Melodeon.net Forums
Discussions => Instrument Design, Construction and Repair => Topic started by: EeeJay on January 30, 2011, 08:59:11 PM
-
Just stumbled across this project. Posting it here rather than 'Makes and Models'... 'cos I think it's probably a prototype...
http://www.eco-rdeon.veganquebec.net/index-en.php (http://www.eco-rdeon.veganquebec.net/index-en.php)
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=kRRjEJGZrbU (http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=kRRjEJGZrbU)
Not as I give two hoots about the ethics myself (speaking as an avowed omnivore) but the constructional techniques... viz. use of alternative materiel/substances to possibly make a better/more consistent/more economical job... this kind of intrigues me...
Notice he uses soy wax to fit the reeds... I'd have thought screws/gasket a more obvious choice...
Ed J
-
Vegans - aren't those the guys who demolished the Earth? Second worst poets in the known universe as I recall. :|glug
Seriously, I hope it goes well for him though, the French interview seems a lot more human than the English information on his webpage and he comes across as a lot less arrogant. It's a very interesting concept and I'd like to see how it develops.
-
Just stumbled across this project. Posting it here rather than 'Makes and Models'... 'cos I think it's probably a prototype...
http://www.eco-rdeon.veganquebec.net/index-en.php (http://www.eco-rdeon.veganquebec.net/index-en.php)
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=kRRjEJGZrbU (http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=kRRjEJGZrbU)
Not as I give two hoots about the ethics myself (speaking as an avowed omnivore) but the constructional techniques... viz. use of alternative materiel/substances to possibly make a better/more consistent/more economical job... this kind of intrigues me...
Notice he uses soy wax to fit the reeds... I'd have thought screws/gasket a more obvious choice...
Ed J
Now you are being pragmatic - obviously a non traditionalist as well as an omnivore. There is a lot to be said for both, I'm a dedicated practicioner
-
Vegans - aren't those the guys who demolished the Earth? Second worst poets in the known universe as I recall. :|glug
Third worst according to THG2TG in second place the Azgoths of Kria .. and the winner is ... Paula Nancy Millstone Jennings of Sussex
ref:http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Vogon ::)
-
Ah, but then......what of those poor trees? Best the box should be made all of plastics........except for those poor dinosaurs. But then again, they all died such a long time ago, the result of volcanoes and meteors and so forth, so no doing of mine.
Maybe the bellows gussets and reed valves could be made of leather from animals that were deemed to have died of natural causes, thus relieving us of the burden of guilt?
Bob
(I suspect that this thread will get shifted over to the new discussion heading, Philosophy of the Accordion.) ;)
-
Vegans - aren't those the guys who demolished the Earth? Second worst poets in the known universe as I recall. :|glug
Seriously, I hope it goes well for him though, the French interview seems a lot more human than the English information on his webpage and he comes across as a lot less arrogant. It's a very interesting concept and I'd like to see how it develops.
Third worst, third worst ;D
I am going to have to be the annoying person here who says that this accordion is interesting, but ultimately a bit ridiculous. I mean, using soy wax instead of beeswax... Really?!.
My mother has always been anti-fur and so on (as am I, I have no interest in seeing potentially vulnerable fluffy creatures killed) and I remember just after buying a new pair of leather walking boots (Scarpa SL M3, for those that are interested. I had them to replace a pair of Meindls that fell to pieces and they are one of the best pairs I've ever owned. I feel like I can trample cities in them) we were walking past a whole load of new graduates of some kind. My Mum expressed indignation at the fur in the hoods and misunderstanding her, I leapt to the defence of my new walking boots. When it emerged that she was talking about the hoods I replied that they are mostly synthetic nowadays. She was a bit quiet about that, it's easy to forget that leather is an animal product :P
-
Interesting project, but the result is a very pretty box, and to my eye the look of the accordion is greatly enhanced by the absence of those garish metal corner pieces.
-
I am going to have to be the annoying person here who says that this accordion is interesting, but ultimately a bit ridiculous. I mean, using soy wax instead of beeswax... Really?!.
I agree.
I think there's people who'd object to something using so many petrochemical products being called "Eco" anything as well...
-
Interesting project, but the result is a very pretty box, and to my eye the look of the accordion is greatly enhanced by the absence of those garish metal corner pieces.
Yes indeed! I think it looks nice.
I'm curious about the "workshop" that he mentioned -- did it take place in Quebec?
-
A worthy project. A poor melodeon. Maybe it is his inexperience at building melodeons rather than the materials.
IMHO, use the best product available (gathered as a by product that is) for the job on hand. Usual caveat of not killing an animal just to harvest one fragment of its anatomy etc.
-
A worthy project. A poor melodeon.
Interested to hear why you don't like the end result?
IMHO, use the best product available (gathered as a by product that is) for the job on hand. Usual caveat of not killing an animal just to harvest one fragment of its anatomy etc.
This maker is using the Vegan principle of not using anything of animal origin regardless of whether the animal is killed. Vegans don't eat dairy products for example, hence the substitute for beeswax. Bees don't have to be killed to harvest their wax (or their honey)
-
A worthy project. A poor melodeon.
Interested to hear why you don't like the end result?
It may have been the video but the response between pressing keys and sound coming out was observable. Secondly the player was exerting great effort to achieve any result at all. My comparisons are with other one row boxes seen on the same medium of Youtube.
IMHO, use the best product available (gathered as a by product that is) for the job on hand. Usual caveat of not killing an animal just to harvest one fragment of its anatomy etc.
This maker is using the Vegan principle of not using anything of animal origin regardless of whether the animal is killed. Vegans don't eat dairy products for example, hence the substitute for beeswax. Bees don't have to be killed to harvest their wax (or their honey). I understood his intentions, just don't agree with them. Sorry to confuse the issue but I didn't want to come across as a blanket killer of any animal if I just wanted bits from it. After all, melodeon players are quite nice peolpe (:) ;)
-
A worthy project. A poor melodeon. Maybe it is his inexperience at building melodeons rather than the materials.
<rant warning>
How can you say it is a poor melodeon? Have you seen the instrument first hand? Have you played it? I suspect not, so how can you judge? It looks and sounds very similar to the one-row instruments that Emmanuel Pariselle makes on his well-established and popular courses, and also very similar to a Wesson Clipper. Are those poor melodeons?
It is indeed a worthy project, despite disparaging remarks about the vegan aspect from some posters. I find it hard to understand why some people on here are so discouraging about anyone new coming up with something slightly different from the accepted norm. What are you afraid of FFS? The same thing happened with Pete Ward's (Jilly) Acorn accordions / Manfrini diatonic project a few months back. A new idea got nothing but flak from some of you on here, so much so that the maker became so discouraged that the entire project was nearly pulled. That was nothing short of shameful. This is supposed to be a friendly forum.
</rant warning>
>:(
-
Steve, the members of this forum are quite a good cross section of melodeon players in the world, not just England or Europe. If the majority views are opposed to yours and that offends you then I am very sorry for that but as a marketing resource, if many are against a project, apathetic or disparaging, it would be unwise to disregard what this forum is feeding back.
Manufacturers may choose to continue or modify. That is the freedom we enjoy. I deeply respect your view and even if I disagree with it I will fight tooth and nail so that you may express it.
-
A worthy project. A poor melodeon.
Interested to hear why you don't like the end result?
It may have been the video but the response between pressing keys and sound coming out was observable. Secondly the player was exerting great effort to achieve any result at all. My comparisons are with other one row boxes seen on the same medium of Youtube.
I think the sound and vision were well out of sync, I'd blame the technical limitations of youtube before I'd condemn the box.
-
It may have been the video but the response between pressing keys and sound coming out was observable. Secondly the player was exerting great effort to achieve any result at all. My comparisons are with other one row boxes seen on the same medium of Youtube.
When I watched it, as Theo says, the audio and video weren't synched up at all. As for the second point, it didn't look like that to me, but I'm not an expert on one-row boxes. I thought that the box itself was really quite attractive, although perhaps not exactly to my taste and sounded fine.
-
As said earlier, the vegan way of life is not easy to grab for some people, yet this guy has achieved to build a nice melodeon (including the bellows) using alternative materials when animal-based products are usually the norm.
A remarkable achievement, IMHO, the instrument is pretty and seems to play well. This guy deserves encouragements!
-
While bees don't have to be killed for us to take their honey and wax, I have been told (by a small-scale beekeeper here in Québec) that most commercial beekeepers in Canada - especially the mega operations out in the western half of the country - start fresh colonies every year, either allowing them to die, or actively killing them, at the end of the season rather than keep them alive during the winter. (Caveat: I haven't bothered to verify my friend's assertions.)
I too am at a loss to understand the disparaging reactions to yer man's effort, and I can't imagine what about the web page might come across as arrogant. Is he supposed to apologise for wanting to be consistent with his own beliefs?
His playing may look like hard work because he's not an expert. And even if the finished product were far from perfect, so what? Marcel Messervier's first effort was probably a long way short of his current standard. ;)
-
I'm curious about the "workshop" that he mentioned -- did it take place in Quebec?
According to the TV interview, it was in Rimouski, Québec. The box he made in the workshop is a 12-bass, can't see how many treble rows it has from the camera angle, but it looks too small to be a 3-row.
Edit: just spotted, it's a 2½ row G/C. He plays a bit of a piece called Valse Astride on it towards the end of the interview segment.
-
I too am at a loss to understand the disparaging reactions to yer man's effort, and I can't imagine what about the web page might come across as arrogant. Is he supposed to apologise for wanting to be consistent with his own beliefs?
His playing may look like hard work because he's not an expert. And even if the finished product were far from perfect, so what? Marcel Messervier's first effort was probably a long way short of his current standard. ;)
Not sure if there are some mixed quotes here but I would like to make it quite clear that I haven't referred to anyone as arrogant. Quite the contrary, 'worthy project' was my genuine opinion.
The power of democracy is certainly shining through on the forum and I feel the weight of opinion is in favour of this melodeon. The real test will of course be when it goes on sale and how many people will feel the provenance of the box merits a purchase.
-
A worthy project. A poor melodeon. (...)
So if "worthy project" was your opinion, why mentioning "poor melodeon" then? ???
-
Sorry for lumping my responses to different reactions together, NSA.
The web page eejay linked to itself gives a link to an article in L'Itinéraire magazine, which is the local equivalent of The Big Issue. This contains a hint that Stéphane Groleau might be contemplating making accordions for sale. He says that he's not sure where he's headed with the Éco-rdéon, but that the next model he would like to design is a 2½ row. "Few makers in Québec turn their attention to this model. It would be a more interesting* market niche to exploit, because Québec already has some very good accordion makers."
*"Intéressant" in French often implies more than "interesting" does in English, e.gé useful, attractive, rewarding or profitable.
-
The real test will of course be when it goes on sale and how many people will feel the provenance of the box merits a purchase.
I didn't get the impression it was going on sale. Have I missed something?
-
So if "worthy project" was your opinion, why mentioning "poor melodeon" then? ???
Many things are worthy, but worthiness by itself does not infer quality. From earlier posts though, I have been corrected for misinterpreting the out of sync recording for a poor response time.
-
"Vegans don't eat dairy products for example, hence the substitute for beeswax" -- Theo
So these are dairy bees, then!? (:)
Bob
-
I think I have stumbled in to the vegan division of the semantic police. ;D ;D
PS "This contains a hint that Stéphane Groleau might be contemplating making accordions for sale." from the article and confirmed by Steve above
-
So these are dairy bees, then!? (:)
There is an ancient belief that bees are begotten of bulls. One of the earliest writers to mention the bull-born bee is Antigonos of Karystos, about 250 B C, who says :
In Egypt if you bury the ox in certain places, so that only his horns project above the ground and then saw them off, they say that bees fly out; for the ox putrefies and is resolved into bees.
(Antigonos, Hist.mir. 19; quoted by Cook Zeus I, 514; Ransome 1937: 114)
What do you know!
-
Bob
(I suspect that this thread will get shifted over to the new discussion heading, Philosophy of the Accordion.) ;)
Definitely going that way and much better than trying to knock chunks of each other.
Zen and the :|||:
-
*"Intéressant" in French often implies more than "interesting" does in English, e.gé useful, attractive, rewarding or profitable.
Well, my bank charges enough interest, and that young lady on the customer care desk is certainly 'interesting' ;)
In Egypt if you bury the ox in certain places, so that only his horns project above the ground and then saw them off, they say that bees fly out; for the ox putrefies and is resolved into bees.
It's also in Virgil - "Georgic IV" - a tad later 29 BC
A portent they espy: through the oxen's flesh, Waxed soft in dissolution, hark! there hum
Bees from the belly; the rent ribs overboil In endless clouds they spread them, till at last
On yon tree-top together fused they cling, And drop their cluster from the bending boughs.
Though Virgil was a bit wet as a lad, much preferred Scot m'self :|glug
-
"through the oxen's flesh, Waxed soft in dissolution, hark! there hum
Bees from the belly; the rent ribs overboil"
Eeeeww! That'd make me into a vegan, right there!
Bob
(Amazing the things one can learn here!)
-
Points in favor:
Mitred corners
None of those cheezy metal corners
the grooves around the frames are to the side of the stop shafts instead of the groove ridiculously running inder the stops.. never did understand the logic of that...( see comment on cheezy corners)
Down side.... fingerboard is to wide
As to Vegan... mox nix... does nothing for me one way or the other.. a non issue.
Interesting project and appears to be well done (pun intended) though I'll take mine "char rare" and a baseball cut.
-
Looks like some readers did not understand the dynamics behind the making of this melodeon!
The maker is vegan and has strong convictions about NOT using animal products or by-products in his lifestyle. That includes the objects he uses, not only his diet. He likes playing the melodeon yet he realizes that there are many animal-based components in them, so he undertakes the task of making one using non-animal components from sustainable sources (that includes the wood).
That's it! There is no other message, IMHO. No intention of revolutionizing the melodeon industry, or making a political statement. In the video he seems proud of playing his creation, and I would be if I had built a melodeon like that myself!
Remember, minds are like parachutes, they work better when they are open... :||:
-
I fully understand the motivation.. immaterial to me.. good for the maker.
-
.. immaterial to me..
Immaterial to me too, but I do admire someone who has the determination to build his own instrument in a way that fits with his beliefs.
-
.. immaterial to me..
Immaterial to me too, but I do admire someone who has the determination to build his own instrument in a way that fits with his beliefs.
I'm just happy to admire someone who builds their own instrument! :||: