Melodeon.net Forums
Discussions => Instrument Makes and Models => Topic started by: Jamie Robertson on November 15, 2007, 05:04:48 AM
-
Does anyone know where to find info on Hohner melodeon models and their ages? I just got a Hohner C/F Pokerwork made in Germany, and was wondering if there is any way to date it. When did Pokerworks start being made in China? Etc.
Thanks
-
You know, I got quite the wrong idea when I saw this subject. I had just been reading a story on the BBC website about a man who became overly fond of his bicycle, you see...
-
That BBC!! Of course, on this side of the pond, we wouldn't just have a story, we'd have a series with over-the-hill celebrities, psychologists, and police entrapping and having interventions with those lovers of inanimate, albeit movable, objects. Then 6 months later, the follow-up to see how the offenders life is.
I don't want to go out with my accordion, I just want to know how old she is.
-
Is the Pokerwork Black or Honey colored
If Honey colored is the fingerboard black or Honey Colored
If Black is the keyboard wood or plastic
If Wood.. does it have pronounced horns ?
Are the reeds "H" reeds or "T" reeds
Do the reeds have "leathers" or plastic valves
-
It's black with a plastic keyboard. I haven't ventured inside to look at reeds/valves.
-
Late 80's 90's or 2000's
It wil have T reeds 9 or if late enough something else
It will have plastic valves
Is the back of the keyboard or the box stamped " Made in Germany"
-
You know, I got quite the wrong idea when I saw this subject. I had just been reading a story on the BBC website about a man who became overly fond of his bicycle, you see...
I'm sure he got a bit confused about people referring to "the local bike."
-
Is the back of the keyboard or the box stamped " Made in Germany"
I sure is.
-
likely made in the 80's or 90's perhaps early 2000's
I'd have to see the reeds to tell anything else
Made in Germany is good....as long as it's pre 2000's.....but even then ... ok
-
The reeds are, I assume, T reeds, since that letter is stamped on the plate the reeds are mounted to. There is also the number "87" rubber stamped on one of the reed blocks.
-
Hohner reedblocks are often stamped 870 to indicate the reference pitch they were tuned to. Today we would call that A=435, and octave below 870, and 5Hz flat of modern concert pitch at A=440.
Your 87 may have lost the final zero.
-
Theo..
But 870 in that late a box
unless the base or reference note is actually below the second reed tuned higher for tremolo
and the higher reed is actually something like 440-441 ??
or the 87 could have been the batch number or box number in a batch
-
Jeff,
Yes it would be a surprise on that late a box. I wasn't offering a definitive diagnosis, just throwing a little more information into the discussion.
I should have said that the 870 is usually found on pre-war boxes.
-
OR.... the fingerboard was changed out
and the box dates to the 50's and made from pre war parts ! ! : )
hmm but that does not explain T reeeds unless the reeds were changed out
conclusion
box is a mutant
gills
-
And the T reed is not diagnostic of anything very specific.
For example I have today been working on a wooden bodied Hohner Erika/Club II 1930s type which shows every sign that the reeds and wax have not been touched since it left the factory. It has zinc reedplates marked with a T.
I've seen the insides of a large number of old Hohners, and you can find all sorts of different combinations of reeds. There seems to have been a long period when both H and T were in use, sometimes mixed in the same box.
And getting back to Jamies original question:
I just got a Hohner C/F Pokerwork made in Germany, and was wondering if there is any way to date it.
As you can see from the discussion Jimmy its a tricky one.
-
I had no idea the dating cold be so dicey. Although with certain vintage guitars and banjoes it is equally problematic.
I guess the best thing for me to do is play the thing until it needs parts or tuning. Or tweaking. I can see that modifying the button travel is a must, once I decide how far I want the keys to sink. The tuning sounds really quite good, and it sounds great. Oh what fun. Once I get the straps on, and the bellows a wee bit tighter, I'll be off and running.
-
By padding the keyboard with felt... after a time the felt will compress even though it may seem a bit high at first
One day I will do a show and tell of how I pad the keyboards
But then I also make my own and put the originals in a bag for posterity.
-
Are the reeds "H" reeds or "T" reeds
Can you describe these. I've not heard of them before
Thanks Robin
-
Are the reeds "H" reeds or "T" reeds
Can you describe these. I've not heard of them before
Thanks Robin
Robin, Hohner (at least in Cherminny ... not sure of Chinese manufacture) stamped reeds -- actually on the plate of the reed -- with the letter H or T or sometimes left no mark on them. As a WAIG, I'm guessing that "H" at one time stood for something like "hoch-qualitat" but I'm pretty sure that it lost any real meaning a long time ago (kinda like "large" is now the smallest size of laundry soap -- if you want bigger, you go for super-size or king-size). But people familiar with Hohners can recognize the reed types and sometimes (in addition to other clues) make some guesses about age, original tuning, etc. of Hohners.
-
Well, not so much date as trying to establish probability of the box being made in Germany, China or indeed elsewhere for my own curiosity.
The box : Hohner D/G pokerwork.
DG stamped on black-painted wood of bass end. Plays in those keys with the usual third-button root, low+ standard accidentals below. "Hohner" - no more than that - inset in pokerwork design on outside of treble end, beyond grille from player's view. - no mention of made in Germany or anywhere else.
Internally, removing the grille of what I'd call bright metal shows a serial number a bit below 001600, a number 9 and a square stamp reading Gepruft [?] in what looks like a rather German font and I think 605 or 685. I'd guess that is the Q A stamp.
Treble keyboard and buttons apparently of plastic. My finger-tips can go into the button-holes but don't get damaged in doing so.
No obvious limitation to treble button travel.
If the bellows frames are between the bellows and the ends, I think they are of black plastic. Bellows in red with gold edging.
Bass buttons with mushroom or T shape, green felt on lower side of buttons.
Reputed age from eBay seller would date it at about 2004 and two previous owners. I'd guess at somewhat earlier to allow for favourable presentation of age as it goes through owners. Was stiff to play when I got it. Not actually been played in. No documentation that I can recall.Straps by Mally, anonymous zipped bag.
To me, the reputed age suggests Chinese being after '97/'98, but the probable plastic bellows frames might mean late European. Corner-pieces on ends seem reasonably well finished and fitted. Pokerwork design just looks like that to me. Mostly fresh except where I've worn it. Neither obviously garish nor drab, not to to me anyway. So it's a puzzle.
It plays OK according to others. I reckon it's harsh, shrill, wet and, perhaps sharp but in tune with itself. Probably could be quicker to speak, but never mind.
Haven't had the ends off. Seems reasonably air-tight so the bellows-pins get left alone.
I'm wondering what any of this may mean, and what I may not have spotted.
-
Well, not so much date as trying to establish probability of the box being made in Germany, China or indeed elsewhere for my own curiosity.
The box : Hohner D/G pokerwork.
DG stamped on black-painted wood of bass end. Plays in those keys with the usual third-button root, low+ standard accidentals below. "Hohner" - no more than that - inset in pokerwork design on outside of treble end, beyond grille from player's view. - no mention of made in Germany or anywhere else.
Internally, removing the grille of what I'd call bright metal shows a serial number a bit below 001600, a number 9 and a square stamp reading Gepruft [?] in what looks like a rather German font and I think 605 or 685. I'd guess that is the Q A stamp.
Treble keyboard and buttons apparently of plastic. My finger-tips can go into the button-holes but don't get damaged in doing so.
No obvious limitation to treble button travel.
If the bellows frames are between the bellows and the ends, I think they are of black plastic. Bellows in red with gold edging. General colour scheme is black underneath and gold decoration on top, white buttons.
Bass buttons with mushroom or T shape, green felt on lower side of buttons.
Reputed age from eBay seller would date it at about 2004 and two previous owners. I'd guess at somewhat earlier to allow for favourable presentation of age as it goes through owners. Was stiff to play when I got it. Not actually been played in. No documentation that I can recall.Straps by Mally, anonymous zipped bag.
To me, the reputed age suggests Chinese being after '97/'98, but the probable plastic bellows frames might mean late European. Corner-pieces on ends seem reasonably well finished and fitted. Pokerwork design just looks like that to me. Mostly fresh except where I've worn it. Neither obviously garish nor drab, not to to me anyway. So it's a puzzle.
It plays OK according to others. I reckon it's harsh, shrill, wet and, perhaps sharp but in tune with itself. Probably could be quicker to speak, but never mind.
Haven't had the ends off. Seems reasonably air-tight so the bellows-pins get left alone.
I'm wondering what any of this may mean, and what I may not have spotted.
-
Dating: Some celloid hohner clubs have a serial number on the treble end (back side) or on the bass strap
Hohner offers a service for €5 to look up the number in their archives.
Contact may be RTritschler@hohner.de - (official e-mail address from german hohner accordeon service page: http://www.hohner.eu/index.php5?1393 )
-
Dating: Many hohners have a serial number on the treble end (back side)
Hohner offers a service for €5 to look up the number in their archives.
Contact may be RTritschler@hohner.de - (official e-mail address from german hohner accordeon service page: http://www.hohner.eu/index.php5?1393 )
Thanks, Michik.