is there anything a melodeon can do that a PA can't doWell, apart from fly through the air a lot easier when thrown the answer is no. I play both and still find the PA more intuitive (due to years of having bashed up and down a keyboard).
Woah Neil! What a way to start a great thread >:EQuoteis there anything a melodeon can do that a PA can't doWell, apart from fly through the air a lot easier when thrown the answer is no....
To me, the melodeon has a particular sound that piano accordions don't seem able to replicate.
Finally, is there anything a melodeon can do that a PA can't do, apart from being easier to carry? Please convince me that a melodeon is the right path to take! Thanks.Yes, two words: looking cool! ;D
Woah Neil! What a way to start a great thread >:EQuoteis there anything a melodeon can do that a PA can't doThere are those who will tell you that the melodeon has more 'bounce' and is better suited to dance music than the PA because of the push pull system. This of course is total trot - that bounce and movement depends on the player's ability.
True, but in my experience there isn't one out of a hundred PA players that can do it convincingly.
May I humbly submit, from this side of the pond, Stanley "Buckwheat Zydeco" Dural, Jr. and (RIP) Clifton Chenier as one of the hundred still playing and the other of the hundred no longer with us.
a decent PA will cost far more than a decent melodeonIt depends. On ebay.de you can find top-class decent 30-year old piano or chromatic button accordions (with 4-voice hand-made reeds) for a great price. Another example a Castagnari Handry/18 (with hand-made type reeds) is not less expensive than a 5-row Castagnari Magica K3 chromatic button accordion (with hand-made reeds).
Thanks for all the comments, very much appreciated and interesting reading. Since my first post I've been out for the evening and returned to find an email confirming the availability of a good condition D/G Pokerwork with straps for just over £300 relatively local to me. This would appear to be the ideal solution, especially at the price being asked. The PA will have to wait until I've amassed a great deal many more brownie points!
is there anything specific I should look out for when checking out a 2nd hand instrument? Obviously I'll need to check all the buttons work on pull and push, are dodgy bellows easy to spot?Mostly use your common sense. If the instrument looks as if it has been badly treated and has significant amounts of rust on the bright-work, that is a bit of a warning sign that all might not be well internally. On Hohner pokerworks (and some others too) the bellows may be prone to superficial wear on the side closest to your body, particularly towards the lower end, where they can be worn by contact with belts/buckles etc. So long as the wear is not too bad, and starting to show deterioration of the cardboard 'mountain folds', this is not necessarily too serious, and can be repaired with replacement bellows tape (plenty of help available from experts on this forum).
They are also far more compactVery true if you want to play only one kind of music at a time. But if you want to play a number of kinds of music: you should bring a herd of diatonic boxes, and you should learn a number of fingering and bass systems.
Woah Neil! What a way to start a great thread >:EQuoteis there anything a melodeon can do that a PA can't doThere are those who will tell you that the melodeon has more 'bounce' and is better suited to dance music than the PA because of the push pull system. This of course is total trot - that bounce and movement depends on the player's ability.
True, but in my experience there isn't one out of a hundred PA players that can do it convincingly.
True, but in my experience there isn't one out of a hundred PA players that can do it convincingly.
May I humbly submit, from this side of the pond, Stanley "Buckwheat Zydeco" Dural, Jr. and (RIP) Clifton Chenier as one of the hundred still playing and the other of the hundred no longer with us.
What I wonder, now is your opinion on the melodeon, if one out of a hundred piano players can get the bounce, what's the number of melodeon players? 50 out of a hundred, 10, 99?
No disrespect meant here, just curious. Thank you, Ben
They are also far more compactVery true if you want to play only one kind of music at a time. But if you want to play a number of kinds of music: you should bring a herd of diatonic boxes, and you should learn a number of fingering and bass systems.
I have done this and I loved the process of learning these systems: it's great fun. But eventually, I want to be proficient on one system only. I still haven't decided either to go for the.
- 3-row bisonoric-diatonic (GCF, ADG) the John Bone style
- 3-row bisonoric-chromatic with 18 bass: G/C/accidentals or D/G/acidentals (Andrea Capezzuoli, Saul Rose and many others)
- unisonoric-chromatic button with stradella bass (CBA)
I didn't see British Chromatic Accordion in that list :P Much better than CBA.The systems I included in my short list are used all over the world and very popular systems. BCC#, maybe the best accordion system ever invented, is an arcane/dead-end/anachronistic system used by only a handful of people. Just like Club-system, it is not a standard model any more on the catalog of any well-known accordion maker.
That's an interesting list. I play a two and a half row (G/C/accidentals) with 12 bass. I never touch the flat key basses. Literally, did it once for a theater project. Anyway, I've been fascinated with each of the types on the list. Even did long-term loans on instruments and came close to buying (for example, a used three row Handry currently available at the Button Box)..
- 3-row bisonoric-diatonic (GCF, ADG) the John Bone style
- 3-row bisonoric-chromatic with 18 bass: G/C/accidentals or D/G/acidentals (Andrea Capezzuoli, Saul Rose and many others)
- unisonoric-chromatic button with stradella bass (CBA)
I didn't see British Chromatic Accordion in that list :P Much better than CBA.The systems I included in my short list are used all over the world and very popular systems. BCC#, maybe the best accordion system ever invented, is an arcane/dead-end/anachronistic system used by only a handful of people. Just like Club-system, it is not a standard model any more on the catalog of any well-known accordion maker.
Fingers crossed I'll be collecting the melodeon on Friday, and no doubt start annoying the family on Christmas day :||:
What do people recommend as good beginners tunes?
I didn't see British Chromatic Accordion in that list :P Much better than CBA.The systems I included in my short list are used all over the world and very popular systems. BCC#, maybe the best accordion system ever invented, is an arcane/dead-end/anachronistic system used by only a handful of people. Just like Club-system, it is not a standard model any more on the catalog of any well-known accordion maker.
Hmm, I wouldn't go that far ;) However, you are right in that there aren't that many being produced, aside from the Compadre with it's useless melodeon bass. I think it's a shame and I think that the Club is a shame as well (although Hohner still produce them). Also not on your list is the hybrids, C#DG, F#GC, GCC# (Ricardo Tesi plays one of the latter two I think, can't remember which atm). I also met someone playing C#D C lydian :P
I also met someone playing C#D C lydian :P
My list, George apparently forgot to write anything. :P I missed out BCE and the other oddball system mixte arrangements.
. I like the limitations of the melodeon, and feel that many of the passing chords and sophisticated schord sequences that can be achieved on a PA simply don't enhance English dance music, which is what I like to play.
Good luck, anyway!
theres nowt quite like passing chords & sophisticated chord sequences to bugger up a good dance tune!True - but who wants to dance anyway? >:E
don't kn ow w;hat happened there - must have pressed post button before I posted!
what I was goin to say was that steve clincscale music has new bcc# 27 bass italian maade boxes for under 2k and also serenellini have made one or two very nice ones recently to special order possibly through birmingham accordions or whatever their proper name is ( they are serenellini agents)
The BCC# is not suitable for classical stuff & exams & grades as right hand chords in set pieces may not be availabale due to not being able to come & go at the same time. It is however a superb traditional/folk box & is the in my opinion, for what its worth, the best choice for melodeonists (of whatever set up) wanting to go chromatic with decent bass whilst retaining the joys?!? of sook an blaw
george - now having said more than he was going to say when he didn't say anything ;D
* eg - having to decide whether C or C# is 'forbidden' against pull A.
* eg - having to decide whether C or C# is 'forbidden' against pull A.
to me one is and t'other isn't - but then being a simple soul I always work on the basis that if ity sounds right it is right & if it sounds bloody awful it isn't
george :D
C Sharp Squared? :-*
* eg - having to decide whether C or C# is 'forbidden' against pull A.
to me one is and t'other isn't - but then being a simple soul I always work on the basis that if ity sounds right it is right & if it sounds bloody awful it isn't
george :D
Isn't this a question of major or minor?