Melodeon.net Forums
Discussions => General Discussion => Topic started by: fallonje on March 22, 2011, 02:22:10 AM
-
I was playing some Cotswold tunes (Constant Billy, Gallant Hussar, William and Nancy etc.) on the one row and was wondering. Are there any sides/musicians who regularly play one row for Morris? Do any of you play the one row for Morris? Just curious.
Joe
-
I always loved the rhyme in the song Gallant Hussar - "His accoutrements shone like a star."
Our NW side have always used 4-stops in C for a few tunes as a change from the usual D/G sound, although it leaves the players somewhat knackered! The border side used to have one player who used a couple of Hohner 4-stops to add a little extra grunt to the sound - wonderful.
Rob.
-
Two of the Grimsby M.M.'s musicians use one row boxes some of the time.
-
Yep....Ken Watson and the remarkable Steve Fuller both play one rows for Grimsby Morris Men and are very, very fine exponents of it......I've also been known to use a one row for morris when the opportunity arises...
-
I have played for morris with a one row, though not often. They are ideal for the explosive steps of Border Morris, especially whilst 'sticking'.
Over the years, I've seen dozens of dances played to a one row. I personally love the sound.
-
Old Glory Molly from East Suffolk also have a band based on Hohner 1-row C boxes.
I agree it's a great sound, and as it's got at least as many notes as a 3 hole pipe, it's got enough for morris.
-
I occasionally play a Hohner 4-stop 1-row for morris, but usually only when I'm the sole musician, as I much prefer my C box - which tends to upset the D/G players a bit! My G 1-row sounds glorious, but is so air-hungry I'd be more worn out than the dancers by the end of a set. It does get the odd bit of use to add a bit of grunt and richness to the ranks of D/Gs, though.
Graham
-
For Cotswold (Bledington) it's always a solo musician for our side. Solo or more for the Border side. I like the punch of the one row and feel I can "dance" with it better than with my D/G. Difficult for the Dorian tunes bass-wise though. I play a Beltuna, key of D.
-
I gave the one row a good workout last night at Morris practice with great results. It even worked OK with Idbury Hill,"wrong" basses and all. It will make a good contrast to the other instruments played by the side, D/G MMM Serenellini Cloud, concertina and fiddle. Are there any recordings that feature the one row for Morris. My searching turns up little. Thanks for the responses.
Joe
-
I'm sure John Kirkpatrick has some somewhere!
-
For Cotswold (Bledington) it's always a solo musician for our side. Solo or more for the Border side. I like the punch of the one row and feel I can "dance" with it better than with my D/G. Difficult for the Dorian tunes bass-wise though. I play a Beltuna, key of D.
The trick is to stop worrying and play.
-
I gave the one row a good workout last night at Morris practice with great results. It even worked OK with Idbury Hill,"wrong" basses and all. It will make a good contrast to the other instruments played by the side, D/G MMM Serenellini Cloud, concertina and fiddle. Are there any recordings that feature the one row for Morris. My searching turns up little. Thanks for the responses.
Joe
I searched high and low and couldn't find any, which is a shame.
The one row deserves a wider audience for english traditional music.
-
Thanks Andrew. I'm not really worried about it. I'm just curious if it's common. The side I play for, The Albemarle Morris Men, have only had a few musicians in their 33 years and none have played the one row, 'til now anyway.
-
Thanks Andrew. I'm not really worried about it. I'm just curious if it's common. The side I play for, The Albemarle Morris Men, have only had a few musicians in their 33 years and none have played the one row, 'til now anyway.
Sorry, I just realised I should have been more specific, this not to worry about the basses not "fitting".
I used to play a one row for border morris, and on one memorable occasion for rapper when it felt like me arm was going to fall off :Ph
-
Yeah, I played guitar in a Cajun band for a while and always stood on the left of the accordion player. And I had a chance to spend some time with Charlie Harris in Ireland last summer. He's known best for his C#/D playing but he's a great one rower. He still plays his very first box, a four stop Hohner in D and says he thinks of using the basses the same way the registers are used on Uillean pipes. You just play 'em and not worry too much.
-
[...] he thinks of using the basses the same way the registers are used on Uillean pipes. You just play 'em and not worry too much.
That's pretty much what I do with the basses on a one-row. Sometimes I think of them as open strings on a fiddle.
-
I always loved the rhyme in the song Gallant Hussar - "His accoutrements shone like a star."
.... The border side used to have one player who used a couple of Hohner 4-stops to add a little extra grunt to the sound - wonderful.
Rob.
And if I may quote from the dance notes section that Border side's site (http://www.hookeagle.org.uk/) "Nothing at all is played as written" which seems thoroughly appropriate.
-
Black Pig Border's dance 'Banana Splits' has all its tunes played in C, which gives me the opportunity get a bit fitter.
-
I have also used my Hohner 4-stop in G whilst dancing out. The other musicians hate it because it is so raucous, and as already noted, if you use the low stop you really have to work the bellows, so it's fine for a novelty act but it wouldn't recommend it over a 2-row.
-
I've been playing the one row exclusively at the last couple of Morris practices and in general the team likes it. The only complaint was that the chords seemed different. I, myself, love it. It's light, loud and contrasts nicely with our other instruments.