Melodeon.net Forums

Discussions => General Discussion => Topic started by: Thrupenny Bit on January 23, 2011, 05:30:22 PM

Title: Do left handed people have better bass technique?
Post by: Thrupenny Bit on January 23, 2011, 05:30:22 PM
I was wondering if being left handed means your basses are quicker learnt, better used etc.

It's hard to define 'lefthandedness', as I write left handed, perfer a left foot with football, use a cricket bat right handed, d-i-y- paint starting off in the left then changing hands to right if up a ladder, put crisps into my mouth left handed...... bit of a mix up, but a stronger left.

I'm often finding if I loose a tune, it somehow picks back up with me hitting the correct bass then melody picks up, hence my post.
In a far off time, I tried McCann Duet concertina, and always felt my left hand much stronger, so would loose melody whilst still doing something on my left hand. In the end I gave up as it really was noticable and doing my head in.
To continue this train of thought, I suppose strongly one-sided players, such as strong right handers, might find their melody good but basses hard to sort out?

Just one of my idle thoughts.....!
Any comments out there?
Q
Title: Re: Do left handed people have better bass technique?
Post by: Kautilya on January 23, 2011, 05:44:37 PM
I was wondering if being left handed means your basses are quicker learnt, better used etc.

It's hard to define 'lefthandedness', as I write left handed, perfer a left foot with football, use a cricket bat right handed, d-i-y- paint starting off in the left then changing hands to right if up a ladder, put crisps into my mouth left handed...... bit of a mix up, but a stronger left.

I'm often finding if I loose a tune, it somehow picks back up with me hitting the correct bass then melody picks up, hence my post.
In a far off time, I tried McCann Duet concertina, and always felt my left hand much stronger, so would loose melody whilst still doing something on my left hand. In the end I gave up as it really was noticable and doing my head in.
To continue this train of thought, I suppose strongly one-sided players, such as strong right handers, might find their melody good but basses hard to sort out?

Just one of my idle thoughts.....!
Any comments out there?
Q
Praps WE are condemned to Purgatory for ever and should just join its Limbo dancing group....

Left handed at cricket and golf, right handed at tennis, figure-skating lead far
better on left turns and jumps, but kick recalcitrant morrismen with right foot and go down the plughole Ozwise.

Maybe we should measure Brian Read's musskels at the next folkattack as he plays left hand main keyboard so he may be weak on the bass ??? ???
Title: Re: Do left handed people have better bass technique?
Post by: **DTN** on January 23, 2011, 06:07:22 PM
Im a lefty" ... I play a lot of Basses!  :|||:
Title: Re: Do left handed people have better bass technique?
Post by: Graham Spencer on January 23, 2011, 06:25:13 PM
An interesting point - a guitarist friend with whom I have played in a number of bands of various kinds over the last 30 years is left-handed but plays guitar right-handed (because when he learned to play, no-one ever suggested he could do otherwise); his left-hand technique is awesome - he can comfortably play chords I never dreamt existed - but his right-hand technique, though not bad, is nowhere near as accomplished.  I'm sure the same may well be true of lefties playing a right-handed melodeon.

Graham
Title: Re: Do left handed people have better bass technique?
Post by: ladydetemps on January 23, 2011, 06:25:47 PM
sounds sinister to me. ;)
Title: Re: Do left handed people have better bass technique?
Post by: Thrupenny Bit on January 23, 2011, 06:56:10 PM
Kautilya: ok.....but just remember, we're the only people in our Right mind  ;)

DTN: Ahhh....well, I'm in good company, just need to get up to (your) speed!
Hmmmmm that means there's hope for me..... eventually

LdeT: Funnily enough, a post from you recently, about not getting waltz time on basses got me thinking.....so twas all your fault ;D

GPS: I suppose the extremely left handed ends up getting a left handed box, so they're then wondering how their right hand is at playing bases. I heard recently - can't remember where - that Hendrix, famously playing his right handed strat upside down cos he was a lefty, could also play exceedingly well right handed. That *is* scary....
I wonder how your guitarist friend would have been if he had started on a l.h. guitar?
That would be quite interesting to find out.......... any experimental psychologists about?

It's amazing what pops into this otherwise empty space on my shoulders at times...... if only it was useful thoughts ;)

bye for now
Q
Title: Re: Do left handed people have better bass technique?
Post by: kdhoffman on January 23, 2011, 06:59:53 PM
I know of two left handed people that play very well with the accodion turned upside down, melody side played with the left hand.
Title: Re: Do left handed people have better bass technique?
Post by: Thrupenny Bit on January 23, 2011, 07:21:23 PM
I wonder why some people, though left handed, play right handed, whilst others will, like your friends, flip the accordian/melodeon/guitar upside down and play it with their left hand.
I presume it's the degree of left handedness ....maybe?
i.e. though left handed, I'm sufficiently 'mixed up' ( ambidextrous, less left handed? ) to be able to reasonably play with my right, whereas some extremely left handed people have no choice *but * to ue their left hand.
Q
Title: Re: Do left handed people have better bass technique?
Post by: Graham Spencer on January 23, 2011, 07:31:18 PM
GPS: I wonder how your guitarist friend would have been if he had started on a l.h. guitar?
That would be quite interesting to find out.......... any experimental psychologists about?


I've thought that, too; his style is very distinctive, and I've often wondered if he would have been as impressive if he'd always played leftie. Guess we'll never know.....and I'm quite glad, because I LOVE the way he plays!

Graham
Title: Re: Do left handed people have better bass technique?
Post by: Thrupenny Bit on January 23, 2011, 10:31:05 PM
Yes, perhaps it's better to just accept what 'is' rather than wonder what isn't.
It's the little quirks that make life so interesting!
Q
Title: Re: Do left handed people have better bass technique?
Post by: Andy Simpson on January 24, 2011, 12:19:51 AM
I often hear good musicians who are left-handed crediting their left-handedness for their ability and explaining how it gives them advantages over right-handers. I also hear left-handed musicians blaming their left-handedness for them not being better players and explaining how it makes things more difficult for them in the same situations.

Now both camps can't be right and I've considered both arguments carefully but with the aid of Ockham's Razor, (who on earth is Occam?), I'm inclined to believe that it's most likely that they're both talking cobblers. ;D
Title: Re: Do left handed people have better bass technique?
Post by: Lester on January 24, 2011, 08:12:16 AM
(who on earth is Occam?

Occam's Razor is attributed to the 14th-century English logician, theologian and Franciscan friar Father William of Ockham (d'Okham) who wrote "entities must not be multiplied beyond necessity" (entia non sunt multiplicanda praeter necessitatem).

Nothing is not educational  ;)
Title: Re: Do left handed people have better bass technique?
Post by: Andy Simpson on January 24, 2011, 08:38:34 AM
I know, but who is this mysterious "Occam" bloke who keeps taking credit for Ockham's Razor?. ;)
Title: Re: Do left handed people have better bass technique?
Post by: ganderbox on January 24, 2011, 09:19:56 AM
 I've mentioned in previous threads on this topic that I know two very good players who are right-handed but play their boxes upside-down so that they can use their dominant (right) hand on the basses.
I definitely think that it works, and I think it's a pity that there aren't more instruments around which have been made "left-handed" so that people could have a go at playing both ways without having to struggle with unreachable air-buttons and upside-down keyboards.
Title: Re: Do left handed people have better bass technique?
Post by: Alan Morley on January 24, 2011, 09:23:50 AM
I can handle bass with either hand  ;D
Title: Re: Do left handed people have better bass technique?
Post by: brianread on January 24, 2011, 11:40:47 AM
I play upside down because when I started I'd never seen anyone play one these beasts, and so I "naturally" played the tune with my left hand (being a serious left hander), 3 years later (and still not using the bases), I started Morris and met some "real" melodeon players.  But it was too late by then.  However with some inspiration and perspiration I was able to get the basses going (actually until then I did not have a box that had basses that worked).  Since then the recent break through was getting a second air button for my thumb (suggested to me by Rees of this parish) on most of my melodeons.

Regarding guitars I had a friend who played a right handed guitar left handed, so he strummed up! It worked well for him.
Title: Re: Do left handed people have better bass technique?
Post by: Rob2Hook on January 24, 2011, 11:42:12 AM
Im a lefty" ... I play a lot of Basses!  :|||:

Yes, we'd noticed!

Rob.
Title: Re: Do left handed people have better bass technique?
Post by: Thrupenny Bit on January 24, 2011, 05:08:34 PM
Brian's point is quite important too - if you've only got a right handed box, you play it in the way your body allows you to.
i.e. normal way or upside down, any way to make it work!

With no left handed box as an option, you make do or don't play.
arghhhh another variable in the hypothesis  ::)
Q
Title: Re: Do left handed people have better bass technique?
Post by: Chris Ryall on January 24, 2011, 05:40:41 PM
I've long thought they do. Andy Cutting once tolt me he was a south paw

  Actually it went "are you left handed"? "How did you know that"!

.. having said this .. he's pretty OK with the right.  8)  There may be another issue at play. The South Paw's spacial awareness - and tendency to perceive patterns (in this case chord structure) rather than detail.  A week ago I was at the Tideswell Scandi weekend (swedish music is ALL 'detail') and was the only left hander of about 35 people.  That's statistically significant.
Title: Re: Do left handed people have better bass technique?
Post by: Mike Averill on January 24, 2011, 07:23:50 PM
With no left handed box as an option...
You only need to buckle the straps on the other way up ( to make it look tidy, not essential) and turn it upside down. Air valves designed for a thumb work fine with a little finger.

The only boxes this doesnt work with are those with Stradella basses, the angle is all wrong. If any one has a true lefthanded (ie played with the right hand) Stradella bass I'd love to try it.
Title: Re: Do left handed people have better bass technique?
Post by: Thrupenny Bit on January 24, 2011, 07:47:11 PM
blimey Chris, lots to think about there!
Yep, Andy's not bad I have to agree. Maybe being *slightly* left handed opens up an interesting advantage.
i.e. If you favour the left  but not totally a Lefty, it seems to be logical that you can be quite original, co-ordinated and strong with basses, as opposed to flapping your fingers round a bit, that a strong Righty might do.
( I think I might have just offended a *whole* lot of people here......  >:E )
But as said, a strong lefty is presumably an upside down Righty.....errr if you see what I mean! so in the extreme could have wonderful basses and rubbish right hand melody. I can see that after my McCann efforts.
Phew getting a bit intense here  :Ph

Mike: I suppose my thoughts fro a left handed box was along the lines of a left handed guitar - built properly for a left handed person not one just turned the other way up, left handed keyboard, lower notes under the chin etc. so a mirror of a normal box, as opposed to a normal one turned upside down.
My friend let me twiddle on a G/D Oakwood the other week. He bought it as a properly made left handed box, and got them to change it back to a normal right handed one for him.
Q
SimplePortal 2.3.5 © 2008-2012, SimplePortal