Melodeon.net Forums

Discussions => Instrument Design, Construction and Repair => Topic started by: Martin J on January 26, 2011, 01:02:28 PM

Title: Hand Made
Post by: Martin J on January 26, 2011, 01:02:28 PM
This thread (http://forum.melodeon.net/index.php/topic,5911.0.html) raised the topic of hand made.  I thought it worthwhile to consider what this means.  Where does it begin.  Cultivate the earth, grow a tree for the wood.  Excavate ore and smelt metal for reeds.  Raise cattle and slaughter them for hide.  Carry out all processes by hand.  Be lucky if you made one melodeon in a lifetime.  Other products fair no better.

I think hand finished is a more accurate description of 'hand made' items but which bits are important and which bits can be sub contracted, possibly to fully mechanised production line?
Title: Re: Hand Made
Post by: savantuk on January 26, 2011, 02:00:43 PM
Hi,

I think that you can do better than hand finished.

I used to make hand-made knives.  I started with a billet of 02 tool steel, forged the blade, and then finished and sharpened it.  The wooden handle, liners, scales and rivets were all hand made by me from raw materials.  The leather sheath was hand cut and hand stitched from hide.  So long ago now, that few pics are left.....

http://www.britishblades.com/forums/showthread.php?t=13011

I only used manufactured material, ie tool steel, because there was no alternative.

I'm guessing that to apply the same criteria to a melodeon or accordian would be more difficult, but not impossible, but the cost would be prohibitive.
Title: Re: Hand Made
Post by: Stiamh on January 26, 2011, 03:01:53 PM
This recent thread on "sustainable development" box manufacture using readily obtainable materials might be of interest (http://forum.melodeon.net/index.php/topic,5225.0.html). (Doug, I think you joined after this was posted).
Title: Re: Hand Made
Post by: Andy in Vermont on January 27, 2011, 12:06:38 PM
This recent thread on "sustainable development" box manufacture using readily obtainable materials might be of interest (http://forum.melodeon.net/index.php/topic,5225.0.html). (Doug, I think you joined after this was posted).

Took the words right out of my mouth! ;)
-A.
Title: Re: Hand Made
Post by: Theo on January 27, 2011, 12:19:34 PM
I agree the term "hand made" is open to so many interpretations that it is almost impossible to define.

I recently came across a description of the ultimate attribution to the makers hand.   Apparently in times past the term "hand polished" was applied to furniture where the final polishing was actually done with a polishing compound applied and buffed directly with the craftsman's hand.  No cloth or brush, just the bare hand.

So by that strict definition about the only material that could really be used for hand making would be clay.  Maybe you could also apply it to the making of stone tools.   
Title: Re: Hand Made
Post by: Quebecois on February 03, 2011, 02:58:11 PM
Then we have "hand tools" and power tools... Some people consider objects made only with "hand tools" to get the label "hand made". Some extend it to the fact that no automated machinery is used to deserve the "hand-made" moniker, yet an artisan could have used power and hand tools.
Title: Re: Hand Made
Post by: Andrew Culwell on February 03, 2011, 03:43:36 PM
My definition for "Hand Made" would be a majority of  component parts manufactured, formed and put together by the artisan or craftsman from raw materials.  This would include the use of power tools and or hand tools.  This would preclude the assembly of the object with a majority of pre-manufactured component parts.  Here is where I think it can be sticky, what is the limit on percentage of pre-manufactured components like reeds and stops etc?
Title: Re: Hand Made
Post by: Telemorris on February 03, 2011, 04:11:24 PM
One approach might be to ask the question, "How many different skills does the artisan need to master a particular area of craft?" If the term hand made is too stringently applied, you can get the "Jack of all trades, master of none," situation.

I used to make musical instruments, stringed instruments, particularly lutes, guitars, and so forth. I don't think my customers quibbled with my lack of skill at making tuning machines for a guitar, or the fact that I'm not an electrician and couldn't begin to make a piezo electric pickup. The tuning machines made by Schaller are much much better than I could make and I don't need to invest in a complete machine shop and the tuition to learn how to use them. I don't have the skills, nor do I wish to acquire them. It's enough to deal with the vagaries of wood, how the different woods sound, how to make a lasting joint, install frets, apply finish, and do all the other manufacturing and assembly that's required for a guitar or lute. The narrower the focus of the skill set, the more likely it is that the craftsperson has the time to develop the skills to a high degree and the judgement to exercise those skills.

It makes me think to realize that if I were to be adamant about making every piece in, say, a melodeon with some sort of sound system installed, and do it well, I'd need to learn most of the skills and humankind has developed through many generations. Mining, timber management, metallurgy, electronics manufacture, the list goes on and on.

One other thought in this debate... Craftsmen and women need to make use of every time saving tool that they can afford to own in order to make a living. Very few craftsmen are able to make a living and support a family without those tools. Many of us know very skilled craftsmen who do the craft in their spare time and have another job to pay the bills.
 
My 2 cents
Title: Re: Hand Made
Post by: Graham Spencer on February 03, 2011, 04:23:21 PM
I, too, make stringed instruments, and I quite unashamedly use a bandsaw, a planer/thicknesser, a belt sander, a drill press, a router, a lathe.......people say "Stradivari never had a bandsaw"; no, he didn't, but if he'd had the opportunity I'll bet he would have said "Excellent - that'll save me some time" (except he would have said it in Italian!).  Masters of the craft such as Stradivari, Amati, Bergonzi and co. used the current state-of-the-art tools available to them, and someone probably accused them of cheating because they weren't using the tools their great-grandfathers had used.  You can have all the machine tools you like, but that's still no guarantee of producing high-quality work; for that you also need skill, sensitivity to your materials, dedication to your craft.....well, you get the picture. (:)

Graham
Title: Re: Hand Made
Post by: Andy Simpson on February 03, 2011, 04:41:31 PM
people say "Stradivari never had a bandsaw"; no, he didn't

Didn't need one either...he had assistants and apprentices to do all the donkey work. ;D

I think the debate about how "hand made" things is mostly a result of many people's unrealistic and heavily romanticised views about artisans and their work.
Title: Re: Hand Made
Post by: Quebecois on February 03, 2011, 04:47:25 PM
I think one needs to look at the skillset of a craftsperson (is this a word?) when making an instrument or anything else. I have no problem in seeing a luthier use a bandsaw, pressdrill or lathe with skill and precision. In fact, I prefer to see holes drilled with a press drill than a hand drill! To me this is "hand made" in comparison to having robots make parts without any human intervention.  But still, when the final assembly of all those parts,   made from quality materials, is done skillfully, I don't really care for a "hand made" label.
Title: Re: Hand Made
Post by: Chris Ryall on February 03, 2011, 05:16:38 PM
My octogenarian (nearly 90) granddad Cyril, sat by his own fireside, once "handmade" me a file.

- heated the middle of a steel bar
- quenched it to make it tough and brittle
- snapped it with a hammer
- heated and slow cooled the long bit to soften it again
- angled the smaller bit (now sharp and hard) onto the longer
- hit its other end with his hammer
  - it cuts a series of teeth (there's a knack to this!)
     - repeated same at an angle to make a cross cut
- heated and quenched the resultant grid to harden
- demonstrated that the result would actually file metal

... all without taking the Woodbine from his lip! :o I was well impressed

It also beat the pants of the current definition of 'hand made' which is to take a meat filling out of a tin, pop it in a dish, slip on a frozen puff pastry crust and leave in the oven until the pub waitress gets back  :|glug
Title: Re: Hand Made
Post by: Martin J on February 03, 2011, 07:51:58 PM
I began my working life as a millwright.  I made the tools that made tools, I made things which had a design brief but no drawings.  I used state of the art machines but I also cut, filed and lapped metal by hand when needed.  Strangely I never thought of what I did as "hand made".  My finished products were often of an extremely accurate nature.  For me 'hand made' was always a term attached to the more 'craft' items, often of an irregular and far from accurate or even consistent finish.  For  many years I considered hand made to be inferior to the superb finishes and extreme precision obtainable by machining.  Motor cars are far better for being subjected to intense machine finishing with close tolerances and repeatable processes.

Not until I considered musical instruments did 'hand made' begin to have a plus value.  Even now I feel  a good factory can produce the wood carcase and all parts far better than any artisan but, and it's a big but, it takes a human to select the wood to be used, the piece of hide that is to be cut and which way to cut these items, the feel of the springs etc.  The greatest need of human intervention is hearing and the final tuning and setting up of the instrument.  Initial tuning can be done far quicker and more accurately by machines but sometimes it takes that human touch.

So I have a mixed view on hand made which made me pose the question in the first place.  Machines can do so much, be so accurate and be repeatable but they will always need the craftsman or artisan to complete, or indeed start, the job.  In other fields, soft furnishing, jewellery making and the host of other things found at summer craft fairs I find the results variable to say the least.  So "Hand Made".  Good or bad?  Was it really all hand made?  Like most things in life, the description only half covers the reality and in some cases is used to hide reality,  :-\, are we just back to caveat emptor?
Title: Re: Hand Made
Post by: Andy in Vermont on February 03, 2011, 08:24:17 PM
For me 'hand made' was always a term attached to the more 'craft' items, often of an irregular and far from accurate or even consistent finish. 

I appreciated your comments!
For me, the distinction has a lot to do with the ratio of "workmanship of risk" vs. "workmanship of certainly" in the processes that created the "hand-made" product.  Hat tip to Chris Pye for the conceptual distinction!
I work wood predominantly with hand tools, for a variety of reasons.  While I am quick to point out that I do it "for fun" (really, that's an unfair designation, because I make many things that we use, which means there is a reason beyond "fun"), it is not entirely clear that one cannot work at commercial speeds and tolerances using the same methods that I use, albeit with a higher degree of skill and experience.  For instance, a friend of mine makes his living operating a woodworking studio where he works 100% with hand tools, and he is extremely fast -- likely as fast as a cabinetmaker in the 18th or early 19th century.  Commercial cabinet shops actually hire him to make drawers, and he specializes in reproductions of 18th century work.
At this point, there are no melodeons other than the ones that Bruno Priez is promoting in Africa, and perhaps the other project in Madagascar, which are built entirely with methods that I would personally label "hand made." However, even the most modernized shops building button accordions have to incorporate a lot of hand processes during assembly and fitting -- reed tuning is just one example.
Title: Re: Hand Made
Post by: oggiesnr on February 03, 2011, 09:45:25 PM
I could (probably) hand-make all the wooden parts of a melodeon, I could not (and I don't know anyone who can) make ALL the parts.  I do know that I could not hand-make all the wooden parts for, and then construct, a melodeon at a price that would make economic sense.  I seriously respect those who can.

Twenty-five years ago I started making wooden toys, I no longer do so because the automated factories in the Far East make them better than me and cheaper than me.  I have my own niche instead.

To me, hand-made is red herring.  The question is "Do I feel that this melodeon is worth the money to me?"  How it's made is irrelevant.  If I don't like the feel or the sound or the look I don't care if someone has poured three months into making every part of it, I won't buy it.

Steve
Title: Re: Hand Made
Post by: Christopher K. on February 04, 2011, 03:56:26 AM
My interpretation of "handmade" is less a function of how many machine tools are used, and more a function of how much individual attention is given by the craftsman (or craftsmen) to the object and its constituent parts during the construction process. A craftsman, or even a small group of them in a single workshop, can build instruments with a mixture of machine and hand tools and I still consider the instruments to be handmade. No offense to Anthony Guidice and his large collection of handplanes and bow saws but who wants to cut and flatten every board by hand if there is a perfectly good table saw and jointer nearby? Machines are by no means a replacement for good skills and practices. In a good small shop, volume is lower by nature but skill levels are high and so is the final quality, regardless of the use of power tools. There can still be a compromise without a trade-off in quality.

But compare the small shop with a factory assembly line. Does a line worker know that the playability of the new accordion is not ideal? Does he know that the tuning is out of whack? Does he have the time to know or care? He'd probably lose his job if he took the time to fix these things. His product should not be described as "handmade." To call such a product "handmade" is dishonest and unfair to real craftsmen who deserve the prestige associated with their work. Unfortunately, this happens frequently.
Title: Re: Hand Made
Post by: Martin J on February 04, 2011, 08:55:05 AM
Whilst I endorse all that has been said about hand made and the care it implies I would like to add the caveat that there are artisans or craft people, well meaning and committed, that unfortunately just don't have what it takes.  No matter how much they care or how much time they put in the resultant product will still be inferior.  If follows that the term 'hand made' cannot be taken with any certainty as to the quality of the product.
Title: Re: Hand Made
Post by: Steve_freereeder on February 04, 2011, 10:12:08 AM
I began my working life as a millwright.  I made the tools that made tools, I made things which had a design brief but no drawings.  I used state of the art machines but I also cut, filed and lapped metal by hand when needed.  Strangely I never thought of what I did as "hand made".  My finished products were often of an extremely accurate nature. ......
I think your two recent posts are really interesting and give a great insight into this whole subject, thank you!

Quote
For me 'hand made' was always a term attached to the more 'craft' items, often of an irregular and far from accurate or even consistent finish.  For many years I considered hand made to be inferior to the superb finishes and extreme precision obtainable by machining. Motor cars are far better for being subjected to intense machine finishing with close tolerances and repeatable processes.
This is a really good example. Precision instruments such as laboratory microscopes, astronomical telescopes, high-resolution scientific cameras, etc., are some others.  

Quote
Not until I considered musical instruments did 'hand made' begin to have a plus value. Even now I feel a good factory can produce the wood carcase and all parts far better than any artisan but, and it's a big but, it takes a human to select the wood to be used, the piece of hide that is to be cut and which way to cut these items, the feel of the springs, etc. The greatest need of human intervention is hearing and the final tuning and setting up of the instrument.
This is excellent! While ever musical instruments are intended to be played by humans, there has to be human input at all stages, even if close-tolerance machines are used in some stages of the construction. The ultimate tests of a good instrument are whether it sounds good, can be played in tune (whatever that entails), and whether the musician can combine symbiotically with the instrument to create music which has passion and soul. In Sanskrit terms it has to have rasa (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Rasa_(aesthetics)). I don't think I have ever heard any synthetic electronic music which has passion and soul.

Quote
So I have a mixed view on hand made which made me pose the question in the first place.  Machines can do so much, be so accurate and be repeatable but they will always need the craftsman or artisan to complete, or indeed start, the job.
Totally agree.

Whilst I endorse all that has been said about hand made and the care it implies I would like to add the caveat that there are artisans or craft people, well meaning and committed, that unfortunately just don't have what it takes. No matter how much they care or how much time they put in the resultant product will still be inferior.
This is an interesting viewpoint. I hadn't thought about it like that before, but I'm sure you are right. I wonder why it is so? I suppose the nearby musical analogy is that for some people, no matter how good an instrument they have, and no matter how much time and practise they put in, if they don't have music within them to begin with, they will never ever create something which is truly musical, with passion and soul. It has no rasa.
Title: Re: Hand Made
Post by: blafleur on February 04, 2011, 02:03:10 PM
As has been said, doing more by "hand" does not equate to better quality.  What you do get with instruments made by a person, no matter how many nice tools he has, is attention to detail in the final fittings and tunings, that can't be done by any machine I know of.  I use as many power tools I can afford to make parts.  But once the parts are cut out, which doesn't take long.  The tedious process of fitting them each begins.  Each rocker arm is individually fit to it's respective slot.  Each valve (pallet) is fit for perfect seal.  Slides are individually fit for seal and operation.  Springs are individually adjusted. Taking the end user's wishes into account for special touches.  Then there's tuning..........

If that doesn't constitute hand made, I just can't imagine what does. The quality comes ( or doesn't) from the skill and experience of the person fitting these parts together, and that's very much a matter of personal preference.
Title: Re: Hand Made
Post by: blafleur on February 04, 2011, 04:55:30 PM

Granddad's file was very rough  ;D

But, a file is supposed to be rough, and it may have been a very effective grade of rough. (:)
Title: Re: Hand Made
Post by: Andy in Vermont on February 05, 2011, 12:01:32 AM
As has been said, doing more by "hand" does not equate to better quality.  What you do get with instruments made by a person, no matter how many nice tools he has, is attention to detail in the final fittings and tunings, that can't be done by any machine I know of.  I use as many power tools I can afford to make parts.  But once the parts are cut out, which doesn't take long.  The tedious process of fitting them each begins.  Each rocker arm is individually fit to it's respective slot.  Each valve (pallet) is fit for perfect seal.  Slides are individually fit for seal and operation.  Springs are individually adjusted. Taking the end user's wishes into account for special touches.  Then there's tuning..........

If that doesn't constitute hand made, I just can't imagine what does.

Bryan,
what is interesting (to me, at least) is that all the processes that you described are also done in a small factory setting such as Castagnari.
-Andy
Title: Re: Hand Made
Post by: blafleur on February 05, 2011, 08:49:14 PM
Makes sense Andy, I don't see how any quality instrument can be made without finishing by hand.  Nice machines can make more parts faster, and maybe do a lot of intriquite detailing, but to make it actually work smooth and sound right, it's gotta be done by a person with some degree of skill.
Title: Re: Hand Made
Post by: oggiesnr on February 05, 2011, 10:37:14 PM
Makes sense Andy, I don't see how any quality instrument can be made without finishing by hand.  Nice machines can make more parts faster, and maybe do a lot of intriquite detailing, but to make it actually work smooth and sound right, it's gotta be done by a person with some degree of skill.

.. and therein lies the difference between a Chinese box and a quality box.  Therein also lies the difference in price.

Steve
Title: Re: Hand Made
Post by: Chris Ryall on February 06, 2011, 08:29:41 AM
what is interesting (to me, at least) is that all the processes that you described are also done in a small factory setting such as Castagnari.

Not quite all.  When I was there they were making the boxes starting from rough seasoned timber (stacked in the yard) - though it's hard to see how they might avoid buying in planed wood nowadays  given their present output. A lot of items - buttons, straps, inlays and importantly reed plates were defo bought in. There was also a production line going with basic woodwork ground floor, finer stuff on 1st, finishing and reed fitting top.

Contrast the Dipper's concertina manufacture. Colin even machines his own bolt threads (though I suspect he bought in the steel and brass rods required).

There's a lot of "Adam Smith" to this thread. Total handmadeness doesn't necessarily equate to quality. I think it is the maker's attention to detail that matters.
Title: Re: Hand Made
Post by: Martin J on February 06, 2011, 11:07:20 AM
I think it is the maker's attention to detail that matters.
.. and his innate ability.
Title: Re: Hand Made
Post by: Andy in Vermont on February 06, 2011, 02:08:28 PM
Not quite all.  When I was there they were making the boxes starting from rough seasoned timber (stacked in the yard) - though it's hard to see how they might avoid buying in planed wood nowadays  given their present output. A lot of items - buttons, straps, inlays and importantly reed plates were defo bought in. There was also a production line going with basic woodwork ground floor, finer stuff on 1st, finishing and reed fitting top.

Chris,
the Cajun builders also bring in buttons, straps, inlays, and reed plates.  My point stands, doesn't it?
-Andy
p.s. do you KNOW that Castagnari is bringing in pre-planed lumber or do you just suspect that?  Because it would not actually save them much in time or money (as my pro-cabinetmaker friends have assured me).
Title: Re: Hand Made
Post by: Andy in Vermont on February 06, 2011, 02:43:54 PM
There's a lot of "Adam Smith" to this thread. Total handmadeness doesn't necessarily equate to quality. I think it is the maker's attention to detail that matters.

I agree completely!  Also, breaking up the process, as long as the individuals have a high degree of skill, maintain a sense of pride, and also have a picture of the "whole" (i.e., Castagnari), the results can be on par with "one-man" shops, and in some cases set the standard.  On the other hand, some products of one-man (or two-person) shops reveal that the makers do not have a sense of what could be possible, if they acquired greater skill and the ability to discern certain hallmarks of craftsmanship, such as wood selection and matching, and surface treatments.

The beholder's perspective is a huge part of this, of course.  I live in a region that is fairly saturated with artisans' workshops -- and there is a wide range of skill and background, from naive to highly skilled, pedigreed backgrounds.  It is clear that some buyers prefer aspects of the naive -- whether it is an idea of the rustic Vermont farmer who turns to making crooked pottery during the winter or whatever.  I think that there is a bit of this mystique involved with Cajun builders, especially if the builder is an amazing musician.
Title: Re: Hand Made
Post by: blafleur on February 06, 2011, 05:23:53 PM
The problem with most high quality hand skills, like most art works, is you can't really get paid for it. For most real crafts people, they choose to do it for personal satisfaction with a little money on the side.  Except for maybe those few people that have established their names at a level (justified or not) that allows them to charge reasonable rates.

If I ever get to thinking about money more than the satisfaction of building the best accordion I can, I hope I have the frame of mind to move on to something else.
Title: Re: Hand Made
Post by: Andy in Vermont on February 06, 2011, 05:38:47 PM
If I ever get to thinking about money more than the satisfaction of building the best accordion I can, I hope I have the frame of mind to move on to something else.

Ha! Let's hope that it doesn't happen!
I do think that there is an element of "sacrifice" in many instrument builders' work -- and this actually gets "fetishized" by the buyers, who are always getting "more" (of the individual artisan's labor?) than their money's worth.

Some hand techniques are time-eaters, others are actually time savers, once they are properly learned.  An example of the latter is proper handplaning (which also involves fine sharpening of the cutter as well as setup of the plane).  A few passes with a smoother (like a #3 or #4) takes so much less time than sanding up through all those grits, and leaves a surface where the grain does not need to be raised before finishing.  So while you might spend a few minutes honing the edge, you still get to skip a lot of other steps, and I would argue that the result is superior (although more obviously so on a large surface like a table top).
Title: Re: Hand Made
Post by: blafleur on February 06, 2011, 05:50:12 PM
  An example of the latter is proper handplaning 

And the sound a sharp plane makes slicing through wood makes me giggle like a girl being tickled.  Well, almost.
Title: Re: Hand Made
Post by: Guy on February 07, 2011, 02:33:18 PM
Not quite all.  When I was there they were making the boxes starting from rough seasoned timber (stacked in the yard) - though it's hard to see how they might avoid buying in planed wood nowadays  given their present output.

p.s. do you KNOW that Castagnari is bringing in pre-planed lumber or do you just suspect that?  Because it would not actually save them much in time or money (as my pro-cabinetmaker friends have assured me).

When I was there last (about 4 years ago) they were still bringing in rough seasoned timber. I met a very active gentleman who told me he was in his in his late 70's. His job was to travel aroung identifying and purchasing suitably seasoned wood of appropriate quality, and who showed me the pile of said timber with a certain amount of well-deserved pride....
Title: Re: Hand Made
Post by: Martin J on February 07, 2011, 05:19:07 PM
I met a very active gentleman who told me he was in his in his late 70's. His job was to travel aroung identifying and purchasing suitably seasoned wood of appropriate quality, and who showed me the pile of said timber with a certain amount of well-deserved pride....
I think this is what 'hand made' is about.  The machines can cut it and finish it but it takes a person to identify and 'choose'
Title: Re: Hand Made
Post by: oggiesnr on February 07, 2011, 05:24:47 PM
The problem with most high quality hand skills, like most art works, is you can't really get paid for it. For most real crafts people, they choose to do it for personal satisfaction with a little money on the side.  Except for maybe those few people that have established their names at a level (justified or not) that allows them to charge reasonable rates.

If I ever get to thinking about money more than the satisfaction of building the best accordion I can, I hope I have the frame of mind to move on to something else.

An instrument maker won the lottery.  When asked what he was going to do with the money he replied "Well, I'll just go on making instruments until the money runs out!"

Steve
Title: Re: Hand Made
Post by: waltzman on February 07, 2011, 10:32:55 PM
  An example of the latter is proper handplaning 

And the sound a sharp plane makes slicing through wood makes me giggle like a girl being tickled.  Well, almost.

Me too.  and there is nothing like a set of japanese water stones for putting the edge on it.
SimplePortal 2.3.5 © 2008-2012, SimplePortal