Melodeon.net Forums
Discussions => Instrument Makes and Models => Topic started by: ladydetemps on January 14, 2011, 09:06:56 AM
-
I like the sound of the features of the Roland and fancy an electric melodeon in principal for silent practice.
Thing is I don't want a huge great one with loads of buttons.
I want a MIDI one row four stop melodeon. Where you can plug earphones in and change the one row and basses to what key you want to play in. (Saves carrying several different boxes). And the option to connect to computer and create tabulature of what your playing also appeals.
-
What would your 'ideal' be? Am I the only one who wants it as a one row?
-
The Streb's still pretty close to my ideal for me. If Steve ever does a Mk3, I'd like:
- 3 row, 18 bass (like the Roland)
- User-programmable (via a PC) keyboard layout (like the Roland), and ideally sample management/upload too.
- Improved built-in samples
- A decent amount of switches on the front so you can change pitch to whatever with one click (the Roland takes 2 clicks), and dedicated reverb/chorus/fine-tune dials
- Adjustable dry/wet tuning (like the Roland) would be nice.
Built in speakers are still a must for me.
The existing Streb actually makes a pretty good one row already (ignore 1.5 treble rows and 10 of the basses); use the 1 row dry one row sample set - I think these came from Lester's box - add a bit of reverb, and it's fast, responsive, and quite convincing.
Clive
-
The existing Streb actually makes a pretty good one row already (ignore 1.5 treble rows and 10 of the basses); use the 1 row dry one row sample set - I think these came from Lester's box - add a bit of reverb, and it's fast, responsive, and quite convincing.
My point is for me extra row etc. would be wasted. I don't want the extra weight/size.
Maybe Rees could make one? ;) A Wesson 'outboard' perhaps?
-
My point it for me extra row etc. would be wasted. I don't want the extra weight/size.
That's the thing, you see. The extra buttons are computer switches; no levers or pallets, and so weigh next to nothing. I don't really see the point of the 2 row 8 bass Streb -it's virtually the same weight as the 2.5 row 12 bass! The main weight is the speakers, and the batteries, and I guess the call you'd need to make is would you want internal speakers, or would you be happy to always use headphones/an external amp. It would be much lighter if you did, especially if you did away with the battery and always ran it off the mains. But even with them, it's about the weight of a pokerwork. Size, of course, is a different issue. The Roland looks huge, and is approx 2kg heavier than my Streb, according to the spec sheet - I'm sure they could make the case smaller if they wanted, but I guess they come from the piano accordion world where size isn't really an issue.
Cheers,
Clive
-
The main weight is the speakers, and the batteries, and I guess the call you'd need to make is would you want internal speakers, or would you be happy to always use headphones/an external amp. It would be much lighter if you did, especially if you did away with the battery and always ran it off the mains. But even with them, it's about the weight of a pokerwork.
I have a little belt 'clip-on' amp I bought when I attempted to learn bass guitar...only used it once.
Size, of course, is a different issue. The Roland looks huge, and is approx 2kg heavier than my Streb, according to the spec sheet - I'm sure they could make the case smaller if they wanted, but I guess they come from the piano accordion world where size isn't really an issue.
Size if definately something that puts me off.
I'm waiting for an i-melodeon. ;) :|||: (I say waiting for the i-pad 2)
-
Size if definately something that puts me off.
I'm working on a small electronic melodeon type instrument. It doesn't have bellows but instead it has a force sensor which can detect whether you are pushing or pulling and how hard.
It's going to be very small but I've no idea if it's going to actually be playable when it's finished :-\. It might turn out to be a fun toy though.
-
Size if definately something that puts me off.
I'm working on a small electronic melodeon type instrument. It doesn't have bellows but instead it has a force sensor which can detect whether you are pushing or pulling and how hard.
It's going to be very small but I've no idea if it's going to actually be playable when it's finished :-\. It might turn out to be a fun toy though.
Sounds cool. :)
-
I'm working on a small electronic melodeon type instrument. It doesn't have bellows but instead it has a force sensor which can detect whether you are pushing or pulling and how hard.
Steve "Wheatstone Concertinas" Dickinson told me that the first attempt at a MIDI concertina was like that, and players didn't like it, so the next version had a bellows and deliberately leaked air in order to have the right feel to it.
But Bill Whaley's MIDI concertina has rigid ends, and he manages OK with it, so simulated bellows movement may be an unnecessary refinement once the player gets used to the instrument.
-
But Bill Whaley's MIDI concertina has rigid ends, and he manages OK with it, so simulated bellows movement may be an unnecessary refinement once the player gets used to the instrument.
Very interesting to hear that someone else has gotten this kind of thing to work.
I wanted it to be small and light and I figured that it shouldn't matter if the ends are getting closer together or further apart whilst you are playing. I thought a bigger problem might be that the ends being fixed together rigidly might force you to hold it in an awkward way.
Maybe having posted this here will encourage me to finish making the thing.
-
But Bill Whaley's MIDI concertina has rigid ends, and he manages OK with it, so simulated bellows movement may be an unnecessary refinement once the player gets used to the instrument.
Very interesting to hear that someone else has gotten this kind of thing to work.
I wanted it to be small and light and I figured that it shouldn't matter if the ends are getting closer together or further apart whilst you are playing. I thought a bigger problem might be that the ends being fixed together rigidly might force you to hold it in an awkward way.
Maybe having posted this here will encourage me to finish making the thing.
Jim are you talkiing this kinda thing?
http://www.flickr.com/photos/stanleylieber/343680887/in/pool-the-art-of-the-concertina#/photos/stanleylieber/343680887/in/pool-1019748@N21/
-
Jim are you talkiing this kinda thing?
http://www.flickr.com/photos/stanleylieber/343680887/in/pool-the-art-of-the-concertina#/photos/stanleylieber/343680887/in/pool-1019748@N21/
Yeah, that looks like the kind of thing I'm trying to do (except melodeon shaped). I'm not sure he has the force sensor thing though. I guess he has a unisonoric layout.
This seems to be the thing Anahata was talking about:
http://www.s-wave.co.uk/controller.html
-
This seems to be the thing Anahata was talking about:
http://www.s-wave.co.uk/controller.html
Exactly the thing (http://www.s-wave.co.uk/history.html) it turns out. His first one was a prototype.
-
I'd actually like to see less on a midi melodeon. Something fairly basic and inexpensive, for an instrument at least, that can be used for silent practice and messing around with different layouts or systems and can be left in a car boot or put in an aircraft hold without worrying about how it'll hold up when travelling.
-
I'm waiting for an i-melodeon.
Take 2 Ipads, and a big heavy duty spring. Glue the spring to the back of each ipad. Wirelessly connect the 2 ipads together so one is treble, one is bass, and use the motion detectors to detect in/out. I really can't think why it hasn't been done already?!
It'd look a little like this: :||:
-
Thinking of smaller MIDI devices... I recall this earlier project... (http://www.users.zetnet.co.uk/alba/midibutt.htm)originally based near Edinburgh (hence the Scottish 'ALBA' branding), but the website gives a later address in Berkshire. Think this project died in the mid/late 90s... even so, the website still lives...
Funny thing was, I discovered it when an elderly relative was taking 'The Sunday Post', published in Dundee - and I chanced to glance at a feature on 'Silicon Glen' (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Silicon_Glen)... including this particular project in some detail... As you can see, it used an Oakwood cabinet - the 'Model 1'... which is/was about the same size as a Lilly, but with 19 bigger (and wider spaced) buttons.
Simon Care (aka 'melodeonplayer' on here) was featured on the publicity. (http://www.users.zetnet.co.uk/alba/gallery.htm) Can't be certain if it ever passed the prototype phase though, 'cos I've never seen any about used... either that, or it was perfect and folks are hanging on to 'em...
Ed J
-
Maybe Rees could make one? ;) A Wesson 'outboard' perhaps?
Wesson Outboard - that is very funny Sara. :D :D :D
-
I'm waiting for an i-melodeon.
Take 2 Ipads, and a big heavy duty spring. Glue the spring to the back of each ipad. Wirelessly connect the 2 ipads together so one is treble, one is bass, and use the motion detectors to detect in/out. I really can't think why it hasn't been done already?!
It'd look a little like this: :||:
There should be a "Like" button on this forum!
Great suggestion Clive :D
-
I'm waiting for an i-melodeon.
Take 2 Ipads, and a big heavy duty spring. Glue the spring to the back of each ipad. Wirelessly connect the 2 ipads together so one is treble, one is bass, and use the motion detectors to detect in/out. I really can't think why it hasn't been done already?!
It'd look a little like this: :||:
You could do the same thing with a Wii controller, as they have accelerometers inside them. And then use computer keyboards like in the poor man's streb. Cheaper than buying 2 iPads, but will include some DIY programming :P
-
Phil Williams built two different concertina's using tupperware boxes and micro switches back in the 90's. One was Anglo the other English. I've still got them in loft my Phil if you need them back. He loaned them to me to develop a midi melodeon as he knew I had been involved with the Howland earlier in the 90's. They were very simple switch devices using a Maplin midi board. The output was anything you wanted dependent on your midi setup, so yes, a simple switch device works very well but limited. The bellows direction felt unreal as the two halves only moved about 2mm, just enough to make a switch. The sophistication of modern midi devices is streets ahead. As is always the case, the prototype and ideas are a lot easier than developing and building a smoothly functioning commercial product.
-
Maybe Rees could make one? ;) A Wesson 'outboard' perhaps?
Wesson Outboard - that is very funny Sara. :D :D :D
I thought you'd like it.
-
What would your 'ideal' be? Am I the only one who wants it as a one row?
I think I'd want three rows, but they could maybe be shorter than usual because you could switch electronically between low and high range for different pieces.
-
How far are we away from a midi harmonica, something that will just send wireless to the house pa. One little gob iron in your top pocket and Roberts your mothers brother.
-
How far are we away from a midi harmonica, something that will just send wireless to the house pa. One little gob iron in your top pocket and Roberts your mothers brother.
We'd be a looooong way from having it sound like a harmonica.
Especially to bend notes blues-style.
-
We'd be a looooong way from having it sound like a harmonica.
Especially to bend notes blues-style.
In the mid seventies Casio brought out a midi Sax / Oboe thing. One of our band bought one. It looked like a child's toy but the sounds were fantastic. It had a wind sensor which was probably better than some of the more professional models. Not being a player myself I can't be sure of the technique but it certainly sounded like he bent the notes. Blowing harder gave more volume but really blowing produced a bend as well. This of course was down a single tube. A harmonica presents different problems but ingenuity and micro electronics will in time, I feel, find a solution.
-
but ingenuity and micro electronics will in time, I feel, find a solution.
But IMHO it would be a solution looking for a problem! Harmonicas are cheap(relatively) small, light, portable, water resistant, the ultimate go-anywhere instrument.
(MIDI: Musical Instrument Devilishly Interfered with)
-
but ingenuity and micro electronics will in time, I feel, find a solution.
But IMHO it would be a solution looking for a problem! Harmonicas are cheap(relatively) small, light, portable, water resistant, the ultimate go-anywhere instrument.
(MIDI: Musical Instrument Devilishly Interfered with)
Agree but found myself thinking of the solution not whether it was needed or not :-[
-
How far are we away from a midi harmonica, something that will just send wireless to the house pa. One little gob iron in your top pocket and Roberts your mothers brother.
We'd be a looooong way from having it sound like a harmonica.
Especially to bend notes blues-style.
Have a look at this on You Tube http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=9SfTDBnQoxM&feature=related (http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=9SfTDBnQoxM&feature=related)
Almo
My first instrument was an harmonica, around about 1958 (lo that dates me) Loads of players for inspiration then too - Larry Adler, Tommy Reilly, Ronald Chesney, Morton Fraser Harmonica Gang, The Three Monarchs. (Sorry for being slightly off topic). Tomy Reilly played the theme tune for the Radio series 'The Navy Lark'.
-
Have a look at this on You Tube http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=9SfTDBnQoxM&feature=related (http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=9SfTDBnQoxM&feature=related)
Almo
Neat! :D
-
What would your 'ideal' be? Am I the only one who wants it as a one row?
nope Im on the waiting list too ;) 4 stop LMMH with individual timbre please
-
2 row, 21 buttons, 24 bass. Customisable layout. Stepped Keyboard. Hawaiian Koa inlaid with sparkly nacreous secretions of assorted endangered sea creatures. Dished buttons. The soundset from the Emu Proteus 2000 Orchestral 1+2/Peter Siedlaczec Orchestra/World Expedition Roms. Blue LEDs and a holographic name badge. Free rucksack. Mally "absolute beginners" book and CD. Plectrum.
Cheers,
J
-
Have a look at this on You Tube http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=9SfTDBnQoxM&feature=related[/url]
Almo
I posted at 9.45 today regarding the rapid increase of electronic technology. I felt it was only at matter of time before Anahata's electronic mouth organ became available I hadn't expected it by 11 minutes past 10
Phew, these Japanese are quick ::)
-
We'd be a looooong way from having it sound like a harmonica.
Especially to bend notes blues-style.
In the mid seventies Casio brought out a midi Sax / Oboe thing. One of our band bought one. It looked like a child's toy but the sounds were fantastic. It had a wind sensor which was probably better than some of the more professional models. Not being a player myself I can't be sure of the technique but it certainly sounded like he bent the notes. Blowing harder gave more volume but really blowing produced a bend as well. This of course was down a single tube. A harmonica presents different problems but ingenuity and micro electronics will in time, I feel, find a solution.
A member of our band has one. It is amazingly effective. He can soar down to play bass or up to play the melody. It helps that he is an exceptional musician. He has a little box so that he can loop himself, which is also fun :P He's currently playing an Eigenharp at the moment though, which is perhaps one of the most extreme electronic instruments :P
-
We'd be a looooong way from having it sound like a harmonica.
Especially to bend notes blues-style.
In the mid seventies Casio brought out a midi Sax / Oboe thing. One of our band bought one. It looked like a child's toy but the sounds were fantastic. It had a wind sensor which was probably better than some of the more professional models. Not being a player myself I can't be sure of the technique but it certainly sounded like he bent the notes. Blowing harder gave more volume but really blowing produced a bend as well. This of course was down a single tube. A harmonica presents different problems but ingenuity and micro electronics will in time, I feel, find a solution.
A member of our band has one. It is amazingly effective. He can soar down to play bass or up to play the melody. It helps that he is an exceptional musician. He has a little box so that he can loop himself, which is also fun :P He's currently playing an Eigenharp at the moment though, which is perhaps one of the most extreme electronic instruments :P
I used to have one too. I really liked it, but it eventually broke and that was the end of that. I've got one of the Akai ones now, which in most respects is much better. And yes, it's extra fun when played through a loop pedal. At one point, I did that as an opening for busking shows. If nothing else, it got people interested in what it was that I was doing. However, it doesn't have the cool sax shape of the Casio, nor the funny little speaker in the horn.
-
Ah, my friend has a Yamaha, not a Casio. Minor brain malfunction there :P The Akai looks really cool, I half considered it at one point. If I was going to get something like that though I'd get an Eigenharp Pico.
-
Ah, my friend has a Yamaha, not a Casio. Minor brain malfunction there :P The Akai looks really cool, I half considered it at one point. If I was going to get something like that though I'd get an Eigenharp Pico.
Ah - quite a big difference between the Yamaha and Casio, I think. The casio was definately in the 'toy' camp, but, for me, that was part of its appeal. The Yamaha is/was a pro-level controller, but with no internal sounds. However, there used to be a separate module particularly suited to it that had particularly high quality wind sounds. I guess that's what you might have heard. My Akai does have internal sounds - but they're very much in the realm of being basic synth sounds, rather than anything designed to emulate real instruments. Personally, I rather like it that way - it doesn't try to be anything that it's not and works accordingly.
The Pico's look fun - but need a computer in order to function. For what I've used it for, that wouldn't be as useful as the generally self-contained Akai.
-
If it would be possible, I'd just like a wooden 2.5 row D/G with handmade reeds, top and bottom stops for octave and thirds.
Then, I'd like to see added, (internally) a velocity and direction sensor for the bellows, triggers on all the buttons, and a stop system to cut all the reeds when the box is midi'ed to one of my several keyboards, or even a plain midi box.
The Melodeon could then be played normally, and just used as a midi source when required.
Best of both worlds.
-
I think the question should be why do you want a midi melodeon.....
I can understand Phill Cunningham having a midi button accordeon with all the multitude of bass note available as piano etc...but you are limited with a melodeon layout.
And Phill Cunningham can actually use the thing...
What would you actually do with a midi melodeon that could be justified... ?
-
What would you actually do with a midi melodeon that could be justified... ?
This, perhaps? http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=T-eEtjyH3E8 (http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=T-eEtjyH3E8)
-
In my case, the answer is simple.
For fun!
I can play most instruments to a very basic standard, ie, I can just about extract a tune from most tubes and strings, but I play a melodeon to a very reasonable standard.
Using this skill means I can have fun with midi. Using a 'melodeon' to play a keyboard, mess with a virtual folk band, play the drums, impress my less knowledgeable friends with my virtuosity - FUN!
But that's purely a means to an end. Midi will never replace the real thing. Midi can never reproduce the nuances or expression that a real box produces in the hands of an expert player, now, or ever. By definition, a MIDI instrument is false, fake, ersatz, a lie! They have their place, and I have to admit that some of the music I've heard from the Roland is astonishingly good. There is something missing though. Soul.
Without soul, listening to a MIDI instrument even played live, would be like listening to a recording - good, perhaps even exceptional, but not the real thing.
I'd love one to play with, it would be great, but in the final analysis, If I could have only one box, I'd choose to play a cheap £200 Chinese box over a £2000 electronic facsimilie every time!
Best wishes,
A Luddite!!
-
What would you actually do with a midi melodeon that could be justified... ?
This, perhaps? http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=T-eEtjyH3E8 (http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=T-eEtjyH3E8)
I can play that much better on my Technics MIDI Piano - and it cost less.
Seriously, apart from the reason I have postulated above, why?? Why would anybody really want, or need to play this sort of music on a melodeon?? It's plain daft!!
-
I would echo savantuc's remarks above but go a little further. I have always said FR18, Streb etc are midi gateways and should not be considered as melodeon substitutes. When used in a band through a PA, they become a little closer to the real thing when mixed in an overall sound and the dancers want the rythm but they really come into their own when used for say bass and piano while someone else plays 'real' reeds. You can draft in a brass or woodwind section for a number or part of a number. You can provide a steel band or any other daft mix just for that extra bit of fun and entertainment. Like all music 'tricks' they should be used sparingly and sympathetically.
-
Seriously, apart from the reason I have postulated above, why?? Why would anybody really want, or need to play this sort of music on a melodeon?? It's plain daft!!
OK, here's my take on it. To my way of thinking, all musical instruments have two distinct components that, when combined, give the instrument it's own character. The first of these is whatever gizmo is present that vibrates the air and makes and sound. The second is the interface - the thing(s) that humans manipulate to get it to do stuff.
Melodeons (real ones) obviously have quite an esoteric interface that differs greatly from many other instruments. The whole push/pull idea and the way it affects phrasing, articulation, dynamics and rhythm is something that can't easily be replicated by other devices. Thus, if the opportunity is there to apply that interface (and the skills developed around it) to a different kind of sound source (in this case, a digital synthesizer), it seems reasonable to expect that there's every opportunity to create something distinctive. Personally, when listening to Clive's music, I can very easily hear traits that suggest that the music has been created using a melodeon-like interface. That, to me, seems as good a reason for doing it as any.
Of course, if you don't like the sound of a digital sound source, or don't feel it's appropriate for the genre of music you play, then such instruments are quite possibly of no interest. But that doesn't necessarily make them pointless for everyone else.
-
I can play that much better on my Technics MIDI Piano - and it cost less.
I can't so a midi device would be good for me. ;D
-
I'd love an accurate Hurdy Hurdy sound for my French tunes....
-
Just sample a cat squealing ;D
I think it's Hurdy Gurdy.
-
I can play that much better on my Technics MIDI Piano - and it cost less.
To add to what has already been said - I can't play a keyboard to that standard - but can have a good go on a melodeon interface
-
It seems to me there's no need for any disagreements on 'real' vs 'midi':
Surely, most if not all players like the acoustic sound a reed box makes?
Equally, many players (most of them also in the first group) would probably like the flexibility in sounds, tunings and ease of playing that a midi box can give.
So both are likely to have their use - the issue is whether there's a third possibility, a box that will give both?
And on this, the jury's still out, I would suggest. The FR18 may do the job, but it may be too unwieldy to satisfy smaller box players, and/or it may not produce a natural enough sound. I'm not convinced that the push-pull sound can't easily be replicated electronically, I think it's just a question of having the right transducers. And I also suggest it ought to be technically possible to go one better than the reed by having touch sensitive buttons. What's more, keyboard sounds are now so lifelike that I don't see an unsurmountable difficulty in reproducing the box sound with a MIDI box. The FR18 may well please CBA and Steirischer players, and maybe also large box players, but I think it's probably still valid to say we still need an FR19.
-
Just sample a cat squealing ;D
I think it's Hurdy Gurdy.
I once heard a nice description - wasp in a bottle....
I'd love to be allowed to play a Hurdy Gurdy, but players are usually very defensive - just in case you touch the wheel and transfere any grease to it from your fingers - it stops the contact between wheel and strings...
When I first heard one ages ago - without seeing it, I thought it was some sort of synth....Then I saw Rossbif at Sidmouth.....
There used to be load of players turn up for a French Music session in Nottingham some time ago...lovely stuff. Horses Brawl 3rd part, played in Dm to stuff us melodeon players.
-
Post snipped since it's only a couple of posts above!
That all seems about right to me. I think EVERY box player likes the sound of a traditional instrument, it is what attracted us to it in the first place. If I really really had to choose one box to keep, it would probably be my old black Erica. But the Streb lets me play around, keeps my interest in some well worn tunes by allowing me to play in different keys (which does encourage playing in a different way somehow) etc etc. I use the melodeon samples almost exclusively, only bothering with the vast majority of the standard MIDI samples when showing people what the instrument does. The exception being that using organ sounds for the bass end is quite nice!
To me, the Roland is too big and too plastic and doesn't have an internal speaker (I think). Not portable therefore in the same way a Pokerwork is. If they made a properly portable melodeon sized instrument with a wide range of box samples, it might appeal much more. Although I suspect the market would be a relatively small subset of the whole diatonic accordion market...
It might be interesting if someone did a bit of innovative thinking as far as an 'electric' squeezebox is concerned. How about a setting to bend the treble notes depending on bellows pressure?
-
How about a setting to bend the treble notes depending on bellows pressure?
Now that would be fun, but I would link the bend control to button pressure. Bellows pressure is needed for dynamics.
-
It might be interesting if someone did a bit of innovative thinking as far as an 'electric' squeezebox is concerned. How about a setting to bend the treble notes depending on bellows pressure?
I agree, that could be really interesting, and I think even more so if it used button pressure.
The thing about an accordion is that it is fundamentally a really ergonomic way of translating what a musician wants from music - melody, rhythm, chordal accompaniment and bass, into life. Therefore, a MIDI instrument ought to be huge success, once its design has been thought through properly. The trouble is perhaps that innovative designers may be put off by the small immediate market, and fail to see the eventual possibilities.
-
Designers seem so far to be intent on ape-ing the melodeon, and that,s good. It will be Mk2 designs which start to add 'new' features, touch sensitivity, pitch bend, slides and all the other gizmos which now appear on even the cheapest keyboard. Today a £125 keyboard gives you not only pianos and organs of every description but almost a full synth as well. Melodeons will never make the mass market but a midi one may well expand the market dramatically and bring in players who would never have dreamed of playing a diatonic instrument. Don't expect these new people to be folkies though.
-
what about electric rather than midi melodeon with whammy bar and wah wah pedal?
-
what about electric rather than midi melodeon with whammy bar and wah wah pedal?
Been there, done that. Not quite the whammy bar, but I use to plug my miked up box into guitar effects pedals to add some 'interesting' sounds. Great fun ;D
-
what about electric rather than midi melodeon with whammy bar and wah wah pedal?
Been there, done that. Not quite the whammy bar, but I use to plug my miked up box into guitar effects pedals to add some 'interesting' sounds. Great fun ;D
With some 'wha wha' and 'distortion' you could be the melodeon answer to Jimi Hendrix.....Speed The Plough Wha wah.........
-
Designers seem so far to be intent on ape-ing the melodeon, and that,s good. It will be Mk2 designs which start to add 'new' features, touch sensitivity, pitch bend, slides and all the other gizmos which now appear on even the cheapest keyboard. Today a £125 keyboard gives you not only pianos and organs of every description but almost a full synth as well. Melodeons will never make the mass market but a midi one may well expand the market dramatically and bring in players who would never have dreamed of playing a diatonic instrument. Don't expect these new people to be folkies though.
This was my point, made in an earlier post. You need to connect a MIDI melodeon to an amp, (lets face it, built in speakers will never cut the mustard), so why not, as is my proposal, utilise a standard melodeon, fit velocity and direction sensors to the bellows, and triggers to all the keys, then you could connect a standard melodeon to a MIDI source.
The velocity sensors, working with the MIDI source/MIDI keyboard's touch sensitivity sensors would allow all the nuances and expression that one extracts when playing as a NORMAL melodeon.
Hence, you have what is in effect a MIDI melodeon, yet one which looks identical, and can be played exactly the same as a standard high quality pneumatic box.
-
Looking at the various videos doing the rounds I think that we're in danger of defining the debate around the music we play which, yes, is a limited market. However if you look at the European and American markets there seem to be a larger number of players of many different genres and that may well be a large part (or even the largest) part of Roland's market. They carefully call it a "Diatonic Accordion" not a melodeon.
As far as whammy bars etc, which hand would one use to operate them? (and yes, I have put a squeezebox through a guitar effects board).
I see a clear divide here, for some band work or for recording (especially other sounds, I wonder if it would if it could be used with the EastWest Orchestral samples or Haupfwerk) I can see a use for one, especially for those of us with limited keyboard skills. For a session down the pub I think I'll be old-fashioned. (:)
Steve
-
Just sample a cat squealing ;D
I think it's Hurdy Gurdy.
I once heard a nice description - wasp in a bottle....
I'd love to be allowed to play a Hurdy Gurdy, but players are usually very defensive - just in case you touch the wheel and transfere any grease to it from your fingers - it stops the contact between wheel and strings...
When I first heard one ages ago - without seeing it, I thought it was some sort of synth....Then I saw Rossbif at Sidmouth.....
There used to be load of players turn up for a French Music session in Nottingham some time ago...lovely stuff. Horses Brawl 3rd part, played in Dm to stuff us melodeon players.
Most of us are more than willing to let people have a go, its how most of us got started out on them! I've heard lots of things about how touching the wheel is terrible for the instrument, but it's all over exaggerated. The worst thing is adjusting the straps to let someone else play, those one size fits all things are a pain in the butt ::)
Just to stay on topic..
Would love to have a go on one of these new fangled midi things (:)
-
Savantuc said "so why not, as is my proposal, utilise a standard melodeon, fit velocity and direction sensors to the bellows, and triggers to all the keys, then you could connect a standard melodeon to a MIDI source."
Well two reasons really. One, cost. You would need to add the cost of the electronics to an expensive instrument and in my opinion devalue the host instrument into the bargain. Secondly, a conversion never seems to be as good as purpose built, plus key changes are impossible without another large cost of fitting stops to eliminate the reeds. The early midi PA's fitted sensors to existing boxes where key changes were not an issue. They quickly went out of favour. Two of my friends had one and the main draw back was the presence of the reeds. These retro fits were from Mr Watkins of the 'Copycat' fame. I did hear tell that he had also converted some melodeons but I don't know anyone to confirm that. So it may or may not already have been done.
I did build a midi bass panel once to fix over the existing bass buttons and used it for string bass, electric bass, low piano, drums and other rhythm sounds etc. It looked naff and felt awful to play and was uni-sonic which I found difficult but the sound was great in a band situation. I ditched it very quickly. I hope the FR18 is better.
-
That answers my question very satisfactorily, thank you. If it's be tried, and found wanting, that's an end to it.
-
That answers my question very satisfactorily, thank you. If it's be tried, and found wanting, that's an end to it.
I'm still hoping someone on the forum can confirm or deny that WEM ala Charlie Marshall of the Copycat fame ever sold or fitted any of his midi conversion kits.
-
Hi Doug
The very thing (http://cgi.ebay.co.uk/ITALIAN-CLUB-HARMONICA-BARO-RAMONA-CASSOTTO-ACCORDION-/320647071757?pt=UK_MusicalInstr_Keyboard_RL&hash=item4aa80e080d#ht_823wt_932) you were asking about. See pic 8
Martin
-
That answers my question very satisfactorily, thank you. If it's be tried, and found wanting, that's an end to it.
I'm still hoping someone on the forum can confirm or deny that WEM ala Charlie Marshall of the Copycat fame ever sold or fitted any of his midi conversion kits.
I will deny it!
Once asked him about fitting one to a P. Soprani and, as I recall, he said something like "that's only a b....y melodeon, not a proper accordion, ask John Lesley about doing it"
-
Hi Doug
The very thing (http://cgi.ebay.co.uk/ITALIAN-CLUB-HARMONICA-BARO-RAMONA-CASSOTTO-ACCORDION-/320647071757?pt=UK_MusicalInstr_Keyboard_RL&hash=item4aa80e080d#ht_823wt_932) you were asking about. See pic 8
Martin
Hi Martin,
Thanks for that. Looking at the pics, it looks like quite an early conversion, and very complicated. Having seen the pics, it makes a good case for having a purpose designed MIDI box.
I'd hate for anything to go wrong with this one!
-
IMHO the big problem with playing a box fitted with reeds and midi is that unless you can mute the reeds when you switch to another layout or sound you, the player, are still going to hear the reeds as tuned.
On the VARIAX "acoustic" guitar there's a setting that allows you to change from "standard" tuning to DADGAD without retuning. Which is fine but then what is coming out of the amp bears no relation to what you're playing and it's probably the least used gimmick on the guitar. Even when used as standard there is usually a delay between what you play and what comes out of the proccessor so you have great fun trying to focus on the sound out of the amp and not the sound on your lap.
Been there, done that, sold the guitar!
Steve
-
Self Tuning Guitar
Here is the Gibson http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=WetVXbYRfWk (http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=WetVXbYRfWk)
Changes tunings too at the turn of a switch..
-
Self Tuning Guitar
Here is the Gibson http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=WetVXbYRfWk (http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=WetVXbYRfWk)
Changes tunings too at the turn of a switch..
Problem with the Variax is that it doesn't retune the guitar physically, it's all in the electronics.
Steve