Melodeon.net Forums

Discussions => Instrument Makes and Models => Topic started by: King Of Breifne on January 06, 2011, 10:50:37 PM

Title: Mengascini D 212 E -v- Saltarelle Irish Bouëbe
Post by: King Of Breifne on January 06, 2011, 10:50:37 PM
Hello, folks!

First post as a brand new aspiring button box player.  I'm going to be playing Irish traditional music, and I'm shopping around for my first instrument.  Right now I'm looking at two main possibilities on pre-owned boxes (listed in the discussion title).

Please give your opinions on both of these accordions and how they would suit a beginner like me.

Thanks in advance!


~ Ryan
Title: Re: Mengascini D 212 E -v- Saltarelle Irish Bouëbe
Post by: tedrick on January 06, 2011, 11:36:59 PM
both very nice boxes -
the Meng is slightly heavier - not a major issue -

the meng is 21 buttons -- having 23 is no immediate benefit for Irish box

Are Mengs built in house? Or do they outsource to a major manufacturer?

Do both have Dural reeds?
Title: Re: Mengascini D 212 E -v- Saltarelle Irish Bouëbe
Post by: Stiamh on January 07, 2011, 02:36:01 AM
the meng is 21 buttons -- having 23 is no immediate benefit for Irish box

23 buttons is a definite benefit if you play C#/D - generally recognised as an Irish box (even by the hidebound conservatives at Comhaltas since, what, 1975? (:) )
Title: Re: Mengascini D 212 E -v- Saltarelle Irish Bouëbe
Post by: Pat. on January 07, 2011, 08:57:34 AM
Mengascini any time ,I have had both and the Meng is way in front as far as I am concerned.
Title: Re: Mengascini D 212 E -v- Saltarelle Irish Bouëbe
Post by: EeeJay on January 07, 2011, 09:51:29 AM
Are Mengs built in house? Or do they outsource to a major manufacturer?

As far as I recall, yes - built in house. They do produce for others though... Verde is one example...

From what I recall there is a family connection (brothers?) with Beltuna, but their production is seperate - no models seem to be shared/similar...

There is (also as far as I recall) a 23 button version of the 2v Mengascini... recall seeing a pic of one online, somewhere...

Ed J
Title: Re: Mengascini D 212 E -v- Saltarelle Irish Bouëbe
Post by: george garside on January 07, 2011, 01:09:05 PM
I like the meng' but would definately go for 23 buttons given the choice

georgr
Title: Re: Mengascini D 212 E -v- Saltarelle Irish Bouëbe
Post by: King Of Breifne on January 07, 2011, 02:24:39 PM
The Mengascini box I'm looking at has 21 buttons.  Will this hinder me greatly?
Title: Re: Mengascini D 212 E -v- Saltarelle Irish Bouëbe
Post by: tedrick on January 07, 2011, 02:29:44 PM
Hey Ryan-
Welcome to mel.net by the way --

people are a lot nicer here than on the mustard board - so no need for obscure name/handle --

You are definitely going to have a better experience as a beginner starting out with a good quality box -- most people probably try and then fall away from the box because they are starting out on an uninspiring sounding and playing instrument --

Strike while the irons hot, get started and don't look back - also, starting off with a quality box will delay the onset of MAD -
Title: Re: Mengascini D 212 E -v- Saltarelle Irish Bouëbe
Post by: tedrick on January 07, 2011, 02:34:43 PM
The Mengascini box I'm looking at has 21 buttons.  Will this hinder me greatly?

not being a c#/d player I can't say - but apparently with c#/d players it is desireable to have those 2 extra notes? Could someone elaborate?

I know myself personally as a b/c player, on the tunes I play, I never need anything lower than the low A on the pull or the low E on the push of the top button on a 21 or the 2nd button in from the top on a 23

pr'aps the c#/d requires 23 trebles to get that low?

Reed
Title: Re: Mengascini D 212 E -v- Saltarelle Irish Bouëbe
Post by: Stiamh on January 07, 2011, 02:58:05 PM
Hey Reed, I explained this in response to something you wrote in another thread. A standard 23-button layout for C#/D gives you low G. There are plenty of fiddle tunes I like to play that go down to that note. (You have it on a 21-button B/C.)

KoB, the standard 21-button layout will hamper you if you want to play those fiddle tunes. OTOH you can play an awful lot of Irish tunes that don't go that low. It depends on your taste and repertoire. I mean Irish flute players have to fudge tunes that go lower than D or possibly C, and good ones get by amazingly well (although some must have low-note envy).

If you end up with a 21-button box and find that you really need that low G, you can always get it put on the bottom button on the outer row. This will mean sacrificing low Bb|A#, which may not seem like a big deal, but personally I'd rather not be without that note either. (Was using it just this morning trying that Finnish "Forest Flowers" waltz - someone recently linked to a YouTube clip of it - in Em.)

You could possibly sacrifice your low F# (bottom button push on the D row) but that puts your low G in the wrong direction, adding more confusion to what is down there in the low end already (because the notes get "out of synch" in the bottom octave, e.g. low B is on a lower button than low A). A toss-up between doing that and putting it on the outer row.

If you were ordering a new 21-button C#/D instrument you could shift all the notes up one button, giving you your low G and losing the high F# at the top end. But that's not the case here, of course.
Title: Re: Mengascini D 212 E -v- Saltarelle Irish Bouëbe
Post by: Theo on January 07, 2011, 03:02:01 PM
I don't think the OP has expressed a preference for B/C or C#/D.  If BC is in the running there is a nice looking Tommy on UK ebay (http://170587699654), just appeared today at £1450 buy it now.
Title: Re: Mengascini D 212 E -v- Saltarelle Irish Bouëbe
Post by: Stiamh on January 07, 2011, 03:04:45 PM
Unless I'm putting 2 and 2 together where I shouldn't, the OP was enquiring on another forum where it transpired that the box in question was indeed a C#/D.

If that thread was started by our OP, he has been promoted. http://www.thesession.org/discussions/display/26435
Title: Re: Mengascini D 212 E -v- Saltarelle Irish Bouëbe
Post by: Theo on January 07, 2011, 03:14:31 PM
Ah that explains it thank you.  I don't often visit the mustard board.
Title: Re: Mengascini D 212 E -v- Saltarelle Irish Bouëbe
Post by: nfldbox on January 07, 2011, 03:33:50 PM
Steve and Reed
I can't believe you two raised C#D vs BC again.
As that great Irishman Chairman Mao said, "Let 100 flowers bloom."
terry
Title: Re: Mengascini D 212 E -v- Saltarelle Irish Bouëbe
Post by: King Of Breifne on January 07, 2011, 03:59:25 PM
Yes...the "Mustard Board" has MORE than its fair share of complete jackwagons.  Some nasty, nasty people over there.

Anyhow, the advice I'm getting is making me lean more toward a B/C box since it sounds like a C#/D with 21 trebles may be lacking everything one needs.
Title: Re: Mengascini D 212 E -v- Saltarelle Irish Bouëbe
Post by: Stiamh on January 07, 2011, 04:33:56 PM
What are you on about Terry? This has absolutely nothing to do with the respective merits of C#/D and B/C systems for playing Irish music. I'm just pointing out that if you choose C#/D, 21 buttons good, 23 buttons better.

21 buttons "lacking everything one needs"? I'll try again.... lacking one note that occurs in a small percentage of tunes. OP, you specifically asked Mengascini or Irish Bouëbe. Irish Bouëbe has 23 buttons - an advantage over the Mengascini to consider when making your choice.
Title: Re: Mengascini D 212 E -v- Saltarelle Irish Bouëbe
Post by: Andrew Culwell on January 07, 2011, 06:40:03 PM
I think Terry is being facetious Steve  ;D  As far as boxes go c#d or b/c I think the Mengascini's are far underrated and that they are equal or superior to the Saltarelle Bouebe.  That said I think either are great starters and The Tommy that Theo pointed out is a great buy also!   As far as the 23 button vs 21 button debate I play b/c and think 21 buttons is fine, I confuse easily so adding more buttons isn't for me!    ::)
Title: Re: Mengascini D 212 E -v- Saltarelle Irish Bouëbe
Post by: Keithypete. on January 07, 2011, 08:08:02 PM
A Tommy will have a open fingerboard - what about the other two in question? Is this something for beginner to consider? I think closed is considered better for the Irish style.
Title: Re: Mengascini D 212 E -v- Saltarelle Irish Bouëbe
Post by: Andrew Culwell on January 07, 2011, 08:19:35 PM
You mean stepped vs flat?  I prefer flat keyboard but that's a personal preference I would think.
Title: Re: Mengascini D 212 E -v- Saltarelle Irish Bouëbe
Post by: King Of Breifne on January 08, 2011, 12:28:35 AM
Yeah...not sure.  Do 10-year-old Mengascinis have a stepped keyboard or a flat keyboard?
Title: Re: Mengascini D 212 E -v- Saltarelle Irish Bouëbe
Post by: Owen Woods on January 08, 2011, 12:40:06 AM
Closed or open is different to flat or stepped. Closed means that you can't see the levers that the buttons are attached to, open means that you can (as with many Italian boxes). I haven't the faintest idea what difference that makes (if any).
Title: Re: Mengascini D 212 E -v- Saltarelle Irish Bouëbe
Post by: tedrick on January 08, 2011, 01:05:15 AM
Hi Ryan -
you're burning up the forum! 2 pages and only your first post! The only thing better than researching an accordion purchase is helping a friend research a box purchase!

Do you have an accordion shop near you where you could try some boxes out? Even if they're not b/c boxes it's still helpful to get a sense for what the differences are --

I personally prefer flat and closed because as a b/c player you are sliding around and between both rows constantly, so a flat smooth surface is helpful in those respects -

Do you have pics of this Meng you are considering? It's probably similar to the meng out at buttonbox --

Title: Re: Mengascini D 212 E -v- Saltarelle Irish Bouëbe
Post by: King Of Breifne on January 08, 2011, 02:29:40 AM
Hey, Reeds...

Really appreciating all the help and advice I'm receiving already.

This particular Meng' is in fact a C#/D.  It's actually in Ireland.  We'll be moving there in a couple months, so I'll be able to see/hear it in-person and make the purchase there as well.  Here are the two photos I have:

(http://img502.imageshack.us/img502/5932/fulli.jpg) (http://img502.imageshack.us/i/fulli.jpg/)

(http://img510.imageshack.us/img510/6306/full1t.jpg) (http://img510.imageshack.us/i/full1t.jpg/)

Title: Re: Mengascini D 212 E -v- Saltarelle Irish Bouëbe
Post by: Curamach on January 09, 2011, 01:05:24 PM
Low G note: I have a reworked Pokerwork C#/D (thanks Theo!) 21 buttons. Last summer Martin Quinn re-tuned the lowest button on the C# row to G on the draw, so I have it. I am a fiddler so felt nervous about not having that note, but so far I don't often play below the D. It will come.

Dan
Title: Re: Mengascini D 212 E -v- Saltarelle Irish Bouëbe
Post by: melodeon on January 10, 2011, 05:16:21 PM
Owing to Saltarelles very spotty quality control, use of modest quality reeds....
my choice woiuld be the Mengascini..

However, 23 buttons is nice.

As to ten years ago, depending on the model... but the ones produced in the keys of B/C and C#/D that I have seen were all flat keyboards.

Check out the Button Box web site in the USA... see current inventory....
Title: Re: Mengascini D 212 E -v- Saltarelle Irish Bouëbe
Post by: Andrew Culwell on January 10, 2011, 05:27:55 PM
Low G note: I have a reworked Pokerwork C#/D (thanks Theo!) 21 buttons. Last summer Martin Quinn re-tuned the lowest button on the C# row to G on the draw, so I have it. I am a fiddler so felt nervous about not having that note, but so far I don't often play below the D. It will come.

Dan

Dan,
did Martin do that at his Swannanoa Tuning workshop?

--Drew
SimplePortal 2.3.5 © 2008-2012, SimplePortal