Melodeon.net Forums

Discussions => Instrument Design, Construction and Repair => Topic started by: Earbrass on February 18, 2011, 03:24:36 PM

Title: Melodeon tuning systems
Post by: Earbrass on February 18, 2011, 03:24:36 PM
Here's a question for the melodeon tuners out there, which I ask out of a purely academic interest: when tuning a (diatonic) melodeon, do you use just intonation or equal temperament scales as the base? If the latter, why, when the instrument will be played in only a small number of related keys? Is the answer different for say B/C boxes (which can play in more keys) than for say a one row?

Just interested, as the topic of tuning systems came up on another music forum, and it set me thinking...
Title: Re: Melodeon tuning systems
Post by: diatonix on February 18, 2011, 05:15:57 PM
Single row melodeons: just scale.
Other diatonic instruments: equal temp. (just scale doesn't quite work, unfortunately: On a GC box you'd end up with 2 very different A's, a fifth of a semitone apart. Additional headaches on the left side too...). One could of course, and some do, modify or adapt the scale in several ways (e.g. by lowering the thirds in each row), but in my opinion there is not so much gained by this.
Title: Re: Melodeon tuning systems
Post by: Theo on February 18, 2011, 05:21:01 PM
Something similar was discussed here (http://forum.melodeon.net/index.php/topic,6081.msg76976.html#msg76976) recently
Title: Re: Melodeon tuning systems
Post by: IanD on February 20, 2011, 02:59:48 PM
There are tuning systems which would work much better on instruments which play in a restricted set of keys like melodeons.

The best would probably be Aaron's mean-tome 1/4 comma, you can listen to it here (and realise how horrible ET really is)

http://leware.net/temper/js/acc.htm

Unfortunately this would only work if everyone used it (or the instrument was played solo); not only would the scale sound out of tune played with ET instruments, but as you move away from the home keys each scale mover about 4 cents further away from ET.

Ian
Title: Re: Melodeon tuning systems
Post by: blafleur on February 20, 2011, 09:50:38 PM
Wouldn't the type of music be a big determining factor in tuning type?
Title: Re: Melodeon tuning systems
Post by: Martin J on February 20, 2011, 11:45:05 PM
Wouldn't the type of music be a big determining factor in tuning type?
I think it would be best to match to the other instruments your normally play with, particularly if they are not instantly tunable such as piano, any reed instrument, brass to some degree etc.

We need an emote with hands over ears !
Title: Re: Melodeon tuning systems
Post by: old geezer on February 21, 2011, 07:12:51 AM
We need an emote with hands over ears !

like this one ???
Title: Re: Melodeon tuning systems
Post by: Martin J on February 21, 2011, 10:51:53 AM
We need an emote with hands over ears !

like this one ???
LOL
Title: Re: Melodeon tuning systems
Post by: LJC on February 21, 2011, 11:10:07 AM
Whilst this isn't particularly scientific, once I have tuned a melodeon to the theoretical 'correct' 0 cent pitches and + cent offsets, I always go back and adjust things so that they sound 'right' or 'sweet'. There is no real system to this - it seems to be different from box to box, key to key, tuning to tuning (I'm sure some proper analysis could determine what is actually happening, but I don't really have the time or inclination!). The upside is that the boxes sound 'musical'.

I think this human touch is more important than the tuning system, and probably why many of the good tuners around are also good musicians and players. You need this ability and confidence in your judgement to say 'yes, this sounds good' and know when to leave it alone.

I really enjoyed that tuning system applet Ian, it's fascinating to hear a bunch of different tunings back to back and mathematically perfect.
Title: Re: Melodeon tuning systems
Post by: Earbrass on February 21, 2011, 12:12:44 PM
Thanks to you all for your replies - most interesting. :Ph
Title: Re: Melodeon tuning systems
Post by: Owen Woods on February 21, 2011, 12:44:41 PM
That applet is fascinating. I hadn't realised just how horrible ET is, although compared to most of the others it's quite nice :P Lehman was good though, that sounded OK.
Title: Re: Melodeon tuning systems
Post by: Dally on February 26, 2011, 05:39:22 PM
That applet has answered many questions that have been bothering me for a long time.  Thank you positng it.  Of course, some new questions pop up.
Why does a triad sound better in "Just" but a note and it's fifth sounds better in "Pythogorean"?  Aren't both based on the harmonic series?
If vibrato was invented to deal with the gaps in ET, as I read recently, then is wet tuning in accordions a tuning solution as well?  Was the thinking, "well, we've got these beats between certains notes and combinations of so notes, so let's just give everything a beat?"  Or, was there a desire for the beats in the first place, as in gamelon music?
ET tuning on diatonic boxes seems like a waste, because you are only going to be playing in a few keys.  Each key as it's own character, which is why Bach and others named all those tunes after the key they were composed in.  ET made every key have the same slightly off character.  With a diatonic instrument it would appear the tuning could be adjusted along the lines of Vitelli to favor the keys you would most likely be playing in.
Title: Re: Melodeon tuning systems
Post by: IanD on February 26, 2011, 06:23:51 PM
That applet has answered many questions that have been bothering me for a long time.  Thank you positng it.  Of course, some new questions pop up.
Why does a triad sound better in "Just" but a note and it's fifth sounds better in "Pythogorean"?  Aren't both based on the harmonic series?
If vibrato was invented to deal with the gaps in ET, as I read recently, then is wet tuning in accordions a tuning solution as well?  Was the thinking, "well, we've got these beats between certains notes and combinations of so notes, so let's just give everything a beat?"  Or, was there a desire for the beats in the first place, as in gamelon music?
ET tuning on diatonic boxes seems like a waste, because you are only going to be playing in a few keys.  Each key as it's own character, which is why Bach and others named all those tunes after the key they were composed in.  ET made every key have the same slightly off character.  With a diatonic instrument it would appear the tuning could be adjusted along the lines of Vitelli to favor the keys you would most likely be playing in.

If you're using a temperament other than ET then each key does have it's own "character", because the scales are slightly different for each key. It's difficlut to see why anyone still thinks this is the case with ET, unless they have perfect pitch and think that (for example) Dma sounds differenct to Cma.

VIbrato almost certainly wasn't invented to deal with ET beats, though it did become heavily used at about the same time. I'd guess it was the same reason for the heavy vibrato used by opera singers, which makes the sound subjectively louder to the ear and is what you need if you're playing (or singing) in a big concert hall as opposed to the smaller venues typically used for earlier music.

Wet tuning has the same effect, it sounds louder because the ear is tuned to pick out varying sounds not static ones. So if you're playing unamplified to a big audience or in a noisy environment it helps for the same reason as it helps opera singers.
Title: Re: Melodeon tuning systems
Post by: forrest on February 26, 2011, 06:50:18 PM
That applet is fascinating. I hadn't realised just how horrible ET is, although compared to most of the others it's quite nice :P Lehman was good though, that sounded OK.

Speaking of Bradley Lehman, here's a clip of him demonstrating his theory of Bach's tuning model....

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=__tbvLNH6FI




VIbrato almost certainly wasn't invented to deal with ET beats, though it did become heavily used at about the same time.......

Wet tuning has the same effect, it sounds louder because the ear is tuned to pick out varying sounds not static ones. So if you're playing unamplified to a big audience or in a noisy environment it helps for the same reason as it helps opera singers.

I also think that 'wetness' in multiple reed tuning could be an attempt to simulate the effect of multiple instruments (such as string sections, woodwinds, or choral groups) in unison. Because each 'voice' is playing a slightly different version of the same note, there is a texture or characteristic which enlarges the sound, and can also make it quite pleasing.
Title: Re: Melodeon tuning systems
Post by: IanD on February 27, 2011, 01:45:53 PM

I also think that 'wetness' in multiple reed tuning could be an attempt to simulate the effect of multiple instruments (such as string sections, woodwinds, or choral groups) in unison. Because each 'voice' is playing a slightly different version of the same note, there is a texture or characteristic which enlarges the sound, and can also make it quite pleasing.

Except that anything other than dry tuning has much more detuning than instruments playing or people singing together -- if two people sang 4Hz apart deliberately it would sound horrible...
Title: Re: Melodeon tuning systems
Post by: Owen Woods on March 01, 2011, 01:13:39 AM
If you're using a temperament other than ET then each key does have it's own "character", because the scales are slightly different for each key. It's difficlut to see why anyone still thinks this is the case with ET, unless they have perfect pitch and think that (for example) Dma sounds differenct to Cma.

I do and it does :P But I think that most people that have played music for a long time have some sort of relative pitch and would be able to characterise each scale by pitch at least. I would find it weird otherwise, but then again, I have it, so I don't know what it's like not to have it. The other category of people who would find differences would be people with synaesthesia, like my girlfriend.

That youtube video is very nice. Out of the things on the applet, Lehman was easily the nicest other than ET (which I am too used to to judge effectively, although with that applet I can hear the dissonances)
SimplePortal 2.3.5 © 2008-2012, SimplePortal