Melodeon.net Forums

Discussions => Other Free Reed Instruments => Topic started by: nemethmik on January 06, 2011, 06:16:49 PM

Title: Roland FR-1
Post by: nemethmik on January 06, 2011, 06:16:49 PM
I've read a couple of posts about Roland FR-1 electronic accordion, and went to a Roland show rom this afternoon. I tried the model FR-1b: What a disappointment!  :'( It took me only 10 minutes to decide that it's a complete waste of money. The whole instrument was made of plastic of the lowest quality. The buttons were loose and of ridiculously crafted. The bellows were made of cheap paper. The whole instrument looked like a Chinese toy instrument. The sound was horrific. It cannot even be used as practice instrument becase the bellows handling is so much different from a real accordion.
In a word, before buying a Roland (or possibly any) electric accordion, visit a show-room and make sure this is really what you want.
For the price of an FR-1 you can buy high quality Italian accordions off ebay germany.
Title: Re: Roland FR-1
Post by: Quebecois on January 06, 2011, 07:45:16 PM
Well, look at the specs on the Roland web site:
"An ultra-light button-type V-Accordion for students, beginners and keyboard players!"

Definitely not a "pro-level" instrument like the FR-7 series.
Title: Re: Roland FR-1
Post by: HallelujahAl on January 06, 2011, 09:23:25 PM
Well I have an FR-1 and although I'm definitely not in the 'pro' spectrum, I'm thoroughly delighted with my instrument - albeit I have the Piano key version. It's a superb instrument, the bellows are completely adjustable so I find that I can indeed have realistic bellows practise - it is in fact not one but many accordions rolled into one, as well as giving me MIDI functions as well.

Does it look like a 'chinese toy instrument' - not too my eyes, and it only cost me £700 - I would suggest that there is nowhere on this planet that one could get a state-of-the-art Italian built (YES - the FR-1 is made in Italy!) accordion for anything like the cost of an FR-1.

So is it 'a complete waste of money'? I don't think so, it has enabled me to get all the accordion sounds and settings that I want and more, enables me to lead worship on it in a large church building by simply plugging it into the Public Address system. And the great advantage is that I can practise silently using headphones at any time of the day or night and not disturb either my family or (perhaps more importantly) my neighbours!

So please tell me where one can buy a new high quality Italian accordion from for around the £700 mark? The sky is a completely different colour in my world I'm afraid! I love my FR-1 and have no hesitation in recommending it. Obviously if I had enough money I'd go for the FR-7X PA - but I'm a poor man, so it ain't ever going to happen  ;D
AL
Title: Re: Roland FR-1
Post by: GbH on January 06, 2011, 10:45:00 PM
I have an FR-3, which I puchased just a few months before getting the melodeon bug  ::).  Thus, it's not really been used as much as it deserves.  I really wish I'd got the button model, or just waited for a few more months...

Anyhow, to me, there's no point in comparing them with accoustic instruments - they're their own thing and seem best treated as such.  The ultimate quality of the voices seems to depend a lot on the way it's amplified and also whether they're played sympathetically.  I've never noticed anything bad about the build quality, but I guess it is a different model to the one mentioned.  I'd certainly agree about trying one before buying, preferably over an extended period, so that the novelty/shock has had a chance to wear off.

All in all, I still find in fun to play with - it invariably leaves me with a silly grin.  But it's a shame that, as things have turned out, it's not really what I really needed.
Title: Re: Roland FR-1
Post by: HallelujahAl on January 07, 2011, 09:31:12 AM
The FR-3 is according to the reports that I have a great box and capable of a great deal more than the it's smaller sibling -btw GbH I'd love to have gone for the FR-3 simply because of the built in speakers which would free me up from using either and amp or headphones. I just found that the FR-1 sat more kindly within my budget so took the opportunity to go for that. My experience has been nothing but positive with the Roland PA although, as GbH says, it's a completely different kind of instrument and not worth trying to compare with a standard acoustic instrument. Horses for course, apples and pears etc...
AL
Title: Re: Roland FR-1
Post by: nemethmik on January 07, 2011, 09:44:42 AM
it's a completely different kind of instrument and not worth trying to compare with a standard acoustic instrument
Basically, this what I wanted to write in the original post. Thank You for your corrections and comments.
Title: Re: Roland FR-1
Post by: GbH on January 10, 2011, 06:17:59 PM
The FR-3 is according to the reports that I have a great box and capable of a great deal more than the it's smaller sibling -btw GbH I'd love to have gone for the FR-3 simply because of the built in speakers which would free me up from using either and amp or headphones.

Al - the speakers are something of a mixed blessing.  Yes, they're useful to have, but add a significant weight and don't sound as good as when playing through an external amp.  I can see why they've produced similar models without them.
Title: Re: Roland FR-1
Post by: Steve C. on January 11, 2011, 01:26:34 AM
Miklos' comment does remind me of my first reaction to playing a Nova II 48 bass i.e "what a bunch of rattly plastic junk."

But after you get over it, it is not a bad instrument for what it is.

On these button chromatics, I think that the treble almost has to have some rattly slack in it, as the rows are linked with each other, by design (I think).
Title: Re: Roland FR-1
Post by: Pushpull on January 11, 2011, 03:13:20 PM
Miklos' comment does remind me of my first reaction to playing a Nova II 48 bass i.e "what a bunch of rattly plastic junk."

But after you get over it, it is not a bad instrument for what it is.

On these button chromatics, I think that the treble almost has to have some rattly slack in it, as the rows are linked with each other, by design (I think).
Some time ago (a couple of years I think), I had a Maugein on loan - rather like this one (albeit in a much prettier purple):

(http://accordeon-occasion.fr/cat_Accordeons%20Chromatiques%2080%20Basses/art_maugein_80_Export/image1.jpg)

There was certainly nothing rattly about it. It was impressively robust and the buttons had a very solid feel (more so than even the Piginis I had a look at). I was very tempted to buy it but thought at the time it wouldn't get the attention it required/deserved. I'm beginning to think again - though I have a feeling I would like to go the whole hog and try free bass.
Title: Re: Roland FR-1
Post by: HallelujahAl on January 11, 2011, 04:00:39 PM
Quote
I have a feeling I would like to go the whole hog and try free bass.
I also have a freebass setting on my little FR-1, s'great!
AL
Title: Re: Roland FR-1
Post by: Pushpull on January 11, 2011, 04:22:26 PM
Quote
I have a feeling I would like to go the whole hog and try free bass.
I also have a freebass setting on my little FR-1, s'great!
AL
Oh. I knew the bigger ones had free bass but looking at the online blurb for the FR-1 it "suggested" stradella only. Hmm. Food for thought. I wonder what it would sound like through my Fender Champ?
Title: Re: Roland FR-1
Post by: HallelujahAl on January 11, 2011, 04:25:47 PM
Yes, there's been a software update and now the freebass is also available on the FR-1.
Sounds great through my amps - I intend putting it my church's PA speaker system at the weekend... >:E
AL
Title: Re: Roland FR-1
Post by: Steve C. on January 11, 2011, 08:57:39 PM
Al, what we really want to hear about:

How are the drum settings?   >:E
Title: Re: Roland FR-1
Post by: HallelujahAl on January 12, 2011, 10:46:00 AM
Quote
Al, what we really want to hear about:

How are the drum settings?
Good fun actually, though I'm still slowly finding my way around them. Essentially what I've found is that I can either have them set so that they operate in conjunction with my bass and chord sounds on the left hand side or I can play a drum set separately with the left hand bass buttons. Either way is fun - though not, from my perspective, terribly useful. I've still much more to work out and my knowledge is still terribly limited (I need time, time, time...!).
AL
Title: Re: Roland FR-1
Post by: Theo on January 12, 2011, 10:48:37 AM
I intend putting it my church's PA speaker system at the weekend... >:E
AL

So that would effectively give you a church organ with a portable console.
Title: Re: Roland FR-1
Post by: HallelujahAl on January 12, 2011, 10:53:33 AM
Quote
So that would effectively give you a church organ with a portable console.
Yes, I'm quite looking forward to it - thankfully my congregation are a very tolerant bunch (and some are also a little bit deaf which probably helps  ;))

My next test is to put the sound through an effects pedal  >:E
Title: Re: Roland FR-1
Post by: nemethmik on January 12, 2011, 11:10:30 AM
Quote
So that would effectively give you a church organ with a portable console.
Yes, I'm quite looking forward to it
Al, Aren't you missing the haunting acoustic sound, the mesmerazing vibration (of the bass reeds) of your real accordions? You have an excellent 3-row 3-reed Hohner, that must sound excellent. Isn't the best acoustic sound that we all are seeking during our long way in accordion world?
Title: Re: Roland FR-1
Post by: Steve C. on January 12, 2011, 01:40:11 PM
Miklos, I do generally agree, but there is room for "non-acoustic" sound too.  Why does (almost) everyone want a Streb on the shelf?
And then there is the (almost) unmentionable:
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=TcbuXXFSXtU&feature=related
 >:E
Title: Re: Roland FR-1
Post by: oggiesnr on January 12, 2011, 02:12:54 PM

...  Why does (almost) everyone want a Streb on the shelf? ...


... because that's the best play for one? >:E

Steve
Title: Re: Roland FR-1
Post by: HallelujahAl on January 12, 2011, 04:37:01 PM
Quote
Al, Aren't you missing the haunting acoustic sound, the mesmerazing vibration (of the bass reeds) of your real accordions?
Well, my Roland IS a real accordion too as far as I'm concerned, it's not just an inverted keyboard. I do love the shimmering sound of my 3 voice Hohner; but I also love some of the great sets available from the FR-1 (like the almost infintely adjustable musette/tremolo option etc). I confess that I use it very much as the box I play for Scottish tunes in particular as I'm able to set the musette tuning very wide. But it is also bringing out the jaaaazman in me  ;D as I've discovered some really cool vibe setting in the RH along with string bass fundamental notes and keyboard chords for the LH  >:E
I've recently spent some time with Harry Hussey jamming, and he's really inspired me to move into new directions musically, and the FR-1 is currently helping me get there.
AL
Title: Re: Roland FR-1
Post by: nemethmik on January 12, 2011, 07:04:00 PM
And then there is the (almost) unmentionable:
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=TcbuXXFSXtU&feature=related
Exectly this was the sound I heared in the Roland show-room, when I tried FR-1 and got terribly disappointed  :(
 
Title: Re: Roland FR-1
Post by: waldoB on January 13, 2011, 09:30:15 AM
If Roland made the button version with flat enclosed style treble action, switchable from quint ( quad ? ) keys to British Chromatic keys and Continental Chromatic that would be a really useful piece of kit. With four rows you could have French Continental and a really useful B,C,C#,D, all with easy stradella basses that you only have to learn once. And it would light enough to actually be playable.
Title: Re: Roland FR-1
Post by: HallelujahAl on January 13, 2011, 09:41:42 AM
Would be a relatively easy software upgrade for them I'd have thought to re-map the key system which would give CBA, British Chromatic, Quint/Quad options - but who'd want it?
AL
Title: Re: Roland FR-1
Post by: waldoB on January 13, 2011, 01:08:49 PM
Perhaps one well known Hero Member might like to rationalise their huge pile of boxes and make one long sufferer's day. It would equate to the impossible, every box finished and working at the same time
Title: Re: Roland FR-1
Post by: Martin J on January 14, 2011, 01:02:18 AM
Exectly this was the sound I heared in the Roland show-room, when I tried FR-1 and got terribly disappointed  :(
Hi Miklos

There has been another thread regarding midi boxes where I gave my opinion.  I think you are always going to be disappointed if you think an electronic box is going to be a melodeon.  I feel they should be regarded as a midi gateway to sounds you can't get on a 'proper' box.  Brilliant in bands and for accompaniments but solo melodeon pieces are best on a real box.  Just my view.  As I don't have a midi box yet (ordered by not yet received) I wonder how current owners view their midi boxes?
Title: Re: Roland FR-1
Post by: Owen Woods on January 16, 2011, 03:30:40 PM
Perhaps one well known Hero Member might like to rationalise their huge pile of boxes and make one long sufferer's day. It would equate to the impossible, every box finished and working at the same time

Was this directed at me? ???
Title: Re: Roland FR-1
Post by: Theo on January 16, 2011, 04:39:04 PM
Was this directed at me? ???

You are one among many.  ;)
Title: Re: Roland FR-1
Post by: HallelujahAl on January 16, 2011, 06:56:52 PM
Quote
Was this directed at me?  ???
Nah! I thought it was me  ;D
Title: Re: Roland FR-1
Post by: Andrel on January 16, 2011, 07:09:30 PM
How about the FR-18 ? Wouldn't mind trying one myself...

http://www.rolandconnect.com/product.php?p=fr-18_diatonic
Title: Re: Roland FR-1
Post by: Steve C. on January 16, 2011, 08:40:42 PM
Is the FR18 the final call on Strebs?  Why would Streb continue?
Title: Re: Roland FR-1
Post by: Lester on January 16, 2011, 09:07:43 PM
How about the FR-18 ? Wouldn't mind trying one myself...

http://www.rolandconnect.com/product.php?p=fr-18_diatonic

See here (http://forum.melodeon.net/index.php/topic,5816.0.html)
Title: Re: Roland FR-1
Post by: nemethmik on January 17, 2011, 05:51:05 AM
How about the FR-18 ?
Based on the youtube videos FR18 has much better accordion sound than any other Roland electronic accordions including FR7. FR7 has exactly the same disappointing "electric toy" sound as the FR1, but FR18 is different.
Title: Re: Roland FR-1
Post by: mikesamwild on January 25, 2011, 08:07:58 PM
http://www.rolandus.com/products/productdetails.php?ProductId=1147
Title: Re: Roland FR-1
Post by: Accordion Dave on January 29, 2011, 01:26:33 AM
Roxy's Music Store in Batavia, New York has presented several concerts featuring the Roland electronic accordions. The sound is quite amazing in the hands of an accomplished player.

I tried one at the store. The feel was a bit different than a regular accordion with reeds and bellows. 

I did not spend a lot of time with it because it was well beyond my price range.

I did buy a wonderful musette accordion at one of the events which was more affordable.
Title: Re: Roland FR-1
Post by: nemethmik on January 29, 2011, 06:46:14 AM
The sound is quite amazing in the hands of an accomplished player.
Thank You Dave for the comment.
Nevertheless, I've yet to listen to a youtube video with decent Roland electr(on)ic accordion sound of any price range. I am still not convinced to go back to the Roland show room and give another try. Although, I am really keen to have a small size/light electric chromatic button accordion.
My daughter's Yamaha PSR K1 keyboard has quite good sound, at least this is what I'd expect from an electric instrument in the thousands-of-euros price range.
Title: Re: Roland FR-1
Post by: Bill Young on January 29, 2011, 08:43:29 AM
Miki,
Have you considered the Limex digitale diatonische harmonika? (http://www.limexmusic.com/cgi-bin/content.pl?q=bD1kZXV0c2NoJmlkPWFra29yZGVvbg&section=produkte&kat=4380)
Title: Re: Roland FR-1
Post by: Accordion Dave on January 30, 2011, 12:57:35 AM
The reason I like an acoustic accordion is that no batteries or electrical hookup are required.

The Roland instruments have a self-contained battery operated amplifier. At least that was the case with the one I tried at the store.

I often play for hours at a time non-stop. With an electronic instrument, I would probably need to carry several rechargeable battery packs. 

Title: Re: Roland FR-1
Post by: Alan Morley on January 30, 2011, 09:45:02 AM
Miklos, I do generally agree, but there is room for "non-acoustic" sound too.  Why does (almost) everyone want a Streb on the shelf?
And then there is the (almost) unmentionable:
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=TcbuXXFSXtU&feature=related
 >:E

Bet he can't play 'Whiter Shade of Pale'..... >:E
Title: Re: Roland FR-1
Post by: GbH on January 30, 2011, 11:53:08 AM
Is the FR18 the final call on Strebs?  Why would Streb continue?

I can't speak for Mr Streb, but the Roland, flexible as it is, still isn't ever going to be 'all things to all men'.

I've had a quick go on the FR18 myself and my immediate impression was that it's happier playing in a smoother, cross row style than on the row.  As to whether this is because of its size, because of the type of voicing I was using or simply because I suck at trying to play along a row I'm not sure. 
Title: Re: Roland FR-1
Post by: Graham Spencer on January 30, 2011, 03:36:11 PM
Miklos, I do generally agree, but there is room for "non-acoustic" sound too.  Why does (almost) everyone want a Streb on the shelf?

I'm glad you added the "almost", because I for one don't!  I've done the synthesised/sampled/MIDI thing to exhaustion on stage over the last ten or twelve years, and I now just love to relax with sound of real reeds driven by air from a real bellows through a real mechanism....there just ain't no substitute!  Added to which, if I want to go & play somewhere all I have to carry is my melodeon case - no need to cart outboard gear, worry about batteries, finish up with a rat's nest of cables to pack away at the end.........


Graham
Title: Re: Roland FR-1
Post by: Alan Morley on January 30, 2011, 04:56:18 PM
Miklos, I do generally agree, but there is room for "non-acoustic" sound too.  Why does (almost) everyone want a Streb on the shelf?

I'm glad you added the "almost", because I for one don't!  I've done the synthesised/sampled/MIDI thing to exhaustion on stage over the last ten or twelve years, and I now just love to relax with sound of real reeds driven by air from a real bellows through a real mechanism....there just ain't no substitute!  Added to which, if I want to go & play somewhere all I have to carry is my melodeon case - no need to cart outboard gear, worry about batteries, finish up with a rat's nest of cables to pack away at the end.........

Graham

I'm with you Graham.. :||:

Alan
Title: Re: Roland FR-1
Post by: NewShoe on February 06, 2011, 03:16:27 AM
I have enjoyed playing my FR-1 for about a year.  I use mainly the accordion settings and appreciate having more voices compared to my 48 bass Hohner.  The button action is better on the fr-1, especially now that the bass buttons are worn and sticking on the Hohner.  Of course the downside is the cable and amp needed to play. 

You really need a good amplifier / speaker with some power and good frequency response.  Tried a small guitar amp which didn't do too well.  I have experimented with some battery powered amps which are OK but sound is better through my home stereo. 
Title: Re: Roland FR-1
Post by: HallelujahAl on February 06, 2011, 08:08:45 AM
Hi Newshoe and welcome to the forum - yes, I agree, the sound system you put it through does make a very big difference. I prefer to play my FR-1 through the headphones actually (so do my family  :D) - as that gives me very good quality sound. I have a Custom Acoustic amp which is also very good. My accordion came 'with' a small guitar amp which is pretty awful and is probably the reason why the person who sold the lot to me had decided to give up on the digital accordion. Suffice to say guitar amp has been relegated to doing what it does best!
AL
Title: Re: Roland FR-1
Post by: Alan Morley on February 06, 2011, 10:08:11 AM

You really need a good amplifier / speaker with some power and good frequency response.  Tried a small guitar amp which didn't do too well.  I have experimented with some battery powered amps which are OK but sound is better through my home stereo. 

Amplifier

There are guitar amps, and guitar amps......
An amp for an electric guitar is different to an acoustic/electric guitar amp...

I have a Peavey VK112 50watt valve amp which I use for my Strat and the Peerless Tonemaster electric guitars - if I plug my Takamine electro/acoustic it through that amp - the sound is 'brittle' and very sharp - you could cut glass....

My other amp is for acoustic instruments - Fishman Loudbox mini - 60 watt - with inputs for instrument - mic - mp3, and it can be output to a PA.

In contrast to the Peavey - when you plug an electric guitar into the acoustic amp - they sound booming with no 'top'.
When the Takamine is plugged into the Fishman amp - wow - the amp is so small - but with a HUGE sound.

It might be worth hunting down the Fishman amp somewhere and plugging your Roland into it and see what happens.

Here is the link for the amp:   http://www.fishman.com/products/details.asp?id=113

Alan
Title: Re: Roland FR-1
Post by: Martin J on February 06, 2011, 11:04:40 AM
That loudbox mini has to be something very special at nearly £500.  You'd need to be very sure it was right for your instrument before splashing that sort of cash. 8)
Title: Re: Roland FR-1
Post by: Alan Morley on February 06, 2011, 11:10:32 AM
That loudbox mini has to be something very special at nearly £500.  You'd need to be very sure it was right for your instrument before splashing that sort of cash. 8)

They are normally retailed at £299 - I paid £330 for mine a week ago - because they are 'special' Fishman are 'THE' name in acoustic amps in my opinion.

Any reviews and demonstrations on the internet, cannot do justice to the sound of this little amp - you need to plug in and play.

I'm not saying the Roland will work with the amp - but - I'd certainly give it a try.....

The picture below will give you the idea of the size of the Fishman.
Title: Re: Roland FR-1
Post by: HallelujahAl on February 06, 2011, 11:45:34 AM
I believe that the FR-1 was designed with the Roland Cube amp in mind - which kind of makes sense. Just that I'm too tight to splash out on a CUBE (waiting for a decent used one to come up on fleabay).
AL
Title: Re: Roland FR-1
Post by: NewShoe on February 06, 2011, 01:36:41 PM
That Fishman amp looks like it would be good to try but at $300 + bucks here it may have to wait for an excess cash situation to develop.   I have experimented with construction of a rude approximation using left over parts around the house.  I used a class D battery powered stereo amp that runs on 12 volts.  My first try was putting the amp in a box about the size of the Fishman amp with a pair of co axial 5-1/4" car speakers - ok but harsh so disconnected tweeters - sounds better.    Next tried a box with 6 1/2" woofer and some speakers for higher range.  I ran the bass to the large speaker and treble to the small speakers.  That was better but the bass side really needs high frequency too.  All this is ok for practice but not enough power for group play since the amp only has 10 w per channel.  Next I will try finding some more efficient drivers and a crossover along with a 60 watt amp circuit.   The project overall has been a fun way to learn about sound equipment design and with a large supply of scrap wood and electronic junk here  a fairly cheap way to experiment.  Also a good excuse to play a few tunes of the month to test my new creations.
Title: Re: Roland FR-1
Post by: Chris Brimley on February 06, 2011, 02:09:50 PM
I'm not sure about the basis of some of the discussion about amps here - provided that have a good quality amplifier of reasonable power, and the input impedance is properly matched (which is often the problem with an acoustic guitar transducer), an amp ought to be capable of having a wide range of uses.  Manufacturers of course like to sell all sorts of different systems for all sorts of niche markets, but basically, they are surely all at heart designed to faithfully reproduce an input signal (OK, possibly with various built-in systems to modify it on purpose).  And the instrument output will also be designed to provide a faithful output signal (which with just a transducer may need pre-amping to make it suitable for input into the amp). 

So for example the Roland Cube may well be promoted as ideal for the FR1, but I'd be surprised if the signal it produces isn't just as good with lots of other competitor's systems.
Title: Re: Roland FR-1
Post by: NewShoe on February 17, 2011, 06:01:00 PM
In trying out some of the TOTM selections I discovered another advantage of the FR-1 in the simplicity of recording directly into a mp3 sound file.  I just plug the accordion output into the microphone input of the  soundcard in the back of my PC with a Y adapt splitter for my speaker and  get a sound file in one operation.  It is important to adjust all the sound levels a little to avoid clipping.  You need software to read the signal from the soundcard. I used the free audacity program.

I think the new Roland melodeon should work similarly for making recordings.

  Here is my first try at it.

http://www.onmvoice.com/play.php?a=41325

Title: Re: Roland FR-1
Post by: Martin J on February 18, 2011, 12:09:54 AM
....  Here is my first try at it.  http://www.onmvoice.com/play.php?a=41325
The left hand sounds quite a good facsimile of an accordion bass but the right hand sounded more piccolo like.  What voice did you select for it?  Was it in fact layered?
Title: Re: Roland FR-1
Post by: NewShoe on February 18, 2011, 02:22:12 AM
I was using the "French Folk" accordian  setting with the LMMH voice.  Probably using the bass a little too much compared to the melodeon players.  The bass was on the master setting.   Otherwise the signal was just run into the computer and recorded once with the worst of the messed up parts of the playing cut off as an edit after.  If folks are interested I can post more tunes with other voices as I certainly could use the practice.

This new accordian has so many different voice settings compared to my two reed Hohner I am still trying to get an idea of the best ways to use them.
Title: Re: Roland FR-1
Post by: NewShoe on February 18, 2011, 02:39:40 AM
Sorry correction - Checked the manual, I actually used French folk (set 7) with the register they call "Arnold" with just M. Second listen it sounded a little thin so I double checked.
Title: Re: Roland FR-1
Post by: Alan Morley on February 18, 2011, 08:16:09 AM
'erm - So you are actually trying to get it to sound like a melodeon..... ::)    ?
Title: Re: Roland FR-1
Post by: Martin J on February 18, 2011, 08:23:39 AM
Thanks New Shoe.  I'm very sold on midi melodeon for the things it can do.  What I am not sold on is its ability to replicate a melodeon or any free reed sound, hence my deep interest in the voicing.  Al posted an audio clip as one of a group of melodeon sounds and it stuck out like the proverbial sore thumb. It will be interesting to see how you can mold or shape the sound output.
Title: Re: Roland FR-1
Post by: Alan Morley on February 18, 2011, 08:51:02 AM
The big problem with midi sounds is that they don't successfully replicate acoustic instruments very well at all.

There are so many subtle elements that creep into to accoustic sounds that midi will always sound robotic...

So that applies to midi for: meodeons / accordions - brass - woodwind - bagpipes - strings - acoustic guitar

What midi does do a good job with is : keyboards - Hammonds, pianos, xylophone, gloc, hammer dulcimer, and of course synth sounds.

But I think if I wanted something to sound like a melodeon - I'd buy a melodeon.....

Midi guitars were very short lived, but you could get some good guitar sound out of them.... ::)
Title: Re: Roland FR-1
Post by: Martin J on February 18, 2011, 09:00:22 AM
But I think if I wanted something to sound like a melodeon - I'd buy a melodeon.....
Totally agree about the melodeons but I I find some replica sounds excellent.  Sax, flute, bassoon, many of the other woodwind variants, synth of course and some orchestral ensembles.  On the other hand I'm very picky about piano sounds and believe that they are quite difficult to extract from a midi melodeon.
Title: Re: Roland FR-1
Post by: Alan Morley on February 18, 2011, 09:14:22 AM
But I think if I wanted something to sound like a melodeon - I'd buy a melodeon.....
Totally agree about the melodeons but I I find some replica sounds excellent.  Sax, flute, bassoon, many of the other woodwind variants, synth of course and some orchestral ensembles.  On the other hand I'm very picky about piano sounds and believe that they are quite difficult to extract from a midi melodeon.

To carry off the midi sound and make it actually sound like the instrument it's pretending to be - you actually have to play the note in the way of the instrument.

The breath control and variation of attack and subtle reed changes of a sax player can't be done on a keyboard. Although they work on a midi sax.

Like a midi guitar trying to sound like a grand piano or a sax - it dont happen....but play a banjo sound and you're close
Title: Re: Roland FR-1
Post by: Martin J on February 18, 2011, 09:19:19 AM
Agreed again.  That's probably why breathy instruments work well on midi melodeon.  Certainly playing cords with a flute or brass voice sounds terrible.  It ought to follow that reed sounds would be good but IMHO there aren't.
Title: Re: Roland FR-1
Post by: NewShoe on February 18, 2011, 02:33:49 PM
Quote
'erm - So you are actually trying to get it to sound like a melodeon..... Roll Eyes    ?

Sure, why not - Many of the melodeon TOTM selections are my favorites anyway.

At this point I'm still trying to get the tunes right so if the accordion sound is a little off that is a small worry.  I find that switching between my two boxes also seems to help my practice.  Perhaps bad habits learned on one box are unlearned with the switch to the alternate.   The key travel is shorter on the Roland and it has 72 bass giving me a set of b cords that are missing from my Hohner 48.   Bad timing is highlighted well on the Roland with the drum setting turned on too.   And of course the ability to turn down the volume or use headphones is appreciated by many around here.

As a learning project I think I will try recording more of the tunes I know using different voices.  I have been using the "Set #7 = Arnold" setting voice a lot lately so I'll try some of the others for a while.   



 
Title: Re: Roland FR-1
Post by: squeezenplease on February 18, 2011, 03:12:42 PM
On the question of amps,the Roland FR-1,which is in effect a keyboard,should always be played through a KB or keyboard amp....Midi accordions sound awful through guitar amps....TPC
Title: Re: Roland FR-1
Post by: nemethmik on February 18, 2011, 06:31:28 PM
FR-1 http://www.onmvoice.com/play.php?a=41325
Your playing is excellent. Thank you for sharing your recording: the sound is exactly what I have experienced myself in the Roland showroom.
Title: Re: Roland FR-1
Post by: NewShoe on February 19, 2011, 07:22:55 PM
Quote
Your playing is excellent. Thank you for sharing your recording: 

- Thank you -


I am noticing that my accordion playing is runs heavier than the melodeons even with the light registers.  With 72 bass buttons it is almost irresistible to use as many of them as possible as much as possible.  It helps me to check out how things sound when I am not involved with playing. 

What I am posting on onmvoice now has the register and accordion set noted.

 

Title: Re: Roland FR-1
Post by: risto on March 04, 2011, 06:25:53 PM
Thanks AL (!) for posting about the update for FR-1 for free bass. One could probably do it by oneself (thru the MIDI port) but I contacted Roland Scandinavia and they told that it is done free of charge, so I rather let them do it. Some additional features will come along but I don't know what they are. I will get the updating done next week after which I know more.

/Risto
Title: Re: Roland FR-1
Post by: HallelujahAl on March 04, 2011, 07:29:03 PM
Good news! Glad to have been of (limited) help.
AL
Title: Re: Roland FR-1
Post by: risto on March 04, 2011, 10:30:33 PM
VERY good news indeed, thanks to you. :D I have been away for some time now, need to check more what you fine people are up to these days:D
Title: Re: Roland FR-1
Post by: Alan on March 23, 2011, 01:22:49 PM
Just recieved my new Roland FR1, and it does take some time to get used to it after an acoustic accordion.
Not that I'm a muscian, just a learner.

I wonder if there is a way of changing the bass or do I have to make do with the three settings?

Many thanks to HallelujahAl for your helpful comments.

Alan of Ardersier
Title: Re: Roland FR-1
Post by: Bill Young on March 23, 2011, 05:09:40 PM
You just have the three bass registers. But (I forget exactly how the FR-3 I used to have worked) don't you get different sets of bass sounds when you change sets on the right hand - Classic, Jazz, Alpine, D Folk etc?
Title: Re: Roland FR-1
Post by: Flanna on March 23, 2011, 05:46:51 PM
I have a Roland FR3b and the quality of build and sounds are excellent. I'm surprised to hear that the FR1b is of much lower quality.
Title: Re: Roland FR-1
Post by: NewShoe on March 23, 2011, 06:10:53 PM
Quote
I wonder if there is a way of changing the bass or do I have to make do with the three settings?

The three bass registers are preset to match the accordion set selected.  So there are seven sets of three registers for the bass in all.   There is also the orchestral bass buttons that you can try which replace the accordion bass sounds.   I like the plucked string bass sound  with the guitar cord  combination.  I think there are also a tuba, bowed bass, organ, strings settings as well.

Also check out the instruction book.  There is a way to adjust the amount of bass vs. treble.   



Title: Re: Roland FR-1
Post by: HallelujahAl on March 23, 2011, 07:26:17 PM
yes, and don't forget the 'freebass' which gives an extra dimension - there are 5 different preset freebass systems on my fr1 including bayan etc
Title: Re: Roland FR-1
Post by: Alan on March 23, 2011, 10:45:21 PM
I believe that you need midi cables to download freebass??

So, changing the treble registers changes the way the bass sounds,  doesn't on this FR1.

Many thanks to all who replied.

Alan of Ardersier
Title: Re: Roland FR-1
Post by: HallelujahAl on March 24, 2011, 07:52:40 AM
It's a simple download - new Roland instruments come with a USB port, older machines utilise the midi in/out port on the instrument, so a USB to Midi adapter is necessary - but they're very easy to get hold of and pretty cheap. Once downloaded it's on there for good, even if the accordion is subsequently reset to factory settings I believe.
AL
Title: Re: Roland FR-1
Post by: Flanna on March 24, 2011, 07:57:05 AM

... So, changing the treble registers changes the way the bass sounds,  doesn't on this FR1.


Changing the treble registers (when used as conventional registers) does not change the way the bass sounds, it only changes the way the treble sounds. Changing the bass registers changes the way the bass sounds. Just like on a traditional accordion.

There are additional controls (that utilize the treble registers together with another control) which can change the sound set for the entire instrument. It could sound like a French, Italian or Alpine accordion, for example. This change effects both bass and treble simultaneously. It's just like picking up a different accordion.

You can also use the bass registers to change the bass and bass chords to play "orchestral" (non accordion) sounds. This is independent of the treble side. Of course you can also set the treble side to play "orchestral sounds" independently of the bass side.
Title: Re: Roland FR-1
Post by: squeezebox63 on March 24, 2011, 07:20:54 PM
The roland also has reed growl and button clicking sounds, most of the effects of regular reed instruments. many choices of accordion sounds and of course midi sounds.also.
I have the fr-7x and it's great. I'd love to get the fr-18. who knows maybe down the road. we only go this way once as far as I know.
One bit of advice, if you can't program a dvr or vcr, you might want to stay clear of these accordions as they are computer type units.
Cliff.
Title: Re: Roland FR-1 free bass
Post by: Alan on March 28, 2011, 12:43:57 PM
Many thanks to all for the info on Roland FR1.  I have now got a midi to usb cable, now how do I download freebass??

Cheers.
Alan
Title: Re: Roland FR-1
Post by: HallelujahAl on March 28, 2011, 01:59:17 PM
Alan - have pm'd you
 ;D
Title: Re: Roland FR-1
Post by: Accordion Dave on October 27, 2011, 03:27:55 AM
I just got the new DVD video recording of Weird Al Yankovic's "Comedy Central" television concert. I see he is using a Roland "Virtual Accordion". I did not look that closely to see what model. It is possible that he was accordion synching and lip synching to the videos.
Title: Re: Roland FR-1
Post by: Robbie on January 11, 2012, 08:34:01 PM
I have a question regarding the bass layout on the Roland FR-1, the handbook shows a 72 bass layout that is not the same as the my tutor book, the good old " Buttons & Keys" Vol 1.:|bl

There seems to be no G,D or A sharps on the counterbass row or fundamental row for that matter, however there seems to be A,E & B flats on the counterbass row, three notes not normally shown on a 72 bass accordion.

Would I be correct in assuming that the G,D and A sharps are in fact A,E and B flats, if you want them to be, as it were. :o

Assuming the above is correct then why not just stick with convention.

Be gentle, I am not a classically trained musician, or even a musician really.

In the world of a classically trained engineer  ;), all is black and white. ;D

Cheers

Bob
Title: Re: Roland FR-1
Post by: Hallelujahal on January 11, 2012, 08:50:51 PM
Yep - posh word is 'enharmonics' - basically a G sharp is the same as A flat etc. Not so much black & white - more like shades of the same grey  ;D

BTW I'm thinking of selling my FR-1 (much against my better judgement frankly) as I've found a 'must have' melodeon being sold by another member of this forum, and need to raise some cash quick. So before I list it, if anyone's interested please pm me.
Regards, AL
Title: Re: Roland FR-1
Post by: Robbie on January 11, 2012, 11:05:26 PM
Many thanks for your response Al, I am keeping the old Carman I have until April, I have given myself a year to make a bang of it, and will then decide on moving up,  or heaving my one in the bin.

Progress wise there are good and bad hair days, however I am now towards the end of Vol 1 of the tutor, and have bought vol 2.

There are 4 other accordion players in the village, all learners, all retired, and we have had a few house sessions, the last one at the hog which was more booze than buttons.  ;)

Take care

Bob
SimplePortal 2.3.5 © 2008-2012, SimplePortal