Melodeon.net Forums
Discussions => Teaching and Learning => Topic started by: NewShoe on March 24, 2011, 01:09:14 PM
-
I was wondering if, for the purposes of learning one instrument, there would be a synergistic benefit to investing time learning to play another. What particular combination of instruments have advanced progress the most for folks here ?
For many years I was a "by the notes" recreational piano player. More recently I picked up playing CBA accordion. The accordion taught me to play by ear the piano with somewhat boring but still usable arrangements. Now I have obtained a viola to play again for the first time in 40 years. I never passed the beginner stage years ago and my skills now are quite effective in clearing the room of listeners.
I notice now after trying to play the viola that my fingers are somewhat aiming for the right note now as I play. Years ago I was preoccupied matching the notes I was reading to the proper string and finger position. I don't know if I have presented this well but I notice a change already in the way I am learning.
Has any one similar experiences ?
-
Well I started on anglo concertina, then 6 months in got a melodeon...and found they helped each other with transferable skills.
e.g. once I'd learned to do basses and treble at same time on melodeon it was suddenly much easier on concertina. I've recently started learning fiddle and find that's helped me get better at sight reading, and actually knowing the name of the notes.
-
Yes, I'm sure that learning another instrument widens the scope of how you think about music, and decouples the connection between dots on the page and where you put you fingers on the instrument. Or to put it another way, it encourages you to think about what the music sounds like when you see the printed notes, which is always a useful skill.
-
Jack of all trades and master of none, but just think of all the extra enjoyment you'll get. To answer the original question, Piano and violin to me is a good combination of mechanics and intuition and listening skills. Don't forget your voice, that's the best musical instrument you've always got it with you (I'm not even going to mention learning to read the ......s).
-
Jack of all trades and master of none
Not necessarily. Some of the greatest players in the world are famous for one instrument but play others very competently indeed. Some years ago I was quite shocked to discover that about half of the members of the National Youth Orchestra had grade 8 piano as well as whatever else they played in the orchestra.
-
Complementary or not....? Do push-pull learners who've never played harmonica still tend to breathe with the bellows? ;D
-
Complementary or not....? Do push-pull learners who've never played harmonica still tend to breathe with the bellows? ;D
I'm pretty sure most learners get some degree of what I know as 'Melodeon Gob'. I still occasionally do it if I'm learning a difficult tune, especially in a different key, but I don't do it with a PA of an English concertina.
I learned to play the piano using the dots, but I play everything else by ear. One I have the tune in my head, I can usually play it with a few attempts.
The one thing I really have difficulty playing is the tin whistle. I can never learn to overblow the octave.
-
I've never noticed a breathing problem.
But...I find when I'm really concentrating on learning a tune I dribble on the bellows. :|bl
-
I've never noticed a breathing problem.
But...I find when I'm really concentrating on learning a tune I dribble on the bellows. :|bl
Good grief Sarah, that really is too much information! :Ph
-
I've never noticed a breathing problem.
But...I find when I'm really concentrating on learning a tune I dribble on the bellows. :|bl
Good grief Sarah, that really is too much information! :Ph
You'll see it in action at M&M. ;)
I find cross rowing seems to cause the most drool...its like it involves same part of the brain and can't handle both.
-
I've never noticed a breathing problem.
But...I find when I'm really concentrating on learning a tune I dribble on the bellows. :|bl
I find myself moaning to myself while playing, followed by a similar reaction from the audience!
-
Folks: One of the most memorable complementary instruments I have seen played was at a concert with the David Grisman Quintet in the 70's. At the time David was playing a concert in the Berklee School of Music in Boston with the great violinist Stephane Grappelli. The concert started with Grisman and his boys and they later brought out Stephane who played wonderfully even in his 80's (I think). At intermission, Stephane came out and played jazz piano for 45 minutes. I had no idea he even played piano. I am sure the piano transferred to his violin and vice versa.
As a mandolin player I always wanted to play an instrument that had sustain. With the bc button accordion I now have that. I only have to learn how to play it. Charlie
-
I've never noticed a breathing problem.
But...I find when I'm really concentrating on learning a tune I dribble on the bellows. :|bl
Good grief Sarah, that really is too much information! :Ph
You'll see it in action at M&M. ;)
I find cross rowing seems to cause the most drool...its like it involves same part of the brain and can't handle both.
New marketing opportunity d'ya think Steve ?? the Melnet bib ?? Nah, we'd never agree on the picture ;D
-
Complementary or not....? Do push-pull learners who've never played harmonica still tend to breathe with the bellows? ;D
I did when I started, although I managed to break the habit.
-
Music being music, I would say that learning to play any instrument is good and can help learning another!
-
Q: Why do orchestras always practise with the doors wide open?
A: So the viola players know where to come in! Boom! Boom! ;D
Etc.
:|glug
-
Jack of all trades and master of none
Not necessarily. Some of the greatest players in the world are famous for one instrument but play others very competently indeed. Some years ago I was quite shocked to discover that about half of the members of the National Youth Orchestra had grade 8 piano as well as whatever else they played in the orchestra.
..and the other half at least grade 5 :D
-
[quote As a mandolin player I always wanted to play an instrument that had sustain. With the bc button accordion I now have that. I only have to learn how to play it. Charlie
[/quote]
none of the diatonics have true everlasting sustain, this being the teritory of piano accordions & continental chromatics where the length of sustaining is only limited by arm fatigue - which is why some are played a bit crapily
george ;D
-
none of the diatonics have true everlasting sustain, this being the teritory of piano accordions & continental chromatics where the length of sustaining is only limited by arm fatigue
Yes, here is where my piano habits may have hurt me. Both instruments have keys but the piano note will eventually die off preventing massive excess hold. It's taken me a long time to pick up my fingers more while playing the CBA accordion. Listening to the examples on the TOTM selections has given me some clues where I am going wrong.
-
I've never noticed a breathing problem.
But...I find when I'm really concentrating on learning a tune I dribble on the bellows. :|bl
Good grief Sarah, that really is too much information! :Ph
You'll see it in action at M&M. ;)
I find cross rowing seems to cause the most drool...its like it involves same part of the brain and can't handle both.
New marketing opportunity d'ya think Steve ?? the Melnet bib ?? Nah, we'd never agree on the picture ;D
I'd like either a Black Five or Drysllwyn Castle please.
Failing that, Felicity Kendal, please :o.
-
Getting back on topic (phew!), I also believe in the value of learning/playing more than one instrument. My main instrument is the clarinet which I have been playing since the age of 10. This has definitely helped my melodeon/concertina playing, which I didn't take up for another 20 years.
I am convinced that playing a wind instrument helps the musician to understand phrasing in a fundamental way, as it is most akin to singing or reciting - you have to breathe in the right places to shape the phrases and make it musical. That sort of skill is transferable to a string or keyboard instrument, where the phrasing is not necessarily so intuitive and therefore easier to miss the breathing places.
-
I am convinced that playing a wind instrument helps the musician to understand phrasing in a fundamental way, as it is most akin to singing or reciting - you have to breathe in the right places to shape the phrases and make it musical.
So pity the poor piper who has to blow into the bag or use the air pump as and when the air reservoir demands it, irrespective of phrasing. So maybe learning the bagpipes as well as the melodeon would be counter productive :|||:
-
My main instruments have always been synthesizers, which traditionally have piano type keys which I hate. Learning to play CBA and especially English concertina, got me up to speed at sight reading. Buying a midi English concertina and later an Axis 64 (all button) midi controller and a Roland FR3b were a very big step forward for my synth playing.
So my synthesizer playing has greatly improved by learning English concertina and CBA (:)
-
So pity the poor piper who has to blow into the bag or use the air pump as and when the air reservoir demands it, irrespective of phrasing. So maybe learning the bagpipes as well as the melodeon would be counter productive :|||:
That's why I play the bellows-blown Northumbrian Pipes. I can still breath normally!
Anyway - apart from the Northumbrian Pipes which has a closed chanter and the Uillean Pipes which is played with a popping pad on the thigh (both examples allowing for silences to be inserted into the music), I don't think bagpipes are capable of phrasing at all. ;)
[dives for cover]
-
Yes, here is where my piano habits may have hurt me. Both instruments have keys but the piano note will eventually die off preventing massive excess hold. It's taken me a long time to pick up my fingers more
That explains a lot of PA playing style, of course.
-
.... the value of learning/playing more than one instrument. My main instrument is the clarinet which ... has definitely helped my melodeon/concertina playing, which I didn't take up for another 20 years.
I am convinced that playing a wind instrument helps the musician to understand phrasing in a fundamental way, as it is most akin to singing or reciting - you have to breathe in the right places to shape the phrases and make it musical. That sort of skill is transferable to a string or keyboard instrument, where the phrasing is not necessarily so intuitive and therefore easier to miss the breathing places.
About a year-and-a-half ago, when I went to Alexander Technique teacher, the advice for playing instruments - melodeon and guitar - was to sing the tune at the same time. Of course, I don't necessarily do this, at least consciously, but the advice from others 'keep breathing' is good.
And if I can't sing the tune then I don't know it. Being in my third or fourth year as a bass in a community [non-dot] choir helps.
The harmonica: our Bagman doesn't play instruments at all but does sing, I'm very much a dancer there. The A Music from Bluebells of Scotland on harmonica at the end of dance practise elicited 'Have you been practising' from him. Not quite sure how he thinks anyone plays music. Or it was very straight-faced teasing. I don't obviously breathe for harmonica when playing melodeon.
The initial instrument was guitar if I discount harmonica in C or possibly chromatic [failed] at about 12. Picked the guitar up again yesterday for the first serous play for a while and my left hand seems to be a bit stronger and a little more accurate than before, presumably from trying to do basses on melodeon and the occasional crack at Anglo.
Next thing as I actually need to get the basses going properly - um-chah away just left handed, so-so, play both hands together very, very slowly, OK-ish, speed up and left hand rhythm and timing gets taken over by right. Ummpph. Back to the playing bass and random on right exercise, probably? Is normal, yes?
-
So pity the poor piper who has to blow into the bag or use the air pump as and when the air reservoir demands it, irrespective of phrasing. So maybe learning the bagpipes as well as the melodeon would be counter productive :|||:
That's why I play the bellows-blown Northumbrian Pipes. I can still breath normally!
Anyway - apart from the Northumbrian Pipes which has a closed chanter and the Uillean Pipes which is played with a popping pad on the thigh (both examples allowing for silences to be inserted into the music), I don't think bagpipes are capable of phrasing at all. ;)
[dives for cover]
I'm struggling to learn pipes on a Uillean practice set, after two years of trying, all pipers have my deepest sympathy :Ph
As for closed pipes, I just can't get used to taking fingers off to get a note as opposed to putting them on.
You're correct, pipes arn't capable of phrasing.. but a good piper is ;D
-
I'm struggling to learn pipes on a Uillean practice set, after two years of trying, all pipers have my deepest sympathy :Ph
As for closed pipes, I just can't get used to taking fingers off to get a note as opposed to putting them on.
You're correct, pipes arn't capable of phrasing.. but a good piper is ;D
Very interesting, I just want to say that bagpipes especially the ones designed for indoor (Border, Small, Northumbrian, Irish, French, Balkan, Carpathian, etc) music are perfect complementary instruments to melodeons, just like the hurdy-gurdy, IMHO. Many of the forum members, Anahata, DTN, steve freereeder, are excellent melodeon players and play the pipes as well.
-
I'd like either a Black Five or Drysllwyn Castle please.
Failing that, Felicity Kendal, please :o.
Now that's a REALLY difficult choice - I think Felicity Kendal would just edge it over the Black 5.....
-
Seriously,folks, the melodeon - though I play it more than any other instrument these days - is really my third instrument. I'm a bass player first and foremost, then probably a rhythm guitarist, then a box player, then a gob-iron player, then a mandolin/Irish bouzouki player, then a keyboard player. As far as I am concerned each instrument informs the rest.
Graham
-
I'm struggling to learn pipes on a Uillean practice set, after two years of trying, all pipers have my deepest sympathy :Ph
As for closed pipes, I just can't get used to taking fingers off to get a note as opposed to putting them on.
You're correct, pipes arn't capable of phrasing.. but a good piper is ;D
Well, if you ever feel like giving up then I'll give you a tenner for them :P I'd love to try Uillean pipes, but they are so expensive!
-
Jack of all trades and master of none
Not necessarily. Some of the greatest players in the world are famous for one instrument but play others very competently indeed. Some years ago I was quite shocked to discover that about half of the members of the National Youth Orchestra had grade 8 piano as well as whatever else they played in the orchestra.
Piano is a very common second study amongst classical music students and indeed is commonly the first instrument learned before moving to an orchestral instrument. It is (fairly obviously) very useful when it comes to studying harmony.
-
As for closed pipes, I just can't get used to taking fingers off to get a note as opposed to putting them on.
You're correct, pipes arn't capable of phrasing.. but a good piper is ;D
I have a set of Julian Goodacre's Leicestershire smallpipes with closed fingering and also a set of Swayne border pipes with what I think is called semi-closed fingering. I find the closed system is easier because going from one note to another you never have to move more (and rarely fewer) than two fingers at a time; on the Swayne pipes you may need to move anything from one to five fingers at once. Not being a long term experienced wind player, I find this really confusing.
-
Piano is a very common second study amongst classical music students and indeed is commonly the first instrument learned before moving to an orchestral instrument. It is (fairly obviously) very useful when it comes to studying harmony.
Totally agreed on both counts. I still visualize a piano keyboard when working out intervals in my head.
It's not only piano though. I once knew somebody who switched from viola to horn in one of the London orchestras.