Melodeon.net Forums

Discussions => General Discussion => Topic started by: melodeon on February 01, 2011, 06:35:27 PM

Title: So Long
Post by: melodeon on February 01, 2011, 06:35:27 PM
I will be absent for a while...

Nothing to do with a recent post by an admirer.
FWII my kids have called me Jefe since they were babies almost 4 decades, hence the e mail address.

In another life I brokered timbres to instrument makers from Canada to Mexico along the West Coast, and
still dabble with rare wood hustling and I make furniture as a full time profession. I collect wood and wood
samples.

The box has butt joints in keeping with the design of the accordeon.
It has an amateur finish job, in keeping with the style of the accordeon.
My comments stand on that subject.


It's been fun.

Jeff
Title: Re: So Long
Post by: savantuk on February 01, 2011, 08:00:07 PM
Hi Jeff,

The post is so obviously directed at me, that I have to reply, and risk the wrath of our host.

It matters not one whit to me what you have been and done in the past, it is just a shame that you do not use your obvious skills in a kindlier and less abrasive manner.  There was no need for you to rip into my accordeon in such a manner.  I stand by my statement that the box is beautiful, and a fine example of the genre.

Around the turn of the 19th/20th century, coincidentally the same sort of time these melodeons were first introduced, there was a move in the UK furniture industry to a style called 'Arts and Crafts'.  It only lasted a few short years, unfortunately, but during the time the Arts and Crafts movement existed, some of the finest and most beautiful British furniture that has ever existed was built.  The ethos of the movement was that the furniture should be made in the most simple of manners.  That all the joints should be as simple as possible, and left exposed so that everybody could see how it had been put together,  Quite often, sawmarks were left on the timber, and no attempt was made to hide them.  The furniture was simple, perhaps too simple, and in some cases, ugly.

Some might say the result was crude, but it has nevertheless become some of the most collectable furniture ever.

A lot of cajun box makers make their boxes in a similar manner, I agree, but for all their apparent crudity, they work, and work well - more than the sum of their parts you might say.  Mine is no different, I however think it looks beautiful, and it makes gorgeous, rich noises, and that after all is what matters most. I wish you could understand that.   As you said in an earlier post 'woodwork with reeds'.

I have no wish to see you leave, come back soon.
Title: Re: So Long
Post by: melodeon on February 02, 2011, 05:13:30 AM


I am a furniture maker,professionally for the last 21 years., as an amateur another 20 prior.  I make  Arts and Crafts furniture ( the more obscure painted pieces and the British made stuff such as Mouseman , as well as Limbert and Byrdcliffe) . I also make Quebecois, Mennonite, Hutterite, Amana, Ukrainian , Gustavian, Monterey and its derivatives etc. Thanks for the education. 

I use  oak , alder and ash,  all cut by me from trees on my own property. Currently I have stickered about 1200 Board feet of quarter sawn oak all from a 105 year old tree (according to the rings) . 1 1/4"  and 2 1/4 " thick by 18-28" wide, 9-12 feet long . The thinner planks will be ready this year.. the others next year.

I did not "rip" your accordeon. I commented on the wood and the appropriateness of the joints for the style.
I am deeply distressed that you are so offended. May I offer my sincerest apologies to you and your box.
I wish I had the opportunity to play it, no doubt it plays well and meets the consensus of opinions about the
E. Martin accordeons.

By turn of the century , you mean 1829 and later ?


Title: Re: So Long
Post by: Alan Morley on February 02, 2011, 08:50:18 AM
There's only one way to settle this.......fight..........
Title: Re: So Long
Post by: Malcolm Austen on February 02, 2011, 08:59:04 AM
Fight,
I think you will find that Harry Hill plays the Ukulele not the Melodeon
Title: Re: So Long
Post by: Alan Morley on February 02, 2011, 09:03:41 AM
Fight,
I think you will find that Harry Hill plays the Ukulele not the Melodeon

You're right - sorry - off topic  ;D
Title: Re: So Long
Post by: Keithypete. on February 02, 2011, 10:14:08 AM
Fight,
I think you will find that Harry Hill plays the Ukulele not the Melodeon

You're right - sorry - off topic  ;D


Or as John Cleese once said "Tennis - really? I used to play cricket ."
   But seriously, a uke has no chance against a well built melodeon. Unless its one of those National-type ukes.
Title: Re: So Long
Post by: savantuk on February 02, 2011, 10:45:02 AM


I am a furniture maker,professionally for the last 21 years., as an amateur another 20 prior.  I make  Arts and Crafts furniture ( the more obscure painted pieces and the British made stuff such as Mouseman , as well as Limbert and Byrdcliffe) . I also make Quebecois, Mennonite, Hutterite, Amana, Ukrainian , Gustavian, Monterey and its derivatives etc. Thanks for the education. 

I use  oak , alder and ash,  all cut by me from trees on my own property. Currently I have stickered about 1200 Board feet of quarter sawn oak all from a 105 year old tree (according to the rings) . 1 1/4"  and 2 1/4 " thick by 18-28" wide, 9-12 feet long . The thinner planks will be ready this year.. the others next year.

I did not "rip" your accordeon. I commented on the wood and the appropriateness of the joints for the style.
I am deeply distressed that you are so offended. May I offer my sincerest apologies to you and your box.

I wish I had the opportunity to play it, no doubt it plays well and meets the consensus of opinions about the
E. Martin accordeons.

By turn of the century , you mean 1829 and later ?




Hi Jeff


Thank you for this post.  It is very welcome.  I apologise to anybody who may in some way have been offended, but I hope not.

Your post does, I think draw a line, and I would like the subject to end here.  Pax??
Title: Re: So Long
Post by: Ebor_fiddler on February 02, 2011, 01:42:20 PM
Anybody who likes Mousey Thompson's stuff has many good points as well as good taste. My dad put his first telephone in. Melodeon don't go.

Regards.

Chris B.
Title: Re: So Long
Post by: tedrick on February 02, 2011, 02:21:10 PM
We could use a return to the philosophy and values of the Arts and Crafts movement -

hopefully as society transforms people will appreciate the value of authentic experiences -

I think as traditional musicians, we appreciate some of what the Arts and Crafts movement represented.
Title: Re: So Long
Post by: Quebecois on February 07, 2011, 03:12:32 PM
I think as traditional musicians, we appreciate some of what the Arts and Crafts movement represented.
...even those who use butt joints??? Really???
Title: Re: So Long
Post by: Theo on February 07, 2011, 03:30:32 PM

...even those who use butt joints??? Really???

Please ...
Title: Re: So Long
Post by: Steve C. on February 08, 2011, 10:58:31 PM
I did not realize we had El Jefe in the forum. (I did not even know he played the melodeon)
Title: Re: So Long
Post by: Steve C. on February 09, 2011, 01:35:56 PM
(El Jefe=Fidel)
Title: Re: So Long
Post by: Ebor_fiddler on February 10, 2011, 12:49:25 AM
Oh, THAT one! I thought you had misspelt - forgive me.  :|bl
SimplePortal 2.3.5 © 2008-2012, SimplePortal