Melodeon.net Forums

Discussions => Teaching and Learning => Topic started by: mrdibbs on March 15, 2011, 10:19:10 PM

Title: How to Spice up a tune
Post by: mrdibbs on March 15, 2011, 10:19:10 PM
Hey out there,

I´m a beginner accordionist, but with a decent past in music and reading music, I have picked it up very quickly!!

One thing that i think is phenominal is how some of the better players can spice up a tune so quickly and easy (any single tune of the month videos!!) and I would love to do that as well. I´m not great at learning by ear, but i do have a good idea of when the added effects and triplets, etc. come into play.

Without revealing their secret, could anyone give me some general tips on how to ornament my music?? I´m a quick learner, but I need something to learn from!

Cheers and força canut
Title: Re: How to Spice up a tune
Post by: **DTN** on March 15, 2011, 10:28:39 PM
Hey out there,

I´m a beginner accordionist, but with a decent past in music and reading music, I have picked it up very quickly!!

One thing that i think is phenominal is how some of the better players can spice up a tune so quickly and easy (any single tune of the month videos!!) and I would love to do that as well. I´m not great at learning by ear, but i do have a good idea of when the added effects and triplets, etc. come into play.

Without revealing their secret, could anyone give me some general tips on how to ornament my music?? I´m a quick learner, but I need something to learn from!

Cheers and força canut

http://www.diatonics.co.uk/tuition.htm
 (http://www.diatonics.co.uk/tuition.htm)

its a start ... willing to help in other ways if required!

DTN
Title: Re: How to Spice up a tune
Post by: Alan Morley on March 15, 2011, 10:50:49 PM
A lot of it is down to experience, and knowing regular patterns that your fingers go to - almost on their own.

When you are comfortable with a tune and can play it with ease, you then relax into it and your instinct takes over.

You can also vary what you play, I probably don't play the same thing twice as I don't consciously think about ornamentation.

Derek's examples are great, and the cross fingering and bass side is something I could do with improving on - even though I have been playing a while.
Title: Re: How to Spice up a tune
Post by: Theo on March 15, 2011, 11:22:08 PM
Despite you saying you are not so good at playing by ear,  I do think the key thing is to listen carefully to the playing you are inspired by and get a feel for the details of dynamics and phrasing.  Conventional ornamentation has it's place too,  but there are a lot of tiny details of timing etc that make the difference between an ok performance and one that is a bit special.
Title: Re: How to Spice up a tune
Post by: george garside on March 16, 2011, 09:16:36 AM
agree with Theo  - all sorts of subtle additions & subtractions can be used  some of which are almost unheard but which have  a considerable effect on the overall sound of a tune.;  It makes sense to practice some ornementation entirely separate from tunes so that you havae a series of 'building blocks' that can be stuck in wherever best suited. eg long & short rolls, 3 finger triplets etc  etc.

There is also the 'less is more' free of charge ornementation which can be very effectivve eg stopping the bass immediately before a fast run up or down the treble end - the art of getting this right is choosing the precise moment when to bring back the bass - and of course there is the careful use of gracenotes by just using a spare finger to hardly touch a non tune button  for a fracation of a second.

My personal view is that if ornementation becomes a major part of the tune there is a distinct danger of buggering things up !

george :D
Title: Re: How to Spice up a tune
Post by: Bob Ellis on March 16, 2011, 11:46:21 AM
I found that there was a definite point in my playing career when a breakthrough took place in the use of ornamentation. I agree entirely with Theo that listening carefully to recordings is essential, but for me it was not sufficient, at least not at first. The breakthrough came when I went to a couple of workshops in quick succession - one led by Julian Sutton and the other by John Spiers, both of whom concentrated on ornamentation. One of these maestros (I forget which one) suggested finding a suitable tune or two in which you could practise a particular ornament to death until it became almost second nature. I took this on board, using Organdi to practice cuts, Trumpet Hornpipe for triplets, Canal en Octobre and Ganivelle for rolls and the B music of Speed the Plough for runs and pedal notes.

Concentrating on individual ornaments in this way enabled me to internalise them so that I can now call on them at appropriate places in other tunes. I agree that less is often more, but I found the need to overdo it initially to make my fingers familiar with how to play the ornaments and to enable my brain to understand where to use them and where not. Having internalised the mechanics of certain ornaments, I then found it easier to recognise their use when listening to tunes on CDs. Of course, we all learn in different ways, so what worked for me may not help others. On the other hand, it is worth a try.
Title: Re: How to Spice up a tune
Post by: mrdibbs on March 16, 2011, 02:33:45 PM
all great responses! Thank you friends!

Dave the Nutter: is that you in those videos??

I think the plan for me needs to be watch, listen, repeat, recreate, and so on. Practice and experience makes perfect, no?

thanks everyone.
Title: Re: How to Spice up a tune
Post by: Owen Woods on March 16, 2011, 06:14:00 PM
I've always been more into spicing up a tune using RH harmony and interesting bass than ornaments. Most of my playing has been done for dance and it is very easy to ruin a good dance tune by putting in too much ornamentation at the expense of bounce. So I have never made a conscious effort to add ornamentation to my tunes. However, over the years, some has snuck in, nothing particularly advanced, but I do now do some. It still isn't important enough to me to want to spend a lot of time on it though.
Title: Re: How to Spice up a tune
Post by: Anahata on March 16, 2011, 06:25:21 PM
I used to do a lot of ornamentation, but that was in the days when I used to play lots of Irish music. But aside from the triplets, grace notes, mordents and rolls that characterise that type of music, there are hundreds of other ways to embellish a tune - many of which George has listed.

Here's a few:
- accents
- accents in unexpected places
- different chords e.g. 1st and 2nd time
- playing a harmony  (If you're playing with someone else)
- missing notes out
- missing basses out (in all sorts of ways)
- adding RH chords
- chromatic "in between" notes
- melodic bass lines (one of my favourites, seemingly one of John K's too)
Title: Re: How to Spice up a tune
Post by: Alan Morley on March 16, 2011, 08:33:58 PM
I'd like to challenge Derek to spice up 'Soliders Joy' one of my least favourite tunes.....
Title: Re: How to Spice up a tune
Post by: Pat. on March 17, 2011, 08:24:48 AM
I totaly agree with George regarding over ornimentation,many a good tune is lost due to over enbelishment ,unfortunatly by  some of the most able of musicians.There is a time for every thing and knowing when and when to orniment,is the mark of a good player as apposed to a gifted musician,Thats my opinion anyway .
Title: Re: How to Spice up a tune
Post by: Theo on March 17, 2011, 08:28:53 AM
knowing when and when to orniment,is the mark of a good player

Stuart Hardy (http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=rztsXjza0zM) says that "ornamentation should serve the groove"  in other words it should add to the rhythm and pulse of the piece.  Couldn't agree more.
Title: Re: How to Spice up a tune
Post by: george garside on March 17, 2011, 09:33:39 AM
I totaly agree with George regarding over ornimentation,many a good tune is lost due to over enbelishment ,unfortunatly by  some of the most able of musicians.There is a time for every thing and knowing when and when to orniment,is the mark of a good player as apposed to a gifted musician,Thats my opinion anyway .

on that basis I'm glad I'm not a gifted musician!

george
Title: Re: How to Spice up a tune
Post by: Anahata on March 17, 2011, 09:57:52 AM
knowing when and when to orniment,is the mark of a good player as apposed to a gifted musician

on that basis I'm glad I'm not a gifted musician!

george
;D I didn't spot that the first time I read it! (I suppose it was meant to be the other way round)

Title: Re: How to Spice up a tune
Post by: melod-ian on March 17, 2011, 04:18:57 PM
I'd like to challenge Derek to spice up 'Soliders Joy' one of my least favourite tunes.....

really? put me down for that challenge too.. its a good tune, theres plenty you can do with that one.
Title: Re: How to Spice up a tune
Post by: Chris Ryall on March 19, 2011, 10:57:58 AM
I'd like to challenge Derek to spice up 'Soliders Joy' one of my least favourite tunes.....

Assuming you mean "soldier's joy" - it was the subject of a very famous Sidmouth workshop given by John K, I believe in the 80's. He apparently spend the entire hour on SJ - "spicing it up".  I wasn't there, but have tried the exercise.  All the techniques Anahata has listed can be brought in - you can even play it as a march  ;)
Title: Re: How to Spice up a tune
Post by: Anahata on March 19, 2011, 11:46:28 AM
He did do workshops on variations, but you might be confusing that with the later and possibly more famous workshop he did on repetition. I was there for that one, and we played Davy Knick Knack continuously for an hour.

The idea was that when you really get into a tune, variations come spontaneously in a way that can't happen if you try to impose them artificially. It's explained in the Medley Mania (http://www.johnkirkpatrick.co.uk/wr_MedleyMania.asp) article on his web site, at the end of which he announces his intention to to run that workshop. Worth a read!

He promises "we'll all have shared a wonderfully exhilarating experience", but what actually happened was a number of EFDSS "social dance" piano accordionists complained (a) that they didn't know the tune and (b) that no music was provided. That was after hearing the tune non-stop for an hour...

Title: Re: How to Spice up a tune
Post by: Ollie on March 19, 2011, 12:14:45 PM
He did do workshops on variations, but you might be confusing that with the later and possibly more famous workshop he did on repetition. I was there for that one, and we played Davy Knick Knack continuously for an hour.

 :o      *shudders*
Title: Re: How to Spice up a tune
Post by: Alan Morley on March 19, 2011, 12:21:13 PM

He promises "we'll all have shared a wonderfully exhilarating experience", but what actually happened was a number of EFDSS "social dance" piano accordionists complained (a) that they didn't know the tune and (b) that no music was provided. That was after hearing the tune non-stop for an hour...

I dropped into some EFDSS sessions in Whitby a couple of years ago - strangest sessions I have been in.

They seem to start off a tune - then instead of playing a set of perhaps three tunes - they all stop after one tune..

I got some really strange looks when on the fist tune of the session - I went on to play the normal second tune and realised that no-one else was playing...Everything seemed SOOOo serious and precise

The best pub I found in Whitby was absolutely nothing to do with the festival - but the locals in there were having a great time singing and playing guitars, all having a damn good laugh in what I would think of a 'proper' session. That was in The Elsinor.
Title: Re: How to Spice up a tune
Post by: Pat. on March 19, 2011, 01:29:09 PM
I know where you are comming from Almo ;)
Title: Re: How to Spice up a tune
Post by: **DTN** on March 19, 2011, 02:22:22 PM
I'd like to challenge Derek to spice up 'Soliders Joy' one of my least favourite tunes.....

I can't stand the tune either!... so i've done an experiment! ;D ... A '1 take' recording of the tune i remember with the first variations that come into my head (then never play the tune ever again!)... so the usual over chording, over complicated, over ornamented mushy stuff i usually do! >:E

derek

http://www.onmvoice.com/play.php?a=45377 (http://www.onmvoice.com/play.php?a=45377)

Title: Re: How to Spice up a tune
Post by: Kautilya on March 19, 2011, 02:27:16 PM
Hey out there,

I´m a beginner accordionist, but with a decent past in music and reading music, I have picked it up very quickly!!

One thing that i think is phenominal is how some of the better players can spice up a tune so quickly and easy (any single tune of the month videos!!) and I would love to do that as well. I´m not great at learning by ear, but i do have a good idea of when the added effects and triplets, etc. come into play.

Without revealing their secret, could anyone give me some general tips on how to ornament my music?? I´m a quick learner, but I need something to learn from!

Cheers and força canut

http://www.diatonics.co.uk/tuition.htm
 (http://www.diatonics.co.uk/tuition.htm)

its a start ... willing to help in other ways if required!

DTN
Lovely clear visuals on the fingering at that link. Tks
Title: Re: How to Spice up a tune
Post by: Kautilya on March 19, 2011, 02:30:39 PM
I'd like to challenge Derek to spice up 'Soliders Joy' one of my least favourite tunes.....

I can't stand the tune either!... so i've done an experiment! ;D ... A '1 take' recording of the tune i remember with the first variations that come into my head (then never play the tune ever again!)... so the usual over chording, over complicated, over ornamented mushy stuff i usually do! >:E



derek

http://www.onmvoice.com/play.php?a=45377 (http://www.onmvoice.com/play.php?a=45377)


How did  you produce the echo?..... which adds so much to the tone - very fruity and jaunty yet light and delicate (:)
Title: Re: How to Spice up a tune
Post by: **DTN** on March 19, 2011, 02:52:02 PM
http://www.onmvoice.com/play.php?a=45377 (http://www.onmvoice.com/play.php?a=45377)


Quote
How did  you produce the echo?..... which adds so much to the tone - very fruity and jaunty yet light and delicate (:)

Bit of 'large room' preset in Cubase EQ   8)
Title: Re: How to Spice up a tune
Post by: Bob Ellis on March 19, 2011, 03:59:50 PM
I'd like to challenge Derek to spice up 'Soliders Joy' one of my least favourite tunes.....

I can't stand the tune either!... derek
http://www.onmvoice.com/play.php?a=45377 (http://www.onmvoice.com/play.php?a=45377)

If this is what you can do with a tune you don't like, Derek :o, then I am going to have to search out your postings of tunes you do like! Soldier's Joy is not one of my favourite tunes either, but listening to your superb rendition of it made me think differently. Methinks it is a tune I shall have to revisit.
Title: Re: How to Spice up a tune
Post by: Alan Morley on March 19, 2011, 04:04:48 PM
I'd like to challenge Derek to spice up 'Soliders Joy' one of my least favourite tunes.....

I can't stand the tune either!... so i've done an experiment! ;D ... A '1 take' recording of the tune i remember with the first variations that come into my head (then never play the tune ever again!)... so the usual over chording, over complicated, over ornamented mushy stuff i usually do! >:E

derek

http://www.onmvoice.com/play.php?a=45377 (http://www.onmvoice.com/play.php?a=45377)

Derek, I sat smiling all the way through your track - I almost like the tune now  ;)

Well doodled, you rose to the challenge, so Soldiers Joy - Nil : DTN - 1

I think there should be a new feature on mel.net " Challenge Derek" - I need to find another pet hate now......

Thanks...and respect..

Alan


Title: Re: How to Spice up a tune
Post by: **DTN** on March 19, 2011, 06:54:53 PM
10/10.  Thanks Derek. And do you still not like it?

Thanks Chris .... and no not really! ;D ;D ;D
Derek
Title: Re: How to Spice up a tune
Post by: Mcgrooger on March 19, 2011, 07:50:42 PM
I'm sure that if this was the first time I'd ever heard the tune, I'd be searching it out, thinking, what a corker! I'm almost feeling that it's a pity we kicked it out of our band repertoire about 15 years ago! A loveley illustration of how to spice up a tune.   :D
Title: Re: How to Spice up a tune
Post by: Chris Ryall on March 20, 2011, 09:02:01 AM
If this is what you can do with a tune you don't like, Derek :o, then I am going to have to search out your postings of tunes you do like! Soldier's Joy is not one of my favourite tunes either, but listening to your superb rendition of it made me think differently. Methinks it is a tune I shall have to revisit.

We were about to move on - but it might be apposite to this thread to reflect on HOW Derek's stylistic verve has beautified this little cygnet of a tune.   http://www.onmvoice.com/play.php?a=45377 (Key=D) listen .. listen ..

  • Little bit of 'tease' in the intro using the chromatic F#-G-Ab run to replace F# G giving stronger resolution onto tunes real 1st note of A 8)
  • A nice brief statement of his tune's leitmotif (why don't we do this in sessions)?
  • Light but assertive pulse on the bellows - I'd say he's playing it as a scottiche
    I hear a short bass and beautifully choked of chords dum 'gap' Chaa 'gap' but it varies
  • punctate, clean right end technique (OK that's not 'spice' but it facilitates it)
  • absolute strict rhythm in the early part of each phrase - making that light swing at the end, all the nicer
  • a lot of double quavers replacing crochets, particularly when those crochets also repeat  
  • using these to substitute right hand runs - same place - 2nd time through
  • simple repetition of a variation when it sounds good
  • nice bass runs 2nd time (Derek 'might' have practised those)!
  • super squaring up of the bass (B+chord together, again cut off.
    I hear this toward the end of 2nd time, and a lot in the 3rd.  
    I think it steadies the pace beautifully  
  • basically further layering on top of [2] in repeat[ [3]
  • left hand has moved on to 'cross' chords
  • uses a sus chord briefly and lightly, replacing a dominant at the end of 1st B music
  • masterly slow down in the final bars
  • ending on a lead note slur C#->D
   



(http://t1.gstatic.com/images?q=tbn:ANd9GcSj5NQlU2wPyG-vS3JiZLlXqwh0HxXYhgaEV2VZxOz31r7tgD8LSQ)

The b'st'rd!  >:E  Having heard so many 'almost the same' melodeon new tunes in sessions - I think some of us would be calling 3rd time through a new composition!  

Underlying this, I think that perhaps makes SJ rather dull - it just goes up and down chords, so much - affords the clean riff that allows the Master so much variation and improvisation. Another example of 'less is more'?  Anyway - thanks  ;D
Title: Re: How to Spice up a tune
Post by: oggiesnr on March 20, 2011, 10:00:02 PM
Beautiful and superbly done.  Thanks.

However I think the other big factor here is that it's played at about half the speed that it's played in most sessions and that gives room for the tune to come through and the variations to be effective.

Steve
Title: Re: How to Spice up a tune
Post by: **DTN** on March 20, 2011, 11:16:23 PM
Beautiful and superbly done.  Thanks.

However I think the other big factor here is that it's played at about half the speed that it's played in most sessions and that gives room for the tune to come through and the variations to be effective.

Steve

You are so right! ... thats the one bit i did think about! ;D
Title: Re: How to Spice up a tune
Post by: Sandy on March 21, 2011, 10:19:47 AM
I really like the new Reggae Soldiers Joy with swing  8)

Thanks Derek.

cheers
Sandy
 (:)
Title: Re: How to Spice up a tune
Post by: Andrew Wigglesworth on March 21, 2011, 01:32:22 PM
He did do workshops on variations, but you might be confusing that with the later and possibly more famous workshop he did on repetition. I was there for that one, and we played Davy Knick Knack continuously for an hour.

The idea was that when you really get into a tune, variations come spontaneously in a way that can't happen if you try to impose them artificially. It's explained in the Medley Mania (http://www.johnkirkpatrick.co.uk/wr_MedleyMania.asp) article on his web site, at the end of which he announces his intention to to run that workshop. Worth a read!

He promises "we'll all have shared a wonderfully exhilarating experience", but what actually happened was a number of EFDSS "social dance" piano accordionists complained (a) that they didn't know the tune and (b) that no music was provided. That was after hearing the tune non-stop for an hour...
Yes, he did the same thing in a workshop at Whitby folk week. It was a memorable experience (a good one!).


Edit: quoting was screwed up
Title: Re: How to Spice up a tune
Post by: Owen Woods on March 26, 2011, 10:28:59 PM
Amazing DTN.
Title: Re: How to Spice up a tune
Post by: Chris Ryall on March 28, 2011, 01:28:01 PM
I really like the new Reggae Soldiers Joy with swing  8)

Seems to be yet another case of 'UK session speed' abandoning all hope of any Beauty in a tune  :-\

[edit]  :Ph
I think the other big factor here is that it's played at about half the speed that it's played in most sessions and that gives room for the tune to come through and the variations to be effective. Steve
Title: Re: How to Spice up a tune
Post by: Sandy on March 28, 2011, 03:17:33 PM
I really like the new Reggae Soldiers Joy with swing  8)

Seems to be yet another case of 'UK session speed' abandoning all hope of any Beauty in a tune  :-\

 ???
Title: Re: How to Spice up a tune
Post by: Thrupenny Bit on March 29, 2011, 05:40:10 PM
 ;D
Just listened to it, spot on DTN!
Lovely meanderings through the tune, taking the odd off-piste route as ever. Cracking.
I think the comments about speed are so important. It's only when you play it at this sort of speed you can investigate it's little nooks and crannys, as opposed to ' first to the end is the winner....' when the only aim can be getting to the end first.

We have an accordionist who regularly attends our monthly sessions, and always starts off too fast, then speeds up  >:(
Many use it as a 'get a pint' time.
My morris dancing non playing mate muttered " hasn't he ever danced?"
....and it's a question to think about. Many tunes have come down via dancing, whether social or display of some sort, so surely have rough parameters for the speed at which they should be played?
i.e. not so fast that you can barely hit all the notes!
But I digress and risk thread drift.....

thanks again DTN
cheers
Q
Title: Re: How to Spice up a tune
Post by: Stiamh on March 29, 2011, 07:15:44 PM
Really fine job, DTN, chapeau! Love the bass lines.
Title: Re: How to Spice up a tune
Post by: GbH on March 30, 2011, 12:19:47 AM
We have an accordionist who regularly attends our monthly sessions, and always starts off too fast, then speeds up  >:(
Many use it as a 'get a pint' time.
My morris dancing non playing mate muttered " hasn't he ever danced?"
....and it's a question to think about. Many tunes have come down via dancing, whether social or display of some sort, so surely have rough parameters for the speed at which they should be played?

Yeah, this is something that's making me feel less and less confident about trying to play tunes that are obviously intended for dancing.  Having not done any sort of folk dancing at all (or, for the most part, any other type, either), I don't have much to draw on that helps me to know how a particular type of tune should feel.   I've tried watching YouTube videos to see if that gives me a better idea about specific dances, but often I don't really know what I'm looking for.
Title: Re: How to Spice up a tune
Post by: Bob Ellis on March 30, 2011, 12:40:51 AM
We have an accordionist who regularly attends our monthly sessions, and always starts off too fast, then speeds up  >:(
Many use it as a 'get a pint' time.
My morris dancing non playing mate muttered " hasn't he ever danced?"
....and it's a question to think about. Many tunes have come down via dancing, whether social or display of some sort, so surely have rough parameters for the speed at which they should be played?

Yeah, this is something that's making me feel less and less confident about trying to play tunes that are obviously intended for dancing.  Having not done any sort of folk dancing at all (or, for the most part, any other type, either), I don't have much to draw on that helps me to know how a particular type of tune should feel.   I've tried watching YouTube videos to see if that gives me a better idea about specific dances, but often I don't really know what I'm looking for.

I don't agree entirely with Thrupenny Bit about this. I would agree that is difficult to play well for dancing (whether Morris or folk dancing) if you have never danced yourself, but it is possible. We have a concertina player with our Morris side who plays very well for dancing although she has never danced herself.

However, there is a difference between playing for dancing and playing in other situations. If you are playing for your own enjoyment, for people to listen to or in sessions, there is no reason why you, GbH, or anyone else should be required to play a tune as if you or they were playing for dancing. Play what you think sounds good and don't worry about whether it would be suitable for dancing - that is a different situation.

Morris tunes are a case in point: when they are played in sessions, they are often played faster than would be suitable for dancing and 'slows' are often omitted. An example of a Morris tune that is often speeded up in sessions is the Upton Stick Dance tune (sometimes known as Twin Sisters, although there is another tune of that name). If people criticise because it is not being played at a speed suitable for dancing, then they are out of order. The criticism would only be valid if you were playing for dancing.
Title: Re: How to Spice up a tune
Post by: Thrupenny Bit on March 30, 2011, 12:29:31 PM
Bob - actually I think you're right!
After reading your reply it reminds me I have a daughter who plays concertina for the morris, never danced but plays at a lovely 'dancable' speed and constant rhythm, so yes perhaps you don't need to dance to play at an appropriate speed.

I think I was trying to say was that for a given tune there's a broadly appropriate speed which will enable you to explore it and add to it beyond the printed dots for it.  I remember attending an improvisation workshop with Oyster probably in the early 80's where John Jones started off by saying since the revival of the 70's we're now learning how to play our ( English ) tunes again. Fast forward to now, and that's what's happening - a lot of people are exploring, trying out things, deviating from dots etc etc..... we are really now starting to 'work' the tunes, as beautifully shown by DTN above, and many others of this parish.
Inevitably some do not play like this, and play too fast to allow such explorations.
Could it be that some started off in other traditions, Irish for example, where speed seems to be a much more sought after commodity, and maybe 'keep the speed' in their other playing?
....or have I inadvertantly insulted a load of other traditional musicians with such a gross generalisation  :|bl

Q

Title: Re: How to Spice up a tune
Post by: Thrupenny Bit on March 30, 2011, 12:38:02 PM
GbH: maybe listening more will help you sort out your worries.
Listen to some of the morris sides, there will be a *huge* variation in music played, some depending on the requirements of the dance, and others on the limitations of the players. A large gathering at a festival is useful for this - like the seafront at Sidmouth on the sunday. If you walk along it, some dancing will catch your eye, and the music draws you in, others do not. Take a stroll with a pint in your hand and when you start to bounce along with a particular band/morris side, that's what you're after!
Similar with sessions - walk past pubs of a town hosting a festival and all sort of noises come out, again some sounding really good, others not quite so good. Go for a pint in the good sounding oes.
As ever....  :|glug can be your guide ;D

Not sure if this is a help, or just another excuse for a drink  ???
cheers
Q
Title: Re: How to Spice up a tune
Post by: george garside on March 30, 2011, 01:10:04 PM
I agree with Bob's comments.  What seems to happen is some sessions  is that  tunes are played with little or no thought  for their puirpose or function on ;the particular occasion or rendition.  As many tunes can be played in different ways for different purposes its useful to consider how to aim it, otherwise there is a likelyhood of it just coming out as the right notes in the right order only!.

Examples are the keel row which works equally well as a hornpipe, a march or a reel  but needs different emphasis on notes ( and length of notes) together with different speed & phrasing for each of the 3 versions. It is of course also a song to be sung & in that case need to be played so as to add rather than detract from the singer(s)  performance

Maggy can come as a slow air, a waltz or a march, 100 pipers  a waltz, pipemarch or jig.

waltzing matilda & click go the shears  as song accompaniment or as polkas

 etc ad infinitum!

Put simply always give a tune a 'purpose' and  posh it up  to aim it at that purpose.

george
Title: Re: How to Spice up a tune
Post by: Bob Ellis on March 30, 2011, 02:12:12 PM
Listen to some of the morris sides, there will be a *huge* variation in music played, some depending on the requirements of the dance, and others on the limitations of the players.

This comment reminds me that there are wide variations in the speed at which different Morris sides will perform the same dance (and therefore differences in the speed at which their musicians will play the tune). There have been a number of occasions when our side has combined with another one to perform a particular dance, usually with one set from each side. On several of these occasions there have been problems because the musicians and dancers from one side want the tune played at a different speed from those of the other side.

While there are speeds that are clearly too slow or too fast for anyone to perform a particular dance, in most cases, when someone says that the speed at which a Morris tune is played is 'too slow' or 'too fast', what they really mean is that it is too slow or too fast for the way that their side prefers to perform the dance.
Title: Re: How to Spice up a tune
Post by: Thrupenny Bit on March 30, 2011, 05:45:11 PM
Bob - over the years we've had numerous discussions about speed in our morris side, sometimes getting quite heated. I remember once our main musician brought in a metronome in an effort to help define our 'perfect' speed. On that night, the difference between what we felt was too fast or too slow actually came down to a matter of a beat or two per minute on the metronome, an unbelievably small difference!
You can add to this other factors, how we're feeling; how tired/fresh we are and very crucially, the venue. Outside a quiet pub on a monday is totally different to a ceilidh spot at a main festival. When we're feeling 'good' the speed slows noticably, as it allows greater time to dance higher.
I remember the best we danced a few years back was on our bike tour, after cycling up some really steep hills out Chagford way, around the edge of Dartmoor. We stopped off at a moorland pub, grabbed a pint and danced on a really steep hill, no audience, that last 'out' of the year, perfect lines ( rare!) and really well and vigorously .....cos we felt like it at that particular time. There is simply no logic to how well, and cosequently at what speed a side dances!
....but all this combines to being an absolute sod for a morris musician, cos they never know the exact speed until the first foot up indicates how the side's feeling at the time. In our side, the musicians starts at a 'normal for the dance' speed, watches what we're doing and adjusts as we get going. Difficult to get right, and this is all different for each side, as you rightly say.
But that's another thread!
cheers
Q
Title: Re: How to Spice up a tune
Post by: Graham Spencer on March 30, 2011, 05:57:04 PM
An example of a Morris tune that is often speeded up in sessions is the Upton Stick Dance tune (sometimes known as Twin Sisters

Sorry to get on one of my hobby horses, but the tune to Upton-Upon-Severn is "Brighton Camp" or something similar;  "The Twin Sisters" is a Newfoundland tune that happened to be published concurrently with Upton by Maud Karpeles, and the dance that most sides do (not ours!) to that tune is in fact the Chingford Stick Dance.  I seem to remember a discussion about this very topic not too long ago. As far as I'm concerned, "Twin Sisters" is ALWAYS played too fast, whether for dancing or listening..........

And FWIW, I don't play morris tunes any faster for listening, whether in a session or a folk club, as I feel it's disrespectful to the tune to do so, and the tune loses its character if its tempo is messed about with.

Dives for cover under nearest olive tree....... ;)
Title: Re: How to Spice up a tune
Post by: Alan Morley on March 30, 2011, 06:46:24 PM
An example of a Morris tune that is often speeded up in sessions is the Upton Stick Dance tune (sometimes known as Twin Sisters

Sorry to get on one of my hobby horses, but the tune to Upton-Upon-Severn is "Brighton Camp" or something similar;  "The Twin Sisters" is a Newfoundland tune that happened to be published concurrently with Upton by Maud Karpeles, and the dance that most sides do (not ours!) to that tune is in fact the Chingford Stick Dance.  I seem to remember a discussion about this very topic not too long ago. As far as I'm concerned, "Twin Sisters" is ALWAYS played too fast, whether for dancing or listening..........

And FWIW, I don't play morris tunes any faster for listening, whether in a session or a folk club, as I feel it's disrespectful to the tune to do so, and the tune loses its character if its tempo is messed about with.

Dives for cover under nearest olive tree....... ;)

When I played for Morris - I seemed to know a lot of tunes called 'Slow Down Alan' - well that's what they used to shout to me...  :||:

Alan
Title: Re: How to Spice up a tune
Post by: Owen Woods on March 30, 2011, 06:49:38 PM
My last experience at playing for Morris was Bampton Trunkles... apparently the corners are BCBCBC. We tried it twice, with one aborted start and I still couldn't do it by the end ::) Naturally tempo was even more all over the place than normal :(
Title: Re: How to Spice up a tune
Post by: Thrupenny Bit on March 30, 2011, 07:28:52 PM
' And FWIW, I don't play morris tunes any faster for listening, whether in a session or a folk club, as I feel it's disrespectful to the tune to do so, and the tune loses its character if its tempo is messed about with.....'

GPS has another good point, respecting the tune and it's original context.
I think there's no need to duck for that one  ;)
Q

Title: Re: How to Spice up a tune
Post by: Lester on March 30, 2011, 07:36:13 PM
' And FWIW, I don't play morris tunes any faster for listening, whether in a session or a folk club, as I feel it's disrespectful to the tune to do so, and the tune loses its character if its tempo is messed about with.....'

GPS has another good point, respecting the tune and it's original context.
I think there's no need to duck for that one  ;)
Q

I feel I must disagree with you both, the tunes won't mind if the are played faster/slower/different time sig etc. As long as you are the starter of a set of tunes it is up to you how you play them. Now if someone else starts the se and you disrespect them that is a whole different kettle of fish.
Title: Re: How to Spice up a tune
Post by: Thrupenny Bit on March 30, 2011, 07:48:11 PM
True.....
I suppose it's all revolving around 'respect'.... to the tune ( yes I know they won't really mind!), the starter etc. I'm sure a lot of us here have started a tune only for the rest of the players to sprint off with it.
....or go into another tune cos it sounds like it, as recently happened when I started Redowa Polka and everyone after the first few bars went off on another tune  >:(
Q
Title: Re: How to Spice up a tune
Post by: GbH on March 30, 2011, 10:59:40 PM
Thans for the responses to my earlier post, above.

Although I don't, obviously, play for dancing, I do sometimes play for others to listen to.  In such situations, it's probably the case that it doesn't really matter how I play individual tunes as most people won't know any different anyway.  However, I do find that there's a real danger of getting "it all sounds the same" comments - and that bothers me when I know they have a point.  I feel it's not really fair to expect others to pick up on differences in tune types when I don't really understand the differences myself.

George's post earlier, about playing single tune in different styles, seems to point to the root of the problem.  If you asked me to play Keel Row as a reel, march and hornpipe, as he mentions, I'd struggle to know what to do to keep faithful to those styles.  Most likely, they'd end up sounding the same, anyway.

As for the beer suggestion........I don't drink, so I'll have to leave that one for others to experiment with. 
Title: Re: How to Spice up a tune
Post by: Owen Woods on March 31, 2011, 12:38:36 AM
Thans for the responses to my earlier post, above.

Although I don't, obviously, play for dancing, I do sometimes play for others to listen to.  In such situations, it's probably the case that it doesn't really matter how I play individual tunes as most people won't know any different anyway.  However, I do find that there's a real danger of getting "it all sounds the same" comments - and that bothers me when I know they have a point.  I feel it's not really fair to expect others to pick up on differences in tune types when I don't really understand the differences myself.

George's post earlier, about playing single tune in different styles, seems to point to the root of the problem.  If you asked me to play Keel Row as a reel, march and hornpipe, as he mentions, I'd struggle to know what to do to keep faithful to those styles.  Most likely, they'd end up sounding the same, anyway.

As for the beer suggestion........I don't drink, so I'll have to leave that one for others to experiment with. 

The issue with it all sounding the same is one that I'm currently facing, with my first solo melodeon spot in a few weeks time. Although the average audience probably won't appreciate the difference between say a fast jig and a fast reel, they will appreciate the difference between a fast tune and a slow tune, a minor tune and a major tune and tunes in radically different keys.
Title: Re: How to Spice up a tune
Post by: Graham Spencer on March 31, 2011, 06:04:32 AM
I feel I must disagree with you both, the tunes won't mind if the are played faster/slower/different time sig etc. As long as you are the starter of a set of tunes it is up to you how you play them. Now if someone else starts the se and you disrespect them that is a whole different kettle of fish.

Actually, Lester, I don't think you are disagreeing with me - I don't play the tunes at a different tempo when they're not being danced to for the reasons I gave, but that doesn't mean that no-one else should.  If a tune I think should be played at one tempo is played at another (usually faster) I have the choice to go with the flow or to sit it out & wait for the next tune.  As you rightly say, however, If I start a tune at a given speed in a session it should stay at that speed, not be hi-jacked by the "look-how-much-faster-than-you-I-can-play" brigade.  

Graham
Title: Re: How to Spice up a tune
Post by: Alan Morley on March 31, 2011, 07:14:40 AM
There are some great Morris tunes that can be played 'differently', I did my version of Princess Royal some time back..

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=84UxOFTTH3U (http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=84UxOFTTH3U)

Alan
Title: Re: How to Spice up a tune
Post by: george garside on March 31, 2011, 09:03:29 AM
[ , If I start a tune at a given speed in a session it should stay at that speed, not be hi-jacked by the "look-how-much-faster-than-you-I-can-play" brigade.  

Graham

absolutely agree and would add that following the 'starter' should also apply even if the starter is struggling and playing a bit on the slow side.  It may have taken that person some courage to start a tune in a session & Hijacking a tune  can really knock their confidence.  If the speedy lot attempt to hijack a tune in my led sessions I just stop the proceedingss & point out that it iss good manners to follow the 'starter' I have never recieved a bollocking for so doing! - not yet anyway!

george
Title: Re: How to Spice up a tune
Post by: Just4Fun on March 31, 2011, 10:24:21 AM
Thanks George for your words of wisdom.
Speaking as a very raw newbie to sessions I can say with confidence that having gone through the terrors of starting a tune with trembling hands it's so reassuring to feel the session plodding along at the only pace I'm capable of (for some reason it's always easier at home). Thankfully the three sessions I go to are all very helpful and supportive as I'm sure that if anyone started running away with the tempo I would falter within a nano second. So a huge thank you to those who are and have been so encouraging.
Title: Re: How to Spice up a tune
Post by: Alan Morley on March 31, 2011, 11:47:05 AM
[ , If I start a tune at a given speed in a session it should stay at that speed, not be hi-jacked by the "look-how-much-faster-than-you-I-can-play" brigade.  

Graham

absolutely agree and would add that following the 'starter' should also apply even if the starter is struggling and playing a bit on the slow side.  It may have taken that person some courage to start a tune in a session & Hijacking a tune  can really knock their confidence.  If the speedy lot attempt to hijack a tune in my led sessions I just stop the proceedingss & point out that it iss good manners to follow the 'starter' I have never recieved a bollocking for so doing! - not yet anyway!

george

It might be of use if beginners were actually in a 'workshop' or 'tune around' more than a session where it's usual to play sets of tunes.

I have often been absolutely delighted to be in Irish or French sessions and completely lost, but loving the chance to hear some fantastic music played by skilled musicians and hoping to get a handle on the tunes and quietly join in. There are times you just have to sit and let it all soak in as the hurdy gurdy players drop into tunes in Dm..

I suppose it depends what you call a 'session'....it can kill a session dead if everyone has to play at the lowest level for too long..it's good to be challenged and stretched.

It also depends on the circumstances of the 'session' - i.e Down the local pub on a Thursday night, or at a Folk Festival venue. Just melodeons or a full range of instruments. Or it could be a sort of pre-arranged structured get together....or a free for all - jump in at the deep end session..

Then again a 'led' session that George refered to is something else, that would need a bit of discipline

(Preparing to be shot down.... :||: )

Alan
Title: Re: How to Spice up a tune
Post by: ladydetemps on March 31, 2011, 12:00:19 PM
[ , If I start a tune at a given speed in a session it should stay at that speed, not be hi-jacked by the "look-how-much-faster-than-you-I-can-play" brigade.  

Graham

absolutely agree and would add that following the 'starter' should also apply even if the starter is struggling and playing a bit on the slow side.  It may have taken that person some courage to start a tune in a session & Hijacking a tune  can really knock their confidence.  If the speedy lot attempt to hijack a tune in my led sessions I just stop the proceedingss & point out that it iss good manners to follow the 'starter' I have never recieved a bollocking for so doing! - not yet anyway!

george
For this very reason I tend to start slower than I can actually play, so that when the speed-a-holics (I've noticed it can only speed up 'so' quickly each time through the tune) speed it up I can still keep up by 3rd time round.


I have been known at one session in particular to turn round and ask if the tune could be played again this time slower. But then I'm cheeky like that. ;)
Title: Re: How to Spice up a tune
Post by: Anahata on March 31, 2011, 12:09:22 PM
It might be of use if beginners were actually in a 'workshop' or 'tune around' more than a session where it's usual to play sets of tunes.
If one exists. There are regular "slow" sessions run deliberately for beginners and early-stages improvers to get a chance to play with others.

Quote
I suppose it depends what you call a 'session'....it can kill a session dead if everyone has to play at the lowest level for too long..it's good to be challenged and stretched.
It doesn't have to be all the same. A mixed ability session should have mixed-ability tunes and playing speeds.

Ultimately though, all sessions are different. Hopefully you find or create one that's at the right level of being challenged and also being able to help others without either feeling too much of an imposition.

We have a couple of regular sessions where we like to keep the quality high and welcome good players and especially those who bring good tunes that we'd like to learn, but if I go to a one-off session or one where I don't know the other players well, I find myself starting off with tunes that I hope are really well known and gauging the session's level by gradually working towards the more obscure and tricky stuff.

By the way, it's been pointed out to me by seasoned sessioneer Flos Headford, that it's often the inexperienced players who go too fast when starting a tune, because they are nervous. A good experienced player can help by joining in and trying to hold it back to a more relaxed tempo. I've occasionally felt myself being held back that way.
Title: Re: How to Spice up a tune
Post by: Bob Ellis on March 31, 2011, 03:16:50 PM
There are some great Morris tunes that can be played 'differently', I did my version of Princess Royal some time back.

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=84UxOFTTH3U (http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=84UxOFTTH3U)

Alan

Almo's video illustrates perfectly the point I made earlier about the validity of playing Morris tunes in sessions at speeds that would be inappropriate when playing for dancers. His is a very good rendition and perfectly appropriate for a session, but I don't think any dancer would want to dance it at that speed.

Anahata's points about sessions are well made. A session that is sensitive to inexperienced players and those lacking confidence should encourage them by playing tunes they start at the speed at which they start them or by helping them to slow down if they have started too fast due to nervousness. Another way of supporting inexperienced or nervous players is to ask them quietly if there are tunes that they play at home but are not confident enough to start in the session. Starting and leading those tunes for them so that they have the opportunity to play them in a session environment will bring closer the day when they will feel confident enough to start those tunes themselves.
Title: Re: How to Spice up a tune
Post by: Alan Morley on March 31, 2011, 04:13:38 PM
There are some great Morris tunes that can be played 'differently', I did my version of Princess Royal some time back.

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=84UxOFTTH3U (http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=84UxOFTTH3U)

Alan

Almo's video illustrates perfectly the point I made earlier about the validity of playing Morris tunes in sessions at speeds that would be inappropriate when playing for dancers. His is a very good rendition and perfectly appropriate for a session, but I don't think any dancer would want to dance it at that speed.

Anahata's points about sessions are well made. A session that is sensitive to inexperienced players and those lacking confidence should encourage them by playing tunes they start at the speed at which they start them or by helping them to slow down if they have started too fast due to nervousness. Another way of supporting inexperienced or nervous players is to ask them quietly if there are tunes that they play at home but are not confident enough to start in the session. Starting and leading those tunes for them so that they have the opportunity to play them in a session environment will bring closer the day when they will feel confident enough to start those tunes themselves.

I wouldn't play Princess Royal that way in a session if I knew others were joining in, I'd keep it 'lively' but a lot simpler - it's different when you play on your own.

I totally agree with Anahata' comments too - there is a place for all skill levels. At a lot of sessions I have played at, there is usually some break in the evening where players can chat about tunes and swap ideas and ask for guidence if they need it - most players will be happy to help less experienced musicians where they can.

Almo
Title: Re: How to Spice up a tune
Post by: Alan Morley on April 12, 2011, 04:50:11 PM
I'd like to challenge Derek to spice up 'Soliders Joy' one of my least favourite tunes.....

I can't stand the tune either!... so i've done an experiment! ;D ... A '1 take' recording of the tune i remember with the first variations that come into my head (then never play the tune ever again!)... so the usual over chording, over complicated, over ornamented mushy stuff i usually do! >:E

derek

http://www.onmvoice.com/play.php?a=45377 (http://www.onmvoice.com/play.php?a=45377)

Having challenged Derek to spice up Soldier's Joy and him doing such a great job, I thought I'd better have a go.

Just recorded this today and uploaded to MySpace - it confirmed my thoughts about the audio quality on MySpace - it made me sound like I'm playing through a phazer....
oh well - you can still hear me anyway....

http://www.myspace.com/alanmorleys/music/songs/Soldier-s-Joy-81207819 (http://www.myspace.com/alanmorleys/music/songs/Soldier-s-Joy-81207819)

Almo
Title: Re: How to Spice up a tune
Post by: Mcgrooger on April 12, 2011, 07:35:38 PM

Having challenged Derek to spice up Soldier's Joy and him doing such a great job, I thought I'd better have a go.

Just recorded this today and uploaded to MySpace - it confirmed my thoughts about the audio quality on MySpace - it made me sound like I'm playing through a phazer....
oh well - you can still hear me anyway....

http://www.myspace.com/alanmorleys/music/songs/Soldier-s-Joy-81207819 (http://www.myspace.com/alanmorleys/music/songs/Soldier-s-Joy-81207819)

Almo

Sounds great to me Almo - shades of Tiger Moth and EII - really liked it.
Title: Re: How to Spice up a tune
Post by: **DTN** on April 12, 2011, 09:26:39 PM

Quote

Having challenged Derek to spice up Soldier's Joy and him doing such a great job, I thought I'd better have a go.

Just recorded this today and uploaded to MySpace - it confirmed my thoughts about the audio quality on MySpace - it made me sound like I'm playing through a phazer....
oh well - you can still hear me anyway....

http://www.myspace.com/alanmorleys/music/songs/Soldier-s-Joy-81207819 (http://www.myspace.com/alanmorleys/music/songs/Soldier-s-Joy-81207819)

Almo

WHOA!!! ... GOOOOOOOD!!
Title: Re: How to Spice up a tune
Post by: robriki on April 12, 2011, 10:12:41 PM
One thing John Whelan taught me in a master class : CCC wich stand for Clean Crisp and Clear.  And it has to bounce too!
SimplePortal 2.3.5 © 2008-2012, SimplePortal