I think most of us would benefit from learning how best to play some bits of tunes, and I must admit I do sometimes notice from videos that the player is making a passage difficult when there is perhaps an easier way of doing it - suggesting that we could benefit from pooling ideas. This really merits another thread I guess, but briefly: The trouble with the French system IMO is that it's just too complex to follow easily while you're playing, and involves wading through lots of repeated information. (To illustrate, for most DG layouts, if you have a G chord, and are playing a RHS G note, it would seem to me there's no point being told whether it's in or out or which row it is, because there's only one choice.) I've found it useful to annotate my music, where the fingering isn't obvious, either with bellows direction or row, as seems intuitive for the particular passage. I guess this would work with abc too, though I don't tend to use it.
- Should we have a place on the forum where players can (if they wish) post some sort of annotation to go with their YouTube videos or sound recordings posted elsewhere, for others who want to learn from what they did?
- What's the best notation system? In that thread I posted some rather verbose text that was the easiest to simply type in.
- What about the tablature the French (and others) use?
- What about other tablatures?
I quite like the idea of a bellows notation for which (if writing by hand) I might use the symbols string players use for up and down bows.
I think maybe there are "instinctive" players and "technical" players, and the twain rarely meet.....
For me one thing that's missing from many methods is more detail on how the basses are played. When you want to get away from Oom-pah basses, just putting "G" on the first bar and "D" on the second doesn't tell you anything useful. And for me the bass end is a melodic line, with chords to fill in when I can't think of anything better, or as a sort of off-beat percussion hit between bass notes.
Ian Dedic has published his arrangement of Serpentiner Och Konfetti here: http://forum.melodeon.net/index.php/topic,1214.msg10963.html#msg10963 the attached PDF shows one way of doing it, with actual staff notation for the bass end. (The chords are no doubt nominal as not all melodeons have the chord reeds at the same pitches.) This approach works for me because I can read music fluently, used to play the piano and still make multi-instrument arrangements on (at least) two staves. It's also quite hard work to encode as ABC but at least it uses the notation that ABC was designed for.
The thing about the details I posted in the Cheshire Waltz thread is that it took me about 20 minutes to do - an instructional video would have eaten up the best part of an evening by the time I'd set it up, done re-takes, edited it, copied files, uploaded it etc. etc.
Notation and tab should complement one another, they're not really alternatives.
I spent some time some years ago working on a system to implement something very similar to the French system in abc. It made use of the w: feature to put button numbers under the notation. I decided it was too complicated to pursue.I agree with Bill, too complicated. I don't really read but a simple treble clef with guitar chord notation is easy. I can add hand written notes regarding any additional bass runs etc ABC is a boon and you can add any extra bass ideas if you want to. It will play the lot although notating it all by hand is tedious. Henric Norbeck's ABCMUS will add chords automatically and then you can adjust and alter them quite easily and printed pages can be produced through ABC2win or other similar programmes.
I think Chris has hit the nail on the head for a newby like me. I absolutely love learning to play the melodion - but the way I feel sometimes is that there are players 'out there' who are talking a different language, one that I might get one day if I live long enough! As you all know, having been newbies at one time yourselves, it's difficult enough getting your brain to work the fingers when you do understand the notation system you are trying to learn (there seems to be a gap just around the wrist level where instructions from the brain constantly take a diversion that was not planned!). I don't understand why 'tunes' can't be just written/passed on in the same way as George's tutor book? Simple to understand, but then of course you have got to do it through practice, practice ...
Mike
Lester,
George's (and Maggie's) book present tunes in the ^v^v with button numbers format (don't know if I'm making myself clear). I know I should be reading music and abc, and I do intend to .. Honestly, I am only speaking from a newbie point of view. It may be that in the future I will think - what a prat was I - it was simple. But it doesn't seem like that at the moment!
While I was typing this Chris added a reply, but I think my comment is still relevant.
Cheers
Mike
My query was around the use of button numbers as a method of presenting melodeon tab. The problem is a there ar too many variables, such as 3rd/4th button start, different key boxes etc.
My query was around the use of button numbers as a method of presenting melodeon tab. The problem is a there ar too many variables, such as 3rd/4th button start, different key boxes etc.
That is one of the reasons why I prefer Mally's method of using a number to indicate which finger to use (rather than which button) and a letter to indicate the row, with underlining or no underlining to indicate pull or push. This system is applicable to any type of melodeon in any combination of keys. It does require the user to learn which notes are under each button, but that is essential to learning your way around your instrument anyway.
I prefer Mally's method of using a number to indicate which finger to use (rather than which button) and a letter to indicate the row, with underlining or no underlining to indicate pull or push. This system is applicable to any type of melodeon in any combination of keys. It does require the user to learn which notes are under each button, but that is essential to learning your way around your instrument anyway.I prefer Mally Mallinson's method of his melodeon tutor book. I extended his annotation method to three-row (GCF, ADG, BbEbAb) melodeons, the numbers (1 - 4) indicate fingers: plain number = inner row, number in box [2] = middle row, number in cirle (1) = outer row; 0,
I spent some time some years ago working on a system to implement something very similar to the French system in abc. It made use of the w: feature to put button numbers under the notation. I decided it was too complicated to pursue.
I spent some time some years ago working on a system to implement something very similar to the French system in abc. It made use of the w: feature to put button numbers under the notation. I decided it was too complicated to pursue.I'm using something similar. I've got a modified version of abc2ps giving similar output (but with barlines in the tab). Since most dutch players expect button notation I still use it quite a lot. Once you're used to it it's not that difficult to type in the numbers. For one-row music I've made a script that adds the button numbers automatically.
There is also another system called "Corgeron system" which is mostly used in the center of France I think.Another system used quite a lot around here has all the button numbers on a single line, where push notes are underlined and inner row buttons are marked with quote, asterisk or brackets. I didn't manage to implement that in abc2ps yet.
I just play the tunes by ear..
.....and I tend to agree with Lester.oh that's true ! I agree : both tabs and ABC notation are really boring and complicated (and I have to know 3 systems here in France : Perrone's, CADB's and Corgeron's !). I often ask myself questions about them and I don't understand why people are re-inventing things which already exist ? Maybe the teaching of traditional music should be differently organised... but this is another debate.
Having had a very quick glance at some notations: They seem to be so much more complicated than simply learning the music!
Q
Having had a very quick glance at some notations: They seem to be so much more complicated than simply learning the music!Only if you know how to play. A lot of melodeon players around here are scared of sheet music and don't have the talent to learn tunes by ear. Perhaps they're not the greatest players, but they have a lot of fun being able to play tunes by pressing the right button at the right time. There's a region in the Netherlands using a notion with numbers only (example (http://home.wanadoo.nl/roel.zuiderbaan/it%20alder%20hus.htm)). The easy notation -even for beginners- is probably what makes the melodeon such a popular instrument for people who otherwise wouldn't play an instrument at all.
the Netherlands example with only numbers does shatter me ... I knew it existed, but I would have to work really hard to get someting out that. I have always been mathematics stubborn or refractory ... so ... ? Think we need something less abstract and more visual, don't we ?Having had a very quick glance at some notations: They seem to be so much more complicated than simply learning the music!Only if you know how to play. A lot of melodeon players around here are scared of sheet music and don't have the talent to learn tunes by ear. Perhaps they're not the greatest players, but they have a lot of fun being able to play tunes by pressing the right button at the right time. There's a region in the Netherlands using a notion with numbers only (example (http://home.wanadoo.nl/roel.zuiderbaan/it%20alder%20hus.htm)). The easy notation -even for beginners- is probably what makes the melodeon such a popular instrument for people who otherwise wouldn't play an instrument at all.
I have always been mathematics stubborn or refractory ... so ... ? Think we need something less abstract and more visual, don't we ?Funny, I was always the same way -- math-phobic -- until my third year in college when I took a music theory class and suddenly math started making sense to me. So music was the "less abstract" thing that opened the door to math for me.
One thing that Lester said -- there are different melodeons with 3rd start 4th start, different keys -- my sense is that there's a lot less of this profligate variability on the continent ... for example, in Alsace I played with twenty other melodeon players and every one of them was doing some form of G/C 3rd button start. That's only anecdotal evidence, of course.Nearly everybody plays on GC melodeons in France, it's quite obvious. So when we meet there is no problem playing toghether, that's true. And we can play as well with hurdy gurdy and pipes, they are adapted with us too.
But what do you mean by "3rd or 4th start" ? is it the place of the first note of the scale (sol and do for a GC diato) ?Yes, that's exactly right. Some boxes have a start on the fourth button, having extra lows or accidentals.
More specifically, some DG boxes have a 4th start button to mitigate the "dusty-end" problem inherent in two-voice DG melodeons.But what do you mean by "3rd or 4th start" ? is it the place of the first note of the scale (sol and do for a GC diato) ?Yes, that's exactly right. Some boxes have a start on the fourth button, having extra lows or accidentals.
The thing about the details I posted in the Cheshire Waltz thread is that it took me about 20 minutes to do - an instructional video would have eaten up the best part of an evening by the time I'd set it up, done re-takes, edited it, copied files, uploaded it etc. etc.
| Well, Tab seems to me most useful for beginners and advancers. It's popular with the non music reader - yet frankly encourages this approach to music? It would seem that to notate any sort of arrangement seems to require about 8 degrees of freedom. Yet as we move from beginner to player .. well my experience has been that you learn to play one end on autopilot while you focus on something 'clever' at the other, and then perhaps reverse that process next practice? So that's where we want to end up. |
What you want to know is which way the bellows are going for each bit, and what bass notes and chords are being played.I agree, I also find it interesting to know why the player made the choices they made. If we were in person and I saw Anahata playing "Cheshire," I'd buy him a beer and just have a great conversation.
I've printed off Ian Dedic's version of Serpentina
...
I then had a few very slow goes and noticed Ian has some nice bass runs as opposed to Um-pahs all the time.
Jack, I think you have pretty convincingly demonstrated that the stave/G g g system takes the player a very long way. I find that example gives a very good insight into how Anahata is playing that piece.
Dots seem to me to have various advantages over other systems, in the context of box playing:
Perhaps that's all that's needed,
Whilst I can see your conundrum Bob regarding which fingers etc the real choice lies in the basses used. In another thread, or earlier in this one I'm not sure, it was recommended that everyone should have two keyboard maps, one push, one pull. The direction of bellows is in the main dictated by the chords required. Knowing which way the bellows are going, one glance at the relevant keyboard map will instantly show the fingering required.
Where there are more buttons than fingers for a phrase then look for where you may change fingers whilst still keeping a button depressed. Having such an anchor point allows you to find the next buttons quite readily. Jumps and leaps around the keyboard come only with year of experience and even then one doesn't always land in the right place.
the Netherlands example with only numbers does shatter me ... I knew it existed, but I would have to work really hard to get someting out that. I have always been mathematics stubborn or refractory ... so ... ?Don't worry. Despite being dutch and having a phd in mathematics I can't read it either. ;)
oh la la ... :|||: this deeply thooses me ! really. So, I'm no longer alone ...the Netherlands example with only numbers does shatter me ... I knew it existed, but I would have to work really hard to get someting out that. I have always been mathematics stubborn or refractory ... so ... ?Don't worry. Despite being dutch and having a phd in mathematics I can't read it either. ;)
I am quite surprised that the majority of people who have posted on this thread seem to favour notation systems that do not indicate which finger to use. In my experience, this is something that is very important for beginners - and also for more experienced musicians who are beginning to play in unfamiliar keys that require the use of accidentals.
There's a related issue here to do with fingering - I've found that my main problem in playing accurately nowadays concerns rapid big leaps across buttons - it's so easy to hit the wrong one if you don't get it just right, and that can put the whole passage out disastrously. [...] Has anyone got any related experience on this sort of thing? I've noticed from people's vids that we all seem to have vastly different techniques in terms of RH movements - some seem to find safety in a vice-like grip, and others like darting about. Maybe the pianists among us may have some words of wisdom?
In nearly every case of a particularly tricky passage, I have found that the answer lies in using fewer fingers. I practically never use the little finger anyway, but jettisoning the ring finger often makes all the difference, even where the nasty passage involves big leaps. Between them my index and middle fingers have a speed and sure-footedness (can I throw in the word "proprioception") that the other fingers just cannot match.
Anyway, I agree with your observation that fewer fingers helps with trickier passage -- even if this does put you at risk of being classed with "three-fingered" guitarists.
Secondly, I am puzzled as to why it was written down with three sharps (key of A or F# minor) rather than two sharps, when all the G notes are naturals rather than sharps. Furthermore it resolves on a B, which makes me think that the tune is in B minor, which would normally be written with two sharps.
I spent some time some years ago working on a system to implement something very similar to the French system in abc. It made use of the w: feature to put button numbers under the notation. I decided it was too complicated to pursue.Hi Bill, can you please post the abc for the Dorchester Hornpipe so I can see how you used the lyrics to show the tablature, I particularly want to know how ...
Chris,I spent some time some years ago working on a system to implement something very similar to the French system in abc. It made use of the w: feature to put button numbers under the notation. I decided it was too complicated to pursue.Hi Bill, can you please post the abc for the Dorchester Hornpipe so I can see how you used the lyrics to show the tablature, I particularly want to know how ...
you drew the horizontal lines
and included |>< and |<> before the first word, as the w: follows the dots usually.
Many Thanks
PS I am still looking for a Dino Baffeti Black Pearl III.....
Chris,I spent some time some years ago working on a system to implement something very similar to the French system in abc. It made use of the w: feature to put button numbers under the notation. I decided it was too complicated to pursue.Hi Bill, can you please post the abc for the Dorchester Hornpipe so I can see how you used the lyrics to show the tablature, I particularly want to know how ...
you drew the horizontal lines
and included |>< and |<> before the first word, as the w: follows the dots usually.
Many Thanks
PS I am still looking for a Dino Baffeti Black Pearl III.....
Bill's post is over 9 years old and he hasn't been active on this forum since April 2019.
Looking at his example, with the horizontal lines and the symbols you are enquiring about, I'm almost certain that it was not done using ABC. I've done similar tablature in a couple of ways:
1. Importing a PDF of ABC music into Powerpoint, then using the drawing and text tools in Powerpoint to make the lines and fingering text.
2. These days I would use MuseScore. You can either enter the notation directly or you can import ABC into MuseScore if you don't want to do that. MuseScore also has comprehensive line drawing and text options too, which are very useful for doing those fingering tablatures.
Thanks Steve, Bill does say he uses the w: feature to put the button numbers under the notation, so he may possibly have used abc, perhaps with some clever extention.Yes, the w: (lyrics) function would work, although it would be a bit of a faff to get the off-set numbers on different levels for the different rows. I still don't think you have the option in ABC to draw horizontal lines, although I may be wrong. Overall, it's much simpler in MuseScore. ;)
For me one thing that's missing from many methods is more detail on how the basses are played. When you want to get away from Oom-pah basses, just putting "G" on the first bar and "D" on the second doesn't tell you anything useful. And for me the bass end is a melodic line, with chords to fill in when I can't think of anything better, or as a sort of off-beat percussion hit between bass notes.
For me one thing that's missing from many methods is more detail on how the basses are played. When you want to get away from Oom-pah basses, just putting "G" on the first bar and "D" on the second doesn't tell you anything useful. And for me the bass end is a melodic line, with chords to fill in when I can't think of anything better, or as a sort of off-beat percussion hit between bass notes.
I know this is a VERY old post, but coming to the melodeon from the accordion I've been a little surprised that the bass line is generally not notated in melodeon music. In scores for the accordion, the right-hand treble (melody) is notated on the treble clef, and the left-hand accompaniment on the bass clef, the convention being that bass notes are written below the centre line of the bass clef, and chords above the centre line. It's a notation convention that works well. I know the melodeon and accordion aren't the same instrument, but being able to see the accompaniment notated is something I personally find very useful.
Chris