Melodeon.net Forums

Discussions => Instrument Design, Construction and Repair => Topic started by: Telemorris on January 04, 2011, 09:08:43 PM

Title: Making a new reed block bottom plate.
Post by: Telemorris on January 04, 2011, 09:08:43 PM
I need to replace the bottom plate on one of the bass side reed blocks. It has cupped across the short dimension.

Making a new piece with felt attached to one side if easy. Has anyone here made a new plate and done the drilling of the holes through both wood and felt? I'm wondering what kind of drill bit is the best for creating a clean hole through both wood and felt? Is a Forstner bit the right thing to use? I don't think Hohner could have used Forstner bits early last century since I think the Forstner bit is a relatively new design though I could be way off on that one.
Title: Re: Making a new reed block bottom plate.
Post by: strad on January 04, 2011, 10:34:19 PM
I would think clamping the wood/felt to a sacrificial piece of wood woul do the trick - obviously with the felt as the jam in the sandwich.

Nigel
Title: Re: Making a new reed block bottom plate.
Post by: Telemorris on January 04, 2011, 10:46:21 PM
Clamping the felt as the "jam" between the plate and another board makes sense. I was planning to do that already. I'm just wondering which kind of drill bit design to use. Maybe standard drill bits (what I have) are fine.
Title: Re: Making a new reed block bottom plate.
Post by: Andy Simpson on January 04, 2011, 10:57:35 PM
Firstly, felt isn't a terribly good gasket material and everyone now uses either soft leather or neoprene. Secondly, putting the gasket on the reedblock isn't done anymore, modern Hohners and every other make of accordion I've seen have the gasket glued to the baseboard with nothing on the reedblock.

How much has it cupped anyway?, it would have to be an awful lot to warrant rebuilding IMO. I'd be surprised if it couldn't just be sanded out reasonably flat and work perfectly well with a gasket of adequate thickness on the baseboard.

As for drill bits, why not try it on scrap with whatever it is you have to hand?. A Forstner bit, (invented in the 1870s), would obviously get the cleanest cut but brad point bits would be adequate, a bit faster and cheaper.
Title: Re: Making a new reed block bottom plate.
Post by: acctech on January 04, 2011, 11:30:14 PM
Unless there is some other damage, the easiest solution is to sand the block flat with 120 grit paper on a hard flat surface. This is a fairly routine method for this problem. It may be necessary to shim the block back tight.
Title: Re: Making a new reed block bottom plate.
Post by: Theo on January 04, 2011, 11:51:13 PM
BUt if that does not work, drill the wood first start with a pilot hole of 1 to 2mm, then drill halfway from each side to avoid any splintering.  I forstner bit would be good, but any bit with a cutting lip would be equally effective.  Glue the gasket material on afterwards (I agree with not felt)  and when the glue is cured cut out the vents with a scalpel. 
Title: Re: Making a new reed block bottom plate.
Post by: Telemorris on January 05, 2011, 12:32:06 AM
Firstly, felt isn't a terribly good gasket material and everyone now uses either soft leather or neoprene. Secondly, putting the gasket on the reedblock isn't done anymore, modern Hohners and every other make of accordion I've seen have the gasket glued to the baseboard with nothing on the reedblock.

How much has it cupped anyway?, it would have to be an awful lot to warrant rebuilding IMO. I'd be surprised if it couldn't just be sanded out reasonably flat and work perfectly well with a gasket of adequate thickness on the baseboard.

As for drill bits, why not try it on scrap with whatever it is you have to hand?. A Forstner bit, (invented in the 1870s), would obviously get the cleanest cut but brad point bits would be adequate, a bit faster and cheaper.

Thanks for all the advice. I'll take a look at the cupping when I get home tonight. If memory serves, the cupping is fairly pronounced. Sanding would leave little wood.

As for the use of leather as a gasket: I'm in the process of rebuilding a Presswood Pokerwork. If I need to take the old felt off the bottom of one of the reed blocks, should I pull it off of the other and glue leather over the matching section of the baseplate/fondo? What thickness and type of leather should I use? Would chamois be acceptable (I have some) or should I use something different?
Title: Re: Making a new reed block bottom plate.
Post by: Theo on January 05, 2011, 09:00:33 AM
I would leave the gasket material where it is,  there is no great advantage in having on the baseboard. 
As for material, chamois could be ok if you can select a piece with an even thickness, the chamois sold for washing cars can be very patch in thickness, but good quality stuff would be ok.  Other leather would have to be similar thickness to the original and soft in texture.  Italian makers use a woven synthetic material with a velvet pile on one side.  Contact me by email if you want me to send you some.  Its main advantage in my experience is that it is much easier to cut and trim than soft leather.
Title: Re: Making a new reed block bottom plate.
Post by: Telemorris on January 05, 2011, 07:33:02 PM
Other leather would have to be similar thickness to the original and soft in texture.  

There's enough curvature in the bottom plate that I'll be removing two to three mm of wood to get the bottom plate flat. I'll need to make up the difference in thickness with the felt/leather/fabric somehow. Maybe I'll need to use some of the felt and leather for pallet facing from CGM to make that work. I am also interested in your Italian fabric. I've sent you an email about that separately. Thanks for the offer Theo.
Title: Re: Making a new reed block bottom plate.
Post by: rees on January 05, 2011, 08:28:29 PM
You don't need to rebuild the thickness that you have removed. Use a single sheet of gasket, fit the reedblocks and then adjust the fasteners that hold the reedblocks in place by shimming with a piece of wood or hard leather.
Title: Re: Making a new reed block bottom plate.
Post by: Telemorris on January 05, 2011, 09:00:17 PM
You don't need to rebuild the thickness that you have removed. Use a single sheet of gasket, fit the reedblocks and then adjust the fasteners that hold the reedblocks in place by shimming with a piece of wood or hard leather.

Thank you very much Rees!

I should have thought of that myself. So simple it could have bitten me but that's why I ask these questions.
Title: Re: Making a new reed block bottom plate.
Post by: rees on January 05, 2011, 09:33:23 PM
simple is good  (:)
SimplePortal 2.3.5 © 2008-2012, SimplePortal