Melodeon.net Forums
Discussions => Instrument Design, Construction and Repair => Topic started by: nemethmik on February 03, 2011, 11:26:23 AM
-
What is the type (hand-made, hand-type, machine) of the reeds on these pictures?
-
What is the type (hand-made, hand-type, machine) of the reeds on these pictures?
Machine made judging by the rivets, but there again what do I know (:)
-
What is the type (hand-made, hand-type, machine) of the reeds on these pictures?
A more useful question to ask about them is how do they sound when the accordion is played.
I've seen 'hand made' reeds in a box that played like porridge, and 'machine made' reeds that were great.
-
What is the type (hand-made, hand-type, machine) of the reeds on these pictures?
A more useful question to ask about them is how do they sound when the accordion is played.
I've seen 'hand made' reeds in a box that played like porridge, and 'machine made' reeds that were great.
Just fitted a set of Cagnoni Macchina reeds to an Erica and they sound fine, just what I wanted. Will stick up a video in a while
-
What is the type (hand-made, hand-type, machine) of the reeds on these pictures?
A more useful question to ask about them is how do they sound when the accordion is played.
I've seen 'hand made' reeds in a box that played like porridge, and 'machine made' reeds that were great.
I agree. A lot also depends on how they are tuned. A correctly tuned set of machine made reeds can sound just as good as a set of a mano or tipo a mano reeds. They can sound even better if the hand made reeds have been mal tuned or abused.
-
Just fitted a set of Cagnoni Macchina reeds to an Erica and they sound fine, just what I wanted. Will stick up a video in a while
I have them in two of my boxes and they sound really nice. Nice price too.
-
What is the type (hand-made, hand-type, machine) of the reeds on these pictures?
Machine made judging by the rivets, but there again what do I know (:)
Having just had my Castagnari Tommy apart to tune a crummy chord I may well change my vote as the rivets looks just like the decent reeds in the Tommy but like I said what do I know.
-
For reference here are a couple of pictures of the reeds from one of my accordions with "hand-made" (a mano) reeds (I suppose Cagnoni):
-
I think looking at rivets is a complete red herring. Any one rivetting on a commercial basis will use a some form of press tool for consistent result and speed. They almost certainly get
a better result from doing so too.
-
Had someone fit Cagnoni Macchina reeds to my wife's Hohner Student (circa 1938 model) Some sounded OK the others were pretty duff. Took it to Rees. Whole thing sounds delightful. Is it the reeds or the way they are set up?
-
I think looking at rivets is a complete red herring.
Quite the opposite, regardless of what anyone thinks about it, the five flats on the rivet head indicate that it's been assembled by hand.
People can debate the differences they make to the player until there are blue faces all round but there are clear and well-established differences between the three main grades of reeds used by Italian makers. It might not make a difference to the sound or playability but TAM and A Mano reeds cost a lot more than Macchina or Export reeds and it's important to know the physical differences if someone's trying to charge more for an instrument with "handmade reeds"...
-
Took it to Rees. Whole thing sounds delightful. Is it the reeds or the way they are set up?
It was "The Rees" who made the difference :D
-
in my ADG gabbanelli the G rows sounds REALY high pitched i think rees once told me they where cagnoni machina, maybe i should get him to check it out, ive been thinkin of getting it switched from MM to LM
purely because the G row sounds so high (and weak)
-
Just received the "official" reply from Borsini that the reeds mentioned in the original post are "typo a mano" made 20 years ago.