Melodeon.net Forums

Discussions => Other Free Reed Instruments => Topic started by: Atzarin on January 30, 2011, 05:52:43 PM

Title: Atzarin bandonion photos.
Post by: Atzarin on January 30, 2011, 05:52:43 PM
Back in September in the General Discussion section of this forum I posted a message about a new 3 row layout for bisonoric free reed instruments called Atzarin. The layout has been used on the Atzarin bandonion and some photos of the unfinished Atzarin prototype can now be seen on the Atzarin website. Although the work is incomplete, the photos give a very good idea of what the instrument actually looks like. Most pages with photos have a photo at the top of the page and at the botton, so make sure you scroll down if you want to see all the photos. Links to pages with videos and photos:

https://www.youtube.com/channel/UCbeEmJNTR45DXESw5dT-sPQ?spfreload=10

http://atzarin.com/eng/instruments/bandonion/atzarin_bandonion_bandoneon_reshaped.html
Title: Re: Atzarin bandonion photos.
Post by: HallelujahAl on January 30, 2011, 05:57:26 PM
Hi Sebastian - looks great, love to hear it now that you've completed the development stage?
Regards, AL
Title: Re: Atzarin bandonion photos.
Post by: Martin J on January 30, 2011, 06:47:20 PM
Hi Atzarin

I have just re read your first thread and like many others on melnet am confused as to the why of it all.  The keyboard map seems counter intuitive and confusing.  This maybe because we are not used to it and have never tried it.  However, help is at hand.  Since your first post the Roland FR18 has become available with bespoke keyboard mapping.  If you could get hold of one, or persuade an owner to use your keyboard map, maybe we can have a practical example and see the advantages.  Best of luck with your project and I hope this helps.
Title: Re: Atzarin bandonion photos.
Post by: Owen Woods on January 30, 2011, 07:52:13 PM
I personally don't think that the fingering system is that counter intuitive, it appeals to me slightly as it is a reasonably logical system, whilst being chromatic and bisonoric. I think that it is the only chromatic, bisonoric system in existence in the true sense.

The bandoneon looks great Sebastian, looking forward to sound and visuals (:)
Title: Re: Finished Atzarin bandonion prototype photos.
Post by: Atzarin on February 20, 2011, 02:54:06 PM
Some photos of the unfinished Atzarin bandonion prototype can now be seen on the Atzarin website. The photos clearly show the shape of the new button arcs and hand rail and the shape and position of the air valve lever which is to be tested on the instrument over the next few weeks.

(http://atzarin.com/eng/instruments/bandonion/images/atzarin_bandonion_stage_3_right.jpg)

http://atzarin.com/eng/instruments/instruments.html

Sound and visuals coming in the near future.

I'll be in the UK with the Atzarin bandonion prototype at the end of April, first in South London and later in Ipswich, so we could arrange to meet if you're interested in having a go on it!

Sebastian
Title: Re: Atzarin bandonion photos.
Post by: Martin J on February 20, 2011, 06:21:21 PM
The instrument has a very professional look about it and I'm sure you'll be paying as much attention to the sound as the design detail, but of course it is the unique keyboard layout that continues to fascinate.

An interesting change on your site Sebastian.  I see for the Bandoneon you set out the directions of increments.  I was slightly confused when I first looked at it so I've attached a map the same as Castagnari do with the Push on top.  I hope you don't mind.  Others may find it more understandable as well.  Depends what you are used to.  I can now understand far better.
Title: Re: Atzarin bandonion photos.
Post by: Atzarin on February 21, 2011, 09:04:18 AM
Thanks for all comments and encouragement!

An interesting change on your site Sebastian.  I see for the Bandoneon you set out the directions of increments.  I was slightly confused when I first looked at it so I've attached a map the same as Castagnari do with the Push on top.  I hope you don't mind.  Others may find it more understandable as well.  Depends what you are used to.  I can now understand far better.

Yes, I decided to leave the diagrams of diatonic keyboard layouts with push on top as well as the diagrams of traditional bandoneon layouts. However, in most diagrams of bandoneon layouts on other sites push notes are drawn on the bottom with draw notes on top, so I decided to do the same with the Atzarin layout diagrams. In fact, I wanted to change all drawings on the web site so as to maintain consistency, but I just haven't been able to find the time.

Thank you very much, No Strings Attached, for going to the trouble of producing an alternative drawing that may help more people to understand the layout better or more easily.

Hi Sebastian - looks great, love to hear it now that you've completed the development stage?
Regards, AL

The development stage is not quite completely over. There will probably be minor alterations in the action, which is why I've still not put up a clear picture of the current action. Also, I'm looking into bringing out an "accordion" tuned model with MM reeds and "warm, dry" tremolo tuning, which may appeal to people who are put off by bandonion double octave super dry tuning.

The air valve lever needs testing as well and might require some modification or alternative. However, after initial testing I'm fairly confident that it will remain as is. The instrument will be tested over the next few days by a professional bandoneonist who will be considering all aspects - the usefulness and playability of the layout and the design aspects in terms of comfort and practicality.

Sorry to all for not responding more to your comments and observations but I really am pressed for time!

Sebastian
Title: Atzarin bandonion
Post by: Atzarin on August 04, 2012, 04:59:16 PM
In January 2011 I posted some links to information about the Atzarin Bandonion. In spite of it not being possible to bring out the new prototype in the time desired, development and improvement have moved ahead. Information about this work and development towards an optimum Atzarin bandoenon is available at:

Stage 4 - Improvements in grip and stability.
http://atzarin.com/eng/instruments/bandonion/atzarin_bandonion_development_stage_4.html

Stage 5 _ Current development for optimum Atzarin Bandonion
http://atzarin.com/eng/instruments/bandonion/atzarin_bandonion_development_stage_5.html

Recent photos in the following links may be of particular interest to people who are skeptical about using the thumb to play notes and/or doubtful about the grip and control on the instrument:

Playing broadly voiced chords
http://atzarin.com/eng/instruments/bandonion/atzarin_bandonion_broad_chords.html

Atzarin bandonion comfort and playability
http://atzarin.com/eng/instruments/bandonion/atzarin_bandonion_comfort_playability.html

There are also recent photos in the following updated pages:

Atzarin bandonion overview
http://atzarin.com/eng/instruments/bandonion/atzarin_bandonion_bandoneon_reshaped.html

Atzarin bandonion hold and stability
http://atzarin.com/eng/instruments/bandonion/atzarin_bandonion_control_and_stability.html

Regards,

Sebastian Brown Apraiz
www.atzarin.com
Title: Atzarin bandonion video.
Post by: Atzarin on May 28, 2016, 12:39:01 PM
The Atzarin bandonion project had been at an impasse for about three years, but has now moved forward. Some information about the impasse and the new development can be found at:

http://atzarin.com/eng/instruments/bandonion/atzarin_bandonion_development_stage_5.html

I have now put together a video, with errors and all, to show how the new grips work. The video is not to show any musical ability as I'm little more than a beginner. The idea is to show that it is possible to use the thumbs for playing technique whilst still maintaining a firm hold on the instrument without losing position on the buttons in chops or arrastres.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=i2HPoTuidL4

Regards,

Sebastian Brown Apraiz
www.atzarin.com
Title: Re: Atzarin bandonion photos.
Post by: melodeon on May 30, 2016, 08:15:00 PM
Congratulations, very professional presentation.
This makes bandoneon playing accessible to more players.

Do you have a video playing the 3 row ?

Thanks
Title: Atzarin accordion video.
Post by: Atzarin on May 31, 2016, 09:01:41 AM
Melodeon,

Thanks for your comments! By "the 3 row" I take it you mean the Atzarin accordion. There's no video of me playing it. I've dedicated a lot of time to redesigning certain aspects of the bandoneon to use the Atzarin layout and the little free time I have left goes into learning how to play it. I've not spent any time practicing on the accordion.

Apart from the question of time, there is another reason I haven't been practicing on the accordion and that is to do with the left hand. On the bandoneon it's bisonoric, but on the accordion it's unisonoric. That means the choices, in terms of bellows reversals, although they can be exactly the same, in practice are usually different, with reversals being less practical on the accordion.

There is a video of Owen Woods playing it after having it for a trial period at:

http://melodeonmusic.com/2013/08/20/inside-and-out-part-7-the-atzarin-accordion/

The video is at the end of the article!

Title: Re: Atzarin bandonion photos.
Post by: stevejay on May 31, 2016, 12:32:14 PM
http://atzarin.com/eng/scales/bandoneon/atzarin_bandonion_scale_patterns.html

Seems easy enough to get started. This was a clever way to demonstrate the scales to theory people and those who need more "hands on"
Title: Re: Atzarin bandonion photos.
Post by: melodeon on May 31, 2016, 04:21:49 PM
" On the bandoneon it's bisonoric, but on the accordion it's bisonoric."

Did you mean "unisonoric" on the accordeon ?

Would dural or tipo a mano reeds make a measurable difference in the tone of the accordeon and do you think it would be worth doing ?

Is the +15 tuning standard and necessary or could the tremolo be reduced a bit?


When do you believe you would have the bandoneon available for purchase ?  Will it be made by H. Geuns or also made in the Czech Republic ?
Title: Re: Atzarin bandonion photos.
Post by: Atzarin on May 31, 2016, 09:09:07 PM
Yes, that's right. On the Atzarin accordion the basses are unisonoric. Sorry for the typo!

As for the difference in tone using different kinds of reeds, I have no expertise in that area so I can only tell you what other people who do know a lot more than me about such things say, and that is yes, it would make a difference. What I can tell you from my limited technical knowledge is that it does make a difference easily measured in pounds and pence or dollars and cents.

The +15 was the standard tremolo that Delicia recommended. After hearing it, I decided that a drier sound wasn't necessary. The tremolo can be reduced a bit on the units I have in stock by retuning. Perhaps we could reach some agreement if that were the intention. New models made to order could be ordered with the desired reeds and tuning, of course. If you are in the United States and interested in having a trial period, let me know via private message.

It is currently not possible to answer your question about availability of the bandoneon at the moment. It will not be made in the Czech Republic, save a last minute change of mind by Delicia. Harry is my first choice, but there are still obstacles in the way of bringing out an affordable model and problems of scale too and Harry's workload etc.
Title: Re: Atzarin bandonion photos.
Post by: Jack Campin on May 31, 2016, 11:17:00 PM
Wouldn't it be quite a bit easier to play if you extended it to a 4- or 5-row the same way as the CBA does it?
Title: Re: Atzarin bandonion photos.
Post by: Atzarin on June 02, 2016, 12:35:03 AM
Easier? An extra row or two would certainly offer more fingering alternatives, but it would come with a cost, not just in terms of money. Originally, in my ignorance of the construction of the keyboard, I had wanted to be able to have 4 row CBA accordions modified to use the Atzarin system.

On CBA the fourth and fifth rows, the two inner rows nearest the bellows, are repeats of the first and second rows. The buttons on the first and fourth rows use the same levers. This is possible because the buttons for the repeated note are not far displaced from the same axis. So, on CBA, you can have repeated rows without having to add extra banks of reeds and extra levers.

On Atzarin, the button producing the repeated note is too far displaced from a common axis for it to be possible to use the same lever. An extra row would require extra reed blocks, reeds and levers, with consequent gains in the weight, size and cost of the instrument.

The bisonoricity of Atzarin offers the advantages of alternative fingerings that may be obtained from a fourth or fifth row on CBA. Another thing to consider is that generally people learning CBA are taught to play on three rows. That then makes it a doddle to transpose as you only need to change the row you start from, or the start button along the same row to play in any key. However, you have to put up with what is generally a bigger, more unwieldy instrument with very uncomfortable, cramped fingering involving crossing fingers over playing fingers in order to reach the next note and the hand contracting when changing from one diagonal to another.

All things considered, CBA is an excellent, though uncomfortable, system, so if you don't mind the extra bulk and weight, if you want to have 4 or 5 rows of buttons, you may as well just play CBA.

Atzarin offers alternative fingerings on just three rows by putting bisonoricity to good use with a movement of the hand in fingering that is similar to continental diatonic accordion cross row style. When changing from one diagonal to another, the hand expands and the fingers move away from each other. 3 rows is the minimum to have a neutral keyboard that can be used to play in any musical key with all notes available in both directions of the bellows. However, you have to be willing to let go of the desire to transfer fingering patterns already learnt on a 2 row and be ready to start from scratch.
Title: Re: Atzarin bandonion video.
Post by: Atzarin on June 13, 2016, 11:21:19 PM
Here's another video of my attempts on the Atzarin bandonion, playing standing up in order to demonstrate the grip and control the Esku Aske grips give over the instrument. This kind of technique, playing standing up, is talked about in the thread on the Hybrid Bandonion Review. Not wanting to generate further thread drift, I feel the video link is more appropriate here:

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=3FWYRglucg8

After murdering "Misty", by Errol Garner, I give a few rudimentary explanations about preparing to play a score and dealing with "extreme" notes, the 3 notes that are not repeated in the other direction of the bellows at each end of the keyboard. The bellows reversals in the bars leading up to and out of the bars containing these kinds of notes require special planning and may require notes to be assigned to each hand differently from the score, particularly when using a score written for piano or a lead sheet.

I've set myself the goal of producing a new video every 2 or 3 weeks explaining different aspects of the Atzarin bandonion and documenting my solitary learning process. At the moment, this instrument is unique, as there is only 1 in existence! So, it really is a lonesome journey I've embarked on. In the past I've been really impressed by the efforts of other, squeeze box players, who really can play their instruments, to blog about their progress with frequent and regular updates. Although I'd love to be able to do the same, I don't really have the time to blog, so these YouTube clips will have to suffice.
Title: Re: Atzarin bandonion photos.
Post by: Chris Brimley on June 14, 2016, 09:31:46 AM
That sound is amazing, Sebastian. (And your playing pretty tidy too!) Your video immediately demonstrates the great power of the layout.  And I think it also shows that using the layout allows players to transfer quite easily from the button accordion to the bandonion.  I don't know anything about bandonions, but I can see the benefit of the grips.

I was also interested in your learning technique from lead sheets, which I recognise with my DGAcc accordion.  Is it correct to say that you always plan your playing from the LHS first, and then add RH melody, harmony and so on? That's my preferred method, and it appeared to be what you were doing in the explanation.

As you know, as a quint box player essentially I found it hard mentally to start learning again on the Atzarin button layout (though I wish I had started with it 40 years ago!)  How are you doing that, is there no substitute for a steep initial learning curve until you have memorised all the buttons in both push and pull?  Or do you perhaps somehow train yourself to think in one and a half tone intervals?  Or perhaps when you play one note, are you thinking where to go to the next one depending on the (isomorphic) pattern of intervals between buttons?  I can see that this potentially could be a powerful concept for playing in any key.

I had a thought about standing up playing - with a melodeon it is trying to keep the RHS rock solid that makes it difficult, but I guess with the bandonion it is finding a technique to support the weight of each end, without compromising your ability to move around the buttons, and you use your knee to support the middle.  How about having a fixed stand to support the middle of the bellows instead?  I know that in the early years of piano accordion playing, there was a music hall trickster who played one blindfold, with the RHS supported on a stand on the stage.

Title: Re: Atzarin bandonion photos.
Post by: Clive Williams on June 14, 2016, 11:05:44 AM
That's pretty neat - have always loved the sound of the bandoneon, but been put off by the somewhat mad note layout they have. This makes a *lot* of sense, and is a good application for your keyboard layout.
Title: Re: Atzarin bandonion photos.
Post by: Atzarin on June 15, 2016, 11:14:54 AM
Chris and Clive, thanks for your encouraging words!

Chris, I generally use lead sheets only for Jazz versions of tunes and sometimes for Tango too. However, I also use scores for bandoneon or for piano for tangos and classical music.

When I started out, I would play every phrase and motif in both directions of the bellows and choose the most comfortable one. At first I thought the priority would be the ease of the right hand part. However, I’ve come to realise that this approach is wrong and a terrible waste of time.

The fact that nearly all notes are repeated on the draw and on the push, can actually be a hinderance to fast preparation of a piece if you don’t have a system. Some phrases are equally comfortable on the push and on the pull, so how do you choose?

Having some notes available in only one direction would help, in a way, because you would have no choice but to just get on with it. So, choice needs to be limited, but systematically. I now work on pieces by assigning bellows directions according to the chords. As each note is repeated at a different button in a different row, the chord shape may different in each direction of the bellows. Chords may be formed entirely on one row, on two adjacent rows, on two non-adjacent rows, or on all three rows.

Priority is given to those shapes that are formed on adjacent rows or the more comfortable of the 2 possible options of 3 row shapes. Comfortable refers to things like not having to use the thumb on the third row or not having to pull the little finger under the ring finger. Those chords that have the same shape on both the draw and the push may be used in different directions in the same piece, depending on what they lead into or out of.

Another interesting thing is that chord inversions may be more comfortable in the opposite direction of the bellows! This is only the case when the chords are broadly voiced. In close voicing the inversions are equally comfortable. But when maintaining the bandoneon style of a very broad chords, inversions may be easier to play with a bellows reversal. Using this system A would normally be played on the draw, on rows 2 and 3, but A/C# in broad voicing c#, a and e, so the e is more than an octave above the c#, is more comfortable on the push, using the thumb to play c# on row 1.

The important thing is to bear in mind the row of the tonic note and the kind of shape the chord will have to decide whether to play it on the draw or on the push. After establishing the bellows reversals, I work out how to play the right hand. So, yes, now I start from the left hand first and then add the right hand.

I’ll answer your question about learning and note mapping in a future post.
Title: Re: Atzarin bandonion photos.
Post by: Atzarin on June 15, 2016, 11:49:46 AM
Obviously, a non-adjacent row chord shape may be preferred so as to avoid unfortunate bellows reversals in the middle of a phrase. Bear in mind that each end of the instrument weighs ablaut 2.5 kilos, so achieving a smooth reversal that does not have an audible impact on the music requires complete mastery of technique. As such, it's better to avoid reversals in the middle of a phrase, wherever possible.

For example, in Over the Rainbow, the Gm7 chord, coming from Cm7 on the draw and leading to Eb Maj7, also on the draw, is best also played on the draw to avoid a bellows reversal and keep the phrase “uninterrupted”. Except for the Gm7 chord, all the reversals in the first part of the tune are chosen according to the system described above. In the turnaround in bar 8, the chords are Eb Maj 7 and Fm7/Bb. The first chord in the bar dictates the direction of the bellows and the sustained note in the right hand means that the bellows cannot be reversed for the next chord. 
Title: Re: Atzarin bandonion photos.
Post by: Chris Brimley on June 16, 2016, 12:13:03 AM
I wanted to add something to my earlier comments, from experiences I had a few years ago - apols if this gets a bit esoteric, but these are the kind of issues that I guess you're grappling with, Sebastian:

Learning to play any instrument is an ergonomic thing, and the player is relying on memory and patterns that he/she does not consciously understand.  The problem that I had a few years ago was related to the fact that I was 'spoilt for choice' with regard to bellows direction - by having a 14 bass 3-row layout I could play a given tune in many different fingerings and bellows directions, and when I wanted to play a given tune, my brain selected either a learned experience from that particular tune, or from previous learning experiences from different tunes. The result was that I often became muddled, and fell over.  This became such a feature of my playing that I realised my learning process was the culprit.  Therefore I tried 'mnemonics' or rehearsal aids added to scores, and that worked quite well.  However recently, I appear to have overcome my problem in ways that I do not really understand - I seem to have unconsciously learnt some sort of algorithm for selecting the right bellows direction and fingering, probably based on more experience, but I don't know.

The relevance of this to the Atzarin bandoneon layout would seem to be that you have the same 'spoilt for choice' problem, and Sebastian, I think you have realised the need for some sort of mental algorithm in your recent discussions, which mirror my own thoughts on the DGAcc.  In my case, the primary driver has proved to be bellows reversals - if one is going to achieve the smoothness benefits of 'one direction' playing, it is necessary to play alternate in and out passages.  With the Atzarin layout, you have the opportunity to use either in or out at will, so you might as well plan a sequence as a first step in learning to play a tune, which as I understand it you agree with.  I see the bandoneon as primarily a 'legato-friendly' instrument (though I realise that many experienced players achieve excellent dynamics).  However, with the quint box, it is often advantageous to plan quick reversals to achieve 'bounce', and thus mix up the dynamics, particularly when playing for folk dancing.  I may be wrong, but it seems from your discussion that this would be very difficult physically with a bandoneon.  This introduces a new dimension into the learning process, and to make sense of that, I have tried to stick to simple ^v^v or v^v^patterns as a norm, simply so that I have a way of remembering them.

I have nothing but admiration for bandoneon players, because it seems to me that the whole learning process is in total so complex that it is well-nigh impossible to achieve!  I applaud your efforts to simplify this, which is why I am interested in the mental algorithms you are using.
Title: Re: Atzarin bandonion photos.
Post by: Atzarin on June 17, 2016, 04:40:24 PM
Quote
I see the bandoneon as primarily a 'legato-friendly' instrument (though I realise that many experienced players achieve excellent dynamics).

Here's a fantastic example of excellent dynamics on the traditional bandoneon:

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=zfmFw95AqMY&list=RDzfmFw95AqMY

On the Atzarin bandonion, using the system described a couple of posts back for distributing bellows reversals throughout a piece, tends to give fairly balanced pumping with little need to use the air valve.

As for the question about how to go about learning the Atzarin keyboard, it is important to bear in mind two kinds of positioning, which will be readily known to website developers, absolute and relative positioning. When giving directions, absolute positioning refers to north, east, south and west, whereas relative positing is given by left, right, up, down etc. For most people relative positioning is much easier to understand, remember and follow than absolute positioning, and I find that to be true on the keyboard too.

On the keyboard absolute positioning would be to say, "middle c push" and your finger would fly to row 3, button 3, or say "e push" and your finger would immediately go to row 1, button 3. This is the way 2 different professional bandoneonists have told me to practice, emphasising the importance of naming the note aloud, not just thinking it. The idea is to develop a trained physical response. When you press the wrong button, you should describe the correction aloud and do it again. It's hard work, but very necessary on a layout as irregular as the bandoneon's.

The interval just described in the previous paragraph is a major third. In relative positioning you start anywhere on the keyboard and you know that if you are on the first or second row, the note a major third above is on the next row out a couple of buttons along. If you are on the third row you know the major third is on the same diagonal, 2 rows away moving towards the thumb.  If you know the musical interval you can find the correct button by thinking in terms of up, down, along etc. Part of relative positioning is learning by shapes. It's very easy to pick up the shapes for triad chords and two notes played together in thirds, fifths and sixths.

The problem with this kind of relative positioning is that you may be able to play entire passages without actually knowing what notes you're playing. That is one of my many problems. Atzarin is 100% regular, with the same musical interval between notes at buttons having the same physical relation, so it's very easy to find your way around the keyboard using interval maps. However, this ease can be your enemy because it makes you lazy about learning the exact relationship of notes to buttons.

The best way to work is by mixing the two systems but being systematic about absolute position training. Hard work, but much easier on an Atzarin accordion or bandonion than on 2 or 3 row melodeons or than on traditional bandoneon, because of the 100% regular keyboard.
Title: Re: Atzarin bandonion photos.
Post by: Atzarin on July 11, 2016, 12:06:57 AM
Here's the latest video documenting my solitary learning journey on the Atzarin bandonion:

https://youtu.be/qVSM7MwyBn4

The music is the A part of an AB structured Tango Waltz, Romance de Barrio, by Anibal Troilo in an arrangement by the superb bandoneonist Rodolfo Mederos. Unfortunately I haven't got the whole piece up to scratch for a video yet, but I needed the first part to exemplify using the thumb on the 3rd, outer row, of buttons.

Several accordionists have shown interest in the possibility of using the thumb on all three rows of buttons and my intention in the video is to show that it is possible and comfortable. It is also my intention to show traditional bandoneonists that the thumb can be used in playing technique on the Atzarin bandonion whilst still maintaining a good grip on the instrument.
SimplePortal 2.3.5 © 2008-2012, SimplePortal