Melodeon.net Forums
Discussions => Instrument Design, Construction and Repair => Topic started by: Thrupenny Bit on February 23, 2011, 08:57:03 PM
-
Having had a bit of time today, I was thinking about a chromatic scale, so tried to find out how my accidentals fitted.
I have briefly checked them before against my daughters' flute tuner, but not really taken much notice, just a mental note that I've the 'normal' Bb, G#, and F, Eb
I tried a scale and it was waaay out, made no sense at all.
Got out the tuner and.......
I then realised - my Push F and Pull Eb were the other way round ( Push Eb and Pull F )
similarly my Push G# and Pull Bb are actually Push Bb and Pull G#
Is is common for these to have been put in like this, or has someone swapped them around since it was made?
....not that it matters I suppose.
Thoughts anyone?
Q
-
It is the opposite way round to "normal" but I have heard it suggested more than once as a sensible mod
-
Having had a bit of time today, I was thinking about a chromatic scale, so tried to find out how my accidentals fitted.
I have briefly checked them before against my daughters' flute tuner, but not really taken much notice, just a mental note that I've the 'normal' Bb, G#, and F, Eb
I tried a scale and it was waaay out, made no sense at all.
Got out the tuner and.......
I then realised - my Push F and Pull Eb were the other way round ( Push Eb and Pull F )
similarly my Push G# and Pull Bb are actually Push Bb and Pull G#
Is is common for these to have been put in like this, or has someone swapped them around since it was made?
....not that it matters I suppose.
Thoughts anyone?
Q
Castagnari standard tuning for me and i totally prefer it that way!!
Push Eb and Pull F gets the Gm / Dm keys working for me!!
DTN
-
Castagnari standard tuning for me and i totally prefer it that way!!
Push Eb and Pull F gets the Gm / Dm keys working for me!!
DTN
I absolutely agree. F on the pull is what you need for A minor as well. I've rarely (if ever) found a use for
Eb pull/ F push, and I've always flipped them if they were the other way round.
Bb/G# is more arguable. I like the G# on the pull (to go with the E bass) but Bb is handy in both directions.
There is lots of discussion about the direction of accidentals in other threads, and it really is down to individual preference. It does seem though that it's becoming more usual for boxes to come with F & G# on the pull, and Eb and Bb on the push, rather than the other way round.
-
As Derek says, it is normal for Castagnari to put them the opposite way from hohner, although I have a Lilly which is the same as my Pokerwork. I tend not to find either arrangement unuseable melodically , but there are tunes which require them for harmonic purposes. Pterodactyl Twostep was written for a Pokerwork and the disonant harmony notes cannot be played with the other arrangement, for example.
Rob.
-
That way round is much better for playing the right notes with unusual chords (normally with 3rds removed) more like the continental style. The normal way is much better for getting semitone grace notes for a more "irish" approach to D/G style.
I find I would like it both ways most times, but have my Eb/F the continental way round on 2 row boxes and the G#/Bb the normal way.
-
Just drifting the thread a little. What tunes do they get used for? The only time I've used one of the accidentals was in an attempt to play jiggery pokerwork. Otherwise they don't get used-I sometimes thing having the low notes would be more useful.
-
Just drifting the thread a little. What tunes do they get used for? The only time I've used one of the accidentals was in an attempt to play jiggery pokerwork. Otherwise they don't get used-I sometimes thing having the low notes would be more useful.
The c music of The Horses Brandle, In the Toyshop, Lilibolero and a load more that wont come to mind.
-
Just drifting the thread a little. What tunes do they get used for? The only time I've used one of the accidentals was in an attempt to play jiggery pokerwork. Otherwise they don't get used-I sometimes thing having the low notes would be more useful.
... depends what you play. But the top end of a DG is so shrill that 'both' is probably optimal (as well discussed here).
Returning to thread, my fist box, pokerwork, came with both Eb and Bb on the pull. When I got a lilly they were push. I was used to the other way and turned the plates (easy enough in a single reeder). And there they rest,
After discovering French music I found eg poules houppées and a whole stack of other harmonic minor stuff actually preferred way 2! Nevertheless my Parigi (transposing to make the point) had its equivalent of Bb flipped to pull for that lovely blue b5th in the E minor scale - I just couldn't live without that now!
Its other plate I left 'French' with the lower note Eb pushing, allowing that wonderfully assertive B7 arpegio (this the reason our a melodeon's 'B' chord is 'major')
On balance I think 'mixed' was a pretty good compromise. Flipping plates feels a little daunting (particularly on 2-3 voicers) and needs to be a 'considered' modification. I think each player should experiment in the context of own style of play and then try to stick to the result.
I'd warn that all this research has left me hopelessly fuddled when I play Cutting's 'in continental mood' - come its B chord I can never remember whether I should fit it in pulling or pushing - still throws me to this day. :-\
[edit] re-reading - I think squeezy has said more or less the same - 'mixed'
-
I'm playing the Tommy 'as is' and have no plans to change the configuration, I was just surprided at it being 'back to front'.
Like LdeT I've tried Jiggery Pokerwork simply to find out where the Bb is and how it fits in, ( Horses Branle etc will be on the list eventually Lester! ). I'm finding that by having to play tunes like Jiggery it makes you find out the odd corners of the box. I had a good go with the tune a while back and then have left it for a few weeks. Had another go with it last night. Bonkers tune - love it!
Haven't discovered the other keys mentioned, so am not sure of what you need to play them, but it'll come in time. My brain's currently only in D/G mode until I'm a bit further down the line!
Thanks all for replying
cheers
Q
-
Got out the tuner and.......
I then realised - my Push F and Pull Eb were the other way round ( Push Eb and Pull F )
similarly my Push G# and Pull Bb are actually Push Bb and Pull G#
Is is common for these to have been put in like this,
My Saltarelle Pastourelle II (4th button start) came from the factory this way round, and I find it very comfortable to play. When I played a friend's Connemara III (3rd button start) they were the opposite way round, and I got into all sorts of trouble with them. I couldn't say whether one way or the other is "standard" but I'm used to the pull F & push Bb. All but one of my other current boxes are 1-rows, so I don't have any problem trying to use both systems. The other 2.5 row is a Club II I'm rebuilding, and I will modify the keyboard to echo the Saltarelle just to make it easier to swap between the two instruments.
-
Hi GPS. Yes it feels ok to me, I suppose it was just curiosity when I asked the question.
So...if your Pastourelle is a 4th button start, and you've got these accidentals, what happens between the accidentals and the 4th buttons?
i.e. you have an extra button on each row, do they give you the lower notes as previously discussed, so allowing low G up the the 'start' button runs?
-
Hi GPS. Yes it feels ok to me, I suppose it was just curiosity when I asked the question.
So...if your Pastourelle is a 4th button start, and you've got these accidentals, what happens between the accidentals and the 4th buttons?
i.e. you have an extra button on each row, do they give you the lower notes as previously discussed, so allowing low G up the the 'start' button runs?
The Salterelle Layouts are here
http://forum.melodeon.net/files/site/DG21plus5saltarelle.gif (http://forum.melodeon.net/files/site/DG21plus5saltarelle.gif)
http://forum.melodeon.net/files/site/DG23plus4saltarelle.gif (http://forum.melodeon.net/files/site/DG23plus4saltarelle.gif)
-
Morning sir!
Hope all's well 'up north'!
thanks for that, will go look
cheers
Q
-
Hi GPS. Yes it feels ok to me, I suppose it was just curiosity when I asked the question.
So...if your Pastourelle is a 4th button start, and you've got these accidentals, what happens between the accidentals and the 4th buttons?
i.e. you have an extra button on each row, do they give you the lower notes as previously discussed, so allowing low G up the the 'start' button runs?
The Salterelle Layouts are here
http://forum.melodeon.net/files/site/DG21plus5saltarelle.gif (http://forum.melodeon.net/files/site/DG21plus5saltarelle.gif)
http://forum.melodeon.net/files/site/DG23plus4saltarelle.gif (http://forum.melodeon.net/files/site/DG23plus4saltarelle.gif)
Two Saltarelle layouts, yes - but not mine. To begin with, mine's 21+4, and it doesn't have the accidentals repeated at the bottom - it goes down to the low G & low D on the relevant row. It's the way it came from the factory (20 years ago) , so is there such a thing as a standard Saltarelle?
Cheers
G
-
GPS: That seems a very sensible option, and as you say, not what the charts show.
In my very limited experience, it appears nothing seems 'standard' at all ???
Q
-
In my very limited experience, it appears nothing seems 'standard' at all ???
Q
Spot on, and many people get them changed in various ways depending on what they play.
-
+1 for having the F on the pull, it makes much more sense for playing across the rows in Dm or Am. The Bb pull is most useful as a pull note as well, in my opinion, but it depends how you like to play. On a Saltarelle 12 bass with an F pull chord as standard you would be mad to have your F notes on the push!