Melodeon.net Forums

Discussions => Instrument Design, Construction and Repair => Topic started by: Theo on March 18, 2011, 08:20:16 AM

Title: Pull effect on tuning. (was Busilacchio melodeon - any good)
Post by: Theo on March 18, 2011, 08:20:16 AM
, and now the reeds pull the notes, which is unsatisfactory.


Could you explain what you mean please?
Title: Pull effect on tuning was Busilacchio melodeon - any good
Post by: old geezer on March 18, 2011, 09:58:23 AM
This pull effect has been mentioned before on this site.

It’s ages since I attempted to tune this box, and was disappointed with the result, and is why I’ve moved on to other projects.
I’m remembering in March 09, that I did ask on this forum; http://forum.melodeon.net/index.php/topic,1495.0.html as to how to blank off one bank of reeds with the rectangle apertures to the reed chambers. I used several foam ear-plugs cut in-half because; the pallet opened a elongated hole, and the centre mullion dividing the 2 reed chambers did not extend to the bottom reed block.
The slip of paper under the reed block would not work imo.
I tuned one C5 to 523hz and its corresponding mate to 526, instead of hearing a crisp tremolo between the two reeds, I’m hearing a flattened note, that I’m not happy with. It’s not occurring to all of the reeds, but is evident with some of the others also.
I have experienced this flattened effect with some Hohner reeds, where I have tuned one reed to equal temperament and the 2nd to 10-12 cents sharp. I have had to sometimes take the reed to about 16 cents, to hear a clear tremolo between the 2.
I do not fully understand why this is occurring. Is it something relating to the properties of steel used, the gap tolerance within the reed plate aperture or type of wood used in construction of the melodeon?
I have thought to treat my Busilacchio to a set of new Cagnoni reeds one day.
Harmonics can play havoc at times, with disastrous effects.
Title: Pull effect on tuning was Busilacchio melodeon - any good
Post by: Owen Woods on March 18, 2011, 10:10:21 AM
This pull effect has been mentioned before on this site.

Has it? ???
Title: Re: Pull effect on tuning. (was Busilacchio melodeon - any good)
Post by: Theo on March 18, 2011, 12:00:41 PM
I've split this to a new topic because its drifted well away from the original subject.

Does this "pull" effect happen when the reedblocks are on the tuning bench, or only when they are fitted in the box?
Title: Re: Pull effect on tuning. (was Busilacchio melodeon - any good)
Post by: george garside on March 18, 2011, 12:33:56 PM
? is it the reed or the arm!

george
Title: Re: Pull effect on tuning. (was Busilacchio melodeon - any good)
Post by: blafleur on March 18, 2011, 01:00:07 PM
I'm not sure if I'm understanding it correctly, but if I understand that you are not able to isolate each individual reed, and one other that the one you are wanting to tune keeps speaking out of turn?  In boxes with fixed reed blocks and no slides (or poor slides), I have used masking tape on the face of the accordion over the rows of holes I'm not tuning, also, toothpicks in the reeds I'm not tuning in a given bank.
Title: Re: Pull effect on tuning was Busilacchio melodeon - any good
Post by: diatonix on March 19, 2011, 08:48:29 AM

I have experienced this flattened effect with some Hohner reeds, where I have tuned one reed to equal temperament and the 2nd to 10-12 cents sharp. I have had to sometimes take the reed to about 16 cents, to hear a clear tremolo between the 2.


Did you make sure that the reed blocks are connected with a metal strip or in some other way? Also, when having this kind of problem with smaller reeds (the ones that normally do not require valves) it often helps to turn them around.
Title: Re: Pull effect on tuning. (was Busilacchio melodeon - any good)
Post by: old geezer on March 21, 2011, 03:48:58 AM
Does this "pull" effect happen when the reedblocks are on the tuning bench, or only when they are fitted in the box?

I was tuning the reeds fitted in the reed blocks in the box, using an OT-120 and contact mic.

Did you make sure that the reed blocks are connected with a metal strip or in some other way? Also, when having this kind of problem with smaller reeds (the ones that normally do not require valves) it often helps to turn them around.

no the reed blocks where not connected at the top

I have noted; Theo recently mentioned fitting a link between the top of the reed blocks. I have seen Hohner Corso’s with pins inserted between the reed blocks, and assumed that this would make the reed blocks more rigid.

I have since pulled the box out of storage and after giving it a squeeze for over an hour, (it originally came with 2 broken reeds) another reed developed a crack so, IMO the reeds are bugga’ed. I’ll fit a new set of reeds to it one day, maybe.
This box is big for a 2 row
Title: Re: Pull effect on tuning was Busilacchio melodeon - any good
Post by: forrest on March 21, 2011, 09:20:09 PM

I tuned one C5 to 523hz and its corresponding mate to 526, instead of hearing a crisp tremolo between the two reeds, I’m hearing a flattened note.....

Hello Jack....what are you comparing the "flattened" note against, in order to determine that it is 'flat'? Intervals with other notes? By ear? Tuning meter?
   As you may well know, identical reeds, when tuned slightly apart, can affect one another and the change will affect both reeds to an extent. I have found that my ear often mistakes a flatted sound for a tonal relationship where one reed, or pair of reeds, or (guitar, mandolin etc.) string has become sharp.
Title: Re: Pull effect on tuning. (was Busilacchio melodeon - any good)
Post by: old geezer on March 23, 2011, 01:46:13 AM
Has fatigue set-in? reeds go flat as a crack develops and eventually break. the reeds in this box appear to have passed their use-by-date, as to 3 broken reeds that I know of, on the C row may well mean that they have all been well used at some time, by a previous owner. I assume that the life of a reed depends on many factors, including how often and hard one plays a box, will contribute to the service life expectancy of reeds.
SimplePortal 2.3.5 © 2008-2012, SimplePortal