Melodeon.net Forums

Discussions => Teaching and Learning => Topic started by: waltzman on March 23, 2011, 11:05:58 PM

Title: fingering choices
Post by: waltzman on March 23, 2011, 11:05:58 PM
One of the fingering 'rules' I picked up when learning the English concertina was never to use the same finger for two notes in a row because it helps your speed and articulation to use two fingers even if it is on the same button.  Does the same principle also apply to the button accordion?  It seems counter-intuitive somehow but I'm usually able to play passages up and down the row faster with two or three fingers than with four.  What say the more experienced members here?

Michael
Title: Re: fingering choices
Post by: Stiamh on March 23, 2011, 11:54:48 PM
Why counterintuitive? Because you assume a button box ought to work like a piano?

I'm a firm believer in using fewer fingers - fewer than four anyway. (:)  (And in the past on this forum I have had a few supercilious comments directed at me for saying so.)

I use three most of the time but occasionally resort to two only for certain passages. And I figured out a long time ago that I could play a scale up and down the row much faster and more accurately using only two fingers. And an arpeggio, for that matter.

I wouldn't make it a rule always to change fingers to hit the same button twice (in other words never to use the same finger to do so), even if I do it an awful lot. And I think if you made a rule that you would never hit two different buttons consecutively with the same finger, you'd be hampering yourself.

Never say never... never even say never use the fourth finger  :D
Title: Re: fingering choices
Post by: Flanna on March 24, 2011, 06:38:37 AM
One of the fingering 'rules' I picked up when learning the English concertina was never to use the same finger for two notes in a row because it helps your speed and articulation to use two fingers even if it is on the same button..
Michael

I think this is a very good rule. It is especially important on the English concertina, where the buttons are small and close together.

I am less rigid with this rule on melodeon. It is usually very good but it depends on where the fingers are going next. Fingers have to move quickly over bigger distances on melodeon. So if I am playing a triplet with my first finger and the next note will be higher, I would use the first finger for all 3 hits. If the note following the triplet was lower, I would play a first finger triplet with fingers 1, 2 then 3, or even 1 2 then 2. I have described this from the point of view of a right handed player. Being left handed, I do this a bit differently (my high notes are near my chin and low notes are, well, lower).
Title: Re: fingering choices
Post by: Alan Morley on March 24, 2011, 08:10:07 AM
I do use four fingers on the treble side, but only two on the bass. I don't know why I only use two - especially as I'm a guitarist and should be used to using four... ::)

It depends on the tune as well for my right hand - I'm sure I don't use the same fingers for the same sequence all through a tune. It's something I don't really think about - just play...
Title: Re: fingering choices
Post by: Theo on March 24, 2011, 08:27:42 AM
Using different fingers for successive notes on the same button helps to get a nice crisp separation of the notes if that is what you want (it often is).  It is also an excellent way of changing hand position so that you can reach further up or further down the fingerboard.

I'm a firm believer in using fewer fingers - fewer than four anyway. (:)  (And in the past on this forum I have had a few supercilious comments directed at me for saying so.)

I believe that using four fingers on the treble is very helpful if you want to play across the rows on a fourth apart system.  Steve plays a semitone system I think, where musically adjacent notes are always physically close across the rows.  Fourth apart systems sometimes need a bigger stretch to reach the right note on the 'other' row.
Title: Re: fingering choices
Post by: LJC on March 24, 2011, 08:29:03 AM
There are too many variables for hard and fast rules. Certainly for a fast triplet type ornament on a single button it would be foolish to only use one finger. However, in other circumstances where you simply have two melody notes on the same button, one finger can be fine, depending on the preceding and following phrase of notes.
Title: Re: fingering choices
Post by: george garside on March 24, 2011, 10:18:00 AM
Thank goodness melodeon playing ( whatever the system) is not full of 'stuffy rules'  that we are bound to follow.  However there are many useful 'guidelines'  around    which have  may work better for some than for others so the short answer is to give various ideas an extensive trial & then decide which work best for you.

I think this applies particularly to semitone boxes where the discussion tends to be about the merits of using either 3 or 4 fingers.  The little finger tnends to be weeker than the other 3 and without due training is therefore of less use than , say, reaching up with the 3rd finger.  The little finger is however well worth; training to do its share as its use can make life easier in certain tunes,. eg on a BC (or BCC#) box I use 4 fingers for both the A & B parts of soldiers joy & harvest home ( both in D) but only use the first three (perhaps illogically) when playing boys of bluehill/lads of north tyne (D).  Perhaps dafter still I use 4 fingers for the AA part of Baron Rocks of Aden & 3 for the B part - but it works wel for me & thats all that really matters.

The DG boxes   lend themselfes well to 4 finger playing but on the other hand many tunes eg winsster gallop, salmon tails, Jimmy Allen etc etc can be played perfectly well with just ANY ONE of the 4 fingers which usefully leaves 3 spares to add a wee bit of embellishment.  For what its worth I did once tech a 2 fingered person to play the DG box & it sounded just as good as  manywith a full set of fingers can  manage

To sum up be open minded & test drive any technique

 george
Title: Re: fingering choices
Post by: Chris Brimley on March 24, 2011, 10:52:28 AM
Quote
The little finger tnends to be weeker than the other 3

True, but strength is not too important - it acts more independently than 2 & 3, and can stretch a long way, so it's well worth learning to use, I feel.  What is sometimes forgotten about Django's formidable technique is that he was forced to reinvent his playing after nearly losing all his fingers in a caravan fire, he didn't do it out of choice.  I agree that 1 and 2, or 1 & 3, can work very quickly together, but the downside of ignoring the other fingers is that you have to leap around the fingerboard more.  For smaller boxes and tunes with not much pitch variation (eg much of Cajun) that may not be so useful, but for bigger ones with more complex fingering runs you can't realistically do without the others, I would have thought.
Title: Re: fingering choices
Post by: waltzman on March 24, 2011, 11:43:03 AM
Thanks for all the replies.  This confirms my own experience that that 'rule' is much less important on the melodeon than on the English concertina.  I found it almost always better to use two fingers on the concertina but only sometimes on the melodeon. Someone here once said that whenever he ran into a passage (on the melodeon) that was giving him trouble the solution almost always involved fewer fingers.  That pretty well sums it up for me too.
Title: Re: fingering choices
Post by: Stiamh on March 24, 2011, 04:12:36 PM
Someone here once said that whenever he ran into a passage (on the melodeon) that was giving him trouble the solution almost always involved fewer fingers.  That pretty well sums it up for me too.

Time gets distorted in the virtual world... that was me, and it was last week (http://forum.melodeon.net/index.php/topic,6381.msg80471.html#msg80471)  ;D

BTW in the next month or two I am supposed to be receiving an EC (family heirloom being restored by the Dippers) and look forward to exploring how it works. Not ruling out any fingers in advance, but happy to know that at least some fingering ideas will be transferrable.
Title: Re: fingering choices
Post by: waltzman on March 24, 2011, 05:25:03 PM
Quote
The little finger tnends to be weeker than the other 3

True, but strength is not too important - it acts more independently than 2 & 3, and can stretch a long way, so it's well worth learning to use, I feel.  What is sometimes forgotten about Django's formidable technique is that he was forced to reinvent his playing after nearly losing all his fingers in a caravan fire, he didn't do it out of choice.  I agree that 1 and 2, or 1 & 3, can work very quickly together, but the downside of ignoring the other fingers is that you have to leap around the fingerboard more.  For smaller boxes and tunes with not much pitch variation (eg much of Cajun) that may not be so useful, but for bigger ones with more complex fingering runs you can't realistically do without the others, I would have thought.

I've heard people speculate about how much more fantastic Django would have been had he had all his fingers but I don't think that is true.  It's true he was forced to learn the guitar again using two fingers but I believe the two finger technique had a lot to do with the unique sound of his style and his blazing speed.  There was another self taught guitar genius named Rev Gary Davis who developed a fantastic thumb and one finger fingerpicking technique with his right hand.  It sounded so good to me and so different from the usual thumb and two finger technique that I made myself practice it until I could do it and it is still my favorite fingerstyle technique on the guitar. 

On the melodeon I stared out learning with four fingers on the buttons and would learn a tune using all four fingers as my default mode.  Now I think I'm better off learning a tune with three fingers and only bringing in the fourth when really needed.  It involves a little more shifting of the hand but overall I can make the tune sound better.  This is the sort of principle I had in mind when I started this thread and I think it is exactly the type of thing that is useful to beginners.  Principles like this make a beginners practice more efficient.
Title: Re: fingering choices
Post by: Chris Brimley on March 25, 2011, 12:10:43 PM
Quote
There was another self taught guitar genius named Rev Gary Davis who developed a fantastic thumb and one finger fingerpicking technique with his right hand.

And on the other hand, there's another, Isaac Guillory, with an even more astonishing and versatile technique, involving picking the top three strings with fingers 2, 3, & 4, and holding a flatpick with thumb and first to allow simultaneous fast up and down bass runs, and then any flatpicking styles he wanted in between!  Gary Davis certainly had drive in his playing, but if you listen to someone like Marcel Dadi or Michael Chapman, they also do, but also the ability to do an awful lot with the RH fingers 1, 2 and 3 which I think you might struggle to equal with just T and 1.

My overall feeling is that, just as with guitar playing, there isn't really a 'right' or a 'wrong' here - each style has its advantages and disadvantages, and a beginner might do best to try them all, for different tunes and boxes.
Title: Re: fingering choices
Post by: Chris Brimley on March 25, 2011, 12:15:27 PM
Quote
Now I think I'm better off learning a tune with three fingers and only bringing in the fourth when really needed.

Just on this point, try hammering 23232323 etc on a table top, then 24242424 etc, and see which you find easiest to keep going at speed.  In my case it's certainly the latter, and I believe it's something to do with the tendon structure in the hand.
Title: Re: fingering choices
Post by: waltzman on March 25, 2011, 01:08:45 PM
Quote
Now I think I'm better off learning a tune with three fingers and only bringing in the fourth when really needed.

Just on this point, try hammering 23232323 etc on a table top, then 24242424 etc, and see which you find easiest to keep going at speed.  In my case it's certainly the latter, and I believe it's something to do with the tendon structure in the hand.

For me, 23232323 is easier.
Title: Re: fingering choices
Post by: Steve C. on March 25, 2011, 11:55:27 PM
Biggest revelation of past year:  DTN's 3 finger roll.  I had no idea how to make that sound, seemed "impossible" but not if you use 3;  just cannot get one finger to move that fast.  KUDO.
Title: Re: fingering choices
Post by: Owen Woods on March 26, 2011, 10:21:36 PM
Obviously 4 fingers is best (;)), but in reference to the OP, you will find that changing finger does make each note stand out nicely. I also find it quicker than pressing the note again. It isn't a rule as such, but certainly in fast tunes it is a good habit to get ingrained.
Title: Re: fingering choices
Post by: Steve C. on March 27, 2011, 02:10:40 PM
In the Mally beginner's book there are some good finger recommendations, he has 4 ways of "shifting" position so you never have to hit the "next" button with the same finger as the last one. 

I think I would be even less far along if not started with Mally book. 
Title: Re: fingering choices
Post by: Thrupenny Bit on March 27, 2011, 04:55:38 PM
I attended several Alistair Anderson's concertina workshops in the late 70's, nad I'm sure he advised to use the same finger on repeat notes!
I still use it now, for both melodeon and English concertina, but will try DTN's roll for the melodeon when I get me head round it.
Changing fingers on an English, in a tight situation???? seems a bit strange to me...... as you'd also loose finger position because changing fingers means the others are out of position due to the hand move. Maybe I use the same finger as that's the way I've been taught and that's the way I play.
all to their own
Q

Title: Re: fingering choices
Post by: waltzman on March 27, 2011, 06:15:30 PM
Changing fingers on an English, in a tight situation???? seems a bit strange to me...... as you'd also loose finger position because changing fingers means the others are out of position due to the hand move.

You are right on both counts.  It is difficult when you first begin to do it but in my opinion the payoff is great.  It improves speed and articulation and allows you to do triplets and ornaments that are impossibly fast for one finger. As always, it depends on the type of music you are playing.  It's completely unnecessary if you are playing waltzes and mazurkas though I still find that it helps with articulation and note clarity even on slow tunes.
Title: Re: fingering choices
Post by: Thrupenny Bit on March 27, 2011, 08:44:16 PM
After posting my reply, I toddled off to the garden but was still thinking about this.
I'm not sure if I'm imagining it or not, but on reflecytion I have a vague recollection that Alistair did touch on it, but I think at the time he too was in the initial learning stages of it and was undecided if it was the way forward or not.......
But I might have dreamt that  ::)
Q
Title: Re: fingering choices
Post by: Gandy on April 01, 2011, 10:08:34 AM
Obviously 4 fingers is best

Plus the thumb in an emergency?
Title: Re: fingering choices
Post by: Rob2Hook on April 01, 2011, 02:18:32 PM
I used the thumb when my single strap came off in mid tune!  Better than DTN's "Melodeons on Watership Down" - mine didn't hit the ground, but then I wasn't falling off a motorbike at the time ;D.  Come to think of it, Del's grip wasn't too secure at Swanage when he lobbed the box skyward (strap acts as a slingshot) and then missed the catch.  What all this proves is that the Pokerwork bounces better than the Saltarelle.

Returning to subject, one finger tends to offer better rythmic control, multiples offer speed.

Rob.
Title: Re: fingering choices
Post by: LDbosca on April 03, 2011, 05:13:48 PM
I'd do the opposite of a lot of people here and, for Irish music, I'd recommend that players never use two fingers to repeat the same note. I find using the same finger to repeat gives a better rhythmic effect and, besides, in Irish music there' nearly always going to be a grace note involved when you repeat a note. Preceeding two repeated notes (repeated with the same finger) with a grace note gives a great rhythmic effect, eg. D B B
SimplePortal 2.3.5 © 2008-2012, SimplePortal