Melodeon.net Forums
Discussions => Instrument Design, Construction and Repair => Topic started by: Graham Spencer on February 04, 2011, 02:41:42 PM
-
I recently acquired a wreck of an old Hohner PA, picked up for a couple of quid for any usable parts and to practise tuning before I attack a potentially decent melodeon. The reeds seem decent quality and sound pretty good - loud & very "Hohnerish", but they aren't steel; they're a yellowish metal which could be brass or bronze or something else. Out of idle curiosity, does anyone know if Hohner routinely used non-steel reeds at any time? Apart from the metal of the tongues, the reeds appear identical to the ones in a 1930s Club I have in bits.
Graham
-
I too have a very old 80-bass PA that has those brass or bronze reeds. The instrument belonged to one of my father's aunts and is more than 75 years old. The sound of the bass notes is amazing.
-
Right, so they were possibly a regular fitting back then. They do sound pretty good, I have to admit - much better than any brass reeds I've come across. I'd love to know what alloy they are - maybe monel metal, or Britannia metal? Or maybe they are bronze?
Graham
-
I too have a very old 80-bass PA that has those brass or bronze reeds. The instruments belonged to one of my father's aunts and is more than 75 years old. The sound of the bass notes is amazing.
Not much help to the OP but I noticed this, too. Bass notes from bronze reeds have a wonderful, powerful tone.
-
Right, so they were possibly a regular fitting back then. They do sound pretty good, I have to admit - much better than any brass reeds I've come across. I'd love to know what alloy they are - maybe monel metal, or Britannia metal? Or maybe they are bronze?
Graham
Think you can rule out Britannia metal - isn't that more silver in colour?
"Yellow metal" reeds were quite commonplace in early 1900s Hohners and sometimes referred to as Steel Bronze (perhaps to differentiate from brass) They also described some harmonicas as having Bell Metal reeds which would point to their being bronze.
I have never tried a magnet on the so-called "steel" bronze ones to see if there was iron content as would be the case with Monel.
-
Yes, you're right about Britannia metal. Bell metal sounds a possibility; they're not quite yellow enough for brass, and they don't have the dirty-brown oxide deposits you'd expect on brass. Britannia metal came to mind because it's a nickel alloy, and I've come across nickel-silver that's been quite yellow - but not as yellow as these reeds. I suppose you'd describe them as a "deep straw" colour - definitely not steel, and almost certainly not brass. Any way up, they sound pretty good, which is the main point!
Thanks all
Graham