Melodeon.net Forums

Discussions => Teaching and Learning => Topic started by: Anahata on March 10, 2011, 05:29:25 PM

Title: Melodeon Tablature (or, "how did you do that?")
Post by: Anahata on March 10, 2011, 05:29:25 PM
In the "Cheshire Waltz" ToTM thread, Chris Brimley posted
Quote
I think most of us would benefit from learning how best to play some bits of tunes, and I must admit I do sometimes notice from videos that the player is making a passage difficult when there is perhaps an easier way of doing it - suggesting that we could benefit from pooling ideas.  This really merits another thread I guess, but briefly:  The trouble with the French system IMO is that it's just too complex to follow easily while you're playing, and involves wading through lots of repeated information.  (To illustrate, for most DG layouts, if you have a G chord, and are playing a RHS G note, it would seem to me there's no point being told whether it's in or out or which row it is, because there's only one choice.)  I've found it useful to annotate my music, where the fingering isn't obvious, either with bellows direction or row, as seems intuitive for the particular passage.  I guess this would work with abc too, though I don't tend to use it.

It all started with this posting: http://forum.melodeon.net/index.php/topic,6275.msg79742.html#msg79742

Questions:

The ToTM thread for the tune seems the place for posting annotations to go with the tune.

I guess the video method is best for somebody like DTN (who has done some excellent video snippets), because he doesn't read and write music anyway, and for learners who also don't read and write music.

I quite like the idea of a bellows notation for which (if writing by hand) I might use the symbols string players use for up and down bows. As Chris says, given that you can deduce which row to use. Also that could quite easily be added to ABC for the tune. OTOH the French system adds button numbers to show you how to actually get the notes, rather like Maggie Moore's system for teaching beginners where you don't even have to be able to read the music to find the notes.

Personally I'm not interested in step-by-step tutorials on how to play the tune: sooner or later everyone has to learn to read music or pick up tunes by ear. I am interested in the next stage though: the choices of bass notes/chords/related RH row crossing where there is more than one way of playing the tune.

So, as Chris requested, new thread for discussion of the above.
Title: Re: Melodeon Tablature (or, "how did you do that?")
Post by: Graham Spencer on March 10, 2011, 06:49:58 PM
  • Should we have a place on the forum where players can (if they wish)  post some sort of annotation to go with their YouTube videos or sound recordings posted elsewhere, for others who want to learn from what they did?
  • What's the best notation system? In that thread I posted some rather verbose text that was the easiest to simply type in.
  • What about the tablature the French (and others) use?
  • What about other tablatures?

I quite like the idea of a bellows notation for which (if writing by hand) I might use the symbols string players use for up and down bows.

Blimey, I just play the tunes - I've no idea which way the bellows is (are?) moving or, half the time, which row I'm on, never mind which finger I'm using. I certainly don't want to sit down and analyse every movement of every digit and every limb.  And - before somebody asks - although I do play by ear a lot of the time I also read music; but once I've found my way round a tune I rarely, if ever, look at the dots again and certainly don't consciously think about fingering or bellows direction.  I think maybe there are "instinctive" players and "technical" players, and the twain rarely meet.....
Maybe I'm wrong - feel free to disagree

Graham
Title: Re: Melodeon Tablature (or, "how did you do that?")
Post by: Anahata on March 10, 2011, 07:02:17 PM
I think maybe there are "instinctive" players and "technical" players, and the twain rarely meet.....

I think you're right there.
This thread is not for everyone, but I was led to believe there is some interest from those who want to get analytical, or maybe those who can get through a tune but feel they need some help in learning how to play it better.

It's surprising, as the melodeon is a particularly "instinctive" instrument, at least at some level.
Title: Re: Melodeon Tablature (or, "how did you do that?")
Post by: Bob Ellis on March 10, 2011, 07:07:12 PM
I know that some players don't feel the need for any kind of notation either because they play intuitively (lucky beggars!) or because they don't read music. Personally, I find a system of notation useful as it helps to remind me how I prefer to play the tune. Therefore I note down how I play most of the tunes in (or on the margins of) my repertoire. To be useful, such a system needs to be simple to understand, quick to write down and easy to read quickly when playing the tune.

The system I use and which meets all of those requirements for me is an adaptation of the one I picked up when learning to play from Mally's instruction books. It is used in conjunction with the music notation and comprises an indication above each note of the row on which that note is played, the finger I use to play it and whether the bellows are pushed or pulled. For instance, a note might have D3 written above it to indicate that I play it on the D row with the third finger as a 'pull' note ('push' notes are not underlined). Below the stave, I write bass fundamental notes in lower case letters and bass chords in capital letters. I find this system very effective, but, of course, it won't suit everyone.
Title: Re: Melodeon Tablature (or, "how did you do that?")
Post by: Gary P Chapin on March 10, 2011, 07:29:16 PM
I love the analytical stuff, but I play instinctively. I like using the analysis to figure out what I did a few minutes ago, so I can remember and communicate it to others.  Reminds me of the joke:  an ant approaches a centipede and says, "That's amazing, how do you coordinate all those legs???"  The centipede says, "I don't know, let me think about it."  And the centipede could never walk again.

It's a funny joke, but it's not me.  Love music theory.  Bring it on.
Title: Re: Melodeon Tablature (or, "how did you do that?")
Post by: Thrupenny Bit on March 10, 2011, 07:30:32 PM
I found the notation to go with the Cheshire Waltz very useful.
Though still beginning, I'm working out how to change direction/change rows to get the right chord for the phrase, and it seems to be coming right for me..
Looking through Anahata's detailed description allowed me to compare his ideas with my embryonic attempt at the tune. I'm currently at the 'sorting out' stage with the tune, trying to work out which chord where, push/pull to get it etc, and it's showed me that I am actually doing the same sort of thing albeit somewhat slower. My chordal knowledge is limited, so it has shown me some interesting variations which I'll try next time I squeeze.
Using this notation to be able to confirm I'm on the right track in what I'm doing is a very useful tool for me. For those learners still grappling with the concepts, it's even more valuable ( not that I'm proficient yet!).
I think this as an occasional thing could be a very useful learning tool for us, though I have no idea about notation style. In my own learning process, I try and sort this thing out from the melody dots, and convert abc's to dots, so am in no position to give an opinion about notation.
...thanks Anahata for taking the trouble to anotate the tune, and also giving air to this thread.
Q
Title: Re: Melodeon Tablature (or, "how did you do that?")
Post by: Chris Brimley on March 10, 2011, 07:31:10 PM
Many thanks, Anahata, I guess that having having asked for it, I'd better post my first thoughts upfront!

An inherent problem with any tablature or button system is obviously going to be that there are a huge number of different keyboard layouts in use, and any system could only apply to one of them at a time.  However Chris Ryall has done so very useful work on a unifying structure, which could assist.  It could be that a common D/G two-row system would help many players, but it may on the other hand be better simply to consider developing a nomenclature system that has basic principles which individual users could adapt to their own box, and I must say that's closest to what I've tried to do with my own annotations.

I've found that the first thing you need to add to a melody, before learning it, is the LH bass and chords, and guitar chords (say with lower and upper case letters for bass and chords and suitable rhythm symbols such as forward slashes) seem to be a pretty good way of showing this, and would be immediately recognisable to many other musicians anyway.

The next thing to know is either what RH row you're going to use, or which bellows direction, or which button.  There's pros and cons here:  If you just say 1,2, or 3 for which row, that's usually unique,and so would do.  However, it sometimes seems slower to take in than learning a pattern of bellows movements, so often just showing a pattern of pushes and pulls is quite enough information for the brain to quickly understand at a glance, to guide it into playing the right fingering - if I see ^v^v or v--- for example above the dots (or it could be above the letters in abc) I immediately know how to play each note from my knowledge of the buttons anyway, and that probably also conveys enough information about which LH buttons to use if there's a choice. But often it's obvious anyway, so there's no need to annotate it.

Is that a useful way of looking at this?
Title: Re: Melodeon Tablature (or, "how did you do that?")
Post by: Mcgrooger on March 10, 2011, 07:33:07 PM
I'm finding recently that chord symbols (i.e. the letter plus sharp or flat symbol if any) added to abc notation is the best reminder of how to play a tune. Most of the time, this dictates which direction the bellows have to move. I appreciate that not everyone can read music and I'm not a very fluent reader myself but having used abc freeware for quite a while now, it has improved my reading and, hopefully, to a small extent, my playing. I'm the guitarist in our band and we have a complete book of chord symbols containing the chords for every tune we play which acts as a great reminder and guide for deps etc.
I can appreciate that some people would like a comprehensive guide of how to play a tune but obviously there comes a point where everyone has to take ownership of their own approach to a tune which is what makes TOTM so interesting and varied. That said, if I was learning a new tune and wanted to emulate someone else initially, I'd like to see the abc notation with chords. Anything more than this gets me confused! ???
Title: Re: Melodeon Tablature (or, "how did you do that?")
Post by: Bill the Farmer on March 10, 2011, 07:51:24 PM
I spent some time some years ago working on a system to implement something very similar to the French system in abc. It made use of the w: feature to put button numbers under the notation. I decided it was too complicated to pursue.
Title: Re: Melodeon Tablature (or, "how did you do that?")
Post by: waltzman on March 10, 2011, 07:58:57 PM
I learn the most from the 'slowed down' video format like Sandy just did with Jump and Jiggery.  I can read music and find the notes and chords  very useful to get the tune in my head.  My ear is fair but is often fooled and having the notes to check it definitely helps.  The thing about the melodeon is that there are frequently many different choices of buttons and fingers for the same run of notes not to mention possible harmonies for the right hand and finally the ultimate magic....the rhythm.  This is where the slowed down video is incredibly useful.  The french tab system is useful once you get used to it because it works out the button and finger and chord choices for you.
Title: Re: Melodeon Tablature (or, "how did you do that?")
Post by: Anahata on March 10, 2011, 09:35:11 PM
Thanks Bill for an example of the "French" notation - a fine piece of work but I can imagine as you say it's hard work to do in ABC. That's the kind of notation I meant though. It's good for RH fingering/row/bellows direction choices but apart from showing a simple chord letter doesn't say much about the bass end playing.

Waltzman: Sandy's video was great for the intended purpose of showing use of the thumb or first finger for accidentals, and anything slowed down must be a help (I've seen it done elsewhere on YouTube). I'm not sure how well that works for basses, but I suppose if you show them in the picture and play slowly enough that can be followed too. Using video has the huge advantage that the learner can hear how it's supposed to sound, which is hard to imagine if you've only got squiggles and dots on paper in front of you.

Good stuff!
Title: Re: Melodeon Tablature (or, "how did you do that?")
Post by: oggiesnr on March 10, 2011, 09:55:19 PM
The most useful thing (IMHO), and why I like the Mally books, is the chord structure, from there I can work out where I need to be (and whether it is possible).  The problem I have with tablature is that we all play different boxes so what I play on a G/C will be different to someone elses D/G. However the chords pull it all together.  Also possible to do in ABC!

Steve
Title: Re: Melodeon Tablature (or, "how did you do that?")
Post by: Anahata on March 10, 2011, 10:17:56 PM
For me one thing that's missing from many methods is more detail on how the basses are played.  When you want to get away from Oom-pah basses, just putting "G" on the first bar and "D" on the second doesn't tell you anything useful. And for me the bass end is a melodic line, with chords to fill in when I can't think of anything better, or as a sort of off-beat percussion hit between bass notes.

Ian Dedic has  published his arrangement of Serpentiner Och Konfetti here: http://forum.melodeon.net/index.php/topic,1214.msg10963.html#msg10963 the attached PDF shows one way of doing it, with actual staff notation for the bass end. (The chords are no doubt nominal as not all melodeons have the chord reeds at the same pitches.) This approach works for me because I can read music fluently, used to play the piano and still make multi-instrument arrangements on (at least) two staves. It's also quite hard work to encode as ABC but at least it uses the notation that ABC was designed for.

The thing about the details I posted in the Cheshire Waltz thread is that it took me about 20 minutes to do - an instructional video would have eaten up the best part of an evening by the time I'd set it up, done re-takes, edited it, copied files, uploaded it etc. etc.

Title: Re: Melodeon Tablature (or, "how did you do that?")
Post by: Alan Morley on March 10, 2011, 10:44:17 PM
To be honest - I don't really know what I play when I'm doing tunes - it's interesting to watch myself and try to figure out just what the heck I do. It's all instinctive and unplanned - what works - works.

Same as some guitar things I record - I can't remember playing them - but they are there all the same....my fingers take over from my head and it's the fingers that play the music....

It's absolutely no use to me to sit down and try to work out planned bass runs - I just go with the flow of the tune..

Title: Re: Melodeon Tablature (or, "how did you do that?")
Post by: GbH on March 10, 2011, 10:50:55 PM
Even though I read conventional musical notation, I've certainly derived additional benefit from the French tab system in the past.  It does seem to give a good clue as to how the original player/arranger would have approached it, which is something I've picked up a few hints from.  Obviously, it would be even better if it was written for D/G from the start...

Other than that, as I suspect that my own learning experiences are somewhat out-of-step from the norm, I'm not sure I'm in a good position to suggest anything further.
Title: Re: Melodeon Tablature (or, "how did you do that?")
Post by: waltzman on March 10, 2011, 11:53:45 PM
For me one thing that's missing from many methods is more detail on how the basses are played.  When you want to get away from Oom-pah basses, just putting "G" on the first bar and "D" on the second doesn't tell you anything useful. And for me the bass end is a melodic line, with chords to fill in when I can't think of anything better, or as a sort of off-beat percussion hit between bass notes.

Ian Dedic has  published his arrangement of Serpentiner Och Konfetti here: http://forum.melodeon.net/index.php/topic,1214.msg10963.html#msg10963 the attached PDF shows one way of doing it, with actual staff notation for the bass end. (The chords are no doubt nominal as not all melodeons have the chord reeds at the same pitches.) This approach works for me because I can read music fluently, used to play the piano and still make multi-instrument arrangements on (at least) two staves. It's also quite hard work to encode as ABC but at least it uses the notation that ABC was designed for.

The thing about the details I posted in the Cheshire Waltz thread is that it took me about 20 minutes to do - an instructional video would have eaten up the best part of an evening by the time I'd set it up, done re-takes, edited it, copied files, uploaded it etc. etc.




Well that surprises me.  I would have thought it much easier to film a slowed down version of an arrangement of a tune than to write out a detailed analysis like you did for cheshire waltz. 
Title: Re: Melodeon Tablature (or, "how did you do that?")
Post by: Gary P Chapin on March 11, 2011, 02:29:52 AM
It probably goes without saying, but I'll say it anyway:  the dots or the tab or the analysis are only helpful if you use them ALONG with your ears.  Even if I'm trolling for mazurkas in the Massif Central book, even if I haven't heard the specific tune, I have heard enough mazurkas to develop an aural approach to the tune.

Sometimes I think conversations like this dichotomize into the eyes vs the ears, and as much as I find the dots and tab and analysis useful (and very fun, honestly), without the ears it don't work.

And, recording a slow version of a tune, I find very difficult to play a tune that I've worked up in an artificially slow style.  I make many more mistakes.
Title: Re: Melodeon Tablature (or, "how did you do that?")
Post by: Howard Jones on March 11, 2011, 08:18:15 AM
Notation and tab should complement one another, they're not really alternatives.  They do different things - notation shows you what notes to play, tab shows you the fingering.  Neither really shows you how to play it, which only comes from familiarity with the genre and a 'feel' for that kind of music. 

It's possible to decipher the whole tune from tab but I find it difficult to do as the written tab gives you no clues to the shape of a tune, you're entirely dependent on using an instrument to decipher it.  I'm not very fluent at reading notation and I haven't mapped most of the dots to the buttons, but looking at notation can give me an idea of the shape of the tune, and where it's a tune I already know that's often sufficient to jog my memory.  I only use tab occasionally, to record a particularly complicated or non-intuitive fingering pattern which I'm worried I might forget. 

The biggest drawback with tab is that it is specific to the instrument, and in the case of melodeons to those in a particular key.  Guitar tab is no use to a melodeon player, and vice versa, but both can use the same notation (for the melody line at least).  But where you know what instrument you're going to play, tab can be very useful.

When I write tunes in ABC I don't usually bother with the chords unless I'm playing something a bit unexpected, something I might forget if I don't play the tune for a while so I'll write it down.  I will sometimes use bowing marks to indicate bellows direction, but I do this very sparingly and only where it's significant.

To learn a tune off the page, I'll transcribe the notation into ABC so I can play it back (and easily transpose it if necessary).  Once I've got the tune into my head I'll play it by ear.  I might then make a few additions to the ABC or write out short sections of tab for specific phrases, to help me remember my arrangement.  I wouldn't write out an entire tune in tab, and I would only try to learn one from tab if there were no alternative.
Title: Re: Melodeon Tablature (or, "how did you do that?")
Post by: Chris Brimley on March 11, 2011, 11:16:15 AM
Quote
Notation and tab should complement one another, they're not really alternatives.

I agree with you there, Howard - there's really no point in repeating information.  I think also that there's certain other things that any system could take as read - for example any G box player would play a GBDB note sequence with a G major chord as pushes on the G row, that's the 'intuition' if you like, the system doesn't need to tell the player that.
Title: Re: Melodeon Tablature (or, "how did you do that?")
Post by: Martin J on March 11, 2011, 12:53:17 PM
I spent some time some years ago working on a system to implement something very similar to the French system in abc. It made use of the w: feature to put button numbers under the notation. I decided it was too complicated to pursue.
I agree with Bill, too complicated.  I don't really read but a simple treble clef with guitar chord notation is easy.  I can add hand written notes regarding any additional bass runs etc  ABC is a boon and you can add any extra bass ideas if you want to.  It will play the lot although notating it all by hand is tedious.  Henric Norbeck's ABCMUS will add chords automatically and then you can adjust and alter them quite easily and printed pages can be produced through ABC2win or other similar programmes.

I really like it when posts include the abc and if Anahata, you can include your bass work, even better.  The standard seems to be capital letters for root notes and lower case for the relevant chord.  ie. GgDgGgDgG for a standard umpah but GgDEFGg  etc to add a bass run in G.  Whilst I agree with Chris about intuative bass and chords, the unusual require a method of communication such as upper and lower case tab.
Title: Re: Melodeon Tablature (or, "how did you do that?")
Post by: Thrupenny Bit on March 11, 2011, 06:03:49 PM
Anahata - As you say, a quick scribble for a few minutes and you've produced some notes on the waltz. Brilliant.
It would be wrong of us forumites to expect a blow by blow account, video etc of *every tune* simply as you say, it'll take all of your time to produce. This isn't fair of us to expect it, and I'm sure you'd get fed up too of having expectations wrongly put on you.

Having some form of hints on techniques are particularly good for beginners, and comments such as ' I'm not sure what I do..... I sort of 'do it naturally'/instinctively...' etc are frustrating for those seeking to learn. I now they are honestly said and meant ny the good people on here, but not helpful if as a beginner you have *no idea* how or where to start!

Maybe sometimes it's a simple tip or phrase to emphasise a particular choice of basses, or how to change rows to achieve the 'right' chord etc.... it all helps! Having just tried the waltz mentioned, I've seen and learnt from Anahata how to get Em's and G's in where I'd have bashed away at D's, so we all learn.
Will take a look at Ian's waltz and notation a bit later - must dash and check the tea!
Q in a hurry
Title: Re: Melodeon Tablature (or, "how did you do that?")
Post by: Chris Brimley on March 11, 2011, 06:33:42 PM
Several people have mentioned their use of 'intuition', but actually, don't they really mean 'past learning and experience'?  I suspect that what they have done is to learn subconsciously which notes fit with which buttons, and which runs of notes work with which bass and chords - in fact they have probably learned a lot of musical theory without realising it, and perhaps without being able to explain it.

Which is all very good, and a great trick if you can do it, but not a lot of use to explain to newbies:  "Don't worry son, you'll get it in twenty years' time!"  would be a somewhat frustrating messge to receive.

Also, if you don't understood what it is you've learnt, you may easily inadvertently learn the wrong things which will give you trouble later on.  A box is a complex but strangely logical instrument, so there must in principle be systems that can help explain the musical groundrules.

 
Title: Re: Melodeon Tablature (or, "how did you do that?")
Post by: mikeed on March 11, 2011, 07:08:23 PM
I think Chris has hit the nail on the head for a newby like me. I absolutely love learning to play the melodion - but the way I feel sometimes is that there are players 'out there' who are talking a different language, one that I might get one day if I live long enough!  As you all know, having been newbies at one time yourselves, it's difficult enough getting your brain to work the fingers when you do understand the notation system you are trying to learn (there seems to be a gap just around the wrist level where instructions from the brain constantly take a diversion that was not planned!).   I don't understand why 'tunes' can't be just written/passed on in the same way as George's tutor book? Simple to understand, but then of course you have got to do it through practice, practice ...

Mike
Title: Re: Melodeon Tablature (or, "how did you do that?")
Post by: Thrupenny Bit on March 11, 2011, 07:33:55 PM
Chris expressed what I was thinking sometime today, then promptly forgot when posting....duh!
The process of automatically selecting chords/basses/bellows direction doesn't suddenly 'come in a flash'. Somehow everyone will have gone through a process of learning and committing to memory, but as Chris has pointed out, the actual process of learning has been forgotten, leaving the player simply with an automatic process of playing.
Mikeed has just confirmed this!( Hi mikeed by the way... welcome aboard)
....so we do need help to enable newbies of the world to get from confused to proficient status.
Q
Title: Re: Melodeon Tablature (or, "how did you do that?")
Post by: Lester on March 11, 2011, 07:35:29 PM
I think Chris has hit the nail on the head for a newby like me. I absolutely love learning to play the melodion - but the way I feel sometimes is that there are players 'out there' who are talking a different language, one that I might get one day if I live long enough!  As you all know, having been newbies at one time yourselves, it's difficult enough getting your brain to work the fingers when you do understand the notation system you are trying to learn (there seems to be a gap just around the wrist level where instructions from the brain constantly take a diversion that was not planned!).   I don't understand why 'tunes' can't be just written/passed on in the same way as George's tutor book? Simple to understand, but then of course you have got to do it through practice, practice ...

Mike

How does George's book present tunes?
Title: Re: Melodeon Tablature (or, "how did you do that?")
Post by: Graham Spencer on March 11, 2011, 07:39:38 PM
Well (at the risk of Thread Drift!), in my case I'd had a reasonable grounding in simple musical theory at school; I'm a not-too-bad sight reader these days, but I can only cope with a single melody line, and that only after a lot of practice.  I'd learned guitar by ear as a teenager, and when the morris side I was with in my early 20s lost most of its musicians I was "elected" to learn to play the accordion; I bought a 24-bass piano accordion in a local junk shop, and I think I had about 3 weeks to learn half a dozen tunes and play them in public. Like the prospect of hanging, it concentrates the mind wonderfully!  Over the next few years I found my way round a PA by trial and error and by watching the accordionist in the ceilidh band I was playing guitar and bass in. Then came my road to Damascus moment - melodeons were suddenly the trendy instrument, I bought an Erica at a folk festival and never looked back. That's around 30 years ago now, so yes, I do now play on the back of a long and varied musical experience, a fair understanding of harmony and a basic knowledge of musical theory. It never occurred to me to analyse and rationalise what I was doing, as I never needed to.  Interestingly, after progressing through 24, 48, 72, 96 and 120 bass accordions and then from the Erica to the Saltarelle I play now, I'm actually getting a huge amount of enjoyment these days from a Hohner 1-row - about as basic a melodeon as you could find. In fact I'm playing it for dancing more than the Saltarelle, because it sounds so glorious and has so much punch and lift.  Back to basics, eh?

Graham
Title: Re: Melodeon Tablature (or, "how did you do that?")
Post by: Chris Brimley on March 11, 2011, 08:01:03 PM
I'd like to illustrate my ideas a bit.  Here's a little example, which I want to post and then discuss, but I'm not sure the technology will work yet - it's a Musescore file saved into Acrobat.
Title: Re: Melodeon Tablature (or, "how did you do that?")
Post by: Chris Brimley on March 11, 2011, 09:01:10 PM
Yep, that seemed to work, so here goes!  (NB Apols, most players will of course know all this already and much more, but I just wanted to use the example to explain the annotation example)

I think that in many cases, a melody line and chords should be enough info for a reasonably competent box player to play from.  I accept that this may not give the LH a lot of variation to do, but the first thing is to recognise how to do an oompah, oompahpah, oom - pah, or whatever, regularly, and correctly (compared with what other musicians are likely to be doing).  (Or if your box won't allow it on a particular tune, for goodness sake don't clash with them, that's what not unreasonably gives them the hump!)

I 'learned to learn' from dots, but I see no reason why this shouldn't apply to abc too.

Logic says that if you're going to play a given set of LH chords (and I believe that's the best place to start), you need to find the melody on the RHS somehow so that it's in the same direction.  So taking the previously attached snippet from the 9/8 tune Foxhunters, and say I'm trying to learn how to play it, I want to try first off to play the LH in the right direction to match the chord.  There's 9 quavers in each bar, split into three.  Ideally, I'd like to play 'oom' on notes 1, 4 and, 7, and 'pah' on 3, 6, and 9, but I might settle for just the 'ooms' if that turns out to be too difficult.

I've played up to here in the tune without too much trouble - the notes and the LH seem to fit together, from my past experience of playing (I've intentionally skipped some stages here).  So no annotation was needed - I could just play by reading the dots and the oompah chords.  But I've now reached the first bar on the attached tune.  I want to play a push G chord against this, so I'll try to find a way of playing notes 1, 3,  4, 6, 7 and 9 on push.  This is not all what you'd expect, because on the G row (which I call row 2), the note A (notes 7 and 9), and the note E (note 3) are pulls, so I'll try to find those notes pushing on the other rows.  I find them on the D row (row 1) for the A, and (luckily for me with reversals), on row 3 for the E.  (I can play notes 2, 5, and 8 either way, because I'm not playing any bass then).

So the pattern of V's and ^'s in my annotation tells me where to go for those notes.  It's easy to see the idea from a glance at the annotation for the whole bar - it's a recognisable pattern to my brain, and it indicates a rhythm of pushes and pulls.  

Alternatively, I could write the row numbers above the bar.  This would look like this for my selected fingering:  223112111.  This might be the best annotation method for some people, but I find it less easy to assimilate than the pattern of pulls and pushes, so after trying both I've tended to go for the V^ symbols.

Now I look at bar 2.  These same numbered notes are going to be pulls.  But I know that from experience, so I don't bother to set it out, except for the last F#, which needs to be a pull.  In this case, it might be best to show it as row 2, rather than ^.

So that's basically all it is.  There's often alternative fingerings, so you need to select the one you want to use.  You can add as much annotation as you feel necessary to remind you how to play it.  I find that by keeping it to just the bits that are tricky or where alternative fingerings exist, it's a good way of highlighting those passages to practice just before playing the tune in public.

I'm interested to see whether this is of interest to anyone, but it has certainly helped me remember how to play many tunes.
Title: Re: Melodeon Tablature (or, "how did you do that?")
Post by: mikeed on March 11, 2011, 09:13:37 PM
Lester,
George's (and Maggie's) book present tunes in the ^v^v with button numbers format (don't know if I'm making myself clear). I know I should be reading music and abc, and I do intend to ..  Honestly, I am only speaking from a newbie point of view.  It may be that in the future I will think - what a prat was I - it was simple. But it doesn't seem like that at the moment!
While I was typing this Chris added a reply, but I think my comment is still relevant.
Cheers
Mike
Title: Re: Melodeon Tablature (or, "how did you do that?")
Post by: Lester on March 11, 2011, 09:26:43 PM
Lester,
George's (and Maggie's) book present tunes in the ^v^v with button numbers format (don't know if I'm making myself clear). I know I should be reading music and abc, and I do intend to ..  Honestly, I am only speaking from a newbie point of view.  It may be that in the future I will think - what a prat was I - it was simple. But it doesn't seem like that at the moment!
While I was typing this Chris added a reply, but I think my comment is still relevant.
Cheers
Mike

My query was around the use of button numbers as a method of presenting melodeon tab. The problem is a there ar too many variables, such as 3rd/4th button start, different key boxes etc.
Title: Re: Melodeon Tablature (or, "how did you do that?")
Post by: Chris Brimley on March 11, 2011, 09:33:07 PM
Button numbers might be OK, I guess, but to be honest I think there's another separate problem with this - if you can actually count them when you're playing, you're probably not holding the box in the right position.  I find that finding the right button is more of a 'touchy/feely/listeny' sort of thing than a visual one.
Title: Re: Melodeon Tablature (or, "how did you do that?")
Post by: Bob Ellis on March 11, 2011, 09:34:06 PM
My query was around the use of button numbers as a method of presenting melodeon tab. The problem is a there ar too many variables, such as 3rd/4th button start, different key boxes etc.

That is one of the reasons why I prefer Mally's method of using a number to indicate which finger to use (rather than which button) and a letter to indicate the row, with underlining or no underlining to indicate pull or push. This system is applicable to any type of melodeon in any combination of keys. It does require the user to learn which notes are under each button, but that is essential to learning your way around your instrument anyway.
Title: Re: Melodeon Tablature (or, "how did you do that?")
Post by: Lester on March 11, 2011, 09:45:56 PM
My query was around the use of button numbers as a method of presenting melodeon tab. The problem is a there ar too many variables, such as 3rd/4th button start, different key boxes etc.

That is one of the reasons why I prefer Mally's method of using a number to indicate which finger to use (rather than which button) and a letter to indicate the row, with underlining or no underlining to indicate pull or push. This system is applicable to any type of melodeon in any combination of keys. It does require the user to learn which notes are under each button, but that is essential to learning your way around your instrument anyway.

Couldnt agree with you more, why use some devious code to annotate a button when it already as a label - the notes I plays. It does not take long to learn the keyboard layout of your weapon of choice, the layouts ar available on this site.

I use ABC to play tunes the most I usually do is to underline the notes in blue for G row and red for D row and as I know what button does what nothing else is needed. Admittedly this does not cover basses 
Title: Re: Melodeon Tablature (or, "how did you do that?")
Post by: nemethmik on March 12, 2011, 06:44:05 AM
I prefer Mally's method of using a number to indicate which finger to use (rather than which button) and a letter to indicate the row, with underlining or no underlining to indicate pull or push. This system is applicable to any type of melodeon in any combination of keys. It does require the user to learn which notes are under each button, but that is essential to learning your way around your instrument anyway.
I prefer Mally Mallinson's method of his melodeon tutor book. I extended his annotation method to three-row (GCF, ADG, BbEbAb) melodeons, the numbers (1 - 4) indicate fingers: plain number = inner row, number in box [2] = middle row, number in cirle (1) = outer row; 0,
Underline or overline for push bellows direction. Bass and chord buttons below or above notes.
Title: Re: Melodeon Tablature (or, "how did you do that?")
Post by: diatosoldo on March 12, 2011, 07:02:44 AM
I spent some time some years ago working on a system to implement something very similar to the French system in abc. It made use of the w: feature to put button numbers under the notation. I decided it was too complicated to pursue.

Your notation is a bit similar to the notation I used to use a few years ago (I was told it was Marc Perrone's, but I'm not sure about that ?), which was like that (see attached) and which I found very acute, simple and visually understandable:
First you have a musical sheet to give you a general idea of the tune.
Then you have numbers representing the notes. Numbers above the line are played on C row and numbers under the line are played on G row (for G/C melodeons of course, but the advantage is that you may play it on any configuration of this kind, i.e it works for D/G as well I suppose, though the real notes on the sheet would be untrue).
And  the line between the notes is  white  when you pull bellow  and black when you push.

Now I've moved from Orléans to french Brittany and here they use another system (CADB system for "collectif accordéon diatonique de Bretagne") which you must have heard of  ? There is also another system called "Corgeron system" which is mostly used in the center of France I think.

Diatosoldo


Title: Re: Melodeon Tablature (or, "how did you do that?")
Post by: Simon on March 12, 2011, 09:14:15 AM
I spent some time some years ago working on a system to implement something very similar to the French system in abc. It made use of the w: feature to put button numbers under the notation. I decided it was too complicated to pursue.
I'm using something similar. I've got a modified version of abc2ps giving similar output (but with barlines in the tab). Since most dutch players expect button notation I still use it quite a lot. Once you're used to it it's not that difficult to type in the numbers. For one-row music I've made a script that adds the button numbers automatically.
The (older) example uses quotes for the inner row; I switched to using brackets, e.g. (3).
I haven't checked recently, but I think one of the diatonic accordion extensions has been included in abcm2ps.
Title: Re: Melodeon Tablature (or, "how did you do that?")
Post by: Simon on March 12, 2011, 09:17:53 AM
There is also another system called "Corgeron system" which is mostly used in the center of France I think.
Another system used quite a lot around here has all the button numbers on a single line, where push notes are underlined and inner row buttons are marked with quote, asterisk or brackets. I didn't manage to implement that in abc2ps yet.
Title: Re: Melodeon Tablature (or, "how did you do that?")
Post by: Bill the Farmer on March 12, 2011, 09:54:40 AM
What I did was based on a modified version of abc2ps, I also wrote some scripts to automatically generate the tab using the chords as a hint to the bellows direction with an option of along the row or across the rows playing. The tab on the score I attached was generated using the scripts. I didn't pursue it, because of the complication and because very few people in this country use tab, except for in tutor books, and there are so many fundamentally different systems.
Title: Re: Melodeon Tablature (or, "how did you do that?")
Post by: Alan Morley on March 12, 2011, 09:55:47 AM
My own situation is possibly out-of-step with many people on the forum.

1) I don't read either dots or A:B notation

2) I haven't a clue what notes I'm playing or where to find them on the keyboard.

I just play the tunes by ear.. :|bl

Alan
Title: Re: Melodeon Tablature (or, "how did you do that?")
Post by: Chris Brimley on March 12, 2011, 10:18:37 AM
I'm interested in the various 'French' systems that have been contributed, and having thought about them, I think the suggestion I'm making is actually aiming at a different market niche.

Most of the French systems seem to have similarities with each other in terms of showing the rows in an easy to follow way (and I agree there's something to be said for showing that pictorially rather than the 1,2,3 method), and by setting out the buttons to be used, that should make it straightforward for a novice to learn technique from.

But I think I and Lester would probably find that the problem for more experienced players is that they repeat information - you really don't need to be told which button to use, because given the row, that information is already conveyed by the pitch of the note on the stave.  If you're presented with two ways of showing the note, that merely makes it take twice as long for the brain to assimilate, while you're trying to read and play.  Surely this doesn't make it easier to learn or play from the music, unless you don't know which button plays which note (in which case isn't that what you need to learn first)?

So I agree with Lester that the best thing to do if you want to develop efficient sight reading is to learn to know your instrument first, and my annotations assume this knowledge.  My concept is to provide the reader with the bare minimum additional information needed to select which button to use, where there are alternatives, in the most player-friendly way.
Title: Re: Melodeon Tablature (or, "how did you do that?")
Post by: Chris Brimley on March 12, 2011, 10:28:53 AM
Quote
I just play the tunes by ear..

Actually, Alan, I think we probably all do, anyway!  With most of the tunes I play I have long ago forgotten what the notes are, they just comes out, in fact I sometimes think that the box knows them better than I do.

However I've found that being able to read reasonably efficiently is a skill I wanted to develop because it has all sorts of advantages in terms of learning new stuff quickly, even if you're going to throw away the music after you've learnt it.
Title: Re: Melodeon Tablature (or, "how did you do that?")
Post by: Thrupenny Bit on March 12, 2011, 11:01:19 AM
In reply to Chris and Almo:
I used to play guitar, from chord diagrams mainly, and though reasonable it was 'sight only', following friends in my local by watching and reacting to chord shapes quickly.
I had no idea how to listen, 'playing by ear' for me then would have involved a painful series of headbutts to the guitar using the side of my head  >:E

A long involved path took me from messing on a melodeon in my tent somewhere in Brittany on a morris trip, via anglo to English concertina, driven by the availability of instruments loaned or borrowed, then funds. By the time I had a decent English concertina, I was also using Ali Anderson's 'Concertina Workshop' along with the accompanying lp.
My point being - I had started the process of 'Learning by Ear'. It takes time, it takes some form of connection - the noise heard on lp/musical source with the sound emanating from your box, whatever it might be.
Until recently when starting melodeon, my classic answer to " What note is that?" would be to press the correct button on the English and say " This one"..... if they wanted to know what notes ( as in A,B, C,C# etc ) I would have to stop and count out from G, where my brain and English concertina have fused into a starting point. Like others above me in this thread, I related totally straight to the concertina, then had to start thinking to what that button represented note-wise.
Again,
*This playing by ear took time and hard work. These things do not happen by miracles, it involves a learning process*

If we have a learner asking about how to play such-and-such, they might not yet have developed an ear, or not yet connected with their instrument. This is another learning process they have to do, connect with the box. Any scrap of help given, whether by abc notations, dots, other types of notation etc will start the process.
You can't 'learn by ear' unless you have got to the stage of doing something to make a sound from said box. You then have to connect in the brain that this sound from this button is a note represented by a dot, abc or notation of some sort. A connection has to be made.
We all might learn by ear, but a total absolute beginner might not have developed or learned how to play be ear. It has to be learnt.
They will probably throw up their hands in a frustrated scream if someone says  " well, I play by ear....." and lob the box into a dust bin!!!!

We must not forget that we all started somewhere.
Q
Title: Re: Melodeon Tablature (or, "how did you do that?")
Post by: Thrupenny Bit on March 12, 2011, 11:05:44 AM
.....and I tend to agree with Lester.
Having had a very quick glance at some notations: They seem to be so much more complicated than simply learning the music!
There Lester, we both agree  and I'm not sure either of us are wrong  ;)
take care all
Q
 
Title: Re: Melodeon Tablature (or, "how did you do that?")
Post by: Thrupenny Bit on March 12, 2011, 11:07:37 AM
With regard to my last comment ......oh, Lester's changed his signature  :|bl
Q
Title: Re: Melodeon Tablature (or, "how did you do that?")
Post by: diatosoldo on March 12, 2011, 12:17:19 PM
.....and I tend to agree with Lester.
Having had a very quick glance at some notations: They seem to be so much more complicated than simply learning the music!
Q
 
oh that's true ! I agree : both tabs and ABC notation are really boring and complicated (and I have to know 3 systems here in France : Perrone's, CADB's and Corgeron's !). I often ask myself questions about them and I don't understand why people are re-inventing things which already exist ? Maybe the teaching of traditional music should be differently organised... but this is another debate.
When learning a new tune, my own personal technique is :
First I listen to it (and if I like the tune, I try to get a music sheet or a tab)
Then I read the music.
Then I consider the basses.
And last, if I cannot make up my mind and choose wether it has to be push or pulled, or if a bass can be both pulled and pushed (G and F on my GC melodeon), I look at the tab, but only for lack of anything better.
However maybe we could consider that the difficulty lies in what is NEW for us : So, a person who can read music notes will have some difficulty in reading tabs, whereas a tab reader will be distressed in front of a music sheet ..
Title: Re: Melodeon Tablature (or, "how did you do that?")
Post by: Bill the Farmer on March 12, 2011, 12:35:24 PM
I think, on balance, the best idea so far is Anahata's suggestion of using the up bow and down bow features in abc to indicate bellows direction, and abc also has the facility to add bass notes and chords. Chords are upper case, bass notes in lower case, so in theory you can add as much detail as you want. It also has the advantage that you can ignore it on the score if not wanted without having distracting extra stuff underneath.

I've attached a page out of a morris tune book showing bass notes and chords.
Title: Re: Melodeon Tablature (or, "how did you do that?")
Post by: Alan Morley on March 12, 2011, 12:39:44 PM
Because I do pick up tunes and play by ear - I find that once the tune is memorised, I can almost immediately play it on guitar or mandolin - again without actually knowing what notes I'm playing. All I need is the first note to go from..

I don't play mandolin much and although I can play tunes, I don't know many chords or inversions.

My 'ear' for tunes started back in 1964 when I was a rhythm guitarist in a 'Beat Group'. It used to fall to me to buy a 45 rpm records or tape a song off Pick of The Pops on radio, listen and work out the chords and patterns.

Most of the guitar tabulation / chord websites on the net, have wrong chords for songs which have been submitted by site users - so I just pick ideas up and correct them if I want to learn a song.
Title: Re: Melodeon Tablature (or, "how did you do that?")
Post by: Bob Ellis on March 12, 2011, 01:39:48 PM
It is hardly surprising that there are so many different forms of notation circulating. We have come to the melodeon in different ways and with different experiences, so some (perhaps coming from a guitar background) prefer tablature, others prefer abc, and still others prefer a system based on annotating sheet music. Many will have been influenced by the tutorial books they used as beginners: Mally, George Garside, Yann Dour, Roger Watson and other writers of instructional books each have their own preferred method for noting how to play tunes on the melodeon and these will have influenced those of us who learnt from one or other of their books.

Although it is interesting to read about the systems that others use, I doubt very much whether anyone will change their method once they have become used to it. Where this discussion is useful, however, is in considering what system(s) to recommend to beginners. There is a temptation to recommend the one that the tutor finds the most useful, but different people see things and learn in different ways, so, in my opinion, it is useful to understand a range of different methods so that one can draw these to the attention of beginners, outlining their advantages and limitations. I would probably recommend a particular system that I think might suit a particular student, explaining why that system might suit them, but I would certainly make it clear that there are other systems available and that the choice has to be theirs.
Title: Re: Melodeon Tablature (or, "how did you do that?")
Post by: Simon on March 12, 2011, 03:13:13 PM
Having had a very quick glance at some notations: They seem to be so much more complicated than simply learning the music!
Only if you know how to play. A lot of melodeon players around here are scared of sheet music and don't have the talent to learn tunes by ear. Perhaps they're not the greatest players, but they have a lot of fun being able to play tunes by pressing the right button at the right time. There's a region in the Netherlands using a notion with numbers only (example (http://home.wanadoo.nl/roel.zuiderbaan/it%20alder%20hus.htm)). The easy notation -even for beginners- is probably what makes the melodeon such a popular instrument for people who otherwise wouldn't play an instrument at all.
Title: Re: Melodeon Tablature (or, "how did you do that?")
Post by: diatosoldo on March 12, 2011, 03:51:53 PM
Having had a very quick glance at some notations: They seem to be so much more complicated than simply learning the music!
Only if you know how to play. A lot of melodeon players around here are scared of sheet music and don't have the talent to learn tunes by ear. Perhaps they're not the greatest players, but they have a lot of fun being able to play tunes by pressing the right button at the right time. There's a region in the Netherlands using a notion with numbers only (example (http://home.wanadoo.nl/roel.zuiderbaan/it%20alder%20hus.htm)). The easy notation -even for beginners- is probably what makes the melodeon such a popular instrument for people who otherwise wouldn't play an instrument at all.
the Netherlands example with only numbers does shatter me ... I knew it existed, but I would have to work really hard to get someting out that. I have always been mathematics stubborn or refractory ... so ... ? Think we need something less abstract and more visual, don't we ?
Title: Re: Melodeon Tablature (or, "how did you do that?")
Post by: Gary P Chapin on March 12, 2011, 04:15:46 PM
I have always been mathematics stubborn or refractory ... so ... ? Think we need something less abstract and more visual, don't we ?
Funny, I was always the same way -- math-phobic -- until my third year in college when I took a music theory class and suddenly math started making sense to me.  So music was the "less abstract" thing that opened the door to math for me.

Overall, I'm very comfortable with any of the types of tab.  I'm most familiar with Corgeron's because of the Frederic Paris Cahier de Repertoire, which has been a huge part of my diato life.  But I've used the CADB and others.  The Netherlands numbers don't seem that impenetrable to me.  One thing that Lester said -- there are different melodeons with 3rd start 4th start, different keys -- my sense is that there's a lot less of this profligate variability on the continent ... for example, in Alsace I played with twenty other melodeon players and every one of them was doing some form of G/C 3rd button start.  That's only anecdotal evidence, of course.
Title: Re: Melodeon Tablature (or, "how did you do that?")
Post by: Thrupenny Bit on March 12, 2011, 08:16:26 PM
I think there's a lot of sense being talked here, we come from all types of background, use differing systems to learn, from musical dots to many notation forms.
I think Simon has a major point - a lot of people are scared of sheet music, and will go to extraordinary lengths to avoid it.

I've had an interesting afternoon. Between being a taxi for the family, I've printed off Ian Dedic's version of Serpentina, as given by Anahata ^^ somewhere up there a few pages back - it is written as sheet music with a treble and bass clef  :Ph

Now, I can read a treble clef, if simple and I know the tune, but a bass clef  ??? I haven't seen one for ~ 20 years after attempting  to get to grips with a McCann duet system. As with the English, I directly related the dots on the page to buttons with lots of counting from known starting points, great for a McCann but......... how to cope with Ians' stuff?
I couldn't be bothered to dig around books from ages back, so googled 'treble and bass clefs', got the notes and applied them to the sheet music. By the time my tea had brewed, taken out the tea bag and got some cow juice in, I'd done it. I was staggered!
I then had a few very slow goes and noticed Ian has some nice bass runs as opposed to Um-pahs all the time.

I'm not trying to show off, simply make the point that maybe we are trying to re-invent the wheel....or sheet music really!
It has all the info we need.
We only need to work out what 6 chords and bass notes look like ( for a D/G )
A few simple rules can be added - if a G or B chord/bass is required, you have to push, so the notes in the melody will mostly be pushed.
E,Em and A chords basses need to be pulled, and so does the melody line.... etc. etc....

Perhaps this is over simplistic, but worth a thought......and perhaps something along these lines and Bill the Farmer's too could be of use.  Though we shouldn't try to impose anything on anyone, it might be an idea to try and demistify sheet music, apply it to the melodeon and maybe help out the music -phobes....
( say he ducking and waiting for flack!!!!!)
Q
Title: Re: Melodeon Tablature (or, "how did you do that?")
Post by: diatosoldo on March 12, 2011, 11:09:28 PM
 One thing that Lester said -- there are different melodeons with 3rd start 4th start, different keys -- my sense is that there's a lot less of this profligate variability on the continent ... for example, in Alsace I played with twenty other melodeon players and every one of them was doing some form of G/C 3rd button start.  That's only anecdotal evidence, of course.
Nearly everybody plays on GC melodeons in France, it's quite obvious. So when we meet there is no problem playing  toghether, that's true. And we can play as well with hurdy gurdy and pipes, they are adapted with us too.
But what do you mean by "3rd or 4th start" ? is it the place of the first note of the scale (sol and do for a GC diato) ?
Title: Re: Melodeon Tablature (or, "how did you do that?")
Post by: Gary P Chapin on March 12, 2011, 11:14:28 PM
But what do you mean by "3rd or 4th start" ? is it the place of the first note of the scale (sol and do for a GC diato) ?
Yes, that's exactly right.  Some boxes have a start on the fourth button, having extra lows or accidentals.
Title: Re: Melodeon Tablature (or, "how did you do that?")
Post by: robriki on March 13, 2011, 05:35:27 AM
I'm a self taught guitarist and accordeonist.  I learned music theory by myself, with the help of many books, some friends and a lot of learning and ear training.  Thus, the best way for me is to work by ear, with the possible help of the chord chart and ultimately the music sheet.  I can read, but very slowly...

But, on the other hand, I teach melodeon to groups of adult, often new players.  I have found that the french tablature system work great at the beginning, but it has limitation, as many of you pointed.  Along with ear training it's working out fine with the new players.

I try to develop a relation from my ear to my hand, and to my instrument.  I have found that if i can sing a tune, i'm most likely to be able to play it (giving that I have all the notes...)  It's a matter of time and confidence. 

Title: Re: Melodeon Tablature (or, "how did you do that?")
Post by: nemethmik on March 13, 2011, 05:37:29 AM
But what do you mean by "3rd or 4th start" ? is it the place of the first note of the scale (sol and do for a GC diato) ?
Yes, that's exactly right.  Some boxes have a start on the fourth button, having extra lows or accidentals.
More specifically, some DG boxes have a 4th start button to mitigate the "dusty-end" problem inherent in two-voice DG melodeons.
GC players does not have this issue with their instruments.
Title: Re: Melodeon Tablature (or, "how did you do that?")
Post by: Chris Ryall on March 13, 2011, 07:43:18 AM
The thing about the details I posted in the Cheshire Waltz thread is that it took me about 20 minutes to do - an instructional video would have eaten up the best part of an evening by the time I'd set it up, done re-takes, edited it, copied files, uploaded it etc. etc.

.. there was I thinking you simply sweethearted MH to brew some tea - while you "did the Vid" using equal measures of flair and panache!  (I feel better now)

Thanks to Anahata for starting this. Deep topic and the answers already reflect that. I tried Tab just once in Isere in 1994.  It was a rendition of Pignol's "British Swing" and he taught the piece from it. I think the notation got me going quickly enough, but quite soon group's focus moved to the dynamics of the piece and we stopped looking at the diagram. FWIW I've never seen Pignol or Milleret teach from tab since, though it does get posted in Trad

My lad loves Tab for his guitar. It's simpler there - just string+fret with a few symbols for left hand effects. We've got row+button+push/pull just for starters, and logically "a few symbols for right hand effects".  Then we have to essentially double that if we are to notate the rich things people do with the left end.  So a big and technical challenge. I've been a bit short in the past on theoretical thread with people whose only contribution has been "this is too much for my small brain" - but may we perhaps focus on why we might want to do this - it it worth it?

   Well, Tab seems to me most useful for beginners and advancers. It's popular with the non music reader - yet frankly encourages this approach to music? It would seem that to notate any sort of arrangement seems to require about 8 degrees of freedom.  Yet as we move from beginner to player .. well my experience has been that you learn to play one end on autopilot while you focus on something 'clever' at the other, and then perhaps reverse that process next practice?  So that's where we want to end up.

I really haven't wrapped my mind round this yet - hence this "what is it about" approach. However I seem to be arguing myself to a conclusion that there might be a good place for a Melnet Tab notation for special effects at each end.   A 'defined MelTab' would certainly be better than the improvised bass descriptions I (and others) have emitted in the past eg  "Om <cut short><gap> Paaaah" etc etc.  :|bl

I do suspect notating a full tune might genuinely be too much for even the Einsteinian brain (he had an extra gyrus y'know!) - but a very interesting thread!
Title: Re: Melodeon Tablature (or, "how did you do that?")
Post by: Thrupenny Bit on March 13, 2011, 11:57:15 AM
As you say Chris - Deep Topic, but inherantly good that we take time to think about it.

As I've just read the recent posts, particularly robriki talking developing ear to hand co-ordination, I wonder if we are trying to bite off more than we can chew?  i.e. Perhaps there are two threads in here.
1. Getting beginners off the starting blocks - somehow trying to get this ear-to-hand co-ordination going, thereby opening up the avenue of learning by ear. As robriki and myself have pointed out, learning by ear is a skill therefore it has to be learnt, so help in getting absolute beginners on the road to establishing this. Maybe here a simple tabulature is something that can help. We all want to get up the road a bit when starting, getting to that First Tune as fast as possible, it's human nature!

2. Maybe the second thread interwoven is that others want to know a little more. Once off the starting blocks you might want to know how to do bass runs, cross basses/chords etc. You have got going a little, are getting tunes out but want a nudge in the right direction for other things. This can also apply to experienced players reflecting on aspects of their playing and wishing to improve. Here we might not especially want a fully annotated tune or video, but a snippet of 'how to do'.....  I'm thinking of a recent thread I started about cross basses/chords, and Chris kindly has put a snippet of the Orange in Bloom waltz on Youtube showing exactly what happens in part of the B music, where he cross basses/chords.
In such cases a simple tabulature might not be the answer, but a combination of -say- a small video,  with notes on what is actually happening, and why, or a fully annotated bar or two of music/tabulature explaining the idea. Again we need to consider that the tutor has other things in his/her life so it musn't be overly time consuming, or else it's not fair on them.

Having started playing in the summer, the learning process is particularly vivid in my mind, hence me chatting a lot here. I have had an unbelievable amount of help from the kind people here, of which I am incredibly grateful for their time and generosity, and also quite amazed at the speed and amount of knowledge imparted to me. I also realise I've been lucky to come in with a fair knowledge of the music I want to play and can play by ear, both attributes acquired from my other instrument.
Others are less lucky, desperately want help but have no idea how to start. I know....that was me sat in a tent in Brittany in '78, with no Menet and no tutor books or learning aids at the time! It is a frustrating place to be......
Q
in need of  :|||:
Title: Re: Melodeon Tablature (or, "how did you do that?")
Post by: Bill the Farmer on March 13, 2011, 12:45:57 PM
As you say, there are two threads here. The first one is getting beginners started, and I think that that is adequately covered by the various systems used in tutor books and the Belgian and various French systems mentioned. The players who use them must be happy with them, or they wouldn't use them. Once started, most people will forget the tab and get on with playing tunes.

The second is where Anahata started from, and that is a simple way of showing how a particular rendition of a tune works. You don't need detail, you can probably already play the tune, and you know where the notes are on the box. What you want to know is which way the bellows are going for each bit, and what bass notes and chords are being played. As I said before, I think the up bow and down bow marks cover the bellows, and you can put in as many bass notes and chords as you like. You don't even have to use abc, you should be able to do that with any decent notation software.
Title: Re: Melodeon Tablature (or, "how did you do that?")
Post by: Gary P Chapin on March 13, 2011, 01:48:35 PM
What you want to know is which way the bellows are going for each bit, and what bass notes and chords are being played.
I agree, I also find it interesting to know why the player made the choices they made.  If we were in person and I saw Anahata playing "Cheshire," I'd buy him a beer and just have a great conversation.
Title: Re: Melodeon Tablature (or, "how did you do that?")
Post by: jack on March 13, 2011, 05:05:12 PM
Reduction based on Anahata's March 2nd video..
Title: Re: Melodeon Tablature (or, "how did you do that?")
Post by: Gary on March 13, 2011, 05:38:11 PM
Having somehow learned by ear, then found Mallys books and Cds which matched my DG box I have made  a lot of progress thanks to his advice in the book and in person,his key word being PRACTICE. So I now have about 200 tunes in my head and a resolve to learn to read music as found in his and many other tune sources. This way I can put together sets and also fill in the gaps in my knowledge about music theory.in the last few years we have got a local session going and having a written set of prompts helps a lot.
Title: Re: Melodeon Tablature (or, "how did you do that?")
Post by: Thrupenny Bit on March 13, 2011, 05:47:10 PM
Thanks Jack, better than my scribbles!
Q
Title: Re: Melodeon Tablature (or, "how did you do that?")
Post by: Chris Brimley on March 14, 2011, 07:52:35 AM
Jack, I think you have pretty convincingly demonstrated that the stave/G g g system takes the player a very long way.  I find that example gives a very good insight into how Anahata is playing that piece.

Dots seem to me to have various advantages over other systems, in the context of box playing: 

1) the rise and fall in pitch is shown intuitively
2) the 'timeline' and the note length symbols together give a good idea of the intended rhythm
3) reading at a steady speed is made easier
4) because it's 2-dimensional, simultaneous musical 'events' such as accompaniment and lyrics can easily be shown vertically
5) it's easy to show simultaneous and overlapping notes
6) the structure of a tune is set out clearly, encouraging quick learning.

I think many players are shy of trying it out, perhaps thinking it's too academic, but it's not, it's basically intuitive.  I think an easy way to start is like this:  just learn where the major triad (main push) notes are - that's GBD on the G row, and DF#A on the D row - and all the others will fit in between, using point 1) above.



Title: Re: Melodeon Tablature (or, "how did you do that?")
Post by: Anahata on March 14, 2011, 08:52:27 AM
I've printed off Ian Dedic's version of Serpentina
...
I then had a few very slow goes and noticed Ian has some nice bass runs as opposed to Um-pahs all the time.

Yes, you've correctly identified the reason why I posted that link. It is hard work to decipher, but it tells you exactly what's going on in the bass end.

And then:
Jack, I think you have pretty convincingly demonstrated that the stave/G g g system takes the player a very long way.  I find that example gives a very good insight into how Anahata is playing that piece.

Dots seem to me to have various advantages over other systems, in the context of box playing:  

Looking at Jack's transcription, with the convention of caps for bass notes and lower case for chords, I have to agree. I  can see clearly what's going on, it goes a lot further than just the notes and stuff like bellows direction and which row to play on can be deduced from the notation given. It's also useful for other chord-playing or bass instruments because you can optionally ignore the upper/lower case and you have the usual chords. Perhaps that's all that's needed, and if the situation arises again I'll use that notation.

Incidentally I make no apologies for the use of staff notation for the tune itself. I'm familiar with it because I've used it for years, and the first time you see several musicians all on different instruments playing a tune from the same sheet music you really get the point of a standard notation. I do have some sympathy for those who are learning it for the first time as it's hard work, but it's such a transferable skill that it's worth learning.

Button number tablature is OK for complete beginners as a confidence booster, but really the training wheels should come off as soon as possible.
Title: Re: Melodeon Tablature (or, "how did you do that?")
Post by: Martin J on March 14, 2011, 10:35:59 AM
Jack has brought us back to page one (http://forum.melodeon.net/index.php/topic,6381.msg79961.html#msg79961) with an excellent graphical illustration.  The only addition I would recommend for newbies is if there is an ABC programme which will do what some piano tutor books do and that is to show the letter of the note to be played within the note symbol.
Title: Re: Melodeon Tablature (or, "how did you do that?")
Post by: Chris Brimley on March 14, 2011, 02:26:59 PM
Anahata, I am pretty much in agreement with you on all this. 

We do all seem to have come full circle on the topic, but I would just like to add to your comment:

Quote
Perhaps that's all that's needed,

by saying that my original point was that there are often alternative fingerings available (probably more so the larger the box), and I was seeking views on ways of showing them, where necessary or helpful in remembering how to play a tune.  I think the conclusion that I'm firming up on for myself is to stick with the stave/chord system, but adding the occasional V's or row numbers.

I think it is very true that this is very much a personal thing, and will depend on how people happen to have learned to play, but that doesn't mean that it's not worthwhile discussing the pros and cons of each system, for future learning.

I think the discussion so far has all been very useful - thanks.
Title: Re: Melodeon Tablature (or, "how did you do that?")
Post by: Bob Ellis on March 14, 2011, 03:39:28 PM
I am quite surprised that the majority of people who have posted on this thread seem to favour notation systems that do not indicate which finger to use. In my experience, this is something that is very important for beginners - and also for more experienced musicians who are beginning to play in unfamiliar keys that require the use of accidentals.

If a tune has a wider range than a single octave, then the hand is going to need to move up or down the keyboard and this often causes problems for beginners because they are don't know how best to avoid running out of fingers. Mally's system shows how to overcome this problem (and there may be other systems that do so), but notation systems based on a number that represents the button to be pressed rather than the finger to be used do not.

In my opinion, one should learn at an early stage which notes are under each button and this should be used with 'the dots' (the basics of which are very easy to learn) to identify where the required notes are to be found. I would reserve numerical annotation for indicating the finger to be used to play each note.
Title: Re: Melodeon Tablature (or, "how did you do that?")
Post by: Martin J on March 14, 2011, 03:49:40 PM
Whilst I can see your conundrum Bob regarding which fingers etc the real choice lies in the basses used.  In another thread, or earlier in this one I'm not sure, it was recommended that everyone should have two keyboard maps, one push, one pull.  The direction of bellows is in the main dictated by the chords required.  Knowing which way the bellows are going, one glance at the relevant keyboard map will instantly show the fingering required.

Where there are more buttons than fingers for a phrase then look for where you may change fingers whilst still keeping a button depressed.  Having such an anchor point allows you to find the next buttons quite readily.  Jumps and leaps around the keyboard come only with year of experience and even then one doesn't always land in the right place.
Title: Re: Melodeon Tablature (or, "how did you do that?")
Post by: Bob Ellis on March 14, 2011, 04:49:11 PM
Whilst I can see your conundrum Bob regarding which fingers etc the real choice lies in the basses used.  In another thread, or earlier in this one I'm not sure, it was recommended that everyone should have two keyboard maps, one push, one pull.  The direction of bellows is in the main dictated by the chords required.  Knowing which way the bellows are going, one glance at the relevant keyboard map will instantly show the fingering required.

Where there are more buttons than fingers for a phrase then look for where you may change fingers whilst still keeping a button depressed.  Having such an anchor point allows you to find the next buttons quite readily.  Jumps and leaps around the keyboard come only with year of experience and even then one doesn't always land in the right place.

Whilst I agree with you for more experienced players, I think the idea of having to consult two keyboard maps plus a method of noting how to play the tune is too cumbersome and confusing for beginners. When teaching beginners, I believe in keeping things as simple and user-friendly as possible. I prefer a system that shows which row and which finger to use. That is why I favour Mally's system with the addition of a symbol to indicate bellows direction.
Title: Re: Melodeon Tablature (or, "how did you do that?")
Post by: Thrupenny Bit on March 14, 2011, 05:08:22 PM
Perhaps we should try and encourage progression.
Start on basic tab forms, like Mally's ( it helped me!) with help to progress onto music. A few basic ideas of what the buttons mean, which note etc...  to aid the cross over to music, with an implication that 'music is the best way forward'. Our Home page has good basic information, perhaps we could aim to get a document on it along the basic tabulature and progressing to music theme?
It might help dispel the " Arghhh.....music, noooo " phobia, and as said, sheet music can impart a whole lot of information.
( Though with notation, we might end up duplicating some tutor books if we're not careful. )

I felt a penny had dropped when I twigged the idea of bellows direction required for certain basses, in some ways it's a concept that once understood can open a lot of doors as to which directions you work the bellows. Some posters here seem to be struggling, understandably so, if we could explain that, using either tabs or music, I think it's a good solid point to get over.
Q
Title: Re: Melodeon Tablature (or, "how did you do that?")
Post by: Martin J on March 14, 2011, 06:13:39 PM
From your reply Bob I see that I didn't expand far enough.  You only need refer once or twice to the keyboard map.  Once you are familiar with which fingers to use for which phrases against a bass structure you never need to refer again.  To use an analogy, it is like creating musical lego blocks, pieces that can be used again and again in different circumstances and tunes.  As you add your pieces so your repertoire builds until you intuitively know where to put your fingers for any given result.

On re reading your response though it seems you are now speaking as the tutor not the pupil.  Everything I have had to say so far is so that a novice may learn in isolation.  I taught melodeon by showing which fingers went where, which way the bellows were going and had the student do it.  I chose first tunes which only used four right hand buttons but more complicated basses.  Once this first step had been grasped, one or two lessons at the most I would then have the student draw their own keyboard map as homework and the next lesson show on the map exactly what they had done.  The next tune would then use the same finger patterns, runs and basses but add just one extra element (another musical lego block if you like)  This method worked extremely well but needed the tutor (me) to intimately know each and every tune being used in the building process.

The topic is " 'how did you do that ?' / music tab" to which I was contributing a method which needs no tutor but of course being on your own it is more cumbersome, more long winded and sometimes tedious, particularly if you don't already read music.  There is no substitute for having a tutor giving basic teaching - show them, have them show you and then drill for skill.

Very soon you have  (:)  :D  ;D  :||: :|||:  :Ph
Title: Re: Melodeon Tablature (or, "how did you do that?")
Post by: Thrupenny Bit on March 14, 2011, 07:30:13 PM
I suspect most will not have a formal tutor such as N.S.A. but either 'go it alone' or have an occasional mate who shows them which fingers to waggle when most appropriate ( technical term  ;) )
If we can pitch it for those which need most help ( go it aloners ) then others can still participate maybe at a quicker speed.

I, amongst others, mentioned a finger chart where I coloured in scales achievable on the pull, then another chart with those on the push. I'm not sure I've referred to it much since, but the actual exercise of sitting down with a coloured pencil and colouring it in helped me enormously. It gave me a picture in my mind rather than an empty space  ::).
We are all different, learn in different ways, but I find sometimes doing something simple and also visual when thinking about things normally heard - musical things - was quite illuminating.
...but we're all different!
Anyway, must go, time for  :M
night all
Q
Title: Re: Melodeon Tablature (or, "how did you do that?")
Post by: Simon on March 15, 2011, 12:03:28 PM
the Netherlands example with only numbers does shatter me ... I knew it existed, but I would have to work really hard to get someting out that. I have always been mathematics stubborn or refractory ... so ... ?
Don't worry. Despite being dutch and having a phd in mathematics I can't read it either.  ;)
Title: Re: Melodeon Tablature (or, "how did you do that?")
Post by: diatosoldo on March 15, 2011, 09:19:26 PM
the Netherlands example with only numbers does shatter me ... I knew it existed, but I would have to work really hard to get someting out that. I have always been mathematics stubborn or refractory ... so ... ?
Don't worry. Despite being dutch and having a phd in mathematics I can't read it either.  ;)
oh la la ...  :|||: this deeply thooses me ! really. So, I'm no longer alone ...
Title: Re: Melodeon Tablature (or, "how did you do that?")
Post by: Chris Brimley on March 16, 2011, 11:48:38 AM
Quote
I am quite surprised that the majority of people who have posted on this thread seem to favour notation systems that do not indicate which finger to use. In my experience, this is something that is very important for beginners - and also for more experienced musicians who are beginning to play in unfamiliar keys that require the use of accidentals.


Bob, I think you have a point here, and we should perhaps discuss it more.  I personally have found that I sort of automatically choose fingers from looking at whether the tune is going up or down next, and I have also noticed that I can often play the same button pattern using different fingers, but without thinking about it - it's as if the brain is somehow thinking in terms of patterns of buttons, rather than which fingers to use.  But just because I seemed to have learned this unconsciously, that doesn't mean that I haven't learnt it, and therefore to show it on the stave somehow would be worthwhile.  I don't think that I would need the whole thing, though, just attach a suitable nomenclature to one or two notes at the start of a run.  (eg T, I, M, R or L for thumb, index, middle, ring, or little?)

There's a related issue here to do with fingering - I've found that my main problem in playing accurately nowadays concerns rapid big leaps across buttons - it's so easy to hit the wrong one if you don't get it just right, and that can put the whole passage out disastrously.  (For example, there's a little passage in McNamara's band where I have to play EDB against an Em chord followed by A against an Am, and the easiest way I've found is to start on the L finger on the third row, followed by R finger on the third row, then jump to R on 1st row, then Index finger on the 2nd row.  I frequently cock it up!)  It may be that if I give myself some reminders about which finger to start the run with, and try to economise on movement, that would reduce this problem.  Has anyone got any related experience on this sort of thing?  I've noticed from people's vids that we all seem to have vastly different techniques in terms of RH movements - some seem to find safety in a vice-like grip, and others like darting about.  Maybe the pianists among us may have some words of wisdom?
Title: Re: Melodeon Tablature (or, "how did you do that?")
Post by: Stiamh on March 16, 2011, 01:30:54 PM
There's a related issue here to do with fingering - I've found that my main problem in playing accurately nowadays concerns rapid big leaps across buttons - it's so easy to hit the wrong one if you don't get it just right, and that can put the whole passage out disastrously.  [...] Has anyone got any related experience on this sort of thing?  I've noticed from people's vids that we all seem to have vastly different techniques in terms of RH movements - some seem to find safety in a vice-like grip, and others like darting about.  Maybe the pianists among us may have some words of wisdom?

Interesting point Chris and this should probably go in a different thread. 

I'm definitely a darter and in a lot of the tunes I play on the system I play (Irish on C#/D) there is no escape from zooming around the keyboard at high speed. I've also spent, and continue to spend, considerable effort trying to find the safest and most accurate fingering for problem passages.

In my case safest and most accurate is very often at odds with what would appear to be most efficient, elegant, or economical visually, or logically, on paper. Or what would have any parallel with piano fingerings (I don't play piano, but I am closely following my young son's steady progress on the instrument under the guidance of expert teachers, so I see what happens there).

In nearly every case of a particularly tricky passage, I have found that the answer lies in using fewer fingers. I practically never use the little finger anyway, but jettisoning the ring finger often makes all the difference, even where the nasty passage involves big leaps. Between them my index and middle fingers have a speed and sure-footedness (can I throw in the word "proprioception") that the other fingers just cannot match.  There's little point in my providing examples, I think, since I play C#/D, but could if anybody is sufficiently interested.

I realize 95% of the players here will think I am misguided, not to say out to lunch. All I can say is, this approach works for me, in the music I play, on the system I play, with the hands I have - and I always try other alternatives.
Title: Re: Melodeon Tablature (or, "how did you do that?")
Post by: Gary P Chapin on March 16, 2011, 03:20:11 PM
In nearly every case of a particularly tricky passage, I have found that the answer lies in using fewer fingers. I practically never use the little finger anyway, but jettisoning the ring finger often makes all the difference, even where the nasty passage involves big leaps. Between them my index and middle fingers have a speed and sure-footedness (can I throw in the word "proprioception") that the other fingers just cannot match. 

After telling us how sure-footed your fingers are, you can throw in any word you want.  Proprioception!  I love it!  ;D

Anyway, I agree with your observation that fewer fingers helps with trickier passage -- even if this does put you at risk of being classed with "three-fingered" guitarists.  There are passages that don't seem difficult on the face, that I have to completely deconstruct and rebuild using two fingers, and finally I get them.  Also, the two-fingers-reduction (not a whiskey reference!) helps a lot with the twiddly-bits and ornaments that I sometimes want to add.
Title: Re: Melodeon Tablature (or, "how did you do that?")
Post by: Graham Spencer on March 16, 2011, 04:05:05 PM
Anyway, I agree with your observation that fewer fingers helps with trickier passage -- even if this does put you at risk of being classed with "three-fingered" guitarists. 

Hey, two fingers worked pretty well for Django..........
Title: Re: Melodeon Tablature (or, "how did you do that?")
Post by: Thrupenny Bit on March 16, 2011, 04:53:20 PM
On occasions I too use two fingers.......but mainly on non melodeon related gestures......
 ::)
Q
Title: Re: Melodeon Tablature (or, "how did you do that?")
Post by: Martin J on March 16, 2011, 07:18:00 PM
Chris, I think you've answered your own question.  It is the button pattern that is important not which fingers to use.  As Steve says, he uses what is comfortable to him and I think that's as it should be.

On thread then how best to convey to someone else what the button pattern is that you wish to share then simplest seems best.  Stave for treble, upper and lower case for bass.  Sort out your own fingers.  Nature's pain response will tell you if you are very wrong  ;)
Title: Re: Melodeon Tablature (or, "how did you do that?")
Post by: Bob Ellis on March 16, 2011, 11:03:43 PM
As Chris B and Steve J have both said, there are occasions when an unusual pattern of fingering is needed to play a particular phrase smoothly and it would be helpful to be able to make a note of that pattern. This is one argument in favour of a system of notation where the numbers refer to fingers rather than buttons (the position of buttons on a box remains constant, but which finger to use for a particular note does not). As I have mentioned before, another argument is that beginners are often very unsure of which fingers to use and therefore a notation system that indicates that would help them. This may be one reason why so many beginners have found Mally's instructional books useful over the years. Of course, such a system will not suit everyone, but, for those who might be interested, I have attached an example of the system I use.

The sheet music, of course, indicates which note to play, the duration of the note etc. The melodeon notation is probably self-evident, but, in case it isn't, the line above the stave is for the melody and uses a letter to indicate the row on which the note is to be played and a number to indicate the finger to be used. The line below the stave is for the basses and uses lower case letters for fundamental notes and capital letters for chords. A lower case letter and a capital are used together when the fundamental and the chord are to be played simultaneously. For both the melody and the basses, notes to be played on the pull are underlined and those to be played on the push are not. I use a smaller font for grace notes and other optional ornaments, but that is just a personal idiosyncrasy.

I have attached this tune, rather than any other, for two reasons. Firstly, it is an example of a tune where the time signature changes (albeit briefly), which is the topic of another current thread. Secondly, I am puzzled as to why it was written down with three sharps (key of A or F# minor) rather than two sharps, when all the G notes are naturals rather than sharps. Furthermore it resolves on a B, which makes me think that the tune is in B minor, which would normally be written with two sharps. But perhaps I am wrong and it is in one of those modes that I don't understand fully.  I would be grateful if someone could explain.
Title: Re: Melodeon Tablature (or, "how did you do that?")
Post by: Stiamh on March 17, 2011, 12:29:48 AM
Secondly, I am puzzled as to why it was written down with three sharps (key of A or F# minor) rather than two sharps, when all the G notes are naturals rather than sharps. Furthermore it resolves on a B, which makes me think that the tune is in B minor, which would normally be written with two sharps.

The three sharps with all the Gs being marked natural is fairly common in stuff notated by people who don't really believe in modes. (Can't believe I'm jumping into a discussion about modes before Chris Ryall  ;)  ) Such people think, oh it must be in A major, and the natural Gs are accidentals. When most folkies would say it's in A mixolydian, meaning A with a flattened seventh, ergo two sharps.

Bob, you're in danger of falling into a similar trap yourself by assuming that just because it ends on B, it ought to be in B minor.... classical thinking.

I have come to the conclusion that modes are an imperfect answer to all the conundrums of tonality in folk tunes. Quite a few Irish tunes that one might easily assume to be in Dorian or Mixolydian have other features that don't really fit that pattern and no doubt this applies to tunes from other traditions. So while I describe things as being in this or that mode for convenience, I do so with mental reservations.

I haven't tried playing your tune, but without whatever conclusions that might lead me to about its real tonality, I'd just say, put a key signature of two sharps and let others worry about what box to fit it into.  :|glug

Edit: trying to hum the tune from the music, it reminds me of some of those Irish tunes I alluded to above, ones that land on a final note that, given the way the tune starts and develops, is unexpected, at least to a conventional musical mind. (A familiar example to people here might be the American tune Over the Waterfall, since IIRC that tune shows all the appearances of being in D major but resolves on G.) Tomas O Canainn, expanding on the work of Sean O Riada, calls these "tunes with complex tonalities" and proposes a system for determining their tonic, or home note, by weighting notes in the tune depending on their frequency or position and crucial points. This in his 1970s book "Traditional Music in Ireland". All very interesting, but... yeah yeah.
Title: Re: Melodeon Tablature (or, "how did you do that?")
Post by: diatosoldo on March 17, 2011, 06:33:26 AM

Maybe this could help ? it looks like it, doesn't it ?

http://www.dailymotion.com/video/xbhvau_les-gnous-les-forgerons-aiment-le-v_music

Title: Re: Melodeon Tablature (or, "how did you do that?")
Post by: Chris Brimley on March 17, 2011, 11:04:10 AM
Bob, I tried playing your tune from your score, and it's an unfamiliar tune to me, so I found it a good test.  I do quite like your annotations, and I think that your system is economical.  On the other hand I did find that I was getting lost with trying to interpret lots of information at once, and I eventually found it easier to play from just the dots and chords, looking at the top line when I was unsure how to play it.  One thing I didn't find easy was simultaneously processing the information with a note D, a chord D, and a row D - OK that example would be easy, but other combinations were more confusing.  Maybe practice would ease this.

If I were annotating this tune for myself using your system, I might just put a few annotations in, over the tricky or alternative fingering passages, rather than the whole lot.  But I do think that with a bit of study, this is a useful way of conveying more about how a tune is to be played. 

Something else with your system that I thought might be useful is maybe a finger slide indicator on the top line, say -, /, or \, or even l with a 3-row box.
Title: Re: Melodeon Tablature (or, "how did you do that?")
Post by: Bob Ellis on March 17, 2011, 12:20:24 PM
Thanks for your comments, Chris. I included the whole notation to show how I would write it out for a beginner (although this is not a beginner's tune), but when using the notation for myself I would only note down difficult or unusual passages.

I think it takes time to get used to any system, so I am encouraged that you followed it without too many problems. Coming to it fresh, it is probably best to use the dots and the notation above the line for the right-hand fingering first to get that pattern in one's mind and then add the bass line when you no longer need to look at the top line. As a system for sight-reading, I agree that there would be too much to take in at once, but it was not intended for that. Its purpose was to record all the relevant information so that one can refer back to whichever bit one needs at any given moment. Even the beginners with whom I have used it seem to pick it up very quickly.

I appreciate your suggestion about a symbol to indicate a finger slide. It is a good idea and I shall think about the best way to incorporate it.
Title: Re: Melodeon Tablature (or, "how did you do that?")
Post by: Gary P Chapin on March 17, 2011, 01:24:57 PM
Bob, great work.  Very interesting.  I'm going to go against the consensus of the group and say I prefer a tab that is not pitch specific, but shows buttons for a typical system and direction.  One of the magical things, to me, of these instruments, is the transferability of fingerings to different keys (instruments).  So, using Corgeron or CADB tab, I can pick up any of my boxes and learn the frame of the tune.  Even if it's not in the key of the dots, or the key that other people play in, I can fix that by picking up another box.

Just my druthers.  I'm still very interested by this project.
Title: Re: Melodeon Tablature (or, "how did you do that?")
Post by: Chris Harris on October 29, 2020, 11:53:48 AM
I spent some time some years ago working on a system to implement something very similar to the French system in abc. It made use of the w: feature to put button numbers under the notation. I decided it was too complicated to pursue.
Hi Bill, can you please post the abc for the Dorchester Hornpipe so I can see how you used the lyrics to show the tablature, I particularly want to know how ...
you drew the horizontal lines 
and included |>< and |<> before the first word, as the w: follows the dots usually.

Many Thanks
PS I am still looking for a Dino Baffeti Black Pearl III.....
Title: Re: Melodeon Tablature (or, "how did you do that?")
Post by: Steve_freereeder on October 29, 2020, 12:50:40 PM
I spent some time some years ago working on a system to implement something very similar to the French system in abc. It made use of the w: feature to put button numbers under the notation. I decided it was too complicated to pursue.
Hi Bill, can you please post the abc for the Dorchester Hornpipe so I can see how you used the lyrics to show the tablature, I particularly want to know how ...
you drew the horizontal lines 
and included |>< and |<> before the first word, as the w: follows the dots usually.

Many Thanks
PS I am still looking for a Dino Baffeti Black Pearl III.....
Chris,
Bill's post is over 9 years old and he hasn't been active on this forum since April 2019.

Looking at his example, with the horizontal lines and the symbols you are enquiring about, I'm almost certain that it was not done using ABC. I've done similar tablature in a couple of ways:

1. Importing a PDF of ABC music into Powerpoint, then using the drawing and text tools in Powerpoint to make the lines and fingering text.

2. These days I would use MuseScore. You can either enter the notation directly or you can import ABC into MuseScore if you don't want to do that. MuseScore also has comprehensive line drawing and text options too, which are very useful for doing those fingering tablatures. 
Title: Re: Melodeon Tablature (or, "how did you do that?")
Post by: Chris Harris on October 29, 2020, 02:34:08 PM
I spent some time some years ago working on a system to implement something very similar to the French system in abc. It made use of the w: feature to put button numbers under the notation. I decided it was too complicated to pursue.
Hi Bill, can you please post the abc for the Dorchester Hornpipe so I can see how you used the lyrics to show the tablature, I particularly want to know how ...
you drew the horizontal lines 
and included |>< and |<> before the first word, as the w: follows the dots usually.

Many Thanks
PS I am still looking for a Dino Baffeti Black Pearl III.....
Chris,
Bill's post is over 9 years old and he hasn't been active on this forum since April 2019.

Looking at his example, with the horizontal lines and the symbols you are enquiring about, I'm almost certain that it was not done using ABC. I've done similar tablature in a couple of ways:

1. Importing a PDF of ABC music into Powerpoint, then using the drawing and text tools in Powerpoint to make the lines and fingering text.

2. These days I would use MuseScore. You can either enter the notation directly or you can import ABC into MuseScore if you don't want to do that. MuseScore also has comprehensive line drawing and text options too, which are very useful for doing those fingering tablatures.

Thanks Steve, Bill does say he uses the w: feature to put the button numbers under the notation, so he may possibly have used abc, perhaps with some clever extention.
regards, Chris
Title: Re: Melodeon Tablature (or, "how did you do that?")
Post by: Steve_freereeder on October 29, 2020, 03:34:19 PM
Thanks Steve, Bill does say he uses the w: feature to put the button numbers under the notation, so he may possibly have used abc, perhaps with some clever extention.
Yes, the w: (lyrics) function would work, although it would be a bit of a faff to get the off-set numbers on different levels for the different rows. I still don't think you have the option in ABC to draw horizontal lines, although I may be wrong. Overall, it's much simpler in MuseScore. ;)
Title: Re: Melodeon Tablature (or, "how did you do that?")
Post by: Tone Dumb Greg on October 29, 2020, 10:52:23 PM
Just for interest, attached is a pdf of a score with DG TAB done in Myriad's Harmony Assistant. The scoring software I used all the time until I discovered ABC.
It was created, completely automatically,  from an imported ABC file.
The automatic choices can be quirky, but they can be edited to your preferred ones very easily.
It shows the two rows separately.
There is a very configurable table defining the available notes and chords. Push notes have an underscore, by default. This can be edited to your preferred symbol. I have just noticed it seems to default to my pull D, but this can be edited.
Chord basses are lower case. Chords are upper case (my choice).
If you don't have chords defined in the score it allocates them automatically, if rather quirkily.
I printed it to pdf. I needed to set margins for a better look, but it's easy to improve it.

This is my first attempt. I never bothered using this before (actually, I never even looked at it properly), but this post reminded me it was there. If I was going to use it seriously I would spend a bit more time setting it up. e.g., I just noticed the chords didn't say whether they were major or minor and I would probably use different symbols for push and pull. It seems to work pretty well, though and the tab is easy to understand.
Title: Re: Melodeon Tablature (or, "how did you do that?")
Post by: Roger Hare on October 30, 2020, 06:00:28 AM
About three years ago, user 'David' initiated this (http://forum.melodeon.net/index.php/topic,20960.msg251772) thread.

It discusses a Python script which adds 'Ed Rennie' style tabs to a simple ABC file, using the ABC w: field as discussed in a couple of
the previous posts.

David's home page is here (https://www.mawds.co.uk/) and the software is lodged on Github here (https://github.com/mawds/abcmelodeon).

I don't know if David has continued development, but his project may be of interest in the light of this discussion?

------
Inspired by this project (and another, Java based application for concertina), I've spent a significant amount of time developing an equivalent program for concertina.
Initially I used ABC 'text annotations' to insert the tabs, but I too have settled on the lyric model, using the ABC w: field. This program is written in Icon (https://unicon.sourceforge.io/). The program
is 'stand-alone' (no need to install Python or Java) and will add tabs in a variety of key signatures (including 'modal' keys) for G/D and C/G concertina, using simple
'along-the-row' and 'cross-row' strategies. It will also add simple 'note names' (see the Python application mentioned above). I'm thinking of 'reverse-engineering'
my program to do the same as David's original - that is add Ed Rennie tabs for a 2-row D/G melodeon...

The tabs (https://www.bushtraditions.org/tutors/concertina.htm) are easy to understand, and I use it all the time. I guess it's at about the same stage of development as the application mentioned by Tone Dumb Greg
in the previous post...

The attached image shows a simple tune after 'tabbing' - both the modified ABC and the resultant score...
Title: Re: Melodeon Tablature (or, "how did you do that?")
Post by: Chris Marriott on November 05, 2020, 12:05:09 PM
For me one thing that's missing from many methods is more detail on how the basses are played.  When you want to get away from Oom-pah basses, just putting "G" on the first bar and "D" on the second doesn't tell you anything useful. And for me the bass end is a melodic line, with chords to fill in when I can't think of anything better, or as a sort of off-beat percussion hit between bass notes.

I know this is a VERY old post, but coming to the melodeon from the accordion I've been a little surprised that the bass line is generally not notated in melodeon music. In scores for the accordion, the right-hand treble (melody) is notated on the treble clef, and the left-hand accompaniment on the bass clef, the convention being that bass notes are written below the centre line of the bass clef, and chords above the centre line. It's a notation convention that works well. I know the melodeon and accordion aren't the same instrument, but being able to see the accompaniment notated is something I personally find very useful.

Chris
Title: Re: Melodeon Tablature (or, "how did you do that?")
Post by: Tone Dumb Greg on November 05, 2020, 05:40:15 PM
For me one thing that's missing from many methods is more detail on how the basses are played.  When you want to get away from Oom-pah basses, just putting "G" on the first bar and "D" on the second doesn't tell you anything useful. And for me the bass end is a melodic line, with chords to fill in when I can't think of anything better, or as a sort of off-beat percussion hit between bass notes.

I know this is a VERY old post, but coming to the melodeon from the accordion I've been a little surprised that the bass line is generally not notated in melodeon music. In scores for the accordion, the right-hand treble (melody) is notated on the treble clef, and the left-hand accompaniment on the bass clef, the convention being that bass notes are written below the centre line of the bass clef, and chords above the centre line. It's a notation convention that works well. I know the melodeon and accordion aren't the same instrument, but being able to see the accompaniment notated is something I personally find very useful.

Chris

Melodeon basses are probably more of a personal choice than accordions, but if you look at the chords, there is a possibility of putting chords as upper case and basses as lower case. A lot of people do this, or something similar (maybe vice versa). Chords and basses can be placed one above the other to give composite chords. I used to do this, but rarely bother now, because I like to vary things each time around.
Title: Re: Melodeon Tablature (or, "how did you do that?")
Post by: tabman on November 28, 2025, 05:35:56 PM
I've developed a method for writing down (or reading) when and where where to place the fingers. I did this for my own use because I couldn't fathom out any other way I could play. I chose tunes I wanted to play and you can see them in my notation here:   http://www.wutheringbikes.org.uk/music/melodeon/
I have received the kind permission of John Kirkpatrick, Paul Young and Dave Mallinson to include some great tunes from their tune books. I've uploaded these accordingly, without claiming endorsement. My transcription assuredly will contain errors, but if these are emailed to me I can look at correction. Since all three are teachers of the melodeon I'll remark that whereas my transcription may help some learners (such as myself) to guide fingers into playing tunes, it won't give what a teacher can : the dynamics of rhythm, stress, volume... My method ignores some subtleties, eg. it copes with ties but not with slurs. For a waltz with regular FCC where a bar is scored as a minim followed by a crotchet, my transcription would be the same as if the bar were scored for three crotchets. Also, my method ignores bars, so along with the bar we lose the extra stress on the first beat of the bar. But while subleties are lost, clarity is gained as regards finger movement. 
Title: Re: Melodeon Tablature (or, "how did you do that?")
Post by: tabman on November 08, 2026, 10:56:59 PM
Almost a year later... I've corrected tune versions in https://www.wutheringbikes.org.uk/music/melodeon
I wrote last year that "my method ignores bars, so along with the bar we lose the extra stress on the first beat of the bar", but this has been rectified.
Incidentally, I've had no feedback but would willingly respond to any interest.
Title: Re: Melodeon Tablature (or, "how did you do that?")
Post by: Thrupenny Bit on November 09, 2026, 11:20:39 AM
Tabman, apologies, I cannot comment on your tab system.

What this thread alert has done is made me look over the entire thread as I wonderd why it popped up in my inbox.
I first joined in the discussion at the start of the thread after ~ about 6 months of starting playing melodeon. I'm now over 16 years in and it's made me reflect for a moment after reading my early comments on how my playing and knowledge has improved over time.

Also quite sad and sobering to realise three good friends commenting in the thread are no longer squeezing with us...
A reflective moment for me all round.
SimplePortal 2.3.5 © 2008-2012, SimplePortal