Melodeon.net Forums

Discussions => Instrument Makes and Models => Topic started by: Andy in Vermont on March 15, 2011, 07:03:56 PM

Title: unavailable melodeons
Post by: Andy in Vermont on March 15, 2011, 07:03:56 PM
I don't think that there is any maker who offers the exact configuration that I would most like to play!
Are there any specific, combined features that you can't find in an available production box?

For me, it's this combination:
-- small scale (ala Benny), 3 row, 12 bass, with LM tuning, switches that turn off either reed, "flat" keyboard, with low bass notes, case in a solid hardwood (like walnut or cherry), reeds could be Voci Armoniche TAM or Binci pro. (I'd like this box in ADG.)

I'm aware that the Saltarelle "Laurentides" comes close, but it doesn't match on several counts.  I'm not keen on the sound of small-scale boxes, but when you need to transport a bundle of accordions in various keys, it's worth the trade-off.
-Andy
Title: Re: unavailable melodeons
Post by: Steve C. on March 15, 2011, 07:14:39 PM
Andy, you are so close to a Benny that you should be able to convince yourself quite easily that you are already there.  >:E
Title: Re: unavailable melodeons
Post by: Andy in Vermont on March 15, 2011, 07:25:05 PM
Andy, you are so close to a Benny that you should be able to convince yourself quite easily that you are already there.  >:E

Steve,
I'm familiar with the Benny, and it doesn't fulfill several of the requirements that are most important to me.
-Andy
Title: Re: unavailable melodeons
Post by: OwenG on March 15, 2011, 07:37:38 PM
How about Marc Serafini?

www.la-baf.com
Title: Re: unavailable melodeons
Post by: Graham Spencer on March 15, 2011, 07:37:58 PM
Personally, I don't think I could live with a 2-voice LM - I like a bit of wetness in my boxes, and you can only really get that tremolo edge with MM voicing. My ideal would be a 3-voice LMM with a low voice switch, but further than that I haven't really thought..........

Graham
Title: Re: unavailable melodeons
Post by: Graham Spencer on March 15, 2011, 07:50:23 PM
Having thought about it for at least 2 minutes, I've come to the conclusion that my ideal melodeon would be either a) at least 15 boxes, each with different characteristics, voicings, tunings etc or b) a single box embodying all of the above that would need a wheelbarrow to transport it and at least 9 digits per hand to play (if not an extra limb or two!). In short, the ideal box doesn't exist - the best you can hope for is an acceptable compromise (or 2...or 3....or...........)  (:)

Graham
Title: Re: unavailable melodeons
Post by: savantuk on March 15, 2011, 08:03:35 PM
How about Marc Serafini?

www.la-baf.com

I've just had a look at the Serafin catalogue.   If I could have a Sanfona III, I think I'd be happy for ever!!

(http://www.tradmagazine.com/05ANNONCES/Photos%20PA/136-annonce-marie-goarin.jpg)

Only Eu3200 :o
Title: Re: unavailable melodeons
Post by: Nick Hudis on March 15, 2011, 09:18:53 PM
My Loffet Pro 3 row 18 bass but with 33 buttons so I can have a pulled Eb and a pushed F in both octaves.  But it mustn't weigh any more.
Title: Re: unavailable melodeons
Post by: Stiamh on March 15, 2011, 09:21:00 PM
I feel I've harped on about my ideal unavailable box once too often on here, but since you asked, Andy:

Compact 2-voice 21-button box (that's the easy part) with 12 basses (which almost nobody will put on a 2-row) and a longer inside row - 10/11 - (which a few makers will do but only on 23 or 25-button machines).
Title: Re: unavailable melodeons
Post by: Owen Woods on March 15, 2011, 09:21:19 PM
The Darwin 24 bass would probably be my ideal box full stop if I'm honest, the LMM version. Tuned BCC# or some other weird variant, whichever system I happen to be playing when I suddenly get enough money to buy one. One day I'd like to at least try one :P
Title: Re: unavailable melodeons
Post by: Steve C. on March 15, 2011, 10:29:40 PM
Van der AA maybe could make?

http://www.accordionmaker.com/home/!boot.php
Title: Re: unavailable melodeons
Post by: george garside on March 15, 2011, 10:32:12 PM
top of my 'wish list' would be a BCC# box about the size & weight of a trichord 3 but built to  shand morino standard & with whatever number of stradella bass that could be fitted in    the available space. 3 voice musette with  treble switches to give single  middle reed or all 3. Trouble is would't be able to afford one !

Would also quite like the 3 row version of the casti lilly, whatever it was called, but tuned BCC# & with at least 12 stradella.  I did try one of these several years ago but it had  12 melodeon bass. the treble end was great but the bass useless. This was a special order that hobgob had that wasn't sold so they were offering it at Sidmouth at greatly reduced price. While I was dithering somebody bought it - does anybody know of its whereabouts?

george
Title: Re: unavailable melodeons
Post by: Steve C. on March 15, 2011, 10:53:34 PM
George--3 row, one voice?
Title: Re: unavailable melodeons
Post by: Andy Simpson on March 15, 2011, 11:18:11 PM
Surely not the infamous Castagnari Matty?... :o

My big gripe was the lack of a 2 row 8 bass 3 voice box with a switch on the back of the keyboard a la the Castagnari Mory or Handry instead of a conventional stop. The Oakwood Model 7 had that very configuration in a very small case so it's definitely feasible but I'm not holding my breath for one appearing secondhand...

In 2009 I emailed Olav Bergflodt about the possibility of such a melodeon and he didn't seem to think it was a problem, (Andy, he could easily make you the box you describe), but in a decision I regret to this day, I didn't go further with it for what I can now see were very daft reasons.
Title: Re: unavailable melodeons
Post by: Andy in Vermont on March 15, 2011, 11:42:55 PM
In 2009 I emailed Olav Bergflodt about the possibility of such a melodeon and he didn't seem to think it was a problem, (Andy, he could easily make you the box you describe), but in a decision I regret to this day, I didn't go further with it for what I can now see were very daft reasons.

I guess this gets to the heart of the matter.  I don't really want a custom-made one-off, especially from a maker whose instruments I have never tried.  My observation -- and this has nothing whatsoever to do with Mr. Bergflodt's instruments -- is that there is a lot of high praise posted on the internet, or even expressed by players who are in the local area of a given builder, but that praise has little to do with my own standards.
As a parallel example, there were dozens of people posting superlatives about a given sawmaker's work (on woodworking forums), and then when I finally got a chance to try a saw that the fellow had made, it was a total dog, and I would have been very disappointed if I had ordered one for myself.
To get back to my original post, I'm not really asking whether there is a builder who would make the instrument configuration that I'm looking for, I'm commenting on the fact that the configuration that I'm looking for -- which is entirely possible to build, unlike some fantasy instruments with tons of features that can't practically be fit into one box -- simply isn't available as a production model by any builder, even the ones who make a dozen or more models.  Steve's comment about the 21-button with the longer inside row is right on the mark.  This is a really useful configuration for C#/D players, but unless you go for 23 or 24 button boxes (with correspondingly longer box dimensions), the box he desires is not available except perhaps as a one-off by builder x.
I had not taken a look at Marc Serafini's website in some time -- some very interesting possibilities there.  Wish I could try one out.
Title: Re: unavailable melodeons
Post by: Martin J on March 16, 2011, 12:12:43 AM
Try this one (http://www.giustozzi.it/ita/?page_id=5&category=27).  It exceeds your spec.
Not quite off the shelf as everyone is built to order so you can choose the wood etc.

mod. 810 / A series accordions more luxury

low / 32 Basses
keys / 27 keys
voices to sing / treble reeds 4 (2M + 2m)
items at low / bass reeds 4
registers sing / 2 + off treble registers
weight / weight kg. 5,6
dimensions / sizes 27 x 20.5 cm

Please don't swamp him with orders until my two new ones are built.  ;D
Title: Re: unavailable melodeons
Post by: Bob Ellis on March 16, 2011, 01:18:48 AM
I suspect that there are few configurations that some manufacturer somewhere would not be prepared to make. The problem, as always, is the risk involved in ordering something from a manufacturer whose instruments you have not had the opportunity to try before ordering.

My ideal instrument would be a 2.5 or 3 row Oakwood (preferrably a 3 row, which I have tried). I know the keyboard layout I would like, but if one with a different layout became available secondhand (since no new ones will be made) I could always move the reeds around and replace one or two to suit my preference.

Since Oakwood's are rare and I will probably seek one in vain, it has been suggested that I might get something similar from one of the better French manufacturers, but, not having tried their boxes, I am reluctant to take the risk.
Title: Re: unavailable melodeons
Post by: Andy in Vermont on March 16, 2011, 01:24:42 AM
Try this one (http://www.giustozzi.it/ita/?page_id=5&category=27).  It exceeds your spec.

That's a cool little box, but actually not anything I'd personally play, since I don't play stradella bass.  Also, I need a 12/11/10, 10/11/10 or 11/12/11 treble side.
Where did you get the info re: wood choice? It looks like a celluloid box.
Title: Re: unavailable melodeons
Post by: Gary P Chapin on March 16, 2011, 01:43:35 AM
This is exactly the sort of accordion-existential experience I've been going through.  The perfect box.  I call it, "The Last Accordion I'll Ever Buy."  An ongoing, unachievable quest.  Love, unrequited.

I had my bearings thrown out from under me on this topic, recently, buying the Nik.  I was actually looking for a three row, high end BIG BOX.  A Handry, I was thinking.  Or a Loffett Pro.  But then I saw the Nik at the Button Box, and decided, on a whim, to try it out.  And it was just PERFECT.  It just fit.  Two row.  Eight bass. G/C. M/M.  No stops.  No decisions, just play.

So, is the last accordion you ever buy going to be the one that does everything you need it to do, or is going to be the one that best suits your ... dare I say it? ... soul?
Title: Re: unavailable melodeons
Post by: melodeon on March 16, 2011, 01:52:17 AM
Hi Andy,

Could Castagnari do this ? Are there other specifics you don't want that are on the Benny.

I wish the Matty was still around.

The idea of the Laurentides was good.. the actual box and the price.. not so good.
Title: Re: unavailable melodeons
Post by: Andy in Vermont on March 16, 2011, 02:01:48 AM
So, is the last accordion you ever buy going to be the one that does everything you need it to do, or is going to be the one that best suits your ... dare I say it? ... soul?

Hi Gary,
The thing is, I'm not looking for "the last accordion I'll ever buy" or any single accordion that suits every feature that I'd want in any diatonic accordion, let alone one that suits my soul.  I play several boxes and don't intend to give up the use of several boxes.  I also play in a group with a variety of other instruments and a vocalist, and thus have a set of requirements that can only be satisfied by several diatonic accordions, not an "ultimate box."
I like big boxes with a minimum of three voices, full-featured basses/chords and lots of switches for variation.  But that is not what I'm talking about in this thread.  I'm talking about specific requirements that are realistic, yet not met by any currently available production box.  Castagnari comes closest with the Benny, but I've corresponded with them and they are unable or unwilling to build one with a flat keyboard (they offered to make a Rik with a flat keyboard).
Title: Re: unavailable melodeons
Post by: Andy in Vermont on March 16, 2011, 02:05:51 AM
Could Castagnari do this ? Are there other specifics you don't want that are on the Benny.

Several years back, I corresponded with them and they said that they could not (or would not) do a Benny with a flat keyboard.  I don't recall the details, but I believe they could do LM with a stop to take out one of the two banks of reeds.  I did not ask about the bass but suspect that they would not put low bass reeds in a Benny. (That is probably the least crucial of my requirements.)
It probably does not matter because I'm not in a position to buy a box now, but I've been pondering options for the future!
I'd love to hear some feedback about the Big 18 if anyone here has been playing one.
Title: Re: unavailable melodeons
Post by: Gary P Chapin on March 16, 2011, 03:33:37 PM
I understand where you are coming from, Andy.  I suppose I drifted because the thread itself did ... but also, because I just went through this, I find the quest for the perfect box a pretty interesting phenomenon amongst melodeonists.  I spend a lot of time thinking about such things.  The phrase "the last accordion I'll ever buy" is just my way of mythologizing it in my head.  It's funny, I mentioned it to Doug at the Button Box -- the last accordion I'll ever buy -- and he responded, "I hope not!"

It is strange that, with all the models out there, your set of criteria aren't being met.  I wonder about the trade off for the size of the Benny, and the low reeds on the bass.  I also wonder about your objection to the stepped keyboard.  I've never been bothered by stepped or flat ... I switch between them without thinking.  However I lack in fleetness, I guarantee that it's because of my playing, not the steps on the keyboard.
Title: Re: unavailable melodeons
Post by: Andy in Vermont on March 16, 2011, 04:49:47 PM

Hi Gary,
Sorry, I didn't mean to be so cranky!

I also switch between a stepped keyboard and a "flat" one.  I find that there are some techniques that are available to me on the flat keyboard that are not achievable (by me) on a stepped keyboard.  Also, I simply prefer the feel of the flat keyboard, especially when the center-to-center button distance is going to be decreased.  I love the feel of the buttons on the Lilliputs and Preciosas that I've tried.

-Andy
Title: Re: unavailable melodeons
Post by: EeeJay on March 16, 2011, 05:12:11 PM
My big gripe was the lack of a 2 row 8 bass 3 voice box with a switch on the back of the keyboard a la the Castagnari Mory or Handry instead of a conventional stop...

Another maker offering this is Frans Van de Aa - his COMPACT II model - 2 row (21 or 23) 8 bass 3 voice... where you can have one low voice 'on/off' slider, or three sliders - which index through L, ML, M, MM and MML settings - scroll down to the 23/24th picture HERE... (http://www.mijnalbum.nl/Album=CFE6DXII)

Castagnari comes closest with the Benny, but I've corresponded with them and they are unable or unwilling to build one with a flat keyboard (they offered to make a Rik with a flat keyboard).

Serenellini may well offer a credible alternative - they usually offer the same model as flat or stepped... this (http://accordeonspecialist.nl/index.php?page=shop.product_details&flypage=flypage.tpl&product_id=502&category_id=12&option=com_virtuemart&Itemid=3) is the closest model I've yet seen to the Benny...

I wish the Matty was still around.

Owned one for a bit (& sold on to another forum member). Very nicely put together, but a bit of a curate's egg/problem child.

Glad mine isn't still around, TBH... :|glug

Ed J
Title: Re: unavailable melodeons
Post by: Pushpull on March 16, 2011, 06:25:41 PM
How about Marc Serafini?

www.la-baf.com

I've just had a look at the Serafin catalogue.   If I could have a Sanfona III, I think I'd be happy for ever!!

(http://www.tradmagazine.com/05ANNONCES/Photos%20PA/136-annonce-marie-goarin.jpg)

Only Eu3200 :o
That's about the same as a Tommy.

Has anyone had a look at the "Darwin" boxes on the same site?
Title: Re: unavailable melodeons
Post by: Quebecois on March 16, 2011, 06:41:22 PM
Uhhh... I thought that the art of playing melodeon was about learning to do more with less and make the listeners believe that the instrument had more notes and features that it actually has!
Title: Re: unavailable melodeons
Post by: Lester on March 16, 2011, 07:38:20 PM
That's about the same as a Tommy.

Has anyone had a look at the "Darwin" boxes on the same site?

I played some of Marc's boxes at the 1 row course he helped out on in Stowmarket, they were fantastic both to play and to listen too, plus they had a number of interesting innovations I have seen nowhere else. Thoroughly recommended.
Title: Re: unavailable melodeons
Post by: Andy in Vermont on March 17, 2011, 02:40:23 PM
Uhhh... I thought that the art of playing melodeon was about learning to do more with less and make the listeners believe that the instrument had more notes and features that it actually has!

I'm not sure how your post relates to this thread:
1. You seem to indicate that I'm trying to pack an unreasonable number of features into a box.  I'm not.  I'm talking about a 2-voice box, simply a combination of features that are not combined in a production instrument.
2. Your post implicitly indicates that I'm not "doing more with less" -- I currently play on two melodeons, how many are listed in your signature?
3. I disagree with your presumption about "the art of playing melodeon" -- I'm pretty sure that it is about playing music, not tricking listeners.  Following your notion to its ultimate conclusion, you should be systematically dismantling the existing features of the instruments that you play.  I suggest starting by removing the bellows.
Title: Re: unavailable melodeons
Post by: Andy in Vermont on March 17, 2011, 02:46:36 PM
Has anyone had a look at the "Darwin" boxes on the same site?

I just had a look at the site again.  Marc Serafini is doing some really interesting things.  There is a page with links that pop up pictures of many very nice features of his designs.
In relation to the original topic of this thread, there is a picture of the bass reedblocks that shows how low bass notes could be incorporated into a box the size of a Benny (or Tommy).  Very very cool stuff!

Looking more closely at his catalogue, he actually does offer instruments that meet my requirements exactly!  I think that I've found my people!  Now where can I try one of these out?
Title: Re: unavailable melodeons
Post by: Quebecois on March 17, 2011, 03:41:49 PM
Andy: I was just commenting on the fact that people seem to want things on melodeons that go beyond what a 'commonly available' instrument has. I do use several boxes with various features but all are 'stock' and unmodified (except for replacing reeds with better ones on a few).

There are so many boxes available with lots of different features, and many makers who can make customized boxes, I am always puzzled to read posts from people who still look for yet another, unavailable box...

When I go to a gig I usually carry one box, sometimes 2, and try to make do with them. And I know it can't do everything, depending on the tunes that will be started by other musicians.  It's the nature of the instrument.

There was no malicious intention in my post.
Title: Re: unavailable melodeons
Post by: Andy in Vermont on March 17, 2011, 04:04:49 PM

Your description of a "gig" sounds like a pick-up group to me.  My band plays and develops a set repertoire of tunes and songs that are arranged for our specific parts.  It is not an option to occasionally not bring an instrument that I'll need for a particular song just because I want to carry fewer instruments on a snowy day!  I'm trying to get to the point where two instruments, preferably not large ones, would serve for the repertoire that we are playing and developing, and it is not too much to require since a G/C/F + an A/D/G would have everything I need.  Yes, there are available boxes in ADG that would suit my need, but some of them do not meet my quality standard (Saltarelle Laurentides) or they have TOO many features, making them overkill for my purposes (Castagnari Handry).

In production three-row boxes, there seems to be an equation of "high performance" with "feature laden."  I am looking for high performance but I don't need tons of bass switches or three treble voices; however in A/D/G I prefer the sound of LM to MM, and typically the low voice is only available in three-voice boxes.  Again, if you actually read what I've written to commence this thread, its not the typical dilemma of choosing features in a limited instrument, or trying to fit an unrealistic number of features into one box. (If I wanted to do that, I'd play a chromatic button accordion instead.)  I think that Steve Jones really understood my point, based on his desired instrument -- there really is no good reason why the instrument he described could not be built, and I bet a lot of C#D players would choose such an instrument. As for the instrument I described, I know that there is at least some demand because some builders who make "one-offs" have made instruments like this -- Pariselle, Hyde, Priez.  And now I see that Marc Serafini actually lists an instrument meeting exactly my requirements in his catalogue. (Incidentally: Steve J.: somewhere on Serafini's site, I spotted an Irish box that would probably tickle your fancy.)  My only reservation is that I actually prefer the fit-and-finish of instruments that come from Castagnari.
Title: Re: unavailable melodeons
Post by: Steve C. on March 17, 2011, 05:23:51 PM
Slightly off topic and not very PC, but this thread is starting to remind me of "the search for the perfect woman". :Ph

(hint: does not exist)
(hint: but does not mean you can't get close)
SimplePortal 2.3.5 © 2008-2012, SimplePortal