Melodeon.net Forums

Discussions => Instrument Design, Construction and Repair => Topic started by: Nick Hudis on March 19, 2011, 03:13:40 PM

Title: Beyond dutch reversals
Post by: Nick Hudis on March 19, 2011, 03:13:40 PM
Having experimented with standard layout and club layout, my next box project will have a dutch reversal.

But that set me thinking.  On a G/C box, it would be really useful to have the G and A reversals in the upper octave as well, as these notes occur frequently in scale runs. Given that the pushed G and pulled A are duplicated  on both rows, it is in theory possible to have a reversed G and A in this octave.  Of course up there you'd need new reeds rather than simply turning the G/A around. You'd need, for example, to replace the C row G/F with a G/A and the C/A with a C/G.  I imagine the reeds would need to be custom made?

Just curious whether anyone has tried this or thought about before.
Title: Re: Beyond dutch reversals
Post by: Nick Hudis on March 20, 2011, 09:57:04 AM
oops I think I was having a bad dyslexia day.  The changed buttons on the inner row would need to be:

Button 8 A/F, Button 9 C/G (that would be E/C and G/D on a D/G box, but I am not sure this layout would be useful to a D/G player)
Title: Re: Beyond dutch reversals
Post by: Nick Hudis on March 23, 2011, 12:39:39 PM
Seem to be having a solo thread here.  Wonder how long I can keep it up? But I am curious that no one does anything with those duplicate notes on knee end of the box. I habitually take the high G and A on the outer row, so the corresponding buttons on the C row are virtually unused. Seems like an opportunity.
Title: Re: Beyond dutch reversals
Post by: Simon on March 23, 2011, 03:39:08 PM
It has been done but I forgot the details.  :-\
Title: Re: Beyond dutch reversals
Post by: Flanna on March 23, 2011, 05:15:36 PM
Seem to be having a solo thread here.  Wonder how long I can keep it up? But I am curious that no one does anything with those duplicate notes on knee end of the box. I habitually take the high G and A on the outer row, so the corresponding buttons on the C row are virtually unused. Seems like an opportunity.

It might be fun to keep the G row as it is and make the inner row all accidentals and reversals. That would get rid of the duplicate notes.
Title: Re: Beyond dutch reversals
Post by: Andy in Vermont on March 25, 2011, 12:42:18 PM
Just curious whether anyone has tried this or thought about before.

You should check out the Milleret/Pignol suggested layouts.
In the simple form, they reverse the lower G/A reedplate on the inside row.
In the more advanced form, they change several reedplates in the higher octave. 
Title: Re: Beyond dutch reversals
Post by: playandteach on July 18, 2013, 09:50:05 PM
Having experimented with standard layout and club layout, my next box project will have a dutch reversal.

But that set me thinking.  On a G/C box, it would be really useful to have the G and A reversals in the upper octave as well, as these notes occur frequently in scale runs. Given that the pushed G and pulled A are duplicated  on both rows, it is in theory possible to have a reversed G and A in this octave.

Just curious whether anyone has tried this or thought about before.
I'm also curious about this now, having lived with the mid G/A reversal for a few weeks. Does anyone else have experience about switching the upper octave? I've got to have some work done that requires removing the reeds very soon, so it might be a good time - or does it require too many compromises?
Title: Re: Beyond dutch reversals
Post by: Cooper on July 18, 2013, 11:09:40 PM
Having experimented with standard layout and club layout, my next box project will have a dutch reversal.

But that set me thinking.  On a G/C box, it would be really useful to have the G and A reversals in the upper octave as well, as these notes occur frequently in scale runs. Given that the pushed G and pulled A are duplicated  on both rows, it is in theory possible to have a reversed G and A in this octave.

Just curious whether anyone has tried this or thought about before.
I'm also curious about this now, having lived with the mid G/A reversal for a few weeks. Does anyone else have experience about switching the upper octave? I've got to have some work done that requires removing the reeds very soon, so it might be a good time - or does it require too many compromises?

i know some people who play with the suggested switches and they are very happy with it.

I myself play half of it. Down low i did remove the pushing G on the innerrow for a pushing A. In the upperoctave i didnt change the original layout because i like to play a lot "up and don the row" there. I like very much not having to change button on the g/f.
I think it is an option to change the highest a on the outerrow btw into something else more useful.

W
Title: Re: Beyond dutch reversals
Post by: playandteach on July 18, 2013, 11:48:42 PM

[/quote]

i know some people who play with the suggested switches and they are very happy with it.

I myself play half of it. Down low i did remove the pushing G on the innerrow for a pushing A. In the upperoctave i didnt change the original layout because i like to play a lot "up and don the row" there. I like very much not having to change button on the g/f.
I think it is an option to change the highest a on the outerrow btw into something else more useful.

W
[/quote]
That's my opposite experience; I dislike having to change bellows direction to play A, G, F in the upper octave - would keeping the outer row A, and changing the inner A to G, on the pull be a common switch?
Title: Re: Beyond dutch reversals
Post by: Owen Woods on July 19, 2013, 08:54:56 AM
Missed this thread. I have a D/Em, which has push Es and pull Ds on the G row (equivalent of push As and pull Gs for a G/C). I am very happy with it, it works very well. I wrote a bit about it here: http://ukebert.wordpress.com/2012/02/18/inside-and-out-part-1-the-super-preciosa/
Title: Re: Beyond dutch reversals
Post by: Cooper on July 19, 2013, 10:00:17 AM


i know some people who play with the suggested switches and they are very happy with it.

I myself play half of it. Down low i did remove the pushing G on the innerrow for a pushing A. In the upperoctave i didnt change the original layout because i like to play a lot "up and don the row" there. I like very much not having to change button on the g/f.
I think it is an option to change the highest a on the outerrow btw into something else more useful.

W
[/quote]
That's my opposite experience; I dislike having to change bellows direction to play A, G, F in the upper octave - would keeping the outer row A, and changing the inner A to G, on the pull be a common switch?
[/quote]

I think the common change is to remove the push G and add an A on push on the innerrow (i tried for a while playing with that a on push on th eouterrow, but that is awful). I guess then the a on pull should be a g, on the innerrow. (to keep your system intact, and i think, if you change the outerrow a in a g it will be too far out)
W
Title: Re: Beyond dutch reversals
Post by: playandteach on July 06, 2015, 09:39:34 PM
What are the options for having a high F on the push (G/C)? It seems really awkward to me not to have a free running E, F, G, A up there.
For example the 3rd full bar of Rose of Raby (in Am on a G/C) I can play all on the pull, but I might want to play it all on the push, so that the pattern remains the same as bar 7 (those are the triplet bars).
Title: Re: Beyond dutch reversals
Post by: Baron Collins-Hill on July 06, 2015, 10:24:01 PM
F's on the push are tricky on a 2 row, unless you want to get rid of a redundant push G on your C row. That would break up the continuity of your on-the-row scale, though. I've designed a reversals-optimized (for me) 3 row, and my C push on a D/G (F on your G/C) is still on the 3rd row. You can read about my layout (D/G/Acc 3 row with the G row fully dutch reversal-ed) here:

http://forum.melodeon.net/index.php/topic,16417.0.html (http://forum.melodeon.net/index.php/topic,16417.0.html)
Title: Re: Beyond dutch reversals
Post by: playandteach on July 06, 2015, 11:41:55 PM
Looks like when you pull a loose thread on a jumper - and the whole thing unravels. For some reason the doubled Gs (G/C) bug me more higher up than in the middle (where I'm changing them anyway).
But maybe I should just learn to play the instrument properly.
Title: Re: Beyond dutch reversals
Post by: Theo on July 07, 2015, 08:10:57 AM
If you feel the need for a more logical layout without duplicates then you need a piano accordion.  It is the limitations that makes the diatonic box. 
SimplePortal 2.3.5 © 2008-2012, SimplePortal