Melodeon.net Forums
Discussions => Instrument Design, Construction and Repair => Topic started by: melod-ian on February 19, 2011, 09:38:47 AM
-
I noticed a reed was sounding slightly off key last week, by the weekend it had dropped a semitone..I just wondered how flat a reed can go?.. is there a stopping point ?
It hasn't got any flatter now, I did think I'd see if it dropped by a tone i wouldn't necessarily need to replace it 8)
-
I noticed a reed was sounding slightly off key last week, by the weekend it had dropped a semitone..I just wondered how flat a reed can go?.. is there a stopping point ?
It hasn't got any flatter now, I did think I'd see if it dropped by a tone i wouldn't necessarily need to replace it 8)
If its gone flat by a semitone it is almost certainly cracked and will break very soon as you continue to play it. It will need to be replaced.
-
Could there be something on the reed or stuck in the gap?
-
Could there be something on the reed or stuck in the gap?
Possible, but not so likely. Tiny objects can get stick near the root of the reed but this usually results in a higher pitch because the effective length of the reed is reduced. More often something stuck in the reed gap will stop it speaking at all.
I'm not saying that a drop in pitch couldn't have another cause, but if the pitch drops gradually and gets flatter the more you pay its the classic symptom of a cracked reed.
-
Agreed - the reed's a goner once it drops that flat as it is more than likely suffering from severe metal fatigue.
-
Prime example is my Castagnari Tommy whose G chord was horrid til I tuned the G reed, then it went horrid til I tuned the G reed, then it went horrid til I tuned the G reed, then I noticed the crack in the reed by holding it up to a bright light. I was quite surprised how long it lasted between each tune but it did get to be less and less.
-
This happened to two different bass reeds in a club I have. The second time I was privileged to experience the death of the reed in the middle of playing a note - the tone dropped like a slide whistle until the reed snapped.