Melodeon.net Forums

Discussions => Instrument Makes and Models => Topic started by: nemethmik on December 21, 2010, 06:50:43 AM

Title: Hohner wet sound with LMM reeds
Post by: nemethmik on December 21, 2010, 06:50:43 AM
I have a Hohner Corona IIIR GCF (from the 60's I guess) with LMM reeds where the MM reeds are tuned to the usual Hohner wet sound. I found that when I play the two MM reeds (Pokerwork style) the sound is great. When I play LM the sound is dry and excellent. But, when I play LMM the sound is awfull to my ears. Have you experienced that a pair of wet MM sounds pleasing to your ear, but when you add a low octave note (L) the sound changes unpleasently agressive? Maybe this is the reason owning an LMMM where two MM reeds are tuned dry matching the L, and you play LMM with these two dry tuned MM reeds only.
Title: Re: Hohner wet sound with LMM reeds
Post by: Andrew Culwell on December 29, 2010, 05:47:56 AM
I had a Hohner Corso that was converted from C/F to B/C the reeds were not Hohner though I believe they were Machine grade Italian tuned what some would call demi-swing, I didn't have the ability to switch to 2 voice and really hated the LMM sound of this box.  I sold it!  It was harsh to my ears also, I am not sure I would ever have another LMM box but I haven't heard many in that configuration.
Title: Re: Hohner wet sound with LMM reeds
Post by: Steve_freereeder on December 29, 2010, 07:35:42 AM
I think it is a matter of personal taste.

Many 3-voice instruments tuned LMM sound perfectly fine to me, and I like the sound. But the caveat here is that my experience of LMM tuning is mostly limited to (a) non-Hohner instruments, principally Castagnaris and Saltarelles, and (b) to the MM reeds being tuned with only a very light tremolo.

Having said that, a friend has a Castagnari Tommy where the MM reeds are tuned with quite a strong tremolo. Yet when the L voice is switched in, it still sounds good to me, with a strong powerful sound.

So maybe Hohner reeds are different, given their particular spectrum of harmonics, and don't sound so good in LMM with a fairly typical Hohner tremolo on the MM.

One solution might be to have the MM reeds tuned in Viennese or 'Dedic' fashion: i.e. M- M+ so that the resultant perceived pitch is at Mconcert. Then, if the L reed is also tuned to Lconcert, the combination of L M- M+ ought to sound very nice indeed. However, the disadvantage of this is that no LM combination is going to sound nice; L M- or L M+ will both sound fairly nasty.

Title: Re: Hohner wet sound with LMM reeds
Post by: Owen Woods on December 29, 2010, 12:09:41 PM
What? Surely MM+ also sounds at MConcert? Or have I missed something? ???
Title: Re: Hohner wet sound with LMM reeds
Post by: Lester on December 29, 2010, 12:17:11 PM
What? Surely MM+ also sounds at MConcert? Or have I missed something? ???

The whole point of "Dedic" tuning M+/M- is that the resulting sound appears to be concert. It is undoubtedly true that M/M+ will always sound sharp of concert pitch.
Title: Re: Hohner wet sound with LMM reeds
Post by: Owen Woods on December 29, 2010, 12:23:27 PM
What? Surely MM+ also sounds at MConcert? Or have I missed something? ???

The whole point of "Dedic" tuning M+/M- is that the resulting sound appears to be concert. It is undoubtedly true that M/M+ will always sound sharp of concert pitch.

Ah, see that was what I thought at first, but since everyone is tuning MM+ I assumed that it would sound at MConcert :P It hadn't occured to me that people would tune it sharper than concert pitch, although it would presumably be only by a few cents, i.e. 4 cents with M+ at 8.

This bothers me. Maybe I'll tune to dedic. Time to scour YouTube to listen to the difference...
Title: Re: Hohner wet sound with LMM reeds
Post by: Owen Woods on December 29, 2010, 12:31:35 PM
This thread explains it: http://forum.melodeon.net/index.php/topic,1318.20.html
Title: Re: Hohner wet sound with LMM reeds
Post by: Graham Spencer on December 29, 2010, 12:44:57 PM
The last post about a "high tuning" in that thread is interesting - I have an old Hohner 4-bass "Vienna" 1-row picked up for a tenner that's ostensibly in C, but actually it plays fairly close to C#. I've been trying to decide whether to break it for spares, tune it down to modern concert, fit it with a complete new set of modern reeds in, maybe, D, or tune it properly to modern C# (that should make for an interesting session or two!). Oops - thread drift warning!!

Graham
Title: Re: Hohner wet sound with LMM reeds
Post by: Steve_freereeder on December 29, 2010, 01:14:40 PM
What? Surely MM+ also sounds at MConcert? Or have I missed something? ???

The whole point of "Dedic" tuning M+/M- is that the resulting sound appears to be concert. It is undoubtedly true that M/M+ will always sound sharp of concert pitch.

Ah, see that was what I thought at first, but since everyone is tuning MM+ I assumed that it would sound at MConcert :P It hadn't occured to me that people would tune it sharper than concert pitch, although it would presumably be only by a few cents, i.e. 4 cents with M+ at 8.

This bothers me. Maybe I'll tune to dedic. Time to scour YouTube to listen to the difference...
A few months ago, I tuned a 2-voice C/F Hohner Erica to Viennese/Dedic tuning. The results have been most gratifying, especially when playing RH chords. Also the LH basses/chords (tuned to concert pitch) now sound in tune with the RH side. Definitely the way to go for a 2-voice instrument IMHO.
Title: Re: Hohner wet sound with LMM reeds
Post by: Theo on December 29, 2010, 04:25:03 PM
Definitely the way to go for a 2-voice instrument IMHO.

If it is wet tuned.   
Title: Re: Hohner wet sound with LMM reeds
Post by: Owen Woods on December 29, 2010, 04:26:35 PM
Definitely the way to go for a 2-voice instrument IMHO.

If it is wet tuned.   

Care to expand on that Theo? Why does that make a difference and what do you class as wet? (:)
Title: Re: Hohner wet sound with LMM reeds
Post by: waltzman on December 29, 2010, 04:38:44 PM
What? Surely MM+ also sounds at MConcert? Or have I missed something? ???
It is undoubtedly true that M/M+ will always sound sharp of concert pitch.

I'm not so sure about this.  I have tuned several Hohners to a swing tremolo and neither my ear nor my Peterson tuner registers the resulting notes as sharp. 

Title: Re: Hohner wet sound with LMM reeds
Post by: george garside on December 30, 2010, 11:23:09 AM
I think it is a matter of personal taste.

Many 3-voice instruments tuned LMM sound perfectly fine to me, and I like the sound. But the caveat here is that my experience of LMM tuning is mostly limited to (a) non-Hohner instruments, principally Castagnaris and Saltarelles, and (b) to the MM reeds being tuned with only a very light tremolo.

Having said that, a friend has a Castagnari Tommy where the MM reeds are tuned with quite a strong tremolo. Yet when the L voice is switched in, it still sounds good to me, with a strong powerful sound.

So 

my serenellini salterello has  a goodly amount of tremelo ( + - I know not what)  and sounds good with low reed in, partiularly for playing waltzes - I like it  but then I always choose a box that , other things being equal, I like the sound of as apart from a complete retune there isn't much you can do about it afterwards.

george
SimplePortal 2.3.5 © 2008-2012, SimplePortal