Melodeon.net Forums

Discussions => General Discussion => Topic started by: pete /acorn on March 06, 2011, 12:57:09 PM

Title: Takticks against ebay snipers
Post by: pete /acorn on March 06, 2011, 12:57:09 PM
Hi

I think I have just been caught out by a seller who has a way of using snipe bids to his advantage.He has someone put in a very late bid a lot higher than item worth thus out bidding snipe bids,he then makes a second chance offer to next highest bidder therefore you will pay,if you accept the offer, your max price.
I don't use snipe but bid in last few seconds.
This happened last night and within 10 minutes a second chance offer was received.
Very crafty

Pete
Title: Re: Takticks against ebay snipers
Post by: Theo on March 06, 2011, 12:59:18 PM
Also against ebay rules, and probably as a type of fraud also probably a criminal offence in England!
Title: Re: Takticks against ebay snipers
Post by: HallelujahAl on March 06, 2011, 06:06:45 PM
Very clever and thanks for bringing this to our attention - however, one should always be prepared to pay one's maximum bid, and at least with a second chance offer you have the opportunity to reflect and perhaps refuse?
Title: Re: Takticks against ebay snipers
Post by: Martin J on March 06, 2011, 10:03:45 PM
Does his/her history reflect the likely hood that this is a regular event ?
Title: Re: Takticks against ebay snipers
Post by: MartinW on March 06, 2011, 11:47:22 PM
Shill bidding - it is against eBay's rule, but can be difficult to prove. You can report it to eBay, but I don't know how much they investigate.

As to whether to accept the 2nd chance offer, at least that is your call - better than a shill bid that pushes you up but leaves you as the winning bidder.  My reaction might depend on what the winning bid would have been with the shill bid, how much I really wanted the item, how good the price was, and how likely it was that a similar item would appear again. If I really wanted it, had been looking for the item for ages, and the bid below mine was only a few pounds less then I might consider it. However in most circumstances I think it would be best to regard it as a warning not to deal with a seller who is of doubtful honesty.
Title: Re: Takticks against ebay snipers
Post by: Neil_M on March 06, 2011, 11:53:52 PM
I've refused a second chance offer in the past, I had a change of heart and used the slightly dodgy situation to my advantage. The seller threatened to put in a complaint until I suggested that receiving a second chance offer just 1 minute after the auction ended was a bit odd!

Personally I think ebay is great, most sellers fall over themselves to provide a good service in order to achieve positive feedback. If the seller has very low feedback be careful - it's common sense.
Title: Re: Takticks against ebay snipers
Post by: Johnjo on March 07, 2011, 11:01:02 AM
It's a bit hard to tell, without knowing what the item was, but in some circumstances, a second chance offer might be received rapidly if the seller has more than 1 identical item to sell.

In years past, I've sold harmonicas on ebay, and once or twice, have made a second chance offer when I've had additional, identical harmonicas in stock, rather than having 2 listings. Probably not strictly within ebay rules, but pretty harmless I'd have thought.

On the other hand, you might just have uncovered a new method of scamming unsuspecting bidders....

John
Title: Re: Takticks against ebay snipers
Post by: Alison Scott on March 07, 2011, 02:20:09 PM
I've refused a second chance offer in the past, I had a change of heart and used the slightly dodgy situation to my advantage. The seller threatened to put in a complaint until I suggested that receiving a second chance offer just 1 minute after the auction ended was a bit odd!

Personally I think ebay is great, most sellers fall over themselves to provide a good service in order to achieve positive feedback. If the seller has very low feedback be careful - it's common sense.

Where I have identical items to sell I regularly use second chance offers; I very often have two or three of something to sell, and in a couple of cases I have many. So if an item goes for a good price I'll offer the second and third place bidders a second chance offer.
Title: Re: Takticks against ebay snipers
Post by: savantuk on March 07, 2011, 02:36:50 PM
I've refused a second chance offer in the past, I had a change of heart and used the slightly dodgy situation to my advantage. The seller threatened to put in a complaint until I suggested that receiving a second chance offer just 1 minute after the auction ended was a bit odd!

Personally I think ebay is great, most sellers fall over themselves to provide a good service in order to achieve positive feedback. If the seller has very low feedback be careful - it's common sense.

The seller can threaten all he likes.  You didn't win the auction, so you are not under any obligation to accept a second chance offer.  Only the highest bidder is under any legal obligation.

I've only been offered a second chance once before.  It was a camera lens at nearly 1k.  I used the opportunity to negotiate the price down to below what my highest offer had been.  In this situation, you are the one with the strongest hand - play it.
Title: Re: Takticks against ebay snipers
Post by: Quebecois on March 07, 2011, 09:27:25 PM
Some unscrupulous sellers use various usernames in order to crank up the bids on their own items, then do the second offer thing once the auction is over.

Don't fall for that! If the seller wins her/his own auction then fine! You have no obligation whatsoever since you were not the highest bidder. If the seller insists in offering you the item then report her/him to eBay.
SimplePortal 2.3.5 © 2008-2012, SimplePortal