You wil make if you so desire.
Title: Re: Pignol and Milleret Learners, Hello?
Post by: waltzman on December 19, 2010, 01:06:07 PM
I think the first volume of P&M is a very good way to get started but there is also a wealth of info on the net for learning this style of music.  It would help you a lot to get a G/C tuned instrument since most of the youtube players use this tuning for this style music.  You mentioned grivemusicienne.... I learned the valse des chevaux de bois using her video and searching out the music on the net.  Here is a good link for music in this genre  http://www.organetto.info/archivio/index.php
Title: Re: Pignol and Milleret Learners, Hello?
Post by: docEdock on December 19, 2010, 03:26:43 PM
Excellent advice, re the G/C. I've chatted with Bernard Loffet and believe I've decided on a G/C two-row three-voice Graeter e Breizh with stops for delivery this spring

I'll be island hopping in the Caribbean Jan - Mar and hesitate to take such a fine box to sea. I just failed to win http://cgi.ebay.com/ws/eBayISAPI.dll?ViewItem&item=23056264186 (http://cgi.ebay.com/ws/eBayISAPI.dll?ViewItem&item=23056264186) which in the end may be a blessing given the forum's advice about old boxes. I was thinking the Hohner might go on the voyage and if it returns as rusted junk despite precautions, I wouldn't be that distraught.

Title: Re: Pignol and Milleret Learners, Hello?
Post by: waltzman on December 19, 2010, 04:39:22 PM
The Button Box has several used Hohners in G/C for sale.  They also carry the Milleret and Pignol books.  Good folks to deal with.

http://www.buttonbox.com/instruments-in-stock.html
Title: Re: Pignol and Milleret Learners, Hello?
Post by: docEdock on December 20, 2010, 11:28:58 PM
Thanks for the Button Box tip. I bought P&M volumes 1-2 from them and while I was shopping wandered over to the used Hohner section. As you point out, they have several G/C's for sale. Melodeon acquisition disorder must be really virulent. Just hanging around the forum puts one at risk.
Title: Re: Pignol and Milleret Learners, Hello?
Post by: Gary P Chapin on December 21, 2010, 05:07:17 AM
I'm about eleven years into the journey you're starting.  I never used the P&M tutorials, but their tunes and tabs in Trad magazine (as well as their recordings) inspired me greatly.  The thing that dragged me into this music was the repertoire.  I just love these tunes.  I had been playing Irish music, but these waltzes, bourrees etc. really moved me.

But you're right, it is lonely.  You'll never have as many collaborators as the Irish players.  Early on I discovered the website www.tradfrance.com, run by Sylvain Piron, of Alsace.  He's an accordionist, dancer/leader, and singer.  I stuck up a correspondence with Sylvain and sent him tunes to comment on, etc.  So, in this very limited way, he was my teacher -- though we've since become good friends.  I traveled to Alsace and was stunned by his community of accordionists -- so many people playing French tunes!  Another time I traveled up to Montreal to take a lesson from Daniel Thonon.  I felt stuck and needed someone to listen to me and direct me.  He was fantastic.

The first time I met people locally (I live in Maine, USA), was looking at the International Dance clubs around here.  Larger folk dance festivals usually have at least one French gathering.  They do a mixture of cultures -- a LOT of Balkan -- but there were a few folks really into the French stuff, including a clarinetist and hurdy gurdy builder.  We ended up getting together and play together informally.

My first box was a used G/C bought from the Button Box.  The French tunes really do sound better on the G/C, with its lower pitch.

I would second the recommendation for Frederic Paris -- who is my hero.  He does have great technical facility, but I find he's not overly flashy.  A very grounded player.

Best of luck,

Gary Chapin
http://www.youtube.com/user/Accordeonaire?feature=mhum
Title: Re: Pignol and Milleret Learners, Hello?
Post by: docEdock on December 21, 2010, 11:37:57 AM
Gary,

Thanks for sharing your experience. It's inspiring to hear that being outside the culture isn't the kiss of death for learning. I too have been playing traditional British and Irish for years and only recently discovered the French music. When I first heard grivemusicianne I thought, I've simply got to learn how to do that. The last time that happened was long ago when I first heard someone walking along and playing a penny whistle, which eventually led to all sorts of whistles, recorders, and concertinas.

I appreciate the tip about finding where players might gather. With any luck I'll be cruising upstate NY and Montreal this summer. Gotta be a "larger folk dance festival" somewhere around there. If you have any recommendations, please say.

But, now I'm off to find out more about Frederic Paris. I've bumped into his name along the way but can't say that I've really explored what's available.
Title: Re: Pignol and Milleret Learners, Hello?
Post by: Andy in Vermont on December 21, 2010, 12:31:56 PM
But, now I'm off to find out more about Frederic Paris. I've bumped into his name along the way but can't say that I've really explored what's available.

Uh, oh, Gary.  I believe we've become "enablers"...
 :D
Title: Re: Pignol and Milleret Learners, Hello?
Post by: Gary P Chapin on December 21, 2010, 06:57:42 PM
Yes, enabling for a hard to get drug!

Paris' best work is on "Carnet de Bal" (I think) I had it on cassette and wore it out.  His Rue de l'Oiseau is also fantastic (and available on CD).  Both recordings are in a book with dots and tab.  Now THAT was a valuable resource.

Frederic Paris plays with La Chavanee (sp?) who have three discs available on iTunes.  There are times when I listen to these and think, "Yes, when God said, 'Let there be music,' this is what he was talking about."

Paris also has two recordings of children's music which you might not think worthy, but they are utterly charming.

So Andy, you're in Vermont, DocEd is considering a trip through upstate New York and Montreal?  Do I sense a gathering???
Title: Re: Pignol and Milleret Learners, Hello?
Post by: docEdock on December 22, 2010, 11:15:19 AM
Could be an opportunity to create critical mass along the Erie canal. I'll let you know whether I get there -- at about 5 mph it's a long way from Georgia. I did the trip two years ago and am determined to return and then head north to Georgian Bay.

Hey, I notice that Hector Awol has been bitten by the French bug as well http://www.youtube.com/user/HectorAwol#g/c/C1B4D9C565390423 (http://www.youtube.com/user/HectorAwol#g/c/C1B4D9C565390423). I'd guess that he's in a similar position of having few co-located enthusiasts.
Title: Re: Pignol and Milleret Learners, Hello?
Post by: Steve C. on December 28, 2010, 12:02:15 AM
Maybe some sort of eastern US get-together could be partnered with the NE Squeeze In? (16-18 Sept 2011)
Title: Re: Pignol and Milleret Learners, Hello?
Post by: docEdock on December 30, 2010, 09:41:29 AM
Excellent tip about the NE Squeeze-In. I'm already thinking about how to be there -- nearest ports look to be in Rhode Island.

The main question is whether to risk an outbreak of acquisition disorder by visiting the Button Box before or after the Squeeze-In. Before might be less risky. At the get-together I'll bet there will be lots of carriers and I'll get a virulent infection. On the other hand, how bad can that be?
Title: Re: Pignol and Milleret Learners, Hello?
Post by: michik on December 30, 2010, 10:26:04 AM
Now I have got the Pignol & Milleret books now :-)
The tunes in the book are very nice ... they seem easy in the first place, but they are challenging somehow.
Title: Re: Pignol and Milleret Learners, Hello?
Post by: docEdock on December 30, 2010, 12:30:37 PM
Michik, I in turn, ordered the Yann Dour series after reading your post. So, there's a curious bit of symmetry.

I listened ahead on the P&M volume 2 CDB to see how I'd sound eventually -- yeah, right -- and thought track 52, La guinguette, particularly appealing, though as you point out it I suspect it might be "challenging somehow", to say the least.

I'll be interested in hearing your thoughts on how P&M's approach differs from or compliments Dour's.
Title: Re: Pignol and Milleret Learners, Hello?
Post by: michik on December 30, 2010, 01:37:28 PM
I'll be interested in hearing your thoughts on how P&M's approach differs from or compliments Dour's.

P&M concentrate much more on technical stuff, whereas YD is "just playing"
... In YD there are quite a lot of tunes, one immediatly starts with tunes, there is not very much technical stuff in it.
but works somehow also.
Title: Re: Pignol and Milleret Learners, Hello?
Post by: Gary P Chapin on December 30, 2010, 01:46:53 PM
I can't comment on the P&M or the Dour book ... so maybe I should just stop ... but I won't, of course.  About eleven or so years ago I encountered Yann on a usenet group (I think) and in the course of the conversation mentioned that I was having a lot of trouble with the basses and chords.  He e-mailed me some left hand exercises that made ALL the difference.  So, I'd always been a believer in "you learn how to play music by playing music" (i.e., tunes not exercises), but I've discovered that there are some techniques that if you nail them early will ease the way later.  Now I may have to buy the P&M books.  Drat.
Title: Re: Pignol and Milleret Learners, Hello?
Post by: docEdock on December 31, 2010, 01:56:02 AM
If you wait long enough, I'll be selling P&M volume 1. It might be years, though. Otherwise it's off to the Button Box for you. I didn't find anywhere else in the US that carried them.
Title: Re: Pignol and Milleret Learners, Hello?
Post by: Andy in Vermont on January 01, 2011, 05:59:44 PM
If you wait long enough, I'll be selling P&M volume 1. It might be years, though. Otherwise it's off to the Button Box for you. I didn't find anywhere else in the US that carried them.

Gary can skip ahead to book 2!
Title: Re: Pignol and Milleret Learners, Hello?
Post by: Andrel on January 01, 2011, 08:27:42 PM
P&M and Yann Dour's tutors are both excellent and complementary, but if you need a break from the theory and learn while having fun you could do worse than getting this stuff: (written for G/C players)
http://www.sheetmusicplus.com/title/Marc-Perrone-Treize-A-La-Douzaine/8263321

A little gem, with Marc Perrone's own tablature system, which you should master in about a couple of minutes. It'd be great if the Button Box offered it. (Doug ??)
Title: Re: Pignol and Milleret Learners, Hello?
Post by: michik on January 02, 2011, 01:23:04 AM
P&M and Yann Dour's tutors are both excellent and complementary, but if you need a break from the theory and learn while having fun you could do worse than getting this stuff: (written for G/C players)
http://www.sheetmusicplus.com/title/Marc-Perrone-Treize-A-La-Douzaine/8263321

or: http://www.tradmagazine.com/02BOUTIQUE/tablatures/TAB.html  (I have numbers 1 to 4 already  >:E :||: )
and http://www.tradmagazine.com/02BOUTIQUE/REPERTRAD/rep.html
Title: Re: Pignol and Milleret Learners, Hello?
Post by: Andrel on January 02, 2011, 06:44:38 PM
Thanks ! some  great stuff there. I noticed La Malaimable is listed as Petit Déjeuner, its alternate title.
Title: Re: Pignol and Milleret Learners, Hello?
Post by: docEdock on January 02, 2011, 08:33:46 PM
If you wait long enough, I'll be selling P&M volume 1. It might be years, though. Otherwise it's off to the Button Box for you. I didn't find anywhere else in the US that carried them.

Gary can skip ahead to book 2!

Ah, yes. Please excuse my unintended slight. I just listened to Gary's TOTM and he's definitely not book 1 material. Perhaps he'll sell me book 3 after he's zipped through it.
Title: Re: Pignol and Milleret Learners, Hello?
Post by: Andy in Vermont on January 02, 2011, 10:53:16 PM
Please excuse my unintended slight. I just listened to Gary's TOTM and he's definitely not book 1 material. Perhaps he'll sell me book 3 after he's zipped through it.

Oops, I didn't mean to imply that -- I was just thinking that book 2 is where many of us in the intermediate/advanced intermediate zone (at least, those of us who have not studied with Milleret or Pignol) will find that the learning curve gets considerably steeper.  Most of the technique that I've learned has been from learning tunes that were progressively more difficult -- volume 2 gets into some technique that goes beyond the playing of those tunes.  It is more about deeping the execution of any given tune with more advanced bass work as well as right hand chords.
Title: Re: Pignol and Milleret Learners, Hello?
Post by: Gary P Chapin on January 03, 2011, 12:30:24 AM
Please excuse my unintended slight. I just listened to Gary's TOTM and he's definitely not book 1 material. Perhaps he'll sell me book 3 after he's zipped through it.

Oops, I didn't mean to imply that -- I was just thinking that book 2 is where many of us in the intermediate/advanced intermediate zone (at least, those of us who have not studied with Milleret or Pignol) will find that the learning curve gets considerably steeper.  Most of the technique that I've learned has been from learning tunes that were progressively more difficult -- volume 2 gets into some technique that goes beyond the playing of those tunes.  It is more about deeping the execution of any given tune with more advanced bass work as well as right hand chords.
There was no slight!  Thanks for the kind words.  I am intending, for my mid january paycheck, to call the button box and drop the sheckles for P&M volumes 2 and 3.  I probably would get book one, but it's just so expensive.  Nearly $175 for the three.  P&M are interesting.  I don't agree, at all, with their dismissal of 3rds in chords, but I've gotten so much joy out of their tunes and recordings.  Lots lots lots to learn there.
Title: Re: Pignol and Milleret Learners, Hello?
Post by: Chris Ryall on January 03, 2011, 09:27:16 AM
Nothing wrong with 3rds in chords. My oakwood has 3rds and a stop to cut them - I think the latter is in/out about 50%

P&M teach chord notes as giving "colour" and that 3rd is one of the highest pigment notes there is. They describe the 1+5 "third harmonic" harmony as an "accord faible" - so in as sense that is the one they dismiss!

I think the problem is rather, technical - one just can't get all the reeds for an 18 bass into the left end. That 18 is actually 6 pairs of chords, plus 6 single basses - but all 12 basses are double reeded, and some are big ones.  B Gaillard also offers a 16 button (8 real chord pairs) option on his Saphir, but once described 9 full chord pairs to me as 'impossible'. His '18' is also that offered by several other makers.

P&M are in practice strongly right hand players, and commonly comp for each other building up really complex stuff on that end. They also like adore the tritone interval which can't be done in a decent voicing on the left. 

It's convenient not having to even think whether you are in major or minor .. but I don't think that comes into it with these two. They use major and minor chords all the time - but on the other end
Title: Re: Pignol and Milleret Learners, Hello?
Post by: Gary P Chapin on January 03, 2011, 11:19:32 AM
Nothing wrong with 3rds in chords. My oakwood has 3rds and a stop to cut them - I think the latter is in/out about 50%

P&M teach chord notes as giving "colour" and that 3rd is one of the highest pigment notes there is. They describe the 1+5 "third harmonic" harmony as an "accord faible" - so in as sense that is the one they dismiss!

I think the problem is rather, technical - one just can't get all the reeds for an 18 bass into the left end. That 18 is actually 6 pairs of chords, plus 6 single basses - but all 12 basses are double reeded, and some are big ones.  B Gaillard also offers a 16 button (8 real chord pairs) option on his Saphir, but once described 9 full chord pairs to me as 'impossible'. His '18' is also that offered by several other makers.

P&M are in practice strongly right hand players, and commonly comp for each other building up really complex stuff on that end. They also like adore the tritone interval which can't be done in a decent voicing on the left. 

It's convenient not having to even think whether you are in major or minor .. but I don't think that comes into it with these two. They use major and minor chords all the time - but on the other end

I agree with every word you've written!  Take that!

My Pastourelle has a stop to pull the 3rds and I find I use it when playing some Breton music or Medieval music or music that I want to sound Breton or Medieval.  Of course Patrick Lefebvre does some amazing complex stuff with Breton music.  I remember in some early Irish sessions (early for me) sitting around and hearing an accordion without the 3rds and wondering "what is that???"  There were some bouzouki players there, tuned ADad, and I was just stunned, "It doesn't HAVE to be major or minor???"

I think P&M are right by their criteria, the 1-5 is "weak" (i.e., low color), which is supposed to be one of its advantages:  no third creates ambiguity.  Sometimes, I experience this as irony ... which I have a low tolerance for these days.
Title: Re: Pignol and Milleret Learners, Hello?
Post by: Chris Ryall on January 03, 2011, 11:53:13 AM
Too kind.  (:) While 'imitation is the sincerest form of flattery' need to quote in full what was only 5 lines up - debatable?   However I'm very grateful for any extra Google points it might get me  ;D

[edit] If you really like major/minor chimaera then get on a plane to Tblisi. The Georgian polyphony scale spaces its notes 'evenly between 1st and 5th'  - which in C gives a 3rd exactly half way between E and Eb  8)
Title: Re: Pignol and Milleret Learners, Hello?
Post by: docEdock on January 03, 2011, 01:05:18 PM
P&M teach chord notes as giving "colour" and that 3rd is one of the highest pigment notes there is. They describe the 1+5 "third harmonic" harmony as an "accord faible" - so in as sense that is the one they dismiss!

P&M are in practice strongly right hand players, and commonly comp for each other building up really complex stuff on that end. They also like adore the tritone interval which can't be done in a decent voicing on the left. 

Chris,
Would you be so kind as to elaborate on your comments -- for someone who slept through music theory? I think I got a sense of what you describe: a chord of 1+5 is less vivid than 1+3+5 and thus fits with both major and minor treble passages?

Is a "tritone interval" tones 1+3 played as a chord (or a sequence?) on the treble? Why can't it "be done in a decent voicing on the left?"
Title: Re: Pignol and Milleret Learners, Hello?
Post by: Steve_freereeder on January 03, 2011, 01:19:35 PM
Is a "tritone interval" tones 1+3 played as a chord (or a sequence?) on the treble? Why can't it "be done in a decent voicing on the left?"
The tritone interval is an augmented fourth, or put another way, three whole tones (hence the name). It is also two successive minor thirds. Example: C to F# is a tritone.

It is a strange, dissonant interval, with a feeling of unresolved tension. It was known as diabolus in musica - "the Devil in music".

Plenty of information and audio examples here:
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tritone
Title: Re: Pignol and Milleret Learners, Hello?
Post by: Gary P Chapin on January 03, 2011, 01:27:41 PM
Isn't the tritone also the famous "flatted fifth" that plays such a big part in jazz?  Or is that something different?
Title: Re: Pignol and Milleret Learners, Hello?
Post by: docEdock on January 03, 2011, 01:39:39 PM
  Tip? :-\ OK, in the B music where the chords go G, C, G - try Em, D, C (all on the pull).  By some
  miracle of melodeonism you'll find the notes of the tune are still there, albeit in different places

How do you sages know the answer to the mystery of which chords might go with that measure? Is this P&M book 2 or 3 stuff? Or can you point me to a fairly simple explanation? Is there a chord progression for beginners topic? I thought that with only has 8 possible buttons on the left hand it should be obvious which one to push. Now you suggest that there are really 16 possibilities . . .

I find reading and rereading posts like the quote above to be like watching an Olympian skate. There's so much going on behind the scenes. Every statement is built on nuance and technique. Here I am wobbling across the ice and asking about a triple axel.
Title: Re: Pignol and Milleret Learners, Hello?
Post by: docEdock on January 03, 2011, 01:52:25 PM
Plenty of information and audio examples here:
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tritone

Steve, thanks for that. I keep forgetting wiki as a source. Most informative, though it left me sprawled on the ice with a knot on my head.
So, back to my question about Chris's comment: is a tritone interval (C F#) hard to voice on a G/C because there is no F# bass on the left hand? The only F# is buried inside the D major chord?
Title: Re: Pignol and Milleret Learners, Hello?
Post by: Steve_freereeder on January 03, 2011, 01:56:28 PM
  Tip? :-\ OK, in the B music where the chords go G, C, G - try Em, D, C (all on the pull).  By some
  miracle of melodeonism you'll find the notes of the tune are still there, albeit in different places

How do you sages know the answer to the mystery of which chords might go with that measure? Is this P&M book 2 or 3 stuff? Or can you point me to a fairly simple explanation? Is there a chord progression for beginners topic? I thought that with only has 8 possible buttons on the left hand it should be obvious which one to push. Now you suggest that there are really 16 possibilities . . .

I find reading and rereading posts like the quote above to be like watching an Olympian skate. There's so much going on behind the scenes. Every statement is built on nuance and technique. Here I am wobbling across the ice and asking about a triple axel.

OK let's go the other route. Perhaps you are trying too hard at this stage and worrying too much about the theory of harmony. For the LH chords, trust your ear instead. Don't be afraid to experiment. If it sounds OK to you, then it probably is.

I believe it was Tony Hall - the wonderful melodeon player from Norfolk in eastern England - who said something to effect of "when you are playing, just poke about a bit with your fingers and see what it sounds like. If you like what you hear then stick with that".
Title: Re: Pignol and Milleret Learners, Hello?
Post by: Steve_freereeder on January 03, 2011, 02:10:57 PM
So, back to my question about Chris's comment: is a tritone interval (C F#) hard to voice on a G/C because there is no F# bass on the left hand? The only F# is buried inside the D major chord?
Yes, that's correct for the LH chords/basses.
However, on the RH side you have a number of options for tritones, all on the pull. On a G/C box, you have on the C-row these tritones: B to the next higher F, and F to the next higher B. Similarly on the G-row you can find F# to the next higher C, and C to the next higher F#.

If you look at this keyboard layout, you will see which buttons give you those particular notes on the pull.
http://forum.melodeon.net/files/site/GC21acc.gif

You will see that the buttons you need are separated by an unplayed button between. Try them and see how they sound. Then try similar button patterns for D and A on the C-row, and A and E on the G-row. These intervals are perfect fifths and sound totally different from the tritones.
Title: Re: Pignol and Milleret Learners, Hello?
Post by: docEdock on January 03, 2011, 02:18:25 PM
Steve,
Thanks for both gracious and informative replies. You remind me that I'm banging away on the wrong keyboard. I'll never learn to play La Marianne by typing. So with that new found confidence, I'm outta here, for a while at least.
Doc
Title: Re: Pignol and Milleret Learners, Hello?
Post by: Gary P Chapin on January 03, 2011, 02:19:24 PM
I believe it was Tony Hall - the wonderful melodeon player from Norfolk in eastern England - who said something to effect of "when you are playing, just poke about a bit with your fingers and see what it sounds like. If you like what you hear then stick with that".

It is one of the facets of the melodeon that puts me in awe of the machine, whatever button you press on the left hand while playing melody on the right CHANCES ARE PRETTY GOOD that it will sound okay.
Title: Re: Pignol and Milleret Learners, Hello?
Post by: Chris Ryall on January 03, 2011, 04:22:59 PM
.... about 90%

Tritone theory - I think Steve has it about right (though there is a G/C# tension available on pull).  

Basically that 3 tone intervals as different as two notes can get in (in)harmonious terms. The notes clash and your chord is unstable - it demands "resolution" - it's "dominant"  Our cleverly defined "90% harmonious " bass end just doesn't do that. You have to employ right hand chords (or your ear, as per the great Tony Hall).

To move on the "as different as it gets" simile - that's essentially why a C-Gbflatted 5th interval is the same as a C-F#augmented 4th.  It sort of depends if your musical bottle is half empty - or half full  :|glug  
Title: Re: Pignol and Milleret Learners, Hello?
Post by: docEdock on January 05, 2011, 04:02:51 PM

Basically that 3 tone intervals as different as two notes can get in (in)harmonious terms. The notes clash and your chord is unstable - it demands "resolution" - it's "dominant"  Our cleverly defined "90% harmonious " bass end just doesn't do that. You have to employ right hand chords (or your ear, as per the great Tony Hall).


P&M teach chord notes as giving "colour" and that 3rd is one of the highest pigment notes there is. They describe the 1+5 "third harmonic" harmony as an "accord faible" - so in as sense that is the one they dismiss!

Chris, I've been pondering your comments about degrees of (in)harmony and P&M vividness of pigment for a chord. Are the two somehow related, perhaps in the sense that a tritone chord is the most vivid of the pigments and the third harmonic is the least? Or, am I totally mixing the concepts?

Here's why I ask. I've always played melody and wished I knew about harmony. On a whistle I thought it not a possibility and on the English concertina I never learned how. For me, one magic of the melodeon is the promise that most left hand buttons sound OK and I can leap frog right into chords. Then I listen to TOTM and read your posts and realize that understanding the points you make would open an entirely different world. The generous explanations that all of you have provided have have given me a glimpse into that world, so thanks. I don't expect you (or anyone) to take on the burden of handing me this stuff on a platter, so if there is a link you'd suggest to answer my question, I'll do the studying.

Title: Re: Pignol and Milleret Learners, Hello?
Post by: GbH on January 05, 2011, 06:04:30 PM
.........I don't expect you (or anyone) to take on the burden of handing me this stuff on a platter, so if there is a link you'd suggest to answer my question, I'll do the studying.


From the sounds of it, you're in a similar position to I was a year or so back.  I'd always managed to avoid learning about such things with other instruments, but the oddities of the melodeon seem to demand some greater understanding about harmony, arrangement and suchlike. 

It's not so difficult to hunt down books or on-line resources that exaplain music theory in a dry, factual way.  But personally, just reading such material alone tends to leave me feeling little-the-wiser, as I'll tend not to make any practical connection with the actual sounds.  In this respect, one on-line resource that I found to be much more inspiring was this one - http://chordmaps.com/index.htm (http://chordmaps.com/index.htm).  Obviously, it's not aimed at melodeon players specifically, nor even 'folk' musicians.  However, there's something about the way that it's presented that makes me want to reach for my instrument and try stuff.  If you're looking for something more on the academic side, you might not like it so much.  But, for me, it helped.

I suppose a more obvious thing to mention, if you've not already discovered it, is that the P&M books II and III themselves help with basic (and relevant!) theory too.  In my view, they're both books that benefit from 'dipping in' where necessary, rather than working through sequentially.  Even though the G/C orientation makes things (for a D/G player) a bit more frustrating than is ideal, I've certainly not regretted buying them and would certainly recommend them to anyone who tends towards cross-row playing.
Title: Re: Pignol and Milleret Learners, Hello?
Post by: Gary P Chapin on January 05, 2011, 06:15:26 PM
I'd always managed to avoid learning about such things with other instruments, but the oddities of the melodeon seem to demand some greater understanding about harmony, arrangement and suchlike. 
I agree, but the oddities of the melodeon really make an excellent opening to the world of theory and harmony.
Title: Re: Pignol and Milleret Learners, Hello?
Post by: docEdock on January 05, 2011, 06:57:21 PM

From the sounds of it, you're in a similar position to I was a year or so back. . . .


Well then, Arthur's La Marianne gives me an enormous boost, especially if he was somewhat (un)harmonic a year ago. After I heard his video I wanted to hunt him down and ask, "How did you do that?" I saw him on the outside row so I suspect he changed keys on me, but the rest flew right by. If he ever wants to do a walk thru-video, I'll stand in line for a ticket.

Thanks for the advice about the link and the tip on reading ahead in P&M. I've skimmed book 2 and listened to the tunes but will start paying more attention to the chord stuff.
Title: Re: Pignol and Milleret Learners, Hello?
Post by: docEdock on January 05, 2011, 08:55:38 PM

I agree, but the oddities of the melodeon really make an excellent opening to the world of theory and harmony.

Well, I can attest that it's forgiving when you wander through chord-land.

On the very first P&M tune, Le branle des vieux, I misunderstood the tab(?) for the chords. So here I am, bouncing all around the left hand, jumping buttons and thinking I'll never get this down. Steep learning curve on that first tune, full of stuff they left out. Several tunes later I realize that C c push and G g pull are actually the same two buttons. Reminds me of a Christmas when I tried to use the bicycle instructions to assemble the doll house.

Now I have two versions of the tune, theirs and mine. Oddly enough mine sounds OK, though theirs involves a lot less clacking. This must be the 80%-90% you and Chris mentioned.
Title: Re: Pignol and Milleret Learners, Hello?
Post by: GbH on January 05, 2011, 10:32:46 PM
Well then, Arthur's La Marianne gives me an enormous boost, especially if he was somewhat (un)harmonic a year ago. After I heard his video I wanted to hunt him down and ask, "How did you do that?" I saw him on the outside row so I suspect he changed keys on me, but the rest flew right by. If he ever wants to do a walk thru-video, I'll stand in line for a ticket.

Hmm, maybe Arthur will try a video tutorial at some point.  But he can offer this for now, if it's of any help...

"The recording was done along a 'theme and variations' idea, so it breaks down into separate, distinct blocks.  Specifically, it was Intro, Theme (A+B), 3 variations (A+B for each), End Section.  The specifiics of each are as follows:

INTRO - This started out as being the whole tune done in D major, on the D row, with lots of minor 7th chords on the bass end.  In the end, I just didn't like how this was turning out.  So, I abandoned most of it, just leaving the B section chords as something different to starting with.

THEME - I decided to leave this as simple as possible, as a contrast to what followed.  Thus, it's just a 4-button G major, 3-chord-trick job with just a couple of slight variations in the tune to prevent repetition.

VARIATION 1 - This features the first drop into the relative minor - in this case, that's E minor.  Thus a move on to the outside row and lots of pulling.  The actual change down worked very smoothly, somewhat to my surprise.  For some reason (probably lack of discipline), when I change into the minor, the tune ends up going out of the window, so what remains is just something that came out of nowhere.  Also, in this variation, I throw a curveball and try to change it into 5/4 time, although this initially doesn't go quite as intended.  I tend to be a bit cautious about changing time like this (am I doing it for the right reasons?), but was happy enough with how it turned out.

VARIATION 2 - I took this back to G major, although the transition seemed to require a slight pause to make it work.  So, yes, back onto the inside row.  Also, we're now safely back in 3/4 time.  For the 'A' music, I just play the tune straight, but using the standard 'thirds' trick (i.e. just holding down adjacent buttons).  Easy win!  For the 'B' music, I varied the tune somewhat, making use of the nice pulled G on the outside row and also the low D on the inside.  It's nothing 'clever', but seems to make a nice contrast to the original figure.  I guess some better bass work might have been good here, but it didn't occur to me at the time.

VARIATION 3 - For this one, I took it back down to E minor again, but left the time in 3/4.  For the A music, I attempted a two-part right hand part, with my little finger stretching to do a simple, but separate, part above the rest of the action.  On the recording, it didn't work out quite right, but I think you can still see the idea.  Also, at this point, I started getting excited, so the tediously inevitable speed-up happens and it ends up going a bit wrong just before the B section.  For the B section itself, I just used the same idea as from Variation 1, but obviously now in 3/4 time.  I guess I was running out of ideas for this bit.

END SECTION - This briefly goes back to G major, repeating again the first two bars of the A music.  I then repeat the same two bars again, fistly in transposed to A major and then again into B major (yep, I needed the half-row for this).  Finally, the closing chords return back to E minor (I guess there's a technical explaination as to why they didn't resolve to G again, but I'm not sure what it is).

So, that's about the sum of it...."
Title: Re: Pignol and Milleret Learners, Hello?
Post by: docEdock on January 06, 2011, 12:32:43 PM
Please do pass along my thanks to Arthur for the details. I'm using it as a crib sheet while I study the video. I thought I saw his pinky dancing around up there but wasn't sure until I read about it.

This is fascinating stuff. Thanks again.
Title: Re: Pignol and Milleret Learners, Hello?
Post by: Chris Ryall on January 06, 2011, 03:57:41 PM
Chris, I've been pondering your comments about degrees of (in)harmony and P&M vividness of pigment for a chord. Are the two somehow related, perhaps in the sense that a tritone chord is the most vivid of the pigments and the third harmonic is the least? Or, am I totally mixing the concepts?

For chords based on C (these more or less standard descriptions)

Note 'Colour' in major chord'Colour' in major minor chord
C tonic tonic has no colourit can even be missed out!
D 9thcoloured+ rings against tonic 'sus' chordIn minor - setting up the 'ALT' chord!
EbGhastly! Axiomatic minor 3rd
EAxiomatic major 3rdGhastly!
F as 4th  sus chord
Gb 5b superpowers minor 'diminished' quality
G 5th neutral, can be omittedneutral, can be omitted
G 5# coloured++ superdominant 'augmented'    
Ab 6b soft secondary minor with Cmin
A coloured+ adds 'brightness' coloured++ 'dorian'
Bb clashes with E 'DOMINANT'neutral
B very relaxed feel coloured++
C .. enter next octave .. the extensions
Db 9b extend a dominant and  
D also 'suggest' whether
D# next chord major or minor
F 11th neutral against major coloured in minor
F# as 11+  Popular jazz note 'lydian'bright
sound but subtle as away from tonic  

Experiment with these in conjunction with a C/E and C/Eb diads (or same intervals v any root you like).
[Thanks Steve - edit/copy/paste is full of traps!]
Title: Re: Pignol and Milleret Learners, Hello?
Post by: Gary P Chapin on January 07, 2011, 10:48:38 PM
Chris, that's a great list.  I wonder if "color" and "associations" are related.  For example, minor is a color, but it's associated with sad stuff or sinister.  The fifth is described as colorless and ambiguous, but it, to me, has very much of a medieval color.  I associate it with medieval music and it evokes all those sorts of images.
Title: Re: Pignol and Milleret Learners, Hello?
Post by: Gary P Chapin on January 07, 2011, 10:49:41 PM
Okay, I just called the Button Box and order P&M vol 2 and 3.  Holy Cow!  Those are expensive ...
Title: Re: Pignol and Milleret Learners, Hello?
Post by: Chris Ryall on January 08, 2011, 08:26:33 AM
Chris, that's a great list.  I wonder if "color" and "associations" are related.  For example, minor is a color, but it's associated with sad stuff or sinister.  The fifth is described as colorless and ambiguous, but it, to me, has very much of a medieval color.  I associate it with medieval music and it evokes all those sorts of images.

I (and P&M) use 'colour' as the effect adding a scale note has on a musical chord.  That's a standard description, except that 3rd is sort of ignored and major/minor chords analysed separately. I've split the list above to reflect that.

The 'association' or 'effect' is secondary and is also cultural, or in the ear of the listener. Believe it or not - the Russian Academy in the 1920's went through all student pieces systematically seeking and erasing 9th chord extensions and 7's other than as simple V dominants - such were considered 'decadent'
Title: Re: Pignol and Milleret Learners, Hello?
Post by: Steve_freereeder on January 08, 2011, 08:59:01 AM

I (and P&M) use 'colour' as the effect adding a scale note has on a musical chord.  That's a standard description, except that 3rd is sort of ignored and major/minor chords analysed separately. I've split the list above to reflect that.

Ah - I think that explains some confusion. Have you made an error? Should your second column be headed 'Colour in Minor chord' ? At the moment it says 'Major chord', the same as the first column.
Title: Pignol and Milleret Learners, Good Bye for Now
Post by: docEdock on January 08, 2011, 09:38:51 AM
I'm off to hunt down French Stuff in the West Indies and will be out of touch for a while. All the good forum positions were already taken -- Emote Wizard, Grumpy old git, Mr. Cool -- so I'm left to serve as forum ethnographer, studying how the tropics and coconut rums have influenced melodeon styles.

I cannot thank you enough for the kindness and support I've received. It made all the difference. A dozen years ago, on a whim, I picked up a flea market Hohner and spent a couple of months pushing its buttons, without much progress. Then I put it on the shelf. Recently through melnet I discovered a world I had sailed by. It has been a terrific landfall.

Until April . . .

doc
Title: Re: Pignol and Milleret Learners, Good Bye for Now
Post by: Steve_freereeder on January 08, 2011, 09:50:34 AM
I'm off to hunt down French Stuff in the West Indies and will be out of touch for a while. All the good forum positions were already taken -- Emote Wizard, Grumpy old git, Mr. Cool -- so I'm left to serve as forum ethnographer, studying how the tropics and coconut rums have influenced melodeon styles.

I cannot thank you enough for the kindness and support I've received. It made all the difference. A dozen years ago, on a whim, I picked up a flea market Hohner and spent a couple of months pushing its buttons, without much progress. Then I put it on the shelf. Recently through melnet I discovered a world I had sailed by. It has been a terrific landfall.

Until April . . .

doc
Thanks for your kind words. The pleasure has been ours too. Have a great trip. Take care to come back in one piece and tell us all about it!  (:)
Title: Re: Pignol and Milleret Learners, Hello?
Post by: playandteach on June 09, 2013, 10:19:26 AM
I'm finding it hard to locate stockists for the Milleret and Pignol series of books. Can anyone point me in the right direction, or better still sell me their dog-eared copies?
Title: Re: Pignol and Milleret Learners, Hello?
Post by: Roger Howard on June 09, 2013, 11:34:12 AM
I'm finding it hard to locate stockists for the Milleret and Pignol series of books. Can anyone point me in the right direction, or better still sell me their dog-eared copies?

I bought mine from Mustradem - this should be a link to the page on their website: http://boutique.mustradem.com/index.php?cPath=24&osCsid=h7o9cq1a44kgkvnh7qm56cou87.

They do look expensive,  I know (especially now the accompanying sound illustrations are apparently downloadable, rather than being actual CDs), but I keep going back to them again and again.  I suspect others do, too, which is why it might take bit of luck to find a second hand set.

When I've dealt with Mustradem, they have been very efficient. Delivery to the UK was no problem at all.

 All the best

Roger
Title: Re: Pignol and Milleret Learners, Hello?
Post by: El-ahrairah on June 26, 2013, 10:22:15 PM
I just ordered a copy of Vol 1 from The Button Box. When it arrives I shall delve into it. I would be lying if I said I was not a bit nervous.  :o
Title: Re: Pignol and Milleret Learners, Hello?
Post by: Mike Hirst on June 27, 2013, 12:22:35 AM
I'm discovering that learning French traditional accordion here in Atlanta Georgia is a lonely sport. Finding local TexMex or Cajun players might not be too hard

I sympathise.

Learning Tejano over here is a slow up hill battle.
Title: Re: Pignol and Milleret Learners, Hello?
Post by: deltasalmon on June 27, 2013, 02:37:12 AM
I don't have the tutor but have seen some of Stephane Milleret's YouTube videos and like that style. It would do me no good if I had the tutor because I play semi-tone anyway.

I'm discovering that learning French traditional accordion here in Atlanta Georgia is a lonely sport. Finding local TexMex or Cajun players might not be too hard

I sympathise.

Learning Tejano over here is a slow up hill battle.


Same here. I am interested in French traditional and Noteño music here but in New Jersey I'm just happy I have some Irish sessions in driving distance. Irish being mostly what I play and listen too.
Title: Re: Pignol and Milleret Learners, Hello?
Post by: playandteach on June 27, 2013, 07:52:47 AM
Could someone let me know what is included in volume 1 - is it good for everyone, or just total beginners. I have been playing for 5 months, and have a playing history of other instruments. I've had a look at the P & M British Swing tutorial on youtube, and that is challenging but manageable eventually.
It looks like volume 1 might still be useful, but I've seen a lot of books that take a long time to get going.
I have a couple of uploads in the beginners' showcase if anyone has the time to compare what I can already do (with stumbles and effort) if they know the standard of the books.
Any advice?
Title: Re: Pignol and Milleret Learners, Hello?
Post by: Roger Howard on June 27, 2013, 08:24:28 AM
I would say that Volume I really  is for beginners in every sense. It makes no assumptions about prior knowledge and takes you through holding the instrument and tablature, before working through exercises and tunes first in 2/4 and then 3/4; then 2/4 with semiquavers, 3/4 with quavers; changing basses; crossing rows; then follow 6/8 and 3/8, ending with a little repertoire which involves everything thus far. Interwoven is material on the G major scale, anacrusis, minor mode, and compound and simple rhythms.

You would probably find it covers what you already know and  can do ...

Hope that helps

Roger
Title: Re: Pignol and Milleret Learners, Hello?
Post by: Steve C. on June 27, 2013, 01:05:52 PM
What the M-P books do is teach one "how to play" the instrument, understand the keyboard, scales, bass/treble relationship, fingering, etc.

Not so much to teach tunes, except as exercises in using the techniques.

So it's great to use early on, if you can handle the fact that you are practicing and playing but not learning a lot of new tunes. 

In some ways it's like an extreme version of Mally's first book, where he focuses on crossing over and some other fingering techniques, that seem awkward and unhelpful in learning tunes, but really come in handy later on when you are learning tunes on your own.

I think the focus on not learning bad habits is very good.
Title: Re: Pignol and Milleret Learners, Hello?
Post by: playandteach on June 27, 2013, 03:36:44 PM
You would probably find it covers what you already know and  can do ...
Roger
Thanks, I'll try the next volume up, though I can always back track if it's too stretching.
Title: Re: Pignol and Milleret Learners, Hello?
Post by: Lost Alamos on June 27, 2013, 05:56:24 PM
HI Teacher, I would think after watching your video's [2], I will watch more! very good stuff.
anyway go for book 3 and forget about the rest. It is probably your touch that needs watching
and your bellow work. You know your music and I think you can be of great value here on this
forum. Not as a know it all but as a teacher who can help others.
anyway go for book 3 just to say you have something to cross reference with. You have
lots of knowledge so welcome to Melodeon Net. I have purchased at the same time as you
2 Serafini's. they are full of music with the slightest touch of the bellows. I want another  (:)
Title: Re: Pignol and Milleret Learners, Hello?
Post by: playandteach on June 28, 2013, 12:04:58 AM
It is probably your touch that needs watching and your bellow work.
 I have purchased at the same time as you
2 Serafini's. they are full of music with the slightest touch of the bellows. I want another  (:)
Thanks for your comments - you are certainly right about bellows - and probably about touch - although I've been making some progress there since videos. I wouldn't be too impressed with the videos - it takes me a fair time to learn songs as yet. I read your back-posts, and it seems like you have owned 14 G/Cs - be great to have some reviews, better still to see you playing some.
Title: Re: Pignol and Milleret Learners, Hello?
Post by: Roger Howard on June 28, 2013, 08:48:03 AM
Just in case it's of any interest, Book II covers:

9/8 rhythms, Embellishing your left hand playing, Use of metronome, Working on scales, Chords, Back-up and arpeggios, and some repertoire.

Book III covers:

Composed basses, ornamentation, asymmetrical bars(sounds gymnastic !!), The blues scale, some synthesis exercises and repertoire.

Roger
Title: Re: Pignol and Milleret Learners, Hello?
Post by: playandteach on June 28, 2013, 11:44:27 AM
Very helpful, Roger.
Looks like I want them both.
Title: Re: Pignol and Milleret Learners, Hello?
Post by: Colombia20102018 on August 02, 2013, 01:27:24 PM
Hello,
Do any of these volumens center in the left hand of the three row accordion? I would like to know if any of these would teach me the following:
1. how to play a short melody with the left hand. I believe this is called melodic bass or harmonic bass or something similar.
2. how by pressing more than one button at the same time with the left hand I can get a new chord and give a different sound (color) to the song.
3. if I am playing a melody with the right hand how to best accompany it with the left. More specifically explaining at what specific moment I should press the left hand button to make it sound better.
4. Are these books focus on the three row diatonic with 12 bass or something different?

I would really like if somebody that has used these books can give feedback related to if these books cover these topics and how in detail. Also, I would like to know what they cover related to the left hand.

Thank you to whoever can clarify these doubts.
Title: Re: Pignol and Milleret Learners, Hello?
Post by: Lost Alamos on August 02, 2013, 03:21:21 PM
HI, the answer is yes. [Book #3]. Book 3 also discusses the 3 row.
Great Books: not a better tutorial out there and the cost has nothing to
do with the big first down payment. These are longtime referance manuals
for someone who will spend time with them. They[the books] can only make
you better. Much cheaper then a teacher too but a teacher would be happy
with you if you were studying these manuals.
LA
Title: Re: Pignol and Milleret Learners, Hello?
Post by: Colombia20102018 on August 02, 2013, 06:45:00 PM
Thank you for your answer Lost Alamos. Do you think I need to buy books 1 and 2 in order to understand book 3?
Thanks.
Title: Re: Pignol and Milleret Learners, Hello?
Post by: Lost Alamos on August 02, 2013, 07:08:54 PM
Quite frankly I don't know what your skills musically are but those 3 books never bite anybody and their cost is that of maybe 10 hours of lessons and you will never get that
much information in three or four years with your master and it will be doubtful he
or she would be a master anyways. If you find a teacher who can help himself and you by using these 3 books that would be a wonderful relationship. BUY THE BOOKS take
them to a teacher and discover lots' [or for selfstudy] and expect rewards as you
apply yourself. Myself, I could never take a teacher but after studying these manuals
for 6 years or maybe 7  I could bring others thru these books and you can do the
same with some hardwork. I think the reward is in the books personally.
the books are dedicated to a 2 row and in the 3rd book they discuss about the use of a 3row and what to look for as you progress. Good Luck and I only post this thinking you are very sincere about learning.
LA
Title: Re: Pignol and Milleret Learners, Hello?
Post by: Colombia20102018 on August 02, 2013, 07:14:40 PM
LA,
Every day I am more convinced of buying these books.
Thanks for the quick reply.
Title: Re: Pignol and Milleret Learners, Hello?
Post by: docEdock on August 02, 2013, 09:36:36 PM
I ended up buying the Pignol and Milleret Vol 1-3 and Yann Dour Vol.1 : Le livre du débutant,  Vol.2 : La mélodie, and Vol.3 : L’accompagnement during the first year I started on diatonic. The P&M and Dour books are very different in approach and the musical genre they cover. Now, nearly three years thereafter, I have my own opinion of the strengths of both series.

As other have written, P&M use a carefully constructed methodology that includes a limited number of tunes to illustrate a wealth of concepts. There are many exercises to prepare for the application of a technique or approach to a tune and recordings of slow and normal speed playing of the exercises and tunes. P&M excel in the theory and application of the basics plus ornamentation, composed bases, accompaniment and most everything else I have wanted to know. For August TOTM I found myself consulting P&M's advice on the composed bases, mazurka rhythm and right hand chords. Since I normally do not have access to a teacher, P&M has become my reference guide.

That said, I stopped the P&M tutorial after the first six months -- somewhere around volume 1 page 36 when the learning curve got too steep for me and I tired of exercises. I switched to Yann Dour and worked my way through volume 1, learning the tunes by just playing them. Dour is more experience oriented than theory based and has some really terrific tunes, also with slow and fast versions. The tunes gradually introduce new techniques but I don't recall any exercises.

Then I started combining the P&M and Dour approaches. Dipping into each to supplement one another and skipping around Dour's volumes to do tunes that caught my fancy. Yeah, I know, I'm a really terrible student despite a career of teaching but I thought this learning the "continental stuff" should be fun rather than work. Had I had a tutor I would not have gotten away with such self indulgence.

A Dour tune would send me to P&M to find a more extensive explanation of what Dour was up to. Dour explains ornaments mainly by including them in tunes with only a short description. P&M explain ornaments by naming them by type, showing variations on how to do them, and giving you exercises to learn each. I find both approaches helpful.

As Los Alamos has pointed out, the expense of the books is nominal compared to the price of lessons. Plus these books tend to stick around and become valued friends over time. I've not regretted purchasing P&M and Dour even though there is more than my lifetime's learning between their covers. (They also tend to hold value in the secondary market should you decide to give them a new home.)

All that to say, you probably can't go wrong with P&M 1-3. You will be a better player for it, especially if you are less a slacker than I. If you like a spot of fun along the way consider adding (or even starting with Yann Dour) or wander into the free G/C partitions on the web as discussed in this post http://forum.melodeon.net/index.php/topic,11900.msg147343.html#msg147343 (http://forum.melodeon.net/index.php/topic,11900.msg147343.html#msg147343) The Catalonian sites, in particular, have an extensive collection of free methodologies, which I suspect they use in their own public music-training programs.
Title: Re: Pignol and Milleret Learners, Hello?
Post by: Gary P Chapin on August 03, 2013, 03:16:44 AM
A Dour tune would send me to P&M to find a more extensive explanation of what Dour was up to. Dour explains ornaments mainly by including them in tunes with only a short description. P&M explain ornaments by naming them by type, showing variations on how to do them, and giving you exercises to learn each. I find both approaches helpful.
I, too, have taken to using the P&M as reference works, and have been very happy using them that way.  I actually had them library bound, because I found myself consulting them often enough that I could envision them deteriorating.
Title: Re: Pignol and Milleret Learners, Hello?
Post by: docEdock on August 03, 2013, 12:22:20 PM

I, too, have taken to using the P&M as reference works, and have been very happy using them that way.  I actually had them library bound, because I found myself consulting them often enough that I could envision them deteriorating.

I had the same concern plus I found V2 doesn't open flat due to its binding. So I scanned my volumes and tucked the originals away.

Now on a really large monitor the dots are as big as paint buckets and the pages stay as crisp as new. When I fly all three P&M are easy to pack and surprisingly lighter than the originals.

I know that I'm fudging by considering this "fair use" for old eyes but I do appreciate not squinting at that increasingly tiny print and being able to position the monitor at just the right bifocal angle. Anyway, so long as I never share or mention this to anyone, I'll be beyond the reach of the law. :Ph
Title: Re: Pignol and Milleret Learners, Hello?
Post by: Colombia20102018 on August 10, 2013, 05:41:41 AM
Hello everybody,
I received my pignol milleret volumes today. It is amazing the amount of information these books have.
I have a question related to composed basses in volume 3. Does the list of composed bass chords in page 18 of volume three only apply if my left hand chords have the third removed? If that is the case, is there a list of composed bass I could do without removing the thirds?
Also,  does the requirement of removing the thirds apply for the whole volume 3 or just to the first chapter of volume three ?
Thanks to anybody that could clarify this.  (:)
Title: Re: Pignol and Milleret Learners, Hello?
Post by: Chris Ryall on August 10, 2013, 06:27:37 PM
M/P don't have thirds, and «accords composés» do work better that way. But I used several eg Em/C, C/A and D/B for yeard on my unstoppable Lilly.

The one that doesn't work is Bmaj/G, which is not Gmaj7 Only worked when I got a stopper
Title: Re: Pignol and Milleret Learners, Hello?
Post by: Steve C. on August 11, 2013, 11:06:38 PM
For lots of music, taking out the thirds is like cutting the balls off the chords, but for the French methods, and of lot tunes in that style, no thirds really open up the use of the chord.
Title: Re: Pignol and Milleret Learners, Hello?
Post by: Caroline on August 19, 2015, 06:11:26 PM
Anyone want to sell their copies of P&M vol 1 plus CD and/or  Yann Dour Vol.1 : Le livre du débutant, plus CD?

Cheers,
Caroline
Title: Re: Pignol and Milleret Learners, Hello?
Post by: Melondeoni on September 05, 2015, 11:00:48 AM
Just ordered the DVD The air and the movement, 3.5 hours lessons.

"provide further insight into the four volumes of their method" not realy understand what they mean by this,
but  'The biginner and seasoned esthete'  sounds good enough for me.

http://boutique.mustradem.com/product_info.php?cPath=24&products_id=183&osCsid=81hm19stb4b1mav9l707lhfuv6
Title: Re: Pignol and Milleret Learners, Hello?
Post by: Steve C. on September 05, 2015, 01:17:57 PM
If you take your old style bound M&P to a bookbinder or decent size print shop they can cut (skive?) off the binding and replace it with spiral for very reasonable cost.
Title: Re: Pignol and Milleret Learners, Hello?
Post by: Chris Ryall on September 05, 2015, 09:32:07 PM
I don't see it as much of an extension to vol 4, which seems to me mostly a collection of jazz scales written out.

But it nicely complements 1,2,3 offering things that you cannot express on page or as a recording. I personally think it should be an early item in a melodeonista's education, certainly corrected a few things I'd taught to myself, quite wrongly.
Title: Re: Pignol and Milleret Learners, Hello?
Post by: Kon on June 18, 2019, 10:18:45 PM
Not sure if reviving this old thread is the best way to ask this question, sorry if it's bad manners:

Can anyone please confirm what keyboard layout the Milleret & Pignol books expect? I can see from the blurb on the Mustradem website it is two-row 8-bass GC, but am wondering about the accidentals in particular. Somebody recently told me that the standard accidentals can be reversed with respect to push-pull in instruments from different manufacturers (is this true?) and I may soon have some work done on my new GC box and want to make sure that I have it set up to make it easiest to start playing along to Milleret and Pignol.
Title: Re: Pignol and Milleret Learners, Hello?
Post by: playandteach on June 18, 2019, 10:52:37 PM
Standard left hand. Right hand is 3rd button start.
G row has button 1 pull Eb, push C#. button 2 is pull F#, push D.
C row button 1 is pull G# push Bb, button 2 is  pull B, push G.
That's all from a diagram on page 7 of volume 2.
The main accidental used in the exercises is the G#. Mine is on the push, and that gives me no problem as the idea is to learn where your buttons are, although his suggested fingering or tab will differ if you have a different layout - but I don't see that as an issue.
Title: Re: Pignol and Milleret Learners, Hello?
Post by: Kon on June 19, 2019, 12:16:57 AM
Thanks for the speedy response playandteach! That agrees with the GC accidental layout on the melnet keyboard layouts page. I will have to decide whether to have the G# on the push or the pull, but reassuring to hear having it the "wrong" way around has not caused you any problems.
Title: Re: Pignol and Milleret Learners, Hello?
Post by: Blake on June 22, 2019, 03:13:32 PM


Can anyone please confirm what keyboard layout the Milleret & Pignol books expect?
I used this layout and it worked very well with the first two books (attached) I didn't use the accidental row much.
Title: Re: Pignol and Milleret Learners, Hello?
Post by: Chris Ryall on June 24, 2019, 03:23:55 PM
The layout is, or is close to 'standard French' and P&M teach to that.  Both have second GCaccs boxes used for tuition (and spares)!

Their stage stuff is played on G(*C with a G#)accs layout, invented by them and now popular in Southern France, also Belgium.  Frankly, they then play mostly in D on it, major or minor(!) and actively seek out off-scale notes  ??? 

You don't need to worry about that unless you move to book 4.  Their base method is designed for standard French G/C kit. 

*In essence that's G/A harmonic minor/accs
SimplePortal 2.3.5 © 2008-2012, SimplePortal