Melodeon.net Forums
Discussions => General Discussion => Topic started by: Graeme on January 19, 2011, 05:16:17 PM
-
I'm on a mission to assist my daughter with some homework. Does anyone know the answer for the vibration frequency of a melodeon reed per second? Does the vibration rate vary with the size of the reed? Bring back the three Rs!
Graeme
-
I'm on a mission to assist my daughter with some homework. Does anyone know the answer for the vibration frequency of a melodeon reed per second? Does the vibration rate vary with the size of the reed? Bring back the three Rs!
Graeme
Basic physics....
Yes. The vibration rate, or frequency, of the reed determines the pitch of the note. The faster the rate the higher the pitch.
A reed which vibrates at 440 times a second will produce the note A (2nd space up in the treble clef). If you double the frequency you get the note which is an octave higher, so the next octave higher, A' will vibrate at 880 times per second, A'' at 1760 times per second, and so on.
Similarly, if you halve the vibration rate, the note sounds an octave lower, So 220, 110, 55, vibrations per second are all A notes, progressively octaves lower. The unit for 'vibrations per second' is termed 'Hertz' (Hz) named after the famous physicist.
Large reeds vibrate more slowly than small reeds, so the lower pitched notes are produced by the largest ones, the higher pitched notes are produced by the smaller reeds.
Hope this helps....
-
If you twang a ruler on the edge of a desk - you can see the principle in action.....
Almo
-
If you twang a ruler on the edge of a desk - you can see the principle in action.....
Almo
Reminds me of my primary school years... when the plastic rulers became common it was even more fun to do! And this got me lots of detention...
-
@Steve: In a nutshell, as ever. (:)
-
Just twanged my wooden desk ruler at the 24cm mark and got a perfect 'F'
I think I've just invented a new musical instrument
;D
-
now't to beat a good twang!
george ;D
-
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=kKfF1kqyYk4 :-)
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=dEh1oxZj5Eg
-
Long, long ago I went to a meeting of the Cambridge Philosophical society. The syndics of the Fitzwilliam museum had an early pot with a script that no one could recognise or translate - except that there weren't many ideograms in use, and they 'repeated'.
Then someone (possibly Joseph Needham) had found an old Chinese Sheng (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sheng_%28instrument%29) - the symbols on it were the same. It was a tune!
The meeting ended with a performance of a melody not played in some 1500 years. But this was Cambridge. And all of 300m from the Cavendish labs. Cue a physicist to explain the dynamics of the free reed in a slot. Apparently the frequency is twice that of the reed vibration. Something to do with second harmonics.
The melody itself was ... quite 'forgettable' :|glug
-
Cue a physicist to explain the dynamics of the free reed in a slot. Apparently the frequency is twice that of the reed vibration. Something to do with second harmonics.
Not usually, I think.
The sound is produced by the reed interrupting the airflow: when the reed moves away from its slot, there is space for air to flow though; when the reed is inside the slot, airflow is almost completely blocked (there's only the microscopic clearance between edge of reed and slot).
It's just possible that if you have a reed mounted on a very thin plate, it would open to air passing though it at both extremities of the reed's vibration. You'd certainly get a lot of second harmonic that way, if it worked at all.
I have a feeling Chris knew I'd reply to this. Even though he didn't use the 'E' word...
-
now't to beat a good twang!
george ;D
I really tempted to post the link for YouTube for the Rainbow kids TV program, where they play with their twangers.....Rainbow Twangers.....but modesty forbids...
And Rod, Jane and Freddy don't play melodeon...
-
OK, here is a better question to you smart guys:
How did they measure A=440 back in the 18th century, when there were no electronics or technology gizmos? ???
-
Just twanged my wooden desk ruler at the 24cm mark and got a perfect 'F'
I think I've just invented a new musical instrument
;D
You could call it a Kalimba or Mbira.....
Cue a physicist to explain the dynamics of the free reed in a slot. Apparently the frequency is twice that of the reed vibration. Something to do with second harmonics.
Not usually, I think.
The sound is produced by the reed interrupting the airflow: when the reed moves away from its slot, there is space for air to flow though; when the reed is inside the slot, airflow is almost completely blocked (there's only the microscopic clearance between edge of reed and slot).
It's just possible that if you have a reed mounted on a very thin plate, it would open to air passing though it at both extremities of the reed's vibration. You'd certainly get a lot of second harmonic that way, if it worked at all.
The "relief" of a concertina reed slot, tapering outwards, allows some air past at the bottom of the reed swing, but I don't think this changes the octave, just the strength of the harmonics and hence the character of the sound.
-
OK, here is a better question to you smart guys:
How did they measure A=440 back in the 18th century, when there were no electronics or technology gizmos? ???
They didn't - the pitch of A was all over the place until 1939 - at least according to this Wikipaedia article http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/History_of_pitch_standards_in_Western_music
-
Tuning pitch.....
Didn't the ancient Chinese used to tune instruments into bells of a standard size...they were also used for measuring grain by volume...
no Tu Ning jokes tyvm....
-
Yes, but how did they know it sounded like an "A", and who was the first to be able to measure the 440, or 435, or whatever Hz?
-
Eeeeee :|glug Won bet with m'self. >:E :|glug
Well, that's what the guy said - but as in all occillating systems one can analyse as a mechanical system - or in harmonic analysis mode. The two are equivalent. I recall reading somewhere that all reed instruments empasise even harmonics - but now I've googled this on bagpipe (similar reed in slot?)
http://www.patrickmclaurin.com/wordpress/wp-content/uploads/2009/04/pitch1.png
.. no such effect. We need something similar for our own instument
http://www.allaboutcircuits.com/vol_2/chpt_7/4.html
This looked interesting - but is actually about electonic simulations of instruments
-
They played a note to a deaf fellow and asked him "Can you hear that note?" His answer was "Ay?" and that was how it got its name.
I'll get me coat!
Nigel
-
Hope this helps....
[/quote]
It does indeed Steve. Sadly physics was not my strongest subject, along with all the others!
Cheers!
Graeme
-
From whippets media:- The pitch used for an English cathedral organ in the 17th century, for example, could be as much as five semitones lower than that used for a domestic keyboard instrument in the same city.
Is that why I can never sing to the pitch used in church nowadays ? It's always too high.
-
Yes, but how did they know it sounded like an "A", and who was the first to be able to measure the 440, or 435, or whatever Hz?
This paper is interesting....
http://www.scribd.com/doc/4731815/Pitch-Perception-and-ModelsAlainde-Cheveigne
....and this extract from it goes some way to answering your 'who?' question.
"The relation between ratios of string length and ratios ofvibration frequency was established by Galileo Galilei [11], whereas Mersenne [12], using strings long enough to count vibrations, determined the actual frequencies of each note of the scale. This provided a relation of pitch with number that was ï¬rmly grounded in the physics of sound."
Scientific pitch frequency has taken the note C as a standard frequency - middle C taken as being 256 Hz. This is mathematically convenient, as the frequencies of successive octaves higher and lower are nice convenient integers corresponding to binary numbers. So - notes of frequencies 2, 4, 8, 16, 32, 64, 128, 256, 512, 1024, etc., are all C (corresponding to 21, 22, 23, 24, 25, 26, 27, 28, 29, 210, ... etc.).
However, as others have pointed out, the actual pitch frequency of notes used in real musical instruments has varied over the centuries and it was only in the 1930s that it became internationally standardised to A=440 Hz. On this standard, middle C = 261.626 Hz, and not the 256 Hz of scientific pitch.
It is not too difficult to determine the frequency of vibrating strings or reeds, with fairly simple equipment. As the paper cited above mentions, Mersenne actually counted the vibrations of long, slow-moving strings, and scaled up and down octaves as required.
It is also possible to use a variable speed strobe lamp to 'freeze' the vibrating object. Or you can view the string through a rotating disk with a regular array of slots cut in its circumference. At the correct speed of rotation of the disk, a vibrating string will appear to freeze, similar to using a strobe lamp.
Supposing you had a disk with 100 equally-spaced slots cut in its circumference, a bit like a circular saw blade. You also have a single peg on the circumference which makes an audible click against a flexible lath of wood each time the disk rotates once. You also need a stop watch or timer, to time the clicks. At a certain speed of disk rotation, a vibrating string appears to freeze when viewed through the slots. Counting the number of clicks of the disk, you notice that there are, say, 20 clicks over a 10 second time interval. This means that the disk is rotating twice per second, which also means that 200 slots are passing your observation point each second. As this is the frequency needed to 'freeze' the string's motion, it follows that the frequency of the string is also 200 Hz. Simples, OK?
(I did this experiment in 'O'-level physics at school, in about 1967. ;) )
As a nice bit of thread drift, in 1849 the French physicist Fizeau used a similar apparatus to determine the speed of light for the first time. The following year, Fizeau and his colleague, Foucault, refined the technique using the
Fizeau–Foucault apparatus (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fizeau–Foucault_apparatus)
OK - back to playing the melodeon now....
-
Excellent exposé and references Steve! Thanks.
-
I take it that the same frequency would apply to a harmonica reed as a melodeon reed ???
Graeme
-
Long, long ago I went to a meeting of the Cambridge Philosophical society. The syndics of the Fitzwilliam museum had an early pot with a script that no one could recognise or translate - except that there weren't many ideograms in use, and they 'repeated'.
Then someone (possibly Joseph Needham) had found an old Chinese Sheng (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sheng_%28instrument%29) - the symbols on it were the same. It was a tune!
I presume you know of Joseph's folkie connection?
-
I take it that the same frequency would apply to a harmonica reed as a melodeon reed ???
Yes - a harmonica reed playing, say, middle C would have the same frequency as a melodeon reed playing middle C. It would also be the same as the string of a violin, piano, harpsichord, etc., playing middle C.
-
Yes, but how did they know it sounded like an "A", and who was the first to be able to measure the 440, or 435, or whatever Hz?
What seems like a very long ago... I spent an afternoon at the science museum in West Palm Beach with my wife, who was my girlfriend at the time (I was unemployed, she paid for my admission!). We were there mainly to see the aquarium portion which featured an electric eel. At one point we split up and wandered around looking at this and that, waiting for the eel feeding. There was an exhibit where you could turn a knob to play a tone through a transparent, horizontal beaker of water that was mounted on the wall just above eye level. The purpose was to demonstrate wave patterns at different frequencies. There was a digital frequency counter mounted above the beaker - if you turned the knob to the left, the pitch went lower and to the right it went higher. I fooled with it for a while, then resorted to listening but not watching the beaker. I tried to play some simple melodies, with limited success, a little bit like you would on a slide whistle. It was fun! Finally I started at the lowest tone and progressed by turning the knob slowly upwards until I settled on a tone that I liked. I really liked it. It felt good, and I decided I shouldn't go any higher. It felt somehow like the tone where I could settle down and just listen for a while.
A few seconds later my other half appeared from around the corner of the exhibit. She tapped me on the shoulder to tell me that I looked strange, like a mad scientist. My eyes were closed. Maybe I was scaring the children. When I looked up on the frequency counter, I had 'settled' on 440 Hz... A!
So either there is an inherently comfortable quality about that frequency, or I've been playing and listening to music for so long that it was comfortable because it was familiar. Probably the latter.
-
I presume you know of Joseph's folkie connection?
And Russell (original don patron of the International Dance Group), and Sydney (my tutor and another syndic). They got about ...
Vaguely back to topic - I once had an X-Ray table in Ab. Actually its motor sounded the note and my brain always heard the first bar of 'Coronation St'. Patient blissfully unaware of all this of course. Now, if one can get as far as the Rover's Return :|glug on a bloody Xray table - I confess mild disappointment that the many physicists and other technos who lurk this this group can't strobe a real reed, FFT its note for us and kick this one well into touch.
Sydney (above) taught his students about diffraction and waves by getting them to microscope a butterfly wing! .. OK .. I'm back off topic :-\
-
- but now I've googled this on bagpipe (similar reed in slot?)
No, bagpipe reeds (double in chanter , single in drones, generally) are beating reeds rather than free reeds. No slot, slap against a surface (single reed) or opposing reed blade (double reed).