Which tutorial books would fit into the French Traditional category?
But, now I'm off to find out more about Frederic Paris. I've bumped into his name along the way but can't say that I've really explored what's available.
I'll be interested in hearing your thoughts on how P&M's approach differs from or compliments Dour's.
If you wait long enough, I'll be selling P&M volume 1. It might be years, though. Otherwise it's off to the Button Box for you. I didn't find anywhere else in the US that carried them.
P&M and Yann Dour's tutors are both excellent and complementary, but if you need a break from the theory and learn while having fun you could do worse than getting this stuff: (written for G/C players)
http://www.sheetmusicplus.com/title/Marc-Perrone-Treize-A-La-Douzaine/8263321
If you wait long enough, I'll be selling P&M volume 1. It might be years, though. Otherwise it's off to the Button Box for you. I didn't find anywhere else in the US that carried them.
Gary can skip ahead to book 2!
Please excuse my unintended slight. I just listened to Gary's TOTM and he's definitely not book 1 material. Perhaps he'll sell me book 3 after he's zipped through it.
There was no slight! Thanks for the kind words. I am intending, for my mid january paycheck, to call the button box and drop the sheckles for P&M volumes 2 and 3. I probably would get book one, but it's just so expensive. Nearly $175 for the three. P&M are interesting. I don't agree, at all, with their dismissal of 3rds in chords, but I've gotten so much joy out of their tunes and recordings. Lots lots lots to learn there.Please excuse my unintended slight. I just listened to Gary's TOTM and he's definitely not book 1 material. Perhaps he'll sell me book 3 after he's zipped through it.
Oops, I didn't mean to imply that -- I was just thinking that book 2 is where many of us in the intermediate/advanced intermediate zone (at least, those of us who have not studied with Milleret or Pignol) will find that the learning curve gets considerably steeper. Most of the technique that I've learned has been from learning tunes that were progressively more difficult -- volume 2 gets into some technique that goes beyond the playing of those tunes. It is more about deeping the execution of any given tune with more advanced bass work as well as right hand chords.
Nothing wrong with 3rds in chords. My oakwood has 3rds and a stop to cut them - I think the latter is in/out about 50%
P&M teach chord notes as giving "colour" and that 3rd is one of the highest pigment notes there is. They describe the 1+5 "third harmonic" harmony as an "accord faible" - so in as sense that is the one they dismiss!
I think the problem is rather, technical - one just can't get all the reeds for an 18 bass into the left end. That 18 is actually 6 pairs of chords, plus 6 single basses - but all 12 basses are double reeded, and some are big ones. B Gaillard also offers a 16 button (8 real chord pairs) option on his Saphir, but once described 9 full chord pairs to me as 'impossible'. His '18' is also that offered by several other makers.
P&M are in practice strongly right hand players, and commonly comp for each other building up really complex stuff on that end. They alsolikeadore the tritone interval which can't be done in a decent voicing on the left.
It's convenient not having to even think whether you are in major or minor .. but I don't think that comes into it with these two. They use major and minor chords all the time - but on the other end
P&M teach chord notes as giving "colour" and that 3rd is one of the highest pigment notes there is. They describe the 1+5 "third harmonic" harmony as an "accord faible" - so in as sense that is the one they dismiss!
P&M are in practice strongly right hand players, and commonly comp for each other building up really complex stuff on that end. They alsolikeadore the tritone interval which can't be done in a decent voicing on the left.
Is a "tritone interval" tones 1+3 played as a chord (or a sequence?) on the treble? Why can't it "be done in a decent voicing on the left?"The tritone interval is an augmented fourth, or put another way, three whole tones (hence the name). It is also two successive minor thirds. Example: C to F# is a tritone.
Tip? :-\ OK, in the B music where the chords go G, C, G - try Em, D, C (all on the pull). By someHow do you sages know the answer to the mystery of which chords might go with that measure? Is this P&M book 2 or 3 stuff? Or can you point me to a fairly simple explanation? Is there a chord progression for beginners topic? I thought that with only has 8 possible buttons on the left hand it should be obvious which one to push. Now you suggest that there are really 16 possibilities . . .
miracle of melodeonism you'll find the notes of the tune are still there, albeit in different places
Plenty of information and audio examples here:
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tritone
OK let's go the other route. Perhaps you are trying too hard at this stage and worrying too much about the theory of harmony. For the LH chords, trust your ear instead. Don't be afraid to experiment. If it sounds OK to you, then it probably is.Tip? :-\ OK, in the B music where the chords go G, C, G - try Em, D, C (all on the pull). By someHow do you sages know the answer to the mystery of which chords might go with that measure? Is this P&M book 2 or 3 stuff? Or can you point me to a fairly simple explanation? Is there a chord progression for beginners topic? I thought that with only has 8 possible buttons on the left hand it should be obvious which one to push. Now you suggest that there are really 16 possibilities . . .
miracle of melodeonism you'll find the notes of the tune are still there, albeit in different places
I find reading and rereading posts like the quote above to be like watching an Olympian skate. There's so much going on behind the scenes. Every statement is built on nuance and technique. Here I am wobbling across the ice and asking about a triple axel.
So, back to my question about Chris's comment: is a tritone interval (C F#) hard to voice on a G/C because there is no F# bass on the left hand? The only F# is buried inside the D major chord?Yes, that's correct for the LH chords/basses.
I believe it was Tony Hall - the wonderful melodeon player from Norfolk in eastern England - who said something to effect of "when you are playing, just poke about a bit with your fingers and see what it sounds like. If you like what you hear then stick with that".
Basically that 3 tone intervals as different as two notes can get in (in)harmonious terms. The notes clash and your chord is unstable - it demands "resolution" - it's "dominant" Our cleverly defined "90% harmonious " bass end just doesn't do that. You have to employ right hand chords (or your ear, as per the great Tony Hall).
P&M teach chord notes as giving "colour" and that 3rd is one of the highest pigment notes there is. They describe the 1+5 "third harmonic" harmony as an "accord faible" - so in as sense that is the one they dismiss!
.........I don't expect you (or anyone) to take on the burden of handing me this stuff on a platter, so if there is a link you'd suggest to answer my question, I'll do the studying.
I'd always managed to avoid learning about such things with other instruments, but the oddities of the melodeon seem to demand some greater understanding about harmony, arrangement and suchlike.I agree, but the oddities of the melodeon really make an excellent opening to the world of theory and harmony.
From the sounds of it, you're in a similar position to I was a year or so back. . . .
I agree, but the oddities of the melodeon really make an excellent opening to the world of theory and harmony.
Well then, Arthur's La Marianne gives me an enormous boost, especially if he was somewhat (un)harmonic a year ago. After I heard his video I wanted to hunt him down and ask, "How did you do that?" I saw him on the outside row so I suspect he changed keys on me, but the rest flew right by. If he ever wants to do a walk thru-video, I'll stand in line for a ticket.
Chris, I've been pondering your comments about degrees of (in)harmony and P&M vividness of pigment for a chord. Are the two somehow related, perhaps in the sense that a tritone chord is the most vivid of the pigments and the third harmonic is the least? Or, am I totally mixing the concepts?
| Note | 'Colour' in major chord | 'Colour' in |
| C tonic | tonic has no colour | it can even be missed out! |
| D 9th | coloured+ rings against tonic 'sus' chord | In minor - setting up the 'ALT' chord! |
| Eb | Ghastly! | Axiomatic minor 3rd |
| E | Axiomatic major 3rd | Ghastly! |
| F as 4th | sus chord | |
| Gb | 5b superpowers minor 'diminished' quality | |
| G 5th | neutral, can be omitted | neutral, can be omitted |
| G 5# | coloured++ superdominant 'augmented' | |
| Ab 6b | soft secondary minor with Cmin | |
| A | coloured+ adds 'brightness' | coloured++ 'dorian' |
| Bb | clashes with E 'DOMINANT' | neutral |
| B | very relaxed feel | coloured++ |
| C | .. enter next octave | .. the extensions |
| Db 9b | extend a dominant and | |
| D | also 'suggest' whether | |
| D# | next chord major or minor | |
| F 11th | neutral against major | coloured in minor |
| F# as 11+ | Popular jazz note 'lydian'bright | |
| sound but subtle as away from tonic |
Chris, that's a great list. I wonder if "color" and "associations" are related. For example, minor is a color, but it's associated with sad stuff or sinister. The fifth is described as colorless and ambiguous, but it, to me, has very much of a medieval color. I associate it with medieval music and it evokes all those sorts of images.
Ah - I think that explains some confusion. Have you made an error? Should your second column be headed 'Colour in Minor chord' ? At the moment it says 'Major chord', the same as the first column.
I (and P&M) use 'colour' as the effect adding a scale note has on a musical chord. That's a standard description, except that 3rd is sort of ignored and major/minor chords analysed separately. I've split the list above to reflect that.
I'm off to hunt down French Stuff in the West Indies and will be out of touch for a while. All the good forum positions were already taken -- Emote Wizard, Grumpy old git, Mr. Cool -- so I'm left to serve as forum ethnographer, studying how the tropics and coconut rums have influenced melodeon styles.Thanks for your kind words. The pleasure has been ours too. Have a great trip. Take care to come back in one piece and tell us all about it! (:)
I cannot thank you enough for the kindness and support I've received. It made all the difference. A dozen years ago, on a whim, I picked up a flea market Hohner and spent a couple of months pushing its buttons, without much progress. Then I put it on the shelf. Recently through melnet I discovered a world I had sailed by. It has been a terrific landfall.
Until April . . .
doc
I'm finding it hard to locate stockists for the Milleret and Pignol series of books. Can anyone point me in the right direction, or better still sell me their dog-eared copies?
I'm discovering that learning French traditional accordion here in Atlanta Georgia is a lonely sport. Finding local TexMex or Cajun players might not be too hard
I'm discovering that learning French traditional accordion here in Atlanta Georgia is a lonely sport. Finding local TexMex or Cajun players might not be too hard
I sympathise.
Learning Tejano over here is a slow up hill battle.
You would probably find it covers what you already know and can do ...Thanks, I'll try the next volume up, though I can always back track if it's too stretching.
Roger
It is probably your touch that needs watching and your bellow work.Thanks for your comments - you are certainly right about bellows - and probably about touch - although I've been making some progress there since videos. I wouldn't be too impressed with the videos - it takes me a fair time to learn songs as yet. I read your back-posts, and it seems like you have owned 14 G/Cs - be great to have some reviews, better still to see you playing some.
I have purchased at the same time as you
2 Serafini's. they are full of music with the slightest touch of the bellows. I want another (:)
A Dour tune would send me to P&M to find a more extensive explanation of what Dour was up to. Dour explains ornaments mainly by including them in tunes with only a short description. P&M explain ornaments by naming them by type, showing variations on how to do them, and giving you exercises to learn each. I find both approaches helpful.I, too, have taken to using the P&M as reference works, and have been very happy using them that way. I actually had them library bound, because I found myself consulting them often enough that I could envision them deteriorating.
I, too, have taken to using the P&M as reference works, and have been very happy using them that way. I actually had them library bound, because I found myself consulting them often enough that I could envision them deteriorating.
I used this layout and it worked very well with the first two books (attached) I didn't use the accidental row much.
Can anyone please confirm what keyboard layout the Milleret & Pignol books expect?