Melodeon.net Forums

Discussions => News and Events => Topic started by: Lester on January 29, 2011, 03:04:38 PM

Title: Melodeon Makers Course July 2011, London
Post by: Lester on January 29, 2011, 03:04:38 PM
Jon Eastman is organising a Melodeon Makers Course led by Emmanuel Pariselle to be run from 4 to 12 July. It will be based at the South Thames College. It will be to make a  2.5 row (D/G plus). He needs 10 students (well 9 because I'm going :) ) to make the course a goer. Cost and application process to follow. If you pm me I can let you have Jon's email address.
Title: Melodeon Makers Course July 2011, London
Post by: melodeanman on January 29, 2011, 03:07:12 PM
Are the details of the course on line?
Title: Melodeon Makers Course July 2011, London
Post by: Lester on January 29, 2011, 03:15:33 PM
Are the details of the course on line?

Not just yet but soon
Title: Re: Melodeon Makers Course July 2011, London
Post by: Theo on January 29, 2011, 03:46:46 PM
I've changed the title to distinguish this thread from other courses
Title: Re: Melodeon Makers Course July 2011, London
Post by: Lester on January 29, 2011, 03:49:19 PM
Another teaser -here is a picture of Fidjit modelling the box he made on the same course in Belgium

(http://forum.melodeon.net/index.php?action=dlattach;topic=1942.0;attach=1288;image)

The bass configuration is yet to be agreed
Title: Re: Melodeon Makers Course July 2011, London
Post by: EeeJay on January 29, 2011, 04:10:21 PM
Hmmmm... wondering if it has to be D/G flavoured...?

The bass configuration is yet to be agreed

Can't see nowt wrong with 14 bass... 8)

Ed J
Title: Re: Melodeon Makers Course July 2011, London
Post by: Theo on January 29, 2011, 04:19:54 PM
Hmmmm... wondering if it has to be D/G flavoured...?


The one-row course allowed the student to choose their own key, and in one case a completely different note layout.  I would have thought the same would apply here, but I'm not the organiser!
Title: Re: Melodeon Makers Course July 2011, London
Post by: melodeanman on January 29, 2011, 04:20:05 PM
Is it the same Emmanuel Pariselle thats singing  la nonchalante on Youtube........ http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=-KjaiWI8WPI
Title: Re: Melodeon Makers Course July 2011, London
Post by: Steve_freereeder on January 29, 2011, 04:21:45 PM
Is it the same Emmanuel Pariselle thats singing  la nonchalante on Youtube........ http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=-KjaiWI8WPI
The very same!
Title: Re: Melodeon Makers Course July 2011, London
Post by: Fidjit on January 29, 2011, 05:27:47 PM
What a nice picture that is.

I  had a great time

Should have waited for this one as the course I was on was all in French!  :|bl  I don't do French. Managed though.  :|glug
Title: Re: Melodeon Makers Course July 2011, London
Post by: melodeanman on January 29, 2011, 05:43:02 PM
Hi Fidjit I have sent a Pm
Title: Re: Melodeon Makers Course July 2011, London
Post by: malcolmbebb on January 29, 2011, 05:48:02 PM
Just to get a flavour, can anyone tell what previous courses have cost?
Title: Re: Melodeon Makers Course July 2011, London
Post by: Lester on January 29, 2011, 05:54:37 PM
Just to get a flavour, can anyone tell what previous courses have cost?

It will have little or no bearing as all the 2.5 row courses were run abroad so no €/£ issues, the price will be available next week. For what is is worth (and I'm not sure how much that is ) the 1 row course cost £1200 early last year.
Title: Re: Melodeon Makers Course July 2011, London
Post by: Fidjit on January 29, 2011, 08:47:47 PM
Price for the 2 & 1/2 row in Belgium 2009 was 1550 euros
This included all meals that were on site. We all chipped in and helped make the food. Actually I mostly just ate the food. :|glug

Pit falls are watch out for the machine that cuts half your hand off. (t happened) But you won't be allowed to get near to those machines. (Regulations)

Be carefull which tuning you choose there are hundreds of different ones.

Good luck to everyone. It's really a Buzz to make your own box.  :|glug

As there was a choice I made mine in G/C

There are some videos of it being played on my Youtube channel And even one of Emmanuel and Christian Maes playing them both together.

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=j7VAiMu0roI

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ZdzR7YR0g9E

Here they are. Just to wet your taste.
Title: Re: Melodeon Makers Course July 2011, London
Post by: Graham W on January 30, 2011, 09:49:41 AM
Hello,

That looks lovely!
Were the treble and bass mechanisms made on the course, or did they use 'bought in' metal components?  In either case I'd be very interested to see them if you have any pics of the treble and bass mechanisms/components parts.

Cheers, Graham

Title: Re: Melodeon Makers Course July 2011, London
Post by: Fidjit on January 30, 2011, 03:01:29 PM
You will work on all of the woodwork and all the mechanical parts. I.e. all the mechanism is hand made.

The only parts that come finished (or nearly) are the bellows and the reeds. The reeds have to be tuned. And here I'm sure it will be either Rees or Theo. Or perhaps Marc from France. I'll see if I can load up some photo's.  :||:  :|||:


Title: Re: Melodeon Makers Course July 2011, London
Post by: savantuk on January 30, 2011, 04:23:35 PM
You will work on all of the woodwork and all the mechanical parts. I.e. all the mechanism is hand made.

The only parts that come finished (or nearly) are the bellows and the reeds. The reeds have to be tuned. And here I'm sure it will be either Rees or Theo. Or perhaps Marc from France. I'll see if I can load up some photo's.  :||:  :|||:




You made a grand job of that box of yours Fidjit!!  I'd love to do this course, but I'm fairly confident that anything I made would end up looking more like a skateboard than a melodeon.
Title: Re: Melodeon Makers Course July 2011, London
Post by: Fidjit on January 30, 2011, 05:03:26 PM
Hello,

That looks lovely!
Were the treble and bass mechanisms made on the course, or did they use 'bought in' metal components?  In either case I'd be very interested to see them if you have any pics of the treble and bass mechanisms/components parts.

Cheers, Graham


Lets see if I can get to upload a photo for you
Title: Re: Melodeon Makers Course July 2011, London
Post by: BFG on January 31, 2011, 09:03:01 AM
Hi Lester - sent you a PM.

Cheers,

Rob
Title: Re: Melodeon Makers Course July 2011, London
Post by: brianread on January 31, 2011, 10:00:01 AM
Lester, knowing what an organised Guy you are - do you have a link to the thread you posted with all the photos that you took of the melodeon making in Suffolk.  I'd like to peruse then in the light of this (and so might others).  It was you wasn't it?
Title: Re: Melodeon Makers Course July 2011, London
Post by: Theo on January 31, 2011, 10:11:55 AM
Lots of photos on EATMT website (http://www.eatmt.org.uk/Melodeon%20Makers.htm), as long as you can wait for the sloooow page loads.

And I have some on facebook (http://www.facebook.com/album.php?aid=159788&id=709188166&l=debb35254d) (public link you don't have to be a fb member)

I'm sure Lester has more.
Title: Re: Melodeon Makers Course July 2011, London
Post by: Fidjit on January 31, 2011, 10:17:14 AM
Theo

I have a set on my myspace site among other things. :|bl

Shouldn't bother with that Theo. MS is a waste of space  ha, ha.

Title: Re: Melodeon Makers Course July 2011, London
Post by: Lester on January 31, 2011, 11:33:06 AM
Lester, knowing what an organised Guy you are - do you have a link to the thread you posted with all the photos that you took of the melodeon making in Suffolk.  I'd like to peruse then in the light of this (and so might others).  It was you wasn't it?

Your wish etc

One row course photos (https://picasaweb.google.com/lester.bailey/10_04_11MelodeonMakers?authkey=Gv1sRgCNuhzLqW2Zv6kQE#)
Title: Re: Melodeon Makers Course July 2011, London
Post by: Thrupenny Bit on January 31, 2011, 04:38:42 PM
That looks like a really nice thing to do.....
and the finished product looks very nicely put together. Well done all
Q
Title: Re: Melodeon Makers Course July 2011, London
Post by: savantuk on February 01, 2011, 12:29:07 AM

One row course photos (https://picasaweb.google.com/lester.bailey/10_04_11MelodeonMakers?authkey=Gv1sRgCNuhzLqW2Zv6kQE#)

These look fabulous, and appear to be every bit as good as those professionally made.  This observation leads me to two possible conclusions, ie, melodeons are very simple to make, or the amateur makers are extremely skilled.

I know that it's extremely difficult to make a melodeon, so.......... :|||:
Title: Re: Melodeon Makers Course July 2011, London
Post by: Bill S on February 01, 2011, 12:51:46 AM
Lester I have sent you a PM
Bill

Edited to add;
I've known of this course for a good while but never expected it to happen in England, so I had to make my first post in the hope I can get on it.

I would also like to say what a useful & informative forum this is, I have often found answers to little problems by scrolling through previous post.......Thanks all.
Title: Re: Melodeon Makers Course July 2011, London
Post by: Theo on February 01, 2011, 08:00:44 AM
This observation leads me to two possible conclusions, ie, melodeons are very simple to make, or the amateur makers are extremely skilled.

I know that it's extremely difficult to make a melodeon, so.......... :|||:

You are neglecting to skill of M Pariselle without whom none of them would have been built.
Title: Re: Melodeon Makers Course July 2011, London
Post by: savantuk on February 01, 2011, 05:32:48 PM
This observation leads me to two possible conclusions, ie, melodeons are very simple to make, or the amateur makers are extremely skilled.

I know that it's extremely difficult to make a melodeon, so.......... :|||:

You are neglecting to skill of M Pariselle without whom none of them would have been built.

Indeed, remiss of me.  Without his skill and knowledge, this level of competence would not have been possible.
Title: Re: Melodeon Makers Course July 2011, London
Post by: Pete on February 04, 2011, 11:49:58 PM
Hi Lester
I'd really like to do the meodeon making course and I think that I sent you a message yesterday but being a bit crap with all this computer stuff I'm not sure .How would do I sign up

Cheers Pete
Title: Re: Melodeon Makers Course July 2011, London
Post by: brianread on February 05, 2011, 05:21:33 AM
Hi Lester
I'd really like to do the meodeon making course and I think that I sent you a message yesterday but being a bit crap with all this computer stuff I'm not sure .How would do I sign up

Cheers Pete

I sent an email to the relevant man last Sat, but have not yet had a response, I guess they are still working out the details.
Title: Re: Melodeon Makers Course July 2011, London
Post by: Graham Spencer on February 05, 2011, 06:09:12 AM
Hi Lester
I'd really like to do the meodeon making course and I think that I sent you a message yesterday but being a bit crap with all this computer stuff I'm not sure .How would do I sign up

Cheers Pete

I sent an email to the relevant man last Sat, but have not yet had a response, I guess they are still working out the details.

I had an almost instant response; you're right, the details are still being worlked out and will be passed on to inquirers in due course.

Graham
Title: Re: Melodeon Makers Course July 2011, London
Post by: brianread on February 05, 2011, 09:37:26 AM
Hi Lester
I'd really like to do the meodeon making course and I think that I sent you a message yesterday but being a bit crap with all this computer stuff I'm not sure .How would do I sign up

Cheers Pete

I sent an email to the relevant man last Sat, but have not yet had a response, I guess they are still working out the details.

I had an almost instant response; you're right, the details are still being worlked out and will be passed on to inquirers in due course.

Graham

mmm, I wonder if my email was lost then, I'll try again...
Title: Re: Melodeon Makers Course July 2011, London
Post by: Pete on February 05, 2011, 03:57:29 PM
Hello Brian ,thanks for the info .I'll leave it a day or two and try again. The bother is that if there are only a few places I wouldn't want to miss out .Any way Cheers Pete
Title: Re: Melodeon Makers Course July 2011, London
Post by: baz parkes on February 11, 2011, 12:13:42 PM
Managed though.  :|glug

If that's the result of "managing" I'd like to have seen the result if you parlayed the old fransey.... (:)
Title: Re: Melodeon Makers Course July 2011, London
Post by: jon_1 on February 11, 2011, 08:17:14 PM
More pics from April last year here https://picasaweb.google.com/115873982086248879926
Title: Re: Melodeon Makers Course July 2011, London
Post by: The Cidermaker on February 12, 2011, 10:22:44 AM
Hello everybody,

I went on the course in Belgium with Chas . It was very hard work but very rewarding, and M Pariselle is an excellent teacher  and very talented. I subsequently returned to Belgium last year and changed the tuning from D/G to C/G which involved making all new reed blocks, I also started building a 3 voice box to Emmanuel's design with a few modifications to the internal mechanism. I have some pics of the internals and mechanism of these boxes.  Emmanuel was telling me some time ago that there might be a workshop in the UK. I will be seeing him soon to collect the reeds for the 3 Voice box.

Being totally computer illiterate if somebody can tell me how to post photos on here, I can put them  on if anybody is interested, or I could send them by e mail.

best wishes,

Richard
Title: CONFIRMED - Melodeon Makers Course July 2011, London
Post by: Lester on March 01, 2011, 07:42:40 AM
Jon has finally manged to confirm that this course will happen.

Short Course:   Melodeon Making with Emmanuel Pariselle
Course Code:   COT1091/MD0CA
Dates:      4th – 12th July 2011
Venue:      Merton Campus, South Thames College London Road, Morden, Surrey SM4 5QX
(except for Saturday 9 and Sunday 10 when the college is closed).
Location:   Merton Campus is ten minutes walk from Morden underground station at the southern end of the Northern Line.
Cost:      Â£1,400
Enrolment:   Call 020 8408 6500 and quote the course code

Title: Re: Melodeon Makers Course July 2011, London
Post by: brianread on March 01, 2011, 09:27:27 AM
Seems to be a problem with enrolling on this at the moment, hoping for a resolution soon!
Title: Re: Melodeon Makers Course July 2011, London
Post by: Fidjit on March 01, 2011, 12:19:24 PM
Hello everybody,

I went on the course in Belgium with Chas . It was very hard work but very rewarding, and M Pariselle is an excellent teacher  and very talented. I subsequently returned to Belgium last year and changed the tuning from D/G to C/G which involved making all new reed blocks, I also started building a 3 voice box to Emmanuel's design with a few modifications to the internal mechanism. I have some pics of the internals and mechanism of these boxes.  Emmanuel was telling me some time ago that there might be a workshop in the UK. I will be seeing him soon to collect the reeds for the 3 Voice box.

Being totally computer illiterate if somebody can tell me how to post photos on here, I can put them  on if anybody is interested, or I could send them by e mail.

best wishes,

Richard


Hi Richard. Nice to hear from you.

Wasn't that place in Belgium just great.

To upload photo's there is an additional options button bottom left.

<Edited to add > When you write a message.

Press that. Then browse your photo's. Make sure they are not too big.

Cheers Chas
Title: Re: Melodeon Makers Course July 2011, London
Post by: Lester on March 01, 2011, 01:03:21 PM
There appears still to be problems with enrolement but should be fixed by tomorrow I am told.
Title: Re: Melodeon Makers Course July 2011, London
Post by: Graham Spencer on March 01, 2011, 07:54:17 PM
I received all the course details this norning. It appears that the only choice is a 2-voice D/G 2.5 row; as I already have one of those that I'm very happy with, I will probably be not be following up. Now if I could build a C/F or a G/C I'd be there like a shot.........

Graham
Title: Re: Melodeon Makers Course July 2011, London
Post by: Dunny on March 02, 2011, 09:08:24 AM
It's still not possible to enrol as at 0900 -apparently it takes 24 hours for the course to appear on the system and it wasn't entered until last night. I was told to try again tomorrow morning.
Title: Re: Melodeon Makers Course July 2011, London
Post by: brianread on March 02, 2011, 09:09:34 AM
I've been told to call back in an hour.
Title: Re: Melodeon Makers Course July 2011, London
Post by: Fidjit on March 02, 2011, 09:28:40 AM
Here are some photo's of the course when held in Norway.

http://www.facebook.com/find-friends/?code=838800209#!/album.php?fbid=10150158417477674&id=723297673&aid=361742

Enjoy.

Cheers Chas

Ah! didn't work. try again.

I see that that all the link is there but facebook wont let you in. Sorry about that.

For those of you that can get into Facebook. Look up Knut Utler then look at his photo's
Title: Re: Melodeon Makers Course July 2011, London
Post by: brianread on March 02, 2011, 10:07:44 AM
ok, successfully registered
Title: Re: Melodeon Makers Course July 2011, London
Post by: Dunny on March 02, 2011, 10:11:06 AM
And me  ;D Thanks to you Brian!
Title: Re: Melodeon Makers Course July 2011, London
Post by: Lester on March 02, 2011, 11:26:56 AM
And me   ;D
Title: Re: Melodeon Makers Course July 2011, London
Post by: brianread on March 02, 2011, 12:27:42 PM
any idea how many others they have?

I see that Katie Howson has emailed it out on her list, so that should pull in a few more.
Title: Re: Melodeon Makers Course July 2011, London
Post by: BFG on March 02, 2011, 12:44:57 PM
I'm really wanting to go - just have to hope I can get it cleared by the powers that be in time to get it booked before the course fills up.

Rob
Title: Re: Melodeon Makers Course July 2011, London
Post by: David J on March 02, 2011, 01:23:03 PM
I'm one who has been 'pulled in'. Can't wait! ;D
Title: Re: Melodeon Makers Course July 2011, London
Post by: Bob Ellis on March 02, 2011, 02:54:22 PM
When I booked a place a few minutes ago, there were only two places left, so get in quickly if you want one!
Title: Re: Melodeon Makers Course July 2011, London
Post by: brianread on March 02, 2011, 03:14:15 PM
Hey, Bob glad to see you up for it - perhaps we can share travelling when we get closer to the time?

I was planning on going on the train  - would you be driving?
Title: Re: Melodeon Makers Course July 2011, London
Post by: BFG on March 02, 2011, 03:37:11 PM
I was in luck for once - managed to get a place on the course!  ;D ;D ;D

I'm really looking forward to this - a real change from the day job!

Cheers,

Rob
Title: Re: Melodeon Makers Course July 2011, London
Post by: Lester on March 02, 2011, 05:10:54 PM
Hey, Bob glad to see you up for it - perhaps we can share travelling when we get closer to the time?

I was planning on going on the train  - would you be driving?

Kind of guess that if it is the same as he one row course that you will need a bunch of tools so not sure how train travel would work.
Title: Re: Melodeon Makers Course July 2011, London
Post by: brianread on March 02, 2011, 06:22:50 PM
Hey, Bob glad to see you up for it - perhaps we can share travelling when we get closer to the time?

I was planning on going on the train  - would you be driving?

Kind of guess that if it is the same as he one row course that you will need a bunch of tools so not sure how train travel would work.

Can you give us an indication?
Title: Re: Melodeon Makers Course July 2011, London
Post by: Lester on March 02, 2011, 06:27:38 PM
Hey, Bob glad to see you up for it - perhaps we can share travelling when we get closer to the time?

I was planning on going on the train  - would you be driving?

Kind of guess that if it is the same as he one row course that you will need a bunch of tools so not sure how train travel would work.

Can you give us an indication?

I will talk to Jon Eastmond and get back to you.
Title: Re: Melodeon Makers Course July 2011, London
Post by: Bob Ellis on March 02, 2011, 07:12:24 PM
Brian,

Ordinarily, I would be delighted to give you a lift, but I am going down the previous Thursday, so that I can take my wife to see Phantom of the Opera (her preference, not mine!) before the course starts. We are taking our caravan to the site at Crystal Palace and will have our two Newfoundland dogs with us, so there will not be a lot of room in our car even for us!

Lester,

I am another one who would like to know what tools are required. Come to think of it, I am also worried about what skills may be required and whether I possess them or can acquire them in the next few months.
Title: Re: Melodeon Makers Course July 2011, London
Post by: Theo on March 02, 2011, 07:19:23 PM
For the one-row courses only basic hand tools had to be brought by the students,  steel rule, pencil, try square, screwdrivers, pliers, that sort of thing, plus an apron.   Nothing that couldn't easily be carried in hand luggage on a train.
Title: Re: Melodeon Makers Course July 2011, London
Post by: Bob Ellis on March 02, 2011, 07:22:40 PM
For the one-row courses only basic hand tools had to be brought by the students,  steel rule, pencil, try square, screwdrivers, pliers, that sort of thing, plus an apron.   Nothing that couldn't easily be carried in hand luggage on a train.

So, it seems that the tools might not be a problem. What about the skill level required?
Title: Re: Melodeon Makers Course July 2011, London
Post by: Theo on March 02, 2011, 07:27:27 PM
What about the skill level required?[/color]

That will improve during the week.

Title: Re: Melodeon Makers Course July 2011, London
Post by: Lester on March 02, 2011, 07:31:59 PM
For the one-row courses only basic hand tools had to be brought by the students,  steel rule, pencil, try square, screwdrivers, pliers, that sort of thing, plus an apron.   Nothing that couldn't easily be carried in hand luggage on a train.

So, it seems that the tools might not be a problem. What about the skill level required?

I entered the one row course as a untrained wood wrecker and made a beautiful instrument, as did everyone else on the course, it is a joint effort with some items production lined so if there is something outside your skill set someone els may well do that whilst you do something else. But as long as you follow Emmanuel's instructions you will be fine, I you don't, to us a Manu catchphrase that you will hear often, "you will be DEAD".

As Theo said the tools are just hand tools but maybe I am just lazy I would not like to carry my tool kit on a train ;) think it is my predilection to clamps that would make it a problem.
Title: Re: Melodeon Makers Course July 2011, London
Post by: Fidjit on March 02, 2011, 08:53:27 PM
For the one-row courses only basic hand tools had to be brought by the students,  steel rule, pencil, try square, screwdrivers, pliers, that sort of thing, plus an apron.   Nothing that couldn't easily be carried in hand luggage on a train.

Don't forget you will require LOTS of several grades of sandpaper. A nice handy sized piece of wood to wrap the sandpaper around will help too.

I seem to remember we did a lot of sanding.

I even wrote a shanty about it
We're sanding on the box. Me Boys! We're sanding on the box.
The Front. The Sides. The Back The Top.
We're sanding on the box.

Cheers  :|glug

Title: Re: Melodeon Makers Course July 2011, London
Post by: Lester on March 02, 2011, 10:10:46 PM
Communicated with Jon and he says:

Being a Musical Instrument Technology Dept, we have most of the tools and equipment needed, so while its fine for people to bring their own small tool box of favourite things, it really isn’t necessary. Plastic clamps is the only thing we might be short of. Your own apron, or clothes you don’t mind getting messy is really the only requirement. The most important next step is to get people to confirm their button/reed configuration. I will send round Emmanuel’s suggestion as soon as I have a contact list. 
Title: Re: Melodeon Makers Course July 2011, London
Post by: Bob Ellis on March 03, 2011, 10:07:45 AM
Communicated with Jon and he says:
Being a Musical Instrument Technology Dept, we have most of the tools and equipment needed, so while its fine for people to bring their own small tool box of favourite things, it really isn’t necessary. Plastic clamps is the only thing we might be short of. Your own apron, or clothes you don’t mind getting messy is really the only requirement. The most important next step is to get people to confirm their button/reed configuration. I will send round Emmanuel’s suggestion as soon as I have a contact list.

Thanks for soliciting that information from John, which is very useful. His comment about asking us for our preferred button/reed configurations is reassuring because I shall want to employ a modified version of the configuration I devised for my three-row Castagnaris. However, I am curious about the 14 button arrangement for the basses on Manu's 2.5 row boxes. Since all the configurations I have seen have had a bass fundamental alongside the relevant bass chord that would suggest either 12 or 16 basses. How does this 14 bass set-up work?
Title: Re: Melodeon Makers Course July 2011, London
Post by: Lester on March 03, 2011, 10:26:34 AM
His comment about asking us for our preferred button/reed configurations is reassuring because I shall want to employ a modified version of the configuration I devised for my three-row Castagnaris. However, I am curious about the 14 button arrangement for the basses on Manu's 2.5 row boxes. Since all the configurations I have seen have had a bass fundamental alongside the relevant bass chord that would suggest either 12 or 16 basses. How does this 14 bass set-up work?[/color]

I have attached the pdf that Jon has sent me. It shows how the 14 button layout is implemented and Emmanuel's "normal" layout for French stuff

Caveat is that I am not sure where we are at with Emmanuel on this
Title: Re: Melodeon Makers Course July 2011, London
Post by: Bob Ellis on March 03, 2011, 11:52:16 AM
Thanks, Lester. The chart is really interesting and useful (although I note your caveat).

At the melody end, my own preference is for a fourth button key note so that I can have a full octave in G and D below the key note. This has implications for the layout of the accidentals and reversals on the third row, which I would do differently. For instance, with only six buttons on the third row, I am not sure that I would want D# (E flat) in both directions.

However, the bass configuration is the thing that is giving me most food for thought. The eight buttons that equate with the basses on a standard two-row D/G box are uncontentious, although I assume that the E is in fact an E minor and my preference would be for a B minor rather than a B major chord on a box where you cannot take the thirds out of the basses. My Castagnaris have the same configuration as Manu's chart for the four bass buttons at the top except that the B flat/F buttons are on the inside row on my boxes and the D#/F# buttons are on the outer row. This seems more logical to me because the F is on the same row as C (useful when playing in C) and the F# (which presumably is F#m) is next to the D/A, which is handy when playing in D. I wonder why Manu prefers them the other way round.

I don't understand the purpose of having those four fundamentals (E/C# and A/G#) on the bottom two bass buttons without having any corresponding chords, although this is probably due to limitations in my knowledge of musical theory or in the way I play the basses. Neither do I understand the need for extra E and A bass fundamentals on the push when we already have them elsewhere on the pull.

If anyone can provide some clarification of Manu's thinking behind any of the points I have raised, it will help me (and perhaps others) to determine my/our preferred layout(s) before John asks us for them.
Title: Re: Melodeon Makers Course July 2011, London
Post by: Bob Ellis on March 03, 2011, 02:52:39 PM
In preparation for the melodeon makers' course, I have been analysing the frequency with which I use the notes under each of the 33 buttons on the melody end of my three-row boxes (D/G plus a row of accidentals and reversals). The reason for doing this is to help me confirm or modify the layout that I think I want on the melodeon I shall build on the course. While far from scientific, the results are interesting. Since they are based on an analysis of how I play 257 tunes in my repertoire, others undertaking the same analysis might come up with very different results.

Firstly, I have discovered that I never use the top two buttons on the D row (F#/C# and A/E), the top two on the G row (G/E and B/F#), the top two on the accidental row (high E flat/D and high E/F) or the bottom button on the accidental row (low B flat/G#). I use all of the notes under the other ten buttons on the D row, the other nine buttons on the G row and the other seven buttons on the accidental row to a greater or lesser extent. Since there are ten buttons on the D row and nine on the G row of the melodeons we will build on the course, it looks as though I have sorted out the notes for those two rows.

Looking at the seven remaining buttons on the accidentals and reversals row, the one I use most frequently is the C/D reversal button: I use the D reversal in 61 of the 257 tunes and the C reversal in 22 tunes. Next in order of frequency comes the higher of the two E reversal/F natural buttons, with the E natural used in 13 tunes and the F natural in 12, closely followed by the B flat/G# button with 17 instances where I use B flat and five where I use G#. Then come the C# reversal/high E flat button with ten instances of E flat and six of C# reversal and the low E reversal/F natural button with nine E reversals and five F naturals. The two I use least frequently are the low E flat/D reversal button, with each note used in three tunes, and the high B flat/G# button, with three instances of G# and one of B flat. Since there are only six buttons on the inside row of the boxes we shall build, I think I shall dispense with the high B flat/G# button, which will mean that there will be four tunes out of the 257 (Jump at the Sun in G minor, Rule Britannia and Da Slockit Light in D and Bluebell Polka in G/D), that I shall not be able to play on the box I build or I shall have to adapt the way I play them.
Title: Re: Melodeon Makers Course July 2011, London
Post by: brianread on March 03, 2011, 03:05:13 PM
Brian,

Ordinarily, I would be delighted to give you a lift, but I am going down the previous Thursday, so that I can take my wife to see Phantom of the Opera (her preference, not mine!) before the course starts. We are taking our caravan to the site at Crystal Palace and will have our two Newfoundland dogs with us, so there will not be a lot of room in our car even for us!


Bob, no problem, I need to leave my car here for my wife (and aged P's), however it looks like carrying the tools will not be a problem on the train.  I once carried a complete paraglider and equipment on the train all the way to Gatwick! Some sympathy with POTO  - we had a long term aim to see that show, and never managed it!

Look forward to seeing you there.
Title: Re: Melodeon Makers Course July 2011, London
Post by: Owen Woods on March 04, 2011, 02:24:06 AM
I don't understand the purpose of having those four fundamentals (E/C# and A/G#) on the bottom two bass buttons without having any corresponding chords, although this is probably due to limitations in my knowledge of musical theory or in the way I play the basses. Neither do I understand the need for extra E and A bass fundamentals on the push when we already have them elsewhere on the pull.

If anyone can provide some clarification of Manu's thinking behind any of the points I have raised, it will help me (and perhaps others) to determine my/our preferred layout(s) before John asks us for them.

One of the things that I've found when designing my own layout is that everybody else is wrong :P It's quite an infididual thing and depends so much on what you play and how.


Firstly, I have discovered that I never use the top two buttons on the D row (F#/C# and A/E), the top two on the G row (G/E and B/F#), the top two on the accidental row (high E flat/D and high E/F) or the bottom button on the accidental row (low B flat/G#). I use all of the notes under the other ten buttons on the D row, the other nine buttons on the G row and the other seven buttons on the accidental row to a greater or lesser extent. Since there are ten buttons on the D row and nine on the G row of the melodeons we will build on the course, it looks as though I have sorted out the notes for those two rows.


I thought the same thing and am currently thinking of getting one tuned as a stab style high-ish accidental on my being-repaired box. Unfortunately tonight I came across two tunes that I play regularly that use the high F#C#, which I don't want to lose. So I might see whether it would be possible to do it on the G/E instead, but I think that I'll have to do the same and go through the whole of say my ceilidh band music and work out how many tunes I'd need it for.
Title: Re: Melodeon Makers Course July 2011, London
Post by: brianread on March 04, 2011, 12:45:44 PM
His comment about asking us for our preferred button/reed configurations is reassuring because I shall want to employ a modified version of the configuration I devised for my three-row Castagnaris. However, I am curious about the 14 button arrangement for the basses on Manu's 2.5 row boxes. Since all the configurations I have seen have had a bass fundamental alongside the relevant bass chord that would suggest either 12 or 16 basses. How does this 14 bass set-up work?[/color]

I have attached the pdf that Jon has sent me. It shows how the 14 button layout is implemented and Emmanuel's "normal" layout for French stuff

Caveat is that I am not sure where we are at with Emmanuel on this

Do we have a size for the box?  Is it larger than a pokerwork? I'm thinking about a bag/case for it. 
I'd like to look at some pictures, but can't find a website for Emmanuel. 
Also will it have a 3rd's removing coupler? 
All answers please on a dustbin lid, left out side No 5 Railway Cuttings East Cheam.  (:)
Title: Re: Melodeon Makers Course July 2011, London
Post by: Bob Ellis on March 04, 2011, 03:34:04 PM
Do we have a size for the box?  Is it larger than a pokerwork? I'm thinking about a bag/case for it. 
I'd like to look at some pictures, but can't find a website for Emmanuel. 

Good question. It would be very useful to know the weight and dimensions of the box. Perhaps we could then prevail upon Theo and/or Rees to bring along a few cases of a suitable size to sell to those of us that want them. As for the pictures, there is one near the start of this thread of Fidgit playing the box he built on a similar course in Belgium and there is one of Manu with a table full of newly-minted boxes in the course information pdf in Lester's posting on this thread on 1 March.  

Also will it have a 3rd's removing coupler? 

Neither of the photographs mentioned above show any evidence of a coupler to remove the thirds.
Title: Re: Melodeon Makers Course July 2011, London
Post by: brianread on March 04, 2011, 03:46:06 PM
I seem to remember we did a lot of sanding.

I even wrote a shanty about it
We're sanding on the box. Me Boys! We're sanding on the box.
The Front. The Sides. The Back The Top.
We're sanding on the box.

Cheers  :|glug

I think we should be told which tune you used for this... (:)
Title: Re: Melodeon Makers Course July 2011, London
Post by: brianread on March 04, 2011, 03:48:43 PM
As for the pictures, there is one near the start of this thread of Fidgit playing the box he built on a similar course in Belgium and there is one of Manu with a table full of newly-minted boxes in the course information pdf in Lester's posting on this thread on 1 March. [/color]

An excellent picture, I wanted one to show my family etc.

Quote
Neither of the photographs mentioned above show any evidence of a coupler to remove the thirds.

True, but with 14 Basses I guess you can have anything you want anyway!!  I need to do some serious thinking abut this - glad we've got 4 months to do it!
Title: Re: Melodeon Makers Course July 2011, London
Post by: Fidjit on March 04, 2011, 03:53:07 PM
No coupler for removal of thirds.

And in Belgium a bag was include.

I suggest you ask John more directly what you are getting for you money.  :|glug

And straps too.
Title: Re: Melodeon Makers Course July 2011, London
Post by: jon_1 on March 05, 2011, 05:51:49 PM


  I need to do some serious thinking abut this - glad we've got 4 months to do it!
[/quote]

Emmanuel needs to place the reed order ASAP, you've got about 4 days, not 4 months!
Title: Re: Melodeon Makers Course July 2011, London
Post by: brianread on March 05, 2011, 05:56:47 PM


  I need to do some serious thinking abut this - glad we've got 4 months to do it!

Emmanuel needs to place the reed order ASAP, you've got about 4 days, not 4 months!
[/quote]

aha, hi Jon (welcome), hadn't understood that at all.  Please give us a "latest" date and I'll schedule some serious thinking time!
Title: Re: Melodeon Makers Course July 2011, London
Post by: Bob Ellis on March 05, 2011, 10:19:10 PM
Emmanuel needs to place the reed order ASAP, you've got about 4 days, not 4 months!

In that case, I (and probably other course members) could really do with an explanation within the next day or two of Emmanuel's reasoning for having 14 basses and for choosing the ones that he suggests. I don't think melodeons with 14 basses are very common, at least in this country. I am certain that I have never come across one before.
Title: Re: Melodeon Makers Course July 2011, London
Post by: Lester on March 06, 2011, 08:24:43 AM
Emmanuel needs to place the reed order ASAP, you've got about 4 days, not 4 months!

In that case, I (and probably other course members) could really do with an explanation within the next day or two of Emmanuel's reasoning for having 14 basses and for choosing the ones that he suggests. I don't think melodeons with 14 basses are very common, at least in this country. I am certain that I have never come across one before.

Little bit more on the basses, the chords have only first and fifth reeds so no major/minor designation needed.

Re 14 buttons, (my view on it, not anyone else's) seems that it gives you a fully chromatic single octave of bass notes. This may well drive the selection of Bb and D# on the chinmost buttons, but there again it is the same as the Castagnari factory layout (http://forum.melodeon.net/files/site/DG21plus5castagnari.gif).

Hope this helps but expect Jon will contact Manu.
Title: Re: Melodeon Makers Course July 2011, London
Post by: Lester on March 06, 2011, 10:32:29 AM
My thought so far, interested in comments, click on the layout for a bigger version

(https://docs.google.com/drawings/pub?id=1aqVa2Z9sX56o5znfA_KWuixMMFtKnE42G9LhAiI2B2E&w=960&h=720) (https://docs.google.com/drawings/pub?id=1aqVa2Z9sX56o5znfA_KWuixMMFtKnE42G9LhAiI2B2E&w=960&h=720)
Title: Re: Melodeon Makers Course July 2011, London
Post by: Lester on March 06, 2011, 11:14:23 AM
I have collected some images of the recent course in Norway and they can be seen HERE (https://picasaweb.google.com/lester.bailey/MelodeonMakers#)
Title: Re: Melodeon Makers Course July 2011, London
Post by: Bob Ellis on March 06, 2011, 12:43:08 PM
Hi Lester - your layout looks interesting. The G/A reversals seem a good idea, but doesn't that make the A fundamental on the bottom button of the outside row redundant? Might it be better to replace it with, say, an A#?

Your comment that the layout you posted from one of Emmanuel's earlier courses is the same as the Castagnari factory layout (to which you posted a link) is not entirely accurate. Emmanuel's layout put the B flat/F buttons on the outer row and the E flat/F# buttons on the inner row, whereas the Castagnari factory layout (which I have on two of my boxes) has the B flat/F buttons on the inner row and the E flat/F# buttons on the outer row, which seems more logical to me. Perhaps there was an accidental transposition on Emmanuel's diagram.

I see your point about C# and G# on those extra bass buttons providing a chromatic set of fundamentals, but the only place I could see them being used is in a bass run because they do not fit with any of the adjacent chords. Now, if there were row to put in a couple more buttons and the associated reeds so that we could have the chords that go with those fundamentals...
Title: Re: Melodeon Makers Course July 2011, London
Post by: Lester on March 06, 2011, 03:07:15 PM
Hi Lester - your layout looks interesting. The G/A reversals seem a good idea, but doesn't that make the A fundamental on the bottom button of the outside row redundant? Might it be better to replace it with, say, an A#?

Good spot, I have actually changed both the kneemost bass buttons to add back the Bb and Eb that I had lost thus maintaining all 12 notes in the bass. New image attached seems to be broken but if you click on it it works.

(https://docs.google.com/drawings/edit?id=1aqVa2Z9sX56o5znfA_KWuixMMFtKnE42G9LhAiI2B2E&hl=en_GB) (https://docs.google.com/drawings/edit?id=1aqVa2Z9sX56o5znfA_KWuixMMFtKnE42G9LhAiI2B2E&hl=en_GB)

Quote

Your comment that the layout you posted from one of Emmanuel's earlier courses is the same as the Castagnari factory layout (to which you posted a link) is not entirely accurate. Emmanuel's layout put the B flat/F buttons on the outer row and the E flat/F# buttons on the inner row, whereas the Castagnari factory layout (which I have on two of my boxes) has the B flat/F buttons on the inner row and the E flat/F# buttons on the outer row, which seems more logical to me. Perhaps there was an accidental transposition on Emmanuel's diagram.


Sorry, I got mess up comparing Manu's portrait picture with the mel.net landscape one, you are of course right.
Title: Re: Melodeon Makers Course July 2011, London
Post by: Theo on March 06, 2011, 03:28:45 PM
My thought so far, interested in comments, click on the layout for a bigger version

(https://docs.google.com/drawings/pub?id=1aqVa2Z9sX56o5znfA_KWuixMMFtKnE42G9LhAiI2B2E&w=960&h=720) (https://docs.google.com/drawings/pub?id=1aqVa2Z9sX56o5znfA_KWuixMMFtKnE42G9LhAiI2B2E&w=960&h=720)

Lester, I'd be interested in your reasons for the E pull on button 1 of the G row.  Is it a repeat of the E on button 3 of the D row?  If so it seems a bit unnecessary. I would find it much more useful to have a low C.  I suppose it depends on what you play, but I have a small but significant number of tunes in G that go down to the low G, and use all the G scale from there up, hence the preference for the low C.  For the same reason I would replace the low F# on button 1 of the D row with a low G.  It would also find the conventional low A pull on the same button much more useful than the low B pull. because  most  all of the D tunes with a low B that I play,  want a B or G cord at that point so it makes more musical sense to use the B on the G row.  Another use for the low pull A is it enables you to play an A7 chord, which is often useful.
Title: Re: Melodeon Makers Course July 2011, London
Post by: brianread on March 06, 2011, 03:39:23 PM
Lester, I'd be interested in your reasons for the E pull on button 1 of the G row.  Is it a repeat of the E on button 3 of the D row?  If so it seems a bit unnecessary. I would find it much more useful to have a low C.  I suppose it depends on what you play, but I have a small but significant number of tunes in G that go down to the low G, and use all the G scale from there up, hence the preference for the low C.  For the same reason I would replace the low F# on button 1 of the D row with a low G. 

I'll probably go for both - the low C and the E on the G row - by having a 4th button start.  I find I can't do DEF#G runs easily switching rows, maybe because of using my little finger (I am upside down remember!).  And i like to play "under" ther fiddles etc, so i need a full octave below the G.  Same for the D Row.
Title: Re: Melodeon Makers Course July 2011, London
Post by: Lester on March 06, 2011, 04:13:39 PM
Lester, I'd be interested in your reasons for the E pull on button 1 of the G row.  Is it a repeat of the E on button 3 of the D row?  If so it seems a bit unnecessary. I would find it much more useful to have a low C.  I suppose it depends on what you play, but I have a small but significant number of tunes in G that go down to the low G, and use all the G scale from there up, hence the preference for the low C. 


It was just a copy of Manu's original layout which I had not considered changing. But now you mention it  ;)

Quote
For the same reason I would replace the low F# on button 1 of the D row with a low G.  It would also find the conventional low A pull on the same button much more useful than the low B pull. because  most  all of the D tunes with a low B that I play,  want a B or G cord at that point so it makes more musical sense to use the B on the G row.  Another use for the low pull A is it enables you to play an A7 chord, which is often useful.

Many thanks Theo, I seem to remember this was the layout you put on the Liliput I had at one time. Should have written it down then

Mark 111 layout (https://docs.google.com/drawings/edit?id=1aqVa2Z9sX56o5znfA_KWuixMMFtKnE42G9LhAiI2B2E&hl=en_GB)
Title: Re: Melodeon Makers Course July 2011, London
Post by: Bob Ellis on March 06, 2011, 05:02:09 PM
I have attached my current thinking about the configuration I want on my box. It is based on a fourth button start so that I can have a full octave below each key note and replicates as much as is feasible of the configuration I use on my 33-button three-row Castagnaris. I am still uncertain about what use to make of the extra bass buttons and so I am following Manu's layout for those buttons, as circulated by Lester.

If anyone thinks any part of this is inadvisable or if they have any other observations, I would be grateful to receive them.
Title: Re: Melodeon Makers Course July 2011, London
Post by: Theo on March 06, 2011, 05:13:42 PM
... or if they have any other observations, I would be grateful to receive them.[/color]

I'm pretty sure I would have no use for the low D/E on button 1 of the D row, but I would want a low F nat on pull somewhere. 
Title: Re: Melodeon Makers Course July 2011, London
Post by: Bob Ellis on March 06, 2011, 05:58:55 PM
I'm pretty sure I would have no use for the low D/E on button 1 of the D row, but I would want a low F nat on pull somewhere. 

Thanks for the observations, Theo. The idea of the low D/E button is to give a full octave of D below the key note. However, I shall check through my repertoire to see how often I actually use it.

As you probably noticed, there are two pulled F naturals on the third row. I use both quite often, but I have not found a need for a lower one. Nevertheless, I shall mull it over.
Title: Re: Melodeon Makers Course July 2011, London
Post by: Theo on March 06, 2011, 06:14:32 PM
Bob,  my logic for going down to low G is that quit a number of tines go down there because it's the lowest not on a fiddle and British (and other European) traditional tunes have been heavily influenced by the fiddle for a couple of centuries. I don't think there has been a similar evolutionary pressure to take tunes down below that.
Title: Re: Melodeon Makers Course July 2011, London
Post by: Martin J on March 06, 2011, 10:18:26 PM
I'm following with interest and would have loved to have enrolled for the course.  Anyway, may I add a comment for consideration.  My Dony came with the factory layout Lester linked to but after only a few days it became apparent that it was difficult to play in practice.  I looked at straddella, set out in the order of descending flats, and changed the four new basses to the opposite end of the row.  I can now reach everything easily and it sits logically in my head.  Fourth button start allows easy playing of C major with correct chords easily reached, no stretch, no jumps.  In fact it's the same for almost everything I play.

Hope this helps.
Title: Re: Melodeon Makers Course July 2011, London
Post by: Bob Ellis on March 07, 2011, 09:51:58 AM
Bob,  my logic for going down to low G is that quite a number of tunes go down there because it's the lowest note on a fiddle and British (and other European) traditional tunes have been heavily influenced by the fiddle for a couple of centuries. I don't think there has been a similar evolutionary pressure to take tunes down below that.

I see your point, Theo, but I do sometimes use that low D/E button to play a repeat of a tune in D in the lower octave. However, your suggestion set me thinking that I rarely use the high D/B button on the D row and both notes are repeated and easily accessible on the G row. On the other hand a high B flat/G# button is something that I do use, so I have put that in as an accidental button at the top of the D row (revised configuration attached). Thanks very much for your input: it helped solve the problem of how to include those accidentals.
Title: Re: Melodeon Makers Course July 2011, London
Post by: BFG on March 08, 2011, 01:30:54 PM
Hi All.

I've been following the discussion on what/what not to have with avid interest and am now trying to figure out what to put on my box as a relative newby. :-\

This has led me to a question filling in the "fingerboard wanted" on Emmanuel's diagram.

The melodeon we will be making definitely has 10 buttons on the D row and 9 on the G row? So I ignore the extra two buttons at the top of the treble end on Emmanuel's "fingerboard wanted" diagram?

Sorry if that seems really dumb, I just don't want to do it wrong and confuse the whole process. :|bl

Thanks,

Rob
Title: Re: Melodeon Makers Course July 2011, London
Post by: brianread on March 08, 2011, 01:36:46 PM
I asked the same question on the MM yahoo group.

Lester counted the buttons on the melodeons in the Norweigan picture, and thinks it is 10+9+6, it would ge good to have definate confirmation of that from Jon?

Title: Re: Melodeon Makers Course July 2011, London
Post by: Bob Ellis on March 08, 2011, 03:25:56 PM
I am also working on the assumption that the configuration is 10+9+6. However, it would be good to have confirmation of that from Manu via Jon.
Title: Re: Melodeon Makers Course July 2011, London
Post by: Pete on March 10, 2011, 08:54:29 AM
Am I the only one to have been told that after paying £1400 that I've got to pay another £550 to do this course?  I would be Interested to know .
Title: Re: Melodeon Makers Course July 2011, London
Post by: Lester on March 10, 2011, 09:06:19 AM
Am I the only one to have been told that after paying £1400 that I've got to pay another £550 to do this course?  I would be interested to know.

You are not the only one and I believe Jon told you the reason in the email that went to us all. I put it down to cock up rather than conspiracy. So far I am aware of 3 of the attendees asking for refunds, which I am told will be freely given, (this includes me) but as the need is to lose 5 attendees this is probably not a problem. 
Title: Re: Melodeon Makers Course July 2011, London
Post by: BFG on March 10, 2011, 09:19:39 AM
I've unfortunately had to drop out as well - can't stretch to the extra 550.

Shame, but hopefully the course will be a success and they'll run it again in the near future.

To all that's still going - have fun!

Cheers,

Rob
Title: Re: Melodeon Makers Course July 2011, London
Post by: brianread on March 10, 2011, 09:30:44 AM
I also have dropped out.  Regrettably.
Title: Re: Melodeon Makers Course July 2011, London
Post by: Bob Ellis on March 10, 2011, 10:07:42 AM
We have all had the same e-mail. I phoned Jon and he explained in detail how the mistake occurred - quite understandable. While the extra £550 is going to be hard to find, I am still committed to going. To be honest, I didn't understand how they could do it for the original price quoted, when you think that each course member is guaranteed to "leave with a professional standard instrument, fully tuned and ready to play". The value of that alone is probably around £1,400 and then there is the cost of hiring the services of Manu, Theo and Rees plus their travelling expenses and accommodation and the cost of using the college facilities. So I think it is still good value at £1,950, although, of course, I regret that some who had set their hearts on going will not now be able to afford to do so.

I believe the state of play last night was that six people had confirmed their places, four had withdrawn, five were still making up their minds and there were a few others who had expressed interest and who would be approached if there were any places left to fill. I am keeping my fingers crossed that four more people will confirm places so that the course can run.
Title: Re: Melodeon Makers Course July 2011, London
Post by: brianread on March 10, 2011, 10:09:13 AM
We have all had the same e-mail. I phoned Jon and he explained in detail how the mistake occurred - quite understandable. While the extra £550 is going to be hard to find, I am still committed to going. To be honest, I didn't understand how they could do it for the original price quoted, when you think that each course member is guaranteed to "leave with a professional standard instrument, fully tuned and ready to play". The value of that alone is probably around £1,400 and then there is the cost of hiring the services of Manu, Theo and Rees plus their travelling expenses and accommodation and the cost of using the college facilities. So I think it is still good value at £1,950, although, of course, I regret that some who had set their hearts on going will not now be able to afford to do so.

I believe the state of play last night was that six people had confirmed their places, four had withdrawn, five were still making up their minds and there were a few others who had expressed interest and who would be approached if there were any places left to fill. I am keeping my fingers crossed that four more people will confirm places so that the course can run.

Good luck Bob, I hope it happens for you.
Title: Re: Melodeon Makers Course July 2011, London
Post by: Alison Scott on March 10, 2011, 05:21:22 PM
We have all had the same e-mail. I phoned Jon and he explained in detail how the mistake occurred - quite understandable. While the extra £550 is going to be hard to find, I am still committed to going. To be honest, I didn't understand how they could do it for the original price quoted, when you think that each course member is guaranteed to "leave with a professional standard instrument, fully tuned and ready to play".

The timing of this course would have been very difficult for work, but even so I was hugely tempted, at least in part because £1400 seemed impossibly cheap for what was on offer. Ah well. Perhaps another time.
Title: Re: Melodeon Makers Course July 2011, London
Post by: Martin J on March 11, 2011, 12:19:00 PM
I was very tempted by this course and am so glad I didn't subscribe.  Whatever reason has been given an offer had been made, acceptance has taken place and consideration has passed.  I am appalled that someone is now asking for an increase even if it is a genuine error.  The error is not on the part of the delegates.

Unlike other members posts, I don't feel it was under priced.  The majority of the cost of making a box is in the labour.  I suspect the majority costs for this project are fees and profits.  There is nothing wrong with either of these, it is after all a business project. The final cost to delegates is no doubt comparable with the ex factory cost of a box made on the continent to which one must add vat, carriage and dealer margins, again all of which are fair and legitimate.  The joy of the course is to have made it yourself.  If you cost in your own time then there are little or no savings.  If you choose to add the hotel and food costs then it would be cheaper to buy outright.

IMHO the people or organisation making the error should have kept quiet, bit on the bullet and allowed the course to run as advertised.
Title: Re: Melodeon Makers Course July 2011, London
Post by: Bob Ellis on March 11, 2011, 12:51:31 PM
IMHO the people or organisation making the error should have kept quiet, bit on the bullet and allowed the course to run as advertised.

They couldn't have done what you suggest because it would have meant one private individual being out of pocket personally by around £2,500. There was a breakdown in communication. The tutor had stated that he could not cope with more than ten course members; the college had done its costings on fifteen. Since the college has not organised the course and its facilities are merely being hired, there is no reason to expect that they would be prepared to hire out those facilities at a loss. The only way the course could have run at the original cost would have been if the tutor had been prepared to run it at a loss or if the middle man who is trying to organise the course had been prepared to foot the bill. Both of these options would be unfair and impractical. This left the options of offering it at the higher cost, which I still believe to be reasonable, or cancelling the whole thing. Since full refunds are being given to those who don't want to or can't find the exta money, the best is being made of an unfortunate situation. If sufficient people feel that the revised course fee is reasonable, the course will run; if not, it won't.

These comments are based on a discussion I had with the course organiser a couple of days ago.
Title: Re: Melodeon Makers Course July 2011, London
Post by: Martin J on March 11, 2011, 01:11:10 PM
Thanks for the full explanation Bob and I do totally take all the points.   I'm sort of coming in from the side so to speak and thinking in business terms.  I'll butt out but I still think it is wrong and unfair on you guys who have subscribed in good faith.
Title: Re: Melodeon Makers Course July 2011, London
Post by: Fidjit on March 11, 2011, 01:56:02 PM
It's only money. Enjoy the experience. The buzz you will get from making your own box will overcome the expense involved.. 
Title: Re: Melodeon Makers Course July 2011, London
Post by: Graham Spencer on March 11, 2011, 03:18:50 PM
IMHO the people or organisation making the error should have kept quiet, bit on the bullet and allowed the course to run as advertised.
I have to say I'm with you on this one; it's unfair practice to advertise a course at a set price, have people enrol in good faith on that basis, then hoik up the price by a not insubstantial amount.  In another life I make carved marionettes; if I quote a customer a price and then something I hadn't bargained for crops up and increases my costs, I wouldn't dream of trying to pass that cost on to my customer. It's not his/her fault that my making costs have risen and they've placed their order in good faith accepting my quotation; and I suspect they'd have a good case in law if I did try to charge them more having agreed what is in effect a legally binding contract. Whoever's the fault, it's not the course members', and they shouldn't be expected to fork out for somebody else's cock-up. The buck stops with whoever is actually in charge of running the course, and a financial loss is one of the risks you take.
Title: Re: Melodeon Makers Course July 2011, London
Post by: Bob Ellis on March 13, 2011, 08:19:18 PM
Things have gone very quiet in the last few days. Has anyone heard anything recently about the likelihood of this course running?
Title: Re: Melodeon Makers Course July 2011, London
Post by: Morrisbox on March 14, 2011, 12:50:54 PM
Quote
Things have gone very quiet in the last few days. Has anyone heard anything recently about the likelihood of this course running?

Not a thing, like you I'm waiting anxiously!

Trevor
Title: Re: Melodeon Makers Course July 2011, London
Post by: Bob Ellis on March 14, 2011, 03:21:23 PM
I have just spoken to the Admissions Department at South Thames College. Apparently seven people have indicated a willingness to take part in the melodeon making course at the increased price of £1,950. The course needs another three members to run. If they do not come forward very soon, the course will be cancelled; so, if there are any people out there who are interested but have not enrolled yet, they need to do so a.s.a.p. or there will not be a course.
Title: Re: Melodeon Makers Course July 2011, London
Post by: brianread on March 15, 2011, 11:36:16 AM
I spoke to the "refund" department, in the hope of getting my credit card refunded beofre it goes through the direct debit, and (predictably?) they knew nothing about refunds, and have promised to get back to me - anyone else got their money back yet?
Title: Re: Melodeon Makers Course July 2011, London
Post by: BFG on March 15, 2011, 12:16:41 PM
Refund requested last Wednesday - I was going to give them until this Wednesday and then chase. Same situation - I'd rather the refund went through before I had to pay the credit card bill.

Rob
Title: Re: Melodeon Makers Course July 2011, London
Post by: David J on March 16, 2011, 02:23:17 PM
I have just spoken to Jon and it appears the course has now been cancelled. The college was inflexible regarding their fee, hence the steep increase. He assured me that all course fees will be refunded by Friday.
Title: Re: Melodeon Makers Course July 2011, London
Post by: brianread on March 16, 2011, 02:57:54 PM
I had a phone call from them yesterday confirming that my money will be refunded on Friday.

Shame that it has failed to happen.

mmm - thinking if it could be arranged somewhere else.  I presume I can assume that there is a need? 

I'll need to make some phone calls...

I'll report on any progress tomorrow.
Title: Re: Melodeon Makers Course July 2011, London
Post by: Steve_freereeder on March 16, 2011, 03:09:59 PM
I have just spoken to Jon and it appears the course has now been cancelled.  He assured me that all course fees will be refunded by Friday.
This is so unfortunate.

Quote
The college was inflexible regarding their fee, hence the steep increase.
This refusal to be flexible and to negotiate makes me sad. In the past I've had similar problems with the university here in Sheffield, resulting in the cancellation of an entire course.

If the college had agreed to go ahead, albeit with a reduced fee, they would have gained some financial benefit, the course would have run and everyone would have been happy. But now the course has been cancelled, the college will receive nothing in fees but will have still have administration costs to absorb from their finances elsewhere. So short-sighted and inflexible. And everyone is disgruntled and unhappy.  :(
Title: Re: Melodeon Makers Course July 2011, London
Post by: Bob Ellis on March 16, 2011, 04:48:36 PM
mmm - thinking if it could be arranged somewhere else.  I presume I can assume that there is a need? 
I'll need to make some phone calls...
I'll report on any progress tomorrow.

I'm very disappointed that the course has been cancelled, especially if it was due to avarice on the part of the college. Its cancellation also leaves me with two tickets for Phantom of the Opera (a treat for my wife while we would have been in London) that we shall probably not be able to use and that we certainly won't be able to return for a refund.  :'(

I agree with you, Brian, that there is probably sufficient demand to be able to run the course at a different venue and I would certainly be willing to sign up for that. You probably know more about suitable venues than I do, but Newcastle University crossed my mind. It runs a degree in folk music which (I think) includes instrument-making and it links up with the Sage Theatre over a number of folk events, so it might be kindly disposed to running a melodeon-making course and ought to have the facilities to accommodate one.
Title: Re: Melodeon Makers Course July 2011, London
Post by: brianread on March 16, 2011, 04:58:12 PM
I agree with you, Brian, that there is probably sufficient demand to be able to run the course at a different venue and I would certainly be willing to sign up for that. You probably know more about suitable venues than I do, but Newcastle University crossed my mind. It runs a degree in folk music which (I think) includes instrument-making and it links up with the Sage Theatre over a number of folk events, so it might be kindly disposed to running a melodeon-making course and ought to have the facilities to accommodate one.[/color]

If someone has a link to the relevent "bit" of Newcastle Uni, then i'd be happy to pursue that, however, bearing in mind the points above about Sheffield Uni, I suspect we might well be in for more of the same.

I have in mind a far less "obvious" venue, to which I have a family connection, but I'll say no more until I have investigated it. By pure co-incidence it is also in the NE!
Title: Re: Melodeon Makers Course July 2011, London
Post by: Dunny on March 16, 2011, 06:22:33 PM
I'm really disappointed that it's been cancelled - it took me ages to convince the boss wife that it was a 'good thing' esp with the price increase.

I'd be up for attending should it be re-arranged and I'll also investigate venues in my area (South Midlands)
Title: Re: Melodeon Makers Course July 2011, London
Post by: Bill S on March 17, 2011, 07:31:36 AM
I am also very disappointed that this has been cancelled & would be interested if rearranged
Bill
Title: Re: Melodeon Makers Course July 2011, London
Post by: Steve_freereeder on March 17, 2011, 07:46:48 AM
Has anyone thought of contacting Katie Howson at EATMT to see if they could host the course?
EATMT has hosted the previous three one-row making courses in Stowmarket.
EATMT Melodeon Making Courses (http://www.eatmt.org.uk/Melodeon%20Makers.htm)


Title: Re: Melodeon Makers Course July 2011, London
Post by: brianread on March 17, 2011, 09:57:10 AM
I've just spoken to Jon on the phone, and he has asked me to post on here that all is not entirely lost, and we could  be hearing some better news from him within a day or two. (:) (:) (:) (:)
Title: Re: Melodeon Makers Course July 2011, London
Post by: Bob Ellis on March 17, 2011, 10:35:38 AM
Great news, Brian. I shall be keeping my fingers firmly crossed (although perhaps I would be able to play better if I uncrossed them!)   ::)
Title: Re: Melodeon Makers Course July 2011, London
Post by: Bob Ellis on March 18, 2011, 02:51:30 PM
Refund cheque received from South Thames College today, as promised!

It's good to hear that the course is back on at a different venue and at a more affordable price (£1,650). I've sent my e-mail to Jon to book a place and I am hoping fervently that all will run smoothly now.
Title: Re: Melodeon Makers Course July 2011, London
Post by: brianread on March 18, 2011, 03:18:56 PM
Refund cheque received from South Thames College today, as promised!

It's good to hear that the course is back on at a different venue and at a more affordable price (£1,650). I've sent my e-mail to Jon to book a place and I am hoping fervently that all will run smoothly now.

yes, got mine as well. and have applied for a place on the "new" course.

Bob - your wife might get to see Phantom after all!
Title: Re: Melodeon Makers Course July 2011, London
Post by: Dunny on March 18, 2011, 04:23:51 PM
Cheque arrived this morning, and I've emailed Jon to book my place  (:)
Title: Re: Melodeon Makers Course July 2011, London
Post by: Bob Ellis on March 19, 2011, 03:02:19 PM
It seems from the latest e-mail from Jon Eastmond that the ten people needed for the course to run have now signed up for it, so the course appears to be back on and the working out of our preferred button configurations can take centre stage once more.

I asked this question before, but it probably got sidelined when the viability of the course was in doubt. Does anyone know on the bass end of Emmanuel's 'fingerboard proposition', which Jon has e-mailed to those participating in the course, why he has chosen E/C# and A/G# fundamentals (with no corresponding chords) for the extra pair of buttons below the G/D and C/C bass buttons? What is the rationale behind this choice? How and when would one use them?

I have e-mailed Jon with these questions and requested that he pass them on to Emmanuel, but, in the meantime, I would be grateful if anyone here can shed any light on this.
Title: Re: Melodeon Makers Course July 2011, London
Post by: Lester on March 19, 2011, 03:25:33 PM
Does anyone know on the bass end of Emmanuel's 'fingerboard proposition', which Jon has e-mailed to those participating in the course, why he has chosen E/C# and A/G# fundamentals (with no corresponding chords) for the extra pair of buttons below the G/D and C/C bass buttons? What is the rationale behind this choice? How and when would one use them?

I am almost 100% certain that they are chosen to give you access to all 12 notes, A to G#, on the bass end.
Title: Re: Melodeon Makers Course July 2011, London
Post by: Bob Ellis on March 19, 2011, 03:37:30 PM
Thanks, Lester, for the reply. That certainly makes sense for the C# and G#. I suppose the E and A give you those notes in the reverse direction, but I wonder how useful they would be.

I am toying with the idea of having G#/C# at the bottom of the inside row and Bb/F at the bottom of the outside row, With the adjacent buttons being G/D, it would be easy to create G minor and D minor chords. Any thoughts on the practicality or otherwise of this?  
Title: Re: Melodeon Makers Course July 2011, London
Post by: brianread on March 19, 2011, 03:52:23 PM
I got my offer just now, hooray  (:) (:)

Toying with G/C or C/F at the moment (I've already got 3 D/G's!)
Title: Re: Melodeon Makers Course July 2011, London
Post by: Lester on March 19, 2011, 04:07:09 PM
This is my proposed layout (may have posted it before)

Title: Re: Melodeon Makers Course July 2011, London
Post by: Bob Ellis on March 20, 2011, 11:54:33 AM
Emmanuel's fingerboard chart, which Jon sent us to complete, is a little confusing. For some reason there are two extra buttons at the bottom of the chart for the melody fingerboard, which I presume we don't need, and there are two fewer than there should be for the bass fingerboard, since these are to be 14-bass boxes.
 
I have produced a Word document of the layout I shall be requesting that replicates Emmanuel's form but corrects the errors and adds a couple of explanatory statements. Anyone who finds it useful is welcome to download it and use it to fill in their own layout. Since it is a Word document, you can edit it by simply highlighting the notes you want to change and typing over them.
Title: Re: Melodeon Makers Course July 2011, London
Post by: brianread on March 20, 2011, 12:10:16 PM
Emmanuel's fingerboard chart, which Jon sent us to complete, is a little confusing. For some reason there are two extra buttons at the bottom of the chart for the melody fingerboard, which I presume we don't need, and there are two fewer than there should be for the bass fingerboard, since these are to be 14-bass boxes.
 
I have produced a Word document of the layout I shall be requesting that replicates Emmanuel's form but corrects the errors and adds a couple of explanatory statements. Anyone who finds it useful is welcome to download it and use it to fill in their own layout. Since it is a Word document, you can edit it by simply highlighting the notes you want to change and typing over them.

This does not translate well to Open Office  (actually I am using Libre Office now)  can you export it in "doc" format?
Title: Re: Melodeon Makers Course July 2011, London
Post by: Thrupenny Bit on March 20, 2011, 01:08:20 PM
Bob - many thanks.
You've posted a keyboard layout that works in Word - well played sir!
It'll be useful for those like me that aren't going on the course, but want to play with a keyboard layout.
thanks
Q
Title: Re: Melodeon Makers Course July 2011, London
Post by: Bob Ellis on March 20, 2011, 01:43:00 PM
Brian: the layout document I posted was in 'doc' format (see the file extension). Unfortunately, this is the only file type allowed as an attachment in which it would be easy to edit this document, so I can't post an alternative. I could send it to you as an 'Open Document' in a private e-mail, if that would be of any use. Send me a private e-mail if you would like me to do so.

Thrupenny Bit: I am glad you found the layout useful.
Title: Re: Melodeon Makers Course July 2011, London
Post by: brianread on March 20, 2011, 02:11:23 PM
Brian: the layout document I posted was in 'doc' format (see the file extension). Unfortunately, this is the only file type allowed as an attachment in which it would be easy to edit this document, so I can't post an alternative. I could send it to you as an 'Open Document' in a private e-mail, if that would be of any use. Send me a private e-mail if you would like me to do so.

so it was (and is) - now why did I think it was docx?
Title: Re: Melodeon Makers Course July 2011, London
Post by: Bob Ellis on March 20, 2011, 02:22:42 PM
Brian: the layout document I posted was in 'doc' format (see the file extension). Unfortunately, this is the only file type allowed as an attachment in which it would be easy to edit this document, so I can't post an alternative. I could send it to you as an 'Open Document' in a private e-mail, if that would be of any use. Send me a private e-mail if you would like me to do so.

so it was (and is) - now why did I think it was docx?

I would have said it was a senior moment, but you're not old enough - so it must have been the booze!  >:E
Title: Re: Melodeon Makers Course July 2011, London
Post by: brianread on March 20, 2011, 02:33:48 PM
Brian: the layout document I posted was in 'doc' format (see the file extension). Unfortunately, this is the only file type allowed as an attachment in which it would be easy to edit this document, so I can't post an alternative. I could send it to you as an 'Open Document' in a private e-mail, if that would be of any use. Send me a private e-mail if you would like me to do so.

so it was (and is) - now why did I think it was docx?

I would have said it was a senior moment, but you're not old enough - so it must have been the booze!  >:E

I think I actually downloaded it from "another place".
Title: Re: Melodeon Makers Course July 2011, London
Post by: Bob Ellis on March 20, 2011, 03:59:45 PM
Bien sûr, je comprends!
Title: Re: Melodeon Makers Course July 2011, London
Post by: brianread on March 20, 2011, 04:26:11 PM
Bien sûr, je comprends!

Actually we are going to Spain next week, so:

hasta pronto

 
Title: Re: Melodeon Makers Course July 2011, London
Post by: EeeJay on April 12, 2011, 01:16:40 PM
Can't recall if this links been posted... but here's some more pictures from the course run in Belgium (http://www.lagattedor.be/galeries-photos/stage-accordeon-2008/) a few years back... :|glug

Ed J
Title: Re: Melodeon Makers Course July 2011, London
Post by: Fidjit on April 12, 2011, 01:43:24 PM
Well John got his hands on the box I made in Belgium at M&M in March So he's one step ahead.

SimplePortal 2.3.5 © 2008-2012, SimplePortal