Melodeon.net Forums

Discussions => Instrument Design, Construction and Repair => Topic started by: WendyG on March 28, 2011, 08:38:37 PM

Title: Glued-in reed blocks
Post by: WendyG on March 28, 2011, 08:38:37 PM
Any ideas how to replace valves on a reed block that is glued to the sound board and is only a couple of centimetres away from the edge of the box?  I will need to remove the reed plates to fit valves to the inside, which isn't a problem, but how on earth, can I wax the reed plates back onto the reedblock nearest the edge.  Will I have to carefully try and remove the reedblock and hope that I don't damage the sound board or is this a no-hoper and I will need to get it done professionally?  I should have asked this at the Melodeon Maintenance Day, but I hadn't taken that much notice of the insides of the box, except to take photos.

Wendy
Title: Re: Glued-in reed blocks
Post by: blafleur on March 29, 2011, 05:06:30 AM
Definitely don't remove the reed blocks.  I use an medicine eye dropper, I prefer the ones with the angle tip.  I would do the bottom first, starting at the high end where it's farthest from the edge.  I turn the box reeds pointing up but with a slight angle so when I start the wax flowing it will flow against the reed plates, and tilt the box toward the low end and let the wax flow all the way down along the plates.  Then tilt the box so the reeds are almost parallel to the ground and flow wax between the plates, tilting it just enough to let wax flow toward the bottom.

There may be better ways, but that works for me.
Title: Re: Glued-in reed blocks
Post by: Theo on March 29, 2011, 08:15:29 AM
I do pretty much the same, letting gravity do the work.   Its one of those skills that you are likely to learn by trial and several errors!   Working with melted wax as it cools you only have a certain amount of time to get the right amount of wax into the correct place.  Don't be surprised if it takes a while to master the process.
Title: Re: Glued-in reed blocks
Post by: diatonix on March 29, 2011, 11:02:33 AM
I can't think of a better way, Blafleur... It's amazing how useful gravity is every now and then.
Title: Re: Glued-in reed blocks
Post by: WendyG on March 29, 2011, 11:50:33 AM
Thank you for your replies.  As the reedblock in question is very firmly glued in place removing it is definitely not an option.  So it looks like I will need to hone my waxing skills (in a very limited space) on something else first. 

Is it possible to overheat the wax and alter its properties?

Wendy
Title: Re: Glued-in reed blocks
Post by: Theo on March 29, 2011, 11:57:37 AM
Thank you for your replies.  As the reedblock in question is very firmly glued in place removing it is definitely not an option.  So it looks like I will need to hone my waxing skills (in a very limited space) on something else first. 

Is it possible to overheat the wax and alter its properties?

Wendy

You could practise on the removable reedblock,  this will give you an opportunity to work out the best angle for the block so that the wax runs at a suitable rate.

Yes wax can be damaged by overheating.   There is also small but significant fire risk,  heating in water bath is safest if you don't have a temperature controlled wax bath.
Title: Re: Glued-in reed blocks
Post by: diatonix on March 29, 2011, 07:04:48 PM
A type of temperature controlled small wax pot normally used by cosmeticians to remove hair from whatever part of the human body is an excellent and inexpensive option. It costs considerably less than f.ex. the batik pot offered by HAtools.
Title: Re: Glued-in reed blocks
Post by: Andy Simpson on March 29, 2011, 07:36:22 PM
I can second that, much easier and safer than the camping stove and bain marie I was using before.
Title: Re: Glued-in reed blocks
Post by: KLR on August 06, 2013, 07:44:53 PM
BUMP!

I'm working on an old 2 row Concertone F/Bb with one removable and one glued in block, and I really have to wonder why they'd do it that way?  I've already revalved/cleaned up the fixed block, last night I did the first half of the removable one, and it's certainly a lot easier to hold these things in your hand as you go along.  It makes me think of Jerry Seinfeld's quip about how Chinese peasants for thousands of years would toil for hours every day pushing a plow through the dirt, then go inside and eat meals with chopsticks... ;D 

Was the fixed block a common feature of old boxes?  This Concertone certainly is that - thumbstrap, latches instead of bellows pins, stepped traditional keyboard with flat pearloid washers.
Title: Re: Glued-in reed blocks
Post by: deltasalmon on August 06, 2013, 08:16:30 PM
BUMP!

I'm working on an old 2 row Concertone F/Bb with one removable and one glued in block, and I really have to wonder why they'd do it that way?  I've already revalved/cleaned up the fixed block, last night I did the first half of the removable one, and it's certainly a lot easier to hold these things in your hand as you go along.  It makes me think of Jerry Seinfeld's quip about how Chinese peasants for thousands of years would toil for hours every day pushing a plow through the dirt, then go inside and eat meals with chopsticks... ;D 

Was the fixed block a common feature of old boxes?  This Concertone certainly is that - thumbstrap, latches instead of bellows pins, stepped traditional keyboard with flat pearloid washers.

Not an answer to this but I noticed the inside of my Weltmeister on the bass side has the bass reed block fixed and the chord reed block removable. I also was curious why as I figured it would be an "all-or-nothing" situation with either both being glued in or both being removable.
Title: Re: Glued-in reed blocks
Post by: Adam-T on August 06, 2013, 08:55:39 PM
the one fixed, one glued was pretty common in bass ends (usually its the chord reedblock which comes out) - in PAs at least , even some Hohners . thankfully the Hohner Melodeons of 2 or more rows seem to have all blocks removable .

Bass ends from Hohner Carmen, Student-IV and Mignon - all with glued in Bass blocks, only the chord one comes out (the screws were there to hold it while the glue was drying) -  dunno why given the small size of the bass blocks and that the melodeons (even big ones) had removable bass blocks

Title: Re: Glued-in reed blocks
Post by: pgroff on August 06, 2013, 09:58:00 PM
Well, in my opinion (seemingly shared by some excellent makers), glued in reedblocks can give give a brighter sound and more immediate response than removeable blocks with a gasket. Maybe it would be better to describe the sound as just a little less muffled when there's no gasket under the reedblock. But having one block removeable improves access for working on the reeds, both for the removeable block and for the one(s) glued in. In 2-voice, two-row accordions there can be a slight imbalance of tone quality between the notes from the inside vs. outside button rows, when one row of pallets is down near the keyboard.  But if the reedblock for that lower row of pallets is glued in, and the other one is removeable, that can help balance the sound between the two rows (as in the red Scandalli box in the center of the photo below).

PG
Title: Re: Glued-in reed blocks
Post by: KLR on August 06, 2013, 10:29:50 PM
Huh!  Even my Castagnari's inner row is a titch dim.  Better than Hohners but definitely there.  My Club Morino doesn't have that problem and Ukebert explained how Morino found a workaround for that, have to read his article on the Shand Morino again.  Whatever that was.  PAs certainly don't have every other other other note sounding dullish, how did they work around that? 

Title: Re: Glued-in reed blocks
Post by: Adam-T on August 07, 2013, 07:11:05 AM
Hmmm, Ive heard this before about glued in blocks avoiding dullness but removable blocks never stopped Pokerworks, Corsos and Ericas from stripping paint  :D

As for PAs, they`re big enough to have all the pallets out in the open, none buried inside the fingerboard and as for the Morinos, the "extra" voice/s are buried in the fingerboard not the main ones and they use 2 rows of pallets for three sets of reeds - something I wish Paolo Soprani (or whoever owned the name during the 70s, 80s and 90s) had latched onto when making the 4 voice boxes .
Title: Re: Glued-in reed blocks
Post by: Kimric Smythe on August 18, 2013, 08:01:02 PM
I run into the glued in bass blocks a lot on smaller and older piano accordions (48 bass). Only once did I find one that had both blocks on the left glued in. There was no way to tune or wax the reeds in between. I think the blocks had been tuned then glued in. Finally took a Japanese flush saw and cut off the chord block ,and made a new block for it out of one from my "spares" pile.
It was a old 1940's italian 32 bass job, and was badly engineered in every way possible. It was a LOT of work to do. More like a reconstruction than a rebuild.
 These small instruments are not common in the US so it is usually worth the effort to rebuild them.
SimplePortal 2.3.5 © 2008-2012, SimplePortal