Melodeon.net Forums

Discussions => Instrument Design, Construction and Repair => Topic started by: Thrupenny Bit on February 17, 2011, 09:21:35 PM

Title: An 'English' Melodeon?
Post by: Thrupenny Bit on February 17, 2011, 09:21:35 PM
Hi All,
I've been trawling around the forum a bit and also had the odd conversations with friends who go on about 'English' melodeons.
It feels like there is a Grail Quest amongst some to establish something quintissentially English in sound, I think the nearest that it appears to have been reached is the now fabled Oakwood.
Though I've been around the scene for a long time, I've never really critically listened to melodeons for their accoustic characteristics before, (of course that has now changed!) so I'm not sure what people mean.
It seems to me most things squeezable from reeds up to complete boxes mainly eminate from Italy, and they sound ok to my somewhat untrained ears. Of course, I need to listen now with a more critical ear, to distinguish what different boxes sound like, rather than just listen to the tunes issuing forth!

But.... Is there such a thing as an 'English' sounding melodeon?
What defines it as such?

I hand it over to the floor for discussion.......
Q


Title: Re: An 'English' Melodeon?
Post by: Ollie on February 17, 2011, 09:43:45 PM
I think it's got much more to do with how you play it. Loffets, for example, are without a doubt a French melodeon, but they are getting quite popular on the English scene and this is undeniably English - http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=8w5VoJd7GPo&feature=related
Title: Re: An 'English' Melodeon?
Post by: Alan Morley on February 17, 2011, 09:47:43 PM
But.... Is there such a thing as an 'English' sounding melodeon?
What defines it as such?

I hand it over to the floor for discussion.......
Q

no - It's like saying is there an English sounding guitar.....or violin etc..

There might be an English style of playing..if you go back to Bob Cann and his Dartmoor style, or these days - John Kirkpatrick of course..
Derbyshire's - Tufty Swift was another great English box player..and Tony Hall of course..

However lot of people have absorbed the style of playing French tunes from the influence of popular players over the last ten years or so.

Even box players for morris side have taken to tunes which would have been played on pipe and drum or fiddle before melodeons came over here in the early 1900's.
Title: Re: An 'English' Melodeon?
Post by: george garside on February 17, 2011, 09:58:29 PM
[ But.... Is there such a thing as an 'English' sounding melodeon?
What defines it as such?

 Q



[/quote]

other than that its most likely to be tuned in D&G  I would say the answer is no!

george
Title: Re: An 'English' Melodeon?
Post by: Thrupenny Bit on February 17, 2011, 10:26:43 PM
Interesting.....
Thanks Ollie, hadn't caught up with those from DTN's repertoire. ( goes green with envy, as ever. Love watching DTN )

Almo - I think without doubt we have our own style, and seemingly absorbing other tunes and influences from France etc.  I'm more interested in the 'mechanics' of the instrument.

For instance.....why does the Music Room think it necessary to 'improve' a Dino baffetti?
Is it to tweak it to make it play/respond better, or are there more subtle things going on?
....not criticising in any way, simply interested.

With our strange desires to go outside and jump around  :M is it to get a penetrating sound ?

As George says, we start off with G/D as the common tuning here, whereas it seems most of Europe prefer other keys, and from previous threads I believe 'G/D' to be a relatively recent developement in melodeon making.
Did we instigate the G/D system because of our typical traditional tunes being in G/D or are our tunes in G/D *because* of the G/D melodeon?
Hmmmm that could be another thread!
Q
Title: Re: An 'English' Melodeon?
Post by: Theo on February 17, 2011, 10:31:52 PM
It's the name 'melodeon' for a two row box that is almost entirely English. Diatonic accordion is the more usual name in other cultures, though there are many other local names too.
Title: Re: An 'English' Melodeon?
Post by: Alan Morley on February 17, 2011, 10:46:22 PM
For instance.....why does the Music Room think it necessary to 'improve' a Dino baffetti?
Is it to tweak it to make it play/respond better, or are there more subtle things going on?
....not criticising in any way, simply interested.


The Music Room Dino Baffetti as I understand from their web page - has been improved by the guy resposible for Oakwood melodeons - an English manufacturer who used to make boxes that I'd kill for....

I had a go on an Oakwood box years ago in Scarborough, when they had a morris festival there - best box I have even played...I regret that I didn't buy one when I could have.

The Dino/Oakwood would be my choice over anything else if I had the money...http://www.themusicroom-online.co.uk/product_info.php?products_id=4165 (http://www.themusicroom-online.co.uk/product_info.php?products_id=4165)

Quote from Music Room page:

Most critically, it sports top of the range hand made Binci reeds, widely regarded as the best reeds available for melodeons (and indeed, Martyn's reeds of choice for his highly sought after Oakwood Melodeons - before you ask, he's got no plans to make any more Oakwood squeezboxes in the foreseeable future). Anyhow, these reeds are loud, bright and responsive to a greater degree than anything else you've ever heard.

Alan
Title: Re: An 'English' Melodeon?
Post by: Lester on February 17, 2011, 11:38:38 PM
I think that you cant beat a good old Hohner Pokerwork/Erica for English Morris/Ceilidh sound but that is probably because I like a good old Hohner Pokerwork/Erica for English Morris/Ceilidh.
Title: Re: An 'English' Melodeon?
Post by: Martin J on February 18, 2011, 12:24:30 AM
It seems that national tastes also change.  Irish tuned boxes used to be very wet, heavy musette tunings but latterly seem to be tuned much drier.  In English tradition I've heard every thing from a harsh Organetto to unison.  I don't think D/G Hohner's are tuned differently for the English market, wiser members may correct me but certainly a fairly recent acquisition in G/C was much dryer tuned.
Title: Re: An 'English' Melodeon?
Post by: EeeJay on February 18, 2011, 12:25:20 AM
Quote from Music Room page:

Most critically, it sports top of the range hand made Binci reeds, widely regarded as the best reeds available for melodeons (and indeed, Martyn's reeds of choice for his highly sought after Oakwood Melodeons...

From what I clearly recall, they were using Antonelli or Salpa reeds when I enquired about Oakwoods back in the late 90s. Indeed, Doug Briggs (http://www.briggsaccordions.com/) uses Antonelli (A Mano (hand-made) blue edge nostrino) reeds these days... and I doubt you could find a more English squeezebox (in spite of their primarily Irish ethos)...

Ed J
Title: Re: An 'English' Melodeon?
Post by: george garside on February 18, 2011, 12:32:37 AM
It seems that national tastes also change.  Irish tuned boxes used to be very wet, heavy musette tunings but latterly seem to be tuned much drier.  In English tradition I've heard every thing from a harsh Organetto to unison.  I don't think D/G Hohner's are tuned differently for the English market, wiser members may correct me but certainly a fairly recent acquisition in G/C was much dryer tuned.

by  irish tuned do you mean BC or    similar semitone tuned box.  Neither is really 'Irish Tuned'  as the BC is also Scottish tuned  so to speak  and of course there are those who playu 'Irish@ tunes very well on DG boxes.
Title: Re: An 'English' Melodeon?
Post by: Owen Woods on February 18, 2011, 02:02:42 AM
I dunno, I have certainly picked up boxes and thought "This would be good for Irish", "This would be good for Scottish", etc. It's to do with the response, the depth of sound, power, amount of tremelo, action, bellows compression, basically everything that you can think of! As it happens in my mind English music is some of the most demanding on the box, in terms of the variety of speed, dynamics, emphasis etc. My Bouebe is great in that it copes really well with Irish, Scottish and English music, although the bass isn't really quick enough for the latter, something that I will get looked at at some point.
Title: Re: An 'English' Melodeon?
Post by: Martin J on February 18, 2011, 08:27:02 AM
by  irish tuned do you mean BC or    similar semitone tuned box.  Neither is really 'Irish Tuned'  as the BC is also Scottish tuned  so to speak  and of course there are those who playu 'Irish@ tunes very well on DG boxes.
Hi George.  I wasn't referring to any particular box configuration, only toward the taste in tuning.  Organetto, French and some other Italian tunings all shared the heavy musette sound but I have noticed that many new Irish players are favouring a dryer sound.
Title: Re: An 'English' Melodeon?
Post by: Alan Morley on February 18, 2011, 08:34:38 AM
I dunno, I have certainly picked up boxes and thought "This would be good for Irish", "This would be good for Scottish",

Bert - you have hit the nail on the head....

It's all to do with what 'sound' you have in your head, and what you want a box to sound like - when they match you have found your own perfect box.
Then all you have to think about is the 'feel' of the box....is it right for your fingers, responds like you think it should etc......

Did all that when my ISIS snuggled close to me and said 'take me home....'
It also matched in with my style of playing - which was shaped by listening to three people - Dave Swarbrick (Fiddle), Derek Hale from Derby (Concertina) and John Kirkpatrick.

I go through the 'sound in my head' thing with guitar / amp combinations, changing guitar pickups etc until the sounds match.

All you have to worry about then is playing the damn thing......
Title: Re: An 'English' Melodeon?
Post by: Anahata on February 18, 2011, 12:40:10 PM
It's a moving target.
30 years ago I'd have said there's nothing more English than the sound of a D/G Hohner pokerwork, or a Hohner 1-row in C played in the appropriate style especially in Suffolk. In those days I was listening to players like John Kirkpatrick, Tony Hall, Bob Cann and Dan Quinn.
Since then there's been a whole new generation or two of English melodeon players players with posh Italian boxes. A different sound and a different way of playing English music - Andy Cutting, Tim Van Eyken etc. Those players have been prominent at a time when English music was rapidly becoming more mainstream and widely recognised.
We seem to be going back to Hohners though. I see Ed Rennie's playing an Erica instead of the Castagnari I used to see him with, the good old pokerwork is still popular and those pressed wood boxes seem to have suddenly popped up from nowhere...
Title: Re: An 'English' Melodeon?
Post by: Thrupenny Bit on February 18, 2011, 05:01:46 PM
Quote from Almo
" The Music Room Dino Baffetti as I understand from their web page - has been improved by the guy resposible for Oakwood melodeons - an English manufacturer who used to make boxes that I'd kill for...."
Exactly my point 'improved....' but Why the need to improve what they admit is a perfectly well built melodeon, and how?
All I can glean from the advert relates more to being a boy racer and modding an old car, somewhat frustrating if you actually want to learn about a product and live the other end of the country so can't pop in to take a look!

Back to the plot: I think Ukebert is touching on the nub of the question.
We play a selection of tunes with a huge variety of requirements. His current Boube is ok but he would prefer quicker basses. A tweak that would help him cope with the variation.
I in my so far limited knowledge would like a 4 button start with low notes before the accidentals to enable me to get down to G below middle C, and as others have said on a previous thread, this then allows us to play fiddle tunes that drop down to this area of the clef. From this previous thread I realise it's possible, with tuning, but a shame they don't come like this!

Friends have commented on the need for 'punchy bases' and I know they have veered towards Baffetti's/Oakwoods for this reason.

Anahata has made a good point about new generations bringing new ideas and repertoires to what was once know as 'standard', so indeed it is an ever changing or more precisely evolving beast to find. As each person will have their own individual requirements or preferences, this too will probably mean there is no communally agreed 'English' Box!
......but it's fun to discuss and think about it!
Title: Re: An 'English' Melodeon?
Post by: Alan Morley on February 18, 2011, 05:23:08 PM
Quote from Almo
" The Music Room Dino Baffetti as I understand from their web page - has been improved by the guy resposible for Oakwood melodeons - an English manufacturer who used to make boxes that I'd kill for...."
Exactly my point 'improved....' but Why the need to improve what they admit is a perfectly well built melodeon, and how?
All I can glean from the advert relates more to being a boy racer and modding an old car, somewhat frustrating if you actually want to learn about a product and live the other end of the country so can't pop in to take a look!

Having played and fell in love an Oakwood many years ago, I know what they are / were like - and they were everything that I'd personally want from a box.

On the other hand - I also played some Dino Baffetti 'Black Pearl' - and for me - I found the action too springy and felt vibrations through the buttons which I found off putting. The bass side was also too loud in my opinion, and not well balanced to the treble side - again just a personal preference.

I have also owned a Tommy and a Lilly which I sold due to lack of funds at one time....having played the newer ones recently - in my opinion they are not a patch on the ones they were making ten or so years ago. There is no way I'd fork out £3k for a Tommy that I personally don't like.

So if the Dino which is already a good box as you say, and has had the Oakwood treatment, and it's selling at £2000.00 I personally know which I'd go for - subject to actually playing one of course.
Title: Re: An 'English' Melodeon?
Post by: oggiesnr on February 18, 2011, 06:40:36 PM
Confession time ...

... on the trip to The Music Room which resulted in me buying a Loffett I played the Dino/Oakwood and I have to confess I hated it!  I play a Plack Pearl which I bought just after Mally started importing them and until I got a C/F Club from Sandy and this Loffett it was the only box I felt I needed.  Good solid all round box, bags of punch (especially in the bass) for morris, quick enough for Irish and loud enough to hear yourself play in a crowded session.

I really wanted to like the D/O and would have bought if I had but it left me cold.  It sounded just like lots of other Italian boxes which are used for playing Irish music at speed, it had lost it's all-roundness and distinctiveness.  Totally subjective I know but I couldn't see the point of paying the extra.  I felt hat it's target market was D/G players looking for a B/C substitute to play Irish music at breakneck speeds.  Sorry  :(

As far as an "English" box is concerned I also felt it was probably a beat up Pokerwork (a la Pete Coe back in the seventies)

Steve
Title: Re: An 'English' Melodeon?
Post by: Thrupenny Bit on February 18, 2011, 07:37:47 PM
Almo: I think I know what you mean. I went around sidmouth festival looking at all I could find. I tried a new Black Pearl. OK, I could barely put a tune together, but a new one felt wrong. Feel was all I could go on. It's newness put me off. It felt unresponsive, but I expect that was my primeval attempt at a tune plus bellows that were very stiff. I did get a Tommy, apparently an older one, it felt immediately responsive and I grabbed it. Our second choice was a red Black Pearl that was well played in, that was nice.

oggiesnr: an interesting confession, and thanks for your opinion.
I wonder if the continued love of Pokerwork is an inbuilt 'defualt setting' for many because that's what they learnt on?
Though I appreciate it ticks all the boxes for a lot of people.
Q
Title: Re: An 'English' Melodeon?
Post by: Anahata on February 18, 2011, 07:51:05 PM
I played a pokerwork until somebody in Hammersmith Morris complained they couldn't hear it over the traffic noise in Richmond-on-Thames one day. "Get an Oakwood!" were the exact words... of course I was already familiar with Ian Dedic's box.

I tried out a number of boxes at the Music Room's stall at Towersey that year, including a Dino which was probably a Black Pearl and which I quite liked, but nothing came close to the shock effect of an Oakwood when squeezed a little harder. I played a short sharp loud chord and two people standing 20-30 feet away jumped and turned to see where the noise was coming from, and I knew I had a winner.

Lots of people have said it's a nice sounding box too.
The Oakwood combines the fast action and reed response of good Italian boxes with the raw power needed to be heard when playing for morris. And the Dino Baffetti Binci is the nearest thing to my current box that money can buy, as mentioned elsethread.
Title: Re: An 'English' Melodeon?
Post by: JohnA on February 18, 2011, 08:00:41 PM
Sorry folks
I have sat on my hands, bit my tongue, persuaded myself I should not hijack a thread, not good forum etiquette etc., but Anahata's last post left me no choice.....
Almo - not £2,000 for a Dino/Oakwood, but........ http://forum.melodeon.net/index.php/topic,6132.0.html - and note the unsolicited praise from forum members!
Cheers      John
Title: Re: An 'English' Melodeon?
Post by: Thrupenny Bit on February 18, 2011, 08:31:57 PM
Hah!
John, don't feel it's a hijack, in fact your thread was one of the things that started my brain ticking (:)
They didn't have any I could try when I was at Sidders, so I have no personal direct comparison.

My only experiences are with a friend's Oakwoods. He's a sturdy lad, and plays with one strap ( I use 2 ) so the only way for me to play was to wrap it around me a couple of times and attack from the side!
Despite this somewhat contorted approach, after a quick  :|||: I started to see..... (:)
Q
Title: Re: An 'English' Melodeon?
Post by: EeeJay on February 18, 2011, 08:46:11 PM
I really wanted to like the D/O and would have bought if I had but it left me cold.  It sounded just like lots of other Italian boxes which are used for playing Irish music at speed, it had lost it's all-roundness and distinctiveness.  Totally subjective I know but I couldn't see the point of paying the extra.  I felt hat it's target market was D/G players looking for a B/C substitute to play Irish music at breakneck speeds.

Funnily enough... there's one on the cover of the Tim Edey 'Irish on a D/G' DVD! ;D

Speaking as someone who does a lot of Irish mileage on D/G (and semitone systems)... and with a tactile preference for closed keyboards/good thumb grooves... it 'don't float my boat' personally (and yes, I've tried one). But they seem to be selling enough of 'em, so hey ho... chacun à son goût...

Hohner Erika/Club 2 is my ideal English machine - reworked as D/G with a 4th start and a good fist full of accidentals... And it's just as much the player as the box...

I can usually beat most folks in a 'melodeon race' even if I'm playing a stereotypically 'slow' machine... >:E

Ed J
Title: Re: An 'English' Melodeon?
Post by: JohnA on February 18, 2011, 09:09:57 PM
"... And it's just as much the player as the box..."

Which is why Saul Rose can make an 18 bass Handry sound like a quintessentially English box! Not to mention DTN's fine playing of English tunes on a variety of boxes.

John

Title: Re: An 'English' Melodeon?
Post by: Thrupenny Bit on February 18, 2011, 10:17:54 PM
Yes of course it's the player. As ever a good player can make a nice sound out of most things. A bad workman blames his tools and all that.
Funnily enough tonight I watched DTN and friend rip up the tip top polka/hp's on their Dnoy's. I'ts one of my favourite vids, watching two extremely competant players tear the tunes apart with so much verve..... on two nice Italian boxes. I sit mesmerised.
Have never seen Saul Rose play, but  think he's part of Random who are playing our ceilidh tomorrow, so will take a pencil and paper  ;)

'A re-worked Erika/club ... ' - again it's tweaking a standard box.

At what point does tweaking become a 'standard tweak'? at which point then you can argue that if there's a lot of players requiring the standard tweak then it should have been built like it in he first place.

Anahata, I would agree you have a lovely sounding melodeon. What comes over when playing on a Youtube vid is that it has a strong 'all round' sound with a feeling that yes, it can go up a notch should you want it to.
Q
Title: Re: An 'English' Melodeon?
Post by: Alan Morley on February 18, 2011, 10:37:48 PM
"... And it's just as much the player as the box..."

Which is why Saul Rose can make an 18 bass Handry sound like a quintessentially English box! Not to mention DTN's fine playing of English tunes on a variety of boxes.

John

It depends what you mean by English - I think of English as  Bob Cann/ John Kirkpatrick/ Tufty Swift style - Saul Rose is Saul Rose style which is OK too but not English.
Title: Re: An 'English' Melodeon?
Post by: Alan Morley on February 18, 2011, 10:40:31 PM
Sorry folks
I have sat on my hands, bit my tongue, persuaded myself I should not hijack a thread, not good forum etiquette etc., but Anahata's last post left me no choice.....
Almo - not £2,000 for a Dino/Oakwood, but........ http://forum.melodeon.net/index.php/topic,6132.0.html - and note the unsolicited praise from forum members!
Cheers      John

John - I wish I had £1400 to spare

Alan
Title: Re: An 'English' Melodeon?
Post by: EeeJay on February 18, 2011, 10:51:04 PM
At what point does tweaking become a 'standard tweak'? at which point then you can argue that if there's a lot of players requiring the standard tweak then it should have been built like it in he first place.

Good point. I personally like a D/G box to match/mirror the fiddle range if possible. Hence 4th start - gives room to take it down to a low G.

Seeing as the Hohner Pokerwork 'factory default' came from a direct transposition of the C/F rig - and not related to fiddles whatsoever - tweaks are needed...

IMHO, even an otherwise standard D/G pokerwork benefits somewhat from the low D on the G row being switched to a low B.

Ed J
Title: Re: An 'English' Melodeon?
Post by: **DTN** on February 18, 2011, 11:25:44 PM
Quote

It depends what you mean by English - I think of English as  Bob Cann/ John Kirkpatrick/ Tufty Swift style - Saul Rose is Saul Rose style which is OK too but not English.

now we disagree!!  >:E >:E >:E

Cut Saul in half ... it says English on the inside!   (modern English!)
Title: Re: An 'English' Melodeon?
Post by: Alan Morley on February 19, 2011, 07:03:06 AM
Quote

It depends what you mean by English - I think of English as  Bob Cann/ John Kirkpatrick/ Tufty Swift style - Saul Rose is Saul Rose style which is OK too but not English.

now we disagree!!  >:E >:E >:E

Cut Saul in half ... it says English on the inside!   (modern English!)

'ello Derek - I'd agree with 'modern English' - styles change as there has been more access to other types of music.

When I was a lad, there were only 78 rpm records and the wireless to listen to, and that's if you were rich enough to buy them. We had to make our own entertainment with cardboard squeezeboxes with shirt buttons stuck on and sing the tunes. We had some grand days in that workhouse....  ;)
Title: Re: An 'English' Melodeon?
Post by: Steve_freereeder on February 19, 2011, 08:00:04 AM
When I was a lad, there were only 78 rpm records and the wireless to listen to, and that's if you were rich enough to buy them. We had to make our own entertainment with cardboard squeezeboxes with shirt buttons stuck on and sing the tunes. We had some grand days in that workhouse....  ;)
Dun't tha meean 'When ah were a lad'?  (Old English) ;)
Title: Re: An 'English' Melodeon?
Post by: Theo on February 19, 2011, 09:14:30 AM
I played a short sharp loud chord and two people standing 20-30 feet away jumped and turned to see where the noise was coming from, and I knew I had a winner.

I suppose it depends where and what you play, but unfortunately I've been in a good number of sessions where rendered less enjoyable by player with the type of box that could make that much noise.  If they learned to play at less than full volume that would be great, but sadly some don't.   It's not just melodeons,  I've heard the same effect from piano accordions and (usually Jeffries) concertinas.   So if you need a loud box for playing unamplified out of doors please remember that playing indoors in a session needs a different technique. 

Moan over.

Back to the original question.

I don't think there is such a thing as typical melodeon for English style.  English music is pretty diverse,  Northumbrian, East Anglian, Devon for example all have styles that are considerably different, but are all English.  If you narrow it down to Morris though I'd agree that you can define a "Morris box"  by the demands of the genre, as something light, and capable of being played with a lot of dynamics.  Oakwood, Baffeti/Bincl, Baffeti Black Pearl,and Hohners Pokerwork and Preciosa all fit this bill.
Title: Re: An 'English' Melodeon?
Post by: Alan Morley on February 19, 2011, 09:41:39 AM
TUFY SWIFT

With this thread setting me off remembering Tufty Swift, I realised that I hadn't actually got any recordings of him.

A quick look on Amazon and I saw his How To Make a Bakewell Tart LP was out on CD and re-mastered too. The bonus was that the CD also has the album Hammer and Tounges by Sue Harris included.

Ordered that and also Plain Capers - John Kirkpatrick etc.....ordered  on Thursday - received them Saturday morning 9-25....fantastic.

Now I can learn a few tunes that I'd forgotten....

Title: Re: An 'English' Melodeon?
Post by: george garside on February 19, 2011, 09:47:36 AM
I played a short sharp loud chord and two people standing 20-30 feet away jumped and turned to see where the noise was coming from, and I knew I had a winner.

  noise.  If they learned to play at less than full volume that would be great, but sadly some don't.  

Moan over.


If only they would play most of a tune at about half their particular boxes maximum volume  they would have instant access to the wonderful world of dynamics

george
Title: Re: An 'English' Melodeon?
Post by: Thrupenny Bit on February 19, 2011, 10:23:07 AM
It appears there are two disctinct uses for the melodeon, playing for morris and playing 'music' whether sessions, bands, floor spots etc.
I agree with Theo about loud instruments, on occasions having had my ears de-waxed by overly loud instruments, anglo's in particular can be piercing in the wrong hands. ::)
With most people not in the throes of MAD, the instrument has to be a jack of all trades, loud for morris ( if required ) and then taken inside after for a session, all on the same box. As said, the player then has to realise they're *not* playing for the morris any more and consequently reduce volume!
It looks like there's a sub species emerging that can allow the diversity of our current repertoire, covering tunes from uk and France, and allowing the players to be more complex in their playing ( more basses, larger keyboards etc ), maybe heavier and possibly not quite so loud. These might not be so useful for carrying around on all day morris tours, shrugging off rain sleet and snow and who's volume can kill at 40 paces ;D

Can't comment on the rights and wrongs of speech beyond Bristol, as tis all Up Country for me , where be Dragons ;)

DTN: Would prefer not to injure anyone simply to make a point.
* No players have been harmed whilst making this thread *
 ;D
Title: Re: An 'English' Melodeon?
Post by: Theo on February 19, 2011, 10:28:32 AM

With most people not in the throes of MAD, the instrument has to be a jack of all trades, loud for morris ( if required ) and then taken inside after for a session, all on the same box. As said, the player then has to realise they're *not* playing for the morris any more and consequently reduce volume!


Yes that's it exactly.  It is not the instruments fault for being too loud, it's the player!  It's akin to a 17 year old passing a driving test and then getting in to a Porsche.  There may be tears.  Fortunately, the worst consequence of the over enthusiastic box players works is some temporary deafness.
Title: Re: An 'English' Melodeon?
Post by: george garside on February 19, 2011, 10:52:51 AM
Speaking as a (mainly north west) morris musician I would ask the question ? is it really necessary to always play loud and 'dynamicless' for morris  (the bear hug syndome).  Those sides fortunate enough to have several musicians will have more than enough volume at half throttle so to speak & even when being the only tune player with eg drum & guitar I stayed around mid volume most of the time with no complaints from dancers or spectators.  Morris sides can dance to a single whistle, fiddle or whatever , none of which have anything like the volume of a melodeon.  It can also be argued that the dancers dance to the drum & the 'tune' is there to help keep the interest of the bystanders  - they will stay to watch & listen for longer if the tunes are nicely played and if they stay longer theres a chance of more money in the tin!

george :||: :|bl
Title: Re: An 'English' Melodeon?
Post by: Martin J on February 19, 2011, 10:55:45 AM
Try this solution.  Sit a mandolin player to the right of the box player and ask the box player to listen to the intricate counter melody being played.  >:E >:E
Title: Re: An 'English' Melodeon?
Post by: Anahata on February 19, 2011, 11:06:11 AM
If anyone has specific complaints about me playing too loud in a session anywhere, would you please let me know, preferably by PM. My Oakwood is not the best box for playing really quietly, but I do have some control over it. (Well, I thought I did...  :|bl )

Point taken, though, about loud instruments in sessions generally. Just like fast cars, they do need to be in capable hands.

Try this solution.  Sit a mandolin player to the right of the box player and ask the box player to listen to the intricate counter melody being played.  >:E >:E

Listen being the keyword, mandolins or none. Judge a musician by how they use their ears, not their fingers.
Title: Re: An 'English' Melodeon?
Post by: Chris Ryall on February 19, 2011, 11:17:25 AM
Listen being the keyword, mandolins or none. Judge a musician by how they use their ears, not their fingers.

So true!

Back on topic - I have a strong feel that Hohner pokerwork or Erica with their loud, wet tuning are very fundamental to an English sound.  Fingering - generally row based, with fairly limited cross rowing. Essentially rhythmic and carried by the bellows on left end chords. 

I was surprised to discover that our French neighbours regard this to be as challenging as we commonly might find the cross row technique generally taught over there.   Makes me wonder if much of the English style might have developed from our penchant for one row melodeons in the first half of the last century?
Title: Re: An 'English' Melodeon?
Post by: Bob Ellis on February 19, 2011, 11:20:34 AM
As regards how loud one should play, it seems to me that it is all about adjusting to the circumstances and situation in which one is playing. For Morris, I tend to play louder at an outdoor venue than at one that is indoors and louder again if there are two sets dancing so that the set further from the musicians can hear the music clearly (if they can't hear it clearly they tend to 'race' the musicians, especially in stick dances). In sessions, my rule of thumb is to play just loud enough to be able to hear my own playing except when I have started (and am therefore 'leading') the tune, in which case I play louder.
Title: Re: An 'English' Melodeon?
Post by: Thrupenny Bit on February 19, 2011, 01:03:56 PM
I think the idea put forward by No strings attached is wonderful, exactly right.
We sometimes build our often used finishing ( morris ) dance from the tune starting with a single oboe......
Other band members have to listen, it gives the audience variation to a wall of sound, and implies something different is happening. The rest of the band come in bit by bit and build up the music, and as a dancer, the hairs on your neck can stand on end when it's a special occasion.

Sadly some people have no personal awareness - as demonstrated by a melodeon player who tagged onto the end of our morris band's finale 'mass dance for audience' at the opening Sidmouth thursday last year. She placed herself next to my daughter who was too polite to say 'please don't' then played her version of the tune too fast and drowned out my daughter and other players near. As I danced I could see players wincing as they battled to hold the tune. Young though my daughter is, she was forthright to me later!

Chris - I have no experience of playing across the channel, so find your points interesting. Perhaps our style *is* evolving to cope with tunes now being played originating from other places, and other melodeons with more complex keyboards coming in to accommodate these other new tunes.

It's reassuring to thing we are evolving because nature shows that evolutionary backwaters end up in the ground as fossils!
Title: Re: An 'English' Melodeon?
Post by: Thrupenny Bit on February 19, 2011, 01:06:15 PM
Yes Bob, i agree ( was posting whilst your comment came in )
As mentioned, I'm afraid some players don't realise you can adjust to suit!
Title: Re: An 'English' Melodeon?
Post by: Chris Ryall on February 19, 2011, 01:37:34 PM
Chris - I have no experience of playing across the channel, so find your points interesting. Perhaps our style *is* evolving to cope with tunes now being played originating from other places, and other melodeons with more complex keyboards coming in to accommodate these other new tunes.

I'd blame Dave Roberts, and Roger Watson - but there are other early culprits
Title: Re: An 'English' Melodeon?
Post by: Steve C. on February 19, 2011, 01:52:48 PM
Ah, Plain Capers, the disc that got me started....

After hearing the Dartington Morris at Fox Hollow, in I think 1976?, started looking for records to learn from, and there were not a lot.

First tune learned:  Wheatly Processional.

Thanks for the memory.
Title: Re: An 'English' Melodeon?
Post by: Theo on February 19, 2011, 02:02:53 PM
I'd blame Dave Roberts, and Roger Watson - but there are other early culprits

Ah, Plain Capers, the disc that got me started....


Interesting how quickly the innovators in a traditional form become the tradition.

In another generation who will be the people who are the new tradition?
Title: Re: An 'English' Melodeon?
Post by: Owen Woods on February 19, 2011, 02:10:59 PM
Interesting how quickly the innovators in a traditional form become the tradition.

In another generation who will be the people who are the new tradition?

Spiers and Boden I expect ;D
Title: Re: An 'English' Melodeon?
Post by: oggiesnr on February 19, 2011, 02:26:14 PM
I wonder if we're now getting a hybrid way of playing with the addition of some cross-rowing and also more "diddly" bits as per Irish music?

I note from other threads dotted about that a lot of us play other, non-reed, instruments as well and I know that I find techniques etc from them creeping into my box playing.

Steve
Title: Re: An 'English' Melodeon?
Post by: Thrupenny Bit on February 19, 2011, 02:30:27 PM
Another thought has occurred:
If there are two distinct types emerging, older style traditional types playing strictly English tunes using Pokerworks/Erics and those more modern  in apporach playing more adventurous tunes from further afield on boxes more accommodating for these.......
The in evolutionary terms, you are splitting the gene pool and two distinct species will emerge just as our species did.

Therefore......
New players seeking tunes from all over and playing boxes to cope with them = Modern Man
Players more engrossed in English tunes on Hohners = Neand.......  >:E
Oppps  ;D
Title: Re: An 'English' Melodeon?
Post by: Thrupenny Bit on February 19, 2011, 02:36:10 PM
Yes oggie, I think you are right.
W'ere coming to it from lots of different angles, and from previous experience of other music.
Also we have been playing english music since the early revival days of Old Swan et al. I remember John Jones of Oyster probably in the early 80's saying we had to learn how to play it again after it almost became extinct bar a few oldies ( East Anglian/ Dartmoor chaps ) keeping it going.
Maybe in the intervening years we have learnt and are now moving on to pastures new, discovering what it's all about in musical terms.
Bit like Modern Man coming out of Africa.
See??? Evolution is hapening all around.

 :Ph Too much profound thoughts
Tea!
Q
Title: Re: An 'English' Melodeon?
Post by: Rob2Hook on February 19, 2011, 03:06:11 PM
I see Ed Rennie's playing an Erica instead of the Castagnari I used to see him with...

I believe Ed's posh box was a Pastourelle II.  When not playing gigs, the Erica would come out - and anyway his favourite four-stop is a Hohner.

Rob.
Title: Re: An 'English' Melodeon?
Post by: Tufty on February 19, 2011, 04:24:20 PM
I started on melodeon in 1978 and played a lot until around 1990. At that point I dropped out of the folk scene for the best part of 20 years, just playing a bit for my own amusement at home. When I came back to it a couple of years ago I noticed a huge difference in the boxes being played and was struck by the technical facility of many younger players. However I do have some concerns that we could throw out the baby with the bathwater. Back in the 70s "folk music" mainly meant Irish music, often  using BC boxes to produce very fast, technically advanced music that left me cold. What attracted me was the more basic, raw sound of Oak and the traditional players who inspired them. These days I am trying to develop my playing to use some of the cross row techniques but I would not like to see cross row become the only "correct" style. We might take warning from what happened in Ireland when the music establishment promoted the BC accordeon so that the country was full of technically proficient but almost indistinguishable players. I hope we never never get so enamoured of technical skill that we lose sight what attracted most us to the instrument originally. Oh an English melodeon - for me probably a pokerwork or Erica but I'm sure its mostly just what I learnt on.
Title: Re: An 'English' Melodeon?
Post by: Chris Ryall on February 19, 2011, 04:27:24 PM
(http://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/thumb/c/cd/Homo_erectus.jpg/200px-Homo_erectus.jpg) (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Homo_erectus)
  click image for Eric's real name
   
Presumably

 homo Erica

  was his good lady?  :|glug
Title: Re: An 'English' Melodeon?
Post by: Thrupenny Bit on February 19, 2011, 04:44:12 PM
Tufty - I share a similar  'sabatical' due to house renovation, family coming along etc. and most importantly, no local pubs to play in, or more precisely no one to play with. Yes, it seems like a different world at times, though in my locallity it was/still is firmly english.
I would add to your observations the flow of good tunes and tune books emerging, and things like this forum. All add up to a brave new world of english music, and some brilliant youngsters coming through. The new vibrancy is quite breath taking I feel.
Given the huge variety of melodeons that people own on here, and the diverse style, I'm not sure it will get pigeon holed quite so easily.
As to which direction it'll eventually go.....who knows, but at least it's going somewhere.

Chris:  ;D
I feel he's looking a tad.....unwell? Undernourished especially ..... thank you sir for that one!

Ed keeps popping up. I work with his good lady wife, and I think he's aorund too.....will find out when school returns!
Title: Re: An 'English' Melodeon?
Post by: Graham Spencer on February 19, 2011, 08:58:59 PM
Another thought has occurred:
If there are two distinct types emerging, older style traditional types playing strictly English tunes using Pokerworks/Erics and those more modern  in apporach playing more adventurous tunes from further afield on boxes more accommodating for these.......
The in evolutionary terms, you are splitting the gene pool and two distinct species will emerge just as our species did.


Personally, I have been playing a substantially (about 95%) English repertoire for well over 20 years, and I've never owned a Pokerwork. OK, my first 2 boxes were Ericas, but still.........

I bought my Pastourelle II in 1991, and it's been my main instrument ever since - indeed my only one for many years. I hugely enjoy my Hohner 4-stop 1-rows, but my real workhorse is the Saltarelle. Yes, it's been tweaked a bit and the keyboard layout is different from the way it was when new, but it's the box on which I play in my (I hope!) English style.


Graham
Title: Re: An 'English' Melodeon?
Post by: Martin J on February 20, 2011, 12:24:40 AM
I don't think I've ever considered cross rowing to be "English"  I learnt in some isolation but with a slight understanding of what was wanted from playing guitar.  It was natural to me to get the chords right first as that dictated which way the bellows were going.  After that I looked to see where the notes were.  I didn't particularly care which row they were on as long as I could get to them.  I learnt Irish tunes in the same way, always having the correct basses and was amazed to discovered later on that they played B/C boxes.  My way gave me easy flowing finger patterns, the B/C way seemed as difficult as standing on one leg in a hammock trying to play.  I guess it's what you get used to but I do like the left hand to be playing the best chords available from a limited palette.  After that the style is down to phrasing, interpretation and decorations.  It's quite possible to play the same tune in any number of 'regional accents'

So, on topic, I think it is the delivery more than anything else that makes it English or otherwise helped by the idiosyncratic nature of certain types of melodeon.
Title: Re: An 'English' Melodeon?
Post by: Chris Ryall on February 20, 2011, 11:01:24 AM
Importantly - English style play is something we should 'celebrate'
Title: Re: An 'English' Melodeon?
Post by: Thrupenny Bit on February 20, 2011, 11:19:38 AM
N.S.A.: I also agree with your comments on cross rowing, I just want to get the notes where easiest too, whilst enabling an appropriate chord. I suppose too, at the back of my mind I want to develope a smoother style as opposed to some styles that seem to flap bellows so much it is heard above the melody. Bit of an exageration, but I hope you know what I mean.

I heard Saul Rose play last night for the first time, with the band Random. I think there was only a couple of tunes I recognised, so had an evening of totally new-to-me tunes. They fitted some standard dances to lovely tunes, very danceable, and not rammed down my throat at max volume. He had a massive 3 row Castagnari hanging on one strap, an occasional 1 row and...yes, a Pokerwork came out at least once! It was a brilliant night, lovely playing, new tunes ...... so there's someone who I suppose we could put in the new wave of people seeking out new ways.

But I need more tea..... as ever, Chris hits the nail on the head

 ' Importantly - English style play is something we should 'celebrate' .....'
Agreed.
More tea Vicar?
Q
 
Title: Re: An 'English' Melodeon?
Post by: Martin J on February 20, 2011, 11:23:49 AM
Importantly - English style play is something we should 'celebrate'
Here, here.  Not just celebrate though, actively promote.  The popularity of traditional Irish music is not an accident it was brought about by Irish government intervention as the genre had almost been lost.

3d, I think most of us who play out take several boxes and use them for their different qualities.  Maybe we should make more announcements to the general public whom we are often playing for.
Title: Re: An 'English' Melodeon?
Post by: Alan Morley on February 20, 2011, 12:25:03 PM
Importantly - English style play is something we should 'celebrate'
Here, here.  Not just celebrate though, actively promote.  The popularity of traditional Irish music is not an accident it was brought about by Irish government intervention as the genre had almost been lost.

3d, I think most of us who play out take several boxes and use them for their different qualities.  Maybe we should make more announcements to the general public whom we are often playing for.
It's sometimes/usually hard to get the general public interested in fine details of what you are doing - as they don't understand what we do as musicians..

A mate of mine is a guitar/vocalist and he's stopped performing 'clever' songs with loads of skill required - as the normal club/pub audience just want something to either sing along with or jump around to.

I sometimes despair when bands are judged to be 'brillient' because they jump about a lot, dress in silly outfits, and play loud and fast.....

Example : http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=rX-AA5t02eo (http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=rX-AA5t02eo)

 :'(
Title: Re: An 'English' Melodeon?
Post by: Thrupenny Bit on February 20, 2011, 12:40:42 PM
In answer to you both - The Irish have never lost the ability to listen and respect live music, whereas in England we have. As said, their government also ackowledged it's culture, whereas we deride it.
As pointed out by a friend who's knowledge of our folk history is encyclopaedic, we have always looked for new things.
Minstrels > Big Band > Jazz etc and the new trend replaced the previous, hence our loss of the traditional element. Also he cites the class struggle in the church ( long story ) but ends up with organs replacing the village bands, as shown in one of Hardy's novels.... so the bands disbanded and another nail in our traditional heritage. The end point being in the early 70's when it revived with only a few oldies keeping the tunes going. Gross generalisation, but you get the flow.

I feel it's all on the turn. A lot of teenages discovering all aspects of folk - music, morris etc, and almost starting up a cool movement of a new wave of culture. Last week's music awards ( can't remember which ) but 2 folkies took top awards instead of pop/rock artists. See previous threads about Bellowhead. Love 'em or hate 'em, they're getting our music into mainstream tv and it's all 'up' as far as I can see.
Maybe we're starting a new rennaisance.....
Blimey. Bit philosophical for a sunday!
...and more tea is required.
( slurpp)
Title: Re: An 'English' Melodeon?
Post by: Martin J on February 20, 2011, 01:09:49 PM
3d.  Your avatar places you in the days of old money so you may remember some of the following.  In the main I agree with your earlier post but I remember when a lot of the chart toppers were in fact folk or folk rock.  The Seekers, The New Seekers, The Carpenters, early Dusty Springfield.  Even some of the giant groups used folk songs.  Slade doing Dapple Rose, Genesis with Doctor Livingstone and many others.  Even things like Mathew and Son had a folk story element to them.

In Ireland they had a similar problem even earlier than we did which has been addressed, but, even today a Daniel O Donnell concert  :'( will pull far more audience than any folk production.
Title: Re: An 'English' Melodeon?
Post by: Steve C. on February 20, 2011, 02:05:59 PM
Don't forget to mention "Whiskey in the Jar".
Title: Re: An 'English' Melodeon?
Post by: Theo on February 20, 2011, 02:06:52 PM

I sometimes despair when bands are judged to be 'brillient' because they jump about a lot, dress in silly outfits, and play loud and fast.....


Especially when the hide the music under a totally inappropriate drum kit sound blanket which completely obliterates any attempt at rhythmic interest in the melody playing!
Title: Re: An 'English' Melodeon?
Post by: rileycat on February 20, 2011, 02:33:52 PM
Indeed, Theo, it is quite hard to think of a good "folk" drummer  (cue for further discussion!?).  The earlier posting with the link to Shamus O'blivion certainly does illustrate your point - leaden music totally missing the rhythmic joys of the rant. English music has many fine opportunities to be sensitive to dancers or singers needs and the melodeon is a great tool to extract those rhythms, even if volume in today's noisy environment is called for - it can be done, as we all know. It's also interesting that concertina.net is currently discussing how Irish music is "damaged" by the speed-at-all-costs approach to the music. On the other hand, perhaps age has dulled my receptiveness to the "excitement of speed" - it's certainly done that to my driving :D - so who am I to comment on what will keep the next generation turned onto the English tradition! Ho hum!
Title: Re: An 'English' Melodeon?
Post by: Thrupenny Bit on February 20, 2011, 02:38:46 PM
N.S.A. : Yes I remember decimalisation .....and remember those mentioned.
It must be decrepit brain cells that made me forget  ;)
....and 'Whisky in the Jar' I remember well, desperately trying to learn the chord shapes from a friend on guitar.
It took me ages to realise that strings were ok, but I wasn't  :D

ahhhh.....happy days.........

As typing another comment came up.
Being close to Oyster and Jonesy, I rember being saddened when they were 'told' a long while back they had to have a drummer for street cred.
 :(
Title: Re: An 'English' Melodeon?
Post by: IanD on February 20, 2011, 02:47:27 PM
Indeed, Theo, it is quite hard to think of a good "folk" drummer  (cue for further discussion!?). 

Rob Gifford (Gas Mark 5, Stomp, Committee Band). Fantastic feel for the music, when he was sound checking the drum kit we could usually tell which tune he was playing.

Not just for ceilidh dancing, listen to how he plays for the Smiffs at the Committee Band farewell dance -- completely different for all three dances (Moresque, Shooting, Sidestep) but fitting perfectly. And the band never even practised any of these with the team, they only ever got played live at occasional events like this.

Ian
Title: Re: An 'English' Melodeon?
Post by: Chris Ryall on February 20, 2011, 03:05:35 PM
I like the drums in Rantan Band!  Simon Booth was one, can't name the other


[edit] I could add that the bodrhan is not English!
Title: Re: An 'English' Melodeon?
Post by: Theo on February 20, 2011, 03:43:39 PM
Agreed, a great drummer is an asset to any band,  trouble is, a not very good drummer is in a position to do more damage than just about any other player!

Coming almost back on topic,  one of the features that for me defines the "Englishness" of some of the best English music, is playful approach to rhythm which puts the emphasis into all sorts of unexpected places, while at the same time maintaining the underlying heartbeat of the music.   Morris tunes seem to lend themselves particularly well to this. 
Title: Re: An 'English' Melodeon?
Post by: Thrupenny Bit on February 20, 2011, 04:02:32 PM
Ian: Yes absolutely, forgot about Rob. He's superb, and must have had a 'senior moment' forgetting him.
My original question was about melodeon design, though we seem to have ambled merrily and thoughtfully on occasions away from my original point.
What would you want in an ideal 'English' melodeon?
....though I think we've almost totally established there aint no such beast!
Maybe a better question is ' what would you build into the 'perfect' melodeon'?
( bear in mind I've chatted to Jerry!)
 
Chris: an old friend, a wonderful Irish fiddler, sometime box player and pipes too, firmly told me once that the Irish disowned it too!
Title: Re: An 'English' Melodeon?
Post by: IanD on February 20, 2011, 06:33:00 PM
Ian: Yes absolutely, forgot about Rob. He's superb, and must have had a 'senior moment' forgetting him.
My original question was about melodeon design, though we seem to have ambled merrily and thoughtfully on occasions away from my original point.
What would you want in an ideal 'English' melodeon?
....though I think we've almost totally established there aint no such beast!
Maybe a better question is ' what would you build into the 'perfect' melodeon'?
( bear in mind I've chatted to Jerry!)
 
Chris: an old friend, a wonderful Irish fiddler, sometime box player and pipes too, firmly told me once that the Irish disowned it too!


I used to think that my Oakwood Model 4 (23 button RH, low notes and accidentals) was the perfect English morris/band box.

Having being bitten by the Preciosa bug, I'd now say that the 25 button layout (2 rows + 4 accidentals) is better.

And much though I love it, I still think the Oakwood has a better sound, especially on the bass end. So I'd say the perfect box for me would be a 25 button Oakwood -- which of course is impossible.

Even better would be the 25 button box I worked out for Jerry using flat-mounted reeds (like the Preciosa, but all on one level) to get an even better sound than the Oakwood, but it doesn't look like this is going to be built now :-(

Ian
Title: Re: An 'English' Melodeon?
Post by: Martin J on February 20, 2011, 07:00:16 PM
I've used a Dony 26 button for nearly twenty years now and find it just spot on.  Brilliant for band and street work, have to he careful in sessions though.  I know you like it Ian.  I hadn't had in very long when I let you try at an 'Ale' in Portsmouth and had difficulty prising it back off you half an hour later.  Maybe a modified Benny might be good if you can't get an Oakwood.

Just lately I've been attracted to more mellow boxes but I still can't say that one box is more English than another.  Still going with the style and the player.
Title: Re: An 'English' Melodeon?
Post by: Anahata on February 20, 2011, 07:02:04 PM
I sometimes despair when bands are judged to be 'brillient' because they jump about a lot, dress in silly outfits, and play loud and fast.....

Example : http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=rX-AA5t02eo (http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=rX-AA5t02eo)

OMG they look and sound desperate
Title: Re: An 'English' Melodeon?
Post by: Alan Morley on February 20, 2011, 07:11:36 PM
I sometimes despair when bands are judged to be 'brillient' because they jump about a lot, dress in silly outfits, and play loud and fast.....

Example : http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=rX-AA5t02eo (http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=rX-AA5t02eo)

OMG they look and sound desperate

I can't possibly comment, as they are still going and live not too far away from me..... ::) 

However see more of their videos - It's like watching a car crash....you don't want to look - but...........

English music at it's best.....
Title: Re: An 'English' Melodeon?
Post by: Thrupenny Bit on February 20, 2011, 07:30:58 PM
thanks Ian....mind you, you never know where Jerry's concerned  ;)
Title: Re: An 'English' Melodeon?
Post by: Gary P Chapin on February 20, 2011, 08:06:19 PM
I've been enjoying this discussion, as it drifts from what makes an English melodeon to what makes English melodeon music, I find myself thinking of my favorite English melodeonists (Kirkpatrick, Spiers, and Parkinson) and wondering what is the common bond between them that I enjoy?  (Warning: I am not an English melodeon expert, and base this on very limited sample.  In other words, I might be talking out of my a**, here.  Also, I use Irish music as a contrast here, not to set the one off against the other.)


Just thoughts.  Thanks.
Title: Re: An 'English' Melodeon?
Post by: Alan Morley on February 20, 2011, 08:21:56 PM
I'm never really sure what my style is. There have been so many influences that have soaked in over the years, since starting on guitar in 1964..

The funniest comment/ compliment I had was when I did a floor spot at Peasmouldier Folk Club in Derby - when I had played, a guy said 'You remind me of someone, with how you play.....'  'Dave Swarbrick......' Well - how nice, cos Swarb has always been a hero of mine....but not known for playing melodeon.

 :P
Title: Re: An 'English' Melodeon?
Post by: Gary P Chapin on February 20, 2011, 08:36:29 PM
Funny you should mention that, Almo.  One of the things I find myself doing is being inspired by musicians on other instruments and thinking, "If I could just get out of my melodeon what she does with her cello ..."  I often wonder, for example, if it would be possible to build on what Robin Williamson does, with stories and all, using the melodeon in place of his harp?  It should be possible.  Maybe not for me, but someone ...

Reminding someone of Dave Swarbrick, though, sweet.
Title: Re: An 'English' Melodeon?
Post by: Alan Morley on February 20, 2011, 08:54:34 PM
Funny you should mention that, Almo.  One of the things I find myself doing is being inspired by musicians on other instruments and thinking, "If I could just get out of my melodeon what she does with her cello ..."  I often wonder, for example, if it would be possible to build on what Robin Williamson does, with stories and all, using the melodeon in place of his harp?  It should be possible.  Maybe not for me, but someone ...

Reminding someone of Dave Swarbrick, though, sweet.

Talking of Robin Williamson - I was also into Incredible String Band / Steeleye / Fairport / Pentangle / Jethro Tull  - I used to get to some strange parties in the ealy 70's.... ;)
Title: Re: An 'English' Melodeon?
Post by: oggiesnr on February 20, 2011, 09:13:24 PM

Can the development of the different dance traditions have effected the music?  Did the Irish step-dance thing influence the way musicians approached tunes, versus the Morris dancing tradition?  How could it have not?  


Not in the modern era as the speed that tunes are now played in sessions and in a band bears no resemblance to the speed that tunes are required for the dance (unless you're talking "Riverdance").

Steve
Title: Re: An 'English' Melodeon?
Post by: Theo on February 20, 2011, 10:19:24 PM
Not sure I agree with all of that.  Some set dancers demand a very very fast tempo, especially on polka and slide figures. Reels tend to be a bit slower, though of course since they generally have 4 notes per beat instead of two they can sound faster to non-dancers
Title: Re: An 'English' Melodeon?
Post by: Thrupenny Bit on February 20, 2011, 10:46:16 PM
Hi Gary, glad you're enjoying a walk though all things 'English' with us!
I have little experience of Irish music, except when dancing in Dublin over 2 Easters, '81/'82 and making good friends, sadly now out of touch. I do remember having one of those deep philosophical chats, as you do at 3am after far too much black stuff with a white top.
I remember voicing my opinion that sometimes I felt some of the music was too fast and furios, 0-60mph in 4 secs tunes..... only to find my friend in total agreement, as he preferred the older players who were far more laid back, as was his fiddle style. His take was the fast-and-furious stuff was mainly for dancing and merely a functional tool to provide a beat necessary for the stepping of the ceilidh dance.
I've always thought that the differences were along the lines of English celidhs are about bounce, rythm and making shapes of figures in the dances, whereas the Irish celidhs that I went to ( only a couple! ) were far more about stepping, and so the music reflects this.

Mind you, I too might be talking out of my Wotsit too!!!!!!!!!!
....and need my pillow.
Night all, thanks for the chats
Q
zzzzzzzzzzzzz
Title: Re: An 'English' Melodeon?
Post by: Gary P Chapin on February 21, 2011, 05:12:18 PM
My experience with Irish music was back in the 1990s, before I'd even touched a melodeon (there's no overlap in time between my Irish-time and melodeon-time).  I was a whistler/flute player, doing gigs and such, and I truly enjoyed myself.  Even then, though, I found myself much more drawn to the Clare tradition of, for example, Jack and Charlie Coen.  They really could make a beautiful thing out of a melody.

I'm not sure why I went off flute (I'd played woodwinds for years), but the moment I found quint melodeon and the Centre France repertoire, I was completely hooked.  It felt like what I was meant to do.  No going back.  Then, melodeon in hand, I heard Kirkpatrick and Spiers, and, apart from specific melodeon content, the Waterson:Carthy clan captured my heart.  Wonderful!  So, whatever understanding of "Englishness" I have (aside from a British grandmother, who's expression of "Englishness" was through food, not music), comes from that experience.
Title: Re: An 'English' Melodeon?
Post by: Thrupenny Bit on February 21, 2011, 07:31:32 PM
Yes, it's surpising how things suddenly take hold unexpectedly, no rhym or reason and.....there's no going back!
Haven't dicovered any French stuff yet, as I'm still getting to grips with the English repertoire, transferring some from English Concertina, learning some new, and actually actively learning some that were forever at the back of my mind that once someone started they sort of tipped out......whilst struggling with the beast otherwise known as a melodeon.
Here be madness methinks ;D

.....and now off to practise the  :M
 cheers
Q
Title: Re: An 'English' Melodeon?
Post by: Matthew B on February 21, 2011, 07:48:14 PM
quint melodeon and the Centre France repertoire . . . British grandmother, who's expression of "Englishness" was through food

French melodeon and English food. 

Interesting choices. 
Title: Re: An 'English' Melodeon?
Post by: IanD on February 21, 2011, 10:39:53 PM
I've used a Dony 26 button for nearly twenty years now and find it just spot on.  Brilliant for band and street work, have to he careful in sessions though.  I know you like it Ian.  I hadn't had in very long when I let you try at an 'Ale' in Portsmouth and had difficulty prising it back off you half an hour later.  Maybe a modified Benny might be good if you can't get an Oakwood.

Just lately I've been attracted to more mellow boxes but I still can't say that one box is more English than another.  Still going with the style and the player.

I've had a (unique?) Dony 30 button (D/G/acc, bandoneon tuned) for almost as long which I love but isn't that English sounding, and it's too big and heavy to play for long periods. The Benny is too mellow sounding and the bass end is too feeble for my taste.

Ian

(I already have an Oakwood, I'm trying to think how it could be improved should the opportunity ever arise)
Title: Re: An 'English' Melodeon?
Post by: Gary P Chapin on February 22, 2011, 12:01:09 AM
quint melodeon and the Centre France repertoire . . . British grandmother, who's expression of "Englishness" was through food

French melodeon and English food. 

Interesting choices. 
These aren't choices.  They are destiny.

Anyway, she could do a steak, my grandmother.  Beyond that ...
Title: Re: An 'English' Melodeon?
Post by: Gary P Chapin on February 22, 2011, 12:02:07 AM
I've had a (unique?) Dony 30 button (D/G/acc, bandoneon tuned)
What do you mean "bandoneon tuned?"
Title: Re: An 'English' Melodeon?
Post by: waltzman on February 22, 2011, 12:06:14 AM
I've had a (unique?) Dony 30 button (D/G/acc, bandoneon tuned)
What do you mean "bandoneon tuned?"

Reeds tuned an octave apart on pitch (LM).  It's dry but different than dry MM.  Bandoneons are tuned this way.
SimplePortal 2.3.5 © 2008-2012, SimplePortal