Melodeon.net Forums

Discussions => Instrument Design, Construction and Repair => Topic started by: docEdock on December 22, 2010, 09:07:14 PM

Title: Convert Hohner A/D to G/C?
Post by: docEdock on December 22, 2010, 09:07:14 PM
I'm learning to play French stuff and need a G/C box to take to sea. Something I won't cry about when it goes for a swim. My current box was flea market priced at $75. I'm wondering whether I might be able to buy G/C reed blocks and swap with the existing blocks. If that isn't the correct term for the removable assembly that holds the reeds attached I'm sure someone will chime in and update my vocabulary.

The box plays well except for clacking like a tractor and other than a crack in the finger board doesn't seem damaged. If I dangle it from the left strap it takes about 30 seconds for the bellows to extend until they stop on their own. I don't know whether that's good, bad or just OK, but as a beginner I'm always running out of wind. Technique or bellows? You decide.

As for whether it's in tune, my Droid's G-String tuner -- now there's a name for a mobile app that really raised my wife's eyebrows when she saw it on my phone -- recognizes which note I'm pressing without too much needle deviation. It sounds pretty much in wet tune to me, but then I can enjoy middle school orchestra concerts while everyone else complains, thus I'll defer to the Droid. Since I'm thinking of replacing the reeds, tune shouldn't matter much, I suppose.
 
So, put in G/C reeds, pad the clacks, bush the left hand buttons and fix the crack? Or, flog it at auction and buy a G/C Hohner?

Pictures at http://picasaweb.google.com/docedoc123/Hohner?authkey=Gv1sRgCKCG2LWAu7rE2wE# (http://picasaweb.google.com/docedoc123/Hohner?authkey=Gv1sRgCKCG2LWAu7rE2wE#)

p.s. Why is 7 stamped on the reed block?

Title: Re: Convert Hohner A/D to G/C?
Post by: Theo on December 22, 2010, 10:07:32 PM
Absolutely nothing wrong with an A/D box for playing French stuff, unless you are playing along with other G/C players.   Emmanuel Pariselle plays a lot on A/D.  I think the box he plays in this clip (http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=4lxKgAXnqKc&feature=related) is A/D
Title: Re: Convert Hohner A/D to G/C?
Post by: docEdock on December 23, 2010, 10:07:37 AM
Absolutely nothing wrong with an A/D box for playing French stuff, unless you are playing along with other G/C players.

That's good to hear. I mis(?)understood that the G/C tuning was somehow much lower than typical with other tunings. So, the difference between a Hohner Pokerwork A/D and a G/C is that on the A/D each note and chord is one tone higher, as in sounds just like a G/C but a bit sharp?

I do anticipate playing along with others -- Pignol (or perhaps it is Mileret on the audio files) has volunteered to join my virtual sessions. With me on A/D I fear we'll sound like a middle school orchestra on a really bad day. But, this isn't all bad because in an anchorage sometimes a neighbor's dogs yip incessantly. Payback.



Title: Re: Convert Hohner A/D to G/C?
Post by: Theo on December 23, 2010, 10:10:55 AM
So, the difference between a Hohner Pokerwork A/D and a G/C is that on the A/D each note and chord is one tone higher, as in sounds just like a G/C but a bit sharp?

Exactly. And anything you learn on the A/D can be played with exactly the same fingering in a G/C, so nothing you learn on the A/D will be wasted.

A/D has the additional advantage that it may be easier to play with fiddle  players who often favour those keys.
Title: Re: Convert Hohner A/D to G/C?
Post by: docEdock on December 23, 2010, 10:27:04 AM
Thanks for the clarification. I'll keep the current tuning and use an editor to re-pitch the audio recordings to A/D.

Any thoughts on whether to fix the keyboard crack or just let it be? I've read about using carpet to pad the mechanism and think I may try that. As I recall it involves removing the keyboard. If so, I'll have access to both sides of the crack should I want to attempt a glue job.
Title: Re: Convert Hohner A/D to G/C?
Post by: ben armatto on December 23, 2010, 12:48:57 PM
Sounds good.  I too am curious about Doc's original question since I seem to come across a number of instruments where the reeds (or reed blocks) are in real bad shape.  I've searched the web a little bit but haven't really seen a good site where reed blocks are presented in different sizes and tunings for sale.  Any suggestions?  Sorry if this has been answered before and thank you, Ben
Title: Re: Convert Hohner A/D to G/C?
Post by: Andy Simpson on December 23, 2010, 01:28:18 PM
  Any suggestions? 

Stop looking because you're not going to find one.  ;D

I'm pretty sure Hohner sell replacement reedblocks through their spares department. Nobody else offers replacement blocks for their instruments as far as I'm aware, certainly not for retail.

Aaro Luukinen offers custom made reedblocks and I imagine somewhere like the Button Box might do it as well but they'd be made to order and not cheap.
Title: Re: Convert Hohner A/D to G/C?
Post by: waldoB on December 23, 2010, 02:37:08 PM
I have a similar problem. My 9 ton Hillyard is very dry but..... I recently changed a B/C Serenellini to D/G with a TAM Cagnoni reedset from Charlie Marshall. Not too expensive, the result is really tuneful ringing small box with top class action to travel with that I would not like to lose, but could be replaced.
Title: Re: Convert Hohner A/D to G/C?
Post by: docEdock on December 23, 2010, 04:17:05 PM
When I saw how easy it was to remove the reed block from my Hohner I thought that ordering another in a different key would be cake.

Let's see, Hohner has made about a gazillion boxes over the years and yet no one is the Hohner junkyard? I can online order a tea cup for Aunt Millie's totally obscure china pattern from replacementslimited and it arrives tomorrow. How can this Hohner gap exist? Is it because the MAD melodeonistas have hoarded all the stock?

I seem to recall a mention of tuning in situ. Perhaps that's what prevents a market from developing. My replacement G/C blocks wouldn't be G/C in the box? You who really know, why?
Title: Re: Convert Hohner A/D to G/C?
Post by: Theo on December 23, 2010, 04:46:14 PM
Hohner do sell replacement reedblocks, but there are two slight problems.  First the hold down arrangement is different so a little woodwork will be required,  second the gasket is fitted to the reedblock on older boxes, and to the baseboard on current production, again fixable with a little time and effort.

Oh and there is a third reason - the price.  UK retail is about £300.
Title: Re: Convert Hohner A/D to G/C?
Post by: docEdock on December 23, 2010, 05:50:26 PM
I laughed at that sly,
Oh and there is a third reason - the price.  UK retail is about £300.
Let's see now, £300 in $USD is OMG. Clearly my flea market find is considerably less than the sum of its parts.

Special offer!!! Hohner A/D reed blocks at half off. But wait, place your order today and also receive a free keyboard, grill, right side , bellows, left side, straps, and . . .

Not really, but why not?
Title: Re: Convert Hohner A/D to G/C?
Post by: Rob2Hook on December 23, 2010, 06:41:25 PM
I have a similar problem. My 9 ton Hillyard is very dry but.....
it wouldn't cost a penny to make it wetter!

Has a lot in common with a Hohner - built to a common sense standard rather than luxury spec.  Pity the yard went under, though.

Rob.
Title: Re: Convert Hohner A/D to G/C?
Post by: Gary P Chapin on December 31, 2010, 11:22:44 PM
I laughed at that sly,
Oh and there is a third reason - the price.  UK retail is about £300.
Special offer!!! Hohner A/D reed blocks at half off. But wait, place your order today and also receive a free keyboard, grill, right side , bellows, left side, straps, and . . .

Not really, but why not?
Depends on what you think of the other aspects of the box:  tone and touch.  I started on an A/D box, playing French stuff, and it was lovely.  It was an especially sweet Pokerwork, but I wouldn't have traded it for anything.  When I did buy my G/C, I bought it in addition to; not instead of.  Oh, and the initial premise of your OP is not entirely wrong.  People do refer to the favorably lower sound of the G/C for French music, but that's usually in comparison to the D/G which is considerably higher than the G/C.  (The G on the G/C and the G on the D/G are a full octave apart.)  The difference is such that the G/C is typically played in the upper register, and the D/G in the lower register, which probably effects how tunes are written.

So you're not entirely crazy, it's just that the difference between a G/C and A/D is just no that much.  The real thing is if you're playing with others.  When I went to Alsace, I was in a room with 29 other diatonic players:  every one of them a G/C.
Title: Re: Convert Hohner A/D to G/C?
Post by: docEdock on January 02, 2011, 01:10:19 AM
Thanks for sorting out my misunderstanding of high, lower, and lowest. I had read about the D/G but didn't think about the implications of which letter comes first. My box's A/D tuning was pure happenstance. For a long time I had no idea how it was tuned, then I thought it was D/A based on using an electronic tuner to measure the 3rd button on inner and outer row, and only recently realized that the A/D was stamped on the bottom of the keyboard. Having recently seen the insides, where A D is stamped all over the reed blocks, I'm thinking it might actually be an A/D, unless someone knows better.

I solved the problem exactly as you suggest. I recently bought a couple of C/G's: one with low notes and the other with accidentals. Well, really, trying to decide between the two was excessively painful, like picking out just one puppy at the shelter. So, I thought, why not have a shelf of the things? MAD, I suppose.

Now I'm looking forward to deciding which one is my favorite. It gets to stay home, while my least favorite gets to go to sea, a cruel and unusual punishment for a melodeon. Look for it on ebay in a couple of years. The one with the rust pitted grill. Yikes.
SimplePortal 2.3.5 © 2008-2012, SimplePortal