Melodeon.net Forums
Discussions => Instrument Design, Construction and Repair => Topic started by: Sandy Flett on January 27, 2011, 03:19:49 PM
-
Edit - turns out my observation/question below about the bass reeds was based on a wrong interpretation, so not relevant anymore. Could not get the Remove button to remove the topic
A friend has just acquired a Castagnari Lilly, date stamped 2001 on the inside. He sent me some photos of the inside and I was amazed to learn (a) the treble reeds are laid flat in a reedpan as opposed to a reedblock (like the Hohner Preciosa, and (b) the bass has one reed per bass button and only one reed per chord button (but in a large reedblock that just about fills the inside volume).
Are all Lillys like this?
How well does the single note work in place of a chord ?
Are the bass reeds "nice and low but fast to sound"?
Are the Saltarelle Epsilon and Excelsior Mini also like this?
-
My other half's Lilly, dated 2000, has three reeds for the chords. I blocked off the thirds on it. It sounds like it has only one bass reed, but I can't remember, it was several years ago I took the bass reed block out. The bass reeds are not particularly low. Don't know about the others, but it's unlikely they have less than two chord reeds. The B Loffet Touptit has two chord reeds.
If your friend's Lilly is like that it's probably a custom job.
-
At a guess the bass mechanism uses the tonic chord reed as well as the bass reed to give a fuller bass note. This is certainly true for the Tommy.
-
The Lily always has the treble reeds mounted flat.
The bass block has 4 reeds for each Bass/chord pair of buttons. Two of them sound for the bass and three for the chord, as Lester says the tonic reed is shared between bass and chord.
-
After Theo's post, I have had another look (and think) and realise I have misinterpreted what I saw in the photo and what my friend had said about the bass sounds - I think the previous owner may have taped off some of the reeds.
I would have removed the topic (to avoid potential confusion for future readers) but seemingly cannot do that anymore.