Melodeon.net Forums
Discussions => Teaching and Learning => Topic started by: Chris Brimley on January 05, 2011, 09:48:50 AM
-
Interesting, I mused recently, how few postings of songs there have been on melnet. Almost all of us seem to use the box as a melody instrument, rather than an accompaniser. Yet, there are many very examples of really successful songs out there - JK, Yves Lambert, (and more locally to me Colin Cater and Simon Ritchie), spring to mind.
I've tried recently to sing a bit with the box, partly because it was a challenge outside my comfort zone - http://www.onmvoice.com/play.php?a=36888 - but I have to say it wasn't easy - I find it difficult to sing confidently at the same time as playing LH and row-crossing RH successfully. And when I've tried to do it in front of an audience, it usually just collapses into wrong chords, wrong fingering and woddled murds. It's as if the concentration you need to get it all together is the very thing that is most difficult to achieve in front of people. The rehearsal time you need to spend on it seems to be a whole order of magnitude greater than just playing a tune. And each different verse is a new challenge.
Do any others experience this, and have any thoughts?
-
I'm not qualified to comment on self accompanyment as my singing voice is such that I was told to mime in the school choir!. However I regularly accompany both solo & quartets of singers and find that the way they prefer me to do it is mostly treble only. on the DG I do this mainly on the row as it gives ready scope for thickening up the proceedings with assortedright hand chords & also of adding a agentle rhythm by way of using a spare finger and/or gently pulsing the bellows. on the BCC# I sometimess use only a single voice for the first time through adding a little bit more perhaps for the chorus& using both right hand chords & gentle 'one finger at a time' bass. It all depends on the type of song & the sturdiness or otherwise of the singers modus operandi!
I think it was Jack Emblow, the very well respected professional accordionist who accompanied many singers on radio etc, who said something on the lines of - never forget that the singer is the artist and you are the accompanyist'.
I haave found that advice useful
george
-
Singing while playing an instrument is a challenge for the brains. Some people can only sing the notes they are playing, for others the instrument playing becomes 'automatic' while singing. I guess it's a skill to acquire, getting a balance between the singing and the playing of the instrument, which accompanies the singing, with the occasional bridge where the instrument takes precedence. Watch artists like Emmanuel Pariselle, and observe how he does it.
-
I sometimes sing and play, but have reservations about it. For one thing, the key isn't always suitable, so some songs that would suit a melodeon accompaniment just don't get one. For another, I think singing is so important that I like to give it all my attention.
But there are times when it's a useful thing to be able to play and sing. It's handy at pub sessions where the addition of an instrument gives the song more presence, and also makes it easier, in terms of keys and rhythm, for other musicians to join in (if you don't mind that). I also do it sometimes in a club floorspot, as I think it's probably more interesting than always singing unaccompanied.
I don't attempt anything veyr complicated, though. The melodeon is just an accompaniment, and I tend to do mostly chords with both hands, with the odd little arpeggio or few bars of melody between verses. If I attempted anything fancier, the singing would suffer.
One nice thing to be able to do is to segue into a dance tune at the end of a song. I haven't done this yet, but maybe in will be one of my "Boxolutions" for 2011.
-
I can do it, but my voice isn't loud enough to be heard over the noise my Hohners make!
-
being able to play the quietly & with feeling is , to me,a prerequisite to song accompanyment (either self or other) even on a hohner!
george ;)
-
This has always been a goal for me. I look at what Robin Williamson does with the harp ... the singing and storytelling ... and think, why can't that be done with the box. My teacher, Sylvain Piron, plays and sings, even dance tunes, WHILE DANCING!!! So, this is a heartfelt New Year's Resolution for me, every year.
I don't have a great voice, but I can sing while playing piano or guitar (tenor guitar, really). But playing the box and singing has eluded me. I was going to suggest that, for one theme of the month we might do songs.
-
Playing and Dancing is a lot easier than playing and singing. And not only because I am a terrible singer :P I can play and sing as long as I am singing what my RH is doing, but I can't play anything else.
-
Cracked it about 5 years ago after years of failure. Essentially it came free with the extra row. The trick is not to play tune against yourself (dull anyway?) but to treat the box as a guitar and play a series of chords. In our case the best way to play these 'sensitively'/'with feeling' is on the right end
Helps to work a 3-chord trick at least in several keys and then pick one to suit your range. For G I'd hope to use D(push or pull, helping with air control), C and of course G. If my bellows are too close for a G - substitute Em, or simply use Em when it sounds nice ;)
Once that's producing the desired effect - work on anything flash. My 'little flourishes' are expressed on a chord base. Also or neat ways to link chords based on a bellows change same button (we do it all the time). Successive chords with common notes where you simply move one or 2 fingers flow particularly well.
Most such decorations are in the nature of things across the rows. In particular - following a line up an down a row push/pull is frankly a real bugger to sing against - though John K can do it!
I once asked Nic Jones how he managed to do such clever guitar, and sing at the same time. He smiled and told me to watch more carefully - "the flash stuff was between the phases of the song". Actually he's never managed to convince me of this in his own music, but it was good advice.
Lester has made a list of D/G right end chords here (http://forum.melodeon.net/index.php/page,chords.html) and my own little MSexcel scale finder (http://forum.melodeon.net/index.php/topic,5248.0.html) will also find chords (needs MSoffice). However it's almost better to seek them by ear. In particular I feel 'sus' chords have the right degree of soft tension against song and tend to lie well under the fingers - but that's a matter of own style and a modal approach.
.. so keep it really simple as you sing, and do your melodeonic things in the gaps :|glug
-
Some good thoughts there, Chris, thanks - and to all the others.
My original posting was intended to be quite a specific problem, how to learn to do everything at once, and I wondered if others had any insights on this. What I find is that although in practice the whole thing seems to work OK, it's for some reason difficult to repeat in front of an audience, because there's just too much for the poor old brain to do all at once, and with the extra performance thing on top, it can easily all go horribly wrong. I've certainly tried the 'play tricky fill-ins only' approach, but then simply remembering which fill-in to play next detracts from my singing so much that I get lost. When playing tunes, somehow overdrive kicks in, and they just come out, but singing seems for me to overload the brain cells. I don't seem to have the same problem with guitar, although I often play quite complicated accompaniments. I think this may be because chordshapes on a guitar give you a sort of underlying structure to the accompaniment which is easily learnable, whereas with the box, I haven't learnt 'chordshapes' in quite the same way. Maybe I should - Chris, is that your approach? However, I have to say that just playing chords to accompany a song isn't really what I want to do - the counterpoint melody is what I'm aiming at.
-
with the box, I haven't learnt 'chordshapes' in quite the same way. Maybe I should - Chris, is that your approach?
Yup. You can then 'work towards' counterpoint (but in my case that'd need 2 brains) ???
-
My original posting was intended to be quite a specific problem, how to learn to do everything at once
Learn the separate parts thoroughly first for a start, but then expect to work hard all over again (as if starting from scratch) on combining the two. Especially if you've not done that whole process before.
I don't sing much, but occasionally do bits of chorus while accompanying Mary. I sometimes find myself playing the tune and singing a harmony, and the only way this works is to be able to do at least one and preferably both parts completely automatically. In other words rely on "muscle memory" (which is really some subconscious part of the brain, of course).
It's one of those things like playing the piano with two hands which is completely brain scrambling the first time you try it, but as time goes on it gets easier, not just to play the piece you've practised, but to learn new pieces too.
Good advice about keeping the accompaniment simple. I don't always, but then I'm not singing; if I was, I'd probably play something much simpler. You can get away with very simple stuff when accompanying a song.
Having said that, listen to some of what John Kirkpatrick does. I think it was hearing him singing The Gravedigger's Song with concertina in two-part canon that made me realize what was possible if you tried. Or the amazing concertina accompaniment for his version of Old Man Jones...
-
Yes, I can only think that JK must have retrofitted a quad core CPU somewhere in his head! He makes it seem so simple, yet he must have practiced each song for months before playing to an audience. I think you're probably right about the automatic music functioning, Anahata, and I tend to use that idea too, but I have also found that this can confuse the memory when you add in the singing bit, and I've wondered whether it may be easier in the long run to learn the whole thing together, very slowly.
-
See http://forum.melodeon.net/index.php/topic,5715.msg72755.html#msg72755 :Ph
[edit x 2]
| C | E7* | A7 | A7(b9) | *(I don't have E chord - use Bdim)
| Dm | A7 | Dm | A7 | (again - could slip a Bb into the 7 chord)
| F | F7 | C | A7 | (F chords work as writ- again I like Fdim)
| D7 | D7 | G7 (or GAlt) | C | (.. resolve back to C)
-
Brilliant Chris - that won't have been easy!
-
Okay, Chris, you've inspired me. I just posted this in Theme of the Month -- bum notes and all. Doing voice and box was MUCH more complicated than just playing tunes! I did what I could. There are some double stops and such, but none of these "chord shapes" of which you speak.
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=mPGSBkpz84E
-
Superb - and also perhaps the first time I've inspired anyone ;) It got better and better as you warmed up.
May I offer that you are actually doing more than I suggest above. You commonly strike a chord and then rock the bellows (attempting tune?). You could rest that left arm more - simply strike your chord, hold and sing across it.
Less is cool in singing (and only died in the wool jazzers do 2 chords per bar) :|glug C
-
Superb - and also perhaps the first time I've inspired anyone ;) It got better and better as you warmed up.
Thank you! By the time of this recording, I'd been playing and singing for about an hour. Any "warmed up" I might have had evaporated the moment I pressed the record button.
May I offer that you are actually doing more than I suggest above. You commonly strike a chord and then rock the bellows (attempting tune?). You could rest that left arm more - simply strike your chord, hold and sing across it.
Yes, that is me playing the tune. I found it preternaturally difficult to play something different while singing the melody. Even something like "hold down the buttons" just flummoxed me. Who can say what devilment might have occurred if I actually tried something rhythmically interesting. That's what practice is for, I guess.
Less is cool in singing (and only died in the wool jazzers do 2 chords per bar) :|glug C
Less is cool. I'm going with that as a motto.
-
I've been singing and acc myself with a PA box as far back as I care to remember, but try it with a diatonic box and all my expertise goes out the window. The only thing I can think of that's more difficult is singing whilst playing violin, which is equally mind numbing.
Do any of you more 'mature' members remember the guy (music hall era I guess) who you'st to hum one tune whilst whistling another? Was it Ronnie Ronald? Part of his patter was to instruct the audience on how to achieve this trick. "I whistle one tune for twenty years, then I hum another tune for twenty years, then I spend another twenty putting them together." I bet he played melodeon as well. :D
-
I also experience difficulties whenever I've attempted singing while playing, though accompanying others singing's not a prob.
The best I can manage is perhaps the odd snatch of chorus 'til me fingers go wobbly.
I can manage playing & singing with guitar, chord organ ok though.
There's a banjo player who comes our seshes who can't sing while playing in the usual sense, but has developed a technique all his own.
His greatest hit is 'Drunken Sailor'
He plays a line, stops, sings the line, stops
Plays the next line, stops, sings the line, stops & so on.
I've never tried this with melodeon but.....?
-
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=mPGSBkpz84E
This video is currently marked as private
-
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=mPGSBkpz84E
This video is currently marked as private
Okay, think I fixed it.
-
Okay, think I fixed it.
Apparently not...
-
Okay, think I fixed it.
Apparently not...
Argh. How about now?
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=mPGSBkpz84E
-
Here's my only (thus far) attempt at singing with melodeon.
http://www.onmvoice.com/play.php?a=50733
The song is called The Lakes of Cold Fen (from an excellent book by Mary Humphreys - http://www.maryhumphreys.co.uk/book.php) and was recorded at the finals of the New Roots competition. I'm once again playing my beloved Bb/Eb Erika. I should probably point out that I was playing through a PA system, so the balance of voice and box is a bit better than it would be without.
-
And absolutely brilliant it is too! Even better live. Do you have video? You should put it up on YouTube, for people like me who have never really got into Onmvoice.
-
I do, but it takes ages to upload (the audio is that from the video). Once I have a few hours where the computer isn't going to go into hibernation, I'll upload it.
-
I do, but it takes ages to upload (the audio is that from the video). Once I have a few hours where the computer isn't going to go into hibernation, I'll upload it.
Aye, it took *some time*, several attempts and some quite strong language before my computer would let me upload mine.
-
I think you have done a great job on the song Ollie.
Many thanks for choosing it and for being so diligent in giving the correct sources.
You deserve to get lots of good gigs from being a participant in this very worthwhile competition.
-
...and here's a video of Mary herself singing a very topical and local song - The Cambridge May Garland Song, which we'll no doubt be doing tomorrow with the Northstow Mummers to celebrate May Day. Recorded and uploaded just tonight:
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=2QbB3XOW9RM
This is a very rare example of Mary playing melodeon, which she learnt to do to teach the song to some children in a school in Suffolk last week. It also shows how you can make quite a little accompaniment go a long way, as long as you're on top of the song itself.
PS I thought YouTube uploads were a pain too, but it's not as bad as some of you seem to be finding - this one took about 15 minutes and the file size is 36MB. Despite Fordham being out in the sticks, our house is not all that far from the nearest telephone exchange so our broadband speeds are quite good.
-
What a brilliant example of how to combine singing and playing the box! I love it when a really skilled person makes something like this look simple (:)
-
PS I thought YouTube uploads were a pain too, but it's not as bad as some of you seem to be finding - this one took about 15 minutes and the file size is 36MB. Despite Fordham being out in the sticks, our house is not all that far from the nearest telephone exchange so our broadband speeds are quite good.
It all depends on the size and the format. With my camera, I record it fairly low quality and then publish through Windows Live Movie Maker. This doesn't take too long. The ones that I did with New Roots were higher quality than what I normally record and were presented to me as quicktime files. For some reason, Windows Live Movie Maker didn't like them, but Windows Movie Maker did, so I used that instead. It's also easier to do titles and transitions on that. Unfortunately it would crash every time I tried to publish. There are three different buttons that you can press to publish and only one of them would work at any one time, every other time it would crash and there seemed to be no pattern to it whatsoever. I tried saving the file and opening it in Live, but the titles got stretched. Good old Vista.
So yes, not as straightforward as I might have liked. And it's all because I wanted to put a title and the New Roots logo at the beginning of each one :(
-
And it's all because I wanted to put a title and the New Roots logo at the beginning of each one :(
Ah yes - that's a sophistication I haven't tried yet...
-
And it's all because I wanted to put a title and the New Roots logo at the beginning of each one :(
Ah yes - that's a sophistication I haven't tried yet...
It's probably perfectly straightforward if you're doing it on a decent piece of software, but not worth it if you're using any of Microsoft's miserable offerings imo.
-
This is a very rare example of Mary playing melodeon, which she learnt to do to teach the song to some children in a school in Suffolk last week. It also shows how you can make quite a little accompaniment go a long way, as long as you're on top of the song itself.
Rare footage indeed (I couldn't believe she didn't play one though)! Looking through it twice ... well firstly a lovely, simple powerfully delivered English ditty. More technically I'd say Mary gets what I'd call 'melodeon playing' over quite early and then sings over basses, with a few dotted-in notes that stops this becoming too solid.
Anahata's final sentence above perhaps says it all. I think the learning point may be that this is a song and that's where the listener's focus goes. I barely perceived the simplification until I went through the second time. Being one of the best current interpreter of English British (whoops!) singing is an advantage we don't all share - but there's a very workable method in play.
btw Long, long ago I asked Nic Jones how he could do such clever guitar and sing all at once. He told me to listen more carefully - the 'flash' was all between the verse. So maybe we have a more general principle?
-
Just to be clear (which I wasn't earlier) , Mary has been playing the one-row (mostly in private) for a while. What she hadn't done before was learnt a song to perform with melodeon in public, until this school gig came up...
-
I can't play and sing....or even play and talk for that matter.
I find that when I use a bellows pull, my lungs try to suck in air and it all goes pear shaped.
I can tap my head and rub my tummy at the same time, but playing and singing defeats me.
Am I alone?