Melodeon.net Forums
Discussions => Instrument Makes and Models => Topic started by: strad on January 20, 2011, 03:50:33 PM
-
Sitting and thinking, as opposed to just sitting, I wondered if a box has ever been made which has stops/couplers or whatever which changed the tuning as in a single row G where you pull up 2 stops and have the key of A?
Nigel
-
Nigel there are a couple of threads here somewhere that talk about various boxes that do this. There's a chap in Louisiana, Randy Falcon, who has a patent for a "dual key melodeon"http://www.freepatentsonline.com/5111726.html (http://www.freepatentsonline.com/5111726.html). Apparently he's not the first person to try this approach, but he's the guy with the paperwork. I've never tried one, but the consensus seems to be that its a complicated solution to a fairly simple problem.
-
Sitting and thinking, as opposed to just sitting, I wondered if a box has ever been made which has stops/couplers or whatever which changed the tuning as in a single row G where you pull up 2 stops and have the key of A?
Nigel
But if the reeds are there for a second key you may as well have a set of buttons for them too, then no need for the stops!
Try looking at the question through the other end of the telescope as it were. If you have a two row box would you consider getting rid of one row of buttons and instead have a stop to choose which set of reeds to play?
Generally speaking a set of reeds and blocks takes up more space, and is heavier than the buttons and levers to work them, so if you have the reeds there you may as well have the buttons too.
-
I didn't say I was thinking sense, did I?
Nigel
-
Indeed not!
I did have an old Saxony 3 stop box for a while where one stop was a 5th above the others. You could use all the stops together to provide a strange harmony effect, but also allowed you to play in one key with up to two reeds, or in the other key with just one.
-
But if the reeds are there for a second key you may as well have a set of buttons for them too, then no need for the stops!
Try looking at the question through the other end of the telescope as it were. If you have a two row box would you consider getting rid of one row of buttons and instead have a stop to choose which set of reeds to play?
Generally speaking a set of reeds and blocks takes up more space, and is heavier than the buttons and levers to work them, so if you have the reeds there you may as well have the buttons too.
Funny how we all see things differently. I imagined a slider which redirected air to existing reeds which would only then require one extra reed per octave and no extra buttons. Implementation wasn't forefront in my mind - it needs to be done, so do it, mentality. However I now see a complex air chamber with a clever slider re directing air as needed. I rather like solving the problem mentally but I fear Theo is right and the complicated result is probably more effort than it is worth save that of the cerebral experience. :-\ Maybe I'll go and look at the patent now.
-
Looked at patent. Wish I hadn't. Firstly it was filed by Randy E Falcon. Perhaps that name is common in parts of the US but I find it difficult not to be amused. Secondly, I know there is a divide on English across the pond but the convoluted prose of his patent is something to behold. Gave up the unequal struggle, let him build it. I'm going for a :|glug
-
Indeed not!
I did have an old Saxony 3 stop box for a while where one stop was a 5th above the others. You could use all the stops together to provide a strange harmony effect, but also allowed you to play in one key with up to two reeds, or in the other key with just one.
That's just plain weird! Consecutive 5ths are generally not a good idea (yes, I know Beethoven used them!). A 3rd above I could live with - from time to time (if the tune lends itself) I play a countermelody a 3rd above simply by playing the whole thing up one button (well OK - it's not quite that straightforward, but it's the general principle) and it sounds quite nice, but all those consecutive 5ths would, I would think, become very tiring on the ear. It didn't catch on, then?
Graham
-
On my hurdy gurdy (3 melody string) I had melody strings in g, g' and d'' ... (now I have g, d' and g')
that produced a quite interesting sound (1st, 2nd and 3rd harmonics together http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Harmonic )
There is even an accordeon with a 5th tuning
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=DxNT97RMpnE
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=F7gUFHHxlUc
-
There is even an accordeon with a 5th tuning
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=DxNT97RMpnE
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=F7gUFHHxlUc
Indeed there is - but that doesn't necessarily mean it's a good idea! It may well appeal to some, and I may be out on a limb (not for the first time!) but it just sounds uncomfortable to my ear.
-
Sitting and thinking, as opposed to just sitting, I wondered if a box has ever been made which has stops/couplers or whatever which changed the tuning as in a single row G where you pull up 2 stops and have the key of A?
Nigel
Roland FR-18 :P
-
A couple of years ago I came accross a bloke who had converted a hohner one row 4 stop to effectively provide a 4 key single voice box (? 4 castagnari lillies for much less than the price of one!) I can't remember what if anything he had done with the 2 bass but if he'd left it as madde there would be reasonable grunt in G and perhaps the odd grunt here & there in other keys ( no worse than BC bass) I think the keys he'd got were CGDA but any combination would of be possible. I thought it was quite a useful session box
george
-
An austrian Steirische builder once built a 4 row Steirische
with an enlargend treble and bass side, where one half was in GCFB, the other half in BbEbAbDb
;D
-
4 castagnari lillies for much less than the price of one!
Except a Lilly is a two row and has eight basses whereas your example has only two basses and they only work for one of the four keys ;)
-
Castagnari made a box which they called the converter I think. It had a lever which shifted the pitch (well, shifted the air to a different set of reedblocks) a semitone. Something like that anyway. Rees mentioned it ages ago, there might be some more info on the forum somewhere, but as far as I recall that was all of it :P
-
This is very popular amongst Tejano/Norteno/conjunto musicians who call the configuration of having two sets of keys in the same box a "dos tonos" box. Lots of switches, big and heavy. Lotsa rhinestones.
http://www.instrumentalsavings.com/GABBANELLI-Button-Accordion-Mod-DOS-TONOS-p/gbnl-2-tone.htm
I think for the average diatonic player, it's easiest to either have a spare set of reedblocks made up for occasional switching out (eventually a gasket issue), or to just buy another accordion. And another. And another... ;D
-
and I have a pic of this HA114,
4 stop err 5 stop
tuned MM in G and D
(edit to add)
apparently the bass stop alters the bass and cord reeds to the respective key
-
is the "Bouchard Melodeon" still in production ?
they were mentioned quite awhile back.
I thought that they were able to be played in several keys.
they have an extra set of keys on a helper row, similar to that of a Club ???
-
I think so as this one was just delivered http://forum.melodeon.net/index.php?topic=4912.0
edit: and here's one being played superbly well in many keys http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=lOef8pOVLO0
-
I think so as this one was just delivered http://forum.melodeon.net/index.php?topic=4912.0
edit: and here's one being played superbly well in many keys http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=lOef8pOVLO0
But I understood that instrument was a standard diatonic one-row, but with extra buttons for accidentals?
-
But if the reeds are there for a second key you may as well have a set of buttons for them too, then no need for the stops!
Randy's dual key accordions have 3 stand up reed blocks, so it is basically 2 three voice accordions with LMH set up. With that setup I don't see where there would be room to add buttons for the second key and stay with a 3 voice. How could that be done?
-
You could learn how to play a chromatic C/C# box and play in any key ya like - but without base notes...Irish style..
-
Looked at patent. Wish I hadn't. Firstly it was filed by Randy E Falcon. Perhaps that name is common in parts of the US but I find it difficult not to be amused. Secondly, I know there is a divide on English across the pond but the convoluted prose of his patent is something to behold. Gave up the unequal struggle, let him build it. I'm going for a :|glug
The convoluted prose is distinctive lawyer talk, purposely meant to befuddle us common folk.
Falcon is not common in the US, it is common in certain parts of south west Louisiana, and came from Spain, and I guess everyone has a name somebody would find amusing.
-
I think the notion of 'variable tunings' comes from the lazy streak that most of us have in that such a box would require no additional learning to play in other keys in much the same way as you can carry a pocketful of mouthies in different keys but you play them exactly the same. - and yes, I would like such an instrument for portability etc.
The CC# and BC (but not DD#) are chromatic but a bugger to play in some keys. Of the sook an blaw boxes only the BCC# gets close 5 fairly easy scales worth of learning providing 12 keys
perhaps the only way to do it sensibly in one small box is a la streb or roland - trouble is I much prefer the sound of half decent reeds and the feel of air doing something useful in the bellos.
george
-
But if the reeds are there for a second key you may as well have a set of buttons for them too, then no need for the stops!
Try looking at the question through the other end of the telescope as it were. If you have a two row box would you consider getting rid of one row of buttons and instead have a stop to choose which set of reeds to play?
Generally speaking a set of reeds and blocks takes up more space, and is heavier than the buttons and levers to work them, so if you have the reeds there you may as well have the buttons too.
This is a great way of looking at it. The patent office only judges whether the design is "patentable," not whether it is an idea worth pursuing. The builder, however, was apparently able to convince some customers to order this box. Seems they never heard of a two-row accordion or pondered what they might be able to do if both "keys" were available simultaneously. If they did, they would likely seek a patent!
-
I had a Hohner Chromatic C/C# Harmonica at the age of around 10, but no-one in the family knew anything about playing it - and at that age I didnt know you could play in any key.
I just played it in C and used the slide button for doing 'twiddly' bits, which is what I thought it was for....
The reason I had the C/C# was that Larry Adler and Tommy Reilly(Navy Lark) played them...and I loved the Three Monarchs , Harmonica Rascals etc.
Later I had a C/C# box, and yes - was too lazy to learn how to play it properly. Same reason I bought a banjitar recently - to lazy to learn banjo.
-
The CC# and BC (but not DD#) are chromatic but a bugger to play in some keys.
A Corona II is also "chromatic" and a real bugger to play in some keys!
-
I think so as this one was just delivered http://forum.melodeon.net/index.php?topic=4912.0
edit: and here's one being played superbly well in many keys http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=lOef8pOVLO0
But I understood that instrument was a standard diatonic one-row, but with extra buttons for accidentals?
I only popped out for a moment and the threads gone wild. Correct Theo but I was answering Old Gezzer's Q about Bouchard still being in production. And by connection, thought the video would explain how they were being played in many keys. No slides, no gizzmo's, just excellent playing, which I feel defeats the argument for an engineering solution to key changing.
My earlier post may have made me seem pro an engineering solution, which I'm not, hence confusion. ;D
-
The CC# and BC (but not DD#) are chromatic but a bugger to play in some keys.
A Corona II is also "chromatic" and a real bugger to play in some keys!
? F natural
george
-
The CC# and BC (but not DD#) are chromatic but a bugger to play in some keys.
Why do you say D/D# isn't chromatic? (I can't imagine wanting one mind, but surely it has all the notes there somewhere, same as BC and C#/D)
-
The CC# and BC (but not DD#) are chromatic but a bugger to play in some keys.
A Corona II is also "chromatic" and a real bugger to play in some keys!
? F natural
george
F natural is good on the ADG Corona; low and high F naturals and a Bb on the three accidental buttons at the end of the rows.
I used them a fair bit when I was playing the scottish dance scene. I guess playing south paw makes it easier to use the accidentals
-
The CC# and BC (but not DD#) are chromatic but a bugger to play in some keys.
Why do you say D/D# isn't chromatic? (I can't imagine wanting one mind, but surely it has all the notes there somewhere, same as BC and C#/D)
[/quote
wasn't thinking straight! yes D# row has Fnatural
george
-
The CC# and BC (but not DD#) are chromatic but a bugger to play in some keys.
A Corona II is also "chromatic" and a real bugger to play in some keys!
? F natural
george
F natural is good on the ADG Corona; low and high F naturals and a Bb on the three accidental buttons at the end of the rows.
I used them a fair bit when I was playing the scottish dance scene. I guess playing south paw makes it easier to use the accidentals
was presuming low notes instead of accidentals at chin end
george
-
To see the dual pitched melodeon US patent, see http://www.google.com/patents/about?id=qi0cAAAAEBAJ&dq=dual+pitched+melodeon (http://www.google.com/patents/about?id=qi0cAAAAEBAJ&dq=dual+pitched+melodeon)
- Wade Falcon, Randy's son
-
Just to add a brief note, regarding the Finnish maker, Jarrko Helin... (http://www.accordion-helin.com/) (another one to add to the maker's list)
I notice this machine (http://c4.ac-images.myspacecdn.com/images01/66/l_1356177f3f51db3c82616b409c37b3df.jpg) on his MySpace... looks like a key switcher, and fairly close to the Falcon design too...
The concept of key switching accordions in Europe isn't new though... the major/minor organetti (as produced/sold by Baffetti, Giustozzi, Polverini and others) have been produced for years. The Italians (Gabbanelli, Beltrami, and others) also produce key switching three rows (e.g. G/C/F to F/Bb/Eb) - usually with no bass reeds - for the Tex Mex market.
Ed J