Melodeon.net Forums

Discussions => General Discussion => Topic started by: Bryson on June 04, 2008, 09:48:35 PM

Title: Advice wanted - Retuning 2.5 row (23+4) D/G Salterelle Connemara II
Post by: Bryson on June 04, 2008, 09:48:35 PM
I've owned my Salty Conny II for about a year now and have come up with a draft re-tuning.

During the drafting period I began to realise what a can of worms I'd opened up for myself.

Hence this request for advice. As usual the carrot would be "a cool blond" i.e. a glass of cold pils :) should any of you good people ever wander over to Berlin.

The link below opens a pdf with my draft tuning, on a stave (pages 1 & 2), a diagram of my draft retuning (page 3) and the current tuning as I bought it.

Can anyone see a major omission?

Can anyone suggest an improvement?

A little of what I intend to play may also help:
I play mostly traditional dance music. What I call "Isles' Music" * i.e. English, Scottish, Irish, Welsh, Faeroe Isles etc etc
I took up cross rowing last year after a number of years banging away along the row on my trusty Pokerwork.

Thanks in anticipation of having to supply a few cool blonds :)

Bryson

http://www.e724.de/MUSIC/connemara_new_tuning_080523.pdf



*my inspiration being a history book by Norman Davies called simple "The Isles"
Title: Re: Advice wanted - Retuning 2.5 row (23+4) D/G Salterelle Connemara II
Post by: Dazbo on June 05, 2008, 04:04:05 PM
Not my area - all these buttons - but it looks like you can play an F in three octaves on the push but your F basses are on the pull.  Is this desirable?
Title: Re: Advice wanted - Retuning 2.5 row (23+4) D/G Salterelle Connemara II
Post by: Clive Williams on June 05, 2008, 04:29:53 PM
Not my area - all these buttons - but it looks like you can play an F in three octaves on the push but your F basses are on the pull.  Is this desirable?

Yep, I agree, that's not a good thing, is it? I'd keep the F basses on the pull, so you have F# basses on the push (which is good if you're playing in D and want to stick a F#m chord in, like you can with a Bm chord when you're playing in G). Reverse the direction of the F accidentals if you can. Also, consider reversing the direction of the D# accidentals so they're on the push - the only sensible chord I've found to play against that note is B major (i.e. B minor with thirds off) which is of course on the push.

Cheers,

Clive

Title: Re: Advice wanted - Retuning 2.5 row (23+4) D/G Salterelle Connemara II
Post by: smiley on June 09, 2008, 05:39:20 AM
I use the same button layout as your  'new tuning' on the treble side of my 19 button 2-row D/G, except I don't have the luxury of button 1 (or the 1/2 row of accidentals). This setup works well for the irish stuff I mostly play, especially having the low G and B there on the D row. I've got a feeling the low F natural would be nice to have on the pull, but at least you'll have it available somewhere handy.
Title: Re: Advice wanted - Retuning 2.5 row (23+4) D/G Salterelle Connemara II
Post by: Bryson on June 12, 2008, 11:38:36 AM
Hi All
Many thanks for the constructive suggestions. Here is the edited retuning:

http://www.e724.de/MUSIC/connemara_new_tuning_080612.pdf

Don't forget to collect your cool blond pils if you're ever in Berlin  :)

cheers
Bryson

PS apologies to Theo as I should have started this topic under "Instrument construction etc"
Title: Re: Advice wanted - Retuning 2.5 row (23+4) D/G Salterelle Connemara II
Post by: Bryson on August 26, 2008, 09:56:47 PM
So here I am some time later with the final tuning layout of my D/G Saltarelle Connemara II

http://www.e724.de/MUSIC/final_tuning_2008_08.pdf

Thanks to all who assisted - though the weather here is more Glühwein then Pils .. the offer is always open.
Although the cool weather gives me an excuse to get to grips with the C Major scale :)
SimplePortal 2.3.5 © 2008-2012, SimplePortal