Hey out there,
I´m a beginner accordionist, but with a decent past in music and reading music, I have picked it up very quickly!!
One thing that i think is phenominal is how some of the better players can spice up a tune so quickly and easy (any single tune of the month videos!!) and I would love to do that as well. I´m not great at learning by ear, but i do have a good idea of when the added effects and triplets, etc. come into play.
Without revealing their secret, could anyone give me some general tips on how to ornament my music?? I´m a quick learner, but I need something to learn from!
Cheers and força canut
knowing when and when to orniment,is the mark of a good player
I totaly agree with George regarding over ornimentation,many a good tune is lost due to over enbelishment ,unfortunatly by some of the most able of musicians.There is a time for every thing and knowing when and when to orniment,is the mark of a good player as apposed to a gifted musician,Thats my opinion anyway .
;D I didn't spot that the first time I read it! (I suppose it was meant to be the other way round)knowing when and when to orniment,is the mark of a good player as apposed to a gifted musician
on that basis I'm glad I'm not a gifted musician!
george
I'd like to challenge Derek to spice up 'Soliders Joy' one of my least favourite tunes.....
I'd like to challenge Derek to spice up 'Soliders Joy' one of my least favourite tunes.....
He did do workshops on variations, but you might be confusing that with the later and possibly more famous workshop he did on repetition. I was there for that one, and we played Davy Knick Knack continuously for an hour.
He promises "we'll all have shared a wonderfully exhilarating experience", but what actually happened was a number of EFDSS "social dance" piano accordionists complained (a) that they didn't know the tune and (b) that no music was provided. That was after hearing the tune non-stop for an hour...
I'd like to challenge Derek to spice up 'Soliders Joy' one of my least favourite tunes.....
Lovely clear visuals on the fingering at that link. TksHey out there,
I´m a beginner accordionist, but with a decent past in music and reading music, I have picked it up very quickly!!
One thing that i think is phenominal is how some of the better players can spice up a tune so quickly and easy (any single tune of the month videos!!) and I would love to do that as well. I´m not great at learning by ear, but i do have a good idea of when the added effects and triplets, etc. come into play.
Without revealing their secret, could anyone give me some general tips on how to ornament my music?? I´m a quick learner, but I need something to learn from!
Cheers and força canut
http://www.diatonics.co.uk/tuition.htm
(http://www.diatonics.co.uk/tuition.htm)
its a start ... willing to help in other ways if required!
DTN
How did you produce the echo?..... which adds so much to the tone - very fruity and jaunty yet light and delicate (:)I'd like to challenge Derek to spice up 'Soliders Joy' one of my least favourite tunes.....
I can't stand the tune either!... so i've done an experiment! ;D ... A '1 take' recording of the tune i remember with the first variations that come into my head (then never play the tune ever again!)... so the usual over chording, over complicated, over ornamented mushy stuff i usually do! >:E
derek
http://www.onmvoice.com/play.php?a=45377 (http://www.onmvoice.com/play.php?a=45377)
How did you produce the echo?..... which adds so much to the tone - very fruity and jaunty yet light and delicate (:)
I'd like to challenge Derek to spice up 'Soliders Joy' one of my least favourite tunes.....
I can't stand the tune either!... derek
http://www.onmvoice.com/play.php?a=45377 (http://www.onmvoice.com/play.php?a=45377)
Derek, I sat smiling all the way through your track - I almost like the tune now ;)I'd like to challenge Derek to spice up 'Soliders Joy' one of my least favourite tunes.....
I can't stand the tune either!... so i've done an experiment! ;D ... A '1 take' recording of the tune i remember with the first variations that come into my head (then never play the tune ever again!)... so the usual over chording, over complicated, over ornamented mushy stuff i usually do! >:E
derek
http://www.onmvoice.com/play.php?a=45377 (http://www.onmvoice.com/play.php?a=45377)
10/10. Thanks Derek. And do you still not like it?
If this is what you can do with a tune you don't like, Derek :o, then I am going to have to search out your postings of tunes you do like! Soldier's Joy is not one of my favourite tunes either, but listening to your superb rendition of it made me think differently. Methinks it is a tune I shall have to revisit.
|
|
Beautiful and superbly done. Thanks.
However I think the other big factor here is that it's played at about half the speed that it's played in most sessions and that gives room for the tune to come through and the variations to be effective.
Steve
He did do workshops on variations, but you might be confusing that with the later and possibly more famous workshop he did on repetition. I was there for that one, and we played Davy Knick Knack continuously for an hour.Yes, he did the same thing in a workshop at Whitby folk week. It was a memorable experience (a good one!).
The idea was that when you really get into a tune, variations come spontaneously in a way that can't happen if you try to impose them artificially. It's explained in the Medley Mania (http://www.johnkirkpatrick.co.uk/wr_MedleyMania.asp) article on his web site, at the end of which he announces his intention to to run that workshop. Worth a read!
He promises "we'll all have shared a wonderfully exhilarating experience", but what actually happened was a number of EFDSS "social dance" piano accordionists complained (a) that they didn't know the tune and (b) that no music was provided. That was after hearing the tune non-stop for an hour...
I really like the new Reggae Soldiers Joy with swing 8)
I think the other big factor here is that it's played at about half the speed that it's played in most sessions and that gives room for the tune to come through and the variations to be effective. Steve
I really like the new Reggae Soldiers Joy with swing 8)
Seems to be yet another case of 'UK session speed' abandoning all hope of any Beauty in a tune :-\
We have an accordionist who regularly attends our monthly sessions, and always starts off too fast, then speeds up >:(
Many use it as a 'get a pint' time.
My morris dancing non playing mate muttered " hasn't he ever danced?"
....and it's a question to think about. Many tunes have come down via dancing, whether social or display of some sort, so surely have rough parameters for the speed at which they should be played?
We have an accordionist who regularly attends our monthly sessions, and always starts off too fast, then speeds up >:(
Many use it as a 'get a pint' time.
My morris dancing non playing mate muttered " hasn't he ever danced?"
....and it's a question to think about. Many tunes have come down via dancing, whether social or display of some sort, so surely have rough parameters for the speed at which they should be played?
Yeah, this is something that's making me feel less and less confident about trying to play tunes that are obviously intended for dancing. Having not done any sort of folk dancing at all (or, for the most part, any other type, either), I don't have much to draw on that helps me to know how a particular type of tune should feel. I've tried watching YouTube videos to see if that gives me a better idea about specific dances, but often I don't really know what I'm looking for.
Listen to some of the morris sides, there will be a *huge* variation in music played, some depending on the requirements of the dance, and others on the limitations of the players.
An example of a Morris tune that is often speeded up in sessions is the Upton Stick Dance tune (sometimes known as Twin Sisters
An example of a Morris tune that is often speeded up in sessions is the Upton Stick Dance tune (sometimes known as Twin Sisters
Sorry to get on one of my hobby horses, but the tune to Upton-Upon-Severn is "Brighton Camp" or something similar; "The Twin Sisters" is a Newfoundland tune that happened to be published concurrently with Upton by Maud Karpeles, and the dance that most sides do (not ours!) to that tune is in fact the Chingford Stick Dance. I seem to remember a discussion about this very topic not too long ago. As far as I'm concerned, "Twin Sisters" is ALWAYS played too fast, whether for dancing or listening..........
And FWIW, I don't play morris tunes any faster for listening, whether in a session or a folk club, as I feel it's disrespectful to the tune to do so, and the tune loses its character if its tempo is messed about with.
Dives for cover under nearest olive tree....... ;)
' And FWIW, I don't play morris tunes any faster for listening, whether in a session or a folk club, as I feel it's disrespectful to the tune to do so, and the tune loses its character if its tempo is messed about with.....'
GPS has another good point, respecting the tune and it's original context.
I think there's no need to duck for that one ;)
Q
Thans for the responses to my earlier post, above.
Although I don't, obviously, play for dancing, I do sometimes play for others to listen to. In such situations, it's probably the case that it doesn't really matter how I play individual tunes as most people won't know any different anyway. However, I do find that there's a real danger of getting "it all sounds the same" comments - and that bothers me when I know they have a point. I feel it's not really fair to expect others to pick up on differences in tune types when I don't really understand the differences myself.
George's post earlier, about playing single tune in different styles, seems to point to the root of the problem. If you asked me to play Keel Row as a reel, march and hornpipe, as he mentions, I'd struggle to know what to do to keep faithful to those styles. Most likely, they'd end up sounding the same, anyway.
As for the beer suggestion........I don't drink, so I'll have to leave that one for others to experiment with.
I feel I must disagree with you both, the tunes won't mind if the are played faster/slower/different time sig etc. As long as you are the starter of a set of tunes it is up to you how you play them. Now if someone else starts the se and you disrespect them that is a whole different kettle of fish.
[ , If I start a tune at a given speed in a session it should stay at that speed, not be hi-jacked by the "look-how-much-faster-than-you-I-can-play" brigade.
Graham
[ , If I start a tune at a given speed in a session it should stay at that speed, not be hi-jacked by the "look-how-much-faster-than-you-I-can-play" brigade.
Graham
absolutely agree and would add that following the 'starter' should also apply even if the starter is struggling and playing a bit on the slow side. It may have taken that person some courage to start a tune in a session & Hijacking a tune can really knock their confidence. If the speedy lot attempt to hijack a tune in my led sessions I just stop the proceedingss & point out that it iss good manners to follow the 'starter' I have never recieved a bollocking for so doing! - not yet anyway!
george
For this very reason I tend to start slower than I can actually play, so that when the speed-a-holics (I've noticed it can only speed up 'so' quickly each time through the tune) speed it up I can still keep up by 3rd time round.[ , If I start a tune at a given speed in a session it should stay at that speed, not be hi-jacked by the "look-how-much-faster-than-you-I-can-play" brigade.
Graham
absolutely agree and would add that following the 'starter' should also apply even if the starter is struggling and playing a bit on the slow side. It may have taken that person some courage to start a tune in a session & Hijacking a tune can really knock their confidence. If the speedy lot attempt to hijack a tune in my led sessions I just stop the proceedingss & point out that it iss good manners to follow the 'starter' I have never recieved a bollocking for so doing! - not yet anyway!
george
It might be of use if beginners were actually in a 'workshop' or 'tune around' more than a session where it's usual to play sets of tunes.If one exists. There are regular "slow" sessions run deliberately for beginners and early-stages improvers to get a chance to play with others.
I suppose it depends what you call a 'session'....it can kill a session dead if everyone has to play at the lowest level for too long..it's good to be challenged and stretched.It doesn't have to be all the same. A mixed ability session should have mixed-ability tunes and playing speeds.
There are some great Morris tunes that can be played 'differently', I did my version of Princess Royal some time back.
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=84UxOFTTH3U (http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=84UxOFTTH3U)
Alan
There are some great Morris tunes that can be played 'differently', I did my version of Princess Royal some time back.
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=84UxOFTTH3U (http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=84UxOFTTH3U)
Alan
Almo's video illustrates perfectly the point I made earlier about the validity of playing Morris tunes in sessions at speeds that would be inappropriate when playing for dancers. His is a very good rendition and perfectly appropriate for a session, but I don't think any dancer would want to dance it at that speed.
Anahata's points about sessions are well made. A session that is sensitive to inexperienced players and those lacking confidence should encourage them by playing tunes they start at the speed at which they start them or by helping them to slow down if they have started too fast due to nervousness. Another way of supporting inexperienced or nervous players is to ask them quietly if there are tunes that they play at home but are not confident enough to start in the session. Starting and leading those tunes for them so that they have the opportunity to play them in a session environment will bring closer the day when they will feel confident enough to start those tunes themselves.
I'd like to challenge Derek to spice up 'Soliders Joy' one of my least favourite tunes.....
I can't stand the tune either!... so i've done an experiment! ;D ... A '1 take' recording of the tune i remember with the first variations that come into my head (then never play the tune ever again!)... so the usual over chording, over complicated, over ornamented mushy stuff i usually do! >:E
derek
http://www.onmvoice.com/play.php?a=45377 (http://www.onmvoice.com/play.php?a=45377)
Having challenged Derek to spice up Soldier's Joy and him doing such a great job, I thought I'd better have a go.
Just recorded this today and uploaded to MySpace - it confirmed my thoughts about the audio quality on MySpace - it made me sound like I'm playing through a phazer....
oh well - you can still hear me anyway....
http://www.myspace.com/alanmorleys/music/songs/Soldier-s-Joy-81207819 (http://www.myspace.com/alanmorleys/music/songs/Soldier-s-Joy-81207819)
Almo
Having challenged Derek to spice up Soldier's Joy and him doing such a great job, I thought I'd better have a go.
Just recorded this today and uploaded to MySpace - it confirmed my thoughts about the audio quality on MySpace - it made me sound like I'm playing through a phazer....
oh well - you can still hear me anyway....
http://www.myspace.com/alanmorleys/music/songs/Soldier-s-Joy-81207819 (http://www.myspace.com/alanmorleys/music/songs/Soldier-s-Joy-81207819)
Almo