Melodeon.net Forums
Discussions => Instrument Design, Construction and Repair => Topic started by: Nick Hudis on June 06, 2008, 09:45:51 PM
-
It often seems to me that the basses on my melodeons tend to drown out the treble. I understand that there may be good physical reasons for this: air flowing with less resistance through the larger bass reed spaces, instruments built with a good solid tutonic oom-pa sound in mind. I am also familar with the musical solutions: playing the bass crisply staccatto, playing the chords rather than the fundamentals in gentler tunes etc. But sometimes I just want to play a nice musical bass line which doesn't sound like a tuba convention.
I've found this to be an issue with the Verde D/G I play (which in fact generally has a very full on sound) and also my currently favourite instrument, an old Hohner Club II Victoria, but less so with my new ( and also favourite) Liliput.
From time to time I wonder if there might be a mechanical solution. e.g.
muffling the bass end in some way
taping over the lowest fundamental, like some of folks tape over the third of the chord
and here's one for you repairers: Would it be totally off the planet to contruct some form of coupler to stop the low bass or third on an old box like the Victoria?
I am sure I am not the first person to raise questions like these, but I'd appreciate the wisdom of you guys out there who understand such things.
-
my box (a Bernard Loffet that I love dearly) also has a very fat bass end. Rich and fabulous, but I do feel sometimes that it can overpower the melody end. As a result I tend to play very sparse basses. A bit of standard vamping but more often a oom or a pah here or there.
Anyway, what is wrong with a tuba convention?
Guy
-
(snip) From time to time I wonder if there might be a mechanical solution. e.g.
muffling the bass end in some way (snip)
I'm not really the person to ask (in my opinion, "too much bass" is like "too many wimmins") but I think that I'd muffle the "outlet" before I did anything else. I don't know the Verde (or Liliput, for that matter) but most 2-row boxes have an "end plate" with holes and a cloth-mesh covering over the holes. I'd try a heavy cloth or felt and cover maybe half the holes. You can do this in 3 minutes and you wouldn't lose the balance of the bass reeds. Not enough muffling, or too much, pull maybe 4 screws and you're in there to fine-tune it.
It might take a little experimentation but you can surely come up with something that suits you (and I'm guessing the layout -- how many holes you baffle and the location of them -- will vary from box to box), but I'd try everything before I started taking out bass reeds.
BH NC USA
-
Sometimes the instrument isn't well designed. But usually, it's just technique.
Every time I show a button box to a novice, it's "Wow, how do you remember all those buttons?"
That's the easy part (as we here all know). It's really all the bellows, which is to squeezing what the bow is to fiddling.
Better bellows control!
-
Regarding a Victoria, it is possible to put the linkage "out of gear" by bending the levers, so that bass buttons only operate for two "bass" reeds instead of adding two of the "chord " reeds. If you do not see what I mean a look at the mechanism should make it apparent.
While reversible, this is obviously a semi permanent modification.
Hohners do not lend themselves to switching out thirds, because of the way the reeds are arranged, and I have never understood how people claim to tape them out?
If you simply want to mute the l/h a sheet of heavy paper over the sound holes might suffice. You can try this from outside before bothering to remove the board.
-
Before you do any modifications, carry out some objective tests to see whether the basses really do overpower the treble.
Remember that because of the acoustics of positioning, the shape of the box, the grille, reeds, pallets, etc., what you hear as the player can be quite different from what listeners hear.
A few years ago, a friend was convinced that her Dino Black Pearl 2 basses were far too loud for the treble, and that the melody line was getting swamped. A group of us listened to her play and found that the basses were not too loud at all, we could hear the melody perfectly well, and overall it sounded just fine. A few other people have had similar concerns since then, including a couple of times on the Melodeons at Witney weekend. In all cases they have been persuaded that their perceptions were different from other people's, and in fact their instruments were OK after all.
It is therefore worth getting other peoples' opinions; you might be pleasantly surprised. Furthermore, if at all possible, I recommend you record yourself playing, with a reasonably good set-up and with the microphone positioned carefully at some central point in front of you a few feet away. Hopefully then you would be able to objectively decide whether your bass and treble ends were unbalanced or not.
-
Remember that because of the acoustics of positioning, the shape of the box, the grille, reeds, pallets, etc., what you hear as the player can be quite different from what listeners hear.
There are good acoustic reasons for this. One is that higher pitch sounds are much more directional than bass sounds, so you could envisage a beam of sound going out from the treble end , while low pitches spread out to all directions relatively quickly. A second acoustic reason is that high pitches are absorbed relatively more by surfaces nearby, so you get more of the bass reflected back to you. The result for the player is the feeling that you are enveloped in bass and the treble sounds weak. If you are noticing this then it mainly means that you are paying careful attention to the sound you are making, in time you will get used to the effect, but its not a sign that you need to start making serious changes to the box.
-
Hohners do not lend themselves to switching out thirds, because of the way the reeds are arranged, and I have never understood how people claim to tape them out?
Simply by putting a piece of sticky tape over the individual reed - over the reed tongue for push reeds, and over the valve for pull reeds. If you have to take the tape off again the valve will usually need to be replaced, or the reed tongue cleaned of sticky residue.
-
This is possibly a really really stupid question, but won't covering up the sound holes at the bass end do something to the bellows pressure (cos it makes it harder for the air to get out)?
-
Simply by putting a piece of sticky tape over the individual reed - over the reed tongue for push reeds, and over the valve for pull reeds. If you have to take the tape off again the valve will usually need to be replaced, or the reed tongue cleaned of sticky residue.
Or you could take out the reed block and put a piece of low-tack masking tape over the relevant air hole or holes. Using this method you can only take out push and pull together, but it's completely reversible. You can even use paper insted of masking tape, it's just a bit fiddlier to keep in place. Remember not to screw the cleat down too hard when replacing the reed block.
-
When I took my wife's Lilly apart for the first time after she'd had it for about five years, we found a piece of card inside the bass end cover spaced away from the sound holes. It works a treat to tone down the bass end a bit, so it stayed in there.
-
.
Or you could take out the reed block and put a piece of low-tack masking tape over the relevant air hole or holes. Using this method you can only take out push and pull together, but it's completely reversible. You can even use paper insted of masking tape, it's just a bit fiddlier to keep in place. Remember not to screw the cleat down too hard when replacing the reed block.
[/quote]
THIS is what I meant about not being possible with Hohners
-
It is therefore worth getting other peoples' opinions; you might be pleasantly surprised. Furthermore, if at all possible, I recommend you record yourself playing, with a reasonably good set-up and with the microphone positioned carefully at some central point in front of you a few feet away. Hopefully then you would be able to objectively decide whether your bass and treble ends were unbalanced or not.
I forgot to add - you could get someone else to play your melodeon while you listen carefully from all angles and directions.
-
Simply by putting a piece of sticky tape over the individual reed - over the reed tongue for push reeds, and over the valve for pull reeds. If you have to take the tape off again the valve will usually need to be replaced, or the reed tongue cleaned of sticky residue.
Or you could take out the reed block and put a piece of low-tack masking tape over the relevant air hole or holes. Using this method you can only take out push and pull together, but it's completely reversible. You can even use paper insted of masking tape, it's just a bit fiddlier to keep in place. Remember not to screw the cleat down too hard when replacing the reed block.
This method works on most Italian built boxes, but the point I was answering was related specifically to Hohners where the thirds for the push and pull chords are not on the same reedplate, except in one or two less common models.
-
Thanks for all this advice: Thanks to Steve and Theo for the explanation of why the boxes sound too bassy. Its funny that when I listen to other players their basses never sound overpowering. Now I know why! I guess I'm just at the stage in learning the instrument where, having given up on vamping, I'm trying to be a bit adventurous with the bass and thinking more about the sound I'm making.
Thanks to Jax for the thought about bellows control. By the way, I love you Club website, its what got me into the idea of playing Clubs and so discovered the type of instrument I'm really at home with.
I might try some external muffling of the holes, but I think as Theo put it, I'll just learn to get used to the sound while I work up my bellows control.
-
I am so pleased to read this discussion and particularly Steves comments about his friend, because that is exactly what I have been "hearing" since treating myself to my new Dino Black Pearl 2 - basses far louder than treble. It IS very disconcerting - but now that Theo has given the official seal of approval (it means we are listening to our playing) then I will relax and enjoy
thanks all ::)
Lin
-
because that is exactly what I have been "hearing" since treating myself to my new Dino Black Pearl 2 - basses far louder than treble
I had the same "problem" with my Dino BPIII. Is this effect more pronounced on BPs as I've not noticed it on my Tommy (perhaps I've just got used to it or because it's only a two voice bass)
-
Hmmm Black Pearls can have particularly loud basses ???
-
confirming what Dazbo said - I dont hear the basses on my Tommy as loudly as on BPII
Lin
-
That sounds right. I find Tommy, and Lily basses a bit wimpy. If you want a good low bass sound you need decent sized reeds with plenty of space for them to breathe. That will always handicap small format boxes like the Tommy etc, at least until the melodeon equivalent of Dr Who can build one that is bigger on the inside than on the outside. Like Harley Davidson buffs say "there ain't no substitute for cubes!"
-
I find Tommy, and Lily basses a bit wimpy
I'd have to agree with that, even with lowering the low G bass note two years ago
-
That sounds right. I find Tommy, and Lily basses a bit wimpy. If you want a good low bass sound you need decent sized reeds with plenty of space for them to breathe. That will always handicap small format boxes like the Tommy etc, at least until the melodeon equivalent of Dr Who can build one that is bigger on the inside than on the outside. Like Harley Davidson buffs say "there ain't no substitute for cubes!"
Theo,
Wash your mouth out with soap and water.You are an Indian man.
Old Bill. >:(
-
Yeugh, that soap tasted terrible.
-
...and Lily basses a bit wimpy.
When I owned a Lily about 12 or 13 years ago I thought the basses much too strong. The Touptit that I now play (no thirds) sounds much better balanced to me so, presumably, my audience can't hear them at all. Can't win.
Like Harley Davidson buffs say "there ain't no substitute for cubes!"
Maybe. I think I still prefer something Japanese that goes like a bomb and works in all weathers. ;D Err.. not talking melodeons here for a moment.
-
Funny how many beginners questions resolve themselves through time and practice! I didn't mess around with the boxes, just kept playing and listening. Surprise surprise - I don't find the basses too loud anymore! I've been experiementing with droning the D basses under the tune and even that wall of sound doesn't seem too loud (works well with Hexham Races which was the first proper tune I learned). Its just a matter of getting your ear in. My background is in classical guitar where you can really punch out the melody over the basses and chords/arpeggios, so I just needed to make an internal adjustment.
Thanks for all the help
-
I'm with Jax Delaguerre. Bass control is quite possible, just difficult. Stabbing can work but only opening the basses a little works too and is much better for soulfull pieces (No it's not an oxymoron on a melodeon). Think of it as squeezing the notes out instead of just stuffing a finger on the appropriate button.
Cut up crisp packets work very well for closing up unwanted reeds and are readily available at sessions. You can do it between tunes if you're quick. (make sure they are empty first)
-
I think this is my last word on this thread but it may amuse you.
I was playing my guitar the other day - I've played the guitar for 30 years and I've definitely got into a groove which works for me and sounds OK - but I haven't played much since I got the melodeon bug. Anyway on this occasion I wasn't happy. "mmmm, those bass notes just don't sound strong enough, I want a bit more melodeon-like oopmh". So I hunted arround until I found an old thumb pick I hadn't used in a decade or so and put that on. Now the bass strings boomed out in a very satisfying manner......
Seems the world is never the same once you've picked up a melodeon
Nick
-
Here are some low basses!
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=MBBa7sUTUJI&feature=related
Chris