Melodeon.net Forums

Discussions => Instrument Makes and Models => Topic started by: tip184 on February 16, 2011, 06:21:20 PM

Title: Identify my new box for me?
Post by: tip184 on February 16, 2011, 06:21:20 PM
I am the lucky(?) winner of this old 2-row Hohner - just won it on ebay (US) and will not receive it for a week or so.  I wonder if anyone can provide a model name or number, or any info about the box.  I have attached a photo, and additional photos can still be seen on ebay at:

http://cgi.ebay.com/ws/eBayISAPI.dll?ViewItem&rt=nc&nma=true&item=160542218626 (http://cgi.ebay.com/ws/eBayISAPI.dll?ViewItem&rt=nc&nma=true&item=160542218626)

(choose "See Full Description")

or go to ebay and search for item# 160542218626

Thanks for any info that you can provide!

Jeff
Title: Re: Identify my new box for me?
Post by: tip184 on February 17, 2011, 01:02:45 PM
C'mon guys!  More than 120 of the world's best and brightest melodeon experts have viewed my post, and nobody can tell me about this old Hohner?  Maybe I'm the proud owner of the world's rarest and most unusual melodeon!  Or maybe nobody wants to tell me that I've been duped and that it's not really a Hohner.

Any info will be appreciated.  Thanks!
Title: Re: Identify my new box for me?
Post by: mglamb on February 17, 2011, 01:23:13 PM
If you're so impatient for info, why not contact Hohner directly?  Good luck fixing it up.
Title: Re: Identify my new box for me?
Post by: tip184 on February 17, 2011, 01:41:39 PM
Hmmmm.  I guess I am impatient, although I might have described it as overly curious.  Sorry to harp.  I'll just sit back and wait.  If I hear anything from Hohner I'll let you know.
Title: Re: Identify my new box for me?
Post by: Quebecois on February 17, 2011, 02:09:11 PM
Well, just hope the inside is in better condition than the outside! Typical box from the early 1900's I guess. I have seen pics of similar instruments in department store catalogs. Nothing to be excited about, really...
Title: Re: Identify my new box for me?
Post by: HallelujahAl on February 17, 2011, 02:14:51 PM
Quote
Sorry to harp
No, you're perfectly right. I looked at it and very rapidly looked away again as I'm afraid I couldn't tell you anything at all about the box that you don't already know., i.e.:

a: it's a very old Hohner - 4 stops - which indicates its voicing
b: has the look of a Saxony style manufacture, so is highly likely to be brass reeded on perhaps long plates rather than individual reeds?
c: is, understandably given it's age, in very poor condition and will take a lot to get it back to reasonable standard
d: it's more of a curiosity rather than an instrument that one would restore for playing purposes

AL
Title: Re: Identify my new box for me?
Post by: rmenhinick on February 17, 2011, 02:33:03 PM

b: has the look of a Saxony style manufacture, so is highly likely to be brass reeded on perhaps long plates rather than individual reeds?


If you zoom into the picture it quite clearly states "Genuine Steel Reeds" on the leather strip back left. It also says "Highest .." something unreadable and "SAN FRANCISCO" and then "1816" (I think .. could be 1616 if so thats probably not a date!) on the leather back right.

On the front I reckon the (partially obscured) wording says "ACCORDION Made in GERMANY"

I bet if it plays nothing else it'll do "Home on the Range" and smell of cows! ;D
Title: Re: Identify my new box for me?
Post by: HallelujahAl on February 17, 2011, 03:16:24 PM
Quote
it quite clearly states "Genuine Steel Reeds" on the leather strip back left. It also says "Highest .."
Yup - I overlooked that although I'd still be a bit dubious given the propensity for 'steel-bronze' reeds etc to be used at that time. And I'd be quite interested to see whether they're on a single plate or on individual plates. Date of the 'Highest Award' looks to be 1916 to my eyes - so that'd date the instrument to around 1920s probably. The fingerboard has a couple of significant cracks running through it which might make things a bit tricky. Although it was made in Germany it was obviously for US consumption as the branding is all in English.

Be interested to hear more when you get the box tip184?
AL
Title: Re: Identify my new box for me?
Post by: tip184 on February 17, 2011, 05:58:00 PM
Thanks all.  I'll gladly share whatever info I can after I receive the box.

It looks nearly identical to the 1-row Hohner that I purchased from ebay 3 years ago - same branding, etc.  That one has individual reeds - steel like it says on the outside.  I consider it the predecessor of the 114, but I do not have a name or model number for it. 
Title: Re: Identify my new box for me?
Post by: tip184 on February 22, 2011, 11:02:48 PM
A quick update.  The box arrived today - well packaged but (as many of you suggested) in terrible shape.  Something is rattling around inside (maybe the missing knob from one of the stops - maybe a reed) and so many pallets fail to close that it is nearly impossible to test it.  I had a quick chance to look at it before heading to work - I'll play with it more tonight.

The ebay seller who said it "Plays Great" was clearly deluded.  Ya gets what ya pays for.

More later, if anyone cares.
Title: Re: Identify my new box for me?
Post by: Steve C. on February 23, 2011, 04:45:05 AM
Tip--

I hope you did not pay too much.

Way back, I was in similar stead with banjoes, I would buy almost anything if priced low enough, but I have to tell you, I spent years futzing around with "junk" that was awfully hard to play and never worth fixing properly.

(in the banjo world, a lot of these instruments are called "no names", for (now) obvious reasons.  ::)
Title: Re: Identify my new box for me?
Post by: Theo on February 23, 2011, 08:16:24 AM
  Something is rattling around inside

Probably one or more reedplates that have broken loose in transit.    The seller may have been truthful.   The reed wax was probably at the end of its life and would have to be replaced anyway.
Title: Re: Identify my new box for me?
Post by: old geezer on February 23, 2011, 08:18:03 AM


close, but no cigar  :P

the difference that I can see is the size of the wooden blocks under the treble keyboard

does yours display 1915 under San Francisco ?

the image below is described as;
Instrument type: Two row accordion
              Brand: Hohner
              Model: No. 621
    Manufacturer: Matth. Hohner A.G.
              Origin: Trossingen, Germany
               Year: 1927? (1927 - 1930)

 
Title: Re: Identify my new box for me?
Post by: tip184 on February 23, 2011, 01:27:58 PM
Geezer -

This is it - exactly the one I received.
_________________________________
the image below is described as;
Instrument type: Two row accordion
              Brand: Hohner
              Model: No. 621
    Manufacturer: Matth. Hohner A.G.
              Origin: Trossingen, Germany
               Year: 1927? (1927 - 1930)
__________________________________

Seller might have been truthful, but only if "plays great" means something totally different in her universe than in mine.  Two bass reed plates are off (and yes - it could have happened in transit) and at least 15 leathers are missing (these are the ones I can see - I can't tell about the hidden ones).

OK - time to buy some reed wax and leathers - I have some learnin' to do.
Title: Re: Identify my new box for me?
Post by: Theo on February 23, 2011, 01:45:49 PM
at least 15 leathers are missing

Remember that there should not be leathers on the highest treble reeds.  The highest reeds speak best without leathers.   Look for the absence of any mark left by the glue holding the leather to see where there were none originally.
Title: Re: Identify my new box for me?
Post by: mglamb on February 23, 2011, 01:49:41 PM

OK - time to buy some reed wax and leathers - I have some learnin' to do.

My only advice for you here would be to remind you of the principal of not throwing good money after bad...  In its day this box was the equivalent of the cheap Chinese accordions that Ebay is flooded with today.  Unfortunately, its day was a lifetime ago and in the interim the materials have dried, cracked, warped and rotted away; parts that require precise fitting no longer do so.  With all the best will in the world, it will never be worth what you have already invested in it.

If your intention was to get a playable instrument for cheap, then chalk this up to experience and move on; if your intention is now to self-learn accordion repair, I suggest you do so on a newer instrument that has a reasonable chance of being put into playable condition.  I'm sorry if this comes across as harsh, but I'm just trying to be honest with you about this instrument, as have several others before me.  Good luck with whatever you choose to do!

Title: Re: Identify my new box for me?
Post by: tip184 on February 23, 2011, 03:41:51 PM
Theo -

Yep - I'm just counting the reeds that ought to have leathers.  I know that that the high ones don't need them (although I don't understand why this would be the case).

mglamb -

Thanks for the good advice - you're telling me something that I already know but don't want to admit.  I am learning on a Hohner Ariette (my main interest is the one-row).  I think for the money it is a decent instrument.  I liked the way this old Hohner looked, but it will take some effort to make it playable. I'll decide soon whether to sell it (and my old, small one-row Parsifal that also needs work) or donate it to a restaurant that wants folksy decorations....
Title: Re: Identify my new box for me?
Post by: Bananayogi on February 23, 2011, 03:52:36 PM
I had an Ariette for a (very short) while. I can't speak for yours, but mine was a truly awful instrument. I certainly couldn't have learned on it.

If I were you, I'd sell the Ariette, the Parsifal and your new Ebay acquisition and buy a Hohner 114.
Title: Re: Identify my new box for me?
Post by: tip184 on February 23, 2011, 03:55:03 PM
I went to the Ariette from a 1920's era Hohner 1-row 4-stop - the Ariette is wonderful in comparison.  Is the 114 that much better?
Title: Re: Identify my new box for me?
Post by: Bananayogi on February 23, 2011, 04:17:47 PM
Yes, I'm afraid so - unless you got an unexpectedly good Ariette. If you can try a modern(ish) 114, do so.

I know some people (on here) have taken a stock Ariette and improved it by working on it at some length, but if you are a player rather than a tech/repairer I really would see if you can get something decent to learn on to start with.
Title: Re: Identify my new box for me?
Post by: Quebecois on February 23, 2011, 04:19:00 PM
The 112 and 114 are neat little boxes, very easy to play.

If you can get an Ariette for cheap (i.e. $100 or less) it can be customized and improved. The bellows on the early models are a bit stiff but can be worked in. The reeds are OK but some high notes on the H set may not play... I replaced the reeds on mine with Cagnoni Macchina and the sound has vastly improved. I had to modify and extend the reedblocks though, the original reedplates where shorter and wider than the italian set. The reedblocks are made of soft wood which makes them easy to modify!

Title: Re: Identify my new box for me?
Post by: Bananayogi on February 23, 2011, 04:24:51 PM
So apart from the bellows and the reeds it was fine then...  ;D

When I had the Ariette I read through the threads detailing what you had done (very impressive) but decided that as a player(ish) rather than an accordion tech, I would be better just getting rid of it. I managed to sell it at no loss on Ebay.
Title: Re: Identify my new box for me?
Post by: tip184 on February 23, 2011, 06:29:09 PM
So, Bananyogi... That's where my Ariette came from!
Title: Re: Identify my new box for me?
Post by: kdhoffman on February 23, 2011, 10:54:52 PM
Been playing single row Cajun Accordion for about 15 years, yesterday I stopped in my friend's music shop, to see what treasures he may have, he's having his annual reduction sale, there was a Ariete sitting there, price tag $125., I picked it up and looked it over and said this looks brand new, and he said, yea it belongs to my daughters boyfriend. I sat down and tried to play a tune and there was no way I could play a tune on it, not to mention it was way out of tune. I've tried a few 114's over the years and I could at least get a tune out of those, but I wouldn't consider owning one. The point is the same that others are trying to tell you, you will never learn to play if you don't get yourself a good accordion. Be good to yourself and get a good one and you will be a good player someday if you work at it.
Title: Re: Identify my new box for me?
Post by: Rob2Hook on February 23, 2011, 11:22:28 PM
To be fair, the 114 has a sound all its own and does what it does well.  But only a gifted few can make them really rock!  Even DTN swore at me after borrowing my Hohner 114C - and he makes me sick with envy when he plays my Castagnari Max.  Not that he failed to play it, but it's hard work by comparison with a modern, quality four-stop, whether Italian or Cajun built (or even Welsh!).

Rob.
Title: Re: Identify my new box for me?
Post by: tip184 on February 24, 2011, 12:16:23 AM
OK - I get the impression that a modern, quality 4-stop 1-row is what many of you think I should cash in my Ariette (etc.) to get.  Some have bad-mouthed the 114.  What do you recommend?

Hand-made Cajun box out of Louisiana (out of my price range)

Gabanelli Cajun King

Excalibur

Castagnari (don't know the price).

What are the Welsh 1-row boxes (and are they available in the US?)

Remember - I'm in melodeon-poor midwest USA.  Advice is appreciated (although given my finances I will probably stick with the Ariette for a few years...).
Title: Re: Identify my new box for me?
Post by: Theo on February 24, 2011, 12:27:10 AM
If you want an inexpensive 4-stop then the modern Weltmeister Cajun is very good.
Title: Re: Identify my new box for me?
Post by: Rob2Hook on February 24, 2011, 01:02:59 AM
The Welsh four-stop is the Wesson Clipper, made by Rees Wesson.  Made to order only.  Contact details on this website under "Makers".

Rob.
Title: Re: Identify my new box for me?
Post by: Steve C. on February 24, 2011, 05:14:31 AM
Button Box has a Welt Cajun in D for $US 850, but maybe worth it, it will likely be tuned and ready to play.
Title: Re: Identify my new box for me?
Post by: Steve_freereeder on February 24, 2011, 10:11:15 AM
The Welsh four-stop is the Wesson Clipper, made by Rees Wesson.  Made to order only.  Contact details on this website under "Makers".
And superb boxes they are too.  (:)
Title: Re: Identify my new box for me?
Post by: tip184 on February 25, 2011, 01:39:21 PM
UPDATE-

The world is not all bad.  Seller agreed to a refund of the purchase price on the old unplayable ("plays great") Hohner.  I eat the shipping charges both ways - that's OK with me. 

Now - do I simply continue with the Ariette, telling myself that it's good enough for my limited skills, or do I  save up for a Hohner HA 114, a Weltmeister, or a US-made Cajun - or maybe the Roland FR-18 (except I would hate to need an amp and speakers every time I want to play)?

Thanks for all of the good advice that you all have provided.

-tip184
Title: Re: Identify my new box for me?
Post by: mglamb on February 25, 2011, 01:52:31 PM
Well, that's certainly a good outcome for you!  I'd keep an eye on Ebay for a nice used 114 - I got a lightly used model in D last year for around $430.00 with almost no visible wear and the bellows nicely broken in.  A new Hohner or Weltmeister will cost you near double that, a Castagnari or custom Cajun considerably more.  Good luck!
Title: Re: Identify my new box for me?
Post by: Steve C. on February 25, 2011, 01:58:54 PM
Tip--

1. Sit tight. You maybe don't yet know what you want.  When you propose a Cajun one row and an FR18 in the same sentence, indicates "early melodeon acquisition confusion syndrome". It is controllable but not curable.
2, You have a decent playable box.  Learn on it, unless it won't play the type of music you are primarily interested in.
3. What box do players on YouTube use, the player who play the music you like?

You probably have seen on this forum that almost all have more than one box.

Opinion: best overall learning box, plays all kinds of music, would be a 2 row in DG or GC.
Title: Re: Identify my new box for me?
Post by: kdhoffman on February 25, 2011, 02:27:35 PM
All very good advice.
Title: Re: Identify my new box for me?
Post by: HallelujahAl on February 25, 2011, 02:44:44 PM
Quote
3. What box do players on YouTube use, the player who play the music you like?
I think that this is the best advice - who are you listening to or watching that is the biggest influence on your box playing? What are they playing? It may give you a pointer as which way to proceed.
AL
Title: Re: Identify my new box for me?
Post by: tip184 on February 25, 2011, 03:08:31 PM
My playing style (and musical tastes):

I started learning "Cajun" accordion a few years ago.  A colleague who played Cajun had died a few years earlier (he had a very nice Jr. Martin box).  He was, like me, a neuroscience professor, and I realized that the class of graduating seniors at the time had never known him.  For reasons still unknown to me I decided to honor his memory by learning the Cajun box - a very unusual instrument in Michigan.  In fact, until last spring I was the 8th best Cajun accordion player in MI, then I learned that there was another player, so I dropped to 9  ;).  In any case, I have no particular interest in Cajun music - mostly I like the challenge of the 1-row - I think of it as my anti-Alzheimer's therapy.  What I tend to play (or try to play) are songs that I know well, so that I can work them out by ear.  My inclination is to stick with the 1-row (I mentioned the FR-18 because it would eliminate the problem that my wife routinely points out - limited key with my Ariette).

Thanks again for all of the advice.  I will continue to lurk on the forum so that I can learn.

- tip184
Title: Re: Identify my new box for me?
Post by: Bananayogi on February 25, 2011, 03:41:15 PM
Glad you got a refund on the Hohner.

If you don't particularly want to play Cajun music, then don't get a Cajun box. Although they look exactly the same as any other one row, the tuning is (or should be) specifically set up for playing Cajun style music. I'll leave it to others to explain the technicalities (if you are interested), but suffice to say that other types of music will sound a bit bizzare and possibly even a bit out-of-tune on a Cajun tuned box.

I'd still say that a decent 114 (or 112) would be best if you actually want a one row instrument. If however you simply want to play 'one-row style' you might want to consider a decent Hohner Pokerwork or Erica. These are two row instruments, effectively two one row instruments in one case - allowing you to just play on one row or the other if you want, or to play in a smoother (more 'continental'?) style using buttons from both rows if you decide in future that's the way you want to go. You will be able to play in more than just the two home keys of the instrument by doing this (which might please your wife).

Despite having a Midi melodeon myself (a Streb not a Roland), I would advise a traditional accoustic instrument to start with.

Depending on your budget (and location) I'd maybe suggest putting a 'Wanted' ad on the Buy and Sell part of this very forum. You can always sell the Ariette on Ebay  >:E
Title: Re: Identify my new box for me?
Post by: Martin J on February 25, 2011, 04:11:11 PM
I echo everyone's sentiment about quality.  A good instrument will draw you on.  As you like single row but are mindful of different keys, this clip (http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=lOef8pOVLO0) may inspire you to a single row with helpers.  This particular box looks very expensive but some of the Italian Organetto's are excellent value and can be tunes just like this.
Title: Re: Identify my new box for me?
Post by: tip184 on February 25, 2011, 06:55:43 PM
OK - I'm feeling brave (or foolish).  Here's a link to my web page where I have posted some of my attempts at playing the Ariette.  Links in the paragraph next to the photo of my three boxes are the relevant ones.

http://campus.albion.edu/wjwilson/about/ (http://campus.albion.edu/wjwilson/about/)

Please keep in mind that I am entirely self-taught.  No lessons, no local partners-in-crime to play with - just me and the occasional web-based tutorial.  Be kind.
Title: Re: Identify my new box for me?
Post by: blafleur on February 26, 2011, 03:58:27 PM
I remodeled an old Hohner like this for a friend (one row with same marking and trim), ended up being a nice instrument to play with a nice tone.  The treble reeds sound good but very low volume.  The base side reeds were much louder in comparison. The fact the leathers are missing isn't too big a deal, surely they were needing replacing, along with the new wax. 
SimplePortal 2.3.5 © 2008-2012, SimplePortal