Melodeon.net Forums
Discussions => Recordings and Videos => Topic started by: Howard Mitchell on March 16, 2011, 11:23:53 AM
-
Release date 11 April 2011, featuring John Kirkpatrick, Andy Cutting, Saul Rose, Matt and Dan Quinn, Katie Howson, Simon Bannister, Simon Care, Simon Ritchie, John Spiers, Nick Cooke, Mark Bazeley, Ed Rennie and special guests.
http://www.folkstore.co.uk/CDs/MrsCaseyRecords/Product/Various-Artists-Banquet-of-Boxes.html (http://www.folkstore.co.uk/CDs/MrsCaseyRecords/Product/Various-Artists-Banquet-of-Boxes.html)
The English Melodeon is central to the Folk Scene - these players are just some of many hundreds who can make the instrument sing.
"Great tunes played with drive, dexterity and sensitivity by some of the finest English Melodeon players around today. A landmark collection in the development of this wonderfully timeless instrument..."
John Jones, Oysterband
-
Already preordered mine :P
-
Have received mine (early Mother's Day pressie, although I thought it was going to be a late pressie!). Well worth buying, also the booklet states what melodeon is used by each player for the tracks.
-
Agh, you lot are bad. Zubz just mentioned this over on facebook, and now I seem to have bought myself a copy! I'm sure it will be worth every penny (at least I'll have something to listen to while I can't afford to do anything!) ::) :D
-
Well, that's another sale just chalked up... Mel-Net should negotiate a commission ;D
-
Well, that's another sale just chalked up... Mel-Net should negotiate a commission ;D
Absolutely. Another one here too.
-
Ah, 'tis a think of beauty.
Each track was recorded as a single take - not always the first take, but no mixing separate tracks.
John Spiers' piece is just wonderful.
Simon Care was at each recording - he described Saul Rose's track as "a masterclass" and as "near to perfection as you could get".
Not bad eh?!
:||:
-
Hopefully it will be on sale at Mendlesham !!
-
Hopefully it will be on sale at Mendlesham !!
Simon says ... "I hope to take some copies with me to Mendlesham".
So I guess "Simon says yes". :|glug
-
Terrific album - and Saul Rose walks away with the Best Pic prize by a country mile. So what chance the 198? 'English Melodeon Players' album being re-issued on CD. If there's anyone out there who can furnish me with a copy you'll be a friend for life as my vinyl is knackered. Sorted last night. Thanks to Mr & Mrs M.
-
Hopefully it will be on sale at Mendlesham !!
I snaffled one there Sandy and thank goodness CD doesn't wear like Vinyl, both BoB and Rees' CD have hardly been off the player since :D
Certainly some class playing and a wonderful variety of styles and sounds, aspirational ! (both on 'em)
Richard
-
I grabbed one at Mendlesham and we listened to it in the car on the way home.
Does what it says on the tin! delicious (:)
-
Mine hasn't come yet :(
-
I was so busy all weekend I forgot to buy one, did read the sleeve notes though, and was delighted to find I get a mention on Simon Ritchie's notes. Now where can I buy online?
-
Theo, you can buy it from the Mrs Casey Music website.
Wendy
-
Thanks Wendy, I have just done exactly that!
-
Mine arrived today. There is some truly remarkable playing on this album. Thank you to Simon Care for coming up with the idea.
-
And Simon C is already thinking who to put on the second one.
-
Just ordered one - I danced with Nick Cook's dad (Nigel - a mean melodeon player in his own right), in the 80's in Bristol.
<later> oops - just re-read this - Cotsworld Morris of course!
-
Mine got sent to the wrong address. I have it now, will listen tomorrow ;D
-
And Simon C is already thinking who to put on the second one.
I vote for Clive, Anahata and DTN!
-
can anyone tell me the track listings? particularly mark bazeley and ed rennie , will have to put this on my birthday list cos i just put a deposit down for a new customised gabbanelli! :o
-
i just ordered 2 copies ... because i know i'll meet someone who wants a copy soon!
And yeah! .. i want to be on the next one! ;D ;D
Melnet ...The Album!
-
i just ordered 2 copies ... because i know i'll meet someone who wants a copy soon!
And yeah! .. i want to be on the next one! ;D ;D
Melnet ...The Album!
We should definitely do melnet the album ;D That way I might stand a chance of getting on it :P
-
Is it me, or has this album been really badly mixed? Everything sounds very harsh, but also very mushy, and there is little separation between bass and treble. It's also all generally very loud and in your face. I actually find it quite hard to listen to. :-\
-
I've found it quite variable. Some tracks are fine, but some really aren't. The Andy Cutting one in particular I have to say :( Part of it is that it is just box recorded in a studio, which is dry. I found a similar sound when recording some stuff using my melodeon mic, the sound was good, but it wasn't quite right, because our perception of the instrument isn't what it sounds like a few cm away, but a few feet away.
-
Is it me, or has this album been really badly mixed? Everything sounds very harsh, but also very mushy, and there is little separation between bass and treble. It's also all generally very loud and in your face. I actually find it quite hard to listen to. :-\
I've only listened to it in the car on the way back from Mendlesham. Must put it on my studio system and have a careful listen...
"Loud and in your face" could be mics too close and/or too much overall compression.
"Harsh and mushy" suggests distortion, for which there is no excuse.
Bass/treble separation: in a dry studio don't expect much unless you artifically mic the two sides separately, but a simple stereo pair in a decent sized room with a good room acoustic should get a realistic sound picture by picking up treble and bass reflected off the side walls.
Part of it is that it is just box recorded in a studio, which is dry. I found a similar sound when recording some stuff using my melodeon mic, the sound was good, but it wasn't quite right, because our perception of the instrument isn't what it sounds like a few cm away, but a few feet away.
Usually a dry studio recording has some artificial reverb added to it, or it will sound dreadfully clinical and close-up.
A mic too close cannot be made to sound like a mic pulled back, but you need the right room sound (or lack of it) for a mic at a more natural distance to sound right.
-
Is it me, or has this album been really badly mixed? Everything sounds very harsh,
Not just you Ollie, I found it uncomfortable to listen to, as if the player was right in my face, even with the volume fairly low.
-
Is it me, or has this album been really badly mixed? Everything sounds very harsh, but also very mushy, and there is little separation between bass and treble. It's also all generally very loud and in your face. I actually find it quite hard to listen to. :-\
I've only listened to it in the car on the way back from Mendlesham. Must put it on my studio system and have a careful listen...
"Loud and in your face" could be mics too close and/or too much overall compression.
"Harsh and mushy" suggests distortion, for which there is no excuse.
Bass/treble separation: in a dry studio don't expect much unless you artifically mic the two sides separately, but a simple stereo pair in a decent sized room with a good room acoustic should get a realistic sound picture by picking up treble and bass reflected off the side walls.
Part of it is that it is just box recorded in a studio, which is dry. I found a similar sound when recording some stuff using my melodeon mic, the sound was good, but it wasn't quite right, because our perception of the instrument isn't what it sounds like a few cm away, but a few feet away.
Usually a dry studio recording has some artificial reverb added to it, or it will sound dreadfully clinical and close-up.
A mic too close cannot be made to sound like a mic pulled back, but you need the right room sound (or lack of it) for a mic at a more natural distance to sound right.
I always use some reverb on my Streb in the band, as the "straight" sound does not sound like a box at all. I guess it is missing the resonance of the instrument itself.
-
Is it me, or has this album been really badly mixed? Everything sounds very harsh,
Not just you Ollie, I found it uncomfortable to listen to, as if the player was right in my face, even with the volume fairly low.
I found it fine...but then I have cheap headphones that need to be turned up full volume to hear anything. lol!
-
And here was I wondering what all the noise was about.
Cheers :|glug
-
Hi Folks,
Thanks for all the kind comments. Was certainly a labour of love.
@Ollie.....I'm concerned about your remarks as i have just relistened three times on my yamaha home system, mycar system and my daughters little cd player and am not suffering harshness, mushyness or lack of separation. Maybe check your eq on your system!!!
Anyway.....all criticism is good.
From a technical point, the instruments were not close miked. And two tracks were recorded in a different studio.The brief for the album was "Raw yet refined" . I personally think we acheived this.
Thanks and enjoy
Simon
-
I ordered mine on Monday (or was it Tues?), not arrived yet.....
-
My EQ is usually Ok; other solo (or nearly) melodeon albums (Spiers & Boden, Andy Cutting etc) sound fine, but there is something about some of these tracks that just doesn't sit right. The overall sound is very loud (over compression was what immediately sprang to mind) and, as Ukebert says, the Andy Cutting track in particular is very harsh... 0:23 seconds (an other places) it does sound like it clips. I dunno, might just be my over-active ears (mixing and mastering all my Music Tech A level coursework at the moment), but there's not a lot of warmth to the sound over all.
The playing is of course superb, but I don't think it'll get many plays, which is such a shame. :-\
-
Seven National radio plays in less than a week is fine for me, Ollie.
Regards
Simon
-
I've listened to it at home, so far on a pair of HHB circle 3's - good bookshelf-size speakers that I use on my computer (they are not "computer speakers") and it seems fine, except I thought I had L and R channels reversed - then I found what seems to be a blown tweeter on the left channel. :|bl
But apart form that, deep bass on some tracks (e.g. the first) seemed a bit too much to be true, but general sound very clear with no mushyness or harshness, and not a dry studio sound, but I'd guess the reverb was artificial.
-
That's interesting. I haven't listened to it through decent speakers yet, but my impression was that most tracks were OK, just exhibited the usual problems with recording boxes. Some tracks are beautifully mixed. The one that stood out was Andy Cutting's track, which was predictably enough one of the best tracks on the CD, but which didn't sound right. I'll have a more detailed listen through proper speakers, it might just be a product of my cheap headphones.
-
A pet theory of mine re listening to box players on headphones - it never seemed to sound right to me until I put the headphones on the "wrong way round". From an audiences' point of view the left is dominantly treble and the right dominantly bass but for a player we normally hear it the other way round as we are stood behind the source of the sound. This is, to my mind, much more apparent when listened to on headphones.
-
Right, I've gone through the album again with decent speakers and it's as I remember it. Overall not too bad, but on some tracks, generally the dry tuned ones for some reason there is something wrong. I'm afraid my ear isn't competent enough to say what, but it sounds like it's just a little bit too raspy on the treble if that makes sense. The Andy Cutting track is definitely wrong though, that's a lot more noticeable. There are several places in the first tune where it's clipping, or doing some other sound techy thing wrong. I have a friend who has done a lot of sound tech but unfortunately he's miles away so can't get his opinion :(
The impression that I do have from the album is that it is loud, but I'm not sure whether that's over-compression or just people playing loudly :P
Whether or not the technical issues exist though it is a very enjoyable album to listen to (:)
-
Just got my version, so sensitised by the comments here, I sat and listened to it all the way through, my initial reaction was that on many of the tracks (especially Nigel's, Saul's, Katie's and others) the bass end was very high versus the treble end. On the other hand you could then "hear" what the player was doing both ends! The recording did seem to be a bit "in your face", with the bass end a bit more instrusive, that is usual for melodeon recordings.
I then dug out my copy of Katie's "the Green 'Un'" and listened to her track on the BOB CD back to back with her on TGU. Definate increase in overall volume (I had to adjust the volumer quickly to avoid annoying the whole house), when going to the BOB recording. Also quite a distinct increase in bass end "visibility" (or whatever the acoustic equivalent is).
I then did the same for Andy Cutting, in this case did not seem to be a lot of difference, volume level was the same on both recordings (at least the tracks I compared), and maybe slightly more bass end on BOB, but not (in this case) intrusively.
Did I enjoy it YES - will I play it again - oh yes. Waiting to hear what it sounds like in the car (tomorrow).
My 2p - YMMV.
-
can anyone tell me the track listings? particularly mark bazeley and ed rennie , will have to put this on my birthday list cos i just put a deposit down for a new customised gabbanelli! :o
-
Its a very very enjoyable CD .. bit Bass heavy at times ... but i like that!... shows off the skill! ..hehe! ;D
Melnet CD .. Im in .. and i want Clive and Sandy on it!!!
-
Melnet CD .. Im in .. and i want Clive and Sandy on it!!!
Ditto squire! ;D I want Sandy and DTN and Anahata and ... lots of other great players we have here!
-
cheers DTN ed rennie is actualy my melodeon tutor!
-
Have been playing the CD all day whilst decorating. Wonderful !
-
Just got my copy, well, we're always a bit slow and behind the times in Devon
I'm flicking back to one track continually. I think Saul's playing is, for me, summed up in one word.
'Exquisite'
Q
-
indeed sauls track is a masterclass
-
I thought we were meant to be having the banquet, but i like the cover picture with all the beautiful melodeons attending the banquet
-
Got my copy at Chippenham at the weekend. I've only listened to the CD in the car and it sounded fine to me (admittedly not the best listening venue but the CD player is good quality). I've also ripped it to my iPod and, again, I can find nothing to complain about. I don't have a proper hi-fi system any more but I will put it in my CD player this evening and see what that sounds like.
Anyway, I love the CD, my stand out tracks being Squeezy's, Saul's and Katie's with an honourable mention for the Simon Care/Will Pound duet.
Darren
-
Had listen last night on my CD player. Didn't notice any problems with loudness or bassiness, the balance sounded fine to me. The Andy Cutting track; not sure whether I was influenced by this thread or whether I actually heard anything but whatever I heard (real or imagined) didn't affect my listening pleasure. Can't wait for volume two.
-
Some videos of the CD launch night:
http://forum.melodeon.net/index.php/topic,7035.msg87813.html#msg87813 (http://forum.melodeon.net/index.php/topic,7035.msg87813.html#msg87813)
-
Yes it was sent to mine by mistake,i hope you don't mind i played it before i sent it on