Melodeon.net Forums

Discussions => Other Free Reed Instruments => Topic started by: Alan Morley on January 28, 2011, 09:13:53 AM

Title: Midi keyboards v acoustic boxes.
Post by: Alan Morley on January 28, 2011, 09:13:53 AM
MIDI or Acoustic

I just found an interesting video on You Tube, with a talented guy playing a set of jigs on a keyboard, I have my own opinions of what he's produced - but see what you think.

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=CF1l-eLeUjU&feature=related (http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=CF1l-eLeUjU&feature=related)

Comments please... :||:
Title: Re: Midi keyboards v acoustic boxes.
Post by: Theo on January 28, 2011, 09:19:02 AM
Pure cheese! ;D
Title: Re: Midi keyboards v acoustic boxes.
Post by: ACE on January 28, 2011, 09:24:58 AM
Might be better with bagpipe sounds, and fingers like little pink maggots with St. Vitus dance ;D
Title: Re: Midi keyboards v acoustic boxes.
Post by: HallelujahAl on January 28, 2011, 09:56:58 AM
Loved it! n Thanks for posting.
AL
Title: Re: Midi keyboards v acoustic boxes.
Post by: **DTN** on January 28, 2011, 11:20:28 AM
Richard Smith does a great job and a very skilled player, i like what he does!
Title: Re: Midi keyboards v acoustic boxes.
Post by: Anahata on January 28, 2011, 11:44:43 AM
A lot of English PA players could benefit from learning to play like that.
Title: Re: Midi keyboards v acoustic boxes.
Post by: Alan Morley on January 28, 2011, 11:46:46 AM
I'd love to hear him on a Piano Accordeon rather than the keyboard.
Title: Re: Midi keyboards v acoustic boxes.
Post by: Martin J on January 28, 2011, 02:13:57 PM
Remarkable skill.  Really picks his fingers up (ref Anahata / PA players)  but!, there was something not quite right.  I think it was the too regular bump in the bass, or lack of syncopation in the accompaniment.
Title: Re: Midi keyboards v acoustic boxes.
Post by: Quebecois on January 28, 2011, 02:38:20 PM
The electronic accompaniment sound part is a bit distracting but he definitely has great talent!
I much prefer to see young people play this kind of music than death thrash metal...
Thumbs up!
Title: Re: Midi keyboards v acoustic boxes.
Post by: Alan Morley on January 28, 2011, 03:30:02 PM
And now on accordeon

This 16 year old accordeon player with the same tunes, I prefer the real sound any time..

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=JsyxbJvN_QA (http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=JsyxbJvN_QA)

Enjoy

Alan
Title: Re: Midi keyboards v acoustic boxes.
Post by: Quebecois on January 28, 2011, 03:32:59 PM
Two sets of skills, two interpretations...
Title: Re: Midi keyboards v acoustic boxes.
Post by: Martin J on January 28, 2011, 03:36:32 PM
Two sets of skills, two interpretations...
As you earlier post, it's great that the youngsters are playing this music.  I felt more relaxed with the accordion piece, even though it was played with more notes in it, it didn't sound rushed.
Title: Re: Midi keyboards v acoustic boxes.
Post by: Quebecois on January 28, 2011, 04:23:00 PM
Two sets of skills, two interpretations...
As you earlier post, it's great that the youngsters are playing this music.  I felt more relaxed with the accordion piece, even though it was played with more notes in it, it didn't sound rushed.
Bottom line is, traditional music lives! I much prefer 'mechanical' instruments with natural sound but as long as the new generations keep carrying the musical heritage they will always get my encouragement and support.
Title: Re: Midi keyboards v acoustic boxes.
Post by: HallelujahAl on January 28, 2011, 04:36:18 PM
Quote
Bottom line is, traditional music lives! I much prefer 'mechanical' instruments with natural sound but as long as the new generations keep carrying the musical heritage they will always get my encouragement and support.

I totally agree - and also as a parent of teenagers I'm very aware that just every now and then I needs must venture outta my cave and feel the sun on my face (even though I don't really like it as it's horrible shiny stuff that hurts my eyes and burns my skin). Thing is, each time I do venture out of my little musical cavern I find that I'm amazed and really impressed with what so many youngsters are achieving musically these days. All of my 4 children are far and away better musicians than I will ever be (and that starts with my youngest 7 year old daughter who is a better pianist and keyboard player than I have ever been). And my teenage son uses Irish & Scots fiddle tunes just to warm up on when he plays his electric guitar - which he does at lightening speed. He claims they help him with some of the solos that he needs to play in his Heavy Metal Rock Band. So traditional music is alive - it's just living in a slightly different way I think.
AL
Title: Re: Midi keyboards v acoustic boxes.
Post by: Alan Morley on January 28, 2011, 04:52:45 PM
The question I really raised was, given two great performances of the same tune - played with skill and feeling, which sounds the better to your ears the electronic keyboard or the natural accordeon.

I agree it great to see young musicians though..

Alan
Title: Re: Midi keyboards v acoustic boxes.
Post by: Theo on January 28, 2011, 04:55:06 PM
I agree it great to see young musicians though..

Yes indeed, there are hordes of them in Tyneside, its great!
Title: Re: Midi keyboards v acoustic boxes.
Post by: Quebecois on January 28, 2011, 05:05:35 PM
The question I really raised was, given two great performances of the same tune - played with skill and feeling, which sounds the better to your ears the electronic keyboard or the natural accordeon.
I don't think this is a 'fair' question  ::) !
Title: Re: Midi keyboards v acoustic boxes.
Post by: Stiamh on January 28, 2011, 05:10:05 PM
I had to stop the electronic version just as he slid into the second tune. Skill yes. But feeling? I didn't discern any in the first tune. It sounded outstandingly unmusical to me - no lilt at all.

Title: Re: Midi keyboards v acoustic boxes.
Post by: HallelujahAl on January 28, 2011, 05:12:35 PM
Quote
The question I really raised was, given two great performances of the same tune - played with skill and feeling, which sounds the better to your ears the electronic keyboard or the natural accordeon.
Without doubt, to my ears, the keyboard was a much better musical interpretation (the keyboard piece also included another jig as well, so like for like comparison runs into difficulties there) - RS certainly played with greater feeling, and used volume and tempo wisely. The young laddie on the piano accordion belted two of the jigs out alright, but musically the keyboard interpretation is the one I'd much rather listen to frankly. But they're two different species playing similar repertoire...so you pays your money... :D
Title: Re: Midi keyboards v acoustic boxes.
Post by: Quebecois on January 28, 2011, 05:15:40 PM
I had to stop the electronic version just as he slid into the second tune. Skill yes. But feeling?
I too have a problem with electronic accompaniments and percussions... I think we are in presence of (at least) two things:
- Musical technique (i.e. playing the notes of a tune on a given instrument)
- Musical expression

The kid on the piano accordion seems to have both! Yet RS uses his electronic gizmo to add some 'expression'.
Title: Re: Midi keyboards v acoustic boxes.
Post by: Theo on January 28, 2011, 05:58:03 PM

The kid on the piano accordion seems to have both!

I think he is called Wullie Scott.  I liked his accordion playing, though he still has to learn that sometimes less is more in music.  He seemed to want to display all his technique as soon as possible.  I'm sure he will become more laid back as he matures as a person and a player.
Title: Re: Midi keyboards v acoustic boxes.
Post by: Owen Woods on January 29, 2011, 01:58:26 AM
I had to stop the electronic version just as he slid into the second tune. Skill yes. But feeling? I didn't discern any in the first tune. It sounded outstandingly unmusical to me - no lilt at all.



It gets slightly better as it goes on, but I agree, little musical expression, even for a keyboard player :( The young accordionist was better, but only just. He has a habit of playing things unnecessarily fast. I am shocked that he is only 16 though, he is this chap: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ex8riLq28TI who a group of us are trying to emulate, trying to get missing time up to speed. It's tricky on BCC#, slightly easier on PA I reckon. I prefer Graeme's version: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=f_MaekQ_7OA
Title: Re: Midi keyboards v acoustic boxes.
Post by: HallelujahAl on January 29, 2011, 12:22:45 PM
It sort of relates so I'll let you guys know here that I've put a little electronic vs acoustic box challenge up for you in the other instruments board (as most of them are PA's): See here (http://forum.melodeon.net/index.php/topic,5990.msg75387.html#new)
Good Luck!
AL
Title: Re: Midi keyboards v acoustic boxes.
Post by: savantuk on March 15, 2011, 11:42:37 AM
Whilst I think both players have tremendous skill, I preferred the keyboard player.

He played the pieces straight, without too much ornamentation, but with abundant enthusiasm.

As a player who has only ever played for dancing and my own enjoyment, I always play without ornamentation.  I remember once being told (by a Northumbrian pipes player), for dancing, always play the music straight, the dancers will appreciate it, and dance better for it.
Title: Re: Midi keyboards v acoustic boxes.
Post by: Bill Young on March 15, 2011, 01:38:05 PM

The kid on the piano accordion seems to have both!

I think he is called Wullie Scott.  I liked his accordion playing, though he still has to learn that sometimes less is more in music.  He seemed to want to display all his technique as soon as possible.  I'm sure he will become more laid back as he matures as a person and a player.
I'm just catching up on this thread. I didn't realise there was a clip of Wullie (Willie, William) Scott on it. I hear him 2-3 times a month at local accordion and fiddle clubs. Now 19, he hasn't slowed down much. A week ago he won the Classical Polka section at the National Association of Accordion and Fiddle Clubs competitions. He can be heard playing at the winners' concert on "Take The Floor" on BBC iPlayer: http://www.bbc.co.uk/iplayer/console/b00z5884/Take_the_Floor_12_03_2011 (http://www.bbc.co.uk/iplayer/console/b00z5884/Take_the_Floor_12_03_2011). He's at 1hr 36min 25sec into the programme and his tune is called, appropriately enough, "A Fond La Caisse", which I understand is colloquial French for "Flat Out" or "Pedal To The Metal".
SimplePortal 2.3.5 © 2008-2012, SimplePortal