But.... Is there such a thing as an 'English' sounding melodeon?
What defines it as such?
I hand it over to the floor for discussion.......
Q
For instance.....why does the Music Room think it necessary to 'improve' a Dino baffetti?
Is it to tweak it to make it play/respond better, or are there more subtle things going on?
....not criticising in any way, simply interested.
Quote from Music Room page:
Most critically, it sports top of the range hand made Binci reeds, widely regarded as the best reeds available for melodeons (and indeed, Martyn's reeds of choice for his highly sought after Oakwood Melodeons...
It seems that national tastes also change. Irish tuned boxes used to be very wet, heavy musette tunings but latterly seem to be tuned much drier. In English tradition I've heard every thing from a harsh Organetto to unison. I don't think D/G Hohner's are tuned differently for the English market, wiser members may correct me but certainly a fairly recent acquisition in G/C was much dryer tuned.
by irish tuned do you mean BC or similar semitone tuned box. Neither is really 'Irish Tuned' as the BC is also Scottish tuned so to speak and of course there are those who playu 'Irish@ tunes very well on DG boxes.Hi George. I wasn't referring to any particular box configuration, only toward the taste in tuning. Organetto, French and some other Italian tunings all shared the heavy musette sound but I have noticed that many new Irish players are favouring a dryer sound.
I dunno, I have certainly picked up boxes and thought "This would be good for Irish", "This would be good for Scottish",
Quote from Almo
" The Music Room Dino Baffetti as I understand from their web page - has been improved by the guy resposible for Oakwood melodeons - an English manufacturer who used to make boxes that I'd kill for...."
Exactly my point 'improved....' but Why the need to improve what they admit is a perfectly well built melodeon, and how?
All I can glean from the advert relates more to being a boy racer and modding an old car, somewhat frustrating if you actually want to learn about a product and live the other end of the country so can't pop in to take a look!
I really wanted to like the D/O and would have bought if I had but it left me cold. It sounded just like lots of other Italian boxes which are used for playing Irish music at speed, it had lost it's all-roundness and distinctiveness. Totally subjective I know but I couldn't see the point of paying the extra. I felt hat it's target market was D/G players looking for a B/C substitute to play Irish music at breakneck speeds.
"... And it's just as much the player as the box..."
Which is why Saul Rose can make an 18 bass Handry sound like a quintessentially English box! Not to mention DTN's fine playing of English tunes on a variety of boxes.
John
Sorry folks
I have sat on my hands, bit my tongue, persuaded myself I should not hijack a thread, not good forum etiquette etc., but Anahata's last post left me no choice.....
Almo - not £2,000 for a Dino/Oakwood, but........ http://forum.melodeon.net/index.php/topic,6132.0.html - and note the unsolicited praise from forum members!
Cheers John
At what point does tweaking become a 'standard tweak'? at which point then you can argue that if there's a lot of players requiring the standard tweak then it should have been built like it in he first place.
It depends what you mean by English - I think of English as Bob Cann/ John Kirkpatrick/ Tufty Swift style - Saul Rose is Saul Rose style which is OK too but not English.
Quote
It depends what you mean by English - I think of English as Bob Cann/ John Kirkpatrick/ Tufty Swift style - Saul Rose is Saul Rose style which is OK too but not English.
now we disagree!! >:E >:E >:E
Cut Saul in half ... it says English on the inside! (modern English!)
When I was a lad, there were only 78 rpm records and the wireless to listen to, and that's if you were rich enough to buy them. We had to make our own entertainment with cardboard squeezeboxes with shirt buttons stuck on and sing the tunes. We had some grand days in that workhouse.... ;)Dun't tha meean 'When ah were a lad'? (Old English) ;)
I played a short sharp loud chord and two people standing 20-30 feet away jumped and turned to see where the noise was coming from, and I knew I had a winner.
I played a short sharp loud chord and two people standing 20-30 feet away jumped and turned to see where the noise was coming from, and I knew I had a winner.
noise. If they learned to play at less than full volume that would be great, but sadly some don't.
Moan over.
With most people not in the throes of MAD, the instrument has to be a jack of all trades, loud for morris ( if required ) and then taken inside after for a session, all on the same box. As said, the player then has to realise they're *not* playing for the morris any more and consequently reduce volume!
Try this solution. Sit a mandolin player to the right of the box player and ask the box player to listen to the intricate counter melody being played. >:E >:E
Listen being the keyword, mandolins or none. Judge a musician by how they use their ears, not their fingers.
Chris - I have no experience of playing across the channel, so find your points interesting. Perhaps our style *is* evolving to cope with tunes now being played originating from other places, and other melodeons with more complex keyboards coming in to accommodate these other new tunes.
I'd blame Dave Roberts, and Roger Watson - but there are other early culprits
Ah, Plain Capers, the disc that got me started....
Interesting how quickly the innovators in a traditional form become the tradition.
In another generation who will be the people who are the new tradition?
I see Ed Rennie's playing an Erica instead of the Castagnari I used to see him with...
| (http://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/thumb/c/cd/Homo_erectus.jpg/200px-Homo_erectus.jpg) (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Homo_erectus) click image for Eric's real name | Presumably homo Erica was his good lady? :|glug |
Another thought has occurred:
If there are two distinct types emerging, older style traditional types playing strictly English tunes using Pokerworks/Erics and those more modern in apporach playing more adventurous tunes from further afield on boxes more accommodating for these.......
The in evolutionary terms, you are splitting the gene pool and two distinct species will emerge just as our species did.
Importantly - English style play is something we should 'celebrate'Here, here. Not just celebrate though, actively promote. The popularity of traditional Irish music is not an accident it was brought about by Irish government intervention as the genre had almost been lost.
It's sometimes/usually hard to get the general public interested in fine details of what you are doing - as they don't understand what we do as musicians..Importantly - English style play is something we should 'celebrate'Here, here. Not just celebrate though, actively promote. The popularity of traditional Irish music is not an accident it was brought about by Irish government intervention as the genre had almost been lost.
3d, I think most of us who play out take several boxes and use them for their different qualities. Maybe we should make more announcements to the general public whom we are often playing for.
I sometimes despair when bands are judged to be 'brillient' because they jump about a lot, dress in silly outfits, and play loud and fast.....
Indeed, Theo, it is quite hard to think of a good "folk" drummer (cue for further discussion!?).
Ian: Yes absolutely, forgot about Rob. He's superb, and must have had a 'senior moment' forgetting him.
My original question was about melodeon design, though we seem to have ambled merrily and thoughtfully on occasions away from my original point.
What would you want in an ideal 'English' melodeon?
....though I think we've almost totally established there aint no such beast!
Maybe a better question is ' what would you build into the 'perfect' melodeon'?
( bear in mind I've chatted to Jerry!)
Chris: an old friend, a wonderful Irish fiddler, sometime box player and pipes too, firmly told me once that the Irish disowned it too!
I sometimes despair when bands are judged to be 'brillient' because they jump about a lot, dress in silly outfits, and play loud and fast.....
Example : http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=rX-AA5t02eo (http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=rX-AA5t02eo)
I sometimes despair when bands are judged to be 'brillient' because they jump about a lot, dress in silly outfits, and play loud and fast.....
Example : http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=rX-AA5t02eo (http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=rX-AA5t02eo)
OMG they look and sound desperate
Funny you should mention that, Almo. One of the things I find myself doing is being inspired by musicians on other instruments and thinking, "If I could just get out of my melodeon what she does with her cello ..." I often wonder, for example, if it would be possible to build on what Robin Williamson does, with stories and all, using the melodeon in place of his harp? It should be possible. Maybe not for me, but someone ...
Reminding someone of Dave Swarbrick, though, sweet.
Can the development of the different dance traditions have effected the music? Did the Irish step-dance thing influence the way musicians approached tunes, versus the Morris dancing tradition? How could it have not?
quint melodeon and the Centre France repertoire . . . British grandmother, who's expression of "Englishness" was through food
I've used a Dony 26 button for nearly twenty years now and find it just spot on. Brilliant for band and street work, have to he careful in sessions though. I know you like it Ian. I hadn't had in very long when I let you try at an 'Ale' in Portsmouth and had difficulty prising it back off you half an hour later. Maybe a modified Benny might be good if you can't get an Oakwood.
Just lately I've been attracted to more mellow boxes but I still can't say that one box is more English than another. Still going with the style and the player.
These aren't choices. They are destiny.quint melodeon and the Centre France repertoire . . . British grandmother, who's expression of "Englishness" was through food
French melodeon and English food.
Interesting choices.
I've had a (unique?) Dony 30 button (D/G/acc, bandoneon tuned)What do you mean "bandoneon tuned?"
I've had a (unique?) Dony 30 button (D/G/acc, bandoneon tuned)What do you mean "bandoneon tuned?"