Melodeon.net Forums
Discussions => General Discussion => Topic started by: savantuk on January 19, 2011, 10:29:52 AM
-
Hi,
I'm a newbie here, so I don't know whether these subjects have been discussed before, and I apologise if they have, but I'd be interested in members opinions.
Why are melodeons so expensive?? Why can a quality 1 row 4 stop cost more than a 2 row, 3v? Why does a Lily cost so much?
A good quality 3 voice 2 row Italian melodeon will cost around £1500. A good quality Italian 72 bass accordian can be had for a lot less.
Why?? The accordian will have many times the amount of reeds, valves, blocks, couplers and parts. The case is bigger, and often more decorative. Surely it should cost a lot more?? Even those with handmade reeds seem to be far better value for money.
Why do good quality 1 row 4 stop boxes cost so much?? OK, they have more reeds on the treble side, but fewer in the bass. The case is much smaller too, but a Castagnari Max will cost more than, say a Studio or a Sander, and a Hohner pokerwork 1 row 4 stop will cost much more than the newer Ariette (which I think is something of a bargain.)
And the biggest mystery of all is the Lily! Why £1500?? Single voice, ok, hand made reeds, but still a single voice, small case simple grille, undecorated case. I've had one, and loved it - it was a thing of wonder, but it wasn't the easiest to play due to high pressure low volume issues, was too quiet for dance use. There are better boxes for a lot less.
These differences become more apparent second hand.
A top of the range Italian accordian, 120 bass tipo mano reeds for under £1000. A top of the range Italian melodeon, 2 row 8 bass tipo mano reeds for as much as £2.5K+, though to be fair, you could hunt one out for £1500.
Is it all down to economy of scale? I wonder??
-
Sometimes we need an outside view to make us look at what we take for granted. I think your points are fair and valid. Not being a manufacturer I can't answer them but it's also true of the new FR18 £1650 against £1050 for the PA version FR1. Sure the pressure sensor has to work out which way the bellows are going and there's a bit more software mapping for the keyboard. Fewer bass buttons as you point out, so why?
-
I'm sure economy of scale is one factor. Piano accordions are played worldwide in a wider range of musical contexts. Diatonic are more or less restricted to some European and N American markets, and many of those markets seem to need different versions. There is also the issue of standardisation. A particular model of 72 bass PA is always the same instrument. A diatonic model may have 5 or 6 different tunings, and that is just the common ones!
In the end its because there are enough people willing to pay for quality instruments.
-
The thing is....when buying any musical instrument, buy the one that suits your style of playing and you feel comfortable and happy with.
Just because an instrument is mega expensive, it doesn't mean it's the one you should buy or aspire to.
The price of Castagnari boxes has got silly now, and they also seem to vary in playability like a lot of instruments do (I have played some really expensive guitars which are truly awful) but then it always comes down to a personal choise.
Like most things - it's what the manufacturers can get away with charging really..
It's also easy to fall in love with the 'look' of an instrument, and forget the tone and playability of it, or want one just because 'so-and-so' plays one and you want to be just like them.
Having said all that - I really really really want the Dino Baffetti/Oakwood from The Music Room http://www.themusicroom-online.co.uk/product_info.php?products_id=4165 (http://www.themusicroom-online.co.uk/product_info.php?products_id=4165)
Almo..
-
Here's a breakdown of manufacturing costs for a Wesson Clipper one row four stop which I sell at £1600.
TAM reeds, bellows and other materials total around £500.
So that's £1100 for labour, marketing etc.
Say it takes me 20 days to make one, including tuning.
Assuming 8 hour working days, that's 160 hours.
£1100 pounds divided by 160 hours comes to £6.88 per hour or £275 for a 40 hour week.
Expensive, my arse!!! ;D
-
So that's £1100 for labour, marketing etc.
Marketing? Do ya wanna buy some advertising space? ;)
-
I'm sure economy of scale is one factor. Piano accordions are played worldwide in a wider range of musical contexts. Diatonic are more or less restricted to some European and N American markets, and many of those markets seem to need different versions. There is also the issue of standardisation. A particular model of 72 bass PA is always the same instrument. A diatonic model may have 5 or 6 different tunings, and that is just the common ones!
In the end its because there are enough people willing to pay for quality instruments.
Hi Theo,
I don't feel that the context in which an instrument is played, should in any way effect it's cost.
An PA is in every way more complicated and therefore must cost more to build than a melodeon. QED.
A melodeon in B/C for the Irish market shouldn't cost more than one in DG for the English market, and clearly they dont, and in particular chromatic instruments (apart perhaps for style) should cost the same for whatever market they are intended.
I agree, that there may be some slight vagaries in price due to regional costs/taxes, but a reed is a reed is a reed, whatever tuning, be it hand made or factory made, within each division, the price should remain the same. Specialist reeds should and will demand a premium, ie Binci, but as these are mostly aftermarket improvements, the would not, in general affect the price of a new instrument, unless specced as O/E, in which case one should expect the instrument to cost more.
Reeds fitted to production Diatonic boxes are usually manufacturers preferences - you know that in the majority of cases, a pokerwork will always come wet side of swing, Paolo Soprani/Dino Bafetti will mostly come swing, and Castagnari will come slightly dry of swing. Cajun boxes will be dry, and Organetto's will come swing. Reed tuning therefore only becomes an issue if you want to have the reeds tuned aftermarket.
We therefore return to my original question - is it a matter of production numbers, or do manufacturers charge more for melodeons??
-
Here's a breakdown of manufacturing costs for a Wesson Clipper one row four stop which I sell at £1600.
TAM reeds, bellows and other materials total around £500.
So that's £1100 for labour, marketing etc.
Say it takes me 20 days to make one, including tuning.
Assuming 8 hour working days, that's 160 hours.
£1100 pounds divided by 160 hours comes to £6.88 per hour or £275 for a 40 hour week.
Expensive, my arse!!! ;D
Rees,
I would never say that a melodeon is expensive in that sense. The enjoyment one gets, and can give from one is beyond price.
One can in no way compare the price of one of your handmade 1 row 4 stop to a high quality but mass market model such as the Castagnari Max. Indeed, I can quite confidently say, having played both, that I would prefer yours, even if it is cheaper.
This however isn't the point. Your melodeon is worth every penny. A truly beautifully handmade item will always demand a premium, which is why I would prefer one of Johns Oakwood boxes every time to the equivalent from Castagnari.
My question was, in essence why does a 72 bass accordion from, say Paolo Soprani or Hohner, cost less than a 2 row 8 bass melodeon from the same factory??
Just imagine how much a 72 bass accordeon with 4 or 5 couplers would cost if you had to make it by hand?? I'd guess a fair bit more than twice what you would charge for the smaller and less complicated melodeon.
I was in the business of selling melodeons and acordeons too for a good few years, so I know how much they cost at trade, and there is no way I could ever have got the price of a Pokerwork anywhere close to a Hohner PA.
-
Whoa Rees
Not getting at individual, hand crafted items such as yours but looking at the mass producers and the differentials. An FR1 PA is exactly the same gubbins as an FR18 with a few slight differences. IMHO not £600 worth. Theo's point about the size of markets is very valid as there are development costs to recoup but Savantok made a general query as to why Melodeons with less components cost more than a PA.
Your costings would be entirely different if you used production methods instead of hand crafting, even though I know you have built jigs etc to assist, but then your product wouldn't be 'hand made' and so wouldn't command a premium, as they say in marketing. A production Honnor 4 stop is £580 but cannot be compared with a Wesson Clipper.
Looking at my box inventory, no one can accuse me of not buying premium products so I'm definitely not trying to start a witch hunt.
amend to generally agree with savantuk
-
Oh, I almost forgot the small investment of £20,000 in workshop and machinery. ;)
-
I've just remembered a good case for high quality handmade boxes not costing a fortune.
Step forward the 'Irish Dancemasters' Sarasota.
This is a hand made 2 row, 8 bass, 3 voice box in popular tunings, sold with 1st grade handmade reeds, for around £1000 (made in USA, so you'd have to pay taxes). This is a truly handmade box for 2/3rds the price of the cheapest full size Castagnari, the Studio, which only has machine reeds.
I played one at Shrewsbury a couple of years ago, and the owner only wanted £800. It was a fabulous sounding box, and if I'd had the money I may have bought it.... well perhaps not, it was green celluloid!!
-
Rees,
Just an observation,
Your hand-made squeezeboxs look interesting, but the web site aint doing you any favours with the design - and there are no video / sound links to anything - so no-one knows what they sound like.
There is a bit of stuff on You Tube http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=dQ_bbVNRHbU (http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=dQ_bbVNRHbU) but no mention of where you are / contact number / weblink.
Why don't you link to that clip from your own website ? Great sounding box and nice playing too..
There are loads of ways to blag free marketing by using YouTube / MySpace / Facebook / Twitter and by optimising your web pages so they can be found by search engines such as Google a lot easier.
You need a website domain called something like www.handmademelodeons.com so that Google will pick up on search words that people might use if they are looking for a hand made melodeon. People won't type into a search 'Wesson Accordeons' because they would not have heard of you.
Nice looking boxes though :)
Almo
-
This seems like an old subject posted in November 2005
http://melodeon.aimoo.com/category/are-melodeons-over-priced-1-87282.html (http://melodeon.aimoo.com/category/are-melodeons-over-priced-1-87282.html)
Almo
-
Rees,
Just an observation,
Your hand-made squeezeboxs look interesting, but the web site aint doing you any favours with the design - and there are no video / sound links to anything - so no-one knows what they sound like.
There is a bit of stuff on You Tube but not really an advert or example of your craftsmanship - and I think it might be in Welsh to - I don't read Welsh.
There are loads of ways to blag free marketing by using YouTube / MySpace / Facebook / Twitter and by optimising your web pages so they can be found by search engines such as Google a lot easier.
You need a website domain called something like www.handmademelodeons.com so that Google will pick up on search words that people might use if they are looking for a hand made melodeon. People won't type into a search 'Wesson Accordeons' because they would not have heard of you.
Nice looking boxes though :)
Almo
Rees will perhaps confirm this, but I suspect his order book is as full as he needs it to be. His instruments are actually well-known and held in very high regard by the UK melodeon-playing community, and rightly so, for they are superb in quality, both in construction workmanship and for the sound and playability.
I don't read Welsh.
Well, now. There's nice project for you to embark upon. (:)
-
Almo's link is to a five year old post, but the prices seem to be about thirty years out of date. An Erica for £49 ???
Steve. I don't think anyone is in anyway demeaning handmade boxes, Ree's or anyone else. The Q was about similar boxes from the same production line costing more when configured as a melodeon than a PA when there are fewer parts in the melodeon.
-
Steve. I don't think anyone is in anyway demeaning handmade boxes, Ree's or anyone else.
Agreed - and I didn't take it that way. My point was that large-scale advertising exposure is not always desirable. There is no advantage in it if you are already selling as many as you can make or want to make.
-
Rees will perhaps confirm this, but I suspect his order book is as full as he needs it to be. His instruments are actually well-known and held in very high regard by the UK melodeon-playing community, and rightly so, for they are superb in quality, both in construction workmanship and for the sound and playability.
I was just picking up on Rees's comment about costs which included marketing - which can be a huge expense for a small business, and just making a suggestion of how advertising can cost you virtually nothing if you know how. It's always good to save some hard earned cash somewhere...
In my own trade (when there is work about) if someone Googles for a kitchen desiger in Nottingham or Derby - I'm on the first Google results page..I need to re-design my sites..
I'd be delighted to hear that Rees has a full order book, his Clipper sounds great, but I have been playing melodeon for about 20 years I suppose, and never heard of or seen his lovely squeezeboxs.
An old mate of mine makes beautiful hand built guitars - but if you Google that - his name isn't there..here's the link http://www.northworthy.com/ (http://www.northworthy.com/). I know his order book is full - which is great, he makes guitars of outstanding value to order.
If you have a quality product that everyone would love - shout about it...or people will continue to buy Italian boxes or American Guitars which are sometimes not a patch on instruments made in Britain or such good quality and value.
Almo
-
If you think quality melodeons are overpriced, check how much a quality hand-made violin costs!
-
£1100 pounds divided by 160 hours comes to £6.88 per hour or £275 for a 40 hour week.
So you're just in this for the money then. Which poor souls are you exploiting at this sorry wage in order to support your lavish lifestyle?
-
The likes of Rees and, from the concertina world, Colin Dipper have no need of advertising in the same way as Morgan Cars. They all have order books that are as full as they want and buyers can sell on at a premium when they receive the goods, in fact I have seen people selling places in Colin's order book, mind you not sure he knows/approves!
-
Rees will perhaps confirm this, but I suspect his order book is as full as he needs it to be. His instruments are actually well-known and held in very high regard by the UK melodeon-playing community, and rightly so, for they are superb in quality, both in construction workmanship and for the sound and playability.
I was just picking up on Rees's comment about costs which included marketing - which can be a huge expense for a small business, and just making a suggestion of how advertising can cost you virtually nothing if you know how. It's always good to save some hard earned cash somewhere...
In my own trade (when there is work about) if someone Googles for a kitchen desiger in Nottingham or Derby - I'm on the first Google results page..I need to re-design my sites..
I'd be delighted to hear that Rees has a full order book, his Clipper sounds great, but I have been playing melodeon for about 20 years I suppose, and never heard of or seen his lovely squeezeboxs.
An old mate of mine makes beautiful hand built guitars - but if you Google that - his name isn't there..here's the link http://www.northworthy.com/ (http://www.northworthy.com/). I know his order book is full - which is great, he makes guitars of outstanding value to order.
If you have a quality product that everyone would love - shout about it...or people will continue to buy Italian boxes or American Guitars which are sometimes not a patch on instruments made in Britain or such good quality and value.
It's very confusing when you don't use the 'quote' feature properly.
I actually wrote this bit:
Rees will perhaps confirm this, but I suspect his order book is as full as he needs it to be. His instruments are actually well-known and held in very high regard by the UK melodeon-playing community, and rightly so, for they are superb in quality, both in construction workmanship and for the sound and playability.
To quote a chunk of text, either use the 'quote' or 'insert quote' option when replying. Alternatively you can type in the tag directly:
To start a quoted section type {quote} but replace the curly brackets by square brackets. To close a quoted section type {/quote}, and similarly replace the curly brackets by square brackets.
I'd be delighted to hear that Rees has a full order book, his Clipper sounds great, but I have been playing melodeon for about 20 years I suppose, and never heard of or seen his lovely squeezeboxs.
Your best chance is to go to some of the English sessions and workshops: English Country Music Weekend, Melodeons and More in Mendlesham, East Anglian Traditional Music Day in Stowmarket, Melodeons at Witney, Sidmouth Folk Festival, Shrewsbury FF, etc. readily come to mind. Then there are the Welsh music events, and Cajun/Zydeco events in various places. Rees is a talented player and performer; highly entertaining, and a superb craftsman.
-
Thank you all for your suggestions re. marketing. I don't spend a penny on it but it does take a lot of time answering e-mails and other admin stuff.
Steve and Lester have it about right when they quote the Dipper factor. I have a full order book and plenty of gigs - life is good. (:)
The very last thing I wish to do is increase production (there are motorcycles to be tinkered with, you know).
Re: PA/melodeon prices. I do think most Italian makers charge a premium for diatonics, although Castagnari are so far ahead of the competition that I think their prices are well justified. Also a top line Pigini PA will certainly cost you more than the most expensive Castagnari melodeon.
-
Glad to see we have all :-* and made up.
Actually Rees, I think you have just run your most intensive marketing campaign so far (:)
Well done dude.
-
On the surface it might look like you're paying a lot for something else but in most cases there's usually a very good reason for the extra cost. The notable exception being unashamed luxury goods that are intentionally overpriced to foster exclusivity, (eg, Rolex raising prices by 10% year on year whether economic conditions warrant it or not).
Re: PA/melodeon prices. I do think most Italian makers charge a premium for diatonics, although Castagnari are so far ahead of the competition that I think their prices are well justified. Also a top line Pigini PA will certainly cost you more than the most expensive Castagnari melodeon.
Let's see, £5k for a Castagnari Handry 18 and £39k for a Pigini Mythos...I think you might have a point there. ;D
I've just remembered a good case for high quality handmade boxes not costing a fortune.
Step forward the 'Irish Dancemasters' Sarasota.
This is a hand made 2 row, 8 bass, 3 voice box in popular tunings, sold with 1st grade handmade reeds, for around £1000 (made in USA, so you'd have to pay taxes). This is a truly handmade box for 2/3rds the price of the cheapest full size Castagnari, the Studio, which only has machine reeds.
I played one at Shrewsbury a couple of years ago, and the owner only wanted £800. It was a fabulous sounding box, and if I'd had the money I may have bought it.... well perhaps not, it was green celluloid!!
The Dancemaster boxes are Chinese units fitted with Italian reeds and set up in the USA, there's absolutely no way anybody could sell a truly handmade instrument for £1000 and stay in business. I think his advertising is very misleading...
-
If you think quality melodeons are overpriced, check how much a quality hand-made violin costs!
If you think quality melodeons are overpriced, check how much a quality hand-made violin bow costs! :o
-
I'd have to say that the Sarasota by Dancemaster is actually not completely hand made. The components are Chinese and the Reeds Binci and the complete package put together and fettled by Michael Usui. The box might be called "hand finished" and as excellent as they are Michael himself would be the first one to tell you they aren't "Hand Made" so to speak. I know it might be quibbling but the distinction should be made! I'm not sure that he makes any claim to them being Hand Made. :-\ As a matter of fact I just had a look at the website and he says "assembled" in his workshop. I doubt any maker would say my accordions come from China and I put them together in my workshop. One mans marketing is another mans Disassembling, that was a bad pun but true!
-
Like Rees, I think I'd get a little defensive if I thought someone was saying handmade one rows are too expensive, but I read the original post not to say this at all, but to discuss the disparity between different types of accordion prices. A fair question it seems, and maybe even one with a logical answer.
I know several one row builders in my home area, and if any of them were in it for the money, they'd be better off digging ditches. ;D
-
Having said all that - I really really really want the Dino Baffetti/Oakwood from The Music Room http://www.themusicroom-online.co.uk/product_info.php?products_id=4165 (http://www.themusicroom-online.co.uk/product_info.php?products_id=4165)
Almo..
I played one in the shop recently and hated it! Couldn't see/feel/hear what had been added (apart from the price). Preferred the BP II. It's all a question of what you're looking for.
Steve
-
Also a top line Pigini PA will certainly cost you more than the most expensive Castagnari melodeon.
A Pigini Bandoneon will also cost you more than a handmade Guens or a mint condition Arnold.
Steve
-
I'd be delighted to hear that Rees has a full order book, his Clipper sounds great, but I have been playing melodeon for about 20 years I suppose, and never heard of or seen his lovely squeezeboxs.
He's only been making them for... er, less than two years I think.
-
Rees will perhaps confirm this, but I suspect his order book is as full as he needs it to be. His instruments are actually well-known and held in very high regard by the UK melodeon-playing community, and rightly so, for they are superb in quality, both in construction workmanship and for the sound and playability.
I assumed from Steve's comment that Rees had been making them for longer than two years...that explains why I haven't knowingly seen/heard one. :||:
-
So Rees whenya going to start making two rows?
-
Here's a breakdown of manufacturing costs for a Wesson Clipper one row four stop which I sell at £1600.
TAM reeds, bellows and other materials total around £500.
So that's £1100 for labour, marketing etc.
Say it takes me 20 days to make one, including tuning.
Assuming 8 hour working days, that's 160 hours.
£1100 pounds divided by 160 hours comes to £6.88 per hour or £275 for a 40 hour week.
Expensive, my arse!!! ;D
Fairest explanation I've ever heard.
-
Breaking News - The Wesson Clipper is rumoured to be going viral any time now ;D ;D ;D
-
Breaking News - The Wesson Clipper is rumoured to be going viral any time now ;D ;D ;D
You can probably get a cream for that ;)
-
I thought the Wesson Clipper was either like the Cutty Sark or something to cut a hedge with.....
-
Actually Rees, I think you have just run your most intensive marketing campaign so far (:)
Well done dude.
I knows it. I had to have a little lie down to recover. :Ph
-
I'd be delighted to hear that Rees has a full order book, his Clipper sounds great, but I have been playing melodeon for about 20 years I suppose, and never heard of or seen his lovely squeezeboxs.
He's only been making them for... er, less than two years I think.
Just coming up to three years now.
-
I'd have to say that the Sarasota by Dancemaster is actually not completely hand made. The components are Chinese and the Reeds Binci and the complete package put together and fettled by Michael Usui. The box might be called "hand finished" and as excellent as they are Michael himself would be the first one to tell you they aren't "Hand Made" so to speak. I know it might be quibbling but the distinction should be made! I'm not sure that he makes any claim to them being Hand Made. :-\ As a matter of fact I just had a look at the website and he says "assembled" in his workshop. I doubt any maker would say my accordions come from China and I put them together in my workshop. One mans marketing is another mans Disassembling, that was a bad pun but true!
Chinese hands are cheap, more likely to be really hand made if chinese than european.
At what point does a melodeon stop being hand made anyway. Are saw benches and routers allowed? Is a wooden jig any less of a machine than a CNC unit? Is the former any more desireable? the later is generally much more accurate.
-
Melodeons cost more because they are more fun. ;D
-
Melodeons cost more because they are more fun. ;D
........ and there's no such thing as too much fun! ;D ;D ;D
-
factory made 'handmade' boxes will haave the woodwork including reedblocks, casing, palletes etc cut by machine in reasonable quantity and witth anaccuracy that does not require highly s;killed labour to glue them together. The same will go for the buttons - moulded plastic not hand made and for the bent bits of wire that connect buttons to palletes etc. so that only leaves the reeds to be made/fettled or dinished according to the price of teh box.
On the other hand the 'expert cottage industry crafstmen' such as Rees and a few otheres give a great deal of attention to both the making of the instrument and to providing a personal (& bespoke) service. Perhaps they should charge more for their craftsmanship & by the same argument the factory producers of costallotis should charge considerably less./
george
-
Melodeons cost more because they are more fun. ;D
........ and there's no such thing as too much fun! ;D ;D ;D
you should have that printed on a t-shirt.
-
Perhaps they should charge more for their craftsmanship & by the same argument the factory producers of costallotis should charge considerably less./
They charge what they can charge and still have people ordering the boxes. Still, there are constraints on pricing. If a one-man-shop decides to charge more, that is up to the artisan. However, saying that the factory producers of Castelfidardo "should charge considerably less" is naive. Have you ever spoken with someone from Castelfidardo about what it is like to live and work there? I suppose that you think that the individuals working in the factories should be paid less, or receive lower grade health insurance? Perhaps the factories should ignore safety regulations to save money so that the consumer can buy a cheaper instrument? No one is getting rich in the production end of this business.
I think that it is fair to debate the value that one gets when buying a given melodeon in comparison to another, but some of the assumptions about fair pricing are bordering on offensive.
-
I need to put my oar in here since this is a topic I have often pondered --
look at the production pictures from the Cairdin web site -- there is a lot of manufacturing time that goes into building a button box.
The Chinese manufacturers are very good at mass production and meeting close tolerances/specifications - they also recognize that their product is not going to meet with acceptance from the high end portion of the melodeon market - so they aren't looking to compete with Castagnari or Saltarelle -
My Dancemaster was a very nice box from a fit and finish standpoint - those are qualities that mass manufacturing can achieve if they are able to meet the design tolerances and specs.
Michael at Dancemaster was very clever in the sense that he recognized that the Chinese mass manufacturers were making an acceptable box - that needed improved reeds and keyboard mechanism tweaks to make a very good sounding and playing box.
So why do boxes cost so much? Because of the time that goes into production and then the quality of the keyboard mechanism and the quality of the reeds and the amount of time it takes to tune the reeds --
As to why a button box cost more than a P/A - perhaps it's scales of supply and demand - internationally there is a larger P/A market than melodeon market -
It is a positive that world wide there is a continuing interest in the accordion - I think we are at a point where people recognize the value of a real musical instrument - that the artificial experiences of interacting with tv and the computer do not satisfy - we need real experiences.
Here in the US we are seeing a return to folk music - people want an authentic experience - people are returning to folk music because they see the value in it - compared against the mass produced popular culture.