Melodeon.net Forums
Discussions => Recordings and Videos => Topic started by: tedrick on March 02, 2011, 04:05:49 PM
-
Curious to get some feedback on how the tuning on my Cairdin sounds:
Heavy jigs on the Cairdin mini BC (http://youtu.be/IMzMEOUZnCk)
I'm trying to get used to the tuning - I still think I'm hearing some funky buzzy sound on the reeds from the valves... not sure if the source of the funkiness is the tuning of the reeds or the performance of the valves....
-
There is a bit of a buzz, isn't there? It seems to be most prominent in the range from F down to D. Could it be something vibrating... like your grille where there is a screw missing? Seems unlikely, but to my (not very experienced) ear it doesn't sound like valve "flutter".
-
Thanks Steve -
I thought I was going crazy - hearing things -
thanks for the idea about a vibration from something on the box - I will investigate...
-
Sounds a bit metalica. Try it with the grid removed and see how the sound is. Two very nice jigs incidentally and well played.
-
I think it could be a tuning problem, those low notes may not be quite in unison. There is a phenomenon which can sound like this if you tune all the reeds by the machine to about 5 cents difference, not enough to produce an audible swing, but just a slightly thicker sound than complete unison. This works fine for most of the range, but on the lower notes you can end up with a buzz like this. I'm not absolutely sure of the reason, but I think its a result of interference in some of the upper partials producing an audible beat. For the higher notes these beats are of a higher pitch than our ears can hear, but as you go down the scale they eventually become perceptible. Just a theory, but it seems plausible. Anyway the solution might be to make some tiny adjustments to the tuning of those lowest notes.
Another trick that can clean up the sound of the lower notes is to fit a metal strap over the reedblocks, but I would expect Cairdin to have done this already.
-
Another trick that can clean up the sound of the lower notes is to fit a metal strap over the reedblocks
Not heard of that one before Theo - what's the theory behind it?
AL
-
It locks the reedblocks together so they can't vibrate with a rocking motion. All modern Italian boxes have them, I've just added one to a Hohner Erica A/D which is tuned with a bit less tremolo than typical Hohner and it cleaned up the sound a treat on the low end of the treble. I always fit one now to any box I rebuild.
-
Couldn't the metal strap vibrate too, or resonate in sympathy?
-
Couldn't the metal strap vibrate too, or resonate in sympathy?
In theory yes, but in practice the strap would have a much higher frequency of vibration and would be so damped that it wouldn't really be resonant. I think mine's made of aluminium, which is not a very springy metal anyway.
Maybe a better description would be to say that it creates (for spurious vibration purposes) a single reedbock of twice the mass in which any induced vibration will be of half the intensity. For that purposes it's a lot cheaper and lighter than attaching a strip of lead along the edge of the block. (:)
I know that it's just the job for curing the burbling noise you get when a pair of tremolo tuned reeds start popping in and out of sync with each other, presumably because that coupling is though vibration of the block.
-
Our man RGF here in the Twin Cities recommended the same idea - a brace between the 2 blocks -
Is there a risk of screwing deep into a reed chamber? do I just put the screws in a place that is not a reed chamber?
I think my main issue is with the sound of the reeds and the tuning -- I'd like a tuning more along the lines of John Whelan - dryer - not as dry as Sharon Shannon but more in that direction than the current tuning --
I think the current tuning is edgy not mellow, harsh, abrasive -- I'm not sure if it can be addressed with tuning or if it's just the sound of these Antonelli reeds -
I want a mello, soft, woody, round, flutey, dry sound -- does that make sense? The sound of my dancemaster was better than how this box currently sounds -- can the reeds in this Cairdin be retuned to sound different?
-
The brace is tiny (less than 2mm thick, maybe 6mm wide) and the screws only need to be very small and short!
-
Is there a risk of screwing deep into a reed chamber? do I just put the screws in a place that is not a reed chamber?
I use 6mm long screws, 2mm in the thickness of the brace, only 4mm into the wood. I aim to put the screws into the central rib of the reedblock.
The other way to achieve the same result is a bit crude but works and requires no screws. I short length of thin steel rod, diameter 1 to 1.5mm cut to length so it can be placed at right angles to the reedblocks and wedged between them. Weltmeister and Hohner used to use this method, but I don't like it because it places extra stress on the base plate of the reedblocks, and on the reedblock clamps.
I want a mello, soft, woody, round, flutey, dry sound -- does that make sense? The sound of my dancemaster was better than how this box currently sounds -- can the reeds in this Cairdin be retuned to sound different?
I think you need to visit a good tuner to discuss what you want. I have a friend locally with a Cairdin that has the sort of sound you describe, it is tuned completely dry. It's possible the "too dry" sound of Sharon Shannon is a function of the make of box she plays.
-
Thanks for the ideas guys -
I made a couple more vids trying to capture the sound - but you can't really hear it in the vids -- in the vids, the box sounds pretty much normal --
but when you're over the sound you can hear it.... frustrating...
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=3TjalbnkY4U
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=F_wf5UhlVhM
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=W2z5u8G3dOE
I would describe it as a fuzz coming off the valves -- the reeds don't sound pure - but sound like they are being interfered with --
would taping off one voice and testing it help track down the source of the buzz?
Reed
-
>:E Perhaps you should have traded with the Beltuna after all. >:E
-
would taping off one voice and testing it help track down the source of the buzz?
Might be worth a try. If the buzz disappears then you will know its likely to be a tuning problem.
-
:D Thanks Pete
I always say... "next time I am definitely going to try before I buy..." :'(
I will try running the box on one set of reeds and see how it sounds - I have a feeling it's still going to be buzzy... or funky sounding...
-
Reeds - what's the name of the Jig here ?
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=W2z5u8G3dOE
Nice playing - sorry about the buzz
-
Thanks Gromit -
this little set of jigs is from a great set I picked up off Damian McKee on youtube - http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ZDg3WGq5Qe8
Paddy Fahey's
Dingle David
Malcolm's New Fiddle
-
Thanks very much
-
Reeds, here is a recording of Ian Stevenson playing a C#D Cairdin (http://soundcloud.com/ianstephenson/sets/ian-stephenson-line-up-samples-melodeon-net-special), only track '2 E Flat Tune' is played on the Cairdin. I tuned this instrument for him to his instruction to tune the two reeds absolutely in unison. Is this the sound you are after?
(edited to correct the key of the Cairdin from DD# to C#/D)
-
yes :'(
I like what you've shared - it's got that warm, round dry, "nutty" sound -- not sharp/nasal/jagged
-
Hi Reeds, I like sound of the D/D# Cairdin - is that how you will have yours tuned? Hopefully you'll get yours sorted. I'm sure it will only be something minor. I'm sure Cairdin would welcome any feedback too.
My Sara was much, much drier when I bought it new, but it didn't sound anything like Iain Stephenson's Cairdin. Different reeds - different box.
By the way - NICE JIGS.
-
Hi Reeds, I like sound of the D/D# Cairdin - is that how you will have yours tuned?
Sorry my mistake, I said Ian's Cairdin was DD#, it actually C#/D, but the tune is played in Eb.
-
Hi Theo -
feel free to move this over to Makes and Models if this is getting away from the Recordings and Videos category --
I had a breakthrough tonight - After reading Theo's description of that Cairdin he tuned dry by tuning each set in perfect unison, I thought to myself, "why not try hearing what the box sounds like if I tape off one set of reeds?"
The results of the test are very pleasing! I have found that the round, flutey, woody sound I'm after is a single reed!
a couple sound samples:
2 slip jigs (http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=UrSRuDpNqqg)
3 jigs (http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=0yws-yEFt5M)
same tunes as the earlier vids (previous vids were as the box is normally - 2 voices)
Now the question is:
1.) live with the box with one voice taped off
2.) have the box tuned to get close to perfect unison
3.) look into having a stop installed to switch between one voice and both voices
-
Reed,
I think it's a waste to tape off one voice when you can just have the box tuned unison. Just my opinion, I know that really dry sound is what your going for so two voices tuned in unison gives you twice the volume. Then again you could have a switch placed that allows you to switch to a nice tremolo when you want to play tremolo. Might be a nice combination. What I'm hearing you say is that in a matter of a few months you have decided to go from the full Chorus 4 voice sound of the 4 voice Paolo to a "single voice" concertina style tuning. Quite an evolution of sound there!
--Drew
-
I'd add a step 4): Get the box properly set up so that it doesn't buzz. I have what I think is the same model as you, it doesn't buzz, it's not tuned unison, and it's a great little box.
Having a stop installed will be complicated because as I understand it a reed block will have to be modified to allow a slider to run underneath it. Single-voice? Haven't listened to your vids but what a waste of the accordion's potential.
-
As Reed already knows, I am a bit less scrupulous about tuning ;D but I just wanted to chime in to agree with Steve. One could reduce the sound to a concertina but it seems a waste of a good box.
-
Hi Guys -
well, I'm going to give it a try - I'm going to try the brace idea -
interestingly, on the note that sounds the funkiest - A in the middle of the keyboard - I have these tuning measurements:
reed set 1:
A4
-1 (approx. 1 cent low)
439.7 (measured freq.)
-0.3 (amount below concert pitch)
reed set 2:
A4
+8 (approx 8 cents high)
442.2 (measured freq.)
2.2 (amount above concert pitch)
I wonder if that 8 cents is causing the funkiness?
other than tuning - perhaps there is some sympathetic resonance causing the fuzzy/buzzyness from about low D to middle B
-
The difference is 9 cents which may be fine but that would depend on whether it is fitting in with the differences of the surrounding notes.
-
copying and pasting from excel - hopefully this is legible:
Reed Set 1 Reed Set 2
C row push C row push
E4 -2 329.2 -0.4 E4 -14 163.4 -1.4
G3 -1 195.9 -0.1 G3 1 196.2 0.2
C4 0 261.8 C4 4 262.4 0.8
E4 -2 329.2 -0.4 E4 2 330 0.4
G4 -1 391.6 -0.4 G4 3 392.8 0.9
C5 -3 522.1 -1.1 C5 5 524.9 1.7
E5 0 659.1 E5 1 660 0.7
G5 -3 782.6 -1.4 G5 0 783.6 -0.4
C6 0 1046.8 C6 4 1049.3 2.8
E6 -3 1316.2 -2.3 E6 1 1319.5 1
C row pull C row pull
A3 -4 219.4 -0.6 A3 2 220.4 0.4
B3 -2 246.6 -0.3 B3 0 246.9 0
D4 -3 293.1 -0.6 D4 2 294.1 0.4
F4 -1 348.9 -0.4 F4 2 349.6 0.4
A4 -1 439.7 -0.3 A4 8 442.2 2.2
B4 -5 492.2 -1.7 B4 1 494.3 0.4
D5 -5 585.5 -1.8 D5 -1 586.7 -0.7
F5 -8 695.2 -3.2 F5 0 698.5 0
A5 -2 878.8 -1.2 A5 2 881.3 1.3
B5 -5 984.6 -3.1 B5 0 987.2 -0.5
I've added an attachment of a screen shot - probably easier to read -
-
I have extracted the cents info from your table and calculated the differences for each note. These normally decrease gently as you go up in tone but as you can see your are all over the place. It looks as if your box needs a severe talking too by a tuner.
| | Reed 1 | Reed 2 | Difference |
| E3 | -2 | -14 | 12 |
| G3 | -1 | 1 | 2 |
| A3 | -4 | 2 | 6 |
| B3 | -2 | 0 | 2 |
| C4 | 0 | 4 | 4 |
| D4 | -3 | 2 | 5 |
| E4 | -2 | 2 | 4 |
| F4 | -1 | 2 | 3 |
| G4 | -1 | 3 | 4 |
| A4 | -1 | 8 | 9 |
| B4 | -5 | 1 | 6 |
| C5 | -3 | 5 | 8 |
| D5 | -5 | -1 | 4 |
| E5 | 0 | 1 | 1 |
| F5 | -8 | 0 | 8 |
| G5 | -3 | 0 | 3 |
| A5 | -2 | 2 | 4 |
| B5 | -5 | 0 | 5 |
| C6 | 0 | 4 | 4 |
| E6 | -3 | 1 | 4 |
-
full report - free radicals tend to be in the middle* possibly contributing to the funkiness in the middle range
C row push 1 2 Difference
E -2 -14 12
G -1 1 2
C 0 4 4
E -2 2 4
G -1 3 4
C -3 5 8*
E 0 1 1
G -3 0 3
C 0 4 4
E -3 1 4
C row pull
A -4 2 6
B -2 0 2
D -3 2 5
F -1 2 3
A -1 8 9*
B -5 1 6
D -5 -1 4
F -8 0 8
A -2 2 4
B -5 0 5
B row push
Eb 0 3 3
F# 2 0 2
B -3 0 3
Eb 0 4 4
F# 2 6 4
B 1 5 4
Eb 0 4 4
F# -5 0 5
B -2 1 3
Eb -3 0 3
D -2 0 2
B row pull
G# 0 0 0
Bb -2 0 2
C# 0 2 2
E -1 1 2
G# -4 9 13*
Bb 2 10 8
C# -2 0 2
E -4 -1 3
G# 0 4 4
Bb -3 3 6
C# -1 0 1
-
As Lester said, if those readings are accurate it appears that your whole box is out of tune not just a few funky notes.
-
I wonder if that 8 cents is causing the funkiness?
I had the tuning on my Cairdin checked by our member, melodona, using Dirk's tuner. It was a pretty constant 8 cents throughout the middle range and it sounds great to my ear.
-
I wonder if that 8 cents is causing the funkiness?
I had the tuning on my Cairdin checked by our member, melodona, using Dirk's tuner. It was a pretty constant 8 cents throughout the middle range and it sounds great to my ear.
The sound that Reeds liked, Ian Stephenson's Cairdin is 0 cents difference throughout the range.
-
Reeds,
What do I know, but I think the only way you'll get close to the sound you want is to have the reeds unison tuned. I also think, though, that Cairdin is not building their boxes for a woody, flutey sound. The Cairdins I've seen and played tend to be loud and raucous sounding which cuts better in a band or session setting. They tend to be a little heavy and very solidly made which may go against woody and flutey. Talk with Michael and see what he says about mellowing out the sound. Have you played the box with the grill off? That may help. I hope you figure it out. Cairdins play great.
Joe
-
Hey guys - would just like to report back that I got the Mini back from Michael Usui down at Irish Dancemaster today - he tuned it unison and it sounds just the way I want it!
I'll put some vids up to show how it sounds now that the tuning is where I want it --
-
Hi Guys -
Here's a comparison of the demi swing Dancemaster with the unison tuned Cairdin -
http://youtu.be/eyLuHUP2VEQ
I'm very happy with how Michael tuned the Cairdin - it sounds the way I wanted it to --
I really like both boxes - I would say demi gives that proper traditional accordion sound while dry tuning gives the box a more jazzy/contemporary sound -
I can only afford to be a one box guy though, so the Dancemaster which was on loan to me from Michael is going back to Florida on Monday --
-
Thanks Reeds that was interesting - my preference is for the dry tuned Cairdin it souns great especially for solo stuff and nice playing again, are you self taught and do you play in sessions?
All the best
John
-
Reeds, I've been pretty much blown away by your vids, and I'm learning so much from them so please keep them coming. I generally prefer the wetter tuned boxes, though sometimes that burbling dry-tuned sound is just so right!
Regards, AL
-
Hi Guys -
Thanks for the kind words and encouragement -
I occasionally get out to the sessions here in the Twin Cities - although it is a bit intimidating just because there are so many tunes - I'll get in a few tunes that I know but for me it's about 10% I can play on and 90% I don't know --
you only learn the tunes by going and hearing them over time and working on them at home --
the session vets will usually invite a new comer to start a few sets, so that is very nice - but the established players show up and want to play their tunes, so you need to get up to speed on those tunes otherwise it makes for a long night of listening and not much playing --
I've really enjoyed my box odyssey - I've enjoyed the comparisons in the sounds and feel of the boxes - I hope my vids are helpful for people making a decision on choosing a box -
-
Nice playing, Reed(s). I admire your sure-fingeredness!
-
Hi Reeds, a good back-to-back comparison there. I thought I would like the Cairdin more than the Dancemaster, and LOVELY as it most certainly is, I prefer just a hint of swing.
Bearing in mind that you have had to get the Cairdin tuned to just how you want it - are you now happy with it in terms of general playabillty over the Dancemaster, or would you be happy with DEAD DRY TUNED Dancemaster?
Glad you're happy with it. Nice playing as usual. What was the name of the tune please?
-
Reeds: Glad you got the Cairdin squared away tuning wise. It sounds great to me, very much like Ian Stephenson's BC instrument on the recordings. Great playing on those tunes also. Did Michael Usui only retune the accordion or did he have to do some other adjustments on it? Just curious. Keep the videos coming. All the best. Charlie
-
Hi Charlie and Pete -
Thanks for the note -
Pete - I would say I prefer the Cairdin keyboard action just a bit more than the Dancemaster - but I could be perfectly happy with the Dancemaster - the button spacing is very comfortable --
The Cairdin is really well broken in so the action is a bit easier - but the Dancemaster is a great little box - if I would have just kept with my original Dancemaster and had Michael put Bincis in and adjust the keyboard height and action from my original Dancemaster I would have saved a couple thousands of dollars and a lot of mental energy --
hindsight is 20/20 though - yes - I love the bone dry sound!!! The Swing on the dancemaster is very nice - but I guess I just like the dry sound a bit more -- the name of that hornpipe is Rover's Fancy -
Charlie - Michael retuned it to unison and replaced some valves - there were some other adjustments with the reed blocks and with the reed tongues that he did as well --
Most importantly however, if I were going out and buying a new box today I would buy the Dancemaster because the reeds are better and Michael can tune it exactly how you want it, the keyboard action is very good and the sound is great. And the Dancemaster is $1000 less.
-
how my mini sounds after a couple months of breaking in -
I'm pretty happy with it -
Reed's unison tuned bc Cairdin mini - reed work and tuning by Irish Dancemaster Accordions (http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=PC5p_DjQLs4)
-
Great playing, great sound. How does it work when you ship him the box for tuning? I must admit I'm tempted but I suspect shipping/customs/general confusion might prevent me.
thanks and well-played sir.
t
-
Hi Reeds - the cairdin sounds great and the playing also - nice set (Soggy's looks a bit tricky)
Thanks I'd almost given up on hearing any Irish trad on this forum (:)
-
Thanks Guys -
shipping down to Michael at Dancemaster is pretty quick and easy - I use FedEx -
you call him up and tell him how you want it tuned, that's about it - pack and ship carefully, insure fully, I've never had any problems -
Not sure if shipping between Canada and the US would be a problem - I've sold ebay stuff to buyers in CA and all I recall was there was a form you had to fill out - but it wasn't any more expensive to ship -
Soggy's is a fun little slip jig - I picked it up off on of my girls' Irish dance practice CDs -
-
Hey Reeds, nice video again. I like the sound and you obviously are happy with it. Is it as good to play for dancing as say, the Paolo? I'm always curious as to how the real sound compares to the recorded sound. Unless I hop over the pond, or vice versa, I'm not very likely ever to hear the 'real' sound though - am I? If I ever get a III or IV voice Paolo, or similar I will have the Beltuna Sara II put back to dead dry, unison tuning.
A question: don't you miss the LOW reed at all?
-
I also enjoyed and was inspired by the video. Now I know what sound to request when I send my Double-Ray to Dancemaster for a retuning next month.
-
Hi Pete and Michael -
Thanks for the comments - I would say the box is plenty loud for playing with dancers - interestingly, a dry box is more direct and penetrating and carries better than a box with more spread out swing/wet tremelo - I find dry to be more focused piercing (which isn't always appreciated ;) while demi/swing/wet the sound is wider and more cushioned -
I don't miss the low voice or the bigger sound my Paolo had - perhaps if I played with other people more often I would miss the variety and the big sound that blends and mixes so nicely with other voices -
but since most of my playing is just me practicing at home, I like the more mellow harmonica-like voice of the unison tuning - the full fledged accordion tremelo sound just starts to be too much when you're at home playing alone for hours on end -
the 4 voice LMMM is definitely a charge to play - kind of like driving a really powerful car with a big engine - the 2 voice unison is fun though too -- kind of like driving a sporty small car
interesting point re: real sound vs. recorded sound - I will try to borrow an h2 zoom and make a recording with that to see if the sound quality is different/better - this last vid was recorded on a panasonic lumix digital camera - the accoustics of my garage are pretty good - a bit of ring -
Michael - when you send your box down to Micheal at Dancemaster tell em Reed sent you! :D
-
the mini in the hands of a pro - Michael Fitzpatrick an outstanding feis musician and great guy -
http://youtu.be/PGpjjTOGP_I (http://youtu.be/PGpjjTOGP_I)
-
I always thought it was the other way around Reed, I found my dry tuned Double Ray to blend better in a session and now that I've changed it to sound rather more wet it seems to really clash (in a good way) when played in sessions. Perhaps it's different when it comes to accompaniment for dancers? Great playing by the way...I've always envied your easy fluidity and skill with ornaments!
-
Reeds
thanks for posting the clip of Michael Fitzpatrick - great tune and player