Melodeon.net Forums
Discussions => General Discussion => Topic started by: Martin J on February 17, 2011, 02:18:01 PM
-
I'm not really one to mind what other people do but when someone abuses that which others hold dear I think they are taking liberties. We have a subscriber who has continually used our forum as a sales platform. Checking the history of his 37 posts only three have been about anything on the forum the rest have been selling his product. Whilst I appreciate we like to know about new things where do we draw the line ?
It may be me, am I being a grumpy ?
-
I'm not really one to mind what other people do but when someone abuses that which others hold dear I think they are taking liberties. We have a subscriber who has continually used our forum as a sales platform. Checking the history of his 37 posts only three have been about anything on the forum the rest have been selling his product. Whilst I appreciate we like to know about new things where do we draw the line ?
It may be me, am I being a grumpy ?
Ah, *that's* who you mean! :D (took me a while to figure it out) Personally, I find his products fascinating and likely to be of interest to the melodeon playing community. I'd much rather be told of melodeon related products than not, and that also applies to instruments for sale and recordings. I have no problem with this whatsoever.
Cheers.
Clive
-
PS: If people have concerns about postings, please report them rather than discussing in the forum; that way the madness of mudcat lies (anyone been following the Mumford thread there? Sheesh....)
-
(anyone been following the Mumford thread there? Sheesh....)
yep. despite trying to resist I did post a reply...probably be ignored though. Usually am coz my posts are reasoned and sensible rather than just 'catty'. ;)
-
(anyone been following the Mumford thread there? Sheesh....)
yep. despite trying to resist I did post a reply...probably be ignored though. Usually am coz my posts are reasoned and sensible rather than just 'catty'. ;)
I think you replied to the tame thread! :o There's another one, locked a day or two ago... It gets really quite nasty.
-
(anyone been following the Mumford thread there? Sheesh....)
yep. despite trying to resist I did post a reply...probably be ignored though. Usually am coz my posts are reasoned and sensible rather than just 'catty'. ;)
I think you replied to the tame thread! :o There's another one, locked a day or two ago... It gets really quite nasty.
That's the tame one??? The other one must have been really bad to get locked.
-
(anyone been following the Mumford thread there? Sheesh....)
yep. despite trying to resist I did post a reply...probably be ignored though. Usually am coz my posts are reasoned and sensible rather than just 'catty'. ;)
I think you replied to the tame thread! :o There's another one, locked a day or two ago... It gets really quite nasty.
Meanies! share and share alike = wot are the urls!? >:E
-
Sorry, you're going to need to look for it yourself! ;D
I think it's probably libellous, so I'm not going to link from here, nor quote it. (Not that I'd want to...)
Cheers,
Clive
-
It's easy enough to find by searching. And there are two threads...
I had a quick skim though the now-closed one, noting the usual suspects among the poster's names.
It was worth it for spotting this quote from Ralphie: "Speaking as a little person"...
(For anyone who hasn't met Ralph Jordan... he's about 7 feet tall.)
-
It was worth it for spotting this quote from Ralphie: "Speaking as a little person"...
(For anyone who hasn't met Ralph Jordan... he's about 7 feet tall.)
Met him at Cheltenham last year. Nice chap. Towered over me even when he was sitting down. lol
;) :P
It's easy enough to find by searching. And there are two threads...
I had a quick skim though the now-closed one, noting the usual suspects among the poster's names.
I think the phrase you don't have to be mad but it helps....applies to mudcat.
On the other hand I posted a question about albums featuring fiddlers and got some helpful answers. So they can't all unhinged. ;)
-
Ah, *that's* who you mean! :D (took me a while to figure it out) Personally, I find his products fascinating and likely to be of interest to the melodeon playing community. I'd much rather be told of melodeon related products than not, and that also applies to instruments for sale and recordings. I have no problem with this whatsoever.
Cheers.
Clive
I don't have a problem with it either. I've seen several examples of people who join and only post something for sale. As long as its items of interest to melodeon players then I think its quite ok.
It may be me, am I being a grumpy ?
On this occasion I'm inclined to agree. ;D
-
If you steer clear of controversial topics Mudcat is absolutely fine.
Also if you've had years on usenet newsgroups, Mudcat is as tame as a basketful of kittens.
---
As for original message on this thread - how can only 37 posts be a nuisance, especially when they are melodeon related and don't contain foul language or personal insults?
If he was ambushing every thread (even when off topic) with his adverts, I might feel a bit different. It took a while to work out who it was...
-
Funnily enough, I was immediately aware of who you meant. I think that in principle such behavior is not on, but in this case I think there is little harm in it.
-
I haven't got a clue who you're talking about - so it must have been at such a low level to be completely off my radar ;D
-
I haven't got a clue who you're talking about - so it must have been at such a low level to be completely off my radar ;D
Ditto, - you see, "Wee folk, good folk, trooping all together", such as HallelujahAL and self, we Hear No Evil See No Evil Speak No Evil --
now let me cut and paste in that mudcat phrase from Anahata! >:E >:E
-
I haven't got a clue who you're talking about - so it must have been at such a low level to be completely off my radar ;D
Ditto, - you see, "Wee folk, good folk, trooping all together", such as HallelujahAl and self, we Hear No Evil See No Evil Speak No Evil --
now let me cut and paste in that mudcat phrase from Anahata! >:E >:E
I give up.... latest mudcat messages i could find searching are April 2010! I suspect my ex-guardian archangel Lucifer is protecting me as usual and I still don't know who our boxwalah is!>:E
-
(anyone been following the Mumford thread there? Sheesh....)
yep. despite trying to resist I did post a reply...probably be ignored though. Usually am coz my posts are reasoned and sensible rather than just 'catty'. ;)
I'm beginning to get paranoid... ::) At least I don't think I was selling anything... :Ph
-
PS: If people have concerns about postings, please report them rather than discussing in the forum; that way the madness of mudcat lies (anyone been following the Mumford thread there? Sheesh....)
Thanks for the heads up. I had no idea about mudcat. It was my natural inclination to debate in public and on this occasion perhaps correct as the general gist is one of agreement, not about the posting being inappropriate but about me being a grumpy. :-[
-
Thanks for the heads up. I had no idea about mudcat. It was my natural inclination to debate in public and on this occasion perhaps correct as the general gist is one of agreement, not about the posting being inappropriate but about me being a grumpy. :-[
This public acclaim could lead to a whole new career (http://www.bbc.co.uk/programmes/b0071jtx) :o
-
I've watched this programme and find their views totally normal and can find nothing to take exception at with no sign of grumpiness, just common sense. >:E >:E
-
To get back to the original topic.....to me this forum is about sharing melodeon related information, this includes things about products, events, recordings and artists as well as the ins and outs of playing and other information. I'll personally be making a couple of posts about products and events in the next day or so and see it as part of the forum and being part of the melodeon community.... :-)
P.S...who is it that's got your dander up..name names ;-)
-
Look forward to your posts Liam. No names. no pack drill. I was wrong and I've apologised.
-
No worries :-) It's all part of being in the melodeon family.....
-
I like the notion that being wrong is a fundamental part of being a melodeonista:
"Sorry, I don't have that note, so I'll play a different one. No, I can't tune it. I like the the squeaks, clacks, and rattles".
-
'wrong....' and also utterly accommodating for the same reasons!
Well said that man!
Q
-
I'm pretty sure I know who you mean, and I think he's an asset to the group. I *am* interested in his products, though, so I might be biased. It's not like he's posting the same message every week. I love the fact that we have professionals involved with the instrument on this forum, and I don't mind that part of what they're doing is selling. I think if it were really getting tedious someone would tell him so.
-
Another ebay item I was interested in and placed a bid, has been advertised on here by a gentleman who looks like he joined just to sell the box..
http://forum.melodeon.net/index.php/topic,6207.0.html (http://forum.melodeon.net/index.php/topic,6207.0.html) since the ad appeared there has been a new bidder on ebay.....It will no doubt get last minute bids too...
Your comment may be premature. Now that Graham has found this forum, I hope we may benefit from his opinions on other topics, especially anything to do with BCC#.
-
The starting price had been sitting at £200 for a few days and I had put a bid in....five mins before the end of the sale another bidder suddenly appears - you can guess the rest - it sold at £300.77p - not to me though... >:(
You got sniped then?
Five minutes before the end of an auction is not sniping. 5-7 seconds before the end is more normal sniping. I've used Auction Sniper (http://www.auctionsniper.com) for several years without problem.
My initial concern was associated with the 'Misuse of melodeon.net' thread in that traders buying and selling boxes could perhaps use m.net to glean information about items that people were interested in on e.bay and use it to their advantage. I hadn't even heard of 'sniping'....Obviously a trader might also use the 'sniping' software to gain an advantage over people that don't use it. Not against the law of course, but perhaps not a level playing field either..
-
....Obviously a trader might also use the 'sniping' software to gain an advantage over people that don't use it. Not against the law of course, but perhaps not a level playing field either..
Not only a trader could do that, so could anyone else. You seem to have a bit of a down on traders. :(
I don't know how many times I need to re-state my original point - but it seems like at least once more....
My original point was really nothing to do with 'sniping' I had never heard of it......I was concerned about the thread of misuse of melodeon.net.
There were suggestions that traders were pushing sales on the forum, I pointed out that another possible use was gleaning information about members who were doing private sales of boxes and out-bidding people on ebay. Which to my mind isn't in the spirit of the informal, trusting, helpful world of melodeon.net.
A forum site like this should not really be used for commercial purposes as a FREE extention to a business's advertising budget, or a trading advantage at the expense of the members.
The thread I followed about 'misuse of melodeon.net' was moved by Clive when the subject altered/ hijacked to sniping....which I had a passing interest in because I had been outbidded in a strange way for a melodeon which I really fancied. I didn't start this thread....
-
"Which to my mind isn't in the spirit of the informal, trusting, helpful world of melodeon.net."
Agreed, 100%, and what I like so much about this place is its sense of community and mutual trust. But the fact is that, once your information is out there, well.....it's out there, and what's to prevent? Sad, perhaps, but a fact of the medium.
Bob
-
I had never heard of 'Justsnipe' but it goes some way to explaining how people manage to 'accidentally' acquire items that they didn't expect to get...as has been mentioned on melodeon.net.
Since I believe I am the only person to have talked about "'accidentally' acquire items" I am a bit put out about this. I don't use sniping software but will be looking into it as I keep missing interesting stuff.
As to your other views:
Misuse could work it two directions of course....dealers using this forum to promote items, but they also can get a handle on anything that might be about to be put on sale on ebay to their advantage.....
Obviously a trader might also use the 'sniping' software to gain an advantage over people that don't use it. Not against the law of course, but perhaps not a level playing field either..
This seems a little paranoid.
Re the original thread it was about a guy who wasn't even selling melodeons ;)
-
Since I believe I am the only person to have talked about "'accidentally' acquire items" I am a bit put out about this. I don't use sniping software but will be looking into it as I keep missing interesting stuff.
All getting a bit confused. I remember in a very recent thread a light hearted remark from Theo regarding the 'accidental' acquisition of boxes as a way of disguising a new purchase. This remark was in no way connected with sniping and you certainly weren't mentioned Lester. So, a case of mistaken identity and context. 8) ;)
-
I had never heard of 'Justsnipe' but it goes some way to explaining how people manage to 'accidentally' acquire items that they didn't expect to get...as has been mentioned on melodeon.net.
Since I believe I am the only person to have talked about "'accidentally' acquire items" I am a bit put out about this. I don't use sniping software but will be looking into it as I keep missing interesting stuff.
As to your other views:
Misuse could work it two directions of course....dealers using this forum to promote items, but they also can get a handle on anything that might be about to be put on sale on ebay to their advantage.....
Obviously a trader might also use the 'sniping' software to gain an advantage over people that don't use it. Not against the law of course, but perhaps not a level playing field either..
This seems a little paranoid.
Re the original thread it was about a guy who wasn't even selling melodeons ;)
I have been careful to use words like 'might' 'could' and 'possibly' in comments, plus I knew nothing of 'sniping' so I don't really think I'm paranoid - but I notice you don't pick up on the Free Advertising bit...
Again - really just commenting of the misuse of melodeon.net thread...but I do understand the temptation to premote peoples own business on here, I might have done it myself if I was selling/repairing boxes. ::)
-
I don't know how many times I need to re-state my original point - but it seems like at least once more....
My original point was really nothing to do with 'sniping' I had never heard of it......I was concerned about the thread of misuse of melodeon.net.
There were suggestions that traders were pushing sales on the forum, I pointed out that another possible use was gleaning information about members who were doing private sales of boxes and out-bidding people on ebay. Which to my mind isn't in the spirit of the informal, trusting, helpful world of melodeon.net.
A forum site like this should not really be used for commercial purposes as a FREE extention to a business's advertising budget, or a trading advantage at the expense of the members.
Alan, if you have information about something underhand going on please let's have it out in the open. But pointing out that traders might be using information here in order to gain advantage in some way without there being some actual evidence or even suspicion just seems to be creating an unpleasant feeling based on not very much. All sorts of things are possible that doesn't mean they are happening.
As you probably have gathered I make my living by repairing and buying and selling boxes, so I feel included in your category of 'trader' and feel that some of your comments might be aimed at me because I do advertise in the "buy and sell" forum, so in a way I am as you say using melnet "for commercial purposes as a FREE extention to a business's advertising budget". The same could be said of several other members here. Do you really believe that nobody who is a 'trader' should be using the forum to publicise the services they are offering?
So if you have evidence of underhand dealings then please let us know, either on the public forum, or if you prefer as a private communication, which had better go to Clive rather than me since I may be involved. If you have no evidence I would be grateful if you could make that clear also.
-
I don't know how many times I need to re-state my original point - but it seems like at least once more....
My original point was really nothing to do with 'sniping' I had never heard of it......I was concerned about the thread of misuse of melodeon.net.
There were suggestions that traders were pushing sales on the forum, I pointed out that another possible use was gleaning information about members who were doing private sales of boxes and out-bidding people on ebay. Which to my mind isn't in the spirit of the informal, trusting, helpful world of melodeon.net.
A forum site like this should not really be used for commercial purposes as a FREE extention to a business's advertising budget, or a trading advantage at the expense of the members.
Alan, if you have information about something underhand going on please let's have it out in the open. But pointing out that traders might be using information here in order to gain advantage in some way without there being some actual evidence or even suspicion just seems to be creating an unpleasant feeling based on not very much. All sorts of things are possible that doesn't mean they are happening.
Do you really believe that nobody who is a 'trader' should be using the forum to publicise the services they are offering?
Perhaps there should be a 'links' page for traders like yourself to publicise your business - but yet again I must say I'm just responding to the original thread about misuse of melodeon.net for advertising.
-
Perhaps there should be a 'links' page for traders like yourself to publicise your business - but yet again I must say I'm just responding to the original thread about misuse of melodeon.net for advertising.
What like THIS (http://forum.melodeon.net/index.php/page,shops_repairers.html)
-
Perhaps there should be a 'links' page for traders like yourself to publicise your business - but yet again I must say I'm just responding to the original thread about misuse of melodeon.net for advertising.
What like THIS (http://forum.melodeon.net/index.php/page,shops_repairers.html)
Yes Lester....excellent page....So why the original 'misuse of melodeon.net' thread, which was what I looked at in the first place,,,,
-
This thread (which I didnt start) is getting blown out of all proportions...so I'm locking it...
-
[[[ Sigh. All further rants and discussion of rants moved back into the original misuse thread, and kept resolutely locked. -- Clive ]]]